# V1 Parity Complete - Tool Display

**Status**: ✅ Matches V1 behavior

---

## What Changed

### 1. ExploringCard No Longer Auto-Collapses

**V1 Behavior (Correct)**:
- Tool calls card stays **open and visible**
- Shows completed tool calls (e.g., "Listed reach")
- Assistant's text response appears **below** the card

**V2 Previous (Wrong)**:
- Card auto-collapsed when streaming finished
- Tool calls disappeared
- User couldn't see what tools were used

**V2 Now (Fixed)**:
- Card stays open showing completed tool calls
- Matches V1 exactly
- User can manually collapse if desired (click the ▼)

---

## How to See Changes

### Option 1: Hard Refresh (Recommended)
```
Cmd+Shift+R (Mac)
Ctrl+Shift+R (Windows/Linux)
```

### Option 2: Full Restart
```bash
# Stop app (Ctrl+C)
npm start
```

---

## Expected UI Flow

### 1. During Tool Execution
```
▼ Deep in thought
  **Running a search with Bash**
  I need to respond that I can use...

▼ Exploring
  → Listing reach
```

### 2. After Tool Completes (Before Assistant Response)
```
▼ Deep in thought
  [collapsed]

▼ Exploring
  → Listed reach
```

### 3. When Assistant Starts Responding
```
▼ Deep in thought
  [collapsed]

▼ Exploring
  → Listed reach

Your reach folder contains the following files:
- file1.txt
- file2.md
...
```

**Key**: The "Exploring" card **stays open** throughout!

---

## File Changes

### ui/components/Chat/ExploringCard.tsx
**Before**:
```typescript
// Auto-collapse when streaming finishes
useEffect(() => {
  if (wasStreamingRef.current && !isStreaming && toolCalls.length > 0) {
    setIsCollapsed(true);  // ❌ Auto-collapsed
  }
  wasStreamingRef.current = isStreaming;
}, [isStreaming, toolCalls.length]);
```

**After**:
```typescript
// Start expanded (matches V1 behavior)
// V1: Keep card open showing completed tool calls, with assistant text below
const [isCollapsed, setIsCollapsed] = useState(false);
// No auto-collapse logic ✅
```

---

## Differences from V1

### Same as V1 ✅
- Customer-friendly command descriptions
- Smart bash command translation (curl → "Getting info from {domain}")
- Fallback to showing actual command
- Card stays open showing completed tool calls
- Assistant text appears below the card

### Different from V1 (Intentional) ✅
- No emojis (⏳, ✓, ✗) - per user request
- Simpler collapse/expand (just click header)
- Status via text only ("Listing" → "Listed")

---

## Testing

1. **Hard refresh** the app: `Cmd+Shift+R`

2. **Send**: "List files in my Dropbox reach folder"

3. **Verify**:
   - ✅ Card shows "Listing reach" during execution
   - ✅ Card updates to "Listed reach" when complete
   - ✅ Card **stays open** (does NOT collapse)
   - ✅ Assistant's text response appears below the card
   - ✅ No emojis shown

---

## Why This Matters

### User Experience Benefits

1. **Visibility**: Users can see what tools the assistant used
2. **Trust**: Transparency builds confidence in AI actions
3. **Debugging**: When something goes wrong, users can see which tool was called
4. **Context**: Understanding the tool calls helps understand the response

### V1 Got This Right

V1 intentionally keeps the actioning card visible because:
- It's **important context** for the assistant's response
- Users want to know "how did you get that answer?"
- It's part of the conversation history
- It's visually separated from the response (card vs. text)

---

## Related Files

- **ExploringCard.tsx** - Tool calls display component
- **MessageItem.tsx** - Renders messages with tool calls
- **useAgent.ts** - Handles streaming chunks

---

## Documentation

- **CUSTOMER_FRIENDLY_TOOL_DISPLAY.md** - Full command translation patterns
- **HOW_TO_REFRESH.md** - How to see UI changes
- **READY_TO_TEST_V2.md** - Quick test guide

---

## Status

✅ **COMPLETE** - V1 parity achieved for tool display behavior

**Next**: Test with various tool calls to verify all patterns work correctly.
