# Code Review — Step 1: Audit write/delete guidance

**Verdict: revise.**

## Findings

1. **Step 1 test/safety decision evidence is not recorded.** `STATUS.md` checks off both the `go test ./internal/tools` run and the `internal/safety/adversarial_test.go` gating decision, but the Execution Log has no Step 1 audit/test entries, and the Discoveries do not state whether `go test ./internal/safety` was run or deferred, nor why. This was an explicit execution note in R002. Please add a concise log/discovery entry with the exact command outcome for `go test ./internal/tools` and the safety-test decision/rationale.
   - `STATUS.md:27-31`, `STATUS.md:83-95`
   - `R002-plan-step1.md:9`

2. **Step state is internally inconsistent.** All Step 1 boxes are checked, but Step 1 still says `In Progress` and the top-level current step remains Step 1. If Step 1 is ready for approval, mark the step complete/update current status; otherwise leave the unfinished checkbox(es) unchecked.
   - `STATUS.md:1-5`, `STATUS.md:24-31`

## Verification run by reviewer

- `go test ./internal/tools` — pass (cached)
- `go test ./internal/safety` — pass (cached)
