ADR EVALUATION SCORECARD
========================

ADR: ADR-0.0.57-foundation-adr-nominal-id-triage
Evaluator: gz-adr-evaluate (manual v6.0.0 — spec-reviewer + quality-reviewer + narrator)
Round: 2 (re-evaluation after CONDITIONAL GO condition resolved)
Date: 2026-05-23
CLI Pre-screen Verdict (round 2): GO (3.85/4.0)

---

## Re-evaluation Summary

This is the second evaluation pass. Round 1 (2026-05-22) issued CONDITIONAL GO with a single blocking condition: the `## Persona` section contained the literal unfilled token `{persona}`, violating AGENTS.md § Persona ("Every agent frame MUST include a Persona").

**Condition resolved:** The Persona section was filled with the `main-session` behavioral identity grounded in this ADR's scope (doctrine + runtime contract + skill). The ADR content affecting all 8 rubric dimensions and all 5 OBPI dimensions is otherwise unchanged.

All dimension scores from round 1 stand. The verdict upgrades to GO.

---

## CLI Pre-Screen Record (for traceability — round 2)

| # | Dimension | CLI Score | CLI Finding |
|---|-----------|-----------|-------------|
| 1 | Problem Clarity | 4 | OK |
| 2 | Decision Justification | 3 | No rationale language in Decision |
| 3 | Feature Checklist | 4 | OK |
| 4 | OBPI Decomposition | 4 | OK |
| 5 | Lane Assignment | 4 | OK |
| 6 | Scope Discipline | 4 | OK |
| 7 | Evidence Requirements | 4 | OK |
| 8 | Architectural Alignment | 4 | OK |

---

## Part 1: ADR Quality Dimensions (Manual — unchanged from round 1)

| # | Dimension | Weight | Score | Weighted | Rationale |
|---|-----------|--------|-------|----------|-----------|
| 1 | Problem Clarity | 15% | 4 | 0.60 | Before/after concrete, "so what?" passes, scope explicit to foundation 0.0.x only. Exemplary. |
| 2 | Decision Justification | 15% | 3 | 0.45 | Justification present but distributed (Intent + Alternatives Considered) rather than inline per decision item. CLI finding confirmed. |
| 3 | Feature Checklist Completeness | 15% | 4 | 0.60 | All 5 items necessary; each has a concrete capability-lost test; ordering logical; consistent granularity. |
| 4 | OBPI Decomposition Quality | 15% | 4 | 0.60 | Acyclic DAG (01→02→05; 04→03→05); Allowed/Denied Paths separate every surface; 1–3 day work units. |
| 5 | Lane Assignment Correctness | 10% | 4 | 0.40 | All 5 Heavy; Gate 3/4/5 obligations acknowledged per brief. Runtime-contract changes confirmed. |
| 6 | Scope Discipline | 10% | 4 | 0.40 | Four explicit anti-patterns named; diagnosis-only invariant declared; self-contained with named dependency ADRs. |
| 7 | Evidence Requirements | 10% | 4 | 0.40 | Every OBPI has concrete bash verification with expected outputs; REQ IDs deterministic; Gate 3/4/5 criteria explicit. |
| 8 | Architectural Alignment | 10% | 4 | 0.40 | Five concrete precedent file paths; nominal-ID precedent (pool slugs, GHI numbers); ghi-triage three-step pattern cited. |

**WEIGHTED TOTAL: 3.85 / 4.0**

THRESHOLD: 3.0 (GO) · 2.5 (CONDITIONAL GO) · <2.5 (NO GO)

---

## Part 2: OBPI Quality Dimensions (Manual — unchanged from round 1)

| OBPI | Slug | Independence | Testability | Value | Size | Clarity | Avg (Manual) | Avg (CLI) | CLI Δ |
|------|------|-------------|-------------|-------|------|---------|--------------|-----------|-------|
| 01 | nominal-id-doctrine | 4 | 4 | 4 | 3 | 4 | **3.8** | 3.6 | +0.2 |
| 02 | gz-adr-create-nominal-allocator | 4 | 4 | 4 | 3 | 4 | **3.8** | 3.2 | +0.6 |
| 03 | foundation-triage-skill | 3 | 4 | 3 | 3 | 4 | **3.4** | 3.6 | −0.2 |
| 04 | foundation-triage-rubric | 4 | 4 | 4 | 3 | 4 | **3.8** | 3.8 | 0 |
| 05 | docs-runbook-fixtures | 3 | 4 | 3 | 3 | 4 | **3.4** | 3.4 | 0 |

THRESHOLD: Average ≥ 3.0 per OBPI. Any dimension scoring 1 must be revised.

**All OBPIs pass. Minimum average 3.4. No dimension scores 1.**

### Key CLI reconciliation notes (unchanged from round 1)

- **OBPI-02 Value CLI=2 → Manual=4**: CLI false negative. The allocator is the core runtime deliverable — removing it makes the ADR aspirational. Heuristic misfired on value-statement distribution.
- **OBPI-02 Size CLI=2 → Manual=3**: CLI false negative. Work is within 1–3 day range; CLI over-penalized multi-surface scope.
- **OBPI-03 Independence CLI=4 → Manual=3**: CLI false positive. `triage.py` imports `rubric.py` (OBPI-04 surface) — Python import dependency not detected by frontmatter-only heuristic.
- **OBPI-05 Independence CLI=4 → Manual=3**: CLI false positive. REQ-05-07 requires real CLI output from operational OBPI-02/03/04 — runtime dependency not detected.

---

## Notable Findings (resolved and informational)

1. **Persona placeholder — RESOLVED**: The `{persona}` token that blocked round 1 is replaced with a scope-specific `main-session` behavioral identity. AGENTS.md § Persona MUST satisfied.

2. **OBPI-03/04 soft ordering dependency** (informational, non-blocking): OBPI-03's `triage.py` imports OBPI-04's `rubric.py`. Acknowledged in Denied Paths prose; not in frontmatter. Pipeline agents must land OBPI-04 before completing OBPI-03's Python module.

3. **Decision Justification distributed** (non-blocking): Decision items lack inline rationale. Justification is present in Alternatives Considered and Intent. Structurally sufficient at score 3.

4. **Dependency ADRs verified**: ADR-0.0.43 (foundation), ADR-0.0.48 (foundation), ADR-0.6.0 (pre-release) all confirmed on disk.

---

## Overall Verdict

[x] **GO** — Ready for proposal/defense review
[ ] CONDITIONAL GO
[ ] NO GO

**ADR weighted total: 3.85 / 4.0 (GO threshold: ≥ 3.0)**
**OBPI averages: 3.4–3.8 (all ≥ 3.0 threshold)**
**No dimension scores 1.**
**Round 1 CONDITIONAL GO condition resolved: persona section filled.**

### Optional improvements (non-blocking)

1. Add inline rationale anchors to each of the three Decision items.
2. Add `depends_on: [OBPI-0.0.57-04]` to OBPI-03 frontmatter for machine-readable ordering.
