# Security Audit Report

**Branch**: fix/issue-28-graph-corruption-shallow-copy
**Base**: main
**Date**: 2025-11-28 08:37 UTC
**Files Analyzed**: 7
**Lines Changed**: ~150 (additions and modifications)

---

## Executive Summary

This branch addresses Issue #28 - graph corruption caused by shallow copy in the `wouldCreateCycle()` method. The primary fix is a security-critical correction that prevents unintended mutation of the dependency graph data structure.

**Overall Assessment**: The changes are security-positive. The main fix (deep copy in `wouldCreateCycle`) corrects a data integrity vulnerability. Additional changes related to spawn delay and settling worker tracking are configuration adjustments, not security issues.

**Security Score**: 9/10

**Merge Recommendation**: APPROVED

---

## Issues in Your Changes (BLOCKING)

**None identified.**

The changes in this branch are security-positive fixes, not security vulnerabilities.

---

## Issues in Code You Touched (Should Fix)

**None identified.**

The files modified contain sound security practices:
- Input validation on TaskId parameters
- Result pattern for error handling (no exceptions)
- Zod schema validation with bounds checking

---

## Pre-existing Issues Found (Not Blocking)

### MEDIUM

**[Information Disclosure via Verbose Logging]** - `/workspace/delegate/src/implementations/resource-monitor.ts:160-168`
- **Vulnerability**: Detailed system resource information logged at debug level
- **Context**: Pre-existing - not changed by this branch
- **Risk**: In production with debug logging enabled, system metrics could be exposed to log aggregators
- **Recommendation**: Consider filtering sensitive metrics in production environments
- **Not blocking**: This is a logging configuration issue, not a code vulnerability

### LOW

**[Configuration via Environment Variables]** - `/workspace/delegate/src/core/configuration.ts:107-126`
- **Vulnerability**: Silent fallback to defaults when environment values fail validation
- **Context**: Pre-existing pattern - not changed by this branch
- **Risk**: Invalid configuration could go unnoticed (line 134-136: silently uses defaults)
- **Recommendation**: Consider logging warnings when env values are invalid
- **Not blocking**: Current behavior is fail-safe (uses secure defaults), not fail-open

---

## Detailed Analysis of Changes

### 1. Deep Copy Fix in DependencyGraph (SECURITY-POSITIVE)

**File**: `/workspace/delegate/src/core/dependency-graph.ts:249-255`

**Change**:
```typescript
// BEFORE (vulnerable):
const tempGraph = new Map(this.graph);

// AFTER (fixed):
const tempGraph = new Map(
  Array.from(this.graph.entries()).map(([k, v]) => [k, new Set(v)])
);
```

**Security Analysis**:
- **Issue Fixed**: Shallow copy of Map only copies Map structure. The Set values remain as references to the original Sets.
- **Impact of Bug**: When `wouldCreateCycle()` adds edges to `tempGraph`, it mutates the original `this.graph` Sets, causing graph corruption.
- **Security Implication**: Corrupted dependency graph could:
  1. Allow cycles to pass undetected (deadlock potential)
  2. Create phantom dependencies affecting task scheduling
  3. Lead to denial of service if tasks become permanently blocked
- **Verdict**: This is a CRITICAL BUG FIX, not a vulnerability introduction. The fix correctly implements immutability.

### 2. Spawn Delay Configuration Change

**File**: `/workspace/delegate/src/core/configuration.ts:32,69`

**Change**:
```typescript
// Default changed from 50ms to 1000ms (1 second)
minSpawnDelayMs: z.number().min(10).max(30000).default(1000)
```

**Security Analysis**:
- This is a **rate limiting improvement**, not a security issue
- Increasing default spawn delay from 50ms to 1s prevents rapid worker spawning
- Combined with settling worker tracking, this prevents resource exhaustion attacks
- The max bound increased from 10000ms to 30000ms - this is acceptable and provides more configuration flexibility
- **Verdict**: Security-neutral to positive. Rate limiting is a defense mechanism.

### 3. Settling Worker Tracking

**File**: `/workspace/delegate/src/implementations/resource-monitor.ts:27-32, 77-98`

**Change**: New mechanism to track recently-spawned workers during a 15-second "settling" window before they appear in system metrics.

**Security Analysis**:
- Addresses a **timing attack on resource monitoring**: Load average is a 1-minute rolling average, so attackers could request many tasks rapidly before the system detects resource exhaustion
- New fields:
  - `SETTLING_WINDOW_MS = 15000` (15 seconds)
  - `recentSpawnTimestamps: number[]` 
- `canSpawnWorker()` now includes settling workers in capacity calculations
- **Potential Concern**: `recentSpawnTimestamps` array could grow unbounded in pathological cases
  - **Mitigated by**: Timestamps are cleaned up on each `canSpawnWorker()` call (line 81-84)
  - **Also mitigated by**: Existing `maxWorkers` limit prevents array from growing beyond that size
- **Verdict**: Security-positive. Closes a resource exhaustion timing gap.

### 4. ResourceMonitor Interface Extension

**File**: `/workspace/delegate/src/core/interfaces.ts:50-56`

**Change**: Added optional `recordSpawn?(): void` method to ResourceMonitor interface.

**Security Analysis**:
- Optional method maintains backward compatibility
- Called from WorkerHandler after successful spawn
- **Verdict**: No security impact. Interface extension is clean.

### 5. WorkerHandler Integration

**File**: `/workspace/delegate/src/services/handlers/worker-handler.ts:295-296`

**Change**: 
```typescript
// Record spawn for settling worker tracking (accounts for lag in load average)
this.resourceMonitor.recordSpawn?.();
```

**Security Analysis**:
- Optional chaining (`?.`) ensures no crash if method doesn't exist
- Called immediately after `incrementWorkerCount()` - correct ordering
- **Verdict**: No security impact. Proper integration.

### 6. Test Coverage (Regression Prevention)

**File**: `/workspace/delegate/tests/unit/core/dependency-graph.test.ts:248-339`

**Added Tests**:
- `should not mutate graph when checking for cycles with existing task`
- `should not mutate graph when checking non-cycle with existing task`
- `should not mutate graph with multiple cycle checks`

**Security Analysis**:
- Tests explicitly verify immutability invariant
- Tests would catch regression to shallow copy bug
- **Verdict**: Security-positive. Regression tests for critical fix.

---

## Security Patterns Observed (Positive)

1. **Result Pattern**: All methods return `Result<T>` instead of throwing exceptions - prevents unhandled errors
2. **Input Validation**: `validateTaskId()` rejects empty strings - prevents injection/confusion
3. **Bounded Configuration**: Zod schema enforces min/max bounds on all numeric config values
4. **Immutability Focus**: Deep copy fix reinforces immutable data pattern
5. **Resource Limiting**: Multiple layers of resource protection (worker count, CPU, memory, settling tracking)

---

## Summary

| Category | Severity | Count | Details |
|----------|----------|-------|---------|
| Your Changes | CRITICAL | 0 | No vulnerabilities introduced |
| Your Changes | HIGH | 0 | - |
| Your Changes | MEDIUM | 0 | - |
| Code You Touched | HIGH | 0 | - |
| Code You Touched | MEDIUM | 0 | - |
| Pre-existing | MEDIUM | 1 | Verbose debug logging |
| Pre-existing | LOW | 1 | Silent config fallback |

**Security Score**: 9/10

**Merge Recommendation**: APPROVED

---

## Notes

1. The primary change (deep copy fix) is a **security improvement**, fixing a data integrity vulnerability
2. The spawn delay and settling worker changes are **defense-in-depth improvements** against resource exhaustion
3. Comprehensive test coverage prevents regression
4. Pre-existing issues are informational only and do not warrant blocking this PR
5. No secrets, credentials, or sensitive data were found in the changes

---

*Report generated by security audit tool*
