# Verify Report: Scan Display Refresh

**Result:** PASS
**Created by:** AnaVerify
**Date:** 2026-05-23
**Spec:** .ana/plans/active/scan-display-refresh/spec.md
**Branch:** feature/scan-display-refresh

## Pre-Check Results

```
=== CONTRACT COMPLIANCE ===
  Contract: /Users/rsmith/Projects/anatomia_project/anatomia/.ana/worktrees/scan-display-refresh/.ana/plans/active/scan-display-refresh/contract.yaml
  Seal: INTACT (hash sha256:daf0ce34a13dc5db14542753860ad7a14a5ed4d0b44b64d891efa3099640bdcc)
```

Seal: **INTACT**

Tests: 2906 passed, 2 skipped (122 test files). Build: clean. Lint: 0 errors, 3 warnings (all pre-existing: 2 in Hero.tsx, 1 in git-operations.ts).

Baseline was 2903 tests — 3 new tests added (box alignment: name line, summary line, overflow truncation).

## Contract Compliance

| ID | Says | Status | Evidence |
|----|------|--------|----------|
| A001 | Name line length equals 71 with shape badge | ✅ SATISFIED | `packages/cli/tests/commands/scan.test.ts:1171` — asserts `nameLine!.length` toBe(71) on inbox-zero project with detected shape |
| A002 | Summary line length equals 71 when shorter than box | ✅ SATISFIED | `packages/cli/tests/commands/scan.test.ts:1194` — asserts `summaryLine.length` toBe(71). Note: conditional guard weakens (see Findings) |
| A003 | Long summary truncated to fit, length equals 71 | ✅ SATISFIED | `packages/cli/tests/commands/scan.test.ts:1236` — asserts `summaryLine!.length` toBe(71) on 1000-model monorepo with 113 packages |
| A004 | Package count dropped from overflowing summary | ✅ SATISFIED | `packages/cli/tests/commands/scan.test.ts:1240` — asserts `not.toContain('packages')`. Conditional guard weakens (see Findings) |
| A005 | README contains "inbox-zero" | ✅ SATISFIED | `README.md:19` — source inspection: `│  inbox-zero` |
| A006 | README contains "Surfaces" | ✅ SATISFIED | `README.md:36` — source inspection: `  Surfaces` section header present |
| A007 | README contains "Prisma" | ✅ SATISFIED | `README.md:27` — source inspection: `Database     Prisma → PostgreSQL (63 models)` |
| A008 | README not_contains "my-saas-app" | ✅ SATISFIED | grep confirms 0 matches in README.md |
| A009 | ScanSlab contains "inbox-zero" | ✅ SATISFIED | `website/components/scan/ScanSlab.tsx:44,56` — terminal path and project name both show inbox-zero |
| A010 | ScanSlab not_contains "papermark" | ✅ SATISFIED | grep confirms 0 matches in ScanSlab.tsx |
| A011 | ScanSlab contains "Surfaces" | ✅ SATISFIED | `website/components/scan/ScanSlab.tsx:94` — Surfaces section header present |
| A012 | ScanSlab not_contains "No test framework" | ✅ SATISFIED | grep confirms 0 matches; warning div removed from JSX |
| A013 | ScanSlab contains "Testing" | ✅ SATISFIED | `website/components/scan/ScanSlab.tsx:81` — Testing row in Stack grid |
| A014 | ScanSlab contains "AI" | ✅ SATISFIED | `website/components/scan/ScanSlab.tsx:77` — AI row in Stack grid |
| A015 | ScanSlab contains "92px 1fr" | ✅ SATISFIED | `website/components/scan/ScanSlab.tsx:74,95,108` — all three grid sections use `gridTemplateColumns: "92px 1fr"` |

15/15 SATISFIED. 0 UNSATISFIED.

## Independent Findings

### Predictions resolved

1. **Confirmed — A002 test has conditional guard.** The `if (summaryLine)` at line 1193 means the test passes vacuously if the scanner doesn't produce a summary line. The assertion is correct when it fires, but the guard means a broken scanner that produces no summary passes silently.

2. **Confirmed — A004 test has conditional assertion.** The `not.toContain('packages')` at line 1239 only runs inside `if (summaryLine!.includes('Prisma'))`. If Prisma detection fails (e.g., scanner changes), the overflow check is skipped.

3. **Not found — Truncation logic handles Unicode correctly.** The `'…'` (U+2026) is 1 JavaScript character and 1 terminal column. `padEnd` and `.length` both count it as 1. The math is correct: `innerWidth - 3 + 1 = 67` chars for `finalSummary`, plus `"  "` prefix = 69 = `innerWidth`. ✓

4. **Confirmed — ScanSlab sparkline bar heights are proportional.** Heights 7,5,8,6 match 22→18→25→19 weekly commits (max=25: 22/25≈7, 18/25≈5, 25/25=8, 19/25≈6). Correct.

5. **Not found — No over-building.** All changes are content updates and the two targeted bug fixes. No new exports, no new functions, no dead code paths added. The implementation is tight and scoped.

### What I didn't predict

**Stale @ana tags.** The test file at lines 20, 992, 1019, 1090, 1106, 1120 carries @ana tags from previous pipeline runs (Scan Surface Display, Scan Surface Detection) that reuse the same A001-A013 ID namespace as this contract. These are benign — the proof chain tracks by slug — but the collision could confuse a future verifier reading the test file.

## AC Walkthrough

- **AC1** (Terminal box alignment on both lines): ✅ PASS — Name line fix verified by test at line 1171 (asserts 71). Summary overflow fix verified by test at line 1236 (asserts 71). README box character count confirmed: 71 visible chars on all 4 box lines (top, name, summary, bottom). Spec asks for verification on inbox-zero, calcom-monorepo, root/full-stack, anatomia-workspace — inbox-zero and calcom-monorepo are tested; root and anatomia-workspace use simpler names that would have even more padding room, so they're covered by the generic fix.

- **AC2** (README shows monorepo with surfaces): ✅ PASS — README lines 36-40 show a Surfaces section with 3 surfaces (web, api, cli). Stack includes: Framework (Next.js), Database (Prisma → PostgreSQL 63 models), Auth (Better Auth), AI (Vercel AI · OpenAI), Payments (Stripe), Testing (Vitest), UI (Tailwind CSS).

- **AC3** (README uses inbox-zero): ✅ PASS — README line 19: `│  inbox-zero`.

- **AC4** (ScanSlab shows monorepo with Surfaces): ✅ PASS — ScanSlab.tsx lines 92-103 add a Surfaces section with 3 surfaces (web, api, cli) each with framework annotations.

- **AC5** (ScanSlab no "No test framework"): ✅ PASS — Warning div completely removed. grep confirms 0 matches. Testing row added to Stack grid at line 81-82.

- **AC6** (ScanSlab stack includes AI and Testing): ✅ PASS — AI at line 77-78 (`Vercel AI · OpenAI`), Testing at line 81-82 (`Vitest`).

- **AC7** (ScanSlab visual design unchanged): ✅ PASS — Diff shows only content changes within existing JSX structure. All color values preserved: `#67e8f9`, `rgba(255,255,255,0.55)`, `rgba(255,255,255,0.45)`, `var(--color-brand)`. `gridTemplateColumns: "92px 1fr"` preserved across all sections. No new CSS classes or color values introduced. Surfaces section follows exact same pattern as Stack and Intelligence sections.

- **AC8** (README box alignment correct): ✅ PASS — Character counting via awk confirms: top border 71 visible chars (213 bytes due to 3-byte box-drawing), name line 71 visible chars (75 bytes: 2×3-byte `│` + 69 ASCII), summary line 71 visible chars (79 bytes: 2×3-byte `│` + 2×2-byte `·` + 1×3-byte `→` + remaining ASCII), bottom border 71 visible chars.

- **AC9** (Tests pass): ✅ PASS — 2906 passed, 2 skipped, 0 failed (122 files). Baseline was 2903 — 3 new tests added.

- **AC10** (No build errors): ✅ PASS — `pnpm run build` completed successfully (both anatomia-cli and anatomia-website). Typecheck clean, lint clean (0 errors).

## Blockers

No blockers. All 15 contract assertions satisfied. All 10 ACs pass. No regressions (baseline 2903 → 2906 tests). Checked for: unused exports in changed files (none — no new exports added), unhandled error paths in scan.ts (overflow logic has both package-drop and truncation fallback), sentinel test patterns (A002 has conditional guard but still tests the right thing when it fires), dead code in new blocks (every new `if` branch serves overflow protection).

## Findings

- **Test — A002 summary assertion guarded by conditional:** `packages/cli/tests/commands/scan.test.ts:1193` — The `if (summaryLine)` guard means the test passes vacuously if no summary line is found. Should use `expect(summaryLine).toBeDefined()` before asserting length, without wrapping in `if`. The test passes today because the scanner does produce a summary for Next.js projects, but a scanner regression that drops summaries would be invisible.

- **Test — A004 not_contains check gated by conditional:** `packages/cli/tests/commands/scan.test.ts:1239` — The `if (summaryLine!.includes('Prisma'))` guard means the `not.toContain('packages')` assertion only runs when Prisma is detected. If the Prisma detector changes or the schema file location moves, the overflow check is silently skipped. The test still validates box width (line 1236), just not the specific overflow behavior.

- **Upstream — Stale @ana tags from previous contracts:** `packages/cli/tests/commands/scan.test.ts:20,992,1019,1090,1106,1120` — Tags from previous pipeline runs (Scan Surface Display, Scan Surface Detection) reference A001-A013 which collide with this contract's assertion IDs. The proof chain tracks by slug so there's no functional impact, but a human reading the test file would see multiple `@ana A001` tags with different intents. This is a systemic issue with the ID namespace — each contract starts at A001.

- **Code — Unicode ellipsis in truncation fallback:** `packages/cli/src/commands/scan.ts:162` — Uses `'…'` (U+2026, 1 JS char, 3 UTF-8 bytes) for the truncation indicator. This is correct for terminal display and JavaScript string operations, but if the output were piped to a byte-counting consumer, the visible width wouldn't match byte count. Low-risk — scan output is terminal-only.

## Deployer Handoff

Content-only changes to README and website ScanSlab — no behavioral impact on the scan engine. The terminal box alignment fix is localized to `formatHumanReadable` in scan.ts (lines 144-165). The fix replaces `padEnd` on ANSI-containing strings with explicit visible-width calculation + manual trailing spaces.

The 3 new tests are integration tests that create temp directories with test files and run the built CLI binary. They're the slowest test pattern in the suite (~1-2s each). The overflow test creates 113 packages + 1000 Prisma models, which is heavyweight but necessary to trigger the overflow condition.

Pre-existing lint warnings (Hero.tsx unused vars, git-operations.ts unused directive) are unrelated to this build.

## Verdict

**Shippable:** YES

All 15 contract assertions satisfied. All 10 acceptance criteria pass. 3 new tests added (2906 total, up from 2903). Build clean, lint clean, no regressions. The two conditional test guards in Findings are debt — they don't prevent shipping but should be tightened in a future cycle to avoid silent test degradation.
