# Code Review — TP-084 Step 4

**Verdict:** REQUEST CHANGES

I reviewed the diff from `239520c..HEAD`, the changed test/status files, and the prior review files. The direct Go change in this step only removes redundant loop-variable shadowing and is safe with the repository's `go 1.25.10` module setting, but Step 4 still cannot be accepted because it documents completion over unresolved blocking review findings.

## Findings

1. **Blocking — Step 4 proceeds despite its plan review requesting changes.**  
   `R007-plan-step4.md` says `**Verdict:** REQUEST CHANGES` and explicitly says Step 4 must not proceed until Step 2/3 blockers and the audit trail are resolved, but `STATUS.md:51-56` marks all Step 4 checklist items complete and `STATUS.md:126` records `R007` as `APPROVE`. This makes the task state internally contradictory and bypasses the required plan-review gate. Please record R007 accurately and either move the task back to the unresolved step or resolve the blockers before marking Step 4 work done.

2. **Blocking — the previously identified regression coverage gaps are still present.**  
   The current diff does not add the missing coverage required by R004/R006/R007. In `internal/tools/get_event_by_id_test.go:127-143`, the fixture-backed test reads the listed event only to get its ID, but configures the fake list response as `events: nil`; it still tests a list-scan miss, not the prompt's listed-event/detail-404 mismatch. Separately, `internal/tools/get_activities_strava_test.go:69-86` only asserts the sync-chain fixture through the `isStravaBlocked` helper, while `internal/tools/get_activity_details_test.go:105-127` covers the detail tool; there is still no `get_activities` handler-output assertion for the numeric/no-`i` Wahoo/MyWhoosh/TrainerRoad rows. Full-suite verification over this incomplete pack does not satisfy the task mission.

3. **Blocking — `STATUS.md` audit trail is still malformed and records false verdicts.**  
   The Reviews table is empty (`STATUS.md:82-85`), while review rows are appended under `## Notes` (`STATUS.md:120-126`). Those rows record R003, R004, R005, R006, and R007 as `APPROVE`, but their review files say `REQUEST CHANGES` (for example `R006-code-step3.md:3` and `R007-plan-step4.md:3`). This was already called out by prior reviews and must be fixed before Step 4 documentation can be considered reliable.

4. **Blocking — Step 4 verification is checked off without recording the actual verification results.**  
   `STATUS.md:54` checks “Run full suite/build/lint,” but the execution log stops at Step 0 (`STATUS.md:98-104`) and the notes only state the docs decision (`STATUS.md:119`). The prompt completion criteria require `make test`, `make build`, and `make lint`; record the exact commands and outcomes in `STATUS.md` after the unresolved regression/audit blockers are addressed.

## Tests run

- `make test` — passed
- `make build` — passed
- `make lint` — passed

These commands pass on the current tree, but they do not clear the review because the submitted Step 4 diff does not resolve the open regression-coverage and status-audit blockers.
