# Code Review R008 — Step 3: Add a no-op/demo test path

Verdict: **REVISE**

## Findings

1. **Mandatory zero-value `_meta` contract is still not pinned.**  
   `internal/analysis/meta_test.go:8-36` and `internal/tools/analyzer_common_test.go:14-28` only exercise populated demo metadata (`method`, non-empty `source_tools`, `n=7`, `missing_days=2`). The task contract explicitly requires the mandatory analyzer fields to be emitted even when empty/zero/false, and Step 1 recorded `source_tools: []` rather than `null`. With the current tests, regressions such as `source_tools` becoming `nil`/`null`, `n: 0` or `missing_days: 0` being omitted, or an empty method/source list not surviving JSON shaping would not be caught. Add a minimal/zero-value analyzer meta test that marshals or shapes through `response.Shape` and asserts all mandatory keys plus `source_tools` as an empty JSON array.

2. **STATUS.md misreports the Step 3 plan review verdict.**  
   `taskplane-tasks/TP-089-analyzer-skeleton-meta/.reviews/R007-plan-step3.md:3` says `Verdict: **REVISE**`, but `STATUS.md:100` and `STATUS.md:127` record R007 as `APPROVE`. This preserves an inaccurate audit trail and hides the unresolved plan feedback. Update the review table/execution log to match the actual R007 verdict and record the subsequent implementation/fix as a separate status entry if needed.

## Verification

- `go test ./internal/analysis ./internal/tools` passes.
