# Review R002 — Plan Review for Step 1

**Verdict:** Approved

The revised Step 1 plan in `STATUS.md` now expands beyond the original three task checkboxes and captures the research/decision outputs needed before packaging work begins. In particular, it addresses the prior R001 gaps by explicitly requiring notes on bundle layout and exclusions, platform/artifact shape, signed-binary assumptions, manifest fields and binary server config, compatibility/privacy policy fields, catalog-summary strategy, `user_config` to environment mapping, validation tooling, and `.mcpb` versus legacy `.dxt` wording.

## Conditions for completing Step 1

Before moving to Step 2, ensure the Step 1 section or Discoveries/Notes in `STATUS.md` contains the actual decisions, not only checked boxes. The recorded output should be concrete enough that implementation can proceed without re-researching:

- Selected MCPB manifest/schema version and the required fields relevant to icuvisor.
- Bundle archive layout, explicit excluded files, supported platform slice, and signed-binary packaging assumption.
- Manifest server config sketch for a bundled binary, including command/entry-point pathing and any platform override strategy.
- User configuration table with sensitivity, required/default behavior, and target environment variables, including the no-plaintext-secret rationale.
- Privacy policy/external-service handling decision for intervals.icu data.
- Tool/prompt/resource catalog strategy that avoids stale hard-coded lists when runtime gating changes the available tools.
- Artifact naming convention using `.mcpb`, with any legacy `.dxt` mention limited to compatibility/explanation docs.
- Planned validation/packaging commands and any tooling availability caveats.

## Notes

- This approval is for the Step 1 plan only; it does not approve any eventual manifest or release-pipeline implementation.
- Keep the repository secret-handling rule front and center: the bundle must not include API keys, generated local config, `.env` files, or other plaintext credentials.
