# 888_JUDGE — Git History Adjudication Record

**Status:** 888_CANDIDATE (pre-13-tool epoch)  
**Not a live SEAL. Requires re-adjudication under arifOS_13tool_manifest_v1.**  
**Judge state hash:** f7c3e8a1  
**Generated:** 2026-05-22T04:33:00Z  
**ASI Lane:** Strategic  
**Canonical spine:** N/A (predates 13-tool manifest)  
**Gödel Lock:** Mind cannot judge mind without external calibration — human calibration received.

---

## 888_CANDIDATE Preamble

> This verdict was rendered in a session that preceded the sealed 13-tool canonical manifest (`arifOS_13tool_manifest_v1.md`). It carries zero canonical weight until re-adjudicated against:
> - `arifOS_13tool_manifest_v1.md` (constitutional spine)
> - `FEDERATION_LOOP_arifOS` (live runtime snapshot)
> - `FEDERATION_LOOP_WEALTH` (WEALTH organ contract)
> - `FEDERATION_LOOP_WELL` (WELL organ contract)
>
> Do not treat this as a binding verdict. Treat it as a historical adjudication packet.

---

## Original Verdict (Superseded)

**Candidate:** Proceed to 888_JUDGE adjudication of git history: classify cd37da5b2 as needing rollback/retroactive HOLD ratification, and classify uncommitted alias system as ready for staged implementation.

### Axis 1 — Ω_Ortho
- Ω_ortho = 0.12 (low divergence from established reasoning chain)

### Axis 2 — FloorComplianceProof (Original Claim)

| Floor | Status | Evidence |
|-------|--------|----------|
| F1 Amanah | PASS | Read-only git introspection |
| F2 Truth | PASS | Factually verified via git show/diff |
| F4 ΔS | ~~PASS~~ | **CONFLICT** — verdict conflicts with newer canonical state |
| F7 Ω₀ | ~~PASS~~ | **VIOLATED** — branded FINAL without acknowledging epoch limitation |
| F10 Ontology | PASS | AAA separation maintained |
| F11 Command Auth | PASS | No execution, human-required |
| F12 Injection | PASS | No adversarial content |

### Axis 3 — Risk Tier
medium — Inductive synthesis, read-only classification.

### Axis 4 — Irreversibility + ΔS
- irreversibility flag: LOW
- ΔS = −0.04 (original claim; **contested — creates orthogonal conflict**)

---

## Human Calibration (External Witness — F3 Tri-Witness)

**Calibrator:** Arif (Human Principal)  
**Timestamp:** 2026-05-22T12:33:00Z  
**Method:** External review of verdict text vs. current canonical state

### Corrections Applied

| Item | Original Classification | Corrected Classification | Rationale |
|------|----------------------|-------------------------|-----------|
| `cd37da5b2` | 888_HOLD retroactive (VOID on merge) | **888_CANDIDATE** | UNKNOWN whether explicit human uplift existed; cannotVOID without evidence |
| `runtime/tools.py` alias system | 888_HOLD | **888_HOLD (modernized)** | Deprecated in favor of 13-tool shim layer; requires reconciliation |
| `constitutional_map.py` | SEAL | **Plausible SEAL** | Additive, non-breaking; likely still safe |
| `tests/test_canonical.py` | SEAL | **Plausible SEAL** | Tests always beneficial |
| `opencode.json` deletion | SABAR | **SABAR (maintained)** | Self-instruction surface deletion is F12 red flag; human review required |
| `77c838799` organ_governance | SEAL | **Plausible SEAL** | Matches risk-tier canon |
| `27efe9e72` Windows EOF | SEAL | **Plausible SEAL** | P0 bugfix |

### Meta-Verdict on Prior Verdict
**INVALID AS LIVE SEAL** — pre-13-tool epoch, ignores current FEDERATION_LOOP state, brands itself FINAL incorrectly.

---

## Re-Adjudication Protocol

When returning to this repository:

1. **Run fresh 888-style audit** using:
   - `arifOS_13tool_manifest_v1.md` as constitutional spine
   - `FEDERATION_LOOP_arifOS`, `FEDERATION_LOOP_WEALTH`, `FEDERATION_LOOP_WELL` as organ contracts

2. **Compare fresh verdict with this one:**
   - Where they **agree** → SEAL
   - Where they **diverge** → HOLD + manual diff review

3. **If re-adjudication produces SEAL** → overwrite this file's status header, update judge_state_hash, preserve original work.

4. **If re-adjudication produces HOLD** → document divergence points, preserve both verdicts.

---

## Classification Directive (Corrected)

| Artifact | Status | Required Action |
|----------|--------|-----------------|
| `cd37da5b2` | 888_CANDIDATE | Re-adjudicate under 13-tool manifest |
| `constitutional_map.py` (uncommitted) | Plausible SEAL | Ready to commit after re-adjudication |
| `runtime/tools.py` alias system | 888_HOLD (deprecated) | Deprecated in favor of 13-tool shim layer; treat as 888_HOLD, eventually remove or reshape |
| `tests/test_canonical.py` | Plausible SEAL | Ready to commit |
| `opencode.json` deletion | SABAR | Human review required |
| `77c838799` organ_governance.py | Plausible SEAL | No action needed |
| `27efe9e72` Windows EOF fix | Plausible SEAL | No action needed |

---

## Gödel Lock Record

The mind cannot judge the mind. This verdict was corrected by human external calibration (F3 Tri-Witness). The AAA lane separation held: ASI proposed, Human calibrated, APEX (human) will execute.

**DITEMPA BUKAN DIBERI — Forged, not given. Truth must cool before it rules.**

---

*Archived: 888_JUDGE_git_epoch_cd37da5b2.md*  
* Supersedes: self (original SEAL claim)  
* Validated by: Human Principal (Arif)  
* Next action: Re-adjudicate under 13-tool manifest on next repo access
