# Plan Review — Step 1: Confirm the version

## Decision
Needs revision before execution.

## Findings

1. **Missing required `git log`/baseline analysis.** The task prompt says to confirm the version with `git log` and `ROADMAP`, but the Step 1 plan only records `git tag --list`, `ROADMAP.md`, and human sign-off. Add an explicit check of commits since the latest tag (currently `v0.1.4`) and record what shipped post-tag vs what remains unreleased.

2. **Do not assume an empty/prerelease tag state.** `git tag --list` currently returns released tags `v0.0.1` through `v0.1.4`. The plan should record this actual state and use `v0.1.4` as the comparison baseline. This also matters because `CHANGELOG.md` currently has a stale `[Unreleased]` compare link pointing at `v0.1.3...HEAD`.

3. **Version rationale needs to address ROADMAP mismatch.** `ROADMAP.md` currently has `v0.2.0`, `v1.0`, `v1.x`, and `v2.x` sections; it does not show a `v0.4.0` phase, and some `v0.2.0` items are still unchecked. Before asking for sign-off, the plan should require documenting why `v0.4.0` is still the correct release instead of `v0.2.0`, `v0.2.0-beta.1`, or another semver-compatible tag.

4. **Human sign-off should be gated on concrete evidence.** The plan says to obtain sign-off, but should specify that `STATUS.md` must include: current latest tag, current branch/commit intended for release, ROADMAP-derived rationale, and the selected version candidate. This prevents asking the human to approve an under-specified immutable tag.

## Suggested Step 1 plan adjustment

- Run and record `git tag --sort=-version:refname | head`, `git describe --tags --abbrev=0`, `git status --branch --short`, and `git log --oneline <latest-tag>..HEAD`.
- Read `ROADMAP.md` and compare completed/unchecked items against the unreleased changelog entries.
- Record the candidate version plus alternatives considered in `STATUS.md`.
- Ask for explicit human approval of the exact tag only after the above evidence is recorded.
