# Self-Coherence Report — Issue #347

**Issue:** cdd/review: Clarify §3.3 — APPROVED requires AC coverage AND zero unresolved findings
**Branch:** cycle/347
**Author:** Alpha (`alpha@cdd.cnos`)

## Change Summary

Added an explicit conjunction rule as the first bullet of §3.3 in
`src/packages/cnos.cdd/skills/cdd/review/SKILL.md`. The new bullet states:

> **APPROVED is a conjunction:** `APPROVED` means (a) all issue ACs are met **and** (b) zero
> findings at any severity remain unresolved. A verdict with unresolved C, B, or A findings is
> internally contradictory — the Severity table declares all of C/B/A "not merge-ready until
> fixed." APPROVED+unresolved-finding is not a valid verdict form.

## AC Verification

| # | AC | Status | Notes |
|---|----|--------|-------|
| AC1 | §3.3 contains explicit positive rule: APPROVED = AC coverage AND zero unresolved findings | MET | New first bullet states conjunction explicitly |
| AC2 | Severity table rows (D/C/B/A) remain consistent — no contradiction, no duplicate text | MET | Table unchanged; §3.3 references it accurately |

## Consistency Check

- Severity table (D/C/B/A = "not merge-ready until fixed"): unchanged, consistent with §3.3.
- §3.3 new bullet cites the Severity table; it does not duplicate the table's rows.
- No contradictions introduced between §3.3 and any other section.

---

## Review Readiness

**Status:** READY FOR REVIEW

- AC1: met — explicit conjunction rule present as first bullet of §3.3
- AC2: met — Severity table consistent, no contradiction, no duplicate text
- Author git identity: `Alpha <alpha@cdd.cnos>`
- Diff is minimal: one bullet added to §3.3, no other files modified
- No stale paths, no broken links introduced
