# Verify Report: Content Pages — Phase 2 (Seven Concept Pages)

**Result:** PASS
**Created by:** AnaVerify
**Date:** 2026-05-12
**Spec:** .ana/plans/active/content-pages/spec-2.md
**Branch:** feature/content-pages

## Pre-Check Results

```
=== CONTRACT COMPLIANCE ===
  Contract: .ana/plans/active/content-pages/contract.yaml
  Seal: INTACT (hash sha256:896416df802a4fce8b0542d20c16951270dd5e1d97df0ee616209bcfbeac1613)
```

Seal status: **INTACT**

Tests: 2178 passed, 0 failed, 2 skipped (100 test files). Build: success (21 pages generated). Lint: 2 errors (pre-existing — `DocsErrorBoundary.tsx` and `PlatformProvider.tsx`, both from the `docs-shell` PR, not introduced by this build).

## Contract Compliance

Phase 2 specific assertions from the contract. No `@ana` test tags exist — this is a website content build with no test files. All assertions verified by source inspection and build output.

| ID | Says | Status | Evidence |
|----|------|--------|----------|
| A010 | All 7 concept pages compile and render at their routes | ✅ SATISFIED | All 7 `.html` files in `.next/server/app/docs/concepts/`: pipeline, skills, context, toolbelt, artifacts, contract, findings. Build output shows `/docs/concepts/*` routes. |
| A011 | Each concept page includes MetaRow with reading time and last reviewed date | ✅ SATISFIED | All 7 MDX files have `readingTime` and `lastReviewed` in frontmatter. Confirmed in rendered HTML: "min read" and "Last reviewed" strings present in `pipeline.html`. |
| A012 | Each concept page has NextCards linking to the next page in sequence | ✅ SATISFIED | All 7 files contain `<NextCards>`. Sequential flow confirmed: pipeline→skills→context→toolbelt→artifacts→contract→findings. |
| A016 | Root meta.json establishes correct top-level sidebar order | ✅ SATISFIED | `website/content/docs/meta.json:3` — pages: `["start", "concepts", "guides"]` |
| A017 | Concepts meta.json orders pages correctly | ✅ SATISFIED | `website/content/docs/concepts/meta.json:3` — pages: `["pipeline", "skills", "context", "toolbelt", "artifacts", "contract", "findings"]`. Matches contract value exactly. |
| A018 | Guides meta.json orders pages correctly | ✅ SATISFIED | `website/content/docs/guides/meta.json:3` — pages: `["using-ana-setup", "verifying-changes", "reading-a-proof", "using-ana-learn", "configurability", "troubleshooting"]`. Matches contract value exactly. |
| A026 | No agents concept page exists at concepts/agents | ✅ SATISFIED | Filesystem check: `concepts/agents.mdx` does not exist. Only 7 expected files + `meta.json` present. |
| A027 | The Scope 1 test index.mdx file is deleted | ✅ SATISFIED | Filesystem check: `website/content/docs/index.mdx` does not exist. |
| A028 | Next.js build completes without errors for all 16 pages | ✅ SATISFIED | `pnpm build` exits 0. Build output: 21 total routes generated (includes non-docs pages). All docs routes present. |
| A029 | MDX pages produce heading structure that populates the right rail TOC | ✅ SATISFIED | All concept pages have 5-9 `## ` headings each. Rendered HTML confirmed: `<h2 id="five-stages">`, `<h2 id="why-independence-matters">` etc. in pipeline.html with auto-generated IDs for TOC. |
| A030 | Pipeline concept links to skills concept and verifying changes guide | ✅ SATISFIED | `pipeline.mdx:60` — `href: "/docs/concepts/skills"` and line 65 — `href: "/docs/guides/verifying-changes"` |
| A031 | Quickstart links to pipeline concept and reading a proof guide | ✅ SATISFIED | `start.mdx:105` — `href: "/docs/concepts/pipeline"` and line 111 — `href: "/docs/guides/reading-a-proof"` |

## Independent Findings

**Predictions resolved:**
1. PipelineDiagram not registered → **Not found.** Properly imported and registered in `[...slug]/page.tsx:13,21`.
2. Broken links to future pages → **Confirmed.** 6 NextCards hrefs and ~10 inline markdown links point to pages that don't exist yet. Expected for multi-phase work but documented below.
3. Dynamic values missing comments → **Not found.** Both instances properly marked with `{/* Dynamic: update on data change */}`.
4. MetaRow missing on some pages → **Not found.** All 7 pages have `readingTime` and `lastReviewed` in frontmatter.
5. Over-building beyond spec → **Not found.** Only the specified 7 MDX files + meta.json were created. No extra components, no extra pages.

**Surprise:** The skills page has a full table linking to 8 individual skill reference pages (`/docs/reference/skills/coding-standards`, etc.) that don't exist in any phase scope. These are editorial forward-references, not broken functionality — NextCards still works fine. But the links will 404 until reference pages are scoped.

**Production risk predictions:**
1. Forward-links will produce 404s in production → Confirmed, but expected given Phase 3 hasn't been built yet. All guide links become valid after Phase 3. Reference/proof links need separate scoping.
2. Dynamic values get stale → Addressed by spec decision to hardcode with comments. The `{/* Dynamic */}` pattern is grep-friendly enough for periodic updates.

## AC Walkthrough

- **AC3: All 7 concept pages render at `/docs/concepts/{slug}`** — ✅ PASS. All 7 HTML files confirmed in `.next/server/app/docs/concepts/`. All have MetaRow frontmatter (`readingTime`, `lastReviewed`). Content matches supermock structure (headings, sections, components).
- **AC10: Ghost agents concept page does NOT exist** — ✅ PASS. No `concepts/agents.mdx` file on disk. No `/docs/concepts/agents` route in build output.
- **AC13: TOC populates correctly from heading structure** — ✅ PASS. All concept pages have 5-9 h2 headings each. Rendered HTML has `<h2 id="...">` with auto-generated IDs from Fumadocs. Pipeline page confirmed: 6 h2 headings with slugified IDs.
- **AC14: NextCards link to correct next page** — ✅ PASS. Sequential flow verified: pipeline→skills, skills→context, context→toolbelt, toolbelt→artifacts, artifacts→contract, contract→findings. All hrefs prefixed with `/docs/`. Quickstart→pipeline link confirmed at `start.mdx:105`.
- **AC12: `pnpm build` succeeds** — ✅ PASS. Build exits 0. 21 pages generated. No TypeScript errors. No missing component imports.
- **No type errors or missing component imports** — ✅ PASS. TypeScript check passed during build (1675ms). All MDX components (`Callout`, `NextCards`, `PipelineDiagram`) registered in `mdxComponents` object.

## Blockers

None. All 12 contract assertions satisfied. All 6 acceptance criteria pass. No regressions — CLI tests remain at 2178 passed, 0 failed. Build compiles cleanly. Lint failures are pre-existing (not introduced by this build).

Checked for: unused component imports in concept pages (none — every `<Callout>`, `<NextCards>`, `<PipelineDiagram>` is used), missing frontmatter fields (all 7 pages have all 4 fields), concept pages outside of scope (only 7 specified files created), broken component references (all 3 components registered in mdxComponents).

## Findings

- **Code — Forward-links to non-existent pages:** 6 NextCards hrefs and ~10 inline markdown links reference pages that don't exist yet: `/docs/guides/*` (Phase 3), `/docs/reference/cli`, `/docs/reference/context`, `/docs/proof/security-hardening`, `/docs/reference/skills/*`. Guide links resolve after Phase 3. Reference and proof links need separate scoping. Not a blocker — expected in multi-phase editorial work — but these will 404 in production until addressed.

- **Code — Skills page links to 8 individual skill reference pages:** `website/content/docs/concepts/skills.mdx:51-58` — the "All 8 skills" table links each skill to `/docs/reference/skills/{name}`. These pages aren't scoped in any phase and will 404. The table is useful editorial content, but the links are promises the site can't keep yet.

- **Code — Context page double-links to /docs/reference/context:** `website/content/docs/concepts/context.mdx:41,45` — both `project-context.md` and `design-principles.md` sections link to the same `/docs/reference/context` page. The page doesn't exist. Minor — consistent with the forward-linking pattern.

- **Code — Dynamic value comment pattern is adequate but informal:** `website/content/docs/concepts/pipeline.mdx:28` and `skills.mdx:47,66` use `{/* Dynamic: update on data change */}`. The pattern is grep-friendly (`grep -r "Dynamic:"`) but there's no automation to flag stale values. The spec explicitly chose this approach over custom components — reasonable for editorial content.

- **Upstream — Pre-existing lint failures block clean lint runs:** `DocsErrorBoundary.tsx:53` (no-html-link-for-pages) and `PlatformProvider.tsx:42` (set-state-in-effect). Both from the `docs-shell` PR (#120), not introduced by this build. Won't block merging but accumulate as tech debt.

## Deployer Handoff

Phase 2 adds 7 concept pages to the docs site. All compile, all render, sidebar ordering is correct. The concept pages contain forward-links to guide pages (Phase 3) and reference pages (not yet scoped) — these will 404 until those pages are created. If deploying before Phase 3, the 404s are cosmetic, not functional. No code changes to the CLI — only website content. The skills.mdx page has a table of all 8 skills with links to reference pages that need separate scoping after all 3 phases complete.

## Verdict

**Shippable:** YES

All 12 relevant contract assertions satisfied by source inspection and build output. All 6 acceptance criteria pass. Build succeeds. Tests pass (2178/2178). No regressions. Lint failures are pre-existing. The forward-links to non-existent pages are the only rough edge, and those are expected in a multi-phase editorial build where guides (Phase 3) and reference pages (separate scope) haven't been built yet. The content is well-structured, follows the spec's patterns, and uses components correctly.
