# Feedback: vm-extensions-functions

## Decision: ✅ APPROVE

All acceptance criteria have been successfully met and verified.

## Summary

### Tests & Quality ✅
- **All 338 tests passed** — zero failures
- **31 new function tests** — exceeds 20+ requirement
- **Regression check passed** — 199 existing tests continue to pass
- **Coverage complete** — all acceptance criteria (AC2.2-2.5, AC2.8 partial) verified with comprehensive tests including edge cases (None handling, negative parameters, deep call stacks, zero vs None distinction)

### Acceptance Criteria Met ✅
- **AC2.2**: Zero-parameter functions execute and return values correctly
- **AC2.3**: Functions with parameters execute correctly (arguments as values)
- **AC2.4**: Local variables properly isolated from global scope
- **AC2.5**: Return without value works (returns None)
- **AC2.8 (partial)**: Function call overhead is measurable
- **Technical Requirements**: DefineFunction stores metadata, Call creates CallFrame/saves state/jumps, Return restores CallFrame/returns value/jumps back

### Code Quality ✅
- Proper error handling and state management
- Effective scope isolation between function calls
- No blocking issues identified

## Non-Blocking Debt Items

The following items are tracked for future improvements (not blockers for this issue):

1. **Test Coverage Enhancement** (suggestion)
   - Stack overflow protection for deeply recursive calls
   - More edge cases with Value::None as arguments
   - Complex nested register scenarios

2. **Register Cloning Performance** (suggestion)
   - Current: `saved_registers: self.registers.clone()` (line 279)
   - Optimization opportunity: Consider sparse storage or lazy cloning since most registers are empty (None)

3. **Value::None Display Formatting** (suggestion)
   - Currently displays as empty string (line 174)
   - Consider more explicit output for debugging scenarios

4. **Documentation** (suggestion)
   - Add comments documenting the param_N parameter naming convention (param_0, param_1, etc.) used at line 273

---

**Status**: Ready for merge. This iteration successfully completes the vm-extensions-functions feature with high-quality, production-ready code.
