# Code Review — TP-084 Step 3

**Verdict:** REQUEST CHANGES

I reviewed `PROMPT.md`, `STATUS.md`, the current diff from `407e563..HEAD`, and the prior reviews. The only changed files in this step are `STATUS.md` and the Step 3 plan review file; no source or regression-test files were changed.

## Findings

1. **Blocking — Step 3 marks work complete while the immediately preceding plan review requested changes.**  
   `R005-plan-step3.md` has `**Verdict:** REQUEST CHANGES`, but `STATUS.md:121` records it as `plan Step 3: APPROVE`, and `STATUS.md:45-47` checks all Step 3 items as complete. This makes the task state internally contradictory and bypasses the requested Step 3 planning corrections. Please update `STATUS.md` to record R005 accurately, leave Step 3 incomplete until the plan blockers are addressed, and do not claim “no production-code fixes were required” until the missing coverage decisions from R004/R005 are resolved.

2. **Blocking — Step 3 did not address the unresolved Step 2 blockers before declaring no fixes needed.**  
   The diff contains no changes under `internal/tools`, `internal/intervals`, or fixtures, so the R004 blockers remain unresolved: the `get_event_by_id` listed/detail-404 mismatch is still not locked against recovery semantics, and the numeric/no-`i` Strava sync-chain fixture is still not asserted through `get_activities` handler output. `STATUS.md:116` says `go test ./internal/tools ./internal/intervals` passed and therefore no fixes were required, but passing the current incomplete pack does not satisfy Step 3’s “fix regressions exposed by the pack” requirement after R004 identified missing/incorrect coverage. Complete or explicitly account for those review findings first, then rerun the targeted tests.

3. **Blocking — STATUS audit trail is still malformed and records incorrect verdicts.**  
   `STATUS.md:82-85` has an empty Reviews table, while review entries are appended under `## Notes` at `STATUS.md:117-121`. Those rows also record `R003`, `R004`, and `R005` as `APPROVE`, but their review files say `REQUEST CHANGES`. This was already called out in R004/R005 and is still present in the Step 3 diff. Move these entries into the intended Reviews/Execution Log sections and record the real verdicts so the task history is reliable.

## Tests run

- `go test -count=1 ./internal/tools ./internal/intervals`

The command passes, but it does not clear the review because the submitted diff does not resolve the missing coverage/semantic blockers identified by prior reviews.
