채점 가이드

This criterion asks whether the deliverable's overall formatting and style are professional and readable. Grade the visible form, not whether the substantive content is correct.

Use the seven dimensions as a decomposition rule: render integrity, layout consistency, readability, visual hierarchy, table legibility, professional finish, and whether a blocking defect is present. Blocking defects include broken layout, unreadable text, blank/default dumps, missing requested deliverable form, or a render/view that prevents judging the style.

If most dimensions are sound and no blocking defect is present, score toward pass. If a blocking defect is present, score toward fail. Mixed quality should receive partial credit. Machine scores are shown only as context; owner_score and owner_reason are the gold source.

Selection note

Selected from the 140 critical `Overall formatting and style` items identified in `rubric_criterion_profile.md`. The sample is stratified across xlsx/pdf/docx/pptx, prioritizes v1-v2 machine-score disagreements, includes the three formatting-diagnosis regression cases (`83d10b06`, `7b08cd4d`, `27e8912c`), and includes one local render smoke case.

LibreOffice/soffice was unavailable in this environment. One locally present DOCX was rendered with macOS QuickLook and embedded inline; the remaining cards fall back to recorded file paths plus machine evidence because the candidate files were not present locally and the private HF result repo was inaccessible without credentials.

#1 `83d10b06` xlsx machine scores disagree
mandatory formatting diagnosis regression case; v1/v2 machine-score disagreement; rubric-heavy / known monster-adjacent case
sector: Professional, Scientific, and Technical Services
occupation: Accountants and Auditors
v1 judge calls: 36

### Render unavailable

Candidate deliverable file is not present in this checkout. Private HF result repo access/token was unavailable, so render falls back to path + machine evidence.

Primary path: `deliverable_files/83d10b06-26d1-4636-a32c-23f92c57f30b/Sample.xlsx`

Recorded deliverable files:

- `deliverable_files/83d10b06-26d1-4636-a32c-23f92c57f30b/Sample.xlsx`
- `deliverable_files/83d10b06-26d1-4636-a32c-23f92c57f30b/Population v2.xlsx`

task_id
`83d10b06-26d1-4636-a32c-23f92c57f30b`
deliverable
`deliverable_files/83d10b06-26d1-4636-a32c-23f92c57f30b/Sample.xlsx`
kind
xlsx
max_score
5

## Rubric Criterion

Overall formatting and style of the deliverable

## Machine Scores (read-only)

### v1-minipass

5 / 5
rubric item: `a64588ed-db04-4b8b-b3b8-3674ddcf10d1`

    [Sheet: Selected Sample]
    No,Division,Sub-Division,Country,Legal Entity,KRIs,Q3 2024 KRI,Q2 2024 KRI,QoQ Variance %,Sample Selected

### v2-minipartial

1.5 / 5
rubric item: `a64588ed-db04-4b8b-b3b8-3674ddcf10d1`

    "merged_ranges": [], "column_widths": {}, "has_charts": false

### v2-standardfail

0 / 5
rubric item: `a64588ed-db04-4b8b-b3b8-3674ddcf10d1`

    "fill": "00000000", "bold": false, "font_color": "Values must be of type <class 'str'>", "border": false

Owner score (0-5)
Owner reason
render_integrity layout_consistency readability visual_hierarchy table_legibility professional_finish blocking_defect_present
Dimension checkboxes export null until the owner changes them. If a box is changed and left unchecked, it exports false.
Blocking defect note
#2 `7b08cd4d` xlsx machine scores disagree
mandatory formatting diagnosis regression case; v1/v2 machine-score disagreement
sector: Professional, Scientific, and Technical Services
occupation: Accountants and Auditors
v1 judge calls: 59

### Render unavailable

Candidate deliverable file is not present in this checkout. Private HF result repo access/token was unavailable, so render falls back to path + machine evidence.

Primary path: `deliverable_files/7b08cd4d-df60-41ae-9102-8aaa49306ba2/2024_Fall_Music_Tour_PnL_As_of_2024-12-31.xlsx`

Recorded deliverable files:

- `deliverable_files/7b08cd4d-df60-41ae-9102-8aaa49306ba2/Fall Music Tour Ref File.xlsx`
- `deliverable_files/7b08cd4d-df60-41ae-9102-8aaa49306ba2/2024_Fall_Music_Tour_PnL_As_of_2024-12-31.xlsx`

task_id
`7b08cd4d-df60-41ae-9102-8aaa49306ba2`
deliverable
`deliverable_files/7b08cd4d-df60-41ae-9102-8aaa49306ba2/2024_Fall_Music_Tour_PnL_As_of_2024-12-31.xlsx`
kind
xlsx
max_score
5

## Rubric Criterion

Overall formatting and style of the deliverable

## Machine Scores (read-only)

### v1-minipass

5 / 5
rubric item: `ce2a2c8c-1eec-4d43-bd5f-dbc9192cc5d7`

    2024 Fall Music Tour – Profit & Loss
    As of 12/31/2024
    Revenue

### v2-minipartial

3 / 5
rubric item: `ce2a2c8c-1eec-4d43-bd5f-dbc9192cc5d7`

    "column_widths": {"A": 22.0, "B": 22.0, "C": 22.0, "D": 22.0, "E": 22.0, "F": 22.0}

### v2-standardpartial

3 / 5
rubric item: `ce2a2c8c-1eec-4d43-bd5f-dbc9192cc5d7`

    "column_widths": {"A": 22.0, "B": 22.0, "C": 22.0, "D": 22.0, "E": 22.0, "F": 22.0}, "merged_ranges": []

Owner score (0-5)
Owner reason
render_integrity layout_consistency readability visual_hierarchy table_legibility professional_finish blocking_defect_present
Dimension checkboxes export null until the owner changes them. If a box is changed and left unchecked, it exports false.
Blocking defect note
#3 `7d7fc9a7` pdf machine scores disagree
v1/v2 machine-score disagreement
sector: Professional, Scientific, and Technical Services
occupation: Accountants and Auditors
v1 judge calls: 49

### Render unavailable

Candidate deliverable file is not present in this checkout. Private HF result repo access/token was unavailable, so render falls back to path + machine evidence.

Primary path: `deliverable_files/7d7fc9a7-21a7-4b83-906f-416dea5ad04f/Aurisic_Prepaid_Insurance.pdf`

Recorded deliverable files:

- `deliverable_files/7d7fc9a7-21a7-4b83-906f-416dea5ad04f/Aurisic_Prepaid_Insurance.pdf`
- `deliverable_files/7d7fc9a7-21a7-4b83-906f-416dea5ad04f/Aurisic_Prepaid_Expenses_Mar25.pdf`
- `deliverable_files/7d7fc9a7-21a7-4b83-906f-416dea5ad04f/Aurisic_Prepaid_Expenses_Apr25.pdf`
- `deliverable_files/7d7fc9a7-21a7-4b83-906f-416dea5ad04f/Aurisic_Prepaid_Expenses_Feb25.pdf`
- `deliverable_files/7d7fc9a7-21a7-4b83-906f-416dea5ad04f/Aurisic_Prepaid_Expenses_Jan25.pdf`
- `deliverable_files/7d7fc9a7-21a7-4b83-906f-416dea5ad04f/COA.xlsx`
- `deliverable_files/7d7fc9a7-21a7-4b83-906f-416dea5ad04f/Aurisic_Prepaid_Amortization_Schedule_Through_Apr2025.xlsx`

task_id
`7d7fc9a7-21a7-4b83-906f-416dea5ad04f`
deliverable
`deliverable_files/7d7fc9a7-21a7-4b83-906f-416dea5ad04f/Aurisic_Prepaid_Insurance.pdf`
kind
pdf
max_score
5

## Rubric Criterion

Overall formatting and style of the deliverable

## Machine Scores (read-only)

### v1-minipartial

3.5 / 5
rubric item: `52b999af-0182-433f-965b-49330e54de07`

    [Sheet: Prepaid Summary]
    Category,Amount

    [Sheet: Prepaid Expenses (1250)]
    Vendor,Invoice Date,Original Amount,Amortization Month,Monthly Expense,Ending Balance

### v2-minifail

0 / 5
rubric item: `52b999af-0182-433f-965b-49330e54de07`

    "fill": "00000000", "bold": false, "border": false

### v2-standardpartial

1.5 / 5
rubric item: `52b999af-0182-433f-965b-49330e54de07`

    {"ref": "A1", "fill": "00000000", "bold": false, "font_color": "Values must be of type <class 'str'>", "border": false}

Owner score (0-5)
Owner reason
render_integrity layout_consistency readability visual_hierarchy table_legibility professional_finish blocking_defect_present
Dimension checkboxes export null until the owner changes them. If a box is changed and left unchecked, it exports false.
Blocking defect note
#4 `43dc9778` pdf machine scores disagree
v1/v2 machine-score disagreement
sector: Professional, Scientific, and Technical Services
occupation: Accountants and Auditors
v1 judge calls: 67

### Render unavailable

Candidate deliverable file is not present in this checkout. Private HF result repo access/token was unavailable, so render falls back to path + machine evidence.

Primary path: `deliverable_files/43dc9778-450b-4b46-b77e-b6d82b202035/LISA W2 COMPRESS MIDDLE SCHOOL edit.pdf`

Recorded deliverable files:

- `deliverable_files/43dc9778-450b-4b46-b77e-b6d82b202035/LISA W2 COMPRESS MIDDLE SCHOOL edit.pdf`
- `deliverable_files/43dc9778-450b-4b46-b77e-b6d82b202035/COMPLETED 2024 Client Intake Form - Bob and Lisa Smith.pdf`
- `deliverable_files/43dc9778-450b-4b46-b77e-b6d82b202035/MORTGAGE INTEREST FORM.pdf`
- `deliverable_files/43dc9778-450b-4b46-b77e-b6d82b202035/LISA 1099-DIV edit.pdf`
- `deliverable_files/43dc9778-450b-4b46-b77e-b6d82b202035/BOB 1099-INT.pdf`
- `deliverable_files/43dc9778-450b-4b46-b77e-b6d82b202035/Bob & Lisa SMITH LTC PREMIUMS PAID 2024.pdf`
- `deliverable_files/43dc9778-450b-4b46-b77e-b6d82b202035/Bob and Lisa 2024 Estimated Taxes Paid.pdf`
- `deliverable_files/43dc9778-450b-4b46-b77e-b6d82b202035/BOB W2 COMPANY X edit.pdf`
- `deliverable_files/43dc9778-450b-4b46-b77e-b6d82b202035/2024 Childcare Statement.pdf`
- `deliverable_files/43dc9778-450b-4b46-b77e-b6d82b202035/BOB W2 COMPANY Z edit.pdf`
- `deliverable_files/43dc9778-450b-4b46-b77e-b6d82b202035/BOB 1099-B edit.pdf`
- `deliverable_files/43dc9778-450b-4b46-b77e-b6d82b202035/LISA STUDENT LOAN INTEREST edit.pdf`
- `deliverable_files/43dc9778-450b-4b46-b77e-b6d82b202035/Smith_2024_Form_1040_Draft.pdf`
- `deliverable_files/43dc9778-450b-4b46-b77e-b6d82b202035/BOB 1099-INT Rose Edit.pdf`
- `deliverable_files/43dc9778-450b-4b46-b77e-b6d82b202035/LISA 1099-B edit.pdf`
- `deliverable_files/43dc9778-450b-4b46-b77e-b6d82b202035/LISA 1099-INT Rose edit.pdf`

task_id
`43dc9778-450b-4b46-b77e-b6d82b202035`
deliverable
`deliverable_files/43dc9778-450b-4b46-b77e-b6d82b202035/LISA W2 COMPRESS MIDDLE SCHOOL edit.pdf`
kind
pdf
max_score
5

## Rubric Criterion

Overall formatting and style of the deliverable

## Machine Scores (read-only)

### v1-minipartial

3.5 / 5
rubric item: `3ac4c272-1d93-490c-a543-3328c4862cda`

    “2024 Individual Income Tax Return – Form 1040 (Draft)
    Prepared for internal review based on client-provided documentation.”

### v2-minipartial

3 / 5
rubric item: `3ac4c272-1d93-490c-a543-3328c4862cda`

    "fonts": ["Helvetica", "Helvetica-Bold", "ZapfDingbats"]

### v2-standardpartial

2 / 5
rubric item: `3ac4c272-1d93-490c-a543-3328c4862cda`

    "fonts": ["Helvetica", "Helvetica-Bold", "ZapfDingbats"]

Owner score (0-5)
Owner reason
render_integrity layout_consistency readability visual_hierarchy table_legibility professional_finish blocking_defect_present
Dimension checkboxes export null until the owner changes them. If a box is changed and left unchecked, it exports false.
Blocking defect note
#5 `ee09d943` xlsx machine scores disagree
v1/v2 machine-score disagreement
sector: Professional, Scientific, and Technical Services
occupation: Accountants and Auditors
v1 judge calls: 40

### Render unavailable

Candidate deliverable file is not present in this checkout. Private HF result repo access/token was unavailable, so render falls back to path + machine evidence.

Primary path: `deliverable_files/ee09d943-5a11-430a-b7a2-971b4e9b01b5/Prof_Fee_Dump-1.xlsx`

Recorded deliverable files:

- `deliverable_files/ee09d943-5a11-430a-b7a2-971b4e9b01b5/Prof_Fee_Dump-1.xlsx`
- `deliverable_files/ee09d943-5a11-430a-b7a2-971b4e9b01b5/PPD1251-1.xlsx`
- `deliverable_files/ee09d943-5a11-430a-b7a2-971b4e9b01b5/Aurisic_Corp_Payrolls_April_2025-1.xlsx`
- `deliverable_files/ee09d943-5a11-430a-b7a2-971b4e9b01b5/Accr2011-1.xlsx`
- `deliverable_files/ee09d943-5a11-430a-b7a2-971b4e9b01b5/Good Insurance Co - Loan II.xlsx`
- `deliverable_files/ee09d943-5a11-430a-b7a2-971b4e9b01b5/Aurisic_Financials_4-25-1.xlsx`
- `deliverable_files/ee09d943-5a11-430a-b7a2-971b4e9b01b5/Legal_Dump-1.xlsx`
- `deliverable_files/ee09d943-5a11-430a-b7a2-971b4e9b01b5/AccrMisc-1.xlsx`
- `deliverable_files/ee09d943-5a11-430a-b7a2-971b4e9b01b5/Rebates-1.xlsx`
- `deliverable_files/ee09d943-5a11-430a-b7a2-971b4e9b01b5/AccrBonus-1.xlsx`
- `deliverable_files/ee09d943-5a11-430a-b7a2-971b4e9b01b5/AR_Accrual-1.xlsx`
- `deliverable_files/ee09d943-5a11-430a-b7a2-971b4e9b01b5/Aurisic_Prepaid_Expenses_4-25-1.xlsx`
- `deliverable_files/ee09d943-5a11-430a-b7a2-971b4e9b01b5/Payroll-1.xlsx`
- `deliverable_files/ee09d943-5a11-430a-b7a2-971b4e9b01b5/Outstanding_CKs_4-30-25-1.xlsx`
- `deliverable_files/ee09d943-5a11-430a-b7a2-971b4e9b01b5/PPD1250-1.xlsx`
- `deliverable_files/ee09d943-5a11-430a-b7a2-971b4e9b01b5/Good Insurance Co - Loan.xlsx`
- `deliverable_files/ee09d943-5a11-430a-b7a2-971b4e9b01b5/Aurisic_Financials_3-25-1.xlsx`
- `deliverable_files/ee09d943-5a11-430a-b7a2-971b4e9b01b5/Aurisic_Final_TB_4-25-1.txt`

task_id
`ee09d943-5a11-430a-b7a2-971b4e9b01b5`
deliverable
`deliverable_files/ee09d943-5a11-430a-b7a2-971b4e9b01b5/Prof_Fee_Dump-1.xlsx`
kind
xlsx
max_score
5

## Rubric Criterion

Overall formatting and style of the deliverable

## Machine Scores (read-only)

### v1-minipartial

3.75 / 5
rubric item: `665a6aca-2c92-49ca-b805-8612cf088f1e`

    "Tab #,Description,Comments\n1,Balance Sheets by Month,TO BE COMPLETED\n4,Cash Availability Status,COMPLETE"

### v2-minipass

5 / 5
rubric item: `665a6aca-2c92-49ca-b805-8612cf088f1e`

    "merged_ranges": ["AX4:AY4", "W4:X4", "BJ4:BK4", "H4:I4", "AU4:AV4"

### v2-standardpass

5 / 5
rubric item: `665a6aca-2c92-49ca-b805-8612cf088f1e`

    "merged_ranges": ["B2:C2"], "column_widths": {"A": 26.28515625, "B": 17.7109375, "C": 16.7109375, "E": 12.28515625, "F": 55.140625}, "has_charts": false

Owner score (0-5)
Owner reason
render_integrity layout_consistency readability visual_hierarchy table_legibility professional_finish blocking_defect_present
Dimension checkboxes export null until the owner changes them. If a box is changed and left unchecked, it exports false.
Blocking defect note
#6 `27e8912c` pdf machine scores disagree
mandatory formatting diagnosis regression case; v1/v2 machine-score disagreement
sector: Government
occupation: Administrative Services Managers
v1 judge calls: 37

### Render unavailable

Candidate deliverable file is not present in this checkout. Private HF result repo access/token was unavailable, so render falls back to path + machine evidence.

Primary path: `deliverable_files/27e8912c-8bd5-44ba-ad87-64066ea05264/Workstation_Ergonomics_Checklist.pdf`

Recorded deliverable files:

- `deliverable_files/27e8912c-8bd5-44ba-ad87-64066ea05264/Workstation_Ergonomics_Checklist.pdf`
- `deliverable_files/27e8912c-8bd5-44ba-ad87-64066ea05264/Organizational_Ergonomic_Action_Items.docx`
- `deliverable_files/27e8912c-8bd5-44ba-ad87-64066ea05264/work_surface_setup.png`
- `deliverable_files/27e8912c-8bd5-44ba-ad87-64066ea05264/keyboard_mouse_setup.png`
- `deliverable_files/27e8912c-8bd5-44ba-ad87-64066ea05264/chair_setup.png`

task_id
`27e8912c-8bd5-44ba-ad87-64066ea05264`
deliverable
`deliverable_files/27e8912c-8bd5-44ba-ad87-64066ea05264/Workstation_Ergonomics_Checklist.pdf`
kind
pdf
max_score
5

## Rubric Criterion

Overall formatting and style of the deliverable

## Machine Scores (read-only)

### v1-minipass

5 / 5
rubric item: `8e5445d2-94c7-4e4d-aeaa-0e043338fd8d`

    Workstation Ergonomics Checklist
    Goal: To ensure office workstations are set up to minimize neck and back strain, support neutral postures, and improve employee comfort and performance.

### v2-minipartial

3.5 / 5
rubric item: `8e5445d2-94c7-4e4d-aeaa-0e043338fd8d`

    "style_histogram": {"Heading 1": 1, "Heading 2": 2, "List Number": 4}

### v2-standardpartial

4 / 5
rubric item: `8e5445d2-94c7-4e4d-aeaa-0e043338fd8d`

    "style_histogram": {"Heading 1": 1, "Heading 2": 2, "List Number": 4}

Owner score (0-5)
Owner reason
render_integrity layout_consistency readability visual_hierarchy table_legibility professional_finish blocking_defect_present
Dimension checkboxes export null until the owner changes them. If a box is changed and left unchecked, it exports false.
Blocking defect note
#7 `99ac6944` xlsx
xlsx stratified overall-style sample
sector: Information
occupation: Audio and Video Technicians
v1 judge calls: 52

### Render unavailable

Candidate deliverable file is not present in this checkout. Private HF result repo access/token was unavailable, so render falls back to path + machine evidence.

Primary path: `deliverable_files/99ac6944-4ec6-4848-959c-a460ac705c6f/IEM_Budget_Breakdown.xlsx`

Recorded deliverable files:

- `deliverable_files/99ac6944-4ec6-4848-959c-a460ac705c6f/West_Coast_Tour_IEM_Mobile_Setup.pdf`
- `deliverable_files/99ac6944-4ec6-4848-959c-a460ac705c6f/IEM_Budget_Breakdown.xlsx`
- `deliverable_files/99ac6944-4ec6-4848-959c-a460ac705c6f/IEM_Signal_Flow.png`
- `deliverable_files/99ac6944-4ec6-4848-959c-a460ac705c6f/IEM_Budget_Breakdown.png`

task_id
`99ac6944-4ec6-4848-959c-a460ac705c6f`
deliverable
`deliverable_files/99ac6944-4ec6-4848-959c-a460ac705c6f/IEM_Budget_Breakdown.xlsx`
kind
xlsx
max_score
5

## Rubric Criterion

Overall formatting and style of the deliverable

## Machine Scores (read-only)

### v1-minipass

5 / 5
rubric item: `eda4b838-a0dd-4f15-aafd-eb646b3b2bc1`

    Mobile In-Ear Monitor (IEM) Setup Proposal

### v2-minino machine grade

--

    No grade JSON item found for this selected task/model.

### v2-standardno machine grade

--

    No grade JSON item found for this selected task/model.

Owner score (0-5)
Owner reason
render_integrity layout_consistency readability visual_hierarchy table_legibility professional_finish blocking_defect_present
Dimension checkboxes export null until the owner changes them. If a box is changed and left unchecked, it exports false.
Blocking defect note
#8 `7bbfcfe9` xlsx
xlsx stratified overall-style sample
sector: Government
occupation: Compliance Officers
v1 judge calls: 40

### Render unavailable

Candidate deliverable file is not present in this checkout. Private HF result repo access/token was unavailable, so render falls back to path + machine evidence.

Primary path: `deliverable_files/7bbfcfe9-132d-4194-82bb-d6f29d001b01/SCRA_Compliance_Test_Questions.xlsx`

Recorded deliverable files:

- `deliverable_files/7bbfcfe9-132d-4194-82bb-d6f29d001b01/SCRA_Compliance_Test_Questions.xlsx`

task_id
`7bbfcfe9-132d-4194-82bb-d6f29d001b01`
deliverable
`deliverable_files/7bbfcfe9-132d-4194-82bb-d6f29d001b01/SCRA_Compliance_Test_Questions.xlsx`
kind
xlsx
max_score
5

## Rubric Criterion

Overall formatting and style of the deliverable

## Machine Scores (read-only)

### v1-minipass

5 / 5
rubric item: `b9b37b71-e8b0-4d59-86e9-717f6bb25f6e`

    [Sheet: SCRA Test Questions]
    Identifier,Statute,Citation,Test Question,Allowed Responses

### v2-minino machine grade

--

    No grade JSON item found for this selected task/model.

### v2-standardno machine grade

--

    No grade JSON item found for this selected task/model.

Owner score (0-5)
Owner reason
render_integrity layout_consistency readability visual_hierarchy table_legibility professional_finish blocking_defect_present
Dimension checkboxes export null until the owner changes them. If a box is changed and left unchecked, it exports false.
Blocking defect note
#9 `f9a1c16c` pdf
pdf stratified overall-style sample
sector: Information
occupation: Audio and Video Technicians
v1 judge calls: 51

### Render unavailable

Candidate deliverable file is not present in this checkout. Private HF result repo access/token was unavailable, so render falls back to path + machine evidence.

Primary path: `deliverable_files/f9a1c16c-53fd-4c8f-88cc-5c325ec2f0bb/Tour_Stage_Plot.pdf`

Recorded deliverable files:

- `deliverable_files/f9a1c16c-53fd-4c8f-88cc-5c325ec2f0bb/Tour_Stage_Plot.pdf`

task_id
`f9a1c16c-53fd-4c8f-88cc-5c325ec2f0bb`
deliverable
`deliverable_files/f9a1c16c-53fd-4c8f-88cc-5c325ec2f0bb/Tour_Stage_Plot.pdf`
kind
pdf
max_score
5

## Rubric Criterion

Overall formatting and style of the deliverable

## Machine Scores (read-only)

### v1-minipartial

2 / 5
rubric item: `133bc04a-4169-4315-8217-0af9623c532e`

    "Tour Stage Plot\nInputs Outputs\nInput 1 - Vox1 Vocal Output 1 - Bass Wedge"

### v2-minino machine grade

--

    No grade JSON item found for this selected task/model.

### v2-standardno machine grade

--

    No grade JSON item found for this selected task/model.

Owner score (0-5)
Owner reason
render_integrity layout_consistency readability visual_hierarchy table_legibility professional_finish blocking_defect_present
Dimension checkboxes export null until the owner changes them. If a box is changed and left unchecked, it exports false.
Blocking defect note
#10 `bbe0a93b` pdf
pdf stratified overall-style sample
sector: Government
occupation: Child, Family, and School Social Workers
v1 judge calls: 61

### Render unavailable

Candidate deliverable file is not present in this checkout. Private HF result repo access/token was unavailable, so render falls back to path + machine evidence.

Primary path: `deliverable_files/bbe0a93b-ebf0-40b0-98dc-8d9243099034/Kent_County_Needs_Assessment_Espanol.pdf`

Recorded deliverable files:

- `deliverable_files/bbe0a93b-ebf0-40b0-98dc-8d9243099034/Kent_County_Community_Resource_Guide.pdf`
- `deliverable_files/bbe0a93b-ebf0-40b0-98dc-8d9243099034/Kent_County_Needs_Assessment_Espanol.pdf`
- `deliverable_files/bbe0a93b-ebf0-40b0-98dc-8d9243099034/Kent_County_Needs_Assessment_English.pdf`

task_id
`bbe0a93b-ebf0-40b0-98dc-8d9243099034`
deliverable
`deliverable_files/bbe0a93b-ebf0-40b0-98dc-8d9243099034/Kent_County_Needs_Assessment_Espanol.pdf`
kind
pdf
max_score
5

## Rubric Criterion

Overall formatting and style of the deliverable

## Machine Scores (read-only)

### v1-minipass

5 / 5
rubric item: `e0692c1e-3c4f-4252-946b-ddae22eae229`

    "Kent County Community Resource Guide\nThis guide lists commonly used free or low-cost resources in Kent County, Michigan.\nFinancial Assistance"

### v2-minino machine grade

--

    No grade JSON item found for this selected task/model.

### v2-standardno machine grade

--

    No grade JSON item found for this selected task/model.

Owner score (0-5)
Owner reason
render_integrity layout_consistency readability visual_hierarchy table_legibility professional_finish blocking_defect_present
Dimension checkboxes export null until the owner changes them. If a box is changed and left unchecked, it exports false.
Blocking defect note
#11 `85d95ce5` pdf
pdf stratified overall-style sample
sector: Government
occupation: Child, Family, and School Social Workers
v1 judge calls: 61

### Render unavailable

Candidate deliverable file is not present in this checkout. Private HF result repo access/token was unavailable, so render falls back to path + machine evidence.

Primary path: `deliverable_files/85d95ce5-b20c-41e2-834e-e788ce9622b6/J.S..pdf`

Recorded deliverable files:

- `deliverable_files/85d95ce5-b20c-41e2-834e-e788ce9622b6/J.S..pdf`
- `deliverable_files/85d95ce5-b20c-41e2-834e-e788ce9622b6/Recommendation Bank T.H..docx`
- `deliverable_files/85d95ce5-b20c-41e2-834e-e788ce9622b6/Notes for Terry Hartsdale.docx`
- `deliverable_files/85d95ce5-b20c-41e2-834e-e788ce9622b6/Social Developmental History Template.docx`

task_id
`85d95ce5-b20c-41e2-834e-e788ce9622b6`
deliverable
`deliverable_files/85d95ce5-b20c-41e2-834e-e788ce9622b6/J.S..pdf`
kind
pdf
max_score
5

## Rubric Criterion

Overall formatting and style of the deliverable

## Machine Scores (read-only)

### v1-minipass

5 / 5
rubric item: `57b03b26-a7de-4681-a74f-15e2244c42e6`

    "SOCIAL DEVELOPMENTAL HISTORY\n----------------------------\nREASON FOR REFERRAL\n-------------------"

### v2-minino machine grade

--

    No grade JSON item found for this selected task/model.

### v2-standardno machine grade

--

    No grade JSON item found for this selected task/model.

Owner score (0-5)
Owner reason
render_integrity layout_consistency readability visual_hierarchy table_legibility professional_finish blocking_defect_present
Dimension checkboxes export null until the owner changes them. If a box is changed and left unchecked, it exports false.
Blocking defect note
#12 `1b1ade2d` docx
docx stratified overall-style sample
sector: Manufacturing
occupation: Buyers and Purchasing Agents
v1 judge calls: 51

### Render unavailable

Candidate deliverable file is not present in this checkout. Private HF result repo access/token was unavailable, so render falls back to path + machine evidence.

Primary path: `deliverable_files/1b1ade2d-f9f6-4a04-baa5-aa15012b53be/Revised_Sourcing_and_Nomination_Workflow_Lamp_Assemblies.docx`

Recorded deliverable files:

- `deliverable_files/1b1ade2d-f9f6-4a04-baa5-aa15012b53be/Revised_Sourcing_and_Nomination_Workflow_Lamp_Assemblies.docx`

task_id
`1b1ade2d-f9f6-4a04-baa5-aa15012b53be`
deliverable
`deliverable_files/1b1ade2d-f9f6-4a04-baa5-aa15012b53be/Revised_Sourcing_and_Nomination_Workflow_Lamp_Assemblies.docx`
kind
docx
max_score
5

## Rubric Criterion

Overall formatting and style of the deliverable

## Machine Scores (read-only)

### v1-minipass

5 / 5
rubric item: `bf27cea9-f15e-43b1-b0a7-63bbc7fbb1b4`

    "Revised Sourcing and Nomination Workflow for Automotive Electronics (Lamp Assemblies) 1. Background and Objective 2. Key Design Principles - Digital-first workflow..."

### v2-minino machine grade

--

    No grade JSON item found for this selected task/model.

### v2-standardno machine grade

--

    No grade JSON item found for this selected task/model.

Owner score (0-5)
Owner reason
render_integrity layout_consistency readability visual_hierarchy table_legibility professional_finish blocking_defect_present
Dimension checkboxes export null until the owner changes them. If a box is changed and left unchecked, it exports false.
Blocking defect note
#13 `93b336f3` docx
docx stratified overall-style sample
sector: Manufacturing
occupation: Buyers and Purchasing Agents
v1 judge calls: 52

### Render unavailable

Candidate deliverable file is not present in this checkout. Private HF result repo access/token was unavailable, so render falls back to path + machine evidence.

Primary path: `deliverable_files/93b336f3-61f3-4287-86d2-87445e1e0f90/EV_Battery_Assembly_Localisation_Partnership_Proposal.docx`

Recorded deliverable files:

- `deliverable_files/93b336f3-61f3-4287-86d2-87445e1e0f90/EV_Battery_Assembly_Localisation_Partnership_Proposal.docx`

task_id
`93b336f3-61f3-4287-86d2-87445e1e0f90`
deliverable
`deliverable_files/93b336f3-61f3-4287-86d2-87445e1e0f90/EV_Battery_Assembly_Localisation_Partnership_Proposal.docx`
kind
docx
max_score
5

## Rubric Criterion

Overall formatting and style of the deliverable

## Machine Scores (read-only)

### v1-minipass

5 / 5
rubric item: `2517cf92-4de2-4059-a40c-91dcb9f6f320`

    "EV Battery Pack Assembly Localisation Partnership Proposal\nPrepared for: Chief Procurement Officer\n1. Executive Summary"

### v2-minino machine grade

--

    No grade JSON item found for this selected task/model.

### v2-standardno machine grade

--

    No grade JSON item found for this selected task/model.

Owner score (0-5)
Owner reason
render_integrity layout_consistency readability visual_hierarchy table_legibility professional_finish blocking_defect_present
Dimension checkboxes export null until the owner changes them. If a box is changed and left unchecked, it exports false.
Blocking defect note
#14 `575f8679` docx
docx stratified overall-style sample
sector: Government
occupation: Child, Family, and School Social Workers
v1 judge calls: 48

### Render unavailable

Candidate deliverable file is not present in this checkout. Private HF result repo access/token was unavailable, so render falls back to path + machine evidence.

Primary path: `deliverable_files/575f8679-b4c1-47a2-8e96-d570d4ed9269/Immigration_and_Family_Stress_Evaluation_Plan.docx`

Recorded deliverable files:

- `deliverable_files/575f8679-b4c1-47a2-8e96-d570d4ed9269/Immigration_and_Family_Stress_Evaluation_Plan.docx`

task_id
`575f8679-b4c1-47a2-8e96-d570d4ed9269`
deliverable
`deliverable_files/575f8679-b4c1-47a2-8e96-d570d4ed9269/Immigration_and_Family_Stress_Evaluation_Plan.docx`
kind
docx
max_score
5

## Rubric Criterion

Overall formatting and style of the deliverable

## Machine Scores (read-only)

### v1-minipartial

3.5 / 5
rubric item: `c2623df6-e407-45f8-9ff5-1847fe8d7f5e`

    "Evaluation Plan: Immigration and Family Stress\nSupporting Immigrant Families’ Mental Health\n1. Program Overview"

### v2-minino machine grade

--

    No grade JSON item found for this selected task/model.

### v2-standardno machine grade

--

    No grade JSON item found for this selected task/model.

Owner score (0-5)
Owner reason
render_integrity layout_consistency readability visual_hierarchy table_legibility professional_finish blocking_defect_present
Dimension checkboxes export null until the owner changes them. If a box is changed and left unchecked, it exports false.
Blocking defect note
#15 `0419f1c3` docx
local candidate file available for render smoke
sector: Real Estate and Rental and Leasing
occupation: Property, Real Estate, and Community Association Managers
v1 judge calls: 49
QuickLook thumbnail: Performance_Improvement_Plan_John_Miller_2025-07-13.docx · recorded path: `deliverable_files/0419f1c3-d669-45d0-81cd-f4d5923b06a5/Performance Improvement Plan – John Miller (07-13-2025).docx` · local source: `/Users/hsjeon/git/gdpval-realworks/batch-runner/workspace/upload/deliverable_files/0419f1c3-d669-45d0-81cd-f4d5923b06a5/Performance_Improvement_Plan_John_Miller_2025-07-13.docx` · resolver: fuzzy
task_id
`0419f1c3-d669-45d0-81cd-f4d5923b06a5`
deliverable
`deliverable_files/0419f1c3-d669-45d0-81cd-f4d5923b06a5/Performance Improvement Plan – John Miller (07-13-2025).docx`
kind
docx
max_score
5

## Rubric Criterion

Overall formatting and style of the deliverable

## Machine Scores (read-only)

### v1-minipass

5 / 5
rubric item: `f1b40fe9-9381-4fea-9d88-b42cd7afe818`

    Performance Improvement Plan (PIP)
    Employee: [REDACTED]
    Position: Superintendent
    Date: 07/13/2025
    1. Summary of Performance Gaps

### v2-minino machine grade

--

    No grade JSON item found for this selected task/model.

### v2-standardno machine grade

--

    No grade JSON item found for this selected task/model.

Owner score (0-5)
Owner reason
render_integrity layout_consistency readability visual_hierarchy table_legibility professional_finish blocking_defect_present
Dimension checkboxes export null until the owner changes them. If a box is changed and left unchecked, it exports false.
Blocking defect note
#16 `6dcae3f5` docx
docx stratified overall-style sample
sector: Health Care and Social Assistance
occupation: First-Line Supervisors of Office and Administrative Support Workers
v1 judge calls: 32

### Render unavailable

Candidate deliverable file is not present in this checkout. Private HF result repo access/token was unavailable, so render falls back to path + machine evidence.

Primary path: `deliverable_files/6dcae3f5-bf1c-48e0-8b4b-23e6486a934c/Email_to_PD_Key_Indicator_Analysis.docx`

Recorded deliverable files:

- `deliverable_files/6dcae3f5-bf1c-48e0-8b4b-23e6486a934c/Email_to_PD_Key_Indicator_Analysis.docx`
- `deliverable_files/6dcae3f5-bf1c-48e0-8b4b-23e6486a934c/Chief Key Indicator 5-Year.xlsx`
- `deliverable_files/6dcae3f5-bf1c-48e0-8b4b-23e6486a934c/Key Indicators.xlsx`

task_id
`6dcae3f5-bf1c-48e0-8b4b-23e6486a934c`
deliverable
`deliverable_files/6dcae3f5-bf1c-48e0-8b4b-23e6486a934c/Email_to_PD_Key_Indicator_Analysis.docx`
kind
docx
max_score
5

## Rubric Criterion

Overall formatting and style of the deliverable

## Machine Scores (read-only)

### v1-minipartial

2 / 5
rubric item: `bc9229f7-7cbf-4310-af6f-7d10ed3c5555`

    "60 resident(s) were identified as being two or more standard deviations below the mean in the following areas:\n- None (None): Neck Dissection- ALL"

### v2-minino machine grade

--

    No grade JSON item found for this selected task/model.

### v2-standardno machine grade

--

    No grade JSON item found for this selected task/model.

Owner score (0-5)
Owner reason
render_integrity layout_consistency readability visual_hierarchy table_legibility professional_finish blocking_defect_present
Dimension checkboxes export null until the owner changes them. If a box is changed and left unchecked, it exports false.
Blocking defect note
#17 `a74ead3b` pptx
pptx stratification
sector: Government
occupation: Child, Family, and School Social Workers
v1 judge calls: 57

### Render unavailable

Candidate deliverable file is not present in this checkout. Private HF result repo access/token was unavailable, so render falls back to path + machine evidence.

Primary path: `deliverable_files/a74ead3b-f67d-4b1c-9116-f6bb81b29d4f/Session_14_Nurturing_Parenting_Recovery.pptx`

Recorded deliverable files:

- `deliverable_files/a74ead3b-f67d-4b1c-9116-f6bb81b29d4f/Session_14_Nurturing_Parenting_Recovery.pptx`
- `deliverable_files/a74ead3b-f67d-4b1c-9116-f6bb81b29d4f/Session_13_Nurturing_Parenting_Recovery.pptx`
- `deliverable_files/a74ead3b-f67d-4b1c-9116-f6bb81b29d4f/neutral_background.png`

task_id
`a74ead3b-f67d-4b1c-9116-f6bb81b29d4f`
deliverable
`deliverable_files/a74ead3b-f67d-4b1c-9116-f6bb81b29d4f/Session_14_Nurturing_Parenting_Recovery.pptx`
kind
pptx
max_score
5

## Rubric Criterion

Overall formatting and style of the deliverable

## Machine Scores (read-only)

### v1-minipass

5 / 5
rubric item: `30671f00-7282-4a6c-9883-690628080c63`

    [Slide 2]
    Icebreaker: Reflecting on Growth
    Share one positive change you have noticed in yourself during recovery.

### v2-minino machine grade

--

    No grade JSON item found for this selected task/model.

### v2-standardno machine grade

--

    No grade JSON item found for this selected task/model.

Owner score (0-5)
Owner reason
render_integrity layout_consistency readability visual_hierarchy table_legibility professional_finish blocking_defect_present
Dimension checkboxes export null until the owner changes them. If a box is changed and left unchecked, it exports false.
Blocking defect note
#18 `ec591973` pptx
pptx stratification
sector: Wholesale Trade
occupation: First-Line Supervisors of Non-Retail Sales Workers
v1 judge calls: 67

### Render unavailable

Candidate deliverable file is not present in this checkout. Private HF result repo access/token was unavailable, so render falls back to path + machine evidence.

Primary path: `deliverable_files/ec591973-04d5-48c0-981c-1ab2fcec2dc1/Differentiated_Distribution_Strategy_Slide.pptx`

Recorded deliverable files:

- `deliverable_files/ec591973-04d5-48c0-981c-1ab2fcec2dc1/Differentiated_Distribution_Strategy_Slide.pptx`

task_id
`ec591973-04d5-48c0-981c-1ab2fcec2dc1`
deliverable
`deliverable_files/ec591973-04d5-48c0-981c-1ab2fcec2dc1/Differentiated_Distribution_Strategy_Slide.pptx`
kind
pptx
max_score
5

## Rubric Criterion

Overall formatting and style of the deliverable

## Machine Scores (read-only)

### v1-minipass

5 / 5
rubric item: `f1e9d131-a8eb-45af-88f2-77781b62cde3`

    "Differentiated Distribution Investment to Protect Client Retention & Brand Health
    Current Business Challenges
    Strategic Response: Channel-Differentiated Experience
    Long-Term Impact"

### v2-minino machine grade

--

    No grade JSON item found for this selected task/model.

### v2-standardno machine grade

--

    No grade JSON item found for this selected task/model.

Owner score (0-5)
Owner reason
render_integrity layout_consistency readability visual_hierarchy table_legibility professional_finish blocking_defect_present
Dimension checkboxes export null until the owner changes them. If a box is changed and left unchecked, it exports false.
Blocking defect note
#19 `9a0d8d36` pptx
pptx stratification
sector: Finance and Insurance
occupation: Personal Financial Advisors
v1 judge calls: 40

### Render unavailable

Candidate deliverable file is not present in this checkout. Private HF result repo access/token was unavailable, so render falls back to path + machine evidence.

Primary path: `deliverable_files/9a0d8d36-6233-4c76-9107-0d1f783c7340/ISO_vs_NQSO_Tax_Comparison.pptx`

Recorded deliverable files:

- `deliverable_files/9a0d8d36-6233-4c76-9107-0d1f783c7340/ISO_vs_NQSO_Tax_Comparison.pptx`

task_id
`9a0d8d36-6233-4c76-9107-0d1f783c7340`
deliverable
`deliverable_files/9a0d8d36-6233-4c76-9107-0d1f783c7340/ISO_vs_NQSO_Tax_Comparison.pptx`
kind
pptx
max_score
5

## Rubric Criterion

Overall formatting and style of the deliverable

## Machine Scores (read-only)

### v1-minipass

5 / 5
rubric item: `f25166eb-a552-408b-a882-c8e3925b065d`

    [Slide 1]
    Incentive Stock Options vs. Non‑Qualified Stock Options
    Tax Treatment and Net Proceeds Comparison

### v2-minino machine grade

--

    No grade JSON item found for this selected task/model.

### v2-standardno machine grade

--

    No grade JSON item found for this selected task/model.

Owner score (0-5)
Owner reason
render_integrity layout_consistency readability visual_hierarchy table_legibility professional_finish blocking_defect_present
Dimension checkboxes export null until the owner changes them. If a box is changed and left unchecked, it exports false.
Blocking defect note
#20 `403b9234` pptx
pptx stratification
sector: Government
occupation: Recreation Workers
v1 judge calls: 16

### Render unavailable

Candidate deliverable file is not present in this checkout. Private HF result repo access/token was unavailable, so render falls back to path + machine evidence.

Primary path: `deliverable_files/403b9234-6299-4b5f-a106-70c1bc11ec4c/Chamber_of_Commerce_Partnership_Proposal.pptx`

Recorded deliverable files:

- `deliverable_files/403b9234-6299-4b5f-a106-70c1bc11ec4c/Chamber_of_Commerce_Partnership_Proposal.pptx`

task_id
`403b9234-6299-4b5f-a106-70c1bc11ec4c`
deliverable
`deliverable_files/403b9234-6299-4b5f-a106-70c1bc11ec4c/Chamber_of_Commerce_Partnership_Proposal.pptx`
kind
pptx
max_score
5

## Rubric Criterion

Overall formatting and style of the deliverable

## Machine Scores (read-only)

### v1-minipass

5 / 5
rubric item: `9e7a1046-1da6-49ce-b8a5-ef3a80b42a67`

    [Slide 1]
    Exploring a Community Partnership
    with the County Chamber of Commerce
    Parks & Recreation Advisory Board Discussion

### v2-minino machine grade

--

    No grade JSON item found for this selected task/model.

### v2-standardno machine grade

--

    No grade JSON item found for this selected task/model.

Owner score (0-5)
Owner reason
render_integrity layout_consistency readability visual_hierarchy table_legibility professional_finish blocking_defect_present
Dimension checkboxes export null until the owner changes them. If a box is changed and left unchecked, it exports false.
Blocking defect note