# Phase 4.4 Mechanical Rubric — /Users/sway003/master-skill/skill/prototypes/scriptwriting-master/output

**Verdict**: `PASS`

Counts: 16 pass / 1 partial / 0 fail / 0 needs subagent / 0 skipped

| # | Item | Status | Detail |
|---|------|--------|--------|
| 1 | 心智模型数 (3-7) | ✅ pass | 7 models (in [3, 7]) |
| 2 | 心智模型局限 100% 填 | ✅ pass | all 7 models have 局限 field |
| 3 | Playbook 数 (5-10) | ✅ pass | 10 rules (in [5, 10]) |
| 4 | Playbook 案例 ≥ 1 | ✅ pass | all 10 rules have 案例 |
| 5 | 工具三层覆盖 | ✅ pass | 必备=7 场景化=7 新兴=5 |
| 6 | 工作流入门-资深差异 ≥ 80% | ✅ pass | 90% workflows have ≥ 2 senior diffs |
| 7 | 表达 DNA 辨识度 | ⚠️ partial | voice samples library: 8 entries (target ≥ 8), voice_confidence: medium — Phase 4.3 subagent run still recommended to confirm voice fidelity |
| 8 | 诚实边界 ≥ 3 条 | ✅ pass | 7 boundary items |
| 9 | 一手来源 ≥ 50% (自报) | ✅ pass | primary ratio = 93% (≥ 50%) |
| 10 | Agentic Protocol 维度 (3-10) | ✅ pass | 7 dimensions (in [3, 10]) |
| 11 | 时效性标注完整 | ✅ pass | 12 markers across 4 key sections |
| 12 | 多 figure 共识门槛 | ✅ pass | all 7 models cite ≥ 2 figures |
| 13 | URL 一手机械验证 ≥ 50% | ✅ pass | manifest first-hand 220/235 = 93.6% (verified_primary=47, surrogate_primary=173) |
| 14 | 无黑名单 URL | ✅ pass | 0 blacklisted, 0 manifest-bucket violations, 0 prose-cited blacklisted URLs (235 manifest entries) |
| 15 | freshness 标注 ≥ 70% | ✅ pass | manifest: 100% entries fresh-dated |
| 16 | claim → evidence ≥ 2 source_ids | ✅ pass | all 7 models cite ≥ 2 distinct source_ids |
| 17 | 数字 / deadline / 拒审率 必带来源 + 置信度 | ✅ pass | 7/8 numbers cited (source_id or caveat) = 88% |

**PASS action**: proceed to Phase 4.1/4.2/4.3 subagent runs (prompts/quality_check.md), then Phase 5.

**Note**: Items marked 🧠 needs_subagent require running `prompts/quality_check.md` Phase 4.3 voice check via spawned subagent. This script does not run subagents.