# Review: Step 3 plan

Verdict: **approved**.

The Step 3 plan is appropriate for the current tree. Step 1 already established the code truth: `get_planning_parameters` is not registered in `internal/tools/catalog.go` / `registry.go`, is absent from `internal/toolcatalog` and `web/data/tools.json`, and the ROADMAP now has only the deferred statement at `ROADMAP.md:22`. The README is intentionally slim and points users to the generated website catalog, so the correct README state for an unregistered tool is no mention.

What is strong:

- The plan starts from registry/catalog truth rather than the stale prompt line numbers.
- It treats the remaining ROADMAP deferred line as the expected single source of truth, not as something to delete.
- It includes README/reference verification, which is important because the old hand-maintained README catalog has been replaced by a website/catalog pointer.

Execution notes, not blockers:

- In the Step 3 `Resolution:` section, explicitly record that this is a no-op content step because the contradiction is already resolved in the current tree.
- Include the key grep evidence: one `ROADMAP.md` deferral, no `README.md` mention, and no code/generated-catalog entry.
- When doing final Step 5 verification, adjust the prompt's stale “exactly one consistent statement remains in each” wording to the actual desired state for an unregistered tool: exactly one ROADMAP deferral and zero README/generated-catalog entries.

No plan changes are required before executing Step 3.
