# Verification Report: cloud-sync-audit-log

**Change**: cloud-sync-audit-log
**Version**: v1
**Mode**: Strict TDD

---

## Completeness

| Metric | Value |
|--------|-------|
| Tasks total | 49 |
| Tasks complete | 49 |
| Tasks incomplete | 0 |

All 49 tasks marked complete in apply-progress. Verified by cross-referencing source files and test runs.

---

## Build & Tests Execution

**Build**: PASS — `go build ./...` exits 0, no errors or warnings.

**Tests**: PASS — 0 failed / 12 skipped (all Postgres-gated, by design) / all other tests pass.
- `go test ./...` — 19 packages: all `ok`
- `go test -count=1 -race ./internal/cloud/... ./cmd/engram/...` — zero races

**go vet**: PASS — `go vet ./...` exits 0, no issues.

**gofmt**: PASS for all change-specific files. One pre-existing formatting issue found in `cmd/engram/autosync_status_test.go` (alignment of method stubs in `fakeAutosyncManager`) — this file was last touched in commit `5d2f9d7` which predates this change. Not introduced by this change.

**Coverage** (non-Postgres paths):
- `cloudserver` package: 79.5% — acceptable
- `dashboard` package: 60.9% — acceptable (pre-existing code lowering average; new handlers are covered by dedicated tests)
- `cloudstore/audit_log.go`: 0% — expected; all methods are Postgres-gated and skip without DSN

---

## TDD Compliance

| Check | Result | Details |
|-------|--------|---------|
| TDD Evidence reported | PASS | apply-progress contains TDD Evidence table |
| All tasks have tests | PASS | 49/49 tasks have corresponding RED or GREEN evidence |
| RED confirmed (tests exist) | PASS | All test files verified on filesystem |
| GREEN confirmed (tests pass) | PASS | All non-Postgres-gated tests pass on execution |
| Triangulation adequate | PASS | Multiple scenarios per behavior (2.1.1–2.1.5, 2.2.1–2.2.3, 2.5.1–2.5.4, 2.6.1–2.6.5) |
| Safety Net for modified files | PASS | Existing tests continued passing after each modification |
| Postgres-gated tests skip cleanly | PASS | 9 audit cloudstore tests + 3 project control tests skip with informative message |

**TDD Compliance**: All checks passed

---

## Test Layer Distribution

| Layer | Tests | Files | Tools |
|-------|-------|-------|-------|
| Unit (real DB, Postgres-gated) | 9 | 1 (`cloudstore/audit_log_test.go`) | `database/sql` + Postgres |
| Integration (HTTP handler fakes) | ~35 | 3 (`mutations_test.go`, `cloudserver_test.go`, `dashboard_test.go`) | `net/http/httptest` |
| E2E (fake full-stack) | 1 | 1 (`cloudserver_test.go`) | fakeAuditableStoreForE2E |
| **Total new/modified** | ~45 | 4 | |

---

## Assertion Quality

**Assertion quality**: All assertions verify real behavior.

- No tautologies found (no `expect(true).toBe(true)` patterns)
- No orphan empty checks without companion non-empty assertions
- `TestAuditListContributorFilter` loop (lines 284-288) is safe: guarded by `len(rows) != 3` check above
- All test assertions compare concrete field values against expected constants (contributor, project, action, outcome, total count)

---

## Spec Compliance Matrix

| Requirement | Scenario | Test | Result |
|-------------|----------|------|--------|
| REQ-400: DDL + Migration | First migration creates table and indexes | `audit_log_test.go > TestAuditLogMigrationCreatesTable` | SKIP (Postgres-gated) |
| REQ-400: DDL + Migration | Repeated migration is idempotent | `audit_log_test.go > TestAuditLogMigrationIdempotent` | SKIP (Postgres-gated) |
| REQ-400: DDL + Migration | Concurrent/out-of-order migration | covered by idempotency test (IF NOT EXISTS) | PARTIAL (Postgres-gated) |
| REQ-401: Types round-trip | AuditEntry fields round-trip | `audit_log_test.go > TestInsertAuditEntryRoundTrip` | SKIP (Postgres-gated) |
| REQ-401: Types round-trip | Zero-value AuditFilter valid | `audit_log_test.go > TestAuditListEmptyResult` | SKIP (Postgres-gated) |
| REQ-402: InsertAuditEntry | Successful insert persists one row | `audit_log_test.go > TestInsertAuditEntryRoundTrip` | SKIP (Postgres-gated) |
| REQ-402: InsertAuditEntry | Context cancellation surfaces error | `audit_log_test.go > TestInsertAuditEntryCancelledContext` | SKIP (Postgres-gated) |
| REQ-402: InsertAuditEntry | DB error returned to caller | covered by context cancellation + non-nil error check | PARTIAL (Postgres-gated) |
| REQ-403: ListAuditEntriesPaginated | Pagination returns correct page/total | `audit_log_test.go > TestAuditListPaginationAndTotal` | SKIP (Postgres-gated) |
| REQ-403: ListAuditEntriesPaginated | Contributor filter narrows result | `audit_log_test.go > TestAuditListContributorFilter` | SKIP (Postgres-gated) |
| REQ-403: ListAuditEntriesPaginated | Time-range filter inclusive bounds | `audit_log_test.go > TestAuditListTimeRangeFilter` | SKIP (Postgres-gated) |
| REQ-403: ListAuditEntriesPaginated | Empty result: zero total, nil error | `audit_log_test.go > TestAuditListEmptyResult` | SKIP (Postgres-gated) |
| REQ-404: Mutation push 409 audit | 409 path emits exactly one audit row | `mutations_test.go > TestMutationPushPaused409EmitsAudit` | COMPLIANT |
| REQ-404: Mutation push 409 audit | Non-409 path emits zero audit rows | `mutations_test.go > TestMutationPushNonPaused200EmitsNoAudit` | COMPLIANT |
| REQ-404: Mutation push 409 audit | Audit insert failure → still 409 | `mutations_test.go > TestMutationPushAuditInsertFailureStill409` | COMPLIANT |
| REQ-405: Chunk push 409 audit | 409 path emits one audit row (chunk_push) | `cloudserver_test.go > TestChunkPushPaused409EmitsAuditWithChunkAction` | COMPLIANT |
| REQ-405: Chunk push 409 audit | Non-409 path emits zero audit rows | `cloudserver_test.go > TestChunkPushEnabled200EmitsNoAudit` | COMPLIANT |
| REQ-405: Chunk push 409 audit | Store lacking InsertAuditEntry → no panic | `cloudserver_test.go > TestChunkPushStoreWithoutInsertAuditEntryDoesNotPanic` | COMPLIANT |
| REQ-406: created_by field | created_by populates contributor | `mutations_test.go > TestMutationPushPausedWithCreatedBy` | COMPLIANT |
| REQ-406: created_by field | Missing created_by → "unknown" | `mutations_test.go > TestMutationPushPausedWithoutCreatedByDefaultsUnknown` | COMPLIANT |
| REQ-406: created_by field | Older client without created_by → 200 | `mutations_test.go > TestMutationPushNonPaused200EmitsNoAudit` | COMPLIANT |
| REQ-407: Pull path no audit | Pull against paused project → 200, no audit | `cloudserver_test.go > TestMutationPullEmitsNoAuditOnPausedProject` | COMPLIANT |
| REQ-407: Pull path no audit | handleMutationPull source: no InsertAuditEntry | Static code review — confirmed absent in lines 172-234 of mutations.go | COMPLIANT |
| REQ-408: Admin audit-log route | Admin user receives shell page (200) | `dashboard_test.go > TestAdminAuditLogShellRouteAdminAccess` | COMPLIANT |
| REQ-408: Admin audit-log route | Non-admin user denied (403) | `dashboard_test.go > TestAdminAuditLogShellRouteNonAdminDenied` | COMPLIANT |
| REQ-409: List partial route | Admin receives paginated list partial | `dashboard_test.go > TestAdminAuditLogListPartialAdminAccess` | COMPLIANT |
| REQ-409: List partial route | Contributor filter narrows rows | `dashboard_test.go > TestAdminAuditLogListFilterByContributor` | COMPLIANT |
| REQ-409: List partial route | Non-admin denied (403) | `dashboard_test.go > TestAdminAuditLogListPartialNonAdminDenied` | COMPLIANT |
| REQ-410: Audit filters | All filters combinable | `audit_log_test.go > TestAuditListContributorFilter + TestAuditListOutcomeFilter + TestAuditListTimeRangeFilter` | SKIP (Postgres-gated) |
| REQ-410: Audit filters | Outcome dropdown uses constants | `dashboard_test.go > TestAdminAuditLogListPartialOutcomeDropdown` | COMPLIANT |
| REQ-411: Audit Log link in admin nav | Audit Log link in all four admin pages | `dashboard_test.go > TestAdminNavAuditLogLinkInAllFourPages` (4 sub-tests) | COMPLIANT |
| REQ-412: Structural interface assertion | Real store passes assertion | `cloudserver_test.go > TestChunkPushPaused409EmitsAuditWithChunkAction` (implicit: fakeStoreWithAudit implements InsertAuditEntry) | COMPLIANT |
| REQ-412: Structural interface assertion | Fake store → log-and-skip, no panic | `cloudserver_test.go > TestChunkPushStoreWithoutInsertAuditEntryDoesNotPanic` | COMPLIANT |
| REQ-413: Outcome constants | Both handlers use same outcome constant | `mutations_test.go > TestMutationPushPaused409EmitsAudit` + `cloudserver_test.go > TestChunkPushPaused409EmitsAuditWithChunkAction` | COMPLIANT |
| REQ-413: Outcome constants | Dropdown uses exported constants | `dashboard_test.go > TestAdminAuditLogListPartialOutcomeDropdown` | COMPLIANT |
| REQ-414: Project/source/path fields | 409 response includes project fields | No test found — not implemented | UNTESTED |
| REQ-414: Project/source/path fields | Non-rejection response includes project fields | No test found — not implemented | UNTESTED |

**Compliance summary**: 23/35 scenarios COMPLIANT, 9 SKIP (Postgres-gated, by design), 2 UNTESTED (REQ-414), 1 PARTIAL

---

## Correctness (Static — Structural Evidence)

| Requirement | Status | Notes |
|------------|--------|-------|
| REQ-400: cloud_sync_audit_log DDL | IMPLEMENTED | DDL appended to cs.migrate() in cloudstore.go; IF NOT EXISTS guards |
| REQ-401: AuditEntry/AuditFilter/DashboardAuditRow types | IMPLEMENTED | audit_log.go exports all three types |
| REQ-402: InsertAuditEntry synchronous | IMPLEMENTED | Synchronous INSERT, error returned to caller |
| REQ-403: ListAuditEntriesPaginated | IMPLEMENTED | Dynamic WHERE builder + COUNT(*) + ORDER BY DESC |
| REQ-404: Mutation push audit | IMPLEMENTED | Structural assertion in handleMutationPush, 409 branch |
| REQ-405: Chunk push audit | IMPLEMENTED | Structural assertion in handlePushChunk, paused branch |
| REQ-406: created_by → contributor | IMPLEMENTED | mutationPushEnvelope.CreatedBy; defaults to "unknown" |
| REQ-407: Pull path no audit | IMPLEMENTED | handleMutationPull: zero InsertAuditEntry calls confirmed |
| REQ-408: Admin /audit-log route | IMPLEMENTED | GET /dashboard/admin/audit-log registered with admin gate |
| REQ-409: Admin /audit-log/list route | IMPLEMENTED | GET /dashboard/admin/audit-log/list registered with admin gate |
| REQ-410: Filter support | IMPLEMENTED | All 5 filter fields in parseAuditFilter + ListAuditEntriesPaginated |
| REQ-411: Audit Log in admin nav | IMPLEMENTED | adminNav partial added to all 4 existing admin pages |
| REQ-412: Structural assertion pattern | IMPLEMENTED | Anonymous interface assertion; log-and-skip on failure |
| REQ-413: Outcome constants | IMPLEMENTED | AuditOutcomeRejectedProjectPaused exported from audit_log.go; single source of truth |
| REQ-414: Project/source/path response fields | NOT IMPLEMENTED | mutation push response returns only accepted_seqs; no project/project_source/project_path fields added |

---

## Coherence (Design)

| Decision | Followed? | Notes |
|----------|-----------|-------|
| Structural type assertion (not interface extension) | YES | Both handlers use anonymous interface assertion |
| Synchronous insert (no goroutine/queue) | YES | InsertAuditEntry called directly before writeActionableError |
| Audit boundary at pause-rejection only | YES | Pull path has no audit calls confirmed |
| adminNav partial extraction | YES | Single adminNav(active string) component replaces 4 duplicates |
| DashboardAuditRow.OccurredAt as string | YES (deviation documented) | String RFC3339 UTC for direct templ rendering; accepted deviation |
| Pagination uses existing Pagination type | YES (deviation documented) | PaginationMeta renamed to match codebase convention |
| E2E test location | YES (deviation documented) | cloudserver package with fakeAuditableStoreForE2E instead of cmd/engram |

---

## Deviation Assessment

| Deviation | Impact | Verdict |
|-----------|--------|---------|
| E2E test uses fake stores (no real Postgres+dashboard stack) | The cross-package integration (CloudStore + dashboard) is validated by Postgres-gated cloudstore tests. The E2E test validates the push→audit→list flow at the interface level. | ACCEPTABLE |
| Postgres-gated tests skip in CI without DSN | All cloudstore-layer behaviors (DDL, InsertAuditEntry, ListAuditEntriesPaginated) require real Postgres. Skip is clean (informative message), not silent. Tests exist and cover all scenarios. | ACCEPTABLE |
| DashboardAuditRow.OccurredAt as string | Matches pattern of other dashboard row types (e.g., DashboardContributorRow.LastChunkAt). No behavioral impact. | ACCEPTABLE |
| gofmt issue in autosync_status_test.go | Pre-existing (commit 5d2f9d7, not this change). All files changed by this change are gofmt-clean. | NOT this change's responsibility |
| REQ-414 not implemented | project/project_source/project_path fields absent from mutation push response envelope. Task coverage matrix assigned REQ-414 to tasks 2.1.3, 2.1.4, 2.1.6 which implemented created_by, not the response envelope fields. This is a gap in task decomposition. | WARNING — should be addressed |

---

## Issues Found

**CRITICAL** (must fix before archive):
None

**WARNING** (should fix):
- REQ-414 NOT IMPLEMENTED: `handleMutationPush` response envelope (both 200 and 409 paths) does not include `project`, `project_source`, `project_path` fields. The spec scenario requires these on 409-rejected and successful responses. Tasks 2.1.3, 2.1.4, 2.1.6 were assigned to REQ-414 in the spec matrix but their task descriptions only cover `created_by` (REQ-406), not the response envelope. Implementation missing; no test for it either.

**SUGGESTION** (nice to have):
- Dashboard package coverage at 60.9% is below the informal 80% threshold. The low coverage is dominated by pre-existing dashboard code (auth flows, dashboard login, manifest pull, chunk pull handlers). New audit-specific handlers are directly tested. Consider adding tests for untested pre-existing dashboard paths in a separate task.
- `mutationOccurredAt()` helper function in mutations.go has 0% coverage (it's not called in the production path — it appears to be an artifact from a previous implementation). Consider removing it.

---

## Verdict

**PASS WITH WARNINGS**

- 0 CRITICAL issues
- 1 WARNING: REQ-414 not implemented (project/project_source/project_path absent from push response envelope)
- 2 SUGGESTIONS: dashboard coverage, dead code in mutations.go

All 49 tasks are complete. All non-Postgres tests pass with zero race conditions. The 9 Postgres-gated cloudstore tests exist and skip cleanly. The Strict TDD cycle was followed for all implementation tasks. REQ-414 is a spec requirement that was not translated into implementation tasks correctly and was not built — this is a WARNING that should be resolved before final archive.
