# Review R008 — Plan Review for Step 5

**Verdict:** REVISE

The Step 5 checklist has the right broad gates, but the plan is still too vague for final verification and does not resolve the overlap with Step 4. Step 4 already recorded `go run scripts/audit_zone_time_coverage.go`, `make test`, `make build`, and `make lint` as passing; Step 5 should either explicitly rerun them as the final gate or state that those exact Step 4 results are being carried forward only if no files changed afterward.

## Required plan changes

- Make the targeted verification command explicit. For this task, the most relevant targeted check is:
  - `go run scripts/audit_zone_time_coverage.go`
  - Compare the summary to `STATUS.md` and `docs/upstream-gaps/zone-time-coverage.md` (`fixture_count 6`, `skipped 36`, and each family `0` precomputed / `0` fallback / `6` unknown).
- Keep the full gates as named commands:
  - `make test`
  - `make build`
  - `make lint`
- Clarify whether Step 5 will rerun those commands or reuse the Step 4 pass results. Reuse is acceptable only if `git status`/the execution log shows no task-relevant file changes since Step 4 verification; otherwise rerun them.
- Record the command outcomes in `STATUS.md`, including any failure handling. Task-caused failures should be fixed; only clearly unrelated/pre-existing failures should be documented with enough output to be actionable.

No new analyzer behavior changes are needed for this step.
