# Verdict — Final cross-view pass (Phase E)

Grader: `skills:uiux-grader`, final cross-pass.
Inputs: rubric, `flow-map.md`, `register.md`, `rubric-weights.md`, all 8 in-scope screenshots.

## Verdict
Overall: **PASS**
Weakest dimension: `affordance-honesty` (4.0 / 5 weighted)
Threshold: 4.0 ≥ 4 → met

## Per-dimension scores

| Dimension | Raw | Weight | Weighted | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| `user-flow-fidelity` | **5** | 1.0 | **5.0** | BLOCKED first on list, last assistant message in first viewport on detail, Spawn disabled + helper text on create — every flow invariant met. |
| `visual-register-match` | 4 | 1.5 | **6.0** | Pure `#0E0E10` base, elevation-only separation, single white CTA accent, pill rounding throughout. Red stop button sits at the edge of the "one accent" rule but is a functional control. |
| `content-density` | **5** | 1.5 | **7.5** | Rows carry full meta, detail has STATS/SUBAGENTS + tabs, create has all fields with helper text. Sparseness reads as composed, never stripped. |
| `affordance-honesty` | 4 | 1.0 | **4.0** | Spawn disabled state visibly dimmed + helper text. Chevrons, tab underline, dock CTA hierarchy, circular icon buttons all consistent. |
| `brand-voice-adherence` | N/A | 0.5 | — | No `project-rules.md` |
| `cross-locale-consistency` | N/A | 0.5 | — | EN-only |

## Trajectory baseline → final

| Dimension | Baseline | Phase B | Phase C | Phase D | Final |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| `visual-register-match` | 1.5 | 5 | 4 | 4 | **4** |
| `content-density` | 2 | 5 | 5 | 4 | **5** |
| `user-flow-fidelity` | 2 | N/A | 5 | 4 | **5** |
| `affordance-honesty` | 2 | 4 | 4 | 4 | **4** |
| **Overall** | REJECT | PASS | PASS | PASS | **PASS** |

Floor (REJECT, weakest weighted 2.25) → ceiling (PASS, weakest weighted 4.0).

## Cross-view consistency confirmed

- App-bar pattern (back / title / sub-line / spinner / kebab) coherent across list (no back, no sub-line), detail (full), create (back + title only).
- Dock present only on list; sheet only opens from list kebab; no view leaks the wrong chrome.
- Color palette identical across all 8 screenshots — no token drift.
- Corner radii consistent: cards 20px, pills 999px, inputs 16px, composer 24px.
- Type scale matches across views: small-caps section labels, body 16px, display 28px on create.
- Single CTA per screen rule honored: `+ New` on list, `Spawn` on create (muted when disabled), send circle on detail composer (muted when empty).

## Residual nits (acknowledged, not blockers)

- Spawn disabled fill is a single grey tone — could add reduced opacity for stronger differentiation in a future polish pass.
- Red stop button introduces a functional accent that's not in the strict "one CTA color" set; acceptable for the destructive-action exception.
- SSE-induced action-bar swap wipes in-flight composer text — only matters for grader screenshot capture, not the production flow where Dashboard.sendInput clears the input synchronously before the SSE event lands.
