# Code Review — TP-076 Step 4

Verdict: **revise**

## Blocking findings

1. **The committed Step 4 evidence is not auditable enough to approve the live re-validation.**
   `taskplane-tasks/TP-076-update-wellness-subjective-write/STATUS.md:59-62` only checks off the Step 4 items, and `STATUS.md:33` only says the already-contaminated locked row was reused. R010 explicitly required the execution to "record in `STATUS.md` exactly what was verified and what remains blocked," and Step 4's acceptance depends on live behavior that I cannot safely infer from checkboxes alone. Please add sanitized evidence for:
   - the stdio MCP `feel` rejection probe, including the public error text and the post-read/no-mutation confirmation;
   - the accepted subjective write path that was exercised, including whether it used the existing locked row or a fresh non-lock row;
   - the re-read confirmation showing the expected writable fields landed;
   - the restore confirmation showing all Step 4 overwrite-able fields were returned to the pre-Step-4 snapshot, with the only remaining blocker being the pre-existing Step 1 locked row.

## Validation

I independently ran the automated validation commands and they passed:

```sh
make build
make test
make test-race
make lint
```

I did not independently re-run the live MCP mutation/re-read flow; this review is based on the committed sanitized evidence for that portion, which currently needs more detail.
