# RTS Meta Explorer Verification

ID: ticket:20260510-rts-meta-verification
Type: Ticket
Status: closed
Created: 2026-05-10
Updated: 2026-05-10
Risk: medium - closure depends on command evidence and fresh-context audit, while visual browser evidence may be limited by available tools.

## Summary

Verify the completed static OpenDota RTS meta explorer MVP against the spec and implementation ticket. Record command evidence and fresh-context audit before claiming the plan is complete.

## Related Records

- `plan:20260510-rts-meta-explorer` - owns the broader closure story.
- `ticket:20260510-static-rts-meta-explorer` - implementation ticket to verify.
- `spec:opendota-rts-meta-explorer` - behavior contract to verify against.

## Scope

May change:

- `.loom/evidence/*.md`
- `.loom/audit/*.md`
- `.loom/tickets/20260510-rts-meta-verification.md`
- `.loom/tickets/20260510-static-rts-meta-explorer.md`
- `.loom/plans/20260510-rts-meta-explorer.md`

May run:

- syntax checks
- static server smoke checks
- Markdown whitespace checks
- fresh-context review via a bounded agent

Must not claim browser-visual verification unless a real browser observation is performed.

## Acceptance

- ACC-001: Verification commands are run and their observed outcomes are preserved in an evidence record.
  - Evidence: `evidence:*` record with command names and outputs.
  - Audit: fresh-context review should challenge whether the evidence supports the claimed scope.

- ACC-002: A fresh-context audit reviews the implementation against the spec and tickets, with findings or an explicit no-finding verdict recorded.
  - Evidence: `audit:*` record created from a fresh-context worker result.
  - Audit: the audit record itself is the adversarial review surface.

- ACC-003: Ticket and plan states are updated truthfully after verification, including any unverified visual/browser limitations.
  - Evidence: updated records and final source diff.
  - Audit: same audit should challenge closure posture.

## Current State

Verification is complete for the checks available in this workspace. Command evidence is recorded in `evidence:20260510-rts-meta-mvp-checks`, and fresh-context audit is recorded in `audit:20260510-rts-meta-mvp` with a pass-with-reservations verdict.

Acceptance state:

- ACC-001 satisfied by `evidence:20260510-rts-meta-mvp-checks`.
- ACC-002 satisfied by `audit:20260510-rts-meta-mvp`.
- ACC-003 satisfied by updating this ticket, `ticket:20260510-static-rts-meta-explorer`, and `plan:20260510-rts-meta-explorer` with the closure state and explicit browser-visual limitation.

No real browser visual pass was performed, so responsive appearance, rendered accessibility behavior, and actual browser CORS/runtime behavior remain unverified.

## Journal

- 2026-05-10: Created verification ticket as the second execution unit for `plan:20260510-rts-meta-explorer`.
- 2026-05-10: Ran available verification checks and recorded command evidence in `evidence:20260510-rts-meta-mvp-checks`.
- 2026-05-10: Ran fresh-context audit and recorded `audit:20260510-rts-meta-mvp`; closed with explicit reservations around unperformed browser visual/runtime verification.
