# Code Review — TP-077 Step 4

Verdict: **revise**

## Blocking findings

1. **Step 4 was executed without an approved Step 4 plan.**
   `taskplane-tasks/TP-077-create-workout-refused/.reviews/R012-plan-step4.md:3` says `Verdict: **revise**`, but `taskplane-tasks/TP-077-create-workout-refused/STATUS.md:83` records the same review as `plan Step 4: APPROVE`. That makes the task audit trail false and means the Step 4 execution is based on a rejected plan. Correct the status history and either address R012's required amendments with a new approved plan review or add the missing approval artifact before marking Step 4 evidence complete.

2. **The committed live-validation evidence does not show the required two-read verification.**
   `STATUS.md:57` claims the stdio MCP smoke created/deleted a workout, but the evidence only names `get_workouts_in_folder` for the positive read and a generic singular cleanup re-read. The Step 4 acceptance criteria and R012 amendments require both `get_workout_library` and `get_workouts_in_folder` to show the workout after create and both to show it gone after delete. Update `STATUS.md` with sanitized evidence for each of those four read checks, without raw athlete/folder/workout IDs.

## Validation

I independently ran the automated validation commands and they passed:

```sh
make build
make test
make test-race
make lint
```

I did not independently re-run the live MCP write/delete smoke; this review is based on the committed sanitized evidence for that portion.
