# Review R005 — Code review for Step 2

**Verdict:** REVISE

## Findings

1. **Full prompt protocol tests are now failing.** Adding `PlanHealthReviewPrompt()` to `NewRegistry()` changes the MCP `prompts/list` catalog to seven entries, but `internal/mcp/protocol_test.go:218-221` still expects six and omits `plan_health_review`. `go test ./internal/mcp` fails in `TestProtocolSharedTransportSuite/prompts_list_and_get` for both transports with `prompts/list length = 7, want 6`. Please update the protocol test expected count/order to include the new prompt so the broader suite stays green.

2. **Task status metadata is inconsistent.** `taskplane-tasks/TP-128-plan-health-review-prompt/.reviews/R004-plan-step2.md:3` says `REVISE`, but `STATUS.md:119` records `Review R004 | plan Step 2: APPROVE`. Please correct the status log/review table so execution history matches the actual review artifact.

## Verification

- `go test ./internal/prompts` passes.
- `go test ./internal/mcp` fails as described above.
