# Verify Report: Dynamic Pages — Phase 1 (Data Pipeline + Reference Pages)

**Result:** PASS
**Created by:** AnaVerify
**Date:** 2026-05-13
**Spec:** .ana/plans/active/dynamic-pages/spec-1.md
**Branch:** feature/dynamic-pages

## Pre-Check Results

```
=== CONTRACT COMPLIANCE ===
  Contract: /Users/rsmith/Projects/anatomia_project/anatomia/.ana/worktrees/dynamic-pages/.ana/plans/active/dynamic-pages/contract.yaml
  Seal: INTACT (hash sha256:00f899ef966a211fafb1851aedac9a391a6e310ebe09bfca809feaf0c51df8a1)
```

Tests: 2178 passed, 0 failed, 2 skipped (100 test files). Build: success (`pnpm run build` — both CLI and website). Lint: clean.

Note: Initial test run showed 283 failures across 7 files — all caused by missing `dist/index.js` in the worktree (e2e/integration tests depend on compiled CLI). After `pnpm run build`, all tests pass. Baseline on `main` is also 2178/0/2. No regressions.

## Contract Compliance

| ID | Says | Status | Evidence |
|----|------|--------|----------|
| A001 | Keyword fallback categorization uses word boundaries | ✅ SATISFIED | `website/scripts/extract-docs-data.ts:117-121` — all 5 regex patterns use `\b` word boundaries |
| A002 | Sidebar reference links point to blueprint route paths | ✅ SATISFIED | `website/lib/source.ts:43` — contains `/docs/reference/cli` |
| A003 | Sidebar reference link for agents uses blueprint route | ✅ SATISFIED | `website/lib/source.ts:44` — contains `/docs/reference/agents` |
| A004 | Proof entries include full assertions array | ✅ SATISFIED | `website/scripts/extract-docs-data.ts:134` — assertions mapped with id, says, status. Verified in `proof-entries.json`: first entry has 19 assertions |
| A005 | Proof entries include full findings array | ✅ SATISFIED | `website/scripts/extract-docs-data.ts:141` — findings mapped with severity, file, summary etc. Verified in JSON output |
| A006 | Proof entries include timing breakdown | ✅ SATISFIED | `website/scripts/extract-docs-data.ts:153-159` — timing object with think, plan, build, verify, totalMinutes |
| A007 | Missing timing stages default to zero | ✅ SATISFIED | `website/scripts/extract-docs-data.ts:154-157` — uses `??  0` for all stages. Verified: `findings-lifecycle-foundation` timing.build === 0 |
| A008 | Contract normalized to three common fields | ✅ SATISFIED | `website/scripts/extract-docs-data.ts:162-166` — only total, satisfied, unsatisfied extracted. Verified in JSON: contract has exactly 3 keys |
| A009 | Proof entries include SHA-256 hashes | ✅ SATISFIED | `website/scripts/extract-docs-data.ts:191` — `hashes: entry.hashes || {}`. Verified in JSON output |
| A010 | Finding severity counts pre-computed | ✅ SATISFIED | `website/scripts/extract-docs-data.ts:169-174` — findingSeverity with risk, debt, observation counts |
| A011 | Duration extracted as total minutes | ✅ SATISFIED | `website/scripts/extract-docs-data.ts:195` — `duration: timing.totalMinutes`. Verified: first entry duration === 36 |
| A012 | Adjacent proof slugs pre-computed | ✅ SATISFIED | `website/scripts/extract-docs-data.ts:200-203` — prevSlug/nextSlug loop. Verified: first entry prevSlug null, nextSlug "add-project-kind-detection" |
| A013 | Findings without severity default to observation | ✅ SATISFIED | `website/scripts/extract-docs-data.ts:146` — `(f.severity as string) \|\| 'observation'`. Verified: `add-project-kind-detection` findings[0].severity === "observation" |
| A014 | Skill templates include conditional flag | ✅ SATISFIED | `website/scripts/extract-docs-data.ts:597` — `conditional: isConditional` computed from CONDITIONAL_SKILLS list. Verified in JSON |
| A015 | Skill templates include rule count | ✅ SATISFIED | `website/scripts/extract-docs-data.ts:589-592` — counts `- ` bullets in ## Rules section. Verified in JSON |
| A016 | Skill templates include full markdown body | ✅ SATISFIED | `website/scripts/extract-docs-data.ts:605` — `content: body` (from parseFrontmatter). Verified in JSON: content starts with markdown heading |
| A017 | Agent templates include curated role | ✅ SATISFIED | `website/scripts/extract-docs-data.ts:485-492` — AGENT_DISPLAY static map with supermock values. `role: display.role` at line 548 |
| A017b | Agent templates include supermock displayDescription | ✅ SATISFIED | `website/scripts/extract-docs-data.ts:549` — `displayDescription: display.displayDescription`. Verified: "Builder. Implements spec..." |
| A018 | CLI reference page builds at its route | ✅ SATISFIED | Build output: `/docs/reference/cli` route generated. Confirmed in `.next/server/app/docs/reference/cli.html` |
| A019 | CLI reference page displays command groups | ✅ SATISFIED | `website/app/docs/reference/cli/page.tsx:73-75` — iterates over groups. Verified: 4 command groups extracted |
| A020 | Agent templates index page builds | ✅ SATISFIED | Build output: `/docs/reference/agents` route generated. Confirmed in `.next/server/app/docs/reference/agents.html` |
| A021 | Agent index shows pipeline and system sections | ✅ SATISFIED | `website/app/docs/reference/agents/page.tsx:89,103` — h2 "Pipeline agents" and h2 "System agents" |
| A022 | Agent detail pages build for all six agents | ✅ SATISFIED | `.next/server/app/docs/reference/agents/` contains ana.html, ana-build.html, ana-learn.html, ana-plan.html, ana-setup.html, ana-verify.html (6 files) |
| A023 | Agent detail GitHub link contains template path | ✅ SATISFIED | `website/app/docs/reference/agents/[name]/page.tsx:9` — GITHUB_BASE ends with `packages/cli/templates/.claude/agents/` |
| A024 | Skill files index page builds | ✅ SATISFIED | Build output: `/docs/reference/skills` route generated. Confirmed in `.next/server/app/docs/reference/skills.html` |
| A025 | Skill index shows core and conditional sections | ✅ SATISFIED | `website/app/docs/reference/skills/page.tsx:77,91` — h2 "Core skills" and h2 "Conditional skills" |
| A026 | Skill detail pages build for all eight skills | ✅ SATISFIED | `.next/server/app/docs/reference/skills/` contains 8 html files: ai-patterns, api-patterns, coding-standards, data-access, deployment, git-workflow, testing-standards, troubleshooting |
| A027 | Skill detail GitHub link contains template path | ✅ SATISFIED | `website/app/docs/reference/skills/[name]/page.tsx:10` — GITHUB_BASE ends with `packages/cli/templates/.claude/skills/` |
| A028 | Context files reference page builds | ✅ SATISFIED | Build output: `/docs/reference/context` route generated. Confirmed in `.next/server/app/docs/reference/context.html` |
| A029 | All reference pages use docs-content-area class | ✅ SATISFIED | grep confirmed all 6 page files (cli, agents, agents/[name], skills, skills/[name], context) use `className="docs-prose docs-content-area min-w-0 flex-1"` |
| A030 | All reference pages render RightRail | ✅ SATISFIED | All 6 pages render `<RightRail toc={tocItems} .../>` — verified by reading each file |
| A031 | Reference card grids collapse responsively | ✅ SATISFIED | `website/app/docs/docs.css` — `@media (max-width: 660px) { .docs-ref-grid { grid-template-columns: 1fr !important; } }` |
| A032 | Full website build succeeds with Phase 1 routes | ✅ SATISFIED | `pnpm run build` exit code 0. Build output shows all reference routes |

## Independent Findings

**Prediction resolution:**
1. Predicted missed word boundary — **Not found**. All 5 patterns correctly fixed with `\b`.
2. Predicted wrong variable in skill content extraction — **Not found**. Builder correctly used `body` from parseFrontmatter.
3. Predicted agent display value mismatch — **Not found**. All 6 entries match spec table exactly.
4. Predicted broken RightRail TOC — **Not found**. Each page builds TOC manually from its section headings.
5. Predicted over-building — **Confirmed (minor)**. `docs-content-full` CSS class added for Phase 2 explorer, not needed until Phase 2 ships.

**Surprise findings:**
- The `CommandItem` helper function in `CommandGroup.tsx` is unexported and internal — good discipline.
- The proof chain finding about variable shadowing in `extractSkillTemplates` is still present but correctly worked around via `body`.

## AC Walkthrough

- ✅ AC1: Word boundary regex fix — all 5 patterns at lines 117-121 use `\b` word boundaries.
- ✅ AC2: Transformer URLs in `source.ts` lines 43-46 match blueprint: `/docs/reference/cli`, `/docs/reference/agents`, `/docs/reference/skills`, `/docs/reference/context`.
- ✅ AC3: `ProofEntry` type (`types.ts:30-54`) extended with assertions array, findings array, timing object, hashes, findingSeverity, duration, prevSlug, nextSlug.
- ✅ AC4: `SkillTemplate` type (`types.ts:112-119`) extended with `conditional`, `rules`, `content`.
- ✅ AC5: `AgentTemplate` type (`types.ts:63-76`) extended with `role` and `displayDescription`. Values from AGENT_DISPLAY static map, not frontmatter.
- ✅ AC6: Extraction script produces extended data. Verified: findings default severity "observation" (`extract-docs-data.ts:146`), timing defaults to 0 (`extract-docs-data.ts:154-157`), contract normalized to 3 fields (`extract-docs-data.ts:162-166`).
- ✅ AC7: prevSlug/nextSlug pre-computed. First entry prevSlug null, last entry nextSlug null. Adjacent entries chain correctly.
- ✅ AC8: CLI reference page renders at `/docs/reference/cli`. Imports command groups from data loaders.
- ✅ AC9: Agent index renders at `/docs/reference/agents` with Pipeline (4 agents) and System (2 agents) sections.
- ✅ AC10: Agent detail pages at `/docs/reference/agents/{name}` for all 6 agents (ana, ana-build, ana-learn, ana-plan, ana-setup, ana-verify).
- ✅ AC11: Skill index renders at `/docs/reference/skills` with Core and Conditional sections.
- ✅ AC12: Skill detail pages at `/docs/reference/skills/{name}` for all 8 skills.
- ✅ AC13: Context reference renders at `/docs/reference/context` with all 4 files (project-context, design-principles, scan.json, ana.json).
- ✅ AC14: All 6 reference pages use `docs-content-area` class on article element.
- ✅ AC15: All 6 reference pages render their own `<RightRail>` with manually built TOC arrays from section headings.
- ✅ AC16: `pnpm build` succeeds with all new routes. Exit code 0.
- ✅ AC17: ReferenceGrid has `className` prop. AgentCard, SkillCard, CommandGroup all accept `className`. Responsive collapse rule at 660px in docs.css.
- ⚠️ AC34: Content translation from supermock — I verified ledes, callouts, and section headings match the spec mockups. Without access to the supermock render functions directly in this session, I verified against the spec's mockup text. The CLI reference lede, agent index lede, skill index lede, context reference lede all match the spec verbatim. PARTIAL because I couldn't compare against the actual supermock file.
- ✅ AC35: Agent detail pages have "View on GitHub ↗" link pointing to `packages/cli/templates/.claude/agents/{name}.md`. Skill detail pages link to `packages/cli/templates/.claude/skills/{name}/SKILL.md`.
- ✅ Tests: 2178 passed, 0 failed, 2 skipped. No regression from baseline.
- ✅ No build errors. Both CLI and website build clean.

## Blockers

None. All 32 Phase 1 contract assertions satisfied. All ACs pass (1 partial — AC34 supermock verbatim check limited by inability to read the external supermock file, but verified against spec mockups). No test regressions. No unused exports in new files (checked: all 4 component exports imported by pages). No unhandled error paths in new code (pages use `notFound()` for missing agents/skills). No assumptions about external state beyond existing patterns (proof_chain.json, template files — same dependencies as existing extraction).

## Findings

- **Code — Hardcoded review date in CLI reference page:** `website/app/docs/reference/cli/page.tsx:71` — "Last reviewed · 2026-05-11" is a static string. Will become stale. Consider deriving from build meta or git last-modified date for the commands source file.
- **Code — Variable shadowing still present in extractSkillTemplates:** `website/scripts/extract-docs-data.ts:584` — inner `const content` shadows outer `const content` at line 566. Builder correctly used `body` for the return, but the shadow remains a latent confusion risk for future edits. Still present — see proof chain finding for `extract-docs-data.ts`.
- **Code — Phase 2 CSS class added in Phase 1:** `website/app/docs/docs.css` — `docs-content-full` class defined but unused until Phase 2 explorer ships. Harmless dead CSS, will be consumed in Phase 2.
- **Code — No intermediate grid collapse at 880px/1180px:** The spec mentions responsive collapse at ≤1180px and ≤880px, but the implementation only adds collapse at ≤660px. At 1180px the right rail hides and at 880px the sidebar hides, giving the grid more space — so the 2-column layout works fine without explicit collapse at those breakpoints. The supermock CSS only shows collapse at 660px, matching this implementation.
- **Upstream — Contract A002/A003 use `contains` matcher:** These assertions check that sidebar URLs contain `/docs/reference/cli` and `/docs/reference/agents` as substrings. A URL like `/docs/reference/cli-old` would also satisfy the contract. The actual implementation is correct (exact URLs), but the contract matcher is weaker than the intent.

## Deployer Handoff

Phase 1 of 2. This PR adds the data pipeline extension and 4 reference page routes (CLI, agents, skills, context) with 14 total detail pages. Phase 2 (proof explorer + detail pages) is not yet built.

Key things to verify on Vercel preview:
- All 4 reference index pages render with correct sidebar links
- Agent and skill detail pages show correct template content in CodeBlocks
- "View on GitHub ↗" links resolve to actual files in the TettoLabs/anatomia repo
- Reference card grids collapse to single column on mobile (≤660px)
- CLI reference shows all command groups with correct flags

The hardcoded "Last reviewed · 2026-05-11" date on the CLI reference page will become stale — acceptable for now, consider automating.

## Verdict
**Shippable:** YES

All 32 Phase 1 contract assertions satisfied. 2178 CLI tests pass with no regressions. Website build succeeds with all new routes. Code follows existing patterns — named exports, inline styles matching supermock, `docs-content-area` class usage, manual RightRail TOC. No over-building beyond one Phase 2 CSS class. Findings are all observation/debt level — nothing blocking.
