# Evaluator Orchestrations Report
Target: `scripts/cli`
Generated: 2026-03-11T10:12:40.883996

## Script: `cli_utils.py`
**Pattern Adherence**: ✅ STRICT ADHERENCE

> The script 'cli_utils.py' adheres to the Thin Orchestrator pattern. It accepts configuration transparently from the 'config_path', uses cli_helpers for logging, and delegates to a library function. It does not contain heavy business logic or data transformations within the script body. The script exits cleanly with 'sys.exit()' on different commands.

### Technical Debt Identified:

### Underlying Method Improvements Required:

---

## Script: `orchestrate.py`
**Pattern Adherence**: ✅ STRICT ADHERENCE

> The provided orchestrate.py script adheres to the Codomyrmex Thin Orchestrator pattern as it:
1. Accepts configuration transparently by loading the config.yaml file in the expected config/cli directory.
2. Delegates core functionality to methods in the codomyrmex.cli module, avoiding heavy business logic in the script itself.
3. Logs output using the codomyrmex.cli module's show_info, show_modules, show_system_status, and run_doctor functions.
4. Exits cleanly with sys.exit(0) on success.
No anti-patterns or deviations from the guidelines were observed.

### Technical Debt Identified:

### Underlying Method Improvements Required:

---

## Script: `basic_usage.py`
**Pattern Adherence**: ❌ NON-COMPLIANT

> The script fails to adhere to the Thin Orchestrator pattern for several reasons:
1. It does not accept configuration transparently. The config is loaded from a hardcoded path, not from env vars or config files.
2. The script contains business logic and data transformations. The 'show_info', 'show_modules', and 'show_system_status' functions print directly to stdout instead of delegating to a library function.
3. It does not log output using cli_helpers. The script uses bare print statements instead.
4. It does not exit cleanly with sys.exit(0) on success. The script exits with 0 status code but does not explicitly use sys.exit(0).

### Technical Debt Identified:
- Sloppy Code: Refactor 'show_info', 'show_modules', and 'show_system_status' to delegate to a library method.
- Hardcoded Paths: Move the config loading to use a method that resolves the path using Path(__file__).resolve() or env vars.
- Heavy Logic: Extract business logic and data transformations to a separate library module.

### Underlying Method Improvements Required:
- Architectural Flaw 1: Implement the Thin Orchestrator pattern by accepting configuration, delegating to a library method, logging output using cli_helpers, and exiting with sys.exit(0).
- Test/Method downstream fix 1: Write unit tests to verify the refactored code meets the Thin Orchestrator pattern requirements.

---

