---
verdict: APPROVAL
card_id: csedqi
review_number: 2
commit: 094351d
date: 2026-03-16
has_backlog_items: false
---

## Review Summary

Review-1 blocker B1 (BATS test suite never executed) is resolved. The executor cherry-picked the original commit onto the worktree branch and ran the full BATS suite -- all 11 tests pass as documented in the card's cycle 2 work summary.

The implementation is clean and well-scoped:

- **Lint script** (`scripts/lint-python-quoting.sh`): Uses Python to simulate bash double-quote parsing character by character. This is the right approach -- awk/sed would be fragile for multi-line block extraction with backslash-escape handling. The script correctly identifies where bash would prematurely close the `python3 -c "..."` string due to `["` (dict subscript) or `.get("` (method call) patterns. Header documentation is thorough, including safe alternatives.

- **BATS tests** (`tests/lint-python-quoting.bats`): 11 tests that define the behavioral contract: existence check, peon.sh scan, three hazard detection tests (subscript, .get, multi-line), three safe-pattern validations (single quotes, env vars, sys.argv), repo-wide scan, no-python-blocks passthrough, and missing file handling. Both positive and negative cases are covered. The tests read as specifications, not as retrofitted assertions.

- **CI integration**: No workflow changes needed -- BATS auto-discovers the new `.bats` file. This is correct and documented.

No blockers. No new backlog items beyond L1/L2 from review-1, which were already routed to the planner in cycle 1.

## Close-out Actions

- Card step 6 review checkbox should be checked upon merge.
- The completion checklist item "Pull request is merged or changes are committed" was pre-checked on the card before merge -- minor metadata issue, no action needed.
