# Resolution Summary

**Branch**: feat/v1.4.0-reliability-eval-redesign -> main
**Date**: 2026-04-14
**Review**: .docs/reviews/feat-v1.4.0-reliability-eval-redesign/2026-04-14_1537
**Command**: /resolve

## Statistics
| Metric | Value |
|--------|-------|
| Total Issues | 19 |
| Fixed | 12 |
| False Positive | 5 |
| Deferred | 7 |
| Blocked | 0 |

## Fixed Issues
| Issue | File:Line | Commit |
|-------|-----------|--------|
| Stale test — timeout default 1800000 → 0 | `tests/security/resource-exhaustion.test.ts:213` | `4d9ccba` |
| Stale test — 3 additional boundary assertions | `tests/security/resource-exhaustion.test.ts` | `4d9ccba` |
| ESLint disable comments in biome project | `codex-adapter.ts`, `gemini-adapter.ts` | `c6e711d` |
| Feedback cap uses chars not bytes | `loop-handler.ts:1492` | `c6e711d` |
| Missing CHECK constraint on eval_type | `database.ts` (migration v22) | `c6e711d` |
| Weak Zod validation — eval_type/judge_agent as string | `loop-repository.ts:64-66` | `c6e711d` |
| TaskRequestSchema missing jsonSchema field | `loop-repository.ts:94-111` | `c6e711d` |
| Judge TOCTOU — predictable .autobeat-judge filename | `judge-exit-condition-evaluator.ts:196` | `374be49` |
| Exhaustive switch fallback masks errors | `composite-exit-condition-evaluator.ts:52-56` | `374be49` |
| Double-completion on decision='stop' | `loop-handler.ts:852-874` | `374be49` |
| No tests for eval-task-waiter.ts (16 tests added) | `tests/unit/services/eval-task-waiter.test.ts` | `c6e711d` |
| No tests for decision branching (17 tests added) | `tests/unit/services/handlers/loop-handler.test.ts` | `c6e711d` |

## False Positives
| Issue | File:Line | Reasoning |
|-------|-----------|-----------|
| Timeout default 0 removes safety boundary | `configuration.ts:20` | Intentional per plan — "Default Timeout to 0 (No Timeout)". Users set explicit timeout when needed. |
| jsonSchema unsanitized to CLI | `claude-adapter.ts:25-26` | Array spawn (no shell interpolation), Zod validates at MCP boundary. No injection surface. |
| Deleted composite test without replacement | `composite-exit-condition-evaluator.test.ts` | Superseded by eval-batch3.test.ts (18 tests, 5 routing scenarios). |
| EvalType uses as const instead of enum | `domain.ts:580-585` | Valid TypeScript pattern; codebase uses both. |
| Heartbeat timer double-cleanup | `event-driven-worker-pool.ts` | Intentional defense-in-depth — cleanupWorkerState and clearTimeoutForWorker both clear timers as belt-and-suspenders. |

## Deferred to Tech Debt
| Issue | GitHub Issue | Risk Factor |
|-------|-------------|-------------|
| handleTaskTerminal 140-line complexity | #137 | Multi-function extraction in core handler |
| Duplicate handleStopDecision blocks | #138 | Shared handler refactoring |
| spawn() 6 positional parameters → options object | #139 | Interface change across all adapters |
| Prompt-building duplicated across 3 evaluators | #140 | Shared utility extraction |
| PID file race in schedule executor | #141 | Concurrency pattern change |
| No tests for handleScheduleExecutor lifecycle | #142 | Process lifecycle testing |
| Duplicated test helpers across eval test files | #143 | Test infrastructure refactoring |

## Blocked
None.

## Post-Resolution Quality
- Simplifier: Fixed stale loop reference in `completeLoop` (passing pre-update loop to `finishLoop`), corrected judge evaluator doc comment ordering
- All test suites passing after resolution
