# Review: Step 1 code/status update

Verdict: **approved**.

I re-ran the requested baseline diff and verified the Step 1 evidence against the current tree. The only changed file is `taskplane-tasks/TP-055-reconcile-doc-conflicts/STATUS.md`, and the added findings accurately reflect the current repository state:

- PRD analyzer wording is already planned/deferred under `docs/prd/PRD-icuvisor.md:286-330`, with no stale `~39 tools` wording found.
- Analyzer tools and `get_planning_parameters` are absent from the registered/catalog surfaces checked (`internal/tools/catalog.go`, `internal/tools/registry.go`, `internal/toolcatalog`, and `web/data/tools.json`); `web/data/tools.json` currently has 40 tools and no analyzer matches.
- `ROADMAP.md:22` is the only remaining `get_planning_parameters` mention and is a deferred statement consistent with the unregistered catalog.
- README is now slim and delegates users to the website catalog at `README.md:21`, so the old per-tool README conflict shape no longer applies.
- The `update_wellness` error literal is correctly captured from code: `field_not_writable: sleepScore (device-managed)` at `internal/tools/update_wellness.go:204`, with the same contract surfaced in the PRD and generated website catalog data.

No blocking issues found for Step 1. Minor follow-up for the next step boundary: once the review is incorporated, mark Step 1 complete in `STATUS.md` before moving on, and keep the noted Step 5 cleanup for the stale CHANGELOG wording that still says the `update_wellness` contract was surfaced in README.
