# Verify Report: Command File Duplication Cleanup

**Result:** PASS
**Created by:** AnaVerify
**Date:** 2026-05-20
**Spec:** .ana/plans/active/command-duplication-cleanup/spec.md
**Branch:** feature/command-duplication-cleanup

## Pre-Check Results
```
=== CONTRACT COMPLIANCE ===
  Contract: .ana/plans/active/command-duplication-cleanup/contract.yaml
  Seal: INTACT (hash sha256:493324dfc0c776533a1e78b731eb028aba414d97e1b165621ec528a5f97f423b)
```

Tests: 2713 passed, 2 skipped (120 test files). Build: success. Lint: 1 warning (pre-existing unused eslint-disable at git-operations.ts:198 — documented in spec as known, not introduced by this build).

## Contract Compliance
| ID | Says | Status | Evidence |
|----|------|--------|----------|
| A001 | Resolves counting runs once before the output branch, not duplicated | ✅ SATISFIED | work.ts:1824-1830 — single loop before `if (options?.json)` at line 1833, used at lines 1857 and 1882 |
| A002 | JSON output includes resolves_claims when upstream findings resolve prior issues | ✅ SATISFIED | work.ts:1857-1858 — `resolvesClaimsCount > 0` guard adds `resolves_claims` to JSON output |
| A003 | Console output shows resolution claim count when upstream findings resolve prior issues | ✅ SATISFIED | work.ts:1882-1883 — console.log with "Verify claims" message uses `resolvesClaimsCount` |
| A004 | The startWork resume path reads the branch name using getCurrentBranch | ✅ SATISFIED | work.ts:1926 — `getCurrentBranch() ?? '(unknown)'`, no `runGit(['rev-parse', '--abbrev-ref', 'HEAD'])` present in that path |
| A005 | Empty audit matrix values are defined once as a shared constant | ✅ SATISFIED | proof.ts:145-156 — `const EMPTY_AUDIT_MATRIX` defined with all 11 fields |
| A006 | Both empty audit paths use the shared constant instead of inline objects | ✅ SATISFIED | proof.ts:1585 and proof.ts:1619 — both reference `EMPTY_AUDIT_MATRIX` |
| A007 | pullBeforeRead is exported from the git utilities module | ✅ SATISFIED | git-operations.ts:220 — `export function pullBeforeRead(proofRoot: string): void` |
| A008 | commitAndPushProofChanges is exported from the git utilities module | ✅ SATISFIED | git-operations.ts:250 — `export function commitAndPushProofChanges(options: {...}): void` |
| A009 | proof.ts no longer defines pullBeforeRead or commitAndPushProofChanges | ✅ SATISFIED | grep for `export function pullBeforeRead` and `export function commitAndPushProofChanges` in proof.ts — zero matches |
| A010 | learn.ts imports git functions from the utilities module, not from proof | ✅ SATISFIED | learn.ts:17 — imports from `'../utils/git-operations.js'` including both `commitAndPushProofChanges` and `pullBeforeRead` |
| A011 | learn.ts does not import anything from proof.ts | ✅ SATISFIED | grep for `from './proof.js'` in learn.ts — zero matches |
| A012 | All existing tests pass and the count is unchanged from baseline | ✅ SATISFIED | 2713 passed, 2 skipped — matches baseline of 2713 passed, 2 skipped |
| A013 | isTimestampRecent remains as its own function in work.ts | ✅ SATISFIED | work.ts:368 — `function isTimestampRecent(savesDir: string, timestampKey: string): boolean` unchanged |
| A014 | The spawnSync import is removed from proof.ts since no code there uses it | ✅ SATISFIED | proof.ts imports (lines 20-46) — no `spawnSync` import present |
| A015 | No new lint violations are introduced by the refactoring | ✅ SATISFIED | lint exits with 0 errors, 1 warning (pre-existing at git-operations.ts:198) |

## Independent Findings

**Predictions resolved:**

1. *"Resolves counting hoist might leave dead variables"* — **Not found.** The console branch cleanly uses the hoisted `resolvesClaimsCount` with no residual loop or dead variable.
2. *"EMPTY_AUDIT_MATRIX might not match both sites"* — **Not found.** Verified the constant at proof.ts:145-156 against both usage sites. The differentiation is in the second argument to `wrapJsonResponse` (one passes `{ entries: [] }`, the other passes `chain`) — exactly as the spec described.
3. *"spawnSync removal might leave partial import"* — **Not found.** The entire `spawnSync` import is gone from proof.ts. git-operations.ts already had its own `spawnSync` import (line 12).
4. *"git-operations.ts might need new imports"* — **Not found.** File already imported `spawnSync` and `chalk` — no new imports were needed.
5. *"`getCurrentBranch() ?? '(unknown)'` might differ from original behavior"* — **Not found.** The original code did `runGit(['rev-parse', '--abbrev-ref', 'HEAD'])` and checked `exitCode` — `getCurrentBranch()` does exactly the same thing, returning null on non-zero exit. The `?? '(unknown)'` provides the same fallback.

**Surprise:** None. This is a textbook mechanical refactor — same logic, fewer copies.

**Over-building check:** No new parameters, no new exports, no new abstractions beyond what the spec requested. The `// @ana A005, A006` tag at proof.ts:158 is a source-code tag (not a test tag) — it documents which assertions the constant satisfies but doesn't constitute over-building.

## AC Walkthrough
| AC | Status | Evidence |
|----|--------|----------|
| AC1: Resolves counting computed once | ✅ PASS | work.ts:1824-1830 — single loop, result used at lines 1857 and 1882 |
| AC2: getCurrentBranch() ?? '(unknown)' | ✅ PASS | work.ts:1926 — exact pattern used |
| AC3: Empty audit matrix extracted to constant | ✅ PASS | proof.ts:145-156, used at lines 1585 and 1619 |
| AC4: Functions exported from git-operations.ts | ✅ PASS | git-operations.ts:220 and 250 — both exported |
| AC5: learn.ts imports from git-operations | ✅ PASS | learn.ts:17 — single import line from `'../utils/git-operations.js'` |
| AC6: All existing tests pass without modification | ✅ PASS | 2713 passed, 2 skipped — matches baseline exactly |
| AC7: isTimestampRecent unchanged | ✅ PASS | work.ts:368-381 — function intact with original logic |
| AC8: No build errors | ✅ PASS | `pnpm run build` succeeds, dist output produced |
| AC9: No new lint violations | ✅ PASS | 0 errors, 1 pre-existing warning |

## Blockers
None. All 15 contract assertions satisfied, all 9 ACs pass. Checked for: unused exports in new code (both moved functions are called by proof.ts and learn.ts), unused parameters (none — function signatures preserved exactly), error paths that swallow silently (the moved functions maintain their existing error handling patterns), dead code introduced by the refactor (no orphaned variables, no commented-out old code).

## Findings

- **Code — EMPTY_AUDIT_MATRIX is a shared mutable object:** `packages/cli/src/commands/proof.ts:145` — The constant is not frozen. Since it's only passed to `wrapJsonResponse` which calls `JSON.stringify` (read-only), mutation is impossible in the current code. But a future callee that destructures or mutates the argument would corrupt all subsequent uses. Spec explicitly notes this is safe and no freeze is needed — accepted.

- **Code — proof.ts re-imports moved functions:** `packages/cli/src/commands/proof.ts:29` — After moving `pullBeforeRead` and `commitAndPushProofChanges` to git-operations.ts, proof.ts imports them back. This is correct (proof.ts still calls them), but the import line is now 6 identifiers long. Cosmetic, not a problem.

- **Upstream — Resolves counting duplication resolved:** Proof context finding `upstream-finding-resolution-C1` (work.ts duplicates resolves counting logic) is directly addressed by this build's AC1 hoist.

- **Upstream — HEAD-reading duplication resolved:** Proof context finding `kind-aware-branch-prefixes-C6` (startWork resume path duplicates HEAD-reading pattern) is directly addressed by this build's AC2 refactor.

- **Code — Pre-existing lint warning:** `packages/cli/src/utils/git-operations.ts:198` — Unused eslint-disable directive for `no-control-regex`. Present for 10+ verify cycles. Not introduced or worsened by this build.

## Deployer Handoff
Pure refactor — no behavior changes, no new features, no config changes. The only runtime difference is import resolution paths (learn.ts now imports from utils/ instead of a sibling command). Test count matches baseline exactly. Safe to merge without staging or feature flags.

## Verdict
**Shippable:** YES

Clean mechanical refactor. Four extractions, all correct, no behavior changes, all tests pass, lint clean (modulo pre-existing warning). The code is simpler with fewer copies of the same logic.
