# Code Review: TP-082 Step 1 — Audit write response shaping

## Verdict: approved

No blocking findings for the Step 1 audit. I verified the audit against the registered `RequirementWrite` tools and the response-shaping paths in `internal/tools`; the matrix in `STATUS.md` covers the current write catalog and correctly calls out the custom-item write divergence as the Step 3 fix candidate.

## Verification performed

- Ran `git diff 41ac592de18a8bc6caf07798d66128a59a976444..HEAD --name-only` and reviewed the full diff.
- Checked the registered `RequirementWrite` tools in `internal/tools/catalog.go` / constructors:
  - `add_or_update_event`
  - `link_activity_to_event`
  - `add_activity_message`
  - `update_wellness`
  - `update_sport_settings`
  - `apply_training_plan`
  - `create_workout`
  - `update_workout`
  - `create_custom_item`
  - `update_custom_item`
- Cross-checked `encodeShaped` call sites and shared row builders for events, wellness, workouts, and custom items.

## Notes

- The custom-item create/update audit is accurate: both paths currently hard-code `encodeShaped(..., true, ...)` via the full custom-item detail shape and should be addressed in Step 3.
- The wellness double-shaping risk is accurately documented. When `include_full` is true, the current wellness row can preserve raw nulls both in the shaped row and under `wellness.full`, so Step 2 tests should be explicit about the expected full-mode shape.
- Non-blocking traceability nit: `STATUS.md` lists the R002 plan review file as `inline`, but the diff adds `.reviews/R002-plan-step1.md`. Consider correcting that during the next status update.
- Non-blocking formatting nit: the final two execution-log rows appear at the end of `STATUS.md` outside the execution-log table. Consider moving them into the table during the next status update.

## Tests

Not run; this step only updates audit/status documentation.
