# Review R021 — Code review for Step 5

Verdict: **REVISE**

Reviewed changes from `aa4c3e4..HEAD`:

- `internal/tools/catalog_test.go`
- `internal/tools/compute_baseline.go`
- `taskplane-tasks/TP-100-analyzer-benchmark-harness/.reviews/R020-plan-step5.md`
- `taskplane-tasks/TP-100-analyzer-benchmark-harness/STATUS.md`

Verification run during review:

```bash
python3 -m unittest discover -s scripts/benchmark -p '*_test.py'
python3 scripts/benchmark/kr5_benchmark.py --mode fixtures --prompt-set scripts/benchmark/prompts/kr5_shared_prompts.json --fixture-dir scripts/benchmark/testdata/fixtures --output /tmp/kr5-results-check.json --generated-at 2026-05-20T00:00:00Z
cmp -s /tmp/kr5-results-check.json scripts/benchmark/results/kr5-results.json
make test
make build
make lint
```

All commands passed locally.

## Blocking findings

1. **`STATUS.md` records the R020 verdict incorrectly in the execution-history rows.**

   The Reviews table and `.reviews/R020-plan-step5.md` both say R020 was `ACCEPT`, but the appended history row says:

   ```md
   | 2026-05-20 23:27 | Review R020 | plan Step 5: REVISE |
   ```

   This repeats the kind of bookkeeping inconsistency that Step 5 was supposed to clean up after R019. Update that row to `ACCEPT`.

2. **Step 5 checkboxes are marked complete, but `STATUS.md` does not record the actual gate outcomes in the execution log.**

   R019 explicitly asked for exact commands and outcomes to be captured after execution. The Step 5 checkboxes are checked, but the execution log section still has no entries for the Python unittest, fixture freshness check, `make test`, `make build`, or `make lint`; the existing command rows are appended after the Notes section rather than inside the execution-log table. Add concise execution-log entries for the commands run and their pass outcomes, or otherwise move the existing history rows into the intended section before marking this verification step complete.

## Notes

The Go changes look correct: prefixing the baseline-local helper functions avoids package-level name collisions with analyzer helpers, and the analyzer catalog test now checks the actual non-stub summaries currently emitted by the catalog. The project gates pass after these changes.
