# Implementation Progress Tracker

**Last Updated:** 2026-06-18  
**Progress:** 95% complete (production features + governance complete)

---

## Executive Summary

✅ **Delivered This Session:**
- CODE_EXECUTION_STRATEGY.md (comprehensive framework guide for agent frameworks)
- Quota tracking (daily operation limits + fast-path checks)
- Session cache mode (fresh subprocess context per call)
- Async operations tools (get_operation_status, cancel_operation)
- **Per-operation metrics** (tool_calls, api_spend_estimate, memory, CPU)
- **Loop detection** (repeated calls 3+, integrated with metrics)
- **Production safety guardrails** (respond to Fame510 feedback on CrewAI #6180)
- **Comprehensive cancellation tests** (6/6 passing, production-grade)
- All community feedback responded to
- **e2B CLA signed & verified** ✅
- **Glama pivot** (honest positioning over forced fit) ✅
- **awesome-mcp-servers PR closed** (not a fit) ✅

⏳ **In Flight:**
- awesome-ai-agents merge (CLA verified, awaiting final merge)

---

## Detailed Progress

### PHASE 1: Compliance Gates — COMPLETED ✅

#### 1.1: Sign e2B CLA (COMPLETED ✅)
- ✅ **Signed:** CLA signed with GitHub account (abhinaykrupa)
- ✅ **Verification:** Posted `@cla-bot check` on PR #1114
- ✅ **Status:** CLA bot verified, PR ready to merge
- ✅ **Impact:** awesome-ai-agents merge in flight

#### 1.2: Registry Strategy (PIVOTED → CLOSED)
- ❌ **Glama Server Registry:** Rejected ("Not a pure MCP server")
- ❌ **Glama Connectors Registry:** Requires deployed endpoint URL (we're local-first)
- ❌ **awesome-mcp-servers PR #8163:** Requires Glama badge (impossible path)
- ✅ **ClawHub:** Requires endpoint URL (not applicable for local stdio server)
- ✅ **Decision:** Stopped chasing badges; focus on honest positioning
- ✅ **Action:** Closed awesome-mcp-servers PR with clear explanation
- ✅ **Rationale:** Better to be honest about architecture (local-first RPC bridge) than force-fit into cloud-hosted categories

---

### PHASE 2: CrewAI Production Guide (COMPLETED ✅)
- ✅ **Created:** `docs/CODE_EXECUTION_STRATEGY.md` (416 lines)
- ✅ **Content:**
  - Decision tree (where/what/when/how code execution)
  - 3 reference implementations:
    - Cloud Sandbox (E2B, Replit)
    - Venv Boundary (SwarmAI pattern)
    - Local Subprocess (cowork-to-code-bridge)
  - Example crew (generator → reviewer → executor)
  - Production checklist (logging, safety, recovery)
  - Resource limits documentation
  - Decision matrix comparing approaches

- ✅ **Commit:** `f5456f0`
- ✅ **Addresses:** CrewAI #6180 feedback from xg-gh-25 (SwarmAI)
- ✅ **Impact:** Positions bridge as canonical reference implementation

---

### PHASE 3: Hermes Integration Enhancements (COMPLETED ✅)

#### 3.1: Quota Tracking (COMPLETED ✅)
- ✅ **Feature:** Quota monitoring in all MCP responses
- ✅ **Implementation:**
  - Reads daily journal from daemon.log
  - Returns: used, remaining, reset_at, limit
  - Default: 100 operations/day
  - Resets: midnight UTC (configurable)
- ✅ **Commit:** `88e6693`
- ✅ **Addresses:** Hermes feedback "How do you track rate limits?"

#### 3.2: Session Cache Mode (COMPLETED ✅)
- ✅ **Feature:** Fresh subprocess context per call
- ✅ **Implementation:**
  - CLI flag: `--session-cache`
  - Routes escalations to subprocess (vs persistent agent)
  - For single-shot debugging workflows
- ✅ **Commit:** `88e6693`
- ✅ **Addresses:** Hermes feedback "Do you have fresh context per call?"

#### 3.3: Async Operation Tools (COMPLETED ✅)
- ✅ **Tool:** `get_operation_status` (idempotent)
  - Check any operation status
  - Returns: status, progress, resume_receipt, quota
  - Safe to call multiple times
- ✅ **Tool:** `cancel_operation` (best-effort)
  - Cancel queued operations (immediate)
  - Graceful shutdown during execution (SIGTERM + timeout)
  - Idempotent: completed operations return no-op
- ✅ **Commit:** `2b2f570`
- ✅ **Addresses:** Async operation semantics needed for long-running workflows

---

### PHASE 4: Polish Enhancements (3-5 hours) — COMPLETED ✅

#### 4.1: Per-Operation Metrics (COMPLETED ✅)
- ✅ **Feature:** Metrics tracking in operation state
- ✅ **Metrics exposed:**
  - tool_calls (count)
  - tool_call_log (history with args/timestamp)
  - api_spend_estimate (cost calculation)
  - memory_mb, cpu_percent (resource tracking)
- ✅ **Integration:** Returned in get_operation_status responses
- ✅ **Commit:** `ffea1f1`
- ✅ **Addresses:** Fame510 feedback (CrewAI #6180)

#### 4.2: Loop Detection (COMPLETED ✅)
- ✅ **Feature:** Automatic repeat-call detection
- ✅ **Logic:** Same tool + args invoked 3+ times triggers alert
- ✅ **Response:** Included in metrics as `repeated_calls` dict
- ✅ **Usage:** Crews use to trigger cancellation
- ✅ **Commit:** `ffea1f1`
- ✅ **Enables:** Automated circuit-breaking for production

#### 4.3: Cancellation Testing (COMPLETED ✅)
- ✅ **Test Suite:** tests/test_cancellation.py (6/6 passing)
- ✅ **Scenarios:**
  - Pre-execution: immediate cancellation (queue deletion)
  - During-execution: SIGTERM signaled, flag set
  - Post-execution: idempotent (no-op)
  - Idempotent retries: safe to retry cancellation
  - Unknown operations: safe no-op
  - Loop detection: correctly identifies repeated calls
- ✅ **Commit:** `103abd1`
- ✅ **Status:** Production-grade semantics validated

#### 4.4: Resume Receipt Enhancement (DOCUMENTATION ADDED)
- ✅ **Updated:** STATEFUL_OPERATION_PATTERN.md
- ✅ **Added:** "Production Safety: Metrics & Loop Detection" section
- ✅ **Content:**
  - Per-operation metrics schema
  - Loop detection explanation
  - Crew integration patterns
  - Agent responsibility (recording metrics)
- ✅ **Commit:** `ffea1f1`

---

### PHASE 5: ClawHub Submission (1-2 hours) — NOT STARTED
- [ ] **Create ClawHub submission**
  - Register as third-party extension
  - Use Dockerfile (ready ✅)
  - Follow ClawHub guidelines

- [ ] **Update integration docs**
  - Add ClawHub link to README
  - Cross-reference from OpenClaw

- [ ] **Post OpenClaw confirmation**
  - Reply to issue #93609
  - Confirm ClawHub submission

---

## Community Feedback Status

| Issue | Feedback | Response | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
| MCP Spec #2925 | Stateful pattern spec | Posted spec doc | ✅ Addressed |
| CrewAI #6180 (1) | Decision tree | Offered framework | ✅ Addressed |
| CrewAI #6180 (2) | Trade-off analysis | Deep comparison | ✅ Addressed |
| AutoGPT #13366 | Isolation + latency | Technical deep-dive | ✅ Addressed |
| Hermes #47199 | Subprocess bridge | Comparison + collaboration | ✅ Addressed |
| OpenClaw #93609 | Community PR redirect | Acknowledged + planned ClawHub | ✅ Addressed |
| Glama #8163 | Dockerfile + badge | Dockerfile added + plan | ⏳ In progress |
| e2B #1114 | CLA signature | Notification + timeline | ⏳ In progress |

**All feedback responded to. No outstanding community questions.**

---

## Code Quality Metrics

**Lines Added (This Session):**
```
CODE_EXECUTION_STRATEGY.md:      416 lines
Quota tracking:                   60 lines
Session cache mode:                8 lines
Async operation tools:           140 lines
Per-operation metrics:           100 lines
Loop detection:                   25 lines
Cancellation tests:              230 lines
Production safety docs:          120 lines
─────────────────────────────────────────
TOTAL:                        1,099 lines
```

**Commits (This Session):** 7
```
103abd1 feat: Add comprehensive cancellation tests and fix operation_id returns
ffea1f1 feat: Add per-operation metrics and loop detection to MCP server
2b2f570 feat: Add get_operation_status and cancel_operation tools
88e6693 feat: Add quota tracking and session cache mode
f5456f0 docs: Add comprehensive code execution strategy guide
62c27f7 Add Dockerfile for Glama registry
ca4f63e docs: Add stateful operation pattern spec
```

**Backward Compatibility:** ✅ All new features are optional/non-breaking

---

## What's Ready to Ship Now

✅ **Code:**
- MCP server with async operation support
- Quota tracking for rate monitoring
- Session cache mode for single-shot workflows
- Graceful cancellation support

✅ **Documentation:**
- CODE_EXECUTION_STRATEGY.md (comprehensive)
- STATEFUL_OPERATION_PATTERN.md (async operations)
- MCP_SERVER_IMPLEMENTATION.md (architecture)
- EXTERNAL_AGENT_INTEGRATION.md (integration guide)

✅ **Community Positioning:**
- Reference implementation for 3 execution strategies
- CrewAI adoption driver (production guide)
- Hermes integration ready (quota + session modes)
- ClawHub registration ready (pending manual submission)

---

## Timeline to Completion

**Remaining (1-2 hours):**
1. Compliance gates (15 min) → sign CLA + Glama registration
2. ClawHub submission (1-2h) → official listing

**Expected Outcome:**
- 2 curated list merges (awesome-mcp-servers + awesome-ai-agents)
- Official ClawHub listing
- Production-grade metrics + loop detection (Fame510 feedback addressed)
- 100% community feedback addressed + responded to

---

## Next Steps

1. **Immediate (User Action):**
   - Sign e2B CLA → unblocks merge #1114 (awesome-ai-agents)
   - Complete Glama registration → unblocks merge #8163 (awesome-mcp-servers)

2. **This Week (Development):**
   - Create ClawHub submission (register as third-party extension)
   - Post confirmation to OpenClaw #93609
   - Update README with ClawHub link

3. **Post-Completion:**
   - Monitor for list merges
   - Monitor for CrewAI/Hermes responses (metrics/loop detection)
   - Track adoption signals across frameworks

---

**Status: 85% complete — All production features delivered. 2 governance gates + ClawHub remaining.**

