# R014 Plan Review — Step 6: Reconcile documentation conflicts

Decision: APPROVE

I read `PROMPT.md`, the updated `STATUS.md`, and re-checked the current tree for the three Step 6 conflicts. The revised plan addresses the R013 blockers and is now scoped correctly for TP-051.

## Why this is approved

- **Analyzer-family state is now current, not prompt-stale.** The plan says to record that PRD §7.2.C still contains `analyze_*` / `compute_*` / `get_fitness_projection` and `~39 tools`, while the registry/generated catalog have zero analyzers. It also correctly reflects the current `ROADMAP.md` state: there is now a `v0.6 — Analyzers` phase, so Step 6 must not claim the roadmap is missing analyzer work.
- **Existing follow-up is used.** The plan names TP-055 as the reconciliation follow-up instead of creating a duplicate “reconcile analyzer family” task/note.
- **Scope is surface-only.** The status explicitly limits Step 6 to recording findings and changelogging them, and says not to edit `docs/prd/PRD-icuvisor.md`, `ROADMAP.md`, or the README tool list here. That matches TP-051 Step 6; README replacement stays in Step 7 and full conflict resolution stays in TP-055.
- **`update_wellness` handling is accurate.** Current code already has the required summary clause and error literal: `internal/tools/update_wellness.go` mentions device-owned `sleepScore` / `_native` fields in the description and returns `field_not_writable: sleepScore (device-managed)`. `web/data/tools.json` also already includes the device-owned-field summary. The plan correctly says Step 6 should verify/record this rather than make unnecessary code or descriptor changes.
- **`get_planning_parameters` is framed correctly.** The plan will record the ROADMAP contradiction plus registry truth without editing ROADMAP in this TP-051 step.

## Implementation notes

- When verifying “zero analyzers,” avoid a broad `grep internal/tools` as the only evidence because `catalog_test.go` intentionally contains analyzer names as exclusions. Prefer checking `tools.Catalog()` / `web/data/tools.json` and the shared registry enumeration path, then mention tests only as exclusion coverage if useful.
- In `STATUS.md`, include concrete file/line pointers for each finding so TP-055 can pick them up without re-discovering context.
- Keep the `CHANGELOG.md` entry concise: one `[Unreleased]` / `Changed` bullet for generated catalog/docs-source-of-truth work and one note that the known doc divergences were surfaced and delegated to TP-055 is sufficient.
