# R012 Code Review — Step 5: Testing & Verification

**Verdict:** REVISE

## Findings

### P1 — Step 5 was checked off even though the Step 5 plan review is REVISE

`STATUS.md:70-74` marks every Step 5 verification checkbox complete, and `STATUS.md:145` records `Review R011 | plan Step 5: APPROVE`, but the checked-in review file added by this step says the opposite: `.reviews/R011-plan-step5.md:3` is `**Verdict:** REVISE`. The same review explicitly blocks proceeding until the prior review debt is closed and concrete verification/recording rules are added (`.reviews/R011-plan-step5.md:13-18`, `.reviews/R011-plan-step5.md:20-36`).

This leaves the task in an internally inconsistent state: the review counter points at R011, the Reviews table still does not list R011, the execution log claims approval, and Step 5 is effectively marked complete without an approved Step 5 plan. Please correct the status bookkeeping to match the actual R011 verdict, address the R011 findings (or add a superseding approval review after the fixes), and only then mark the Step 5 checks complete.

### P1 — The public `get_activity_details` schema gap called out by R010/R011 is still unfixed

R011 specifically required resolving the remaining R010 schema finding before final verification, but `activityReadOutputSchema()` still describes only gear fields and does not document `calories_burned` semantics: `internal/tools/get_activity_details.go:293-294`. This is part of the task’s completion criteria (“Calories fields are semantically disambiguated and documented”) and is exposed to MCP clients through the registered output schema, so passing tests/build/lint is not enough.

Please update the activity detail output schema description to mention that activity detail rows expose `calories_burned` as active/exercise calories when upstream provides it, then regenerate/check docs if the catalog output changes.

### P2 — Claimed Step 5 command results are not recorded in `STATUS.md`

`STATUS.md:70-74` says targeted tests, `make test`, `make build`, and `make lint` all passed, but the execution log at `STATUS.md:113-120` contains no entries for any Step 5 command, and the targeted command is still unnamed. This repeats the R010/R011 recording issue and makes the audit trail unverifiable from the task status.

Please record the exact command list and outcomes in `STATUS.md`, including at least `go test -count=1 ./internal/tools`, `make test`, `make build`, and `make lint` (and `make docs-tools` if the schema/docs fix requires catalog regeneration), or document any unrelated pre-existing failure before checking the final failure-handling box.

## Verification

Notes:

- The requested full baseline hash `91dc8cba618c5a02bd98ef1fb3f98f46f25840f0` is not present in this worktree; I used the existing baseline commit prefix `91dc8cb31e9ba5627d8973dc74c4b7313411b574` for the diff review.

Ran:

```sh
git diff 91dc8cb..HEAD --name-only
git diff 91dc8cb..HEAD
go test -count=1 ./internal/tools
make test
make build
make lint
```

Results: the Go test/build/lint commands passed locally. The review findings are about unresolved task/review blockers and missing public schema/status updates, not local command failures.
