# Persona-Dispatch Verdicts — ADR-0.0.68 Audit (2026-06-09)

Independent subagent reviews per gz-adr-audit § Persona Dispatch.

## spec-reviewer — SPEC-REVIEW: PASS

All 6 REQs trace to their declared proof channels under REQ-kind discipline:

| REQ | Kind | Proof channel | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|
| REQ-0.0.68-01-01 | behavior | `.pre-commit-config.yaml:88-93` + `tests/test_pre_push_hook.py:36-53` | PASS |
| REQ-0.0.68-01-02 | support | `docs/user/runbook.md:376` (`uvx pre-commit install --hook-type pre-push`) | PASS |
| REQ-0.0.68-02-01 | behavior | `src/gzkit/governance/trust_audits/session_green_gate.py:32-85` + `tests/test_session_green_gate_validator.py` (6 fixtures incl. GHI #600 sibling-verb hardening) | PASS |
| REQ-0.0.68-02-02 | behavior | `src/gzkit/commands/quality.py:327` + check-scope test | PASS |
| REQ-0.0.68-02-03 | support | `docs/user/manpages/validate.md:1367` (exit-3 contract) | PASS |
| REQ-0.0.68-02-04 | structural-fence | parent ADR § Boundary Invariants #1; code read confirms no scope enumeration | PASS |

Every behavior test asserts REQ-derived semantics and can fail under regression.

## quality-reviewer — QUALITY-REVIEW: COHERENT

1. **Integration chain composes end-to-end** [COHERENT] — six-link chain verified:
   config declaration → `audit_session_green_gate` → validate dispatch/flag →
   `run_session_green_gate_audit` → `_build_check_steps`. Self-referential claim
   holds: deleting the declaration turns the next `gz check` red.
2. **GHI #600 token-adjacency match sound** [COHERENT] — `gz checkpoint` and
   `gz check-config-paths` rejected; `uv run gz check --fast`, quoted and
   multi-line entries pass; no `IndexError` on short entries.
3. **Boundary Invariant #1 satisfied** [COHERENT] — no hardcoded validator-scope
   list anywhere in the gate chain; pure `gz check` delegation (ln-sunset needs
   zero rewiring).
4. **Local `covers` shadow in test file** [DEFECT, minor] — REMEDIATED in-ceremony:
   direct fix `423701ea` replaces the shadow with `gzkit.traceability.covers`
   (restores import-time REQ-existence guard); module 7/7 OK.
5. **`entry`-as-list edge** [BRITTLE, minor/acceptable] — invalid pre-commit
   schema, rejected by pre-commit itself; defensive posture acceptable per
   ADR § Consequences #5.
6. **Naming/placement/SRP match cited precedent** [COHERENT] — mirrors
   `run_adr_status_fresh_audit` exactly.

## Ceremony-start remediation (driver)

`gz adr audit-check ADR-0.0.68` initially FAILED (exit 3) on one blocking
covers-backfill finding — diagnosed as a validator false positive: `git log -L`
and `git blame` cross-attribute content-identical `@covers` lines when the
GHI #600 fix inserted a twin decorator block. Direct fix `5b2a71ed`
(blame re-anchor in `adr_audit_covers_backfill.py`, RED→GREEN, 4 new tests,
GHI #272/#309 protections preserved). Re-run: PASS exit 0.
