# OVERALL-STYLE GOLD SELECTION

- Output: `tasks/0601_monday/gold_grading_sheet.html`
- Rubric SHA: `11e7900`
- Items: 20
- Kind distribution: docx 5, pdf 6, pptx 4, xlsx 5
- Machine disagreement picked: 6
- Render status: rendered 1, fallback 19
- Machine scores available: v1-mini 20/20, v2-mini 6/20, v2-standard 6/20

## Selection Rationale

Selected from the critical `Overall formatting and style` population identified in `rubric_criterion_profile.md`. The sample covers xlsx/pdf/docx/pptx, prioritizes v1-v2 disagreements, includes mandatory regression cases `83d10b06`, `7b08cd4d`, and `27e8912c`, and includes the local DOCX render smoke item `0419f1c3`.

## Selected Items

| # | task | kind | reason | deliverable | v1 | v2-mini | v2-standard | render |
|---:|---|---|---|---|---:|---:|---:|---|
| 1 | `83d10b06` | xlsx | mandatory formatting diagnosis regression case; v1/v2 machine-score disagreement; rubric-heavy / known monster-adjacent case | `deliverable_files/83d10b06-26d1-4636-a32c-23f92c57f30b/Sample.xlsx` | 5 | 1.5 | 0 | fallback |
| 2 | `7b08cd4d` | xlsx | mandatory formatting diagnosis regression case; v1/v2 machine-score disagreement | `deliverable_files/7b08cd4d-df60-41ae-9102-8aaa49306ba2/2024_Fall_Music_Tour_PnL_As_of_2024-12-31.xlsx` | 5 | 3 | 3 | fallback |
| 3 | `7d7fc9a7` | pdf | v1/v2 machine-score disagreement | `deliverable_files/7d7fc9a7-21a7-4b83-906f-416dea5ad04f/Aurisic_Prepaid_Insurance.pdf` | 3.5 | 0 | 1.5 | fallback |
| 4 | `43dc9778` | pdf | v1/v2 machine-score disagreement | `deliverable_files/43dc9778-450b-4b46-b77e-b6d82b202035/LISA W2 COMPRESS MIDDLE SCHOOL edit.pdf` | 3.5 | 3 | 2 | fallback |
| 5 | `ee09d943` | xlsx | v1/v2 machine-score disagreement | `deliverable_files/ee09d943-5a11-430a-b7a2-971b4e9b01b5/Prof_Fee_Dump-1.xlsx` | 3.75 | 5 | 5 | fallback |
| 6 | `27e8912c` | pdf | mandatory formatting diagnosis regression case; v1/v2 machine-score disagreement | `deliverable_files/27e8912c-8bd5-44ba-ad87-64066ea05264/Workstation_Ergonomics_Checklist.pdf` | 5 | 3.5 | 4 | fallback |
| 7 | `99ac6944` | xlsx | xlsx stratified overall-style sample | `deliverable_files/99ac6944-4ec6-4848-959c-a460ac705c6f/IEM_Budget_Breakdown.xlsx` | 5 | no grade | no grade | fallback |
| 8 | `7bbfcfe9` | xlsx | xlsx stratified overall-style sample | `deliverable_files/7bbfcfe9-132d-4194-82bb-d6f29d001b01/SCRA_Compliance_Test_Questions.xlsx` | 5 | no grade | no grade | fallback |
| 9 | `f9a1c16c` | pdf | pdf stratified overall-style sample | `deliverable_files/f9a1c16c-53fd-4c8f-88cc-5c325ec2f0bb/Tour_Stage_Plot.pdf` | 2 | no grade | no grade | fallback |
| 10 | `bbe0a93b` | pdf | pdf stratified overall-style sample | `deliverable_files/bbe0a93b-ebf0-40b0-98dc-8d9243099034/Kent_County_Needs_Assessment_Espanol.pdf` | 5 | no grade | no grade | fallback |
| 11 | `85d95ce5` | pdf | pdf stratified overall-style sample | `deliverable_files/85d95ce5-b20c-41e2-834e-e788ce9622b6/J.S..pdf` | 5 | no grade | no grade | fallback |
| 12 | `1b1ade2d` | docx | docx stratified overall-style sample | `deliverable_files/1b1ade2d-f9f6-4a04-baa5-aa15012b53be/Revised_Sourcing_and_Nomination_Workflow_Lamp_Assemblies.docx` | 5 | no grade | no grade | fallback |
| 13 | `93b336f3` | docx | docx stratified overall-style sample | `deliverable_files/93b336f3-61f3-4287-86d2-87445e1e0f90/EV_Battery_Assembly_Localisation_Partnership_Proposal.docx` | 5 | no grade | no grade | fallback |
| 14 | `575f8679` | docx | docx stratified overall-style sample | `deliverable_files/575f8679-b4c1-47a2-8e96-d570d4ed9269/Immigration_and_Family_Stress_Evaluation_Plan.docx` | 3.5 | no grade | no grade | fallback |
| 15 | `0419f1c3` | docx | local candidate file available for render smoke | `deliverable_files/0419f1c3-d669-45d0-81cd-f4d5923b06a5/Performance Improvement Plan – John Miller (07-13-2025).docx` | 5 | no grade | no grade | rendered |
| 16 | `6dcae3f5` | docx | docx stratified overall-style sample | `deliverable_files/6dcae3f5-bf1c-48e0-8b4b-23e6486a934c/Email_to_PD_Key_Indicator_Analysis.docx` | 2 | no grade | no grade | fallback |
| 17 | `a74ead3b` | pptx | pptx stratification | `deliverable_files/a74ead3b-f67d-4b1c-9116-f6bb81b29d4f/Session_14_Nurturing_Parenting_Recovery.pptx` | 5 | no grade | no grade | fallback |
| 18 | `ec591973` | pptx | pptx stratification | `deliverable_files/ec591973-04d5-48c0-981c-1ab2fcec2dc1/Differentiated_Distribution_Strategy_Slide.pptx` | 5 | no grade | no grade | fallback |
| 19 | `9a0d8d36` | pptx | pptx stratification | `deliverable_files/9a0d8d36-6233-4c76-9107-0d1f783c7340/ISO_vs_NQSO_Tax_Comparison.pptx` | 5 | no grade | no grade | fallback |
| 20 | `403b9234` | pptx | pptx stratification | `deliverable_files/403b9234-6299-4b5f-a106-70c1bc11ec4c/Chamber_of_Commerce_Partnership_Proposal.pptx` | 5 | no grade | no grade | fallback |

## Render Note

LibreOffice/soffice was not available on PATH. One local DOCX candidate (`0419f1c3`) was rendered with macOS QuickLook and embedded directly into the HTML as base64. Most exp003 candidate deliverables are not present in this checkout and the private HF results repo was not accessible without credentials, so those cards intentionally show file-path fallback and machine evidence rather than being dropped.
