# Code Review — TP-084 Step 5

**Verdict:** REQUEST CHANGES

I reviewed the diff from `88c4194..HEAD`, the current task status, the Step 5 plan review, and the affected regression tests. The verification commands do pass, but Step 5 cannot be accepted because the task is being marked verified over unresolved blocking review findings and the status audit trail records false verdicts.

## Findings

1. **Blocking — Step 5 proceeds despite the Step 5 plan review requesting changes.**  
   `R009-plan-step5.md` has `**Verdict:** REQUEST CHANGES`, but `STATUS.md:129` records `Review R009 | plan Step 5: APPROVE`, and `STATUS.md:64-68` checks all Step 5 verification items as complete. This bypasses the plan-review gate. Please record R009 accurately, leave Step 5 incomplete, and address or formally disposition the R009 blockers before claiming final verification.

2. **Blocking — the verification claim is made over still-missing regression coverage.**  
   The same mission-critical coverage gaps called out in R004/R006/R008/R009 are still present. `internal/tools/get_event_by_id_test.go:127-143` loads the listed-event fixture only to extract the ID, then configures the fake list response with `events: nil`, so it does not test the prompt’s listed-event/detail-404 mismatch against recovery behavior. `internal/tools/get_activities_strava_test.go:69-86` only tests the sync-chain fixture through `isStravaBlocked`, while `internal/tools/get_activity_details_test.go:105-127` covers detail output; there is still no `get_activities` handler-output assertion for the numeric/no-`i` Wahoo/MyWhoosh/TrainerRoad rows. Passing tests over this incomplete pack does not satisfy the task completion criterion that all three upstream signals have stable regression tests.

3. **Blocking — `STATUS.md` still has an unreliable review/audit trail.**  
   The Reviews table is empty (`STATUS.md:82-85`), while review rows are appended under Notes (`STATUS.md:121-129`). Those rows record multiple review files as `APPROVE` even though the review files say `REQUEST CHANGES` (including R008 and R009). The task also lists `## Blockers` as `*None*` (`STATUS.md:108-110`) despite the outstanding review blockers. Please move the entries into the Reviews/Execution Log sections and record the actual verdicts before closing verification.

## Tests run

- `go test -count=1 ./internal/tools ./internal/intervals` — passed
- `make test` — passed
- `make build` — passed
- `make lint` — passed

These passing commands are good, but they do not clear the review because the submitted Step 5 diff does not resolve the open regression-coverage and status-audit blockers.
