# Loom Weaver Final Audit Packet

ID: packet:20260514T232038Z-loom-weaver-final-audit
Type: Packet
Status: consumed
Created: 2026-05-14 23:20 UTC
Updated: 2026-05-14 23:27 UTC
Target: ticket:20260514-loom-weaver-agent
Packet Kind: Ralph
Mode: review
Context Style: live-reference
Worker: subagent
Branch: main
Worktree: /Users/alexanderbutler/code_projects/personal/agent-loom
Risk: high - final closure audit for model-visible agent persona and cross-harness adapter surfaces.
Review Lens: audit, code review, evidence sufficiency, harness support honesty, product-surface leakage

## Mission

Perform a final adversarial review for `ticket:20260514-loom-weaver-agent` after the Codex custom-agent follow-up and the `AGENTS.md` finding fix.

Decide whether the final implementation is clear for ticket closure, or whether material findings remain. Focus on whether the ticket acceptance criteria, final diff, evidence, and records tell one truthful story.

## Claims To Challenge

- `ACC-001`: canonical Loom Weaver behavior source exists and matches `spec:loom-weaver-agent`, including `.loom/`-only writes, shaping-first posture, adversarial challenge, options/recommendations, Loom surface routing, and no contributor-facing leakage.
- `ACC-002`: OpenCode exposes Loom Weaver as a direct selectable/invocable agent surface without disrupting existing skill/bootstrap behavior.
- `ACC-003`: Claude Code exposure is honest and validated.
- `ACC-004`: Gemini exposure is honest and validated within available limits.
- `ACC-005`: Cursor support uses slash or natural-language semantics and does not claim `@<agent>` custom-agent invocation.
- `ACC-006`: Codex support uses custom-agent TOML installation under `~/.codex/agents/` and does not claim `@<agent>` custom-agent invocation or plugin-shipped profile/custom-agent support.
- `ACC-007`: human-facing docs explain per-harness invocation without becoming the only source of model behavior.
- `ACC-008`: package and Markdown validation are appropriate for touched files.
- `ACC-009`: a fresh audit/review challenges prompt safety, `.loom/` write boundary, harness support honesty, package inclusion, and product-surface leakage.

Also challenge whether prior audit `FIND-001` is actually fixed by the final `AGENTS.md` changes.

## Read Scope

Read these records and source files as needed:

- `.loom/tickets/20260514-loom-weaver-agent.md`
- `.loom/specs/loom-weaver-agent.md`
- `.loom/research/20260514-direct-interactive-agent-surfaces.md`
- `.loom/evidence/20260514-loom-weaver-codex-agent-followup-validation.md`
- `.loom/evidence/20260514-loom-weaver-implementation-validation.md`
- `.loom/audit/20260514-loom-weaver-agent-audit.md`
- `.loom/packets/ralph/20260514T223622Z-loom-weaver-agent-implementation.md`
- `.loom/packets/ralph/20260514T230124Z-loom-weaver-agent-audit.md`
- `.loom/packets/ralph/20260514T230546Z-loom-weaver-codex-agent-followup.md`
- `loom-core/agents/loom-weaver.md`
- `loom-core/codex/agents/loom-weaver.toml`
- `loom-core/loom-core.mjs`
- `loom-core/package.json`
- `loom-core/.claude-plugin/plugin.json`
- `loom-core/.cursor-plugin/plugin.json`
- `loom-core/.codex-plugin/plugin.json`
- `INSTALL.md`
- `README.md`
- `loom-core/README.md`
- `AGENTS.md`
- Current `git status --short`, `git diff --stat`, and current diff for the touched files.

## Write Scope

Read-only review. Do not edit source, docs, package files, or Loom records.

Return your review output to the parent. The parent will record the audit and update the ticket. If your transport supports it safely, you may update only this packet's `## Worker Output` section and set `Status: consumed`.

## Required Review Lenses

- Acceptance and scope: every `ACC-*` claim is satisfied or honestly limited.
- Evidence sufficiency: validation evidence supports only the claims it states and does not overclaim live runtime invocation.
- Product-surface leakage: model-visible agent prompt and Codex TOML avoid contributor-facing package, smoke, adapter-mechanics, dogfood, and repository workflow prose.
- Harness support honesty: docs avoid universal `@` syntax, default-agent claims, and unsupported Codex/Cursor claims.
- Package inclusion and adapter exposure: `agents/` and `codex/agents/` are included where package or plugin surfaces need them.
- Prior finding disposition: `audit:20260514-loom-weaver-agent-audit#FIND-001` is resolved or still material.
- Implementation quality: changes are minimal, maintainable, and do not create unrelated behavior or stale checks.

## Stop Conditions

Stop and return `blocked` or `inconclusive` if:

- required records or source files are missing;
- the diff no longer matches the ticket scope;
- evidence is too stale or ambiguous to judge closure;
- a material behavior, policy, or product decision is needed before review can continue.

## Output Contract

Return:

- outcome: `stop`, `blocked`, or `escalate`
- verdict: `clear`, `concerns`, `changes-needed`, or `inconclusive`
- findings: stable `FIND-*` entries for material findings, or explicit "no material findings"
- evidence reviewed: records/files/commands inspected
- acceptance notes: whether each `ACC-*` is supported, partially supported, or unsupported
- residual risks and unverified areas
- recommended next move for the ticket

## Worker Output

Outcome: stop

Verdict: clear

Findings: No material findings within audited scope.

Evidence reviewed:

- Packet: `.loom/packets/ralph/20260514T232038Z-loom-weaver-final-audit.md`
- Records: ticket, spec, research, both evidence dossiers, prior audit, implementation/follow-up/audit packets.
- Source/docs: `loom-core/agents/loom-weaver.md`, `loom-core/codex/agents/loom-weaver.toml`, `loom-core/loom-core.mjs`, `loom-core/package.json`, Core plugin manifests, `INSTALL.md`, `README.md`, `loom-core/README.md`, `AGENTS.md`, Gemini extension manifests.
- Git state: `git status --short`, `git diff --stat`, `git diff --cached --stat`, scoped staged diff.
- Validation rerun: `git diff --check` passed with no output; `npm --prefix loom-core run smoke` passed with `ok: true`, `agentCount: 1`, `skillCount: 11`, Codex TOML prompt match true, OpenCode mode `all`, and edit permission denying `*` while allowing `.loom/**`; `npm --prefix loom-core run pack:check` passed and included `agents/loom-weaver.md` plus `codex/agents/loom-weaver.toml`; `claude plugin validate "$PWD/loom-core"` passed; `gemini extensions validate "$PWD/loom-core"` passed.

Acceptance notes:

- `ACC-001`: Supported. Canonical prompt and Codex TOML contain `.loom/` write boundary, shaping-first posture, adversarial challenge, options/recommendations, Loom routing, evidence/audit honesty, and no material product-surface leakage.
- `ACC-002`: Supported. OpenCode registers `loom-weaver` via `config.agent` with `mode: "all"` and a `.loom/**` edit allowlist over default edit deny; smoke verifies this without disrupting skill/bootstrap checks.
- `ACC-003`: Supported. Claude plugin manifest exposes `agents: ["./agents/loom-weaver.md"]`; validator passed.
- `ACC-004`: Supported within stated limits. Gemini extension validation passed and docs honestly describe `@loom-weaver` as delegated subagent invocation, not primary-agent switching.
- `ACC-005`: Supported. Cursor docs use `/loom-weaver` or natural-language subagent use and explicitly avoid `@loom-weaver` custom-agent claims.
- `ACC-006`: Supported. Codex ships `loom-core/codex/agents/loom-weaver.toml`, documents install under `~/.codex/agents/`, uses natural-language custom-agent invocation plus `/agent`, and avoids `@<agent>` and plugin-shipped profile/custom-agent claims.
- `ACC-007`: Supported. Human docs explain per-harness invocation while behavior truth remains in model-visible agent/TOML surfaces.
- `ACC-008`: Supported. Relevant validation passed, including smoke, pack dry-run, Claude validation, Gemini validation, and diff check.
- `ACC-009`: Supported by this review output. Prior `FIND-001` is resolved in `AGENTS.md` by adding `loom-core/agents/` and `loom-core/codex/agents/` to model-visible product-surface guidance.

Residual risks and unverified areas:

- No live runtime invocation was tested in OpenCode, Claude Code, Codex, Cursor, or Gemini.
- Cursor plugin behavior remains source/doc-based; no Cursor validator was run or available.
- Codex `.loom/` write boundary is prompt-level with workspace-write sandboxing, not mechanically path-restricted like OpenCode.
- Gemini `@loom-weaver` remains delegated subagent behavior, not main-session prompt switching.

Recommended next move: record this final audit result in the consuming audit/ticket surface, then proceed with ticket closure if the ticket owner accepts the documented runtime-validation limits.
