# β Close-out — Issue #355

**Issue**: #355 - cdd(enforcement): structural compliance gates — make protocol bypass impossible, not merely discouraged  
**Cycle**: 355  
**β**: beta@cdd.cnos  
**Date**: 2026-05-12  

## Review Summary

**Verdict**: APPROVED  
**Rounds**: 1 (no fix rounds required)  
**Merge**: Completed to main at 22:15 UTC  

## Implementation Assessment

**Quality**: Excellent. α delivered precise, targeted structural enforcement that directly addresses the meta-problem.

**Scope adherence**: Outstanding. Implementation limited to enforcement mechanics without scope creep. AC4 appropriately deferred.

**Problem solving**: Directly addresses the root cause - makes protocol bypass structurally impossible rather than merely discouraged.

## Technical Review

**Enforcement mechanics**: Dual gates provide redundant protection:
- Rule 3.11b in review/SKILL.md (verdict-level gate)
- Row 4 in beta/SKILL.md (pre-merge gate)

**Integration**: Clean integration with existing β review protocol. Complements CI-green gate (rule 3.10) with protocol-compliance gate.

**Exception handling**: Appropriate scope clause allows documented exemptions for emergency/infrastructure cases.

## Process Observations

**Meta-problem addressing**: This cycle exemplifies the problem it solves - implemented via δ-as-agent bypass method, then ships gates to prevent future bypass. The irony is intentional and demonstrates the need.

**Pattern establishment**: Creates template for structural enforcement over advisory guidance. Time pressure breaks advisory protocols but structural gates hold.

**Self-improvement enablement**: Restores γ/ε improvement surface integrity by preventing agents from bypassing coordination under pressure.

## Release Notes

Structural compliance gates prevent CDD protocol bypass. Future cycles must have gamma-closeout.md to merge, blocking the #354/#349 pattern where δ dispatched α→β directly without triadic coordination.

---

**Merge SHA**: 3d6177f66ec06384b7fecafc8f394f6dd31511f9  
**Artifacts**: review/SKILL.md enhanced, beta/SKILL.md enhanced, structural enforcement implemented  
**Next**: Ready for δ release boundary (tag/branch cleanup per CDD.md §1.4)