# Review R012 — Code Review for Step 5

**Verdict:** REVISE

## Findings

### 1. Step 5 verification results are checked off but not recorded in `STATUS.md`

`STATUS.md` marks all Step 5 gates as passing (`targeted tests`, `make test`, `make build`, `make lint`) at lines 65-72, but the Execution Log still stops at Step 0 and contains no command names, timestamps, or outcomes for the Step 5 verification run (lines 111-117). The approved Step 5 plan explicitly required making the targeted test command explicit and updating `STATUS.md` with each command/outcome (`.reviews/R011-plan-step5.md` lines 13-20).

Please add Step 5 execution log entries for the commands that were run, including outcomes, or explicitly document that the Step 4 verification is being carried forward because no implementation/docs changed after R010. Without this, the Step 5 status change is not auditable from the task artifact.

## Tests run during review

- `go test ./internal/analysis ./internal/resources ./internal/tools ./internal/toolchecks` — pass
- `make test` — pass
- `make build` — pass
- `make lint` — pass
