# Review R005 — Code review for Step 3: icuvisor measurement

Verdict: Request changes

## Findings

1. **Step 3 is marked complete, but the measurement artifacts are not in the reviewed diff.** `git diff fd807b9..HEAD --name-only` only shows `taskplane-tasks/TP-034-kr5-benchmark-harness/STATUS.md`, while `STATUS.md:32-33` checks off measurement capture and `STATUS.md:109` references `scripts/benchmark/results/kr5-results.json`. In a clean checkout of `HEAD`, that result file and the harness/fixtures are absent, so the claimed measurements cannot be reviewed or reproduced. Add the redacted harness/results files to git, or leave Step 3 unchecked.

2. **The referenced icuvisor fixture is not an exact `tools/list` catalog measurement.** In the untracked fixture, `get_athlete_profile` has a generic rewritten description, but the actual tool description in `internal/tools/get_athlete_profile.go:20` is different. KR5’s token metric is defined as the token count of registered tool descriptions + schemas as returned by `tools/list`; replacing non-secret catalog text with synthetic filler makes the 2,393/5,340 token counts meaningless. Re-run/record the exact icuvisor `tools/list` payload for core and full tiers, with only athlete data redacted from call responses.

## Notes

I was able to reproduce the untracked `kr5-results.json` from the untracked fixtures, but that only proves fixture determinism; it does not validate that the fixtures came from the real icuvisor catalog.
