{
  "system": "rag",
  "version": "v3-checkpointed",
  "run": 1,
  "answer_model": "openai/gpt-4.1-mini",
  "answer_max_tokens": 200,
  "answer_temperature": 0,
  "judge_model": "openai/gpt-4o-mini",
  "judge_max_tokens": 10,
  "judge_temperature": 0,
  "smoke_test": false,
  "timing": {
    "total_wall_clock_s": 1020.4,
    "avg_answer_latency_s": 2.94,
    "avg_judge_latency_s": 1.88,
    "p95_answer_latency_s": 4.32,
    "p95_judge_latency_s": 2.87
  },
  "j_score": 86.2,
  "total_correct": 1327,
  "total_questions": 1540,
  "num_judge_runs": 3,
  "by_category": {
    "single_hop": {
      "correct": 245,
      "total": 282,
      "accuracy": 86.9
    },
    "multi_hop": {
      "correct": 271,
      "total": 321,
      "accuracy": 84.4
    },
    "temporal": {
      "correct": 76,
      "total": 96,
      "accuracy": 79.2
    },
    "open_domain": {
      "correct": 735,
      "total": 841,
      "accuracy": 87.4
    }
  },
  "details": [
    {
      "question": "When did Caroline go to the LGBTQ support group?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "7 May 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the message where Caroline mentions going to the LGBTQ support group.  \n- Result 1 [2023-05-08]: Caroline says, \"I went to a LGBTQ support group yesterday,\" which would be approximately May 7, 2023.\n\nStep 2: Confirm no other earlier or later messages contradict or specify a different date.  \n- No other messages specify a different date for the support group visit.\n\nFinal answer: Caroline went to the LGBTQ support group on May 7, 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.44,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.31
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Melanie paint a sunrise?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": 2022,
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Melanie painting a sunrise.  \n- Result 1: Melanie to Caroline on 2023-05-08 says, \"Yeah, I painted that lake sunrise last year (approximately May 08, 2022)! It's special to me.\"\n\nStep 2: Confirm no other conflicting or additional dates about Melanie painting a sunrise.  \n- No other results mention Melanie painting a sunrise with a different date.\n\nFinal answer: Melanie painted a sunrise around May 8, 2022.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.98,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.77
    },
    {
      "question": "What fields would Caroline be likely to pursue in her educaton?",
      "category": 3,
      "gold_answer": "Psychology, counseling certification",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for any direct mentions of Caroline's education or career interests.\n\n- Result 1 (2023-05-08): Caroline says she will continue her education and check out career options.\n- Result 83 (2023-06-27): Caroline says she has been looking into counseling and mental health as a career, wanting to help people who have gone through similar experiences.\n\nStep 2: Check for any other career-related hints.\n\n- Result 23 (2023-05-08): Melanie suggests Caroline would be a great counselor due to her empathy and understanding.\n- Result 28 (2023-07-12): Melanie acknowledges Caroline's drive to help and asks about her plan to pitch in, implying a helping profession.\n- Result 46 and 72 (2023-05-25): Caroline is researching adoption agencies, indicating interest in family and child welfare.\n- Result 31 and 86 (2023-07-17 and 2023-",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.79,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.72
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Caroline research?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Adoption agencies",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for mentions of Caroline researching something in the context.\n\nStep 2: In Result 27 (2023-05-25), Caroline to Melanie says: \"Researching adoption agencies \u2014 it's been a dream to have a family and give a loving home to kids who need it.\"\n\nStep 3: This is the only direct mention of Caroline researching something.\n\nFinal answer: Caroline researched adoption agencies to help her pursue her dream of having a family and giving a loving home to kids in need.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.6,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.38
    },
    {
      "question": "What is Caroline's identity?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Transgender woman",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for direct mentions of Caroline's identity in the conversation excerpts.\n\n- Result 40 (2023-10-13): Caroline says, \"Yeah, I drew it. It stands for freedom and being real. It's like a nudge to always stay true to myself and embrace my womanhood.\"\n- Result 64 (2023-10-13): Caroline describes attending a transgender poetry reading and feeling empowered by it.\n- Result 74 (2023-07-06): Caroline mentions having a great support system that helped her accept and grow into her true self and that they were instrumental in her transition.\n- Result 99 (2023-08-23): Caroline says painting helps her explore her identity and be true to herself.\n- Result 46 (2023-05-25): Caroline chose an adoption agency that helps LGBTQ+ folks.\n- Result 53 (2023-08-28): Caroline talks about her struggles and sharing her story to support others",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 4.64,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.27
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Melanie run a charity race?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "The sunday before 25 May 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify any mention of Melanie running a charity race.  \n- Result 2 [2023-05-25]: Melanie says she ran a charity race for mental health last Saturday.  \n- Result 1 [2023-05-25]: Caroline responds to Melanie's charity race mention on the same day.  \n\nStep 2: Determine the date of the charity race.  \n- The message from Melanie is dated 2023-05-25 and she says \"last Saturday.\"  \n- The Saturday before 2023-05-25 (Thursday) is 2023-05-20.  \n\nFinal answer:  \nMelanie ran the charity race on Saturday, May 20, 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.48,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.8
    },
    {
      "question": "When is Melanie planning on going camping?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "June 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of camping plans by Melanie.\n\n- In Result 2 (2023-05-25), Melanie says: \"We're thinking about going camping next month.\" Since this is late May, \"next month\" would be June 2023.\n\nStep 2: Check if the camping actually happened around that time.\n\n- Result 3 (2023-06-27) Melanie says: \"I just took my fam camping in the mountains last week (approximately June 20, 2023).\"\n\nStep 3: Look for any other mentions of planned camping trips.\n\n- Result 16 (2023-08-17) Melanie says: \"Wanna do a family outing this summer?\" which could imply more plans but no specific camping date.\n\n- Result 22 (2023-09-13) Melanie says: \"We went camping with the kids a few weeks ago,\" indicating a camping trip in late August or early September.\n\nStep 4: Summar",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 4.96,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.45
    },
    {
      "question": "What is Caroline's relationship status?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Single",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for any direct mentions of Caroline's relationship status in the excerpts.\n\nStep 2: In the provided context, there is no explicit statement from Caroline or Melanie about Caroline being married, engaged, or in a specific relationship.\n\nStep 3: The conversations focus more on Caroline's adoption journey, her transition, support system, and advocacy, but no direct mention of a partner or relationship status.\n\nStep 4: Melanie mentions marrying her partner in Result 7, but that is about Melanie, not Caroline.\n\nStep 5: Caroline talks about support from friends and family but no mention of a partner.\n\nFinal answer: Not enough information to determine Caroline's relationship status.",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.11,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.22
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Caroline give a speech at a school?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "The week before 9 June 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for mentions of Caroline giving a speech or talking at a school event.\n\nStep 2: Result 87 [2023-06-09T19:55:00] Caroline to Melanie says: \"I wanted to tell you about my school event last week (approximately June 02, 2023). It was awesome! I talked about my transgender journey and encouraged students to get involved in the LGBTQ community.\"\n\nStep 3: This clearly states Caroline gave a speech at a school event around June 2, 2023.\n\nFinal answer: Caroline gave a speech at a school event around June 2, 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.0,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.4
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Caroline meet up with her friends, family, and mentors?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "The week before 9 June 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for mentions of Caroline meeting up with friends, family, and mentors.\n\nStep 2: Result 49 [2023-06-09T20:00:00] Caroline to Melanie says: \"Thanks, Mel! My friends, family and mentors are my rocks \u2013 they motivate me and give me the strength to push on. Here's a pic from when we met up last week (approximately June 02, 2023)!\"\n\nStep 3: This clearly states Caroline met up with her friends, family, and mentors around June 2, 2023.\n\nFinal answer: Caroline met up with her friends, family, and mentors around June 2, 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.94,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.64
    },
    {
      "question": "How long has Caroline had her current group of friends for?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "4 years",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Caroline's group of friends or support system.\n\n- Result 76 (2023-06-09): Caroline says her friends, family, and mentors are her rocks and shared a pic from a meetup around June 2, 2023.\n- Result 27 (2023-07-06): Caroline says she is lucky to have a great support system around her, which has helped her transition.\n- Result 50 (2023-07-06): Melanie acknowledges Caroline has support.\n- Result 57 (2023-07-06): Melanie comments on Caroline's friends and family helping with her transition.\n- Result 28 (2023-05-08): Caroline says the support group has made her feel accepted and given her courage.\n- Result 77 (2023-05-25): Caroline chose a group that helps LGBTQ+ folks with adoption.\n- Result 14 (2023-07-06): Caroline appreciates friends and family helping",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.92,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.41
    },
    {
      "question": "Where did Caroline move from 4 years ago?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Sweden",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Review all excerpts for any mention of Caroline's move or origin.\n\nStep 2: Several messages mention Caroline's transition and support system (e.g., Results 72, 93), but none specify where she moved from.\n\nStep 3: No direct or indirect reference to Caroline's previous location or origin is found in the context.\n\nFinal answer: Not enough information.",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.51,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.23
    },
    {
      "question": "How long ago was Caroline's 18th birthday?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "10 years ago",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant excerpt mentioning Caroline's 18th birthday.  \n- Result 38 [2023-06-27]: Caroline to Melanie: \"I've got some other stuff with sentimental value, like my hand-painted bowl. A friend made it for my 18th birthday ten years ago.\"\n\nStep 2: The message date is June 27, 2023, and Caroline says the bowl was made for her 18th birthday \"ten years ago.\"\n\nStep 3: Calculate the year of Caroline's 18th birthday: 2023 - 10 = 2013.\n\nStep 4: Since the message is in 2023 and the birthday was 10 years ago, Caroline's 18th birthday was 10 years before June 2023.\n\nFinal answer: Caroline's 18th birthday was 10 years ago from June 2023, around 2013.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 4.73,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.54
    },
    {
      "question": "What career path has Caroline decided to persue?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "counseling or mental health for Transgender people",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for any mentions of Caroline's career plans or aspirations in the context.\n\nStep 2: In Result 4 (2023-05-08), Caroline says: \"Gonna continue my edu and check out career options, which is pretty exciting!\"\n\nStep 3: In Result 76 (2023-06-27), Caroline says: \"Lately, I've been looking into counseling and mental health as a career. I want to help people who have gone through the same things as me.\"\n\nStep 4: Melanie responds in Result 77 (2023-07-12) encouraging Caroline about her desire to help others with mental health.\n\nStep 5: No other career paths are mentioned for Caroline.\n\nFinal answer: Caroline has decided to pursue a career in counseling and mental health.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.75,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.5
    },
    {
      "question": "Would Caroline still want to pursue counseling as a career if she hadn't received support growing up?",
      "category": 3,
      "gold_answer": "Likely no",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Caroline repeatedly mentions that the support she received was crucial to her own mental health journey and inspired her to pursue counseling and mental health work (Results 1, 2, 10, 17, 43).\n\nStep 2: She says the support made her realize the importance of having someone to talk to and helped her find self-acceptance (Results 1, 8, 14, 24, 43, 59).\n\nStep 3: Caroline\u2019s motivation to help others comes directly from her own experience of receiving support and how it positively impacted her life (Results 1, 2, 10, 17, 24, 43).\n\nStep 4: There is no indication that she would have pursued counseling without that support; rather, the support was a key factor in her decision.\n\nFinal answer: No, Caroline\u2019s desire to pursue counseling as a career is directly tied to the support she received growing up, so without that support,",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.58,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.37
    },
    {
      "question": "What activities does Melanie partake in?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "pottery, camping, painting, swimming",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of activities Melanie does in the conversation excerpts.\n\n- Pottery: Melanie signed up for a pottery class around July 2, 2023 (Result 33), enjoys pottery for creativity and calmness (Result 76), and has made pottery creations (Result 57).\n- Painting: Melanie mentions painting as a calming and satisfying activity and has shared paintings (Results 57, 88).\n- Family camping trips: Melanie describes family camping trips with roasting marshmallows, telling stories, hiking, and nature exploration (Results 22, 48, 80).\n- Running: Melanie mentions running as a way to refresh and stay present (Result 81).\n- Playing violin: Melanie plays violin (Result 81).\n- Hiking and exploring forests/mountains: Melanie enjoys hiking and exploring nature with family (Results 75, 48).\n- Attending music shows: Melanie went to a music show called \"Summer Sounds\" (Results 26, 27).\n",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.95,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.38
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Melanie sign up for a pottery class?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "2 July 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about Melanie signing up for pottery class.  \n- Result 6 [2023-07-03]: Melanie says she signed up for a pottery class \"yesterday,\" which would be approximately July 2, 2023.  \n- Result 2 and 28 [2023-07-03]: Melanie talks about pottery and shows a bowl she made, consistent with having started recently.\n\nStep 2: Confirm no other earlier mention of signing up for pottery class.  \n- No earlier messages mention signing up before July 2, 2023.\n\nFinal answer: Melanie signed up for a pottery class around July 2, 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.96,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.43
    },
    {
      "question": "When is Caroline going to the transgender conference?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "July 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of the transgender conference in the context.\n\n- Result 1 (2023-07-03): Caroline says, \"I'm going to a transgender conference this month.\"\n- Result 7 (2023-07-12): Caroline says, \"I went to an LGBTQ conference two days ago,\" indicating she attended the conference around July 10, 2023.\n\nStep 2: From Result 1, \"this month\" refers to July 2023 (message dated July 3, 2023).\n\nStep 3: From Result 7, Caroline confirms she attended the conference two days before July 12, 2023, which is approximately July 10, 2023.\n\nFinal answer: Caroline attended the transgender conference around July 10, 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.02,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.44
    },
    {
      "question": "Where has Melanie camped?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "beach, mountains, forest",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of camping locations by Melanie.\n\n- Result 15 (2023-06-27): Melanie mentions camping in the mountains last week (around June 20, 2023).\n- Result 21 (2023-07-15): Melanie says they went on another camping trip in the forest.\n- Result 48 (2023-07-06): Melanie shares a pic of family camping at the beach.\n- Result 39 and 43 (2023-07-20): Melanie talks about a recent beach trip with the kids.\n- Result 99 (2023-09-13): Melanie mentions camping with the kids a few weeks ago, exploring the forest and hiking.\n\nStep 2: Summarize the locations mentioned.\n\nMelanie has camped in the mountains, the forest, and at the beach.\n\nFinal answer:  \nMelanie has camped in the mountains, the forest, and at the beach.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.54,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.66
    },
    {
      "question": "What do Melanie's kids like?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "dinosaurs, nature",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Melanie's kids and their interests or activities.\n\n- Result 32: Kids loved pottery, excited to get their hands dirty and make something with clay.\n- Result 34: The 2 younger kids love nature; they enjoyed exploring nature, roasting marshmallows, hiking.\n- Result 20 & 70: Kids had a blast at the beach; they enjoy beach trips, though only once or twice a year.\n- Result 90: Kids had fun exploring and playing at the park.\n- Result 27: Kids were scared but tough and resilient after an accident involving their brother.\n- Result 39: Luna and Oliver are pets (not kids), but shows Melanie's household includes playful pets.\n- Result 41 & 51: Family outings and camping trips are special and enjoyed by the kids.\n- Result 32 & 53: Kids enjoy creative projects like pottery and other arts.\n\nStep 2: Summarize the kids' likes based on",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.45,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.41
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Melanie go to the museum?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "5 July 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify any mention of Melanie going to the museum.  \n- Result 27 [2023-07-06T20:19:30] Melanie to Caroline: \"Yesterday (approximately July 05, 2023) I took the kids to the museum - it was so cool spending time with them and seeing their eyes light up!\"\n\nStep 2: Confirm the date of the message to understand the exact day of the museum visit.  \n- The message is dated July 6, 2023, and Melanie says \"Yesterday,\" which means the museum visit was on July 5, 2023.\n\nFinal answer:  \nMelanie went to the museum on July 5, 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.91,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.3
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Caroline have a picnic?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "The week before 6 July 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for mentions of Caroline having a picnic in the context.\n\nStep 2: In Result 8 [2023-07-06T20:23:00], Caroline to Melanie says: \"We even had a picnic last week (approximately June 29, 2023)!\"\n\nStep 3: The message is dated July 6, 2023, so \"last week\" refers to the week before July 6, which aligns with June 29, 2023.\n\nFinal answer:  \nCaroline had a picnic around June 29, 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.41,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.8
    },
    {
      "question": "Would Caroline likely have Dr. Seuss books on her bookshelf?",
      "category": 3,
      "gold_answer": "Yes, since she collects classic children's books",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Caroline mentions in [Result 10] (2023-07-06) that she is creating a library for when she has kids, including kids' books, classics, stories from different cultures, and educational books ([Result 18]).\n\nStep 2: Melanie asks Caroline about favorite childhood books and mentions \"Charlotte's Web\" as a favorite from her own childhood ([Results 2, 3]).\n\nStep 3: Caroline does not specifically mention Dr. Seuss books anywhere in the excerpts.\n\nStep 4: However, given Caroline's interest in kids' books, classics, and educational stories, it is likely she would include well-known children's authors like Dr. Seuss in her library.\n\nStep 5: There is no direct confirmation, but the context suggests it is probable.\n\nFinal answer: While Caroline does not explicitly mention Dr. Seuss books, it is likely she would have them on her bookshelf given her focus on children's classics and educational books.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.85,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.91
    },
    {
      "question": "What books has Melanie read?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "\"Nothing is Impossible\", \"Charlotte's Web\"",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of books Melanie has read.\n\n- Result 4: Melanie says she loved reading \"Charlotte's Web\" as a kid.\n- Result 37: Melanie mentions a book she read last year (around July 12, 2022) that reminds her to always pursue her dreams, inspired by Caroline's experience.\n- Result 11: Melanie says she has been reading a book Caroline recommended a while ago to keep busy.\n- Result 35: Melanie agrees with Caroline about lessons from a book about self-acceptance and finding support, also mentioning pets for joy and comfort.\n- Result 21: Caroline mentions loving \"Becoming Nicole\" by Amy Ellis Nutt, a book about a trans girl and her family, which Caroline highly recommends. Melanie may have read this since Caroline recommended it and Melanie refers to a book Caroline recommended.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.\n\nMelanie has read \"Charlotte's Web\" from childhood. More recently, she has",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.12,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.56
    },
    {
      "question": "What does Melanie do to destress?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Running, pottery",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for mentions of Melanie's activities related to destressing or mental health.\n\nStep 2: In Result 32 (2023-07-12), Melanie says to Caroline: \"I've been running farther to de-stress, which has been great for my headspace.\"\n\nStep 3: In Result 23 (2023-10-13), Caroline mentions pottery as a way to relax and Melanie confirms in Result 96 (2023-09-13) that painting and pottery are her muses and calming activities.\n\nStep 4: In Result 42 (2023-10-20), Melanie describes peaceful family time in nature as refreshing her soul.\n\nStep 5: These indicate Melanie destresses by running, painting, pottery, and spending peaceful time in nature with family.\n\nFinal answer: Melanie destresses by running, painting, doing pottery, and spending peaceful time in nature with her family.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.95,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.78
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Caroline go to the LGBTQ conference?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "10 July 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Caroline attending an LGBTQ conference.  \n- Result 2 (2023-07-12): Caroline says she went to an LGBTQ conference two days ago.  \n- Result 10 (2023-07-03): Caroline mentions she is going to a transgender conference \"this month\" (July 2023), so this is a future event relative to July 3.  \n\nStep 2: Focus on Result 2 for the actual attendance date since it says \"two days ago\" from July 12, 2023.  \n- Two days before July 12, 2023 is July 10, 2023.  \n\nStep 3: Confirm no other conflicting dates or mentions.  \n- No other specific dates for the LGBTQ conference attendance are given.  \n\nFinal answer: Caroline went to the LGBTQ conference on July 10, 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.56,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.13
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Melanie read the book \"nothing is impossible\"?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": 2022,
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for any mention of Melanie reading a book called \"nothing is impossible\" or similar.\n\nStep 2: Scan the context for any references to books Melanie read or mentioned.\n\nStep 3: In Result 75 (dated 2023-07-12), Melanie says: \"This book I read last year (approximately July 12, 2022) reminds me to always pursue my dreams, just like you are doing!\ud83c\udf1f\" This is the only explicit mention of Melanie reading a book with a motivational theme.\n\nStep 4: No other direct mention of the book title \"nothing is impossible\" is found, but the phrase \"reminds me to always pursue my dreams\" aligns with the theme of \"nothing is impossible.\"\n\nStep 5: Therefore, Melanie read the book around July 12, 2022 (last year from the 2023-07-12 message).\n\nFinal answer: Melanie read the book \"nothing is impossible\" around July ",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 4.0,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.24
    },
    {
      "question": "Would Caroline pursue writing as a career option?",
      "category": 3,
      "gold_answer": "LIkely no; though she likes reading, she wants to be a counselor",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Review Caroline's stated career interests.  \n- In Result 53 (2023-06-27), Caroline says she has been looking into counseling and mental health as a career to help people with similar experiences.  \n- In Result 91 (2023-05-08), Caroline says she is keen on counseling or working in mental health to support those with similar issues.  \n- In Result 5 (2023-05-08), Caroline mentions continuing education and checking out career options, which is exciting.  \n- There is no mention anywhere in the excerpts of Caroline expressing interest in writing as a career.\n\nStep 2: Check if writing is mentioned as a career option or interest.  \n- The only related mention is a transgender poetry reading (Result 39, 2023-10-13), which Caroline attended and found empowering, but she does not say she wants to pursue writing professionally.  \n- Melanie encourages Caroline's empathy and counseling potential (Result 13",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.74,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.51
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Caroline go to the adoption meeting?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "The friday before 15 July 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Caroline attending adoption-related meetings or events.\n\n- Result 12 [2023-07-15]: Caroline says, \"Last Friday I went to a council meeting for adoption.\"\n- Result 25 [2023-08-23]: Caroline says she applied to adoption agencies \"this week,\" which is after the July meeting.\n- Result 15 [2023-10-13]: Caroline mentions contacting her mentor for adoption advice, indicating ongoing steps after the July meeting.\n\nStep 2: Determine the date of \"last Friday\" relative to the message date in Result 12.\n\n- Result 12 is dated 2023-07-15 (Saturday).\n- The \"last Friday\" before 2023-07-15 is 2023-07-14.\n\nFinal answer: Caroline went to the adoption council meeting on Friday, July 14, 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.34,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.34
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Melanie go to the pottery workshop?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "The Friday before 15 July 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Melanie attending a pottery workshop.\n\n- Result 5 [2023-07-15]: Melanie says, \"Last Fri I finally took my kids to a pottery workshop.\"\n- Result 11 [2023-07-15]: Melanie mentions the kids loved the workshop and made pottery.\n- Result 29 [2023-06-27]: Caroline responds positively to family moments but no workshop mention.\n- Result 81 [2023-07-03]: Melanie says she made a bowl in her pottery class, but no workshop mention.\n\nStep 2: Determine the date of \"Last Fri\" mentioned in Result 5.\n\n- Result 5 is dated 2023-07-15 (Saturday).\n- \"Last Fri\" would be the day before, 2023-07-14.\n\nStep 3: Confirm no other pottery workshop dates are mentioned.\n\n- No other specific workshop dates found.\n\nFinal answer: Melanie went to the pottery workshop on Friday",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.19,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.21
    },
    {
      "question": "Would Melanie be considered a member of the LGBTQ community?",
      "category": 3,
      "gold_answer": "Likely no, she does not refer to herself as part of it",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Review the context for any direct statements or implications about Melanie's identity.\n\n- Most messages are from Caroline to Melanie, discussing Caroline's experiences and journey as a transgender woman.\n- Melanie consistently supports Caroline and the LGBTQ community.\n- Melanie talks about her family, kids, and outings, but there is no direct mention of Melanie identifying as LGBTQ.\n- Melanie encourages Caroline and praises her advocacy and art but does not share personal LGBTQ experiences or identity.\n- No explicit statement or hint that Melanie is LGBTQ or transgender.\n\nStep 2: Consider indirect clues.\n\n- Melanie is very supportive and involved in conversations about LGBTQ issues.\n- Melanie's family and kids are mentioned, but no indication that Melanie herself is LGBTQ.\n- Melanie's tone and comments suggest allyship rather than personal identification.\n\nStep 3: Conclusion.\n\nThere is no explicit or implicit evidence in the conversation excerpts that Melanie identifies as a member of the LGBTQ community. She appears as a strong ally and supporter.\n\nFinal answer:  \nNo",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.35,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.29
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Melanie go camping in June?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "The week before 27 June 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of camping in June.\n- Result 10 (2023-06-27): Melanie says she took her family camping in the mountains last week, which would be around June 20, 2023.\n- Result 65 (2023-06-27): Caroline asks how the camping trip was, confirming it happened recently.\n- Result 2 (2023-06-27): Melanie describes the camping trip with hiking and marshmallows, consistent with the June trip.\n\nStep 2: Confirm the approximate date.\n- Result 10 explicitly states \"last week\" from June 27, 2023, so the camping trip was around June 20, 2023.\n\nFinal answer:  \nMelanie went camping in the mountains around June 20, 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.49,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.36
    },
    {
      "question": "What LGBTQ+ events has Caroline participated in?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Pride parade, school speech, support group",
      "generated_answer": "Step-by-step review of Caroline's LGBTQ+ event participation from the context:\n\n1. May 7, 2023: Attended an LGBTQ support group (Result 5, 15, 77).\n2. June 2, 2023: Spoke at a school event about her transgender journey (Result 23, 78).\n3. June 17, 2023 (approx.): Attended an LGBT pride event (Result 6, 10).\n4. June 26, 2023 (approx.): Went to an LGBTQ+ pride parade (Result 10).\n5. June 29, 2023 (approx.): Had a picnic with friends/family (Result 63).\n6. July 2023: Joined a mentorship program for LGBTQ youth (Result 31, 6).\n7. July 2023: Joined a new LGBTQ activist group called \"Connected LGBTQ Activists\" (Result 9, 17, 21, 49).\n",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.68,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.3
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Caroline go to a pride parade during the summer?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "The week before 3 July 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Caroline attending pride parades in summer (June-August).\n\n- Result 4 (2023-07-03): Caroline says she went to a pride parade last week, approximately June 26, 2023.\n- Result 16 (2023-07-17): Caroline mentions attending an LGBT pride event last month, approximately June 17, 2023.\n- Result 3 (2023-07-20): Caroline says last weekend the city held a pride parade, but she missed it.\n- Result 5 (2023-08-14): Caroline says she went to a pride parade last Friday (which would be August 11, 2023).\n- Result 10 (2023-08-17): Caroline refers to a Pride fest last year (August 17, 2022), not summer 2023.\n- Result 7 and 19 (2023-07-15): Caroline refers to a pride parade",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.12,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.63
    },
    {
      "question": "What events has Caroline participated in to help children?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Mentoring program, school speech",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Caroline participating in events related to helping children.\n\n- Result 12 (2023-08-28): Caroline volunteered at an LGBTQ+ youth center, guiding and supporting young people, sharing her story to help them feel less alone.\n- Result 67 (2023-08-28): Caroline is continuing to volunteer at the youth center, making strong community connections and supporting each other.\n- Result 55 (2023-08-28): Caroline is organizing a talent show for the kids next month to showcase their talents and build pride.\n- Result 30 (2023-07-17): Caroline is mentoring young folks, supporting them and witnessing their resilience.\n- Result 36 & 38 (2023-05-25): Caroline is researching adoption agencies to create a family for kids in need.\n- Result 17 & 41 (2023-05-25): Caroline is taking in kids in need, preparing to be a single parent.\n-",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.84,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.6
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Melanie go camping in July?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "two weekends before 17 July 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of camping trips in July.\n\n- Result 11 [2023-07-20]: Melanie mentions going to the beach recently (around July 13, 2023), but this is a beach trip, not camping.\n- Result 25 [2023-07-15]: Melanie says her family went on another camping trip in the forest.\n- Result 72 [2023-07-17]: Melanie says she had a quiet weekend after camping with her family two weekends ago. Counting back from July 17, two weekends ago would be around July 1-2.\n- Result 45 [2023-07-06]: Melanie shares a pic of family camping at the beach, which is a camping trip but at the beach, not forest.\n- Result 1 and 3 [2023-07-20]: Melanie and Caroline discuss family camping trips as a summer tradition but no specific July date.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the timing.\n\n",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.74,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.32
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Caroline join a mentorship program?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "The weekend before 17 July 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Caroline joining a mentorship program.  \n- Result 27 [2023-07-17]: Caroline says, \"Last weekend I joined a mentorship program for LGBTQ youth.\"  \n- The message date is July 17, 2023, so \"last weekend\" would be around July 8-9, 2023.\n\nStep 2: Confirm no other earlier or later mentions contradict this.  \n- No other messages mention an earlier date for joining a mentorship program.\n\nFinal answer: Caroline joined a mentorship program for LGBTQ youth around the weekend of July 8-9, 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.57,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.68
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Melanie paint recently?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "sunset",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Melanie's recent paintings in the context.\n\n- Result 2 (2023-07-15): Melanie mentions painting nature-inspired works together with Caroline, showing their latest work from the previous weekend.\n- Result 48 (2023-08-25): Melanie says she painted landscapes and still life, especially nature, and shares a painting from around August 18, 2023.\n- Result 94 (2023-08-23): Melanie shares a horse painting done around August 16, 2023.\n- Result 50 (2023-10-13): Melanie shares a sunset-inspired painting from about October 6, 2023.\n- Result 51 (2023-10-13): Melanie mentions an abstract painting done recently.\n- Result 18 (2023-08-17): Melanie talks about making art to catch the eye and make people smile, expressing feelings in each stroke.\n- Result 37 (2023-07",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.85,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.43
    },
    {
      "question": "What activities has Melanie done with her family?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Pottery, painting, camping, museum, swimming, hiking",
      "generated_answer": "Step-by-step analysis of activities Melanie has done with her family based on the conversation excerpts:\n\n1. Camping trips: Melanie mentioned family camping trips where they roast marshmallows, tell stories around the campfire, and enjoy each other's company (Results 22, 31, 64, 87).\n\n2. Exploring nature and hiking: Melanie described exploring nature, roasting marshmallows around a campfire, and going on hikes with her family (Results 16, 31, 87).\n\n3. Playing games and eating good food together (Result 4).\n\n4. Beach trips: Melanie mentioned going to the beach once or twice a year, enjoying the time together and relaxing (Results 23, 41).\n\n5. Celebrating special occasions: Melanie celebrated her daughter's birthday with a concert and music (Result 93).\n\n6. Family outings and spending quality time together (Results 11, 38).\n\n7. Watching kids take milestones like first steps (Result 64).\n\nFinal answer",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.33,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.4
    },
    {
      "question": "In what ways is Caroline participating in the LGBTQ community?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Joining activist group, going to pride parades, participating in an art show, mentoring program",
      "generated_answer": "Step-by-step analysis of Caroline's participation in the LGBTQ community based on the context:\n\n1. **Support Groups and Mentorship:**\n   - Caroline attended LGBTQ support groups (Result 3, May 7, 2023).\n   - She mentors a transgender teen, helping build confidence and positive strategies (Result 7, June 17, 2023).\n   - She joined a mentorship program for LGBTQ youth (Result 25, July 17, 2023).\n\n2. **Activism and Advocacy:**\n   - She joined an LGBTQ activist group called \"Connected LGBTQ Activists\" (Result 2, July 20, 2023; Result 10).\n   - She participates in regular meetings, plans events and campaigns to support LGBTQ rights (Result 2).\n   - She gave a talk at a school event about her transgender journey to encourage involvement in the LGBTQ community (Result 53, June 2, 2023).\n   - She spoke publicly about her",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.24,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.66
    },
    {
      "question": "How many times has Melanie gone to the beach in 2023?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": 2,
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of beach visits by Melanie in 2023.\n\n- Result 1 (2023-07-20): Melanie says they went to the beach recently, approximately July 13, 2023.\n- Result 2 (2023-07-20): Melanie says they don't go often, usually only once or twice a year.\n- Result 47 (2023-07-06): Melanie shares a pic of family camping at the beach, implying a beach visit around early July.\n- No other explicit mentions of beach visits by Melanie in 2023.\n\nStep 2: Check if the camping at the beach (Result 47) is a separate visit from the July 13 beach trip.\n\n- Result 47 is dated July 6, 2023, and mentions a family camping at the beach.\n- Result 1 mentions a beach trip around July 13, 2023.\n- These are about a week apart, so likely two separate visits",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.78,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.62
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Caroline join a new activist group?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "The Tuesday before 20 July 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify any mention of Caroline joining a new activist group.  \n- Result 49 [2023-07-20T20:57:00] Caroline to Melanie: \"I just joined a new LGBTQ activist group last Tues.\"  \n- The message is dated July 20, 2023, so \"last Tues\" would be July 18, 2023.\n\nStep 2: Confirm no other conflicting or additional information about joining a new group.  \n- Result 11 [2023-07-20T20:58:00] Caroline to Melanie mentions the group \"Connected LGBTQ Activists,\" which aligns with the timing.  \n- No other dates or mentions contradict this.\n\nFinal answer:  \nCaroline joined a new LGBTQ activist group on Tuesday, July 18, 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 4.08,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.07
    },
    {
      "question": "Would Melanie be more interested in going to a national park or a theme park?",
      "category": 3,
      "gold_answer": "National park; she likes the outdoors",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for mentions of Melanie's interests in outdoor activities or parks.\n\n- Result 2 (2023-07-15): Melanie says they enjoy hiking in the mountains and exploring forests, which are typical national park activities.\n- Result 10 (2023-07-20): Melanie talks about family camping trips roasting marshmallows and telling stories around the campfire, again consistent with national park or natural settings.\n- Result 18 (2023-06-27): Melanie describes a camping trip in the mountains with hiking and enjoying nature.\n- Result 19 (2023-09-13): Melanie mentions going camping with the kids, exploring the forest and hiking.\n- Result 7 (2023-08-28): Melanie took her kids to a park to explore and play, enjoying the outdoors.\n- Result 24 (2023-07-20): Melanie mentions beach trips, which are natural outdoor settings.\n- Result 48 (2023-08-",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.91,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.91
    },
    {
      "question": "What kind of art does Caroline make?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "abstract art",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Caroline's art types:\n- [Result 25] Caroline mentions a recent self-portrait painting.\n- [Result 35] Caroline shows a piece she made (likely painting).\n- [Result 40] Caroline shares a painting for an art show.\n- [Result 48] Caroline has a hand-painted bowl with sentimental value.\n- [Result 60] Caroline talks about representing inclusivity and diversity in her art and shows a recent painting.\n- [Result 63] Caroline says her art expresses her trans experience.\n- [Result 74] Caroline made a painting symbolizing her path as a trans woman with red and blue colors.\n- [Result 86] Caroline describes a painting called \"Embracing Identity\" about self-acceptance.\n- [Result 81] Caroline mentions being busy painting and shows a recent piece.\n- [Result 49] Caroline has been creating art since about age 17, finding it empowering and cathartic",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.65,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.52
    },
    {
      "question": "When is Melanie's daughter's birthday?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "13 August",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify any mention of Melanie's daughter's birthday in the context.\n\n- Result 3 [2023-08-14]: Melanie to Caroline says, \"Last night was amazing! We celebrated my daughter's birthday with a concert surrounded by music, joy and the warm summer breeze.\"\n\nStep 2: Determine the date of the message and the date of the birthday celebration.\n\n- The message is dated 2023-08-14 and Melanie says \"Last night,\" so the birthday celebration was on 2023-08-13.\n\nStep 3: Confirm no other conflicting information about the birthday date.\n\n- No other messages mention a different date for the daughter's birthday.\n\nFinal answer: Melanie's daughter's birthday is on August 13.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.25,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.24
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Caroline attend a pride parade in August?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "The Friday before 14 August 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Caroline attending pride parades in August.\n\n- Result 5 [2023-08-14]: Caroline says she went to a pride parade \"last Friday,\" which would be August 11, 2023.\n- Result 3 [2023-08-25]: Caroline mentions seeing a rainbow sidewalk for Pride Month but does not say she attended a parade in August.\n- Result 9 [2023-08-17]: Caroline refers to Pride fest last year (August 2022), not this year.\n- No other direct mentions of attending a pride parade in August.\n\nStep 2: Confirm the date of the pride parade Caroline attended in August.\n\n- Since Result 5 is dated August 14, 2023, and Caroline says \"last Friday,\" the parade was on August 11, 2023.\n\nFinal answer: Caroline attended a pride parade on Friday, August 11, 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.32,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.59
    },
    {
      "question": "Would Melanie be considered an ally to the transgender community?",
      "category": 3,
      "gold_answer": "Yes, she is supportive",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for evidence of Melanie's attitude and actions toward the transgender community.\n\n- Result 7 and 13 show Caroline thanking Melanie for her backing and support, and Melanie praising Caroline's courage and advocacy for the trans community.\n- Result 8 shows Melanie asking Caroline about her decision to transition and join the transgender community, indicating interest and support.\n- Result 24 and 36 show Melanie admiring Caroline's art that tells trans stories and wanting to see more.\n- Result 74 and 77 show Melanie agreeing with Caroline's passion for helping LGBTQ youth and being there for each other.\n- Result 66 and 67 show Melanie appreciating family and support, which aligns with being supportive.\n- Result 98 shows Melanie acknowledging the difficulty of changes Caroline faced and celebrating positive community moments.\n\nStep 2: Look for any negative or unsupportive remarks from Melanie.\n\n- There are no messages from Melanie that show negativity or rejection toward Caroline or the transgender community.\n\nStep 3: S",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.04,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.57
    },
    {
      "question": "Who supports Caroline when she has a negative experience?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Her mentors, family, and friends",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Caroline having negative experiences or struggles.  \n- Result 7 (2023-08-28): Caroline talks about her own struggles and feeling alone in the past.  \n- Result 54 (2023-10-20): Caroline mentions kids being resilient in tough situations, implying awareness of challenges.  \n- Result 84 (2023-06-09): Caroline acknowledges being blessed with loads of love and support throughout her journey.  \n- Result 70 (2023-07-06): Caroline appreciates friends and family helping with her transition.  \n- Result 11 (2023-07-06): Caroline says she is lucky to have a great support system around her.  \n- Result 4 (2023-10-22): Caroline appreciates support of those close to her.  \n- Result 59 (2023-09-13): Melanie notes Caroline has found people who uplift and accept her.  \n\nStep 2: Identify who provides support",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.49,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.51
    },
    {
      "question": "What types of pottery have Melanie and her kids made?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "bowls, cup",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of pottery made by Melanie and her kids.\n- Result 5 (2023-07-15): Melanie took her kids to a pottery workshop where they all made their own pots.\n- Result 7 (2023-07-15): The kids made a pottery piece with clay.\n- Result 1 and 10: Melanie mentions bowls and pottery creations.\n- Result 33 and 84: Melanie made a bowl in her pottery class.\n- Result 42 and 9: Melanie made a plate and a pottery project.\n\nStep 2: Types of pottery mentioned:\n- Bowls (Results 1, 4, 33, 84)\n- Pots (Result 5)\n- Plate (Result 42)\n- Cups (Result 6 mentions a cup made by kids)\n- General pottery projects (Results 9, 10, 17)\n\nStep 3: Confirm that the kids made pots and cups specifically (Result 5 and ",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.06,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.72
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Caroline and Melanie go to a pride fesetival together?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": 2022,
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of pride festivals or pride events involving both Caroline and Melanie.\n\n- Result 19 [2023-08-17]: Caroline says, \"We had a blast last year (approximately August 17, 2022) at the Pride fest.\"\n- Result 52 [2023-07-17]: Caroline mentions mentoring a transgender teen and attending an LGBT pride event last month (approximately June 17, 2023), but this seems to be Caroline alone.\n- Result 29 [2023-07-03]: Caroline says she went to an LGBTQ+ pride parade last week (approximately June 26, 2023), no mention of Melanie.\n- Result 3, 4, 5, 6, 18, 48 [2023-07-15]: Both Caroline and Melanie discuss a pride event or parade, with Caroline saying it was awesome and Melanie talking about marrying her partner and the day being full of love and joy. This",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.32,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.56
    },
    {
      "question": "What would Caroline's political leaning likely be?",
      "category": 3,
      "gold_answer": "Liberal",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Caroline is involved in LGBTQ+ advocacy and adoption support for LGBTQ+ folks (Results 25, 78, 79, 99).\n\nStep 2: Caroline values inclusivity, acceptance, and community support, as seen in her appreciation for supportive groups and events (Results 64, 70, 78, 79, 97).\n\nStep 3: Caroline is described as passionate about helping others, especially marginalized groups, and is engaged in activism and community organizing (Results 11, 20, 78, 99).\n\nStep 4: These values and activities typically align with progressive or left-leaning political views, which emphasize social justice, equality, and support for LGBTQ+ rights.\n\nFinal answer: Caroline's political leaning is likely progressive or left-leaning.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.29,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.49
    },
    {
      "question": "What has Melanie painted?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Horse, sunset, sunrise",
      "generated_answer": "Step-by-step reasoning:\n\n1. Melanie and Caroline have been painting together, often nature-inspired themes (Results 2, 4, 34).\n2. Melanie painted a lake sunrise last year (May 8, 2022) (Result 56).\n3. Melanie painted a horse recently (around August 16, 2023) (Results 36, 62, 75).\n4. Melanie painted a sunset-inspired abstract painting around October 6, 2023 (Results 7, 31, 58).\n5. Melanie enjoys painting landscapes and still life, especially nature (Result 50).\n6. Melanie also painted flowers, which were important in her wedding decor (Result 71).\n7. Melanie and her kids made pottery and paintings together (Results 21, 63).\n8. Melanie's paintings often carry emotional and calming themes, such as tranquility with blue streaks (Result 14).\n\nFinal concise answer:\n\nMelanie has painted nature-inspired works including",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.13,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.45
    },
    {
      "question": "What are Melanie's pets' names?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Oliver, Luna, Bailey",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Melanie's pets in the context.\n\n- Result 5 (2023-07-12): Melanie says they have a pup and a kitty.\n- Result 7 (2023-07-12): Melanie names the pets Luna and Oliver.\n- Result 25 (2023-08-23): Melanie mentions they got another cat named Bailey, and shows a pic of Oliver.\n- Result 86 (2023-08-23): Melanie talks about Oliver's funny behavior.\n\nStep 2: Summarize the pet names.\n\nMelanie has at least three pets: Luna, Oliver, and Bailey.\n\nStep 3: Confirm the types of pets.\n\n- Luna and Oliver are described as a dog and a cat (Result 5).\n- Bailey is another cat (Result 25).\n\nFinal answer:  \nMelanie's pets are named Luna (dog), Oliver (cat), and Bailey (cat).",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.73,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.44
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Caroline apply to adoption agencies?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "The week of 23 August 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify any direct mentions of Caroline applying to adoption agencies.  \n- Result 12 [2023-08-23T15:31:00] Caroline to Melanie: \"Guess what I did this week? I took the first step towards becoming a mom - I applied to adoption agencies!\"\n\nStep 2: Confirm the date of this message is August 23, 2023, so \"this week\" refers to the week of August 23, 2023.\n\nStep 3: No other earlier or later messages contradict or specify a different date for the application.\n\nFinal answer: Caroline applied to adoption agencies in the week of August 23, 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.97,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.16
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Caroline draw a self-portrait?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "The week before 23 August 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify any mention of Caroline drawing a self-portrait.  \n- Result 2 [2023-08-23]: Caroline to Melanie says: \"Here's a recent self-portrait I made last week (approximately August 16, 2023).\"\n\nStep 2: Confirm no other conflicting or additional dates about the self-portrait.  \n- No other results mention a different date for the self-portrait.\n\nFinal answer: Caroline drew a self-portrait around August 16, 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.77,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.29
    },
    {
      "question": "What subject have Caroline and Melanie both painted?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Sunsets",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify what Caroline has painted.\n- Caroline painted a piece conveying unity and strength after visiting an LGBTQ center (Results 4, 31, 33).\n- Caroline painted flowers and bright colorful bouquets (Results 13, 32, 62).\n- Caroline painted a sunset with vivid colors (Results 10, 11, 30, 93).\n- Caroline painted a self-portrait (Result 42).\n- Caroline painted a piece about her trans experience and identity (Results 26, 35, 37, 81).\n- Caroline painted a piece with red and blue representing smashing binary gender (Results 5, 37).\n- Caroline painted a bowl with patterns and colors (Results 56, 84).\n- Caroline painted nature scenes (implied by flowers and sunset).\n\nStep 2: Identify what Melanie has painted.\n- Melanie and her kids painted nature-inspired paintings, including flowers (Results 6, 7, 52).\n- Melanie painted",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.45,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.22
    },
    {
      "question": "What symbols are important to Caroline?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Rainbow flag, transgender symbol",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of symbols important to Caroline in the context.\n\n- Result 11 (2023-08-25): Caroline explains the rainbow flag mural symbolizes the courage and strength of the trans community, and the eagle symbolizes freedom and pride, representing her own resilience and that of others.\n\n- Result 76 (2023-06-27): Caroline mentions a necklace given by her grandmother from Sweden, symbolizing love, faith, and strength, and serving as a reminder of her roots and family support.\n\n- Result 70 (2023-10-13): Caroline says a drawing she made stands for freedom and being real, a nudge to stay true to herself and embrace her womanhood.\n\nStep 2: Summarize the key symbols and their meanings.\n\n- Rainbow flag mural: courage, strength, community support (trans community).\n\n- Eagle: freedom, pride, resilience.\n\n- Necklace: love, faith, strength, family roots.\n\n- Drawing: freedom, authenticity,",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.35,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.77
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Caroline encounter people on a hike and have a negative experience?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "The week before 25 August 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant excerpt about Caroline's negative experience on a hike.\n\n- Result 5 [2023-08-25]: Caroline to Melanie says she went hiking last week (around August 18, 2023) and got into a bad spot with some people.\n\n- Result 72 [2023-08-17]: Melanie acknowledges the bad hike experience Caroline had and offers support.\n\nStep 2: Confirm the date of the hike.\n\n- Caroline's message on August 25, 2023, says the hike was \"last week,\" which places the hike approximately on August 18, 2023.\n\nStep 3: Summarize.\n\nCaroline had the negative encounter with people on a hike around August 18, 2023.\n\nFinal answer:  \nCaroline had the negative experience with people on a hike around August 18, 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.95,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.08
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Melanie make a plate in pottery class?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "24 August 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Melanie making pottery items.\n- Result 2 (2023-08-25): Melanie says she made a piece in pottery class \"yesterday,\" which is approximately August 24, 2023.\n- Result 8 (2023-08-25): Caroline asks Melanie if she made a plate.\n- Result 26 (2023-07-03): Melanie confirms she made a bowl in her class.\n- Result 12 (2023-07-03): Melanie says she signed up for a pottery class \"yesterday,\" approximately July 2, 2023.\n\nStep 2: Focus on the plate specifically.\n- Result 8 (2023-08-25): Caroline asks if Melanie made the plate.\n- Result 2 (2023-08-25): Melanie confirms she made \"it\" in pottery class yesterday (August 24, 2023).\n\nStep 3: Confirm the date.\n- The message from Melanie",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.63,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.93
    },
    {
      "question": "Would Caroline be considered religious?",
      "category": 3,
      "gold_answer": "Somewhat, but not extremely religious",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for any direct mentions of religion or religious beliefs in the conversation excerpts.\n\nStep 2: In Result 37 (2023-08-25), Caroline mentions a painting made for a local church, which shows time changing lives and her journey as a transgender woman. This indicates some connection or at least interaction with a church community.\n\nStep 3: There is no explicit statement from Caroline about being religious or practicing a faith.\n\nStep 4: The mention of the church is related to art and personal journey, not necessarily a declaration of religious belief.\n\nStep 5: No other excerpts mention Caroline's religious beliefs or practices.\n\nFinal answer: Caroline is not explicitly described as religious, but she has some connection to a local church through her art. Therefore, it is unclear if she would be considered religious. \n\nConcise answer: Not enough information to determine if Caroline is religious, though she has created art for a local church.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.64,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.2
    },
    {
      "question": "What instruments does Melanie play?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "clarinet and violin",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Melanie playing instruments.\n- Result 8: Melanie says she plays clarinet, started young.\n- Result 12: Melanie mentions playing violin as part of her me-time.\n- No other instruments explicitly mentioned for Melanie.\n\nStep 2: Confirm no contradictions or additional instruments.\n- No other instruments attributed to Melanie in the context.\n\nFinal answer: Melanie plays the clarinet and the violin.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.65,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.25
    },
    {
      "question": "What musical artists/bands has Melanie seen?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Summer Sounds, Matt Patterson",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Melanie attending shows or concerts and any bands or artists named.\n\n- Result 5 (2023-08-28): Melanie mentions a picture from a show she went to, describing the fun and how music brings people together.\n- Result 6 (2023-08-28): Melanie mentions \"Summer Sounds\" as an awesome pop song that got everyone dancing and singing at the show.\n- Result 7 (2023-08-28): Caroline asks if Melanie saw that band, implying a specific band was at the show.\n- Result 12 (2023-08-28): Caroline asks what the band was.\n- No direct band name is given in these excerpts.\n\nStep 2: Check if any other specific artists or bands are mentioned as seen by Melanie.\n\n- Result 16 (2023-08-28): Melanie says she is a fan of classical composers Bach and Mozart, and modern artist Ed Sheeran's \"Perfect,\" but this",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.12,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.06
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Melanie go to the park?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "27 August 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Melanie going to the park.\n- Result 5 (2023-08-28): Melanie says she took her kids to a park \"yesterday,\" which is approximately August 27, 2023.\n- Result 4 (2023-09-13): Caroline refers to Melanie having a good time at the park, confirming the event happened before this date.\n\nStep 2: Confirm the date of the park visit.\n- Since Melanie's message on August 28 says \"yesterday,\" the park visit was on August 27, 2023.\n\nFinal answer:  \nMelanie went to the park on August 27, 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 8.18,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.3
    },
    {
      "question": "When is Caroline's youth center putting on a talent show?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "September 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of a talent show related to Caroline's youth center.\n- Result 1 (2023-08-28): Caroline says, \"We're putting together a talent show for the kids next month.\"\n- Result 6 (2023-08-25): Melanie says, \"Can't wait to see your show - the LGBTQ community needs more platforms like this!\"\n- Result 7 (2023-08-25): Caroline says, \"Gonna be a great night featuring LGBTQ artists and their awesome talents.\"\n- Result 56 (2023-08-25): Caroline says, \"I'm putting together an LGBTQ art show next month and I'm gonna show my paintings.\" (This is an art show, possibly related but distinct from the talent show.)\n\nStep 2: Determine the date of the messages about the talent show.\n- The earliest mention is on 2023-08-25 and 2023-08-28, both saying the show is \"next month",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.74,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.54
    },
    {
      "question": "Would Melanie likely enjoy the song \"The Four Seasons\" by Vivaldi?",
      "category": 3,
      "gold_answer": "Yes; it's classical music",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Melanie mentions liking classical music, specifically naming Bach and Mozart (Result 2).\n\nStep 2: Vivaldi's \"The Four Seasons\" is a well-known classical piece, similar in style and era to Bach and Mozart.\n\nStep 3: Since Melanie enjoys classical music by composers like Bach and Mozart, it is reasonable to infer she would likely enjoy Vivaldi's \"The Four Seasons.\"\n\nFinal answer: Yes, Melanie would likely enjoy \"The Four Seasons\" by Vivaldi because she appreciates classical music by composers like Bach and Mozart.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.59,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.27
    },
    {
      "question": "What are some changes Caroline has faced during her transition journey?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Changes to her body, losing unsupportive friends",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Caroline's transition and related changes.\n\n- Result 14 (2023-08-14): Caroline says art helped her explore her transition and changing body, working through challenges and learning to accept imperfections.\n- Result 19 (2023-07-15): Caroline says realizing she can be herself without fear and having courage to transition was freeing and authentic.\n- Result 20 (2023-10-22): Caroline says transitioning and acceptance were not easy; help from friends, family, and role models was invaluable; she wants to support others.\n- Result 25 (2023-07-06): Caroline says having a great support system helped her accept and grow into her true self; support was instrumental.\n- Result 32 (2023-07-06): Caroline appreciates friends and family helping with her transition; they make all the difference.\n- Result 68 (2023-07-06): Melanie notes Caroline has love and support around her;",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.97,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.88
    },
    {
      "question": "What does Melanie do with her family on hikes?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Roast marshmallows, tell stories",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of hiking with Melanie's family.  \n- Result 1: Melanie says they enjoy hiking in mountains and exploring forests to connect with nature and each other.  \n- Result 8: Melanie describes exploring nature, roasting marshmallows around the campfire, and going on a hike with her family; the view from the top was amazing.  \n- Result 17: Melanie mentions going on another camping trip in the forest with family.  \n- Result 37: Melanie talks about bonding over stories, campfires, and nature during camping trips.  \n- Result 64: Melanie mentions roasting marshmallows and sharing stories around the campfire, and kids getting excited learning about nature.  \n\nStep 2: Summarize activities during hikes and related family outings.  \n- Hiking involves exploring nature (mountains, forests).  \n- They roast marshmallows and share stories around campfires.  \n- They enjoy the views from hikes.  \n- The experience is peaceful",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.65,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.69
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Caroline go biking with friends?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "The weekend before 13 September 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for any mention of Caroline biking with friends in the context.\n\nStep 2: The closest relevant mention is in Result 1 (2023-09-13), where Melanie says: \"Biking sounds like a great way to get out in nature.\" This implies Caroline mentioned biking recently.\n\nStep 3: No direct date or event is given for when Caroline went biking with friends.\n\nStep 4: No other excerpt explicitly states when Caroline went biking with friends.\n\nStep 5: Since the biking mention is in a message dated 2023-09-13, it suggests the biking happened shortly before that date.\n\nFinal answer: Caroline went biking with friends shortly before September 13, 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.92,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.09
    },
    {
      "question": "How long has Melanie been practicing art?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "Since 2016",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about Melanie's art experience.\n\n- Result 2 (2023-09-13): Caroline asks Melanie how long she has been into art.\n- Result 5 (2023-09-13): Melanie replies she has been practicing art for seven years.\n- Result 50 (2023-05-08): Melanie mentions painting as a way to express feelings and relax.\n- Result 16 and 20 (2023-07-03): Melanie talks about starting pottery recently (signed up July 2, 2023).\n- Result 54 (2023-10-13): Melanie mentions a setback in pottery in September 2023.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.\n\nMelanie has been practicing art for seven years as of September 13, 2023. She has recently focused on painting and pottery as her main art forms.\n\nFinal answer:  \nMelanie has been practicing art for seven years as of September 2023",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.71,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.49
    },
    {
      "question": "What personality traits might Melanie say Caroline has?",
      "category": 3,
      "gold_answer": "Thoughtful, authentic, driven",
      "generated_answer": "Step-by-step reasoning:\n\n1. Melanie frequently praises Caroline's courage and strength, especially regarding her transition and sharing her story (Results 17, 51, 59, 72, 82, 96).\n2. Melanie describes Caroline as caring and having a big heart (Result 3).\n3. Melanie admires Caroline's passion and hard work to help others (Result 22).\n4. Melanie notes Caroline's authenticity and self-acceptance (Results 7, 63).\n5. Melanie appreciates Caroline's ability to inspire and motivate others (Results 17, 22, 51, 72).\n6. Melanie acknowledges Caroline's resilience and ability to find joy and peace despite challenges (Results 11, 59).\n7. Melanie values Caroline's creativity and expression through art (Results 24, 38, 58).\n8. Melanie highlights Caroline's supportive nature and willingness to help others (Results 17, 41, 82).\n\nFinal answer:  \n",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.44,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.61
    },
    {
      "question": "What transgender-specific events has Caroline attended?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Poetry reading, conference",
      "generated_answer": "Step-by-step review of transgender-specific events Caroline attended based on the context:\n\n1. [Result 1, 9, 49] - LGBTQ Pride event in June 2023, described as very encouraging and full of love and acceptance.\n2. [Result 4, 13] - Transgender conference in July 2023, where she met others in the community and learned about advocacy.\n3. [Result 11, 28] - School event in early June 2023 where Caroline talked about her transgender journey and encouraged involvement.\n4. [Result 5, 26, 32, 55] - Transgender poetry reading event in October 2023, where transgender people shared stories through poetry.\n5. [Result 15, 33] - LGBTQ support group meeting in early May 2023, described as powerful.\n6. [Result 49, 59] - Joined a mentorship program for LGBTQ youth, helping and supporting young people.\n7.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.43,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.29
    },
    {
      "question": "What book did Melanie read from Caroline's suggestion?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "\"Becoming Nicole\"",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify any mention of books recommended by Caroline to Melanie.\n\n- Result 4 (2023-10-13): Melanie says, \"Been reading that book you recommended a while ago...\"\n- Result 44 (2023-07-12): Caroline says she loved \"Becoming Nicole\" by Amy Ellis Nutt and highly recommends it.\n- Result 37 (2023-07-12): Melanie mentions a book she read last year that reminds her to pursue her dreams, but no title is given.\n\nStep 2: Check if Melanie confirms reading \"Becoming Nicole.\"\n\n- Result 4 implies Melanie is reading a book Caroline recommended.\n- Result 44 is Caroline recommending \"Becoming Nicole.\"\n- No other book titles recommended by Caroline are mentioned.\n\nStep 3: Conclusion\n\nMelanie read \"Becoming Nicole\" by Amy Ellis Nutt, which Caroline recommended.\n\nFinal answer: Melanie read \"Becoming Nicole\" by Amy Ellis Nutt from Caroline's suggestion.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 4.08,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.36
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Melanie's friend adopt a child?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": 2022,
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant excerpt about Melanie's friend adopting a child.  \n- Result 3 [2023-10-13]: Melanie to Caroline says, \"a buddy of mine adopted last year (approximately October 13, 2022).\"\n\nStep 2: Confirm the date of the message to understand the reference \"last year.\"  \n- The message is dated 2023-10-13, so \"last year\" means 2022.\n\nStep 3: Note the approximate adoption date given: October 13, 2022.\n\nFinal answer:  \nMelanie's friend adopted a child around October 13, 2022.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.1,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.22
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Melanie get hurt?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "September 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify any mention of Melanie getting hurt.  \n- Result 95 (2023-10-13) Melanie says: \"Recently (approximately October 06, 2023) I had a setback. Last month (approximately September 13, 2023) I got hurt and had to take a break from pottery...\"\n\nStep 2: Confirm the date of injury.  \n- Melanie clearly states she got hurt around September 13, 2023.\n\nFinal answer:  \nMelanie got hurt around September 13, 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.06,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.45
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Melanie's family go on a roadtrip?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "The weekend before 20 October 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of a road trip involving Melanie's family.  \n- Result 67 (2023-10-20): Melanie mentions a road trip \"this past weekend\" with an accident involving her son.  \n- Result 17 (2023-10-20): Melanie confirms the trip started badly due to the accident but her son is okay.  \n- Result 33 (2023-10-20): Melanie says they just did \"it yesterday\" (the family outing) after the road trip, approximately October 19, 2023.\n\nStep 2: Determine the date of the road trip.  \n- \"This past weekend\" from a message dated 2023-10-20 implies the road trip happened on the weekend just before October 20, 2023.  \n- The family outing after the trip was on October 19, 2023, a Thursday, so the road trip likely occurred the weekend before that, around October 14-",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 4.04,
      "judge_latency_s": 3.25
    },
    {
      "question": "How many children does Melanie have?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": 3,
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for mentions of Melanie's children in the excerpts.\n\n- Result 4 (2023-10-20): Caroline says, \"Glad your son is okay, Melanie.\"\n- Result 12 (2023-10-20): Caroline asks, \"How did they handle the accident?\" referring to \"the kids.\"\n- Result 22 (2023-10-20): Melanie replies, \"They were scared but we reassured them and explained their brother would be OK. They're tough kids.\"\n- Result 24 (2023-06-09): Melanie says, \"I'm lucky to have my husband and kids.\"\n- Result 27 (2023-07-15): Melanie says, \"My fam's been awesome - they helped out and showed lots of love and support.\"\n- Result 33 (2023-06-09): Melanie describes a family activity with \"We played games, ate good food, and just hung out together.\"\n- Result 35 (",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.11,
      "judge_latency_s": 3.46
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Melanie go on a hike after the roadtrip?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "19 October 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the road trip date.\n- Melanie mentions a road trip and accident on October 20, 2023 (Results 3, 48).\n- The road trip happened \"this past weekend\" before October 20, so approximately October 14-15, 2023.\n\nStep 2: Find when Melanie went hiking after the road trip.\n- Melanie says \"we just did it yesterday (approximately October 19, 2023)\" referring to an activity the kids loved after the road trip (Result 5).\n- Result 81 mentions Melanie's family went on another camping trip in the forest, which involves hiking and was after July 15, 2023.\n- Result 51 mentions camping and hiking \"a few weeks ago\" from September 13, 2023, so before the road trip.\n- No direct mention of hiking exactly after the road trip except the \"yesterday\" activity on October 19, 2023, which was a",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.98,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.54
    },
    {
      "question": "Would Melanie go on another roadtrip soon?",
      "category": 3,
      "gold_answer": "Likely no; since this one went badly",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify any mentions of road trips or travel plans by Melanie.  \n- Result 47 (2023-10-20): Melanie mentions a recent road trip that was \"insane\" and involved a scary accident with her son, but thankfully he was okay.  \n- Result 18 (2023-10-20): Melanie confirms the trip got off to a bad start due to the accident but emphasizes the importance of cherishing family.  \n- Result 22 (2023-10-20): Melanie says they just did \"it\" yesterday (October 19, 2023), referring to a relaxing activity after the road trip.  \n- Result 31 (2023-10-20): Melanie describes peaceful family bonding in nature after the trip.  \n- Result 94 (2023-10-20): Caroline comments on the refreshing nature experience after the drive.  \n\nStep 2: Look for any explicit or implicit statements about future road trips.  \n-",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.67,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.58
    },
    {
      "question": "What items has Melanie bought?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Figurines, shoes",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for mentions of items Melanie has acquired or bought.\n\nStep 2: In Result 23 [2023-07-12T16:41:30], Melanie tells Caroline: \"Luna and Oliver! They are so sweet and playful - they really liven up the house! Just got some new shoes, too!\"\n\nStep 3: This indicates Melanie has bought new shoes recently (around July 12, 2023).\n\nStep 4: No other explicit mentions of items Melanie has bought are found in the context.\n\nFinal answer: Melanie has bought new shoes recently.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.78,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.35
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Caroline pass the adoption interview?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "The Friday before 22 October 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify any direct mentions of Caroline passing the adoption interview.  \n- Result 4 [2023-10-22]: Caroline says, \"I passed the adoption agency interviews last Friday!\"\n\nStep 2: Determine the date of \"last Friday\" relative to the message date.  \n- The message is dated 2023-10-22 (Sunday).  \n- The Friday before 2023-10-22 is 2023-10-20.\n\nFinal answer: Caroline passed the adoption interview on Friday, October 20, 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.66,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.69
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Melanie buy the figurines?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "21 October 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant excerpt mentioning the figurines.\n- Result 3 [2023-10-22T09:55:30] Melanie to Caroline: \"These figurines I bought yesterday (approximately October 21, 2023) remind me of family love.\"\n\nStep 2: Confirm the date of the message to understand the \"yesterday\" reference.\n- The message is dated 2023-10-22, so \"yesterday\" would be 2023-10-21.\n\nFinal answer:  \nMelanie bought the figurines on October 21, 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.09,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.37
    },
    {
      "question": "Would Caroline want to move back to her home country soon?",
      "category": 3,
      "gold_answer": "No; she's in the process of adopting children.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Review the context for any mention of Caroline's plans or desires about moving back to her home country.\n\nStep 2: Scan for keywords like \"move,\" \"home country,\" \"return,\" or any direct statements about relocation.\n\nStep 3: The excerpts mostly focus on Caroline's adoption journey, support system, family, and community involvement. There is no explicit mention of her wanting or planning to move back to her home country.\n\nStep 4: Some messages mention transitions and support during them (e.g., Results 35, 63), but these relate to personal growth and acceptance, not geographic relocation.\n\nStep 5: No direct or indirect evidence suggests Caroline wants to move back to her home country soon.\n\nFinal answer: Not enough information.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.35,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.55
    },
    {
      "question": "What did the charity race raise awareness for?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "mental health",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of the charity race in the context.  \n- Result 2 (2023-05-25): Melanie says she ran a charity race for mental health last Saturday.  \n- Result 1 (2023-05-25): Caroline praises Melanie for taking part in a charity race raising awareness for mental health.  \n- Result 8 (2023-05-25): Melanie reflects on the event being thought-provoking and about self-care, linking it to mental health.\n\nStep 2: Confirm the cause the race supported.  \nBoth Melanie and Caroline explicitly mention the race was for mental health awareness.\n\nFinal answer:  \nThe charity race raised awareness for mental health.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.15,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.56
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Melanie realize after the charity race?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "self-care is important",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant excerpts about the charity race and Melanie's reflections on it.\n\n- Result 2 (2023-05-25): Melanie says she ran a charity race for mental health last Saturday and found it rewarding.\n- Result 7 (2023-05-25): Melanie says the event was thought-provoking and she is starting to realize that self-care is really important.\n- Result 66 (2023-05-25): Caroline agrees that taking care of ourselves is important and praises Melanie for prioritizing self-care.\n- Result 70 (2023-05-25): Caroline encourages Melanie for taking time for herself and looking after herself and her family.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.\n\nMelanie realized after the charity race that self-care is very important. She sees it as a journey but understands that when she looks after herself, she can better care for her family.\n\nFinal answer:  \nAfter the charity race, Melanie realized that self-care is really",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.55,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.11
    },
    {
      "question": "How does Melanie prioritize self-care?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "by carving out some me-time each day for activities like running, reading, or playing the violin",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Melanie prioritizing self-care in the context.\n\n- Result 3 (2023-05-25): Melanie says self-care is important and a journey for her, helping her better look after her family.\n- Result 14 (2023-05-25): Melanie ran a charity race for mental health, showing active engagement in mental health awareness.\n- Result 21 (2023-07-12): Melanie says mental health is important to her and has made a big improvement.\n- Result 89 (2023-07-12): Melanie mentions running farther to de-stress, which helps her headspace.\n- Result 98 (2023-05-08): Melanie says taking care of ourselves is vital and mentions going swimming with her kids.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize how Melanie prioritizes self-care based on these details.\n\nMelanie prioritizes self-care by engaging in physical activities like running and swimming, which help her mental health and stress relief",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.39,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.7
    },
    {
      "question": "What are Caroline's plans for the summer?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "researching adoption agencies",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for any direct mentions of Caroline's summer plans in the excerpts.\n\n- Result 4 (2023-08-17): Caroline suggests a family outing or planning something special for the summer, just the two of them, to catch up and explore nature.\n- Result 71 (2023-08-17): Caroline expresses excitement for \"the trip,\" presumably the one Melanie mentioned.\n- Result 50 (2023-08-25): Melanie asks Caroline about why she found a supportive community special, implying Caroline is involved in community or volunteer activities.\n- Result 16 and 61 (2023-08-28): Melanie asks Caroline about specific projects or activities she is looking forward to in volunteering.\n- Result 100 (2023-08-28): Caroline describes a recent experience guiding and supporting young people, indicating ongoing volunteer work.\n\nStep 2: Summarize Caroline's summer plans based on these.\n\nCaroline is considering a family outing or a special",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.32,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.03
    },
    {
      "question": "What type of individuals does the adoption agency Caroline is considering support?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "LGBTQ+ individuals",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify where Caroline talks about the adoption agency she is considering.  \n- Result 1, 2, and 3 show Caroline discussing adoption agencies.  \n- Result 3 specifically says: \"I chose them 'cause they help LGBTQ+ folks with adoption. Their inclusivity and support really spoke to me.\"\n\nStep 2: Confirm the type of individuals the agency supports.  \n- Caroline explicitly states the agency helps LGBTQ+ folks with adoption, emphasizing inclusivity and support.\n\nFinal answer:  \nThe adoption agency Caroline is considering supports LGBTQ+ individuals.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.32,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.82
    },
    {
      "question": "Why did Caroline choose the adoption agency?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "because of their inclusivity and support for LGBTQ+ individuals",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about Caroline's choice of adoption agency.  \n- Result 2: Caroline says she chose the agency because they help LGBTQ+ folks with adoption.  \n- Result 13: Melanie asks what made Caroline pick the agency.  \n- Result 2 again clarifies the reason: inclusivity and support for LGBTQ+ people.  \n\nStep 2: Confirm no other conflicting or additional reasons are given.  \n- No other excerpts provide a different or additional reason.  \n\nFinal answer:  \nCaroline chose the adoption agency because they provide inclusivity and support specifically for LGBTQ+ individuals, which resonated with her.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.0,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.84
    },
    {
      "question": "What is Caroline excited about in the adoption process?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "creating a family for kids who need one",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify Caroline's statements about adoption excitement:\n- [Result 1, 5, 6, 33] Caroline expresses excitement about giving kids a loving home, starting a new chapter, and making a family for kids who need one.\n- [Result 8] She chose an agency that supports LGBTQ+ folks, showing excitement about inclusivity.\n- [Result 11] She passed adoption agency interviews, showing progress and excitement.\n- [Result 58] She dreams of creating a safe and loving home for kids.\n- [Result 50] She feels empowered to make a positive difference in someone's life through adoption.\n\nStep 2: Look for Melanie's responses that reflect Caroline's excitement:\n- [Result 2, 9, 24] Melanie supports Caroline's caring heart and new chapter.\n- [Result 7, 17] Melanie acknowledges Caroline's passion for helping kids.\n- [Result 10] Melanie mentions a friend who adopted, possibly encouraging Caroline",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.62,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.94
    },
    {
      "question": "What does Melanie think about Caroline's decision to adopt?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "she thinks Caroline is doing something amazing and will be an awesome mom",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify Melanie's comments about Caroline's adoption decision.\n\n- [Result 2] Melanie acknowledges the agency's inclusivity and support positively.\n- [Result 3] Melanie expresses excitement and encouragement about the adoption process.\n- [Result 5] Melanie praises Caroline's caring heart and is excited for her new chapter.\n- [Result 6] Melanie calls Caroline's decision \"awesome\" and highlights the loving home Caroline will provide.\n- [Result 7] Melanie agrees that everyone deserves love and admires Caroline's passion.\n- [Result 20] Melanie congratulates Caroline and expresses happiness about the adoption.\n- [Result 33] Melanie calls Caroline kind and says her future family is lucky.\n- [Result 34] Melanie shares that a friend adopted last year and seems inspired by Caroline.\n- [Result 40] Melanie congratulates Caroline for pursuing what she cares about.\n- [Result 63] Melanie notes that love and acceptance can be found everywhere, supporting Caroline",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.01,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.58
    },
    {
      "question": "How long have Mel and her husband been married?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Mel and her husband have been married for 5 years.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant messages about Mel's marriage duration.\n- Result 1: Caroline asks Mel how long she has been married.\n- Result 53: Melanie replies, \"5 years already! Time flies- feels like just yesterday (approximately June 08, 2023) I put this dress on! Thanks, Caroline!\"\n\nStep 2: Confirm the date of the message to understand the timeline.\n- Result 53 is dated 2023-06-09, so as of June 2023, Mel and her husband had been married for 5 years.\n\nFinal answer: Mel and her husband have been married for 5 years as of June 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.73,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.3
    },
    {
      "question": "What does Caroline's necklace symbolize?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "love, faith, and strength",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify where Caroline talks about her necklace.  \n- In Result 3, Caroline says: \"This necklace is super special to me - a gift from my grandma in my home country, Sweden. She gave it to me when I was young, and it stands for love, faith and strength. It's like a reminder of my roots and all the love and support I get from my family.\"\n\nStep 2: Extract the symbolism from Caroline's own words.  \n- The necklace symbolizes love, faith, strength, a connection to her roots, and the love and support from her family.\n\nFinal answer:  \nCaroline's necklace symbolizes love, faith, strength, and serves as a reminder of her roots and the love and support from her family.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.02,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.86
    },
    {
      "question": "What country is Caroline's grandma from?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Sweden",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for any mention of Caroline's grandma and her origin in the context.\n\nStep 2: In Result 67 [2023-06-27T10:38:00], Caroline to Melanie says: \"Thanks, Melanie! This necklace is super special to me - a gift from my grandma in my home country, Sweden.\"\n\nStep 3: This clearly states Caroline's grandma is from Sweden.\n\nFinal answer: Caroline's grandma is from Sweden.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.02,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.18
    },
    {
      "question": "What was grandma's gift to Caroline?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "necklace",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for mentions of Caroline's grandma or a gift from her in the context.\n\nStep 2: In Result 46 [2023-06-27T10:38:00], Caroline tells Melanie: \"This necklace is super special to me - a gift from my grandma in my home country, Sweden. She gave it to me when I was young, and it stands for love, faith and strength.\"\n\nStep 3: This clearly states that the gift from Caroline's grandma was a necklace.\n\nFinal answer:  \nCaroline's grandma gave her a necklace as a gift.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.07,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.49
    },
    {
      "question": "What is Melanie's hand-painted bowl a reminder of?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "art and self-expression",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Melanie's hand-painted bowl in the context.  \n- Result 1: Caroline mentions her own hand-painted bowl made by a friend for her 18th birthday, but this is Caroline's bowl, not Melanie's.  \n- Result 3, 4, 6, 8, 13, 26, 31, 61, 65, 69: Melanie talks about pottery and bowls she made, but no direct mention of a \"hand-painted bowl\" or what it reminds her of.  \n- Result 1 is the only explicit mention of a hand-painted bowl, but it is Caroline's, not Melanie's.\n\nStep 2: Check if Melanie's bowl is described as hand-painted or what it symbolizes.  \n- No direct statement about Melanie's bowl being hand-painted or what it reminds her of.  \n- Melanie mentions pottery as calming and creative (Results 8, 26, 69), but no symbolic meaning is",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.56,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.47
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Melanie and her family do while camping?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "explored nature, roasted marshmallows, and went on a hike",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify all mentions of camping activities by Melanie and her family.\n\n- Result 1 (2023-07-20): Melanie mentions roasting marshmallows, telling stories around the campfire, and enjoying each other's company as highlights of their family camping trip.\n- Result 2 (2023-06-27): Melanie says they explored nature, roasted marshmallows around the campfire, went on a hike, and the younger kids love nature.\n- Result 9 (2023-09-13): Melanie again mentions roasting marshmallows and sharing stories around the campfire.\n- Result 12 (2023-07-15): Melanie mentions going on another camping trip in the forest.\n- Result 63 (2023-07-15): Melanie says they enjoy hiking in the mountains and exploring forests as part of their family activities.\n- Result 97 (2023-10-20): Melanie says camping trips help her reset and recharge, appreciating the peace and",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.39,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.59
    },
    {
      "question": "What kind of counseling and mental health services is Caroline interested in pursuing?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "working with trans people, helping them accept themselves and supporting their mental health",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Caroline expresses a general interest in counseling and mental health careers multiple times (Results 1, 3, 4, 5, 9).\n\nStep 2: She specifically mentions wanting to help people who have gone through similar struggles as her, including mental health challenges and self-acceptance (Results 1, 3, 11, 19, 58).\n\nStep 3: Caroline is interested in working with trans people, helping them accept themselves and supporting their mental health (Result 23).\n\nStep 4: She also mentors LGBTQ youth and is involved in LGBTQ advocacy and support (Results 63, 92, 83).\n\nStep 5: Overall, her focus is on counseling and mental health services that support LGBTQ individuals, especially trans people, and those dealing with mental health struggles related to identity and acceptance.\n\nFinal answer:  \nCaroline is interested in counseling and mental health services focused on supporting LGBTQ individuals, particularly trans people, helping them with self",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.79,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.74
    },
    {
      "question": "What workshop did Caroline attend recently?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "LGBTQ+ counseling workshop",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for mentions of Caroline attending any workshops or similar events.\n\nStep 2: In Result 32 (2023-07-15), Melanie says: \"Last Fri I finally took my kids to a pottery workshop. We all made our own pots, it was fun and therapeutic!\" This is Melanie attending a pottery workshop with her kids, not Caroline.\n\nStep 3: In Result 96 (2023-07-03), Melanie says: \"I just signed up for a pottery class yesterday (approximately July 02, 2023). It's like therapy for me, letting me express myself and get creative. Have you found any activities that make you feel the same way?\" This is Melanie signing up for pottery, no mention of Caroline attending.\n\nStep 4: No direct mention of Caroline attending a workshop is found in the excerpts.\n\nStep 5: Caroline mentions mentoring young people (Result 80), attending pride events (Result 20), and being involved in art",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.84,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.08
    },
    {
      "question": "What was discussed in the LGBTQ+ counseling workshop?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "therapeutic methods and how to best work with trans people",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about the LGBTQ+ counseling workshop.\n\n- Result 1 [2023-06-27]: Caroline mentions attending an LGBTQ+ counseling workshop last Friday, describing it as enlightening.\n- She says the workshop covered different therapeutic methods and how to best work with trans people.\n- She was impressed by the passion of professionals creating safe spaces for people like her.\n\nStep 2: Summarize the content discussed in the workshop.\n\n- The workshop focused on therapeutic methods.\n- It emphasized working effectively with trans people.\n- It highlighted creating safe, supportive environments for LGBTQ+ individuals.\n\nFinal answer:  \nThe LGBTQ+ counseling workshop discussed different therapeutic methods and how to best work with trans people, focusing on creating safe and supportive spaces for them.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.24,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.76
    },
    {
      "question": "What motivated Caroline to pursue counseling?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "her own journey and the support she received, and how counseling improved her life",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify Caroline's statements about her motivation for counseling.\n\n- Result 2 (2023-06-27): Caroline says she wants to help people who have gone through the same things as her.\n- Result 3 (2023-07-12): Caroline explains she struggled with mental health and the support she received was really helpful, which made her realize the importance of a support system for others.\n- Result 37 (2023-06-27): Caroline says her own journey and the support she got made a huge difference, inspiring her to help others through counseling and support groups.\n- Result 39 (2023-10-22): Caroline mentions that transitioning and acceptance were tough, but the help from friends, family, and role models was invaluable, motivating her to pass on that support to others.\n- Result 95 (2023-06-09): Caroline emphasizes sharing experiences to promote understanding and acceptance, wanting to pass on the love and support she received.\n\n",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.79,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.26
    },
    {
      "question": "What kind of place does Caroline want to create for people?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "a safe and inviting place for people to grow",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about Caroline's intentions for creating a place for people.\n\n- Result 1 (2023-10-22): Melanie praises Caroline for giving a home to needy kids, calling it loving.\n- Result 4 (2023-05-25): Melanie says Caroline has a caring heart and will provide love and stability.\n- Result 40 (2023-05-25): Melanie says Caroline taking in kids in need is kind and lucky for the kids.\n- Result 48 (2023-10-22): Caroline says her dream is to create a safe and loving home for these kids, emphasizing love and acceptance as everyone's right.\n- Result 66 (2023-05-25): Caroline mentions researching adoption agencies to have a family and give a loving home to kids who need it.\n- Result 70 (2023-05-25): Caroline chose agencies that help LGBTQ+ folks with adoption, valuing inclusivity and support.\n\nStep 2",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 4.36,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.97
    },
    {
      "question": "Did Melanie make the black and white bowl in the photo?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Yes",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of the black and white bowl.  \n- Result 1 (2023-07-03): Caroline asks Melanie if she made the black and white bowl.  \n- Result 6 (2023-07-03): Melanie replies she made \"this bowl\" in her class and is proud of it.  \n\nStep 2: Confirm if the \"this bowl\" Melanie refers to is the same black and white bowl Caroline mentioned.  \n- The timing of the messages is the same day and close in time (Result 1 at 13:39, Result 6 at 13:39:30).  \n- Caroline's message is about a bowl with a black and white design.  \n- Melanie responds directly to Caroline's compliment about the bowl, confirming she made it in class.  \n\nStep 3: No contradictory information is found.  \n\nFinal answer:  \nYes, Melanie made the black and white bowl in the photo.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.24,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.84
    },
    {
      "question": "What kind of books does Caroline have in her library?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "kids' books - classics, stories from different cultures, educational books",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about Caroline's library and books.\n- Result 5 (2023-07-05): Caroline says she is creating a library for when she has kids and looks forward to reading to them.\n- Result 8 (2023-07-06): Caroline says she has lots of kids' books including classics, stories from different cultures, and educational books.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.\nCaroline's library mainly consists of children's books, including classic stories, multicultural stories, and educational books.\n\nFinal answer:  \nCaroline's library contains lots of children's books, including classics, stories from different cultures, and educational books.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.85,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.54
    },
    {
      "question": "What was Melanie's favorite book from her childhood?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "\"Charlotte's Web\"",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify any mentions of Melanie's favorite childhood book in the context.\n\nStep 2: In Result 6 (2023-07-06T20:22:30), Melanie tells Caroline: \"I loved reading 'Charlotte's Web' as a kid. It was so cool seeing how friendship and compassion can make a difference.\"\n\nStep 3: No other childhood book favorites from Melanie are mentioned.\n\nFinal answer: Melanie's favorite book from her childhood was \"Charlotte's Web.\"",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.59,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.19
    },
    {
      "question": "What book did Caroline recommend to Melanie?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "\"Becoming Nicole\"",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify any mention of Caroline recommending a book to Melanie.  \n- Result 4 (2023-10-13): Melanie says, \"Been reading that book you recommended a while ago...\" indicating Caroline recommended a book before this date.  \n- Result 21 (2023-07-12): Caroline to Melanie says, \"I loved 'Becoming Nicole' by Amy Ellis Nutt. It's a real inspiring true story about a trans girl and her family. ... Highly recommend it for sure!\" This is a clear recommendation from Caroline.  \n\nStep 2: Confirm if Melanie refers to this book later.  \n- Result 4 shows Melanie reading a book Caroline recommended, likely \"Becoming Nicole\" since no other book recommendation from Caroline is mentioned.  \n\nFinal answer:  \nCaroline recommended the book \"Becoming Nicole\" by Amy Ellis Nutt to Melanie.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.27,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.48
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Caroline take away from the book \"Becoming Nicole\"?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Lessons on self-acceptance and finding support",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant excerpts about \"Becoming Nicole.\"\n\n- Result 3 (2023-07-12): Caroline says she loved \"Becoming Nicole\" by Amy Ellis Nutt, describing it as an inspiring true story about a trans girl and her family. It made her feel connected and gave her hope for her own path.\n- Result 49 (2023-07-12): Caroline says the book taught her self-acceptance and how to find support. It showed her that tough times don't last and that hope and love exist. She also mentions pets bring joy.\n- Result 53 (2023-07-12): Melanie agrees with Caroline's lessons from the book about self-acceptance, finding support, and the joy pets bring.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the takeaways.\n\nCaroline took away from \"Becoming Nicole\" lessons of self-acceptance, finding support, hope during tough times, and the importance of love. The story made",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.35,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.47
    },
    {
      "question": "What are the new shoes that Melanie got used for?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Running",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the message mentioning Melanie's new shoes.  \n- Result 10 [2023-07-12T16:41:30] Melanie to Caroline: \"Luna and Oliver! They are so sweet and playful - they really liven up the house! Just got some new shoes, too!\"\n\nStep 2: Look for any follow-up or related messages that explain what the new shoes are used for.  \n- Result 33, 34, 35 [2023-07-12] Caroline asks about running and mentions shoes:  \n  - [35] \"Love that purple color! For walking or running?\"  \n  - [33] \"Wow! What got you into running?\"  \n  - [34] \"Cool, Melanie! Running can really boost your mood. Keep it up!\"  \n- Result 85 [2023-07-12T16:42:30] Melanie to Caroline: \"Thanks, Caroline! These are for running",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.84,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.64
    },
    {
      "question": "What is Melanie's reason for getting into running?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "To de-stress and clear her mind",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about Melanie and running.  \n- Result 1: Caroline asks Melanie what got her into running.  \n- Result 2: Melanie replies she\u2019s been running farther to de-stress, which helps her headspace.  \n- Result 4: Melanie says she\u2019s been running longer since their last chat as a great way to destress and clear her mind.  \n- Result 41: Melanie mentions carving out me-time each day with running, reading, or violin to refresh and stay present for her family.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.  \nMelanie\u2019s main reason for running is to de-stress and improve her mental well-being, helping her clear her mind and maintain a good headspace.\n\nFinal answer:  \nMelanie got into running to de-stress and clear her mind, which has been great for her mental well-being and headspace.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.95,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.46
    },
    {
      "question": "What does Melanie say running has been great for?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Her mental health",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of running by Melanie in the context.\n\n- Result 2 [2023-07-12T16:43:30] Melanie to Caroline: \"I've been running farther to de-stress, which has been great for my headspace.\"\n- Result 4 [2023-07-12T16:42:30] Melanie to Caroline: \"Been running longer since our last chat - a great way to destress and clear my mind.\"\n\nStep 2: Both excerpts indicate that Melanie finds running helpful for de-stressing and improving her mental state.\n\nFinal answer:  \nMelanie says running has been great for de-stressing and improving her headspace.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.33,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.42
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Mel and her kids make during the pottery workshop?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "pots",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant excerpts about the pottery workshop with Mel and her kids.\n\n- Result 1 (2023-07-15): Mel says she took her kids to a pottery workshop last Friday and they all made their own pots.\n- Result 2 (2023-07-15): Mel says the kids loved getting their hands dirty and making something with clay, and they made \"this\" (likely referring to a pot or cup).\n- Result 6 (2023-07-15): Caroline comments on a cup made by the kids, calling it cute.\n- Result 46 (2023-07-15): Mel mentions they love painting together lately, especially nature-inspired ones, and shares their latest work.\n- Result 39 (2023-07-15): Mel says they both helped with a painting, bonding over it and chatting about nature.\n\nStep 2: Focus on the pottery workshop specifically.\n\n- Mel says they made their own pots (Result ",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.93,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.42
    },
    {
      "question": "What kind of pot did Mel and her kids make with clay?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "a cup with a dog face on it",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of pottery made by Mel and her kids.\n- Result 2 (2023-07-15): Mel says she took her kids to a pottery workshop where they all made their own pots.\n- Result 1 (2023-07-15): Mel says the kids loved it and made something with clay, showing their creativity.\n- Result 10 (2023-07-15): Caroline comments on a cup Mel showed, asking about other creative projects.\n- Result 99 (2023-07-03): Mel mentions making a bowl in her class.\n\nStep 2: Look for specific details about the kind of pot made with clay by Mel and her kids.\n- Result 1 shows the kids made something with clay but does not specify the type.\n- Result 2 says they made their own pots, plural, but no specific type.\n- Result 10 references a \"cup\" that Mel showed, which Caroline calls cute.\n- Result 99",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.2,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.61
    },
    {
      "question": "What creative project do Mel and her kids do together besides pottery?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "painting",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of creative projects Mel and her kids do together.\n- Result 4 (2023-07-15): Mel took her kids to a pottery workshop.\n- Result 17 (2023-07-15): Mel says they love painting together lately, especially nature-inspired ones.\n- Result 18 (2023-07-15): Caroline asks if they worked on the painting together.\n- Result 40 (2023-07-17): Mel says she and her kids just finished another painting like their last one.\n\nStep 2: Confirm that painting is a creative project Mel and her kids do together besides pottery.\n- Multiple messages confirm painting as a shared activity with her kids.\n- No other creative projects with kids are mentioned as frequently or clearly.\n\nFinal answer: Besides pottery, Mel and her kids do painting together, especially nature-inspired paintings.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.37,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.51
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Mel and her kids paint in their latest project in July 2023?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "a sunset with a palm tree",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the timeframe: The question asks about Mel and her kids' latest painting project in July 2023.\n\nStep 2: Look for mentions of Mel and her kids painting in July 2023.\n\n- Result 6 [2023-07-15]: Melanie to Caroline: \"The kids loved it! They were so excited to get their hands dirty and make something with clay. It was special to watch their creativity and imagination come to life, they made this!\" (mentions clay, pottery, not painting)\n\n- Result 10 [2023-07-15]: Melanie to Caroline: \"We love painting together lately, especially nature-inspired ones. Here's our latest work from last weekend.\" (mentions painting together, nature-inspired)\n\n- Result 18 [2023-07-17]: Melanie to Caroline: \"Wow, Caroline! It really conveys unity and strength - such a gorgeous piece! My kids and I just finished another painting like our last one.\" (mentions",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.02,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.43
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Caroline see at the council meeting for adoption?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "many people wanting to create loving homes for children in need",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant excerpt about the council meeting for adoption.  \n- Result 2 [2023-07-15]: Caroline to Melanie mentions attending a council meeting for adoption last Friday.  \n\nStep 2: Extract details from that excerpt.  \n- Caroline says the meeting was inspiring and emotional.  \n- She saw many people wanting to create loving homes for children in need.  \n- The experience made her more determined to adopt.  \n\nStep 3: Confirm no other excerpts contradict or add more details about what she saw at the meeting.  \n- No other excerpts provide additional specifics about the meeting itself.  \n\nFinal answer:  \nCaroline saw many people at the council meeting who wanted to create loving homes for children in need, and the experience was inspiring and emotional for her.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 4.46,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.82
    },
    {
      "question": "What do sunflowers represent according to Caroline?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "warmth and happiness",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify where Caroline talks about the meaning of sunflowers.  \nStep 2: In Result 1, Caroline says: \"Sunflowers mean warmth and happiness, right?\"  \nStep 3: This is a direct statement from Caroline about what sunflowers represent to her.\n\nFinal answer: According to Caroline, sunflowers represent warmth and happiness.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.42,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.06
    },
    {
      "question": "Why are flowers important to Melanie?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "They remind her to appreciate the small moments and were a part of her wedding decor",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify all mentions of flowers related to Melanie in the context.\n\n- Result 1: Melanie says flowers bring joy, represent growth, beauty, and remind her to appreciate small moments. They were important in her wedding decor and always remind her of that day.\n- Result 3: Melanie mentions finding lovely flowers while painting with Caroline and appreciating small things in life.\n- Result 4 and 7: Caroline talks about drawing flowers and appreciating nature, Melanie responds positively about art and flowers.\n- Result 40: Melanie mentions loving painting nature-inspired works including flowers.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.\n\nMelanie values flowers because they symbolize joy, growth, beauty, and serve as reminders to appreciate small moments in life. They hold personal significance as part of her wedding decor, evoking memories of that special day.\n\nFinal answer:  \nFlowers are important to Melanie because they bring joy, symbolize growth and beauty, and remind her to appreciate small moments; they also hold special meaning",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.46,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.8
    },
    {
      "question": "What inspired Caroline's painting for the art show?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "visiting an LGBTQ center and wanting to capture unity and strength",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Caroline's painting for the art show.  \n- Result 34 (2023-07-17): Caroline to Melanie: \"Check out my painting for the art show! Hope you like it.\"  \n- Result 73 (2023-07-17): Caroline to Melanie: \"Yay! Next month I'm having an LGBTQ art show with my paintings - can't wait!\"\n\nStep 2: Look for Caroline's explanation of the inspiration behind her art shown at the art show.  \n- Result 68 (2023-07-17): Caroline to Melanie: \"I painted this after I visited a LGBTQ center. I wanted to capture everyone's unity and strength.\"  \n- Result 63 (2023-09-13): Caroline to Melanie: \"I made this painting to show my path as a trans woman. The red and blue are for the binary gender system, and the mix of colors means smashing that rigid thinking. It's a reminder to love my",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.79,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.69
    },
    {
      "question": "How often does Melanie go to the beach with her kids?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "once or twice a year",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about Melanie's beach visits with her kids.\n\n- Result 4 (2023-07-20): Melanie mentions going to the beach recently (around July 13, 2023) and that the kids had a blast.\n- Result 1 (2023-07-20): Melanie says they don't go often, usually only once or twice a year.\n- Result 12 (2023-07-06): Melanie shares a family camping at the beach photo, indicating they enjoy it but no frequency mentioned.\n- Result 28 (2023-08-25): Caroline comments on a beach-inspired art piece Melanie shared, showing the beach is a meaningful place but no frequency info.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.\n\nMelanie explicitly states in Result 1 that they usually go to the beach only once or twice a year, indicating infrequent visits.\n\nFinal answer:  \nMelanie goes to the beach with her kids usually only once or twice",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.68,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.48
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Melanie and her family see during their camping trip last year?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Perseid meteor shower",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the time frame for \"last year.\" The latest messages are from October 2023, so \"last year\" refers to 2022.\n\nStep 2: Check if there is any mention of a camping trip in 2022 or \"last year.\" The conversations mostly mention camping trips in 2023, such as around June 20, 2023 (Result 50), and other summer 2023 trips.\n\nStep 3: Look for any details about what Melanie and her family saw during camping trips mentioned. In Result 2 (2023-06-27), Melanie says they explored nature, roasted marshmallows, went on a hike, and the view from the top was amazing. The 2 younger kids love nature.\n\nStep 4: No explicit mention of a camping trip in 2022 or \"last year\" is found in the context.\n\nStep 5: Since the question is about \"last year,\" and no direct information about",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.31,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.16
    },
    {
      "question": "How did Melanie feel while watching the meteor shower?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "in awe of the universe",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about the meteor shower.\n- Result 1 (2023-07-20): Melanie said the sky was clear, filled with stars, and the meteor shower was amazing, making her feel part of something huge and awe-inspiring.\n- Result 3 (2023-07-20): Melanie said it was a moment where she felt tiny and in awe of the universe, reminding her how awesome life is with many little moments like that.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize Melanie's feelings.\nMelanie felt awe, smallness in the vast universe, amazement, and a deep appreciation for life during the meteor shower.\n\nFinal answer:  \nMelanie felt tiny, awe-inspired, and amazed by the meteor shower, which made her appreciate the vastness of the universe and the beauty of life.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.24,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.87
    },
    {
      "question": "Whose birthday did Melanie celebrate recently?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Melanie's daughter",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify any mentions of birthdays in the context.  \n- Result 3 [2023-08-14]: Melanie to Caroline says, \"Last night was amazing! We celebrated my daughter's birthday with a concert surrounded by music, joy and the warm summer breeze.\"\n\nStep 2: Confirm no other birthday mentions contradict or add to this.  \n- No other birthday celebrations mentioned by Melanie or Caroline.\n\nFinal answer: Melanie recently celebrated her daughter's birthday.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.58,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.28
    },
    {
      "question": "Who performed at the concert at Melanie's daughter's birthday?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Matt Patterson",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the concert related to Melanie's daughter's birthday.  \n- Result 2 (2023-08-14) mentions Melanie celebrating her daughter's birthday with a concert.  \n- Caroline asks about the band in Result 9 and Result 10 (both 2023-08-28).  \n- Melanie replies in Result 3 (2023-08-28) that the concert was \"Summer Sounds\" and mentions an awesome pop song that got everyone dancing and singing.\n\nStep 2: Check if any specific band name is given.  \n- Melanie calls the event \"Summer Sounds\" but does not mention a specific band name.  \n- Caroline asks \"What's the band?\" (Result 9) and \"Did you see that band?\" (Result 10), but Melanie does not provide a band name in the excerpts.\n\nStep 3: Confirm no other band or performer names are mentioned in the context related to the concert.  \n- No other specific band or performer names",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.04,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.92
    },
    {
      "question": "Why did Melanie choose to use colors and patterns in her pottery project?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "She wanted to catch the eye and make people smile.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about Melanie's pottery colors and patterns.\n\n- Result 11 [2023-08-17]: Caroline asks Melanie what gave her the idea for all the colors and patterns in her bowl.\n- Result 35 [2023-08-17]: Melanie replies she is obsessed with those (colors and patterns), made something to catch the eye and make people smile, and that painting helps her express feelings and be creative, with each stroke carrying a part of her.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize Melanie's explanation.\n\nMelanie chose colors and patterns to create eye-catching pottery that makes people smile, and as a way to express her feelings and creativity, with each stroke representing a part of herself.\n\nFinal answer:  \nMelanie used colors and patterns in her pottery to catch the eye and make people smile, while also expressing her feelings and creativity, with each stroke carrying a part of her.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.65,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.0
    },
    {
      "question": "What pet does Caroline have?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "guinea pig",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for mentions of Caroline's pets in the conversation excerpts.\n\nStep 2: In [Result 16] (2023-08-23), Caroline says: \"And yup, I do- Oscar, my guinea pig. He's been great.\"\n\nStep 3: This is a direct statement from Caroline about her pet.\n\nStep 4: No other pets of Caroline are mentioned explicitly.\n\nFinal answer: Caroline has a guinea pig named Oscar.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.15,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.42
    },
    {
      "question": "What pets does Melanie have?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Two cats and a dog",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Melanie's pets in the conversation excerpts.\n\n- Result 3 (2023-07-12): Melanie says, \"We've got a pup and a kitty.\"\n- Result 9 (2023-07-12): Melanie names the pets \"Luna and Oliver,\" describing them as sweet and playful.\n- Result 23 (2023-08-23): Melanie mentions they got another cat named Bailey in addition to Oliver.\n- Result 44 (2023-08-23): Melanie shares a funny story about Oliver, confirming Oliver is a pet.\n- Result 36 (2023-08-23): Caroline asks about Oliver, and Melanie confirms Oliver is a pet who likes parsley.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.\n\nMelanie has at least two cats named Oliver and Bailey, and a dog named Luna.\n\nFinal answer:  \nMelanie has a dog named Luna and two cats named Oliver and Bailey.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.12,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.8
    },
    {
      "question": "Where did Oliver hide his bone once?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "In Melanie's slipper",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Oliver and his bone in the context.  \nStep 2: Result 1 from 2023-08-23T15:33:30 has Melanie telling Caroline: \"Oliver's hilarious! He hid his bone in my slipper once!\"  \nStep 3: This is a direct answer to the question.\n\nFinal answer: Oliver once hid his bone in Melanie's slipper.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.93,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.66
    },
    {
      "question": "What activity did Caroline used to do with her dad?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Horseback riding",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for any mention of Caroline's past activities or memories involving her dad.\n\nStep 2: Check for any direct references to Caroline talking about her childhood or family experiences.\n\nStep 3: In Result 50, Caroline says: \"It taught me self-acceptance and how to find support. It also showed me that tough times don't last - hope and love exist. Pets bring so much joy too, though.\" This is about lessons learned, but no mention of dad.\n\nStep 4: In Result 11, Melanie says: \"I loved reading 'Charlotte's Web' as a kid. It was so cool seeing how friendship and compassion can make a difference.\" No direct link to Caroline.\n\nStep 5: In Result 90, Caroline says: \"Wow, that's great! It sure shows how important friendship and compassion are. It's made me appreciate how lucky I am to have my friends and family helping with my transition. They make all the difference. We even",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 4.21,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.41
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Caroline make for a local church?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "a stained glass window",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for any mention of Caroline making something, especially for a local church.  \nStep 2: Review the excerpts for references to Caroline creating art or crafts.  \nStep 3: The closest relevant mentions are about paintings and murals by Caroline (Results 3, 11, 15, 21, 30, 44, 62, 73), but none specify a local church.  \nStep 4: Caroline mentions a mural in Result 64: \"Stuff like this mural are really special to me!\" but no direct link to a church.  \nStep 5: No explicit mention in any excerpt that Caroline made something specifically for a local church.\n\nFinal answer: Not enough information.",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.85,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.58
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Caroline find in her neighborhood during her walk?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "a rainbow sidewalk",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify any mentions of Caroline walking or exploring her neighborhood.  \nStep 2: Look for details about what she found or experienced during such a walk.  \nStep 3: Check for direct responses from Caroline or Melanie's comments about Caroline's discoveries.\n\nReviewing the context, the closest relevant excerpt is:  \n- Result 30 [2023-08-25T13:43:30] Melanie to Caroline: \"Wow, that's gorgeous! Where did you find it?\"  \n- Result 29 [2023-08-25T13:45:30] Melanie to Caroline: \"Wow, Caroline, that's so nice! The colors are so bright and the flowers are so pretty. Art is such a source of joy.\"  \n- Result 3 [2023-07-15T13:54:30] Melanie to Caroline: \"Thanks, Caroline! We both helped with the painting - it was great bonding over it and chatting about nature. We found",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.28,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.91
    },
    {
      "question": "Which song motivates Caroline to be courageous?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Brave by Sara Bareilles",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of songs that have significance or motivation for Caroline.\n- Result 1: Caroline says \"Brave\" by Sara Bareilles has a lot of significance for her, about being courageous and fighting for what's right.\n- Result 3: Melanie asks Caroline if any songs have deep meaning for her.\n- Result 2: Melanie agrees \"Brave\" fits Caroline's journey and determination.\n\nStep 2: Confirm that \"Brave\" is linked to courage.\n- Result 1 explicitly states the song is about being courageous and fighting for what's right.\n- Result 4 shows Melanie encouraging Caroline's courage, linking motivation and courage.\n\nStep 3: No other song is mentioned as motivating Caroline to be courageous.\n\nFinal answer: The song \"Brave\" by Sara Bareilles motivates Caroline to be courageous.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.15,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.73
    },
    {
      "question": "Which  classical musicians does Melanie enjoy listening to?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Bach and Mozart",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify where Melanie mentions her music preferences.\n- In Result 1, Melanie says: \"I'm a fan of both classical like Bach and Mozart, as well as modern music like Ed Sheeran's 'Perfect'.\"\n\nStep 2: Extract the classical musicians she enjoys.\n- She specifically names Bach and Mozart as classical musicians she likes.\n\nFinal answer: Melanie enjoys listening to classical musicians Bach and Mozart.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.54,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.42
    },
    {
      "question": "Who is Melanie a fan of in terms of modern music?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Ed Sheeran",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify where Melanie talks about her music preferences.  \nStep 2: In [Result 3], Melanie says she is a fan of both classical music like Bach and Mozart, and modern music like Ed Sheeran's \"Perfect.\"  \nStep 3: This directly answers the question about who Melanie is a fan of in modern music.\n\nFinal answer: Melanie is a fan of Ed Sheeran in terms of modern music.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.65,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.93
    },
    {
      "question": "How long has Melanie been creating art?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "7 years",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about Melanie's art experience.\n\n- Result 3 (Caroline to Melanie, 2023-09-13): Caroline asks Melanie how long she has been into art.\n- Result 5 (Melanie to Caroline, 2023-09-13): Melanie replies she has been creating art for seven years.\n\nStep 2: Confirm no contradictory information.\n\nNo other messages mention a different duration for Melanie's art experience.\n\nFinal answer: Melanie has been creating art for seven years.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.14,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.7
    },
    {
      "question": "What precautionary sign did Melanie see at the caf\u00e9?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "A sign stating that someone is not being able to leave",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of a sign and a caf\u00e9 in the context.\n\n- Result 4 (2023-09-13T00:16:30) Melanie to Caroline: \"...Here's to a good time at the caf\u00e9 last weekend - they even had thoughtful signs like this! It brings me so much happiness.\"\n- Result 1 (2023-09-13T00:17:00) Caroline to Melanie: \"Whoa, Mel, that sign looks serious. Did anything happen?\"\n- Result 2 (2023-09-13T00:17:30) Melanie to Caroline: \"The sign was just a precaution, I had a great time.\"\n\nStep 2: Check if the sign's content or nature is described.\n\n- No direct description of the sign's wording or exact message is given.\n- Caroline notes the sign \"looks serious.\"\n- Melanie clarifies it was \"just a precaution\" and she had a great time.\n\nStep 3: Synthesize",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.97,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.55
    },
    {
      "question": "What advice does Caroline give for getting started with adoption?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Do research, find an adoption agency or lawyer, gather necessary documents, and prepare emotionally.",
      "generated_answer": "Step-by-step from the context:\n\n1. Caroline advises to do research and find an adoption agency or lawyer who can help with the process and provide all necessary information. (Result 3)\n\n2. She mentions gathering important documents such as references, financial information, and medical checks. (Result 3)\n\n3. Caroline emphasizes the importance of preparing emotionally because the waiting period can be difficult. (Result 3)\n\n4. She reassures that despite the challenges, the process is worth it in the end. (Result 3)\n\nFinal answer:  \nCaroline advises starting adoption by researching and finding a reputable adoption agency or lawyer, gathering required documents like references, financial and medical information, and preparing emotionally for the potentially long wait, assuring that it is all worth it in the end.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.65,
      "judge_latency_s": 4.16
    },
    {
      "question": "What setback did Melanie face in October 2023?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "She got hurt and had to take a break from pottery.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify any mention of a setback Melanie faced in October 2023.  \nStep 2: Result 26 from 2023-10-13T10:34:30 shows Melanie telling Caroline about a recent setback: \"Recently (approximately October 06, 2023) I had a setback. Last month (approximately September 13, 2023) I got hurt and had to take a break from pottery, which I use for self-expression and peace.\"\n\nStep 3: This clearly states the nature of the setback was an injury that forced her to pause pottery.\n\nFinal answer:  \nIn October 2023, Melanie faced a setback due to an injury in mid-September that required her to take a break from pottery, which she uses for self-expression and peace.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.27,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.53
    },
    {
      "question": "What does Melanie do to keep herself busy during her pottery break?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Read a book and paint.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify when Melanie mentions her pottery break.  \n- In Result 16 (2023-10-13), Melanie says she had a setback recently (around October 6, 2023) and had to take a break from pottery since she got hurt last month (around September 13, 2023).\n\nStep 2: Look for what Melanie does during this break to keep busy.  \n- In Result 90 (2023-10-13), Melanie says she is doing okay and has been reading the book Caroline recommended and painting to keep busy.\n\nFinal answer:  \nDuring her pottery break, Melanie keeps herself busy by reading a book recommended by Caroline and painting.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.14,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.62
    },
    {
      "question": "What painting did Melanie show to Caroline on October 13, 2023?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "A painting inspired by sunsets with a pink sky.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the date and sender/receiver in the question: Melanie showed a painting to Caroline on October 13, 2023.\n\nStep 2: Look for messages around October 13, 2023, from Melanie to Caroline that mention a painting.\n\n- Result 22 [2023-10-13T10:37:00] Caroline to Melanie: Caroline praises a painting Melanie did around October 6, 2023, inspired by sunsets with calming colors.\n- Result 37 [2023-10-13T10:37:30] Melanie to Caroline: Melanie says she painted it because it was calming and mentions an abstract painting she did.\n- Result 54 [2023-10-13T10:36:30] Melanie to Caroline: Melanie shares a painting from last week (approx. October 6, 2023) inspired by sunsets with calming colors.\n- Result 39 [2023-10-13T10:38",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.75,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.58
    },
    {
      "question": "What kind of painting did Caroline share with Melanie on October 13, 2023?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "An abstract painting with blue streaks on a wall.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the date and relevant messages around October 13, 2023.\n\n- Result 15 [2023-10-13T10:36:00] Caroline to Melanie: \"Cool that you have creative outlets. Got any paintings to show? I'd love to check them out.\"\n- Result 18 [2023-10-13T10:37:00] Caroline to Melanie: \"Wow Mel, that's stunning! Love the colors and the chilled-out sunset vibe. What made you paint it? I've been trying out abstract stuff recently (approximately October 06, 2023). It's kinda freeing, just putting my feelings on the canvas without too much of a plan. It's like a cool form of self-expression.\"\n- Result 49 [2023-10-13T10:38:00] Caroline to Melanie: \"Wow, that looks great! The blue adds so much to it. What feelings were you hoping to portray?\"\n- Result 61",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 4.59,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.39
    },
    {
      "question": "What was the poetry reading that Caroline attended about?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "It was a transgender poetry reading where transgender people shared their stories.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of the poetry reading Caroline attended.  \n- Result 9 (2023-10-13): Caroline says she went to a poetry reading last Friday and found it powerful.  \n- Result 1 (2023-10-13): Caroline explains the poetry reading was a transgender poetry reading where transgender people shared their stories through poetry. It was a safe place for self-expression and empowering.  \n- Result 5 and 14 (2023-08-28): Caroline talks about the event being special, reminding her of her struggles, and how she shared her story to support others.  \n- Result 82 (2023-08-25): Caroline mentions finding a supportive community and that murals like this are special to her, which aligns with the theme of community and acceptance.  \n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.  \nThe poetry reading Caroline attended was specifically a transgender poetry reading where transgender individuals shared their personal stories through poetry. It was a safe,",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.53,
      "judge_latency_s": 3.79
    },
    {
      "question": "What did the posters at the poetry reading say?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "\"Trans Lives Matter\"",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant excerpt about the poetry reading and posters.  \n- Result 1 and Result 2 describe the poetry reading event.  \n- Result 2 specifically mentions the posters: \"The posters were amazing, so much pride and strength!\"\n\nStep 2: Look for any direct quotes or detailed descriptions of what the posters said.  \n- No direct text or slogans from the posters are given.  \n- The posters conveyed themes of pride and strength, likely related to transgender identity and empowerment.\n\nStep 3: Confirm no other excerpts provide more detail about the posters' wording.  \n- No other results mention the posters' exact content.\n\nFinal answer:  \nThe posters at the poetry reading expressed themes of pride and strength, celebrating transgender identities, but no exact wording was provided.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.48,
      "judge_latency_s": 3.13
    },
    {
      "question": "What does Caroline's drawing symbolize for her?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Freedom and being true to herself.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Caroline's drawing and its symbolism.\n\n- Result 11 (2023-10-13): Caroline says her drawing \"stands for freedom and being real,\" a nudge to stay true to herself and embrace her womanhood.\n- Result 35 (2023-08-25): Caroline explains the rainbow flag mural symbolizes courage and strength of the trans community; the eagle symbolizes freedom and pride, representing her resilience.\n- Result 49 (2023-09-13): Caroline made a painting showing her path as a trans woman; red and blue represent the binary gender system, mixed colors mean smashing rigid thinking, reminding her to love her authentic self.\n- Result 26 (2023-08-25): Caroline says a painting is a symbol of togetherness, celebrating differences and closeness.\n- Result 52 (2023-07-17): Caroline painted after visiting an LGBTQ center to capture unity and strength.\n- Result 50 (2023-",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.01,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.16
    },
    {
      "question": "How do Melanie and Caroline describe their journey through life together?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "An ongoing adventure of learning and growing.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about their journey through life together.\n\n- Result 2 (2023-10-13): Melanie says, \"Life's about learning and exploring. Glad we can be on this trip together.\"\n- Result 11 (2023-10-13): Caroline says, \"Being ourselves is such a great feeling. It's an ongoing adventure of learning and growing.\"\n- Result 3 (2023-08-17): Melanie says, \"You make life's struggles more bearable.\"\n- Result 18 (2023-08-17): Melanie says, \"Life's tough but it's worth it when we have things that make us happy.\"\n- Result 19 (2023-06-09): Caroline says, \"We can tackle life's challenges together! We got this!\"\n- Result 84 (2023-08-17): Melanie says, \"I appreciate our friendship too, Caroline. You've always been there for me.\"\n\nStep 2: Synthesize these",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.27,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.51
    },
    {
      "question": "What happened to Melanie's son on their road trip?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "He got into an accident",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of the road trip and Melanie's son in the context.  \n- Result 5 (2023-10-20): Melanie says the road trip was \"insane\" and that her son \"got into an accident.\"  \n- Result 1 (2023-10-20): Melanie confirms they got into an accident and was scared but her son is okay.  \n- Result 4 (2023-10-20): Caroline expresses sympathy about the accident and relief that Melanie's son is okay.  \n- Result 19 (2023-10-20): Melanie says the kids were scared but reassured them their brother would be okay.  \n- Result 89 (2023-10-20): Melanie reflects on the accident and how it made her appreciate family more.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.  \nMelanie's son was involved in an accident during their recent road trip, which was a scary experience for the family. Fortunately,",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.89,
      "judge_latency_s": 3.75
    },
    {
      "question": "How did Melanie's son handle the accident?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "He was scared but reassured by his family",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of the accident involving Melanie's son.  \n- Result 7 (2023-10-20): Melanie says the road trip was insane and they were freaked when her son got into an accident but he was okay.  \n- Result 3 (2023-10-20): Melanie says she was really scared but thankfully her son is okay.  \n- Result 9 (2023-10-20): Melanie says the kids were scared but they reassured them and explained their brother would be okay.  \n- Result 25 (2023-10-20): Melanie reflects on how important family is, especially after the accident, and says the kids enjoyed the Grand Canyon a lot.  \n- Result 2 and 4 (2023-10-20): Caroline expresses relief that Melanie's son is okay.  \n- Result 10 (2023-10-20): Caroline comments on kids' resilience in tough situations.\n\nStep 2: S",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.96,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.67
    },
    {
      "question": "How did Melanie feel about her family after the accident?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "They are important and mean the world to her",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about the accident and Melanie's feelings about family afterward.\n\n- Result 3 (2023-10-20): Melanie said the trip started badly with an accident, was scared, but her son was okay, and it reminded her that life is precious and to cherish family.\n- Result 21 (2023-10-20): Melanie said family is super important to her, especially after the accident, and she thought a lot about how much she needs them; she is thankful to have them.\n- Result 33 (2023-10-20): Melanie mentioned the kids were scared but reassured, showing her care and resilience.\n- Result 46 (2023-10-20): Melanie described the road trip as insane and scary due to the accident but was thankful her son was okay.\n- Result 13 and 39 (2023-10-20): Caroline acknowledged Melanie's love for family and support during tough times.\n\nStep 2:",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.4,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.56
    },
    {
      "question": "How did Melanie's children handle the accident?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "They were scared but resilient",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of the accident and how the children reacted.\n\n- Result 2 (Melanie to Caroline): Melanie says she was scared during the accident but her son is okay, implying the children were affected but safe.\n- Result 6 (Melanie to Caroline): Melanie says the kids were scared but they reassured them and explained their brother would be okay, and calls them \"tough kids.\"\n- Result 26 (Melanie to Caroline): Melanie reflects on the importance of family after the accident and mentions the kids enjoyed the Grand Canyon a lot, suggesting they recovered well.\n- Result 62 (Melanie to Caroline): Melanie says they did \"it\" yesterday (likely a relaxing activity) and the kids loved it, indicating they bounced back after the accident.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.\n\nMelanie's children were scared initially by the accident, but with reassurance from their parents, they handled it well and showed resilience. They were able to enjoy family activities",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.78,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.55
    },
    {
      "question": "How did Melanie feel after the accident?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Grateful and thankful for her family",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify messages about the accident and Melanie's feelings.  \n- Result 2 (Melanie to Caroline, 2023-10-20): Melanie says she was really scared when they got into the accident.  \n- Result 23 (Melanie to Caroline, 2023-10-20): Melanie says they were all freaked out when her son got into an accident and it was a real scary experience.  \n- Result 73 (Melanie to Caroline, 2023-10-20): Melanie reflects that after the accident, she thought a lot about how much she needs her family and is thankful to have them.  \n- Result 11 and 6 (Caroline to Melanie, 2023-10-20): Caroline acknowledges it must have been traumatizing and expresses relief that Melanie's son is okay.  \n- Result 51 (Caroline to Melanie, 2023-10-20): Caroline notes Melanie's love for her family and",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.09,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.88
    },
    {
      "question": "What was Melanie's reaction to her children enjoying the Grand Canyon?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "She was happy and thankful",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about the Grand Canyon trip and Melanie's reaction.\n\n- Result 5 (2023-10-20): Melanie says, \"Thankfully, they enjoyed the Grand Canyon a lot!\"\n- Result 22 (2023-10-20): Melanie mentions the trip started badly with an accident but is thankful her son is okay.\n- Result 80 (2023-10-20): Melanie describes the road trip as \"insane\" due to the accident but relieved it\u2019s over.\n- Result 61 (2023-10-20): Melanie notes the kids were scared but reassured and are tough.\n- Result 73 (2023-10-20): Melanie describes the peacefulness and bonding during the trip.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize Melanie's reaction.\n\nDespite the accident at the start, Melanie is grateful her son is okay and expresses thankfulness that the kids enjoyed the Grand Canyon a lot. She values the family time and finds the experience peaceful",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.64,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.62
    },
    {
      "question": "What do Melanie's family give her?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Strength and motivation",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for mentions of Melanie's family and what they provide or give her.\n\n- Result 3 (2023-10-20): Caroline says Melanie's family \"really are your rock,\" implying strong support.\n- Result 6 (2023-07-20): Caroline calls Melanie's family \"awesome.\"\n- Result 9 (2023-07-15): Caroline asks how Melanie's family has been supportive during her move.\n- Result 13 (2023-07-20): Melanie says \"It's special moments like these that make me appreciate life and how lucky I am to be with my family and have our love.\"\n- Result 18 (2023-07-15): Melanie says \"My fam's been awesome - they helped out and showed lots of love and support.\"\n- Result 47 (2023-07-15): Melanie says \"my family's been great - their love and support really helped me through tough times.\"\n- Result 48 (202",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.63,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.96
    },
    {
      "question": "How did Melanie feel about her family supporting her?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "She appreciated them a lot",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts where Melanie talks about her family support.\n\n- Result 21 (2023-07-15): Melanie says, \"My fam's been awesome - they helped out and showed lots of love and support.\"\n- Result 50 (2023-07-15): Melanie says, \"Yeah, Caroline, my family's been great - their love and support really helped me through tough times. It's awesome! We even went on another camping trip in the forest.\"\n- Result 25 (2023-07-20): Melanie says, \"Yeah, they sure are. It's special moments like these that make me appreciate life and how lucky I am to be with my family and have our love.\"\n- Result 60 (2023-07-06): Melanie shares a pic of her family camping and says, \"We love it, it brings us closer!\"\n- Result 48 (2023-10-20): Melanie says about her kids after an accident, \"",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.41,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.59
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Melanie do after the road trip to relax?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Went on a nature walk or hike",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the road trip and accident context.  \n- Melanie mentioned a road trip with an accident involving her son on October 20, 2023 (Results 16, 25).  \n- Caroline asked how the kids handled the accident and mentioned the road trip (Results 13, 14, 55).  \n\nStep 2: Look for what Melanie did after the road trip to relax.  \n- Melanie said they did something the day after the road trip (approximately October 19, 2023) that the kids loved and was a nice way to relax (Result 27).  \n- Caroline responded about nature refreshing them and R&R after the drive (Result 98).  \n\nStep 3: Determine what the relaxing activity was.  \n- Result 1 mentions Melanie spending peaceful, tranquil time with family in nature.  \n- Result 27 implies the relaxing activity was a family outing the day after the road trip.  \n- Result 98 confirms nature was involved",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-26",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.9,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.56
    },
    {
      "question": "When Jon has lost his job as a banker?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "19 January, 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify any direct mentions of Jon losing his job as a banker.  \n- Result 5 [2023-01-20]: Jon to Gina says he lost his job as a banker \"yesterday,\" which would be approximately January 19, 2023.  \n- Result 18 [2023-01-20]: Gina acknowledges Jon lost his job \"this month,\" confirming the timing in January 2023.\n\nStep 2: Confirm no other conflicting dates or mentions.  \n- No other messages contradict this date.\n\nFinal answer:  \nJon lost his job as a banker on January 19, 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-30",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.11,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.18
    },
    {
      "question": "When Gina has lost her job at Door Dash?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "January, 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Gina losing her job at Door Dash.  \n- Result 1 (2023-03-16): Gina says, \"Since I lost my job at Door Dash, things have been tough.\"  \n- Result 30 (2023-01-20): Gina says, \"Unfortunately, I also lost my job at Door Dash this month.\"  \n- Result 72 (2023-04-25): Gina says, \"After losing my job, I wanted to take control...\" (implying it happened before this date)  \n- Result 87 (2023-06-16): Gina says, \"I've been one 'cause I lost my job. I opened an online clothing store...\" (indicating the job loss was before June 16)  \n\nStep 2: Narrow down the timeframe.  \n- Result 30 is dated January 20, 2023, and Gina says she lost her job \"this month,\" meaning January 202",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-30",
      "answer_latency_s": 5.56,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.75
    },
    {
      "question": "How do Jon and Gina both like to destress?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "by dancing",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of how Jon likes to destress.\n- Result 24 (2023-05-11): Jon says, \"Dancing helps me de-stress. It's where I'm most alive. It's a must-have in my life.\"\n- Result 33 (2023-02-08): Jon says, \"Dance gives me an escape to be myself.\"\n- Result 94 (2023-07-23): Jon mentions dancing has kept him going during stressful times.\n\nStep 2: Identify mentions of how Gina likes to destress.\n- Result 13 (2023-01-29): Gina advises Jon to \"take breaks and dance it out when you need to destress!\"\n- Result 34 (2023-05-11): Gina says, \"Dance is just me -- I can't picture life without it. It's like air.\"\n\nStep 3: Synthesize the information.\nBoth Jon and Gina use dancing as a way to destress and find relief",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-30",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.98,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.82
    },
    {
      "question": "What do Jon and Gina both have in common?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "They lost their jobs and decided to start their own businesses.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for mentions of shared interests or experiences between Jon and Gina.\n\n- Result 1 (2023-03-16): Jon says, \"It's great we both face the same challenges, it motivates us and it's like having a partner to dance with!\"\n- Result 74 (2023-03-16): Gina says, \"Yep! We're both on different paths, but it's nice to have someone to root for us.\"\n- Result 14 (2023-03-16): Gina says, \"Let's keep chasing our dreams, supporting each other, and celebrating achievements.\"\n- Result 38 (2023-02-08): Gina says, \"Chasing our dreams and helping each other out.\"\n- Result 63 (2023-02-08): Jon says, \"Dance gives me an escape to be myself.\"\n- Result 27 (2023-05-11): Gina says, \"Dance is just me -- I can't picture life without it. It's",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-30",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.1,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.71
    },
    {
      "question": "Why did Jon decide to start his dance studio?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "He lost his job and decided to start his own business to share his passion.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Jon mentions in [Result 6] (2023-01-20) that dancing has been his passion and escape since he was a kid, and he wants to start a dance studio to teach others the joy that dancing brings him.\n\nStep 2: In [Result 11] (2023-05-11), Jon says losing his job gave him the push to finally start his dream business, his own dance studio.\n\nStep 3: In [Result 78] (2023-02-08), Jon explains that taking risks and leaving his secure 9-5 banking job motivated him to turn his passion for dancing into a business.\n\nStep 4: In [Result 77] (2023-05-11), Jon says he wants to create a place for people to dance and express themselves, which has been a dream of his.\n\nSynthesizing these points: Jon decided to start his dance studio because dancing has been his lifelong passion and escape",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-30",
      "answer_latency_s": 4.28,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.63
    },
    {
      "question": "What Jon thinks the ideal dance studio should look like?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "By the water, with natural light and Marley flooring",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify any direct mentions by Jon about his ideal dance studio.\n\n- Result 23 [2023-01-20T16:13:30] Jon to Gina: \"Wow, that must've been great! Check my ideal dance studio by the water.\"\n- Result 84 [2023-01-29T14:34:30] Jon to Gina: \"It's downtown which is awesome cuz it's easy to get to. Plus the natural light! Gotta check the size & floor quality too. We need a good dance floor with enough bounce for me & my students to dance safely.\"\n- Result 49 [2023-01-29T14:35:30] Jon to Gina: \"Yeah, good flooring's crucial. I'm after Marley flooring, which is what dance studios usually use. It's great 'cause it's grippy but still lets you move, plus it's tough and easy to keep clean.\"\n\nStep 2: Synthesize these details.\n\n- Location",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-30",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.0,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.83
    },
    {
      "question": "When is Jon's group performing at a festival?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "February, 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Jon's group performing at a festival.  \n- Result 16 (2023-01-20): Jon says they are finishing choreography to perform at a nearby festival next month.  \n- Result 2 and 3 (2023-01-20): They confirm the group is performing at the festival.  \n- Result 27 (2023-02-08): Jon mentions the festival performance already happened and it was awesome.\n\nStep 2: Determine the timing of the festival.  \n- On 2023-01-20, Jon says the festival is \"next month,\" which would be February 2023.  \n- By 2023-02-08, Jon refers to the festival performance as having already occurred.\n\nFinal answer:  \nJon's group performed at the festival in February 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-30",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.66,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.64
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Gina launch an ad campaign for her store?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "29 January, 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify any mention of Gina launching an ad campaign.  \n- Result 1 (2023-01-29) Gina to Jon: \"I just launched an ad campaign for my clothing store...\"  \n\nStep 2: Confirm no other earlier or later specific mentions of launching an ad campaign.  \n- Result 16 (2023-04-03) Gina mentions new offers and promotions, but not specifically launching an ad campaign.  \n- Result 99 (2023-04-03) Gina talks about plans for ads in the next few months, implying the initial campaign was earlier.  \n\nStep 3: The earliest and explicit mention of launching an ad campaign is in Result 1 on January 29, 2023.\n\nFinal answer: Gina launched an ad campaign for her store around January 29, 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-30",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.11,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.56
    },
    {
      "question": "When was Jon in Paris?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "28 January 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify any mention of Jon being in Paris.  \n- In [Result 12] (2023-01-29), Jon says: \"I even found a place with great natural light! Oh, I've been to Paris yesterday (approximately January 28, 2023)! It was sooo cool.\"\n\nStep 2: Confirm the date of the message to understand the reference to \"yesterday.\"  \n- The message is dated 2023-01-29, so \"yesterday\" would be 2023-01-28.\n\nFinal answer:  \nJon was in Paris on January 28, 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-30",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.97,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.36
    },
    {
      "question": "Which city have both Jean and John visited?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Rome",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of cities visited by Jon and Gina (Jean is likely a typo for Gina).\n\n- Jon mentions visiting Paris on January 28, 2023 (Result 3).\n- Jon mentions a short trip to Rome around June 12, 2023 (Result 8).\n- Gina mentions she has been to Rome once (Result 1).\n\nStep 2: Check if both have visited the same city.\n\n- Jon has been to Paris and Rome.\n- Gina has been to Rome once but never to Paris.\n\nStep 3: Conclusion.\n\nBoth Jon and Gina have visited Rome.\n\nFinal answer: Both Jon and Gina have visited Rome.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-30",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.66,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.11
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Gina team up with a local artist for some cool designs?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "February, 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for mentions of Gina working with an artist on designs.  \nStep 2: Result 11 [2023-02-08] Gina to Jon says: \"I got the idea from a fashion mag and saw there wasn't much around like it. So I worked with the artist to make it happen...\"  \nStep 3: This indicates Gina teamed up with a local artist before or around early February 2023, as the message is dated 2023-02-08.  \n\nFinal answer: Gina teamed up with a local artist for some cool designs by early February 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-30",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.86,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.73
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Gina get her tattoo?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "A few years ago",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Jon asks Gina on 2023-02-08 if she just got her tattoo (Result 1).\n\nStep 2: Gina replies on the same day that she got the tattoo a few years ago (Result 2).\n\nStep 3: Gina also mentions on 2023-02-08 that the tattoo is a reminder to stay positive through tough times (Result 31).\n\nNo exact date is given, but \"a few years ago\" indicates it was not recent as of early 2023.\n\nFinal answer: Gina got her tattoo a few years before February 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-30",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.64,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.51
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Jon start to go to the gym?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "March, 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step-by-step reasoning:\n\n1. Look for any mention of Jon going to the gym.\n2. In Result 14 [2023-03-16T14:35:00], Jon says: \"Been hectic for me lately. Started hitting the gym last week (approximately March 09, 2023) to stay on track with the venture.\"\n3. This clearly states Jon started going to the gym around March 9, 2023.\n\nFinal answer:  \nJon started going to the gym around March 9, 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-30",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.04,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.18
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Gina open her online clothing store?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "16 March, 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Gina opening her online clothing store.\n\n- Result 19 [2023-03-16]: Gina says, \"Yay! My online clothes store is open! I've been dreaming of this for a while now.\"\n- Result 31 [2023-04-25]: Gina says, \"Oh, and BTW, I started my own online clothing store not so long ago.\"\n- Result 2 [2023-03-23]: Gina refers to her store as already running, describing it as a \"roller coaster but rewarding.\"\n- Result 28 [2023-06-16]: Gina says she opened an online clothing store after losing her job.\n\nStep 2: The earliest explicit statement about the store being open is from March 16, 2023 (Result 19).\n\nStep 3: Earlier messages from January and February mention plans and preparations but not that the store was open yet.\n\nConclusion: Gina opened her online clothing store by March ",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-30",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.02,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.71
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Jon start expanding his studio's social media presence?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "April, 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for mentions of Jon expanding or working on social media for his dance studio.\n\nStep 2: In Result 88 (2023-04-03), Jon says: \"I'm expanding my dance studio's social media presence and offering workshops and classes to local schools and centers.\"\n\nStep 3: This is the earliest explicit mention of expanding social media presence.\n\nStep 4: Later mentions (Results 56, 57, 73) show continued work on social media but no earlier date than April 3, 2023.\n\nFinal answer: Jon started expanding his studio's social media presence by at least early April 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-30",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.9,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.56
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Jon host a dance competition?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "May, 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for mentions of Jon hosting or organizing a dance competition.\n\nStep 2: In [Result 26] dated 2023-04-03, Jon says: \"I'm also hosting a dance competition next month to showcase local talent and bring more attention to my studio.\"\n\nStep 3: The message is from April 3, 2023, so \"next month\" refers to May 2023.\n\nStep 4: No other mentions specify a different date for hosting a competition.\n\nFinal answer: Jon hosted a dance competition in May 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-30",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.99,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.72
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Jon go to a fair to get more exposure for his dance studio?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "24 April, 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Jon attending a fair or festival for exposure.  \n- Result 73 (2023-02-08): Jon mentions a festival performance where many people complimented his dance moves, which reminded him why he's passionate about dance.  \n- Result 54 (2023-04-03): Jon talks about a dance competition next month to showcase local talent and bring attention to his studio.  \n- Result 89 (2023-02-04): Jon says he is getting ready for a dance competition near him next month to show his skills and get recognition.\n\nStep 2: Determine which event was specifically for exposure.  \n- The festival mentioned in Result 73 is described as a performance with many people attending and compliments received, implying exposure.  \n- The competition mentioned in Result 54 is planned for the future (from April 3, 2023) and is also for showcasing talent and attention.  \n- The competition in Result 89 (February ",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-30",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.03,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.08
    },
    {
      "question": "Why did Gina decide to start her own clothing store?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "She always loved fashion trends and finding unique pieces and she lost her job so decided it was time to start her own business.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for Gina's own statements about why she started the store.  \n- Result 35 (2023-03-16): Gina says she is passionate about fashion trends and finding unique pieces, and wanted to blend her love for dance and fashion, making it a perfect match.  \n- Result 25 (2023-02-08): Gina says she got the idea from a fashion magazine and noticed there wasn't much like it around, so she worked with an artist to create something different and ahead of the game.  \n- Result 33 (2023-06-16): Gina mentions she became an entrepreneur because she lost her job and wanted to be her own boss doing something she loves.  \n- Result 40 (2023-03-16): Gina says she had been dreaming of opening an online clothes store for a while.  \n\nStep 2: Synthesize these reasons:  \n- Passion for fashion and dance  \n- Desire to blend her interests creatively  \n-",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-30",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.6,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.43
    },
    {
      "question": "Do Jon and Gina start businesses out of what they love?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Yes",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify evidence that Jon started a business out of what he loves.\n- Result 33 (2023-05-11): Jon lost his job and started his dream business: a dance studio.\n- Result 47 (2023-04-09): Jon is turning his love of dance into a business.\n- Result 61 (2023-03-16): Jon says losing his job was hard but now he is living his dreams by starting his business.\n- Result 56 (2023-04-09): Jon says losing his job gave him the push to do what he loves.\n- Result 78 (2023-05-11): Jon says dancing is like second nature and he is living his dream by having his own dance studio.\n\nStep 2: Identify evidence that Gina started a business out of what she loves.\n- Result 11 (2023-06-16): Gina lost her job and opened an online clothing store, being her own boss",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-30",
      "answer_latency_s": 5.05,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.78
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Gina interview for a design internship?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "10 May, 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant excerpt about Gina's design internship interview.  \n- Result 4 [2023-05-11T15:20:30] Gina to Jon: \"Oh, btw, I had an interview for a design internship yesterday (approximately May 10, 2023)! It was so cool.\"\n\nStep 2: Confirm the date of the message to understand the \"yesterday\" reference.  \n- The message is dated May 11, 2023, so \"yesterday\" refers to May 10, 2023.\n\nFinal answer: Gina interviewed for a design internship on May 10, 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-30",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.28,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.57
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Gina get accepted for the design internship?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "27 May, 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Gina's internship acceptance or interview.\n\n- Result 2 (2023-05-27): Gina says she \"just got accepted for a fashion internship.\"\n- Result 7 (2023-05-11): Gina mentions having an interview for a design internship \"yesterday,\" approximately May 10, 2023.\n- Result 8 (2023-05-27): Gina confirms the internship is a part-time position in the fashion department.\n\nStep 2: Determine the timeline.\n\n- Gina had the interview on May 10, 2023.\n- By May 27, 2023, she says she \"just got accepted\" (Result 2).\n- This suggests she was accepted sometime between May 10 and May 27, 2023.\n\nFinal answer: Gina got accepted for the design internship between May 10 and May 27, 2023, likely shortly before May 27, 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-30",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.02,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.37
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Jon start reading \"The Lean Startup\"?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "May, 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant excerpt mentioning Jon reading \"The Lean Startup.\"  \n- Result 1 [2023-05-27T19:20:30] Jon to Gina: \"I'm currently reading 'The Lean Startup' and hoping it'll give me tips for my biz.\"\n\nStep 2: The message timestamp is 2023-05-27 at 19:20:30, and Jon says he is \"currently reading\" the book at that time.\n\nStep 3: There is no earlier mention of Jon reading the book, so the earliest confirmed time he started reading it is on or just before 2023-05-27.\n\nFinal answer:  \nJon started reading \"The Lean Startup\" around May 27, 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-30",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.41,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.59
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Gina develop a video presentation to teach how to style her fashion pieces? ",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "June, 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant excerpt mentioning Gina developing a video presentation.  \n- Result 6 [2023-06-13T20:30:30] Gina to Jon: \"I have developed a video presentation to teach how to style my fashion pieces, btw.\"\n\nStep 2: Note the date of this message: June 13, 2023.\n\nStep 3: No other excerpts mention an earlier or later time for this video presentation development.\n\nFinal answer: Gina developed the video presentation to teach how to style her fashion pieces by June 13, 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-30",
      "answer_latency_s": 4.0,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.63
    },
    {
      "question": "How did Gina promote her clothes store?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "worked with an artist to make unique fashion pieces, made limited-edition sweatshirts, got some new offers and promotions for online store, developed a video presentation showing how to style her pieces",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Gina launched an ad campaign to grow her clothing store (Result 3, 2023-01-29).\n\nStep 2: She used new offers and promotions to attract customers (Result 27, 2023-04-03; Result 100, 2023-04-03).\n\nStep 3: Gina planned to work with fashion bloggers and influencers to get more attention (Result 36, 2023-04-03).\n\nStep 4: She used social media channels and collaborated with influencers for bigger reach (Result 31, 2023-06-16).\n\nStep 5: Gina also did research and networking to source trendy pieces and expand her contacts, which helped her store (Result 56, 2023-07-21).\n\nStep 6: She developed a video presentation to teach how to style her fashion pieces (Result 61, 2023-06-13).\n\nFinal answer:  \nGina promoted her clothing store",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-30",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.09,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.82
    },
    {
      "question": "Which events has Jon participated in to promote his business venture?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "fair, networking events, dance competition",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Jon participating in events related to promoting his business.\n\n- Result 90 (2023-04-25): Jon attended a fair on April 24, 2023, to show off his studio, which was stressful but productive with possible leads.\n- Result 39 (2023-07-21): Jon attended a networking event where he met investors and got good advice.\n- Result 28 (2023-06-19): Gina congratulates Jon on the launch of his studio event happening the next day (June 20, 2023).\n- Result 62 (2023-04-03): Gina mentions a cool event Jon is involved in and expresses interest in joining.\n- Result 35 (2023-07-21): Gina congratulates Jon on a successful night, likely referring to the networking event.\n- Result 53 (2023-07-21): Jon is working on an online platform to showcase the studio, possibly related",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-30",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.63,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.1
    },
    {
      "question": "What does Jon's dance studio offer?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "one-on-one metoring and training to dancers,  workshops and classes to local schools and centers",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of what Jon's dance studio offers.\n\n- [Result 28] (2023-06-13): Jon says he offers dance classes, workshops, and one-on-one mentoring and training to help dancers reach their full potential.\n- [Result 49] (2023-04-03): Jon mentions expanding social media presence, offering workshops and classes to local schools and centers, and hosting a dance competition to showcase local talent.\n- [Result 37] (2023-04-09): Jon talks about working with students and learning with them.\n- [Result 66] (2023-07-09): Jon is excited to guide and mentor aspiring dancers.\n- [Result 50] (2023-02-08): Jon loves running his own studio, helping dancers of all ages and levels express themselves.\n- [Result 63] (2023-06-13): Jon wants the studio to be a place of support and encouragement for",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-30",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.25,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.31
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Jon receive mentorship to promote his venture?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "15 June, 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for mentions of Jon receiving mentorship related to his business or venture.\n\nStep 2: In Result 92 (2023-06-16), Jon says: \"I got mentored by this amazing business dude yesterday (approximately June 15, 2023)! It was really inspiring and now I'm even more pumped to chase my dreams.\"\n\nStep 3: This is the only explicit mention of Jon receiving mentorship.\n\nFinal answer: Jon received mentorship to promote his venture around June 15, 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-30",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.03,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.4
    },
    {
      "question": "Did Jon and Gina both participate in dance competitions?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Yes",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for evidence that Jon participated in dance competitions.  \n- Result 31 (2023-01-20): Jon mentions his dance crew took first place in a local competition last year (around January 2022).  \n- Result 65 (2023-02-04): Jon is preparing for a dance competition near him next month.  \n\nStep 2: Look for evidence that Gina participated in dance competitions.  \n- Result 2 (2023-01-20): Gina says she used to compete in dance competitions and shows, with a favorite memory of winning first place at regionals at age 15.  \n- Result 14 (2023-04-09): Gina shares a trophy from a dance contest as a reminder of hard work and joy.  \n\nStep 3: Confirm both have direct experience in competitions.  \n- Jon has competed and won with his crew and is actively preparing for more competitions.  \n- Gina has competed and won in competitions in",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-30",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.55,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.52
    },
    {
      "question": "When was Jon in Rome?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "June 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify any mentions of Jon being in Rome in the context.\n\n- Result 1 (2023-01-29): Gina mentions Paris and Rome but no specific date for Jon.\n- Result 2 (2023-06-19): Jon says he took a short trip last week to Rome to clear his mind.\n- The message is dated 2023-06-19, so \"last week\" would be approximately June 12, 2023.\n\nStep 2: Confirm no other mentions contradict or add to this.\n\n- No other excerpts specify Jon being in Rome at a different time.\n\nFinal answer: Jon was in Rome around June 12, 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-30",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.08,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.54
    },
    {
      "question": "Which cities has Jon visited?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Paris, Rome",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for any mentions of cities Jon has visited in the conversation excerpts.\n\nStep 2: In Result 1 (2023-01-29), Gina mentions Paris and Rome, but says she has never been to Paris and only been to Rome once. This implies Jon might have mentioned Paris as a place he is considering or has been, but no direct confirmation Jon has visited Paris.\n\nStep 3: No other excerpts mention Jon visiting any specific cities.\n\nStep 4: Jon mentions an ideal dance studio by the water (Result 69), but no city is named.\n\nStep 5: No direct statement from Jon about cities he has visited.\n\nFinal answer: Not enough information to determine which cities Jon has visited.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-30",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.03,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.47
    },
    {
      "question": "When Jon is planning to open his dance studio?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "20 June, 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step-by-step reasoning:\n\n1. Early in the year (January-February 2023), Jon was still searching for a location for his dance studio (Results 5, 15, 27, 74, 99).\n\n2. By April 2023, Jon had a functioning studio with students and was expanding social media presence and hosting events (Results 3, 25, 41, 48).\n\n3. In mid-June 2023, Gina mentions a launch \"tomorrow\" and congratulates Jon on the studio looking amazing and the progress made (Results 31, 34).\n\n4. Jon confirms he is still working on opening the studio in June but also prepping more than ever (Results 17, 19).\n\n5. By July 2023, Jon is working on business plans, pitching investors, and developing an online platform, indicating the studio is not fully open yet (Results 18, 54, 57, 63, 64",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-30",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.98,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.75
    },
    {
      "question": "How long did it take for Jon to open his studio?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "six months",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify when Jon started working on the studio.  \n- On 2023-01-20, Jon mentions starting a dance studio as a dream and is looking for a location (Results 24, 71, 74, 98).  \n- On 2023-02-01, Jon says he is still searching for a place to open the studio (Result 65).  \n- On 2023-02-04, Jon confirms searching for a location is tricky (Result 22).  \n\nStep 2: Track progress over time.  \n- By 2023-04-09, Jon is sunk tons of time into the studio and has students (Result 69).  \n- On 2023-04-25, Jon attended a fair to show off the studio (Result 27).  \n- On 2023-06-13, Jon is prepping for the studio more than ever (Result 40).  \n- On 2023",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-30",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.19,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.1
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Gina design a limited collection of hoodies?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "June 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about Gina designing hoodies or collections.  \n- Result 1 [2023-06-21]: Gina says the hoodie is from her own collection, a limited edition line made last week (approximately June 14, 2023).  \n- No other excerpts mention a specific date for designing hoodies or collections.\n\nStep 2: Confirm the date of the limited edition line creation.  \n- Gina explicitly states it was made last week from June 21, 2023, which is approximately June 14, 2023.\n\nFinal answer:  \nGina designed a limited collection of hoodies around June 14, 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-30",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.25,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.45
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Jon visit networking events for his store?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "20 June, 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for mentions of Jon attending networking events.\n\n- Result 27 [2023-06-21T14:17:30] Jon to Gina: \"Yesterday (approximately June 20, 2023) I chose to go to networking events to make things happen.\"\n- Result 15 [2023-07-21T17:46:30] Jon to Gina: \"Lately I've been networking and it's gotten me some good stuff. Really can't beat what connections can do. Check this pic I got from the last networking event!\"\n\nStep 2: From Result 27, Jon explicitly states he attended networking events on June 20, 2023.\n\nStep 3: From Result 15, Jon mentions recent networking activity around July 21, 2023, implying ongoing attendance.\n\nFinal answer: Jon visited networking events starting at least on June 20, 2023, and continued networking through July 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-30",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.9,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.08
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Gina start being recognized by fashion editors?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "July 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for mentions of Gina being noticed or recognized by fashion editors.\n\nStep 2: In Result 50 (dated 2023-07-09), Gina says to Jon: \"Last week (approximately July 02, 2023) was wild, I got noticed by fashion editors and it's been amazing but kinda scary.\"\n\nStep 3: This is the only direct mention of Gina being recognized by fashion editors, specifying the timing as \"last week\" relative to July 9, 2023, which is approximately July 2, 2023.\n\nFinal answer: Gina started being recognized by fashion editors around July 2, 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-30",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.07,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.19
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Jon start learning marketing and analytics tools?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "July, 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify any mention of Jon learning marketing and analytics tools.  \nStep 2: In Result 2 (dated 2023-07-09), Jon says: \"Started to learn all these marketing and analytics tools to push the biz forward today.\"  \nStep 3: This indicates Jon began learning marketing and analytics tools on or around July 9, 2023.\n\nFinal answer: Jon started learning marketing and analytics tools around July 9, 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-30",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.5,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.44
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Jon and Gina decide to collaborate to create dance content?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "21 July 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for mentions of collaboration between Jon and Gina related to dance content.\n\nStep 2: Result 5 (2023-07-21T17:52:30) Jon to Gina says: \"Definitely, Gina! Let's make our collaboration awesome and bring some dance magic to the world.\"\n\nStep 3: Result 50 (2023-07-21T17:50:30) Jon to Gina says: \"Sounds great. I'd really appreciate your help with making content and managing my social media. Let's get together and make the dance studio look awesome!\"\n\nStep 4: Result 84 and 89 (both 2023-07-21) Gina and Jon express excitement about collaborating and making a difference together.\n\nStep 5: These messages are all from July 21, 2023, indicating that the decision to collaborate on dance content happened around that date.\n\nFinal answer: Jon and Gina decided to collaborate to create dance content around July 21,",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-30",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.36,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.83
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Gina mention Shia Labeouf?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": " 23 July, 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for mentions of \"Shia Labeouf\" in the context.\n\nStep 2: Found in Result 1: [2023-07-23T18:47:30] Gina to Jon: \"It's Shia Labeouf!\"\n\nStep 3: This is the only direct mention by Gina about Shia Labeouf.\n\nFinal answer: Gina mentioned Shia Labeouf on July 23, 2023, at 18:47:30.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-30",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.51,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.63
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Gina go to a dance class with a group of friends?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "21 July 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for any mention of Gina attending a dance class with friends.\nStep 2: In [Result 76] dated 2023-07-23, Gina says: \"Last Friday at dance class with a group of friends I felt it.\"\nStep 3: The message is from 2023-07-23, so \"last Friday\" would be 2023-07-21.\n\nFinal answer: Gina went to a dance class with a group of friends on Friday, July 21, 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-30",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.13,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.79
    },
    {
      "question": "What is Gina's favorite style of dance?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Contemporary",
      "generated_answer": "Step-by-step reasoning:\n\n1. In Result 1 (2023-01-20), Gina says: \"Contemporary dance is so expressive and graceful - it really speaks to me.\"\n2. In Result 5 (same date), Gina says dance is her go-to for stress relief but does not specify a style.\n3. In Result 54 (2023-04-09), Gina mentions she used to compete in a few dance competitions and shows, with a favorite memory winning first place at regionals at age fifteen, but no style is specified.\n4. No other excerpt explicitly states Gina's favorite dance style.\n5. The only direct mention of Gina's favorite style is contemporary dance in Result 1.\n\nFinal answer:  \nGina's favorite style of dance is contemporary dance.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-30",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.55,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.4
    },
    {
      "question": "What is Jon's favorite style of dance?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Contemporary",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for mentions of Jon's favorite dance style in the conversation excerpts.\n\nStep 2: In Result 13 (2023-01-20T16:07:30), Jon says: \"I love all dances, but contemporary is my top pick. It's so expressive and powerful!\"\n\nStep 3: This is a clear and direct statement of Jon's favorite dance style.\n\nFinal answer: Jon's favorite style of dance is contemporary.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-30",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.68,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.51
    },
    {
      "question": "What was Gina's favorite dancing memory?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Winning first place at a regionals dance competition",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Gina's favorite dancing memory in the context.  \n- Result 5 [2023-01-20]: Gina says her favorite memory was when her team won first place at a regional competition at age fifteen.  \n- Result 31 [2023-04-09]: Gina shares a trophy from a dance contest as a reminder of hard work and joy, which aligns with the competition memory.  \n- Result 64 [2023-06-16]: Gina mentions a tough but worth-it road in dancing, likely referring to her journey including competitions.\n\nStep 2: Confirm no other favorite memory is mentioned.  \nNo other specific favorite dancing memory from Gina is noted.\n\nFinal answer:  \nGina's favorite dancing memory was when her team won first place at a regional competition when she was fifteen.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-30",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.01,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.59
    },
    {
      "question": "What kind of dance piece did Gina's team perform to win first place?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "\"Finding Freedom\"",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify where Gina talks about her dance competition win.  \n- In [Result 1], Gina mentions her favorite memory was when her team won first place at a regionals at age fifteen.\n\nStep 2: Check if Gina specifies the dance style or piece her team performed.  \n- Gina does not specify the dance style or piece in [Result 1] or anywhere else in the excerpts.\n\nStep 3: Look for any indirect clues about Gina's dance style preferences.  \n- In [Result 10], Gina says contemporary dance is expressive and graceful and speaks to her.  \n- In [Result 63], Gina says dance is her go-to for stress relief and is asked about favorite styles, but no direct answer about the competition piece.\n\nStep 4: Check if Jon or Gina mention the style of Gina's winning piece.  \n- No mention of the specific dance piece or style performed by Gina's team at the competition.\n\nFinal answer: Not enough information to determine",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-30",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.88,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.52
    },
    {
      "question": "What do the dancers in the photo represent?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "They are performing at the festival",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify references to a photo with dancers and what it represents.\n\n- Result 1: Gina says the photo \"brings back lots of memories\" and that dance is still Jon's happy place.\n- Result 3: Jon says the photo shows dancers looking great and passionate about dancing, reminding him how much he loves performing.\n- Result 42: Gina says the dance studio looks awesome, referring to a photo.\n- Result 24: Jon shares a photo of them during one of the dance classes, highlighting student success and motivation.\n- Result 41: Gina shares a trophy photo as a reminder of hard work, dedication, and joy dance brings.\n- Result 51: Gina says Jon looks happy when he dances in the photo, encouraging him to show his true self.\n- Result 33: Jon says dancing is a way to express himself and find his happy place, overcoming fear of judgment.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the meaning of the dancers in the photo.\n\n",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-30",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.23,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.11
    },
    {
      "question": "What does Gina say about the dancers in the photo?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "They look graceful",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of a photo involving dancers from Gina's messages.\n\n- Result 24 (2023-06-16): Gina says, \"Wow, that's an awesome pic! You guys look great and passionate about dancing. Reminds me how much I love performing. Thanks for sharing!\"\n- Result 69 (2023-01-20): Gina says, \"Wow, it looks awesome! Are they yours at the festival? They're so graceful!\"\n- Result 71 (2023-04-09): Gina says, \"Yeah, I do remember those dance classes! That photo looks awesome, brings back lots of memories.\"\n- Result 57 (2023-04-03): Gina says, \"Check out this pic of my fave dance session!\"\n- Result 54 (2023-04-09): Gina says, \"Here's one of my trophies from a dance contest, nice reminder of the hard work, dedication and joy it brings.\"\n\nStep 2: Focus",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-30",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.26,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.71
    },
    {
      "question": "What is Jon's attitude towards being part of the dance festival?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Glad",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of the dance festival in the context.\n\n- Result 26 (2023-01-20): Gina asks Jon about dances he practices and projects planned.\n- Result 37 (2023-01-20): Jon says the dancers are performing at the festival, practicing hard and will impress.\n- Result 40 (2023-01-20): Jon rehearsed with a small group, finishing choreography for a festival next month, excited.\n- Result 85 (2023-01-20): Gina is excited about the dancers rocking the festival.\n- Result 97 (2023-01-20): Gina compliments the dancers at the festival.\n\nStep 2: Look for Jon's expressed feelings or attitude about the festival.\n\n- Result 37: Jon is confident about the dancers' grace and skill.\n- Result 40: Jon is \"super stoked\" about the chance to show his skills and get recognition from the dance community.\n- Result 39",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-30",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.81,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.54
    },
    {
      "question": "What kind of flooring is Jon looking for in his dance studio?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Marley flooring",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of flooring in the context.  \n- Result 1: Jon says he is after Marley flooring, which dance studios usually use. He describes it as grippy, allows movement, tough, and easy to clean.  \n- Result 12: Jon mentions needing a good dance floor with enough bounce for safety.  \n- Result 24: Gina confirms Marley flooring is perfect with the right grip and movement.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.  \nJon specifically wants Marley flooring for his dance studio because it is suitable for dancing\u2014grippy yet allows movement, tough, easy to clean, and has enough bounce for safety.\n\nFinal answer:  \nJon is looking for Marley flooring for his dance studio because it provides the right grip, movement, durability, and safety for dancers.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-30",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.42,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.95
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Gina find for her clothing store on 1 February, 2023?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "The perfect spot for her store",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify messages around 1 February 2023 mentioning Gina and her clothing store.\n\n- Result 5 [2023-02-01T00:51:00] Jon to Gina: \"Your store looks great - your customers will be so comfy.\"\n- Result 6 [2023-02-01T00:49:00] Jon to Gina: \"Wow, Gina! You found the perfect spot for your store. Way to go, hard work's paying off!\"\n- Result 32 [2023-02-01T00:50:00] Jon to Gina: \"Wow, it looks great! Must've taken you ages to design it. What made you pick out the furniture and decor?\"\n\nStep 2: These messages indicate that on or by 1 February 2023, Gina had found a perfect spot for her store and had chosen furniture and decor, implying she found a location and designed the store's interior.\n\nStep 3: No",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-30",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.08,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.79
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Gina design for her store?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "the space, furniture, and decor",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for mentions of Gina's store and what she designed or sells.  \n- Result 1: Jon praises Gina's commitment and creativity in her business and asks about her cool designs.  \n- Result 23: Gina says she got the idea from a fashion magazine and worked with an artist to create a unique fashion piece for her store, aiming to be ahead of the game and offer something different.  \n- Result 36 and 37: Gina mentions blending her love for dance and fashion, combining them in her store, including dance-inspired items.  \n- Result 38: Gina acquired some new unique pieces for her store.  \n- Result 58: Gina describes choosing furniture and decor for her store to make it cozy and stylish, including a chandelier for glam.  \n- Result 30 and 40: Gina talks about launching an online clothing store and the challenges of starting a business.  \n- Result 14 and 76: Gina talks about designs that reflect grit and",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-30",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.16,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.46
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Gina want her customers to feel in her store?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "cozy and comfortable",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts where Gina talks about her store and customer experience.\n\n- Result 26 [2023-02-01T00:51:30] Gina to Jon: \"Making my spot comfortable and inviting for my customers is key. I want 'em to feel like they're in a cool oasis. Just creating an experience that'll make 'em wanna come back.\"\n\n- Result 58 [2023-02-01T00:52:30] Gina to Jon: \"Thanks. Your support means a lot. I'm sure with my hard work and effort, I can make a special shopping experience for my customers. It's tough but I'm up for the challenge!\"\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.\n\nGina wants her customers to feel comfortable, invited, and like they are in a \"cool oasis,\" creating a special experience that encourages them to return.\n\nFinal answer:  \nGina wanted her customers to feel comfortable and like they were in a cool oasis, creating a",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-30",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.51,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.91
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Jon say about Gina's progress with her store?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "hard work's paying off",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Gina's store progress by Jon.\n\n- [Result 2] (2023-02-01): Jon says, \"Wow, Gina! You found the perfect spot for your store. Way to go, hard work's paying off!\"\n- [Result 21] (2023-04-25): Jon says, \"Your store looks great, I remember it!\"\n- [Result 29] (2023-01-29): Jon says, \"Whoa, your store looks great! All your hard work really paid off - congrats!\"\n- [Result 42] (2023-06-21): Jon says, \"Congrats on your store, Gina! Happy for you! It looks sick - is it a unique piece you're selling?\"\n- [Result 59] (2023-04-03): Jon mentions shutting down his bank account for his biz but also asks Gina, \"Anything new for you?\" implying interest in her progress.\n",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-30",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.91,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.85
    },
    {
      "question": "What made Gina choose the furniture and decor for her store?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "personal style and customer comfort",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about Gina's choice of furniture and decor.\n\n- Result 1 (Jon to Gina, 2023-02-01): Jon asks what made Gina pick out the furniture and decor.\n- Result 5 (Gina to Jon, 2023-02-01): Gina replies it took time, she wanted the place to reflect her own style and make customers feel cozy. She chose furniture that looks great and is comfy. The chandelier adds glam and matches the store style.\n- Result 20 (Gina to Jon, 2023-02-01): Gina says the spot is cozy and inviting, perfect for customers to check out trendy pieces.\n- Result 35 (Gina to Jon, 2023-02-01): Gina emphasizes making the spot comfortable and inviting, creating an experience that makes customers want to come back.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.\n\nGina chose furniture and decor to reflect her personal style, create",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-30",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.75,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.12
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Jon say about creating a special experience for customers?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "It's the key to making them feel welcome and coming back",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about Jon's comments on creating a special experience for customers.\n\n- Result 1 [2023-02-01]: Jon to Gina: \"That's a great goal! Creating a special experience for customers is the key to making them feel welcome and coming back. I think you can create that space you're imagining.\"\n- Result 47 [2023-02-01]: Jon to Gina: \"I'm always here to support you! Go create something awesome with your store. Keep it up!\"\n\nStep 2: Summarize Jon's view from these excerpts.\n\nJon emphasized that creating a special experience for customers is essential to make them feel welcome and encourage repeat visits. He expressed confidence that Gina could create the inviting space she envisioned.\n\nFinal answer:  \nJon said that creating a special experience for customers is key to making them feel welcome and encouraging them to come back, and he believed Gina could create the space she was imagining.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-30",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.37,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.64
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Gina say about creating an experience for her customers?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "making them want to come back",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts where Gina talks about creating an experience for her customers.\n\n- Result 5 [2023-02-01T00:51:30] Gina to Jon: \"Thanks! Making my spot comfortable and inviting for my customers is key. I want 'em to feel like they're in a cool oasis. Just creating an experience that'll make 'em wanna come back.\"\n\n- Result 53 [2023-02-01T00:52:30] Gina to Jon: \"Thanks. Your support means a lot. I'm sure with my hard work and effort, I can make a special shopping experience for my customers. It's tough but I'm up for the challenge!\"\n\nStep 2: Summarize Gina's statements.\n\nGina emphasized making her store comfortable and inviting, aiming to create a \"cool oasis\" atmosphere that encourages customers to return. She also expressed confidence that with hard work, she can create a special shopping experience despite the challenges.\n\nFinal answer:  \n",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-30",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.75,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.97
    },
    {
      "question": "How is Gina's store doing?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "The store is doing great.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Multiple messages from Jon and Gina mention the store doing well and growing:\n- [Result 11] Gina says on 2023-02-04: \"The store's doing great! It's a wild ride.\"\n- [Result 17] Gina on 2023-04-03: \"I got some new offers and promotions going on my online store to try and bring in new customers.\"\n- [Result 45] Gina on 2023-06-21: \"I have acquired some new unique pieces for my store.\"\n- [Result 83] Gina on 2023-07-21: \"Last week, I built a new website for customers to make orders. It's been a wild ride but I'm loving it.\"\n\nStep 2: Jon consistently congratulates Gina and encourages her, indicating progress and success:\n- [Result 4] Jon on 2023-06-21: \"Congrats on your store, Gina! Happy for you! It",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-30",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.19,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.7
    },
    {
      "question": "What does Gina's tattoo symbolize?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Freedom and expressing herself through dance",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Gina's tattoo in the context.\n\n- Result 10 (2023-02-08): Gina says the quote she tattooed kept her positive through tough times and is a push to keep going.\n- Result 1 (2023-02-08): Gina says she got the tattoo a few years ago, and it stands for freedom\u2014dancing without worrying what people think. It is a reminder to follow her passions and express herself.\n- Result 11 (2023-02-08): Jon agrees it is a nice reminder about freedom and self-expression.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.\n\nGina's tattoo symbolizes freedom, specifically the freedom to dance without worrying about others' opinions. It also serves as a personal reminder to follow her passions and express herself, helping her stay positive through tough times.\n\nFinal answer:  \nGina's tattoo symbolizes freedom\u2014dancing without worrying what people think\u2014and serves as a reminder to follow her passions and",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-30",
      "answer_latency_s": 4.21,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.74
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Jon and Gina compare their entrepreneurial journeys to?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "dancing together and supporting each other",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for mentions of Jon and Gina discussing their entrepreneurial journeys and any metaphors or comparisons they used.\n\nStep 2: In Result 3 [2023-03-16T14:42:00], Jon says to Gina: \"It's great we both face the same challenges, it motivates us and it's like having a partner to dance with!\"\n\nStep 3: This is a direct comparison of their entrepreneurial journeys to dancing with a partner.\n\nStep 4: No other metaphor or comparison is as clear or specific as this one in the context.\n\nFinal answer:  \nJon and Gina compared their entrepreneurial journeys to dancing with a partner.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-30",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.43,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.45
    },
    {
      "question": "What advice does Gina give to Jon about running a successful business?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "build relationships with customers, create a strong brand image, stay positive",
      "generated_answer": "Step-by-step analysis of Gina's advice to Jon about running a successful business:\n\n1. From [Result 5] (2023-02-08), Gina says taking risks is scary but necessary for growth and success.\n2. From [Result 14] (2023-06-16), Gina advises using social media channels and working with influencers for marketing reach.\n3. From [Result 20] (2023-06-21), Gina encourages perseverance and hard work, telling Jon not to quit when things get rough.\n4. From [Result 28] (2023-04-25), Gina suggests staying motivated by focusing on the big goal, why you\u2019re doing it, getting support from others, and using dance as a stress relief.\n5. From [Result 43] (2023-04-25), Gina emphasizes the importance of confidence, reminding oneself of successes and progress, having a support system, and focusing on the love for the business.\n6.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-30",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.58,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.24
    },
    {
      "question": "Why did Jon shut down his bank account?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "for his business",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Jon mentions shutting down his bank account on 2023-04-03 (Result 1), saying it was tough but necessary for his business.\n\nStep 2: There is no direct explanation of why shutting down the bank account was needed, but Jon is clearly focused on his business and facing challenges after losing his job (Result 35).\n\nStep 3: The context suggests Jon is restructuring or making tough decisions to support his new business venture, possibly to manage finances better or start fresh.\n\nFinal answer: Jon shut down his bank account because it was a tough but necessary step to support and focus on his business.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-30",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.5,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.65
    },
    {
      "question": "Why did Gina combine her clothing business with dance?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "she is passionate about dance and fashion",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts where Gina explains her reason for combining clothing and dance.\n\n- Result 5 (2023-04-03): Gina says, \"I'm passionate about dance and fashion so combining them lets me show my creativity and share my love with others. Plus, I can add dance-inspired items to my store!\"\n- Result 9 (2023-03-16): Gina says, \"I'm passionate about fashion trends and finding unique pieces. Plus, I wanted to blend my love for dance and fashion, so it was a perfect match.\"\n- Result 38 (2023-04-03): Gina says, \"Dance is my stress relief and fashion fuels my creativity. I love finding new trends for my store. It keeps me motivated to keep growing.\"\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the reasons Gina gave.\n\nGina combined her clothing business with dance because she is passionate about both and wants to express her creativity by blending them. This combination allows her to share her love",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-30",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.69,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.47
    },
    {
      "question": "What does Jon's dance make him?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "happy",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for mentions of how Jon feels or what dance does for him.\n\n- Result 2 (2023-04-09): Gina says Jon looks happy when he dances.\n- Result 24 (2023-05-11): Jon says dancing is like second nature to him and that he is living his dream by having his own dance studio and teaching others.\n- Result 26 (2023-05-11): Jon says dance is his stress-buster since childhood.\n- Result 33 (2023-04-09): Jon says dancing is a way to express himself and find his happy place.\n- Result 42 (2023-05-11): Jon says dancing helps him de-stress and is where he feels most alive.\n- Result 54 (2023-04-09): Jon says dancing makes him happy and sharing it with others brings him joy.\n- Result 40 (2023-02-08): Jon says dance gives him an",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-30",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.59,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.57
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Gina receive from a dance contest?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "a trophy",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Gina and dance contests or competitions.  \n- Result 6 (2023-01-20): Gina says she used to compete in dance competitions and her favorite memory was winning first place at a regional competition at age fifteen.  \n- Result 14 (2023-04-09): Gina sends Jon a photo of one of her trophies from a dance contest, calling it a nice reminder of hard work, dedication, and joy.  \n- Result 67 (2023-06-16): Gina shares a picture from her dancing days, mentioning it was a tough road but worth it.  \n- Result 69 (2023-06-16): Jon comments on a photo Gina shared, appreciating the passion shown.\n\nStep 2: Confirm what Gina received from the dance contest.  \n- Result 14 explicitly states Gina has a trophy from a dance contest.  \n- Result 6 supports this by mentioning winning first place at a regional competition.\n\nFinal answer",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-30",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.1,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.23
    },
    {
      "question": "How does Gina stay confident in her business?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "By reminding herself of her successes and progress, having a support system, and focusing on why she started",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts where Gina talks about confidence or motivation in business.\n\n- Result 54 [2023-04-25]: Gina to Jon says she stays motivated by reminding herself of her successes and progress, having a good support system, and focusing on why she started because she loves it. She encourages Jon to have faith in himself.\n\n- Result 86 [2023-02-04]: Gina to Jon says setbacks are opportunities for comebacks, and she has skills, passion, drive, and full support, implying these help her stay confident.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize Gina's approach to confidence.\n\nGina stays confident by focusing on her past successes and progress, relying on a strong support system, remembering her love for what she does, and viewing setbacks as chances to come back stronger.\n\nFinal answer:  \nGina stays confident in her business by reminding herself of her successes and progress, relying on a good support system, focusing on her love for the work,",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-30",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.72,
      "judge_latency_s": 3.9
    },
    {
      "question": "What kind of professional experience did Gina get accepted for on May 23, 2023?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "fashion internship",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the date and event related to Gina's acceptance.\n- Result 45 [2023-05-27]: Gina says, \"Hey Jon! Long time no talk! A lot's happened - I just got accepted for a fashion internship!\"\n\nStep 2: Confirm the timing and details.\n- Result 4 [2023-05-27]: Jon congratulates Gina on the fashion internship.\n- Result 6 [2023-05-27]: Gina explains it is a part-time position in the fashion department of an international company.\n\nStep 3: The question asks about May 23, 2023, but the closest message is from May 27, 2023, where Gina mentions just getting accepted. It is reasonable to conclude the acceptance happened around that date.\n\nFinal answer:  \nGina got accepted for a part-time fashion internship in the fashion department of an international company around May 23, 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-30",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.38,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.31
    },
    {
      "question": "Where is Gina's fashion internship?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "fashion department of an international company",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Gina's fashion internship in the context.  \n- Result 2 (2023-05-27): Gina says she just got accepted for a fashion internship.  \n- Result 4 (2023-05-27): Gina says it is a part-time position in the fashion department of an international company.  \n- No other excerpt specifies the company name or location.\n\nStep 2: Check if any other excerpt gives more details about the internship location or company.  \n- No mention of the company name or city/country is found.  \n- The only detail is that it is part-time and with an international company.\n\nFinal answer: Gina's fashion internship is a part-time position in the fashion department of an international company, but the exact location or company name is not provided.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-30",
      "answer_latency_s": 5.26,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.25
    },
    {
      "question": "What book is Jon currently reading?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "The Lean Startup",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for any mention of Jon reading a book in the context.  \nStep 2: Result 35 shows Jon to Gina on 2023-05-27: \"Yeah, the book got me thinking about building a focused and efficient business. Adapting and tweaking from customer feedback is important too, so I'm gonna try it out!\"  \nStep 3: Result 69 on the same date from Jon to Gina says: \"I'm currently reading 'The Lean Startup' and hoping it'll give me tips for my biz.\"\n\nFinal answer: Jon is currently reading \"The Lean Startup.\"",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-30",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.71,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.32
    },
    {
      "question": "What is Jon offering to the dancers at his dance studio?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "One-on-one mentoring and training",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts where Jon talks about what he offers at his dance studio.\n\n- Result 14 [2023-06-13]: Jon says, \"Besides the dance classes and workshops, I'm offering one-on-one mentoring and training to help dancers reach their full potential.\"\n- Result 45 [2023-07-09]: Jon mentions being \"excited to guide and mentor aspiring dancers on their dreams.\"\n- Result 49 [2023-04-03]: Jon talks about expanding social media presence, offering workshops and classes to local schools and centers, and hosting a dance competition.\n- Result 39 [2023-06-13]: Jon says he wants the studio to be a place of support and encouragement for all dancers.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.\n\nJon offers dance classes, workshops, one-on-one mentoring and training, guidance and support to help dancers reach their full potential, and organizes events like dance competitions to showcase talent.\n\nFinal answer:  \n",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-30",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.13,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.56
    },
    {
      "question": "How does Jon use the clipboard with a notepad attached to it?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "To set goals, track achievements, and find areas for improvement",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Jon using organizational tools.  \n- Result 1 (2023-06-13): Jon mentions using a whiteboard to stay on track, visualize goals, and tokenize successes.  \n- Result 32 (2023-06-13): Jon says he uses the whiteboard to stay organized and motivated, set goals, track achievements, and find areas to improve.  \n- Result 79 (2023-05-27): Jon says the whiteboard helps him keep track of ideas and milestones, gives a visual of progress, and keeps him organized.\n\nStep 2: Check if there is any mention of a clipboard with a notepad attached.  \n- No direct mention of a clipboard with a notepad is found in the conversation excerpts.\n\nStep 3: Since the question is about a clipboard with a notepad, and the only organizational tool Jon explicitly mentions is a whiteboard, there is no information on how Jon uses a clipboard with a notepad",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-30",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.94,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.57
    },
    {
      "question": "What does Jon tell Gina he won't do?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "quit",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify statements where Jon mentions what he won't do.  \n- Result 10 (2023-06-16): \"I'm not giving up.\"  \n- Result 21 (2023-07-23): \"I won't quit. I'm gonna keep going, whatever comes my way.\"  \n- Result 29 (2023-07-09): \"I won't quit, even when it's hard.\"  \n- Result 38 (2023-02-04): \"I won't give up!\"  \n- Result 59 (2023-03-23): \"I won't quit - your words motivate me to keep going!\"  \n\nStep 2: Synthesize these statements.  \nJon repeatedly tells Gina that he will not give up or quit despite challenges.\n\nFinal answer:  \nJon tells Gina that he won't give up or quit.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-30",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.46,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.78
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Jon take a trip to Rome for?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "To clear his mind",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify any mention of Jon traveling to Rome.  \n- Result 2 (2023-06-19) states Jon took a short trip last week (around June 12, 2023) to Rome to \"clear my mind a little.\"\n\nStep 2: Confirm the purpose of the trip.  \n- Jon explicitly says the trip was to \"clear my mind a little,\" indicating it was for mental relaxation or a break.\n\nNo other context contradicts or adds to this.\n\nFinal answer:  \nJon took a trip to Rome around June 12, 2023, to clear his mind and relax.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-30",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.67,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.36
    },
    {
      "question": "What is Jon working on opening?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "a dance studio",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for mentions of what Jon is working on opening.\n\n- Result 2 (2023-06-19): Jon says, \"The official opening night is tomorrow,\" referring to his project.\n- Result 13 (2023-06-19): Gina congratulates Jon on the studio and the launch tomorrow.\n- Result 18 (2023-06-19): Gina asks, \"When are you opening the studio?\"\n- Result 21 (2023-04-09): Gina says, \"The dance studio looks awesome.\"\n- Result 44 (2023-07-21): Gina congratulates Jon on a successful night and asks about plans.\n- Result 85 (2023-06-19): Jon says, \"Still working on opening a dance studio.\"\n- Result 98 (2023-04-09): Jon says, \"I'm determined to make this studio work.\"\n- Result 79 (2023-03-23): Gina mentions Jon",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-30",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.24,
      "judge_latency_s": 3.3
    },
    {
      "question": "How does Gina describe the studio that Jon has opened?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "amazing",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify all mentions of Gina describing Jon's dance studio.\n\n- Result 2 (2023-04-09): Gina says, \"The dance studio looks awesome.\"\n- Result 16 (2023-06-19): Gina says, \"Congrats, Jon! The studio looks amazing.\"\n- Result 39 (2023-06-19): Gina says, \"Can't wait for tomorrow's grand opening!\"\n- Result 50 (2023-04-03): Gina says, \"Wow! That's fantastic that your studio's expanding and giving dancers an outlet.\"\n- Result 62 (2023-06-19): Gina says, \"Can't wait to make more memories at your dance studio!\"\n- Result 95 (2023-06-19): Gina says, \"I love being around friends and having such a great time. Can't wait to have fun at your dance studio!\"\n\nStep 2: Summarize Gina's descriptions.\n\nGina uses positive adjectives like \"",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-30",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.9,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.58
    },
    {
      "question": "How does Jon feel about the opening night of his dance studio?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "excited",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of the opening night and Jon's feelings about it.\n\n- Result 10 (2023-06-19): Gina says Jon must be excited and that tomorrow's going to be a blast, encouraging him to savor the moment.\n- Result 37 (2023-06-19): Gina congratulates Jon, says the studio looks amazing, and is pumped for the launch tomorrow.\n- Result 38 (2023-06-19): Jon says he is still working on opening the studio.\n- Result 92 (2023-06-19): Jon says the official opening night is tomorrow, he is working hard to make everything just right, and can't wait to see it all come together.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize Jon's feelings.\n\nJon expresses anticipation and excitement about the opening night, working hard to prepare and looking forward to the event.\n\nFinal answer:  \nJon feels excited and eager about the opening night of his dance studio, working hard to prepare",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-30",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.09,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.8
    },
    {
      "question": "How does Gina describe the feeling that dance brings?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "magical",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify excerpts where Gina talks about the feeling dance brings.\n\n- Result 5 (2023-01-20): Gina says contemporary dance is \"so expressive and graceful - it really speaks to me.\"\n- Result 46 (2023-05-11): Gina says \"Dance is just me -- I can't picture life without it. It's like air.\"\n- Result 49 (2023-02-08): Gina says \"Dancing lets us be ourselves and ain't nothing like the feeling it gives us.\"\n- Result 50 (2023-02-08): Gina mentions her tattoo stands for freedom - \"dancing without worrying what people think,\" a reminder to follow passions and express herself.\n- Result 53 (2023-04-09): Gina says dance is \"awesome for expressing yourself and finding happiness.\"\n- Result 61 (2023-05-11): Gina says dance is her \"stress fix\" and \"It's amazing what we can do for our",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-30",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.41,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.74
    },
    {
      "question": "What does Jon plan to do at the grand opening of his dance studio?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "savor all the good vibes",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of the grand opening in the context.  \n- Result 42 (2023-06-19): Gina says the studio looks amazing and is pumped for the launch tomorrow.  \n- Result 43 (2023-06-19): Gina asks Jon when he is opening the studio.  \n- Result 79 (2023-06-19): Gina says \"Can't wait for tomorrow's grand opening!\"  \n- Result 15 (2023-06-19): Gina tells Jon tomorrow's gonna be a blast and to savor it.  \n- Result 91 (2023-06-19): Jon says \"Yeah! Let's make some awesome memories tomorrow at the grand opening!\"\n\nStep 2: Look for Jon's plans or activities for the grand opening.  \n- Result 15: Gina encourages Jon to capture the joy and thrill that dance brings.  \n- Result 91: Jon expresses excitement to make awesome memories at the grand opening.  \n- Result",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-30",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.33,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.96
    },
    {
      "question": "What does Gina say to Jon about the grand opening?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Let's live it up and make some great memories",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify all messages mentioning the grand opening.\n\n- Result 1 (2023-06-19): Gina to Jon: \"Can't wait for tomorrow's grand opening!\"\n- Result 2 (2023-06-19): Jon to Gina: \"Yeah! Let's make some awesome memories tomorrow at the grand opening!\"\n- Result 6 (2023-06-19): Jon to Gina: \"Woohoo! Tomorrow's opening will be so much fun. Can't wait for it - and for you to be there!\"\n- Result 27 (2023-06-19): Gina to Jon: \"Can't wait too!\"\n- Result 63 (2023-06-19): Gina to Jon: \"Wow, Jon, you must be so excited! You've come so far since we last talked, and tomorrow's gonna be a blast! All those long nights were worth it - so take some time to savor it. Capture the joy and thrill that dance brings - it's magical",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-30",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.9,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.78
    },
    {
      "question": "What is the general sentiment about the upcoming grand opening?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "excitement",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify messages about the grand opening and their tone.\n\n- Result 1 (Gina): \"Can't wait for tomorrow's grand opening!\" \u2014 excited, positive.\n- Result 2 (Jon): \"Let's make some awesome memories tomorrow at the grand opening!\" \u2014 enthusiastic, positive.\n- Result 3 (Jon): \"The official opening night is tomorrow. I'm working hard... Can't wait to see it all come together!\" \u2014 hopeful, excited.\n- Result 4 (Jon): \"Tomorrow's opening will be so much fun. Can't wait for it - and for you to be there!\" \u2014 excited, looking forward.\n- Result 5 (Gina): \"Congrats, Jon! The studio looks amazing... pumped for the launch tomorrow.\" \u2014 supportive, excited.\n- Result 69 (Gina): \"Wow, Jon, you must be so excited! ... tomorrow's gonna be a blast! ... take some time to savor it.\" \u2014 very positive, encouraging.\n- Result",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-30",
      "answer_latency_s": 4.32,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.79
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Gina make a limited edition line of?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Hoodies",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant excerpt about Gina making a limited edition line.  \n- Result 40 [2023-06-21T14:16:00] Gina to Jon: \"Thanks! This hoodie isn't for sale, it's from my own collection. I made a limited edition line last week (approximately June 14, 2023) to show off my style and creativity - it was tough but worth it!\"\n\nStep 2: From this, Gina made a limited edition line of hoodies as part of her own collection.\n\nFinal answer:  \nGina made a limited edition line of hoodies.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-30",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.1,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.66
    },
    {
      "question": "According to Gina, what makes Jon a perfect mentor and guide?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "His positivity and determination",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify where Gina praises Jon as a mentor and guide.  \n- Result 2 (2023-07-09): Gina says, \"You're definitely the perfect mentor & guide. Your positivity and determination will make your dance studio a hit!\"\n\nStep 2: Extract the qualities Gina attributes to Jon that make him a perfect mentor and guide.  \n- Positivity  \n- Determination\n\nStep 3: Confirm if other excerpts support these qualities.  \n- Result 81 (Jon to Gina): Jon acknowledges Gina's support helps him keep pushing.  \n- Result 68 (Gina to Jon): Gina calls Jon inspiring with determination and passion for dance.  \n- Result 3 (Gina to Jon): Gina notes Jon's one-on-one mentoring and training push dancers to reach goals.\n\nStep 4: Synthesize the answer.  \nGina considers Jon a perfect mentor and guide because of his positivity, determination, and his ability to provide one-on-one mentoring that helps dancers",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-30",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.81,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.0
    },
    {
      "question": "What plans does Jon have after receiving advice at the networking event?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Sprucing up his business plan, tweaking his pitch to investors, and working on an online platform.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant messages about Jon's plans after the networking event.\n\n- Result 7 (2023-07-21T17:46:30) Jon to Gina: He mentions networking has gotten him good stuff and shares a pic from the last event.\n- Result 64 (2023-07-21T17:47:30) Jon to Gina: He says the event was awesome, met investors, got good advice, and feels motivated.\n- Result 3 (2023-07-21T17:48:00) Gina to Jon: Asks about Jon's plans after the event.\n- Result 90 (2023-07-21T17:48:30) Jon to Gina: He says he is sprucing up his business plan, tweaking his pitch to investors, and working on an online platform to showcase the dance studio.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.\n\nAfter the networking event, Jon plans to improve his business plan",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-30",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.61,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.77
    },
    {
      "question": "What offer does Gina make to Jon regarding social media?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Helping with making content and managing his social media accounts.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of social media in Gina's messages to Jon.\n\n- Result 1 (2023-06-16): Gina advises Jon to use social media channels and work with influencers for bigger reach.\n- Result 3 (2023-07-21): Gina says, \"Let's create some cool content and manage your social media accounts.\"\n- Result 17 (2023-07-21): Gina offers help with Jon's online platform and asks if he needs help with anything.\n- Result 21 (2023-07-21): Gina enthusiastically agrees to collaborate.\n- Result 19 (2023-06-16): Jon asks Gina if she has thought about being an entrepreneur, after her social media advice.\n- Result 20 (2023-07-21): Jon responds positively to Gina's offer to help with content and social media management.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the offer.\n\nGina offers to help Jon by creating content and managing his social",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-30",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.82,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.59
    },
    {
      "question": "Who did Maria have dinner with on May 3, 2023?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "her mother",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify any mention of Maria having dinner around May 3, 2023.\n\nStep 2: Result 99 [2023-05-04T15:25:30] Maria to John says: \"Wow, John! It's great when you have that kind of support. My mom and I made some dinner together last night!\"\n\nStep 3: The message is dated May 4, 2023, and \"last night\" would be May 3, 2023.\n\nStep 4: Therefore, Maria had dinner with her mom on May 3, 2023.\n\nFinal answer: Maria had dinner with her mom on May 3, 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 4.13,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.42
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Maria donate her car?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "21 December 2022",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify any mention of Maria donating her car in the context.\n\n- Result 15 [2022-12-22T18:10:00] Maria to John: \"I donated my old car to a homeless shelter I volunteer at yesterday (approximately December 21, 2022).\"\n\nStep 2: Confirm no other conflicting or additional information about the car donation.\n\n- No other messages mention Maria donating her car.\n\nFinal answer:  \nMaria donated her car around December 21, 2022.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.15,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.49
    },
    {
      "question": "What martial arts has John done?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Kickboxing, Taekwondo",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of martial arts John has done.\n- Result 4 (2022-12-22): John says, \"I'm off to do some taekwondo!\"\n- Result 29 (2022-12-17): John says, \"I'm doing kickboxing and it's giving me so much energy.\"\n- Result 1 (2023-07-22): John mentions the place offers \"kickboxing\" among other classes.\n- Result 13 (2022-12-17): Maria asks John about goals related to kickboxing, implying he does kickboxing.\n\nStep 2: Confirm no other martial arts mentioned.\n- No other martial arts styles are mentioned by John.\n\nFinal answer: John has done taekwondo and kickboxing.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.83,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.71
    },
    {
      "question": "What type of volunteering have John and Maria both done?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Volunteering at a homeless shelter",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify Maria's volunteering activities:\n- Maria has been volunteering at a homeless shelter since about August 2022 (Result 1, 4, 16, 23, 34, 58).\n- She has organized meals and events for shelter residents (Result 19, 34, 60).\n- She has given talks at the homeless shelter (Result 34).\n- She volunteers at the shelter front desk (Result 58).\n\nStep 2: Identify John's volunteering activities:\n- John has volunteered at homeless shelters giving out food and supplies (Result 12).\n- He helped renovate a community center last year (Result 29).\n- He set up a 5K charity run to help veterans and their families (Result 9, 28, 96).\n- He volunteers as a mentor for a local school (Result 31).\n- He participated in community events and helped veterans (Results 32, 38, 43, 83).\n- He",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.7,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.45
    },
    {
      "question": "When did John join the online support group?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "The week before 1 January 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about John joining an online support group.\n\n- Result 2 [2023-01-01]: John says he joined a service-focused online group last week, approximately December 25, 2022.\n- Result 39 [2022-12-22]: Maria asks John about his networking and conversations, indicating the group was active around that time.\n- Result 68 [2023-01-01]: John expresses excitement about the group.\n\nStep 2: Confirm the date of joining.\n\nJohn explicitly states on 2023-01-01 that he joined the group \"last week,\" which is approximately December 25, 2022.\n\nFinal answer:  \nJohn joined the online support group around December 25, 2022.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.51,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.36
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Maria go to the beach?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "December 2022",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Maria going to the beach.\n- Result 2 (2023-01-01): Maria says she took a beach photo last month, approximately December 2, 2022.\n- Result 1 (2023-06-16): John references a beach photo Maria shared and reminisces about a past beach vacation.\n- Result 4 (2023-05-25): John shares a beach photo of his family, but this is not Maria's trip.\n\nStep 2: Confirm the date of Maria's beach visit.\n- Result 2 clearly states Maria took the beach photo last month from the message date January 1, 2023, which places her beach visit around early December 2022.\n\nFinal answer:  \nMaria went to the beach around early December 2022.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.96,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.36
    },
    {
      "question": "Where has Maria made friends?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "homeless shelter, gym, church",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Maria making friends.\n- Result 2 (2022-12-22): Maria says her family is small but she loves spending time with the friends she has, doing activities like movies, hiking, and game nights.\n- Result 63 (2023-01-09): Maria says she is now friends with one of her fellow volunteers.\n- Result 48 (2023-03-06): Maria talks about forming connections by listening and showing compassion, implying friendships formed through volunteering or community work.\n\nStep 2: Look for specific places or contexts where these friendships were made.\n- Result 63 indicates Maria made friends through volunteering.\n- Result 2 suggests Maria\u2019s friends are people she spends quality time with at her place or on activities.\n- Result 48 supports that Maria\u2019s friendships are connected to her volunteer or community involvement.\n\nFinal answer:  \nMaria has made friends through volunteering and community involvement, as well as by spending quality time with them during activities",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.81,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.44
    },
    {
      "question": "What items des John mention having as a child?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "A doll, a film camera",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify any mentions of John's childhood or items he had as a child in the context.\n\nStep 2: Review the excerpts for any direct references to John's childhood possessions.\n\nStep 3: In Result 22 (2023-02-05), Maria says: \"Thanks, John. When I was younger, we had some money problems and had to rely on outside help from our auntie.\" This is about Maria's childhood, not John's.\n\nStep 4: No other excerpts mention John specifically talking about items he had as a child.\n\nStep 5: There is no direct mention of items John had as a child in the provided context.\n\nFinal answer: Not enough information.",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.95,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.37
    },
    {
      "question": "What might John's financial status be?",
      "category": 3,
      "gold_answer": "Middle-class or wealthy",
      "generated_answer": "Step-by-step reasoning:\n\n1. In Result 21 (2023-04-10), John mentions his car broke down and it was putting a strain on his wallet, indicating some financial difficulty.\n\n2. In Result 74 (2023-08-05), John says he lost his job at the mechanical engineering company because the company tanked, which would likely worsen his financial situation.\n\n3. In Result 42 (2023-08-05), Maria expresses sympathy for John's job loss and asks how he is holding up, implying concern about his financial and emotional state.\n\n4. Earlier, in Result 66 (2023-02-05), John talks about unemployment in the community and helping with a food drive, which may reflect awareness of financial struggles around him.\n\n5. There is no mention of John having a new job or improved financial status after the job loss.\n\nFinal answer:  \nJohn is currently experiencing financial difficulties due to his car troubles earlier in the year and losing his",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.91,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.19
    },
    {
      "question": "Who gave Maria's family money when she was younger and her family was going through tough times?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Her aunt",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant excerpt about Maria's family receiving money during tough times.\n\nStep 2: Result 2 [2023-02-05T14:37:00] Maria to John states: \"When I was younger, we had some money problems and had to rely on outside help from our auntie.\"\n\nStep 3: This clearly indicates that Maria's aunt provided financial help to her family during their difficult period.\n\nFinal answer: Maria's aunt gave her family money when they were going through tough times.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.95,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.5
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Maria meet Jean?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "February 24, 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify any mention of \"Jean\" in the conversation excerpts.  \nStep 2: Review all excerpts for any reference to meeting Jean or timing related to Jean.  \nStep 3: No excerpt mentions the name \"Jean\" or any meeting involving Jean.  \n\nFinal answer: Not enough information.",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.46,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.16
    },
    {
      "question": "What people has Maria met and helped while volunteering?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "David, Jean, Cindy, Laura",
      "generated_answer": "Step-by-step reasoning:\n\n1. Maria started volunteering at a homeless shelter around August 3, 2022 (Result 1).\n2. She has met and helped various people at the shelter, including:\n   - A woman going through a tough time with divorce, job loss, and homelessness, who still values kindness (Result 7).\n   - A woman named Jean, who had been through a lot but stayed optimistic and resilient, teaching Maria about gratitude and connection (Result 48).\n   - A shelter resident named Laura, who wrote a letter expressing gratitude for the help received (Result 20).\n3. Maria also mentioned meeting an amazing woman while volunteering yesterday (Feb 24, 2023) who inspired her (Result 48).\n4. She has helped many shelter residents by organizing meals, giving talks, and volunteering at the front desk, providing food and beds (Results 2, 23, 62).\n5. Maria has formed connections with fellow volunteers and residents,",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.8,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.33
    },
    {
      "question": "What test has John taken multiple times?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "The military aptitude test",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of John taking a test.  \n- Result 1 (2023-03-06): John retook the aptitude test last week (around Feb 27, 2023) with great results.  \n- Result 6 (2023-01-01): John mentions failing the military aptitude test recently (around Dec 25, 2022).\n\nStep 2: Confirm if it's the same test mentioned multiple times.  \n- Both mentions refer to an aptitude test related to military service.  \n- John failed it around Dec 25, 2022, then retook it around Feb 27, 2023.\n\nFinal answer:  \nJohn has taken the military aptitude test multiple times.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.16,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.85
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Maria's grandmother pass away?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "The week before 6 March 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant excerpt mentioning Maria's grandmother's passing.  \n- Result 42 [2023-03-06]: Maria to John says, \"Last week (approximately February 27, 2023), my grandma passed away and it's been really hard.\"\n\nStep 2: Confirm the date of the message to understand the timing of \"last week.\"  \n- The message is dated March 6, 2023.  \n- \"Last week\" from March 6, 2023, would be around the last week of February 2023.\n\nStep 3: Maria approximates the date as February 27, 2023.\n\nFinal answer:  \nMaria's grandmother passed away around February 27, 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.43,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.08
    },
    {
      "question": "Would John be considered a patriotic person?",
      "category": 3,
      "gold_answer": "Yes",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: John expresses great respect for the military and a desire to support veterans (Results 1, 15, 27, 36, 71, 81, 89).\n\nStep 2: He participated in a marching event for veterans' rights and worked on projects to support veterans, showing active involvement in patriotic causes (Results 15, 14, 81).\n\nStep 3: John mentions his time in the military and the bond he felt, indicating personal experience and commitment (Results 7, 27).\n\nStep 4: He talks about wanting to serve his country and community, including running for office to make an impact (Results 22, 41, 25).\n\nStep 5: John\u2019s motivation is tied to honoring those who served and making a difference in his community, which aligns with patriotic values (Results 1, 36, 71).\n\nFinal answer: Yes, John would be considered a patriotic person based on his respect for the military",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 6.72,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.79
    },
    {
      "question": "What writing classes has Maria taken?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Poetry, creative writing",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify any mentions of Maria taking writing classes in the context.\n\nStep 2: Result 6 [2023-02-25T20:55:00] Maria to John states: \"I took a creative writing class recently (approximately February 18, 2023), and it was super enlightening!\"\n\nStep 3: No other writing classes taken by Maria are mentioned in the context.\n\nFinal answer:  \nMaria has taken a creative writing class around February 18, 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.02,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.67
    },
    {
      "question": "When did John get his degree?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "The week before 2 April 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify any direct mentions of John's graduation date or timeframe.\n\n- Result 4 [2023-04-02]: John says, \"I graduated last week (approximately March 26, 2023)!\"\n\nStep 2: Confirm no other conflicting information about the graduation date.\n\n- Result 1 and 4 show Maria congratulating John on finishing his degree on April 2, 2023, and John confirms he graduated about a week before that date.\n\nNo other messages contradict this.\n\nFinal answer: John got his degree around March 26, 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.54,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.37
    },
    {
      "question": "What might John's degree be in?",
      "category": 3,
      "gold_answer": "Political science, Public administration, Public affairs",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: John talks about his passion for improving education and infrastructure in the community (Results 3, 17, 60).\n\nStep 2: Maria congratulates John on finishing his degree around late March 2023 (Results 2, 15).\n\nStep 3: John mentions considering going into policymaking because of his degree and passion for making a positive impact (Result 13).\n\nStep 4: John is involved in community meetings discussing education and infrastructure upgrades (Result 79).\n\nStep 5: John is interested in education reform, infrastructure development, and community empowerment (Results 3, 14, 60).\n\nStep 6: The degree likely relates to public policy, education, or community development given his focus on policymaking and community improvement.\n\nFinal answer: John's degree is likely in a field related to public policy or community development with a focus on education and infrastructure.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.62,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.65
    },
    {
      "question": "Who did John go to yoga with?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Rob",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of John attending yoga classes.\n- Result 10 (2023-04-07): John says he started a weekend yoga class with a colleague.\n- Result 6 (2023-02-25): John mentions a colleague Rob invited him to a beginner's yoga class.\n\nStep 2: Check if John mentions going with anyone else.\n- Result 10: John says \"I started a weekend yoga class with a colleague\" but does not name the colleague.\n- Result 6: The colleague is named Rob, who invited John.\n\nStep 3: Check if John mentions going with Maria.\n- No direct mention of John going to yoga with Maria.\n- Maria encourages John to try yoga and mentions her own aerial yoga, but no indication they attend together.\n\nStep 4: Conclusion.\nJohn went to yoga with a colleague named Rob.\n\nFinal answer: John went to yoga with his colleague Rob.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.83,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.69
    },
    {
      "question": "What damages have happened to John's car?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Broken windshield, Car broke down",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of John's car and any damages.\n- Result 2 (2023-04-10): John says his car broke down last Friday on his way to work, causing financial strain.\n- Result 1 (2023-05-06): John mentions roadways full of potholes that can be dangerous and damaging to cars.\n- Result 5 (2023-01-09): John mentions handling a situation calmly and making it back safely, possibly related to a car incident.\n- Result 52 (2023-01-09): John refers to an unexpected incident on his way home around January 2, 2023.\n- Result 47 (2023-01-09): Maria asks how John handled the incident.\n- Result 32 (2023-01-09): John felt relieved to make it through without incident.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.\n- The main explicit damage mentioned is the car breaking down on April 7",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.85,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.6
    },
    {
      "question": "When did John take a road trip to the Pacific Northwest?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "2022",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the mention of John's road trip to the Pacific Northwest.\n- Result 2 [2023-04-10]: John says, \"We explored the coast up in the Pacific Northwest and hit some cool national parks.\"\n\nStep 2: Check for any time references around this message.\n- Result 25 [2023-05-04]: John mentions planning a trip to the East Coast and references \"approximately April 11, 2023\" as the time of the message.\n- Result 7 [2023-04-10]: Maria asks John where he went on the road trip, indicating the trip was recent or ongoing around early April 2023.\n\nStep 3: No explicit date is given for the road trip, but the conversation about it is on April 10, 2023, and John refers to it in past tense, so the trip likely happened shortly before April 10, 2023.\n\nFinal answer: John took the road trip to",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.0,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.4
    },
    {
      "question": "What areas of the U.S. has John been to or is planning to go to?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Pacific northwest, east coast",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of places John has been to or plans to visit in the U.S.\n\n- Result 13 (2023-04-10): John mentions exploring the Pacific Northwest coast and national parks.\n- Result 20 (2023-04-18): John says he is planning a trip to the East Coast.\n- Result 36 (2023-07-07): John mentions his old area, West County, was hit by a flood.\n- Result 55 (2023-05-06): John wants to work on improving his old area, West County.\n- Result 45 (2023-03-06): John retook an aptitude test and feels drawn to serving his country, implying some connection to the U.S., but no specific location mentioned.\n- Result 92 (2023-08-09): John set up a 5K charity run in their neighborhood (location unspecified).\n\nStep 2: Summarize the areas mentioned.\n\n-",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.93,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.42
    },
    {
      "question": "When did John go to a convention with colleagues?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "March 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant excerpt about John going to a convention with colleagues.  \n- Result 1 [2023-04-18]: John to Maria says, \"My colleagues and I went to a convention together last month (approximately March 19, 2023).\"\n\nStep 2: Confirm the date of the convention.  \n- John explicitly states it was \"last month\" relative to April 18, 2023, which places the convention around March 19, 2023.\n\nFinal answer:  \nJohn went to a convention with colleagues around March 19, 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.82,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.19
    },
    {
      "question": "What desserts has Maria made?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Banana split sundae, Peach cobbler",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of desserts Maria has made in the context.\n\n- Result 1 (2023-05-04): Maria mentions enjoying a banana split sundae.\n- Result 8 (2022-12-22): Maria says she made some peach cobbler recently (around December 15, 2022).\n- Result 71 (2023-05-04): Maria mentions making dinner with her mom, but no dessert specified.\n- Result 2 and 5 (2022-12-22): John and Maria talk about making pizza, no dessert mentioned.\n- Result 3 (2023-05-04): John mentions making apple pie, but that was John, not Maria.\n\nStep 2: Summarize desserts Maria has made.\n\n- Peach cobbler (around December 15, 2022)\n- Banana split sundae (Maria's favorite dessert she enjoys after volunteering)\n\nNo other desserts made by Maria are mentioned.\n\nFinal answer:  \nMaria",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.78,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.65
    },
    {
      "question": "When did John start boot camp with his family?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "April.2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about John starting boot camp with his family.  \n- Result 1 [2023-05-04]: John says, \"I just started going to boot camps with my fam last month,\" which would be approximately April 04, 2023.\n\nStep 2: Confirm no other conflicting or more precise dates are given.  \n- No other messages specify a different start date for the boot camp.\n\nFinal answer: John started boot camp with his family in early April 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.52,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.28
    },
    {
      "question": "What European countries has Maria been to?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Spain, England",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Maria traveling to European countries in the context.\n\n- Result 7 (2023-05-04): Maria mentions a solo trip last year (2022) to Spain.\n- Result 3 (2023-03-06): John asks Maria about a place in England.\n- Result 85 (2023-03-06): Maria says she got an idea from a trip to England a few years ago, mesmerized by castles.\n\nStep 2: Confirm the countries mentioned are in Europe.\n\n- Spain and England are both European countries.\n\nStep 3: Check if any other European countries are mentioned.\n\n- No other European countries are referenced in the context.\n\nFinal answer:  \nMaria has been to Spain and England in Europe.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.25,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.03
    },
    {
      "question": "What has Maria done to feel closer to her faith?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Join a local church, buy a cross necklace",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Maria and her faith in the context.\n\n- Result 7 (2023-04-10): Maria mentions buying a cross necklace to feel closer to her faith.\n- Result 4 (2023-05-06): Maria says she joined a nearby church to feel closer to a community and her faith.\n- Result 18 (2023-04-10): Maria talks about nature helping put things in perspective but this is more about peace than faith.\n\nStep 2: Summarize the actions Maria took related to her faith.\n\n- She bought a cross necklace.\n- She joined a nearby church.\n\nFinal answer:  \nMaria has bought a cross necklace and joined a nearby church to feel closer to her faith.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.6,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.14
    },
    {
      "question": "When did John have a party with veterans?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "The Friday before 20 May 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of a party with veterans.\n- Result 4 [2023-05-20]: John to Maria says, \"We had a great time throwing a small party and inviting some veterans to share their stories.\"\n- Result 5 and 6 also relate to the same event, emphasizing the sense of community and gratitude.\n\nStep 2: Check for any date references around this event.\n- Result 1 [2023-05-20] mentions John working on a project to support veterans \"last week (approximately May 13, 2023).\"\n- Result 35 [2023-05-20] John says, \"Here's a pic from last Friday with some veterans who are really excited about this.\" Since the message is on May 20, 2023 (Saturday), \"last Friday\" would be May 19, 2023.\n\nStep 3: Synthesize the timing.\n- The party with veterans likely happened on Friday, May ",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.04,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.46
    },
    {
      "question": "What causes does John feel passionate about supporting?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Veterans, schools, infrastructure",
      "generated_answer": "Step-by-step reasoning:\n\n1. John mentions a strong urge to serve his country and community and running for office to make an impact (Result 41).\n2. He is involved in activism and politics focused on positive change and community support (Results 2, 24, 57).\n3. John has a deep respect for the military and veterans, participating in events supporting veterans' rights and showing appreciation for their sacrifices (Results 5, 30, 40, 61, 79, 93).\n4. He is involved in helping underserved communities with education, mentorship, job training, and resume building (Results 28, 76).\n5. John participates in charity events and volunteering, including homeless shelters and community food drives (Results 3, 46, 60, 62).\n6. He values community support, kindness, and helping others through small acts and collective efforts (multiple results including 10, 27, 53, 75).\n\nFinal answer:",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.62,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.48
    },
    {
      "question": "What events is Maria planning for the homeless shelter funraiser?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Chili cook-off, ring-toss tournament",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Maria planning events for the homeless shelter fundraiser.\n\n- Result 10 (2023-05-25): Maria says she is busy at the shelter getting ready for a fundraiser next week.\n- Result 17 (2023-05-20): Maria mentions planning a ring-toss tournament for the homeless shelter's fundraiser later that month.\n- Result 65 (2023-05-25): Maria shares a poster for a chili cook-off at the fundraiser.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.\n\nMaria is organizing a fundraiser for the homeless shelter that includes a ring-toss tournament and a chili cook-off event.\n\nFinal answer:  \nMaria is planning a ring-toss tournament and a chili cook-off as part of the homeless shelter fundraiser.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.22,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.46
    },
    {
      "question": "What shelters does Maria volunteer at?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "The homeless shelter, the dog shelter",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Maria volunteering at shelters.\n- Result 1: Maria started volunteering at a homeless shelter about August 3, 2022.\n- Result 4: Maria is still volunteering at the homeless shelter as of April 18, 2023.\n- Result 9: Maria mentions volunteering at a homeless shelter.\n- Result 13: Maria helped organize a meal for shelter residents.\n- Result 16: Maria gave talks at the homeless shelter she volunteers at.\n- Result 18: Maria volunteered at the homeless shelter and received a medal.\n- Result 28: Maria volunteered at the shelter front desk.\n- Result 31: A resident named Cindy at the shelter wrote a letter.\n- Result 32: Maria volunteers at a local dog shelter once a month.\n- Result 89: Maria met kids at the shelter.\n- Result 97: Maria dropped off baked goods at the homeless shelter.\n\nStep 2: Differentiate types of shelters.\n- The main",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.19,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.45
    },
    {
      "question": "When did John get his dog Max?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "In 2013",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: John mentions in Result 14 (2023-06-03) that Max was an important part of their family for 10 years and that they recently had to say goodbye to him.\n\nStep 2: Since the conversation about Max's passing is in June 2023, and Max was with them for 10 years, John must have gotten Max around 2013.\n\nStep 3: There is no exact date of when John got Max, but the 10-year duration mentioned is the key detail.\n\nFinal answer: John got his dog Max approximately 10 years before June 2023, around 2013.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 4.81,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.41
    },
    {
      "question": "What outdoor activities has John done with his colleagues?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Hiking, mountaineering",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of John doing outdoor activities with colleagues.\n- Result 18 (2023-06-12): John mentions going on a mountaineering trip last week (around June 5, 2023) with some workmates.\n- Result 13 (2023-04-10): John talks about exploring the coast in the Pacific Northwest and visiting national parks, but it\u2019s not explicitly stated if this was with colleagues.\n- Result 7 (2023-08-13): John mentions loving being outdoors with family, but no mention of colleagues.\n- Result 17 (2023-08-11): John mentions a camping trip with Max, presumably family, not colleagues.\n\nStep 2: Confirm the specific outdoor activity with colleagues.\n- The only clear mention of an outdoor activity with colleagues is the mountaineering trip around June 5, 2023.\n\nStep 3: Check if there are other outdoor activities with colleagues.\n- No other explicit mentions",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.53,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.11
    },
    {
      "question": "What types of yoga has Maria practiced?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Aerial, kundalini",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Maria practicing yoga in the excerpts.\n\n- Result 4 (2022-12-17): Maria says she just started doing aerial yoga.\n- Result 14 (2023-06-12): Maria mentions enjoying aerial yoga.\n- Result 15 (2023-06-12): Maria again praises aerial yoga.\n- Result 8 (2023-06-16): Maria says she is trying kundalini yoga.\n- Result 80 (2023-06-12): Maria mentions enjoying upside-down poses, which are common in aerial yoga.\n\nStep 2: Confirm no other types of yoga are mentioned by Maria.\n\n- No other yoga styles are mentioned by Maria besides aerial yoga and kundalini yoga.\n\nFinal answer: Maria has practiced aerial yoga and kundalini yoga.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.72,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.99
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Maria join a gym?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "The week before 16 June 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify any mention of Maria joining a gym.  \n- Result 7 [2023-06-16]: Maria says she joined a gym last week (approximately June 09, 2023).\n\nStep 2: Confirm no other conflicting or additional information about the gym joining date.  \n- No other messages contradict or specify a different date.\n\nFinal answer:  \nMaria joined a gym around June 9, 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.48,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.3
    },
    {
      "question": "What states has Maria vacationed at?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Oregon, Florida",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Maria's vacations or trips in the context.\n\n- Result 44 (2023-01-01): Maria took a photo at the beach last month (approx. Dec 2, 2022), implying a beach location but no state mentioned.\n- Result 53 (2023-05-04): Maria took a solo trip to Spain last year (approx. May 4, 2022) \u2014 not a U.S. state.\n- Result 58 (2023-06-12): Maria mentions a family road trip to Oregon when John talks about mountaineering.\n- Result 98 (2023-05-04): John comments on Maria's trip and asks if she learned anything meaningful, but no new location is given.\n- Result 44 and 53 are the only direct mentions of Maria's trips with locations: Spain (international) and Oregon (U.S. state).\n\nStep 2: Check if any other states are mentioned",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.09,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.63
    },
    {
      "question": "What music events has John attended?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Live music event, violin concert",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of music events in the context.\n\n- Result 1 (2023-03-06): John mentions finding a violin concert last week (around Feb 27, 2023) that they all enjoyed.\n- Result 5 (2023-06-27): John mentions attending a live music event last week (around June 20, 2023) with family, where they had a blast dancing and enjoying the energy.\n\nStep 2: Confirm no other music events mentioned.\n\n- No other explicit mentions of John attending music events were found.\n\nFinal answer:  \nJohn attended a violin concert around February 27, 2023, and a live music event around June 20, 2023, both of which he enjoyed with family.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.53,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.06
    },
    {
      "question": "What events for veterans has John participated in?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Petition, march, party, visiting veterans hospital, 5K charity run",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify all mentions of John participating in events related to veterans.\n\n- Result 1 (May 20, 2023): John worked on a project to support veterans around May 13, 2023.\n- Result 4 (July 3, 2023): John participated in a marching event for veterans' rights.\n- Result 14 (May 20, 2023): John helped throw a small party inviting veterans to share their stories.\n- Result 8 & 9 (July 17, 2023): John visited and heard stories from an elderly veteran named Samuel.\n- Result 32 (July 17, 2023): John visited a veteran's hospital around July 10, 2023.\n- Result 13 & 16 (August 9, 2023): John set up a 5K charity run to help veterans and their families.\n- Result 19 (August 3, 2023): John asked family",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.54,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.19
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Maria get in a car accident?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "July 2, 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify any mentions of a car accident involving Maria.  \n- Result 4 [2023-07-03]: Maria says a car ran a red light and hit them, but everyone is okay.  \n- Result 29 [2023-07-03]: John asks what happened after hearing about the tough time.  \n- Result 68 [2023-07-03]: Maria mentions something not so great happened yesterday (approximately July 2, 2023).  \n\nStep 2: Correlate the dates and events.  \n- The messages about the accident are all from July 3, 2023.  \n- Maria refers to \"yesterday\" as approximately July 2, 2023, when the accident happened.  \n\nFinal answer:  \nMaria got in a car accident on approximately July 2, 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.0,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.19
    },
    {
      "question": "Around which US holiday did Maria get into a car accident?",
      "category": 3,
      "gold_answer": "Independence Day",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the date of the car accident.\n- Result 3 (2023-07-03) Maria to John: \"A car ran a red light and hit us, but thankfully everyone is okay.\"\n- Result 34 (2023-07-03) Maria to John: \"She had to leave and find a new place in a hurry...\"\n- Result 14 (2023-07-03) John to Maria: \"That's so sad. Can I do anything to help? What happened?\"\n- Result 61 (2023-07-03) John to Maria: \"That's really nice of you. It's important to help family during hard times. How is she doing now?\"\n- Result 9 (2023-07-03) Maria to John: \"Any resources or organizations you know of that could help her out? Thanks!\"\n\nStep 2: The accident happened \"yesterday\" relative to July 3, 2023, so approximately July",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.52,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.41
    },
    {
      "question": "What are the names of John's children?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Kyle, Sara",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for mentions of John's children and their names in the conversation excerpts.\n\nStep 2: In Result 19 [2023-03-06T18:09:00], John tells Maria: \"Our one-year-old is so cute, his name is Kyle!\"\n\nStep 3: No other specific names of John's children are mentioned in the excerpts.\n\nFinal answer: John's child mentioned by name is Kyle.",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        true,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.37,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.47
    },
    {
      "question": "Does John live close to a beach or the mountains?",
      "category": 3,
      "gold_answer": "beach",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: John mentions a mountaineering trip he took around June 5, 2023 (Result 39), indicating he has access to mountains or at least can travel to them.\n\nStep 2: John also talks about beach vacations and shares beach pictures with Maria (Results 2, 7, 27), and mentions family time at the beach.\n\nStep 3: John describes exploring the Pacific Northwest coast and national parks (Result 8), which is a region known for both mountains and coastline.\n\nStep 4: John frequently mentions outdoor activities like hiking, camping, and beach visits (Results 13, 16, 36), suggesting proximity to natural areas including both mountains and beaches.\n\nStep 5: There is no explicit statement that John lives directly on the beach or in the mountains, but his frequent access to both types of environments and activities implies he lives near or within reasonable travel distance to both.\n\nFinal answer: John lives near areas where he can easily access",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.42,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.77
    },
    {
      "question": "What area was hit by a flood?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "West County",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of a flood in the context.  \n- Result 1 (2023-07-07): John mentions his old area was hit by a nasty flood last week (around June 30, 2023).  \n- Result 96 (2023-05-06): John mentions wanting to work on improving his old area, West County.\n\nStep 2: Check if the flood-hit area is named explicitly.  \n- Result 1 does not name the area directly but refers to it as \"my old area.\"  \n- Result 96 reveals John's old area is called West County.\n\nStep 3: Synthesize the information.  \nSince John refers to the flood hitting his old area and he calls his old area West County, it is reasonable to conclude that West County was the area hit by the flood.\n\nFinal answer:  \nJohn's old area, West County, was hit by the flood.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.92,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.37
    },
    {
      "question": "When was John's old area hit with a flood?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "The week before 7 July 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant excerpt mentioning the flood in John's old area.  \n- Result 1 [2023-07-07]: John to Maria says his old area was hit by a nasty flood last week (approximately June 30, 2023).\n\nStep 2: Confirm the date of the flood from the message timestamp and the \"last week\" reference.  \n- The message is dated July 7, 2023. \"Last week\" from July 7 would be around the end of June 2023.  \n- John approximates the flood date as June 30, 2023.\n\nFinal answer: John's old area was hit with a flood around June 30, 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.68,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.26
    },
    {
      "question": "What activities has Maria done with her church friends?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Hiking, picnic, volunteer work",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Maria doing activities with church friends.\n- Result 11 [2023-07-17]: Maria says, \"last weekend I had a picnic with some friends from church. We chilled under the trees, played games, and ate yummy food.\"\n\nStep 2: Check if there are any other mentions of activities with church friends.\n- No other explicit mentions of activities with church friends were found.\n\nFinal answer:  \nMaria had a picnic with her church friends where they chilled under the trees, played games, and ate yummy food.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.23,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.41
    },
    {
      "question": "Would John be open to moving to another country?",
      "category": 3,
      "gold_answer": "No, he has goals specifically in the U.S. like joining the military and running for office.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for any direct mentions of John considering moving to another country or expressing openness to it.\n\nStep 2: Check for any references to travel, relocation, or interest in other countries.\n\nStep 3: Review relevant excerpts:\n\n- Result 11 [2023-03-06]: John asks Maria, \"Where in England was it?\" showing interest in England but no indication of moving.\n\n- Result 83 [2023-03-06]: Maria mentions a trip to England a few years ago, but this is about Maria's experience, not John\u2019s plans.\n\n- Result 26 [2022-12-17]: John talks about chatting with local leaders and organizations for his next move, but this seems to be about community action, not relocation abroad.\n\n- Result 21 [2023-08-11]: John mentions exploring options like joining local organizations or volunteering programs, again local.\n\n- Result 47 [2023-08-13]: John talks about looking",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.66,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.67
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Maria go hiking with her church friends?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "The weekend before 22 July 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Maria hiking with church friends.\n- Result 16 [2023-07-22]: Maria says she had a great experience last weekend hiking with her church friends.\n- Result 9 [2023-07-17]: Maria mentions having a picnic with some friends from church last weekend.\n\nStep 2: Determine the date of the message mentioning the hike.\n- Result 16 is dated 2023-07-22 and refers to \"last weekend,\" which would be the weekend before July 22, 2023.\n- The weekend before July 22, 2023, is July 15-16, 2023.\n\nStep 3: Confirm consistency.\n- Result 9 is dated 2023-07-17 and mentions a picnic with church friends \"last weekend,\" which would be the weekend of July 8-9, 2023.\n- Since Result 16 specifically mentions hiking with church friends last weekend (relative to July",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.62,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.48
    },
    {
      "question": "What exercises has John done?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Weight training, Circuit training, Kickboxing, yoga",
      "generated_answer": "Step-by-step reasoning:\n\n1. From [Result 2] (2023-07-22), John mentions the instructor offers yoga, kickboxing, and circuit training.\n2. From [Result 5] (2023-07-22), John says he has done weight training, describing it as challenging but peaceful like yoga.\n3. From [Result 10] (2023-04-07), John says he is doing a beginner yoga class focusing on fundamentals like poses and breathing.\n4. From [Result 49] (2022-12-17), John mentions doing kickboxing.\n5. From [Result 71] (2022-12-22), John says he is doing taekwondo.\n6. From [Result 20] (2023-06-16), John mentions trying different workout regimes and specifically rock climbing.\n7. From [Result 86] (2023-02-25), John mentions a colleague invited him to a beginner",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.03,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.21
    },
    {
      "question": "When did John have his first firefighter call-out?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "The sunday before 3` July 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of John joining the fire brigade and his first call-out.\n\n- Result 3 (2023-08-16): John tells Maria he is now part of the fire-fighting brigade.\n- Result 7 (2023-07-31): John says, \"Last Sunday we had our first call-out, and it was intense.\"\n\nStep 2: Determine the date of \"last Sunday\" relative to the message date.\n\n- The message in Result 7 is dated 2023-07-31 (Monday).\n- \"Last Sunday\" before 2023-07-31 would be 2023-07-30.\n\nStep 3: Confirm no other earlier mention of a call-out.\n\n- No earlier messages mention a call-out before July 30, 2023.\n\nFinal answer:  \nJohn had his first firefighter call-out on Sunday, July 30, 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.37,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.58
    },
    {
      "question": "What food item did Maria drop off at the homeless shelter?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Cakes",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Maria dropping off food at the homeless shelter.\n- Result 39 [2023-07-31T13:59:30] Maria to John: \"last week (approximately July 24, 2023) I dropped off that stuff I baked at the homeless shelter.\"\n\nStep 2: Look for details about what Maria baked or the food items she brought.\n- Result 16 [2023-05-04T15:26:30] Maria to John: Mentions a spread with salads, sandwiches, and homemade desserts, with a favorite being a banana split sundae, but this is from May, not the July drop-off.\n- Result 18 [2023-05-04T15:26:00] John to Maria: Talks about a spread and mentions he made an apple pie for kids on May 3, 2023.\n- No direct mention of the specific baked item dropped off in July.\n\nStep 3:",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.04,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.25
    },
    {
      "question": "What attributes describe John?",
      "category": 3,
      "gold_answer": "Selfless, family-oriented, passionate, rational",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for direct descriptions or attributes mentioned about John in the excerpts.\n\n- [Result 5, 10, 37, 81] John cherishes a special bond with a loved one (Max), values unconditional love and loyalty, and is reflective and grateful.\n- [Result 13, 99] John experiences self-doubt and questions his impact and decisions but shows resilience and determination to overcome challenges.\n- [Result 22, 42, 66] John has a strong sense of community, teamwork, and respect for the military; he is courageous (saved a family from a burning building).\n- [Result 73, 86] John values friendship, support from loved ones, and believes in the power of trust and collaboration.\n- [Result 65, 70] John is motivated by family, exercise, friends, and finding sources of inspiration to stay motivated and tackle challenges.\n- [Result 74, 24] John is proactive in exploring options",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 4.2,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.51
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Maria start volunteering at the homeless shelter?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "Around August 2022",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify any direct statements about when Maria started volunteering.\n\n- Result 1 (2023-08-03): Maria says, \"I started volunteering here about a year ago (approximately August 03, 2022).\"\n- Result 23 (2023-01-28): Maria mentions being inspired by her aunt to volunteer but does not specify a start date.\n- Result 36 (2023-04-02): Maria references volunteering together last year (April 02, 2022), but this is John talking about a joint experience, not Maria's start date.\n- Result 13 (2022-12-22): Maria donated her old car to a homeless shelter she volunteers at, indicating she was volunteering by December 2022.\n- Result 39 (2023-01-28): Maria volunteered at a shelter event in January 2023.\n\nStep 2: The clearest and most specific statement is from Result 1, where Maria explicitly",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.34,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.33
    },
    {
      "question": "Who have written notes of gratitude to Maria?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Cindy, Laura",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of notes or letters of gratitude in the context.\n\n- Result 1 (2023-08-03): Maria says Cindy, a resident at the shelter, wrote a heartfelt note of gratitude.\n- Result 2 (2023-07-03): Maria says Laura, another shelter resident, wrote a letter expressing gratitude.\n- Result 8 (2023-08-03): John asks Maria about the note and who wrote it, which aligns with Result 1.\n\nStep 2: Confirm no other names mentioned as writers of gratitude notes.\n\n- No other specific names besides Cindy and Laura are mentioned as writers of gratitude notes.\n\nFinal answer:  \nCindy and Laura, both residents at the shelter, have written notes of gratitude to Maria.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.14,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.25
    },
    {
      "question": "When did John help renovate his hometown community center?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "2022",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about John renovating a community center.\n\n- Result 1 (2023-08-05): John says, \"Last year (approximately August 05, 2022), I helped renovate a rundown community center back home.\"\n- Result 6 (2022-12-17): John mentions the renovation enabled needed repairs and made the environment safer.\n- Result 44 (2023-04-02): Maria recalls volunteering together last year (April 02, 2022), which may relate to community work but not specifically the center.\n- Result 85 (2022-12-17): John is passionate about improving education and infrastructure, consistent with renovation efforts.\n\nStep 2: Confirm the timing.\n\nJohn explicitly states in Result 1 on August 5, 2023, that the renovation happened \"last year,\" approximately August 5, 2022.\n\nFinal answer: John helped renovate his hometown community center around August 2022.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.78,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.73
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Maria take up community work with her church friends?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "August 4, 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify any mention of Maria taking up community work with church friends.  \nStep 2: Result 94 [2023-08-05T17:22:30] Maria to John says: \"Yesterday (approximately August 04, 2023), I took up some community work with my friends from church.\"  \nStep 3: This is a direct statement about when Maria started community work with her church friends.\n\nFinal answer: Maria took up community work with her church friends on August 4, 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.1,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.53
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Maria receive a medal from the homeless shelter?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "The week before 9 August 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Maria receiving a medal.  \n- Result 4 [2023-08-09]: Maria says, \"Last week (approximately August 02, 2023) was wild - I volunteered at the homeless shelter and they gave me a medal!\"\n\nStep 2: Confirm the date of the medal event.  \n- The message is dated August 9, 2023, and Maria refers to \"last week,\" which she approximates as August 2, 2023.\n\nFinal answer:  \nMaria received a medal from the homeless shelter around August 2, 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.75,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.32
    },
    {
      "question": "When did John participate in a 5K charity run?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "first weekend of August 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of John participating in a 5K charity run.\n- Result 1 (2023-08-09): John to Maria says he set up a 5K charity run in their neighborhood.\n- Result 10 (2023-08-09): John mentions participating in a community event last weekend to raise money for a good cause.\n- Result 39 (2023-08-09): Maria asks John about the run and how he organized it.\n- Result 12 (2023-08-09): John talks about getting sponsors for the event.\n- Result 91 and 92 (2023-08-09): John discusses challenges and the cause of the event.\n\nStep 2: Determine the date of the event.\n- John\u2019s messages about the 5K run are dated August 9, 2023.\n- He refers to the event as happening \"last weekend\" in message 10, which would be the weekend before August",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.89,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.3
    },
    {
      "question": "What causes has John done events for?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Toy drive, Community food drive, veterans, domestic violence",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of events John has done and the causes involved.\n\n- Result 18 (2023-01-01): John mentions events at a homeless shelter giving out food and supplies, and a toy drive for kids in need.\n- Result 12 (2023-08-09): John says they worked with a local organization helping victims of domestic abuse, raising awareness and funds.\n- Result 6 & 13 & 55 (2023-07-31): John describes a rescue mission where they saved a family from a burning building, implying involvement with fire brigade or emergency response.\n- Result 1 & 4 & 43 & 80 & 87 (2023-08-09): Maria asks about an event John was involved in, which John confirms was for domestic abuse victims.\n- Result 21 & 39 & 63: John talks about running for office to make an impact, but this is political, not an event cause.\n- Result",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.03,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.42
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Maria get Coco?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "Two weeks before 11 August 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the message where Maria mentions getting Coco.  \n- In [Result 2] dated 2023-08-11T00:10:00, Maria says: \"Guess what - I got a puppy two weeks ago! Her name's Coco and she's adorable.\"\n\nStep 2: Determine the date of the message: August 11, 2023.  \nStep 3: Calculate two weeks before August 11, 2023, which is approximately July 28, 2023.\n\nFinal answer:  \nMaria got Coco around July 28, 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.5,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.45
    },
    {
      "question": "When did John go on a camping trip with Max?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "The summer of 2022",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of John camping with Max.\n- Result 2: John to Maria on 2023-08-11 says, \"Max and I had a blast on our camping trip last summer.\"\n\nStep 2: Determine the timing of \"last summer\" relative to the message date.\n- The message is dated 2023-08-11.\n- \"Last summer\" from August 2023 would refer to summer 2022.\n\nStep 3: Confirm no other conflicting information.\n- No other messages specify a different camping trip date with Max.\n- Max passed away before June 3, 2023 (Result 7), so the camping trip must have been before that.\n\nFinal answer: John went on a camping trip with Max in the summer of 2022.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.27,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.11
    },
    {
      "question": "What are Maria's dogs' names?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Coco, Shadow",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Maria's dogs and their names in the context.\n\n- Result 7 (2023-08-13): Maria says, \"Her name is Shadow! She's full of energy and always puts a smile on my face. ... They get along great.\" This indicates one dog named Shadow.\n\n- Result 8 (2023-08-11): Maria says, \"Guess what - I got a puppy two weeks ago! Her name's Coco and she's adorable.\" This indicates another dog named Coco.\n\n- Result 10 (2023-08-13): Maria says, \"I just adopted this cute pup from a shelter last week (approx. August 06, 2023).\" This likely refers to Shadow, given the timing.\n\n- Result 1 and 4 (2023-08-13): John asks about Maria's new pup and if she and her other dog get along, confirming Maria has at least two dogs.\n\nStep 2: Confirm no",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.54,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.18
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Maria adopt Shadow?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "The week before 13 August 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Shadow and adoption timing.  \n- Result 1 (2023-08-13): Maria tells John, \"Her name is Shadow! She's full of energy and always puts a smile on my face. She's been a great addition to my life.\"  \n- Result 52 (2023-08-13): John asks Maria about Shadow, indicating this is a recent topic.  \n- Result 39 (2023-08-13): Maria says Shadow is an amazing learner and brings her joy.\n\nStep 2: Look for any earlier mentions of Shadow or adoption timing.  \n- No earlier messages mention Shadow or the adoption date.  \n- The conversation about Shadow appears only around August 13, 2023.\n\nStep 3: Since the first mention of Shadow is on August 13, 2023, and Maria says \"She's been a great addition,\" it suggests the adoption was recent but no exact date is given.\n\nFinal answer:  \nMaria",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.49,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.43
    },
    {
      "question": "How many dogs has Maria adopted from the dog shelter she volunteers at?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "two",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Maria adopting dogs from the shelter.\n- Result 3 (2023-08-13): Maria says she adopted a cute pup from a shelter last week (around August 6, 2023).\n- Result 21 (2023-08-11): Maria says she got a puppy two weeks ago named Coco.\n- Result 96 (2023-08-13): Maria says the pup's name is Shadow, full of energy, and they get along great with her other dog.\n\nStep 2: Check if Coco and Shadow are the same dog or different.\n- Result 21 says Maria got a puppy two weeks ago (around late July/early August 2023) named Coco.\n- Result 3 says she adopted a pup last week (around August 6, 2023) but does not name her.\n- Result 96 says the pup's name is Shadow and they get along with her other dog.\n\nStep 3:",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.24,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.82
    },
    {
      "question": "How many weeks passed between Maria adopting Coco and Shadow?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "two weeks",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify when Maria adopted Coco.  \n- Result 2 (2023-08-11): Maria says she got a puppy two weeks ago. Since the message is dated August 11, 2023, two weeks before is approximately July 28, 2023.  \n- Result 4 (2023-08-13): Maria says she adopted a pup from a shelter last week (approximately August 06, 2023). This likely refers to Shadow, since Result 3 (same date) says \"Her name is Shadow.\"\n\nStep 2: Confirm which dog is which.  \n- Coco was adopted about July 28, 2023 (Result 2).  \n- Shadow was adopted about August 6, 2023 (Result 4 and 3).\n\nStep 3: Calculate the weeks between the two adoption dates.  \n- From July 28 to August 6 is about 9 days, which is roughly 1 week and ",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.16,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.02
    },
    {
      "question": "What job might Maria pursue in the future?",
      "category": 3,
      "gold_answer": "Shelter coordinator, Counselor",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Review mentions of Maria's interests and activities related to work or future plans.\n\n- Result 26 (2023-01-01): Maria says empowering individuals through education and mentorship is crucial and looks forward to John's initiatives.\n- Result 14 (2023-08-13): Maria talks about \"she\" (likely her child or someone she mentors) being an amazing learner and bringing her joy.\n- Result 86 (2023-05-04): Maria mentions taking care of herself physically, emotionally, and mentally, including exercise, music, and spending time with loved ones.\n- Result 58 (2023-07-22): Maria mentions wanting to make connections, laugh together, and take in nature's beauty.\n- Result 75 and 76 (2023-07): Maria asks John about classes and activities, showing interest in learning and growth.\n- Result 14 and 68 (2023-08): John and Maria talk about a young learner Maria",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 4.18,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.78
    },
    {
      "question": "What is John's main focus in local politics?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Improving education and infrastructure",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of John's political focus in the excerpts.\n\n- Result 3 (2022-12-17): John says he hopes to get into local politics because he loves helping the community.\n- Result 10 (2022-12-17): John states his main focuses are improving education and infrastructure.\n- Result 25 (2023-04-18): John mentions education reform and infrastructure development as recent policy focuses.\n- Result 24 (2023-04-02): John talks about understanding challenges in education and infrastructure systems.\n- Result 83 (2023-04-02): John says improving education and infrastructure is particularly interesting to him.\n- Result 7 (2023-04-18): John blogs about politics and mentions the need for better education and infrastructure.\n- Result 21 (2023-05-06): John is thinking about starting a community project regarding infrastructure.\n- Result 41 (2023-07-05): John reflects on",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.78,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.19
    },
    {
      "question": "What sparked John's interest in improving education and infrastructure in the community?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Seeing how lack of education and crumbling infrastructure affected his neighborhood while growing up.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: John mentions growing up seeing how lack of education and crumbling infrastructure affected his neighborhood (Result 14, 2022-12-17).  \nStep 2: He expresses a desire to prevent future generations from experiencing the same issues (Result 14).  \nStep 3: He also talks about hearing stories that fired up his passion to improve education (Result 23).  \nStep 4: His involvement in community meetings and seeing the challenges firsthand deepened his understanding and motivation (Results 2, 15, 42).  \nStep 5: The negative effects on neighborhoods and the impact on kids' dreams he witnessed personally and through volunteering reinforced his commitment (Results 19, 67).\n\nFinal answer:  \nJohn's interest in improving education and infrastructure was sparked by growing up witnessing their lack and negative effects in his neighborhood, which motivated him to prevent future generations from facing the same struggles. Hearing impactful stories and his community involvement further fueled his passion.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.86,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.35
    },
    {
      "question": "How did the extra funding help the school shown in the photo shared by John?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Enabled needed repairs and renovations, making the learning environment safer and more modern for students.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant messages about the school and funding.\n- Result 2 (2022-12-17): John shared a photo of a school from last year (around Dec 17, 2021) after they got funding.\n- Result 3 (2022-12-17): John said the extra funding enabled needed repairs and renovations, making the learning environment safer and more modern.\n- Result 1 (2022-12-17): Maria asked how the extra funding helped.\n- Result 37 (2022-12-17): Maria acknowledged the difference the funding made for schools and students.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.\nJohn clearly states the extra funding allowed for repairs and renovations that improved safety and modernized the school environment.\n\nFinal answer:  \nThe extra funding enabled necessary repairs and renovations that made the school safer and more modern for students.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.31,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.44
    },
    {
      "question": "What type of workout class did Maria start doing in December 2023?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "aerial yoga",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant time frame and details about Maria's workout classes.\n\nStep 2: Look for mentions of Maria starting a workout class around December 2023.\n\nStep 3: The closest relevant message is from 2022-12-17 (December 17, 2022), where Maria says:  \n\"Been busy volunteering at the homeless shelter and keeping fit. Just started doing aerial yoga, it's great.\" [Result 6]\n\nStep 4: There is no mention of Maria starting a new workout class in December 2023 (which is in the future relative to the latest messages in 2023-08).\n\nStep 5: The question likely meant December 2022, as that is the only December mentioned with a new workout class start.\n\nFinal answer:  \nMaria started doing aerial yoga in December 2022.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.88,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.46
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Maria donate to a homeless shelter in December 2023?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "old car",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant time frame and donation details.  \nStep 2: Look for any mention of Maria donating something to a homeless shelter in December 2023.  \nStep 3: Result 11 states: \"[2022-12-22T18:10:00] Maria to John: Hey John, been a few days since we chatted. In the meantime, I donated my old car to a homeless shelter I volunteer at yesterday (approximately December 21, 2022).\"  \nStep 4: This is the only mention of a donation by Maria to a homeless shelter in December, but it is December 2022, not 2023.  \nStep 5: There is no mention of any donation by Maria to a homeless shelter in December 2023 in the provided context.\n\nFinal answer:  \nNot enough information about any donation Maria made to a homeless shelter in December 2023; the only donation mentioned was an old car in December 2022",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.64,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.41
    },
    {
      "question": "What kind of meal did John and his family make together in the photo shared by John?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "pizza",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant messages about the meal John and his family made together.\n- Result 12 [2022-12-22T18:21:30] John to Maria: \"We made pizza! We had so much fun making them together. It was great picking out toppings and sharing a tasty meal with family.\"\n- Result 17 [2022-12-22T18:19:30] John to Maria: \"Yeah Maria, making memories with family is priceless! Life is so much more meaningful when we spend time together. Here's a pic of us at dinner.\"\n- Result 28 [2022-12-22T18:22:00] Maria to John: \"I can picture you all laughing and having a blast making your own pizzas - a great way to bond!\"\n\nStep 2: Confirm the meal type.\n- John explicitly says they made pizza together.\n- Maria confirms the image shows them making their own pizzas.\n\nStep 3: Confirm",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.13,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.4
    },
    {
      "question": "What kind of online group did John join?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "service-focused online group",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about John joining an online group.\n\n- Result 1 [2023-01-01]: John says he joined a \"service-focused online group\" around December 25, 2022.\n- Result 24 [2023-08-03]: John mentions a \"virtual support group\" he is part of, advocating for the military.\n- Result 9 [2023-08-11]: John talks about exploring options like joining local organizations or volunteering programs.\n- Result 66 [2023-07-03]: John talks about being around others who share his values and passion, related to activism.\n- Result 43 [2023-07-17]: John mentions hearing stories from a veteran, which ties to his interest in military support.\n- Result 13 [2023-05-20]: John reflects on the importance of helping veterans.\n- Result 24 and 42: John invited family and friends to join the virtual support group advocating",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.34,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.36
    },
    {
      "question": "What kind of activities did John and his mates from the online group do as part of their service efforts?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "gave out food and supplies at a homeless shelter, organized a toy drive for kids in need",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of John\u2019s online group and their activities.\n\n- Result 3 (2023-01-01): John joined a service-focused online group around Dec 25, 2022.\n- Result 5 (2023-01-01): They held events including visiting a homeless shelter to give out food and supplies, and organized a toy drive for kids in need.\n- Result 6 (2023-08-16): John mentions the group succeeded in something important in just two hours, working hard and feeling satisfied.\n- Result 27 (2023-02-05): John mentions being overwhelmed by volunteers at a recent event.\n- Result 96 (2023-02-05): John decided to act on unemployment effects by doing a community food drive.\n- Result 76 (2023-08-16): They raised a ton of donations including canned food, toiletries, and clothes.\n- Result 21 (2023-08-09): John",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 4.18,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.71
    },
    {
      "question": "Who inspired Maria to start volunteering?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Her aunt",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for mentions of Maria's inspiration to start volunteering.  \nStep 2: In Result 2 (2023-01-28), Maria says she started volunteering to make a difference and was inspired by her aunt, who believed in volunteering and helped her family when they were struggling.  \nStep 3: Result 84 (2023-02-05) also supports this, where Maria mentions that when she was younger, her family had money problems and relied on help from her aunt, teaching her the importance of helping others.  \n\nFinal answer:  \nMaria was inspired to start volunteering by her aunt, who believed in volunteering and helped her family during tough times.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.87,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.17
    },
    {
      "question": "Why did Maria sit with the little girl at the shelter event in February 2023?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "The girl seemed sad and had no other family",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant excerpts about Maria and the little girl at the shelter event in February 2023.\n\n- Result 39 [2023-01-28]: Maria to John says she noticed a little girl around 8 sitting all alone, looking sad, so she sat with her and talked.\n- Result 14 [2023-01-28]: John acknowledges Maria was there for the girl when she needed someone.\n- Result 4 [2023-02-25]: Maria explains the girl had a tough time (divorce, job loss, homelessness) but remained positive.\n- Result 1 and 27 [2023-02-25]: John and Maria discuss the girl's situation and positivity.\n\nStep 2: Understand the reason Maria sat with the girl.\n\nMaria saw the girl alone and sad, with no other family, which broke her heart. She wanted to give her comfort and a listening ear.\n\nFinal answer:  \nMaria sat with the little girl because she",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.7,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.39
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Jean go through before meeting Maria?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "divorce, job loss, homelessness",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify who \"Jean\" is in the context. The name \"Jean\" does not appear in the conversation excerpts, but there is a mention of \"she\" who had a tough time before meeting Maria.\n\nStep 2: Look for details about a female person who had difficulties before Maria was involved.  \n- Result 6 (Maria to John, 2023-02-25): \"She had a tough time, going through a divorce, losing her job, and ending up homeless. Yet, she still values the little things and believes in the good of kindness.\"  \n- Result 81 (Maria to John, 2023-07-03): \"Things have been tough for her lately. She had to leave and find a new place in a hurry, which has been really stressful, but she's making progress.\"  \n- Result 83 (John to Maria, 2023-07-03): \"That's really nice of you. It's important to help family",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.5,
      "judge_latency_s": 3.07
    },
    {
      "question": "Why did John decide to run for office again?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "saw the impact he could make in the community through politics",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about John's decision to run for office again.\n\n- Result 1 (2023-05-06): John says he decided to run for office again around April 29, 2023, despite not being successful before, because he can't let go of his dream to make a difference in his community.\n- Result 4 (2023-02-05): John says unemployment in the community was the reason behind his decision.\n- Result 9 (2023-02-25): John says after his last run, he saw the impact he could make in the community through politics and found it rewarding to work towards positive changes and a better future.\n- Result 23 (2023-02-05): John says seeing the effect unemployment has on neighbors made him decide to act, including doing a community food drive.\n- Result 46 (2023-02-05): John says he feels a strong urge to serve his country and community, and running",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.84,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.78
    },
    {
      "question": "What activity did John's colleague, Rob, invite him to?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "beginner's yoga class",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify any mention of John's colleague Rob in the context.  \nStep 2: Look for the specific activity Rob invited John to.  \n\nFrom [Result 66] dated 2023-02-25, John says:  \n\"Let's do it, Maria! Together, we can make a real difference and bring a brighter future. And nothing too soon, but my colleague Rob invited me to a beginner's yoga class.\"\n\nThis clearly states the activity Rob invited John to.\n\nFinal answer:  \nJohn's colleague Rob invited him to a beginner's yoga class.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.02,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.65
    },
    {
      "question": "What is the name of John's one-year-old child?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Kyle",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for mentions of John's children and their names in the context.\n\nStep 2: In [Result 8] (2023-03-06T18:04:30), John tells Maria: \"Our one-year-old is so cute, his name is Kyle!\"\n\nStep 3: This is a direct statement identifying the name of John's one-year-old child.\n\nFinal answer: John's one-year-old child's name is Kyle.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.39,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.59
    },
    {
      "question": "How often does John take his kids to the park?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "A few times a week",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about John taking his kids to the park.\n\n- Result 1 (2023-03-06): Maria asks John if he takes his kid to the park often.\n- Result 2 (2023-03-06): John replies they go a few times a week.\n- Result 3 (2023-06-12): John mentions an awesome day at the park with his family.\n- Result 6 (2023-03-06): John talks about swinging and fun activities at the park.\n- Result 14 (2023-08-13): John mentions loving outdoors activities including hanging out at the park.\n- Result 68 (2023-03-06): John talks about walks or picnics in the park as fun family activities.\n\nStep 2: Look for explicit frequency statements.\n\n- Result 2: \"Yeah, we go a few times a week.\"\n- Result 41 (2023-05-04):",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.51,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.5
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Maria make for her home to remind her of a trip to England?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "painting of a castle on a hill",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Maria's trip to England and what she created inspired by it.  \n- Result 2: Maria says she got the idea from a trip to England a few years ago, mesmerized by castles, and wanted to bring that magic to her home. She also mentions she made a painting.  \n- Result 1: Maria mentions the trip was in London and the architecture inspired her to recreate some of that charm in her space.\n\nStep 2: Confirm what exactly she made for her home.  \n- Result 2 explicitly states: \"I made a painting too!\"\n\nFinal answer:  \nMaria made a painting for her home to remind her of her trip to England.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.57,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.47
    },
    {
      "question": "Where did Maria get the idea for the castle shadow box in her home?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "England",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant excerpts about the castle shadow box and its inspiration.\n\n- Result 1 (Maria to John, 2023-03-06): Maria says she got the idea from a trip to England a few years ago, mesmerized by the castles.\n- Result 4 (John to Maria, 2023-03-06): John asks what gave her the idea for the picture.\n- Result 7 (Maria to John, 2023-03-06): Maria clarifies it was in London, and the architecture there was captivating, inspiring her to recreate that charm in her home.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.\n\nMaria's idea for the castle shadow box came from her trip to England, specifically London, where she was captivated by the castles and architecture, which she wanted to bring into her home as a reminder of London's history and grace.\n\nFinal answer:  \nMaria got the idea for the castle shadow box from her trip to London, England",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.82,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.54
    },
    {
      "question": "What did John receive a certificate for?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "completion of a university degree",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for mentions of a certificate or similar recognition in the context.  \nStep 2: Result 2 and Result 77 mention John's promotion and a trophy, which is a symbol of his journey and overcoming obstacles (Results 28, 30).  \nStep 3: No direct mention of a certificate specifically, but the trophy and promotion are related recognitions.  \nStep 4: No other explicit mention of a certificate or what it was for.  \n\nFinal answer:  \nNot enough information to determine what John received a certificate for.",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.37,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.94
    },
    {
      "question": "What areas is John particularly interested in for policymaking?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "education and infrastructure",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of John's policymaking interests in the context.\n\n- Result 1 (2023-04-02): John mentions considering policymaking due to his degree and passion for positive impact.\n- Result 9 (2022-12-17): John states he is passionate about improving education and infrastructure.\n- Result 19 (2023-04-18): John specifies education reform and infrastructure development as recent focuses.\n- Result 53 (2023-04-02): John says improving education and infrastructure is particularly interesting to him.\n- Result 21 (2023-04-02): John talks about community meetings giving him better understanding of challenges in education and infrastructure.\n- Result 14 (2023-01-01): John mentions brainstorming to help underserved communities with education, mentorship, job training, and resume building.\n- Result 6 (2023-02-05): John was motivated by unemployment to do a community food drive.\n- Result 17 (",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 4.17,
      "judge_latency_s": 4.6
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Maria participate in last weekend before April 10, 2023?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "a 5K charity run",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the date of the question reference: \"last weekend before April 10, 2023\" means the weekend just before April 10, 2023, which would be around April 8-9, 2023.\n\nStep 2: Look for any mention of Maria's activities around early April 2023.\n\nStep 3: Check the context for any mention of Maria's activities on or near that date.\n\n- Result 9 (2023-04-07) John to Maria talks about an event Maria was part of, with Maria responding in Result 50 (2023-04-07) with a picture from the event and saying the energy was great and inspiring.\n\n- Result 16 (2023-04-02) Maria to John asks about John's future plans, no mention of her own activities.\n\n- No direct mention of a weekend activity by Maria just before April 10, 2023.\n\nStep 4: Check for any other",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.54,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.64
    },
    {
      "question": "What event did John volunteer at last weekend?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "career fair at a local school",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the date of \"last weekend\" in the context of John's messages.  \n- The latest messages from John are dated around August 9-16, 2023.  \n- \"Last weekend\" relative to August 9, 2023, would be the weekend of August 5-6, 2023.\n\nStep 2: Look for any mention by John about volunteering at an event around that time.  \n- Result 45 [2023-08-09]: John says, \"Last weekend, I participated in a community event to raise money for a good cause. We got a great turnout and it was amazing to be surrounded by so many supportive people.\"  \n- Result 43 [2023-08-16]: John says, \"It only took us two hours. We worked hard but did something good \u2013 it was really satisfying.\" This is likely referring to the same event.  \n- Result 7 [2023-08-09]:",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.13,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.93
    },
    {
      "question": "What did John do that put a strain on his wallet?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "His car broke down",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for mentions of John having financial strain or something costly happening to him.  \nStep 2: In Result 1 (2023-04-10), John tells Maria that his car broke down last Friday on his way to work and that trying to get it fixed is tough and putting a strain on his wallet.  \nStep 3: No other context contradicts or adds to this specific financial strain detail.\n\nFinal answer: John\u2019s car broke down, and the cost of getting it fixed put a strain on his wallet.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.99,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.47
    },
    {
      "question": "Where did John explore on a road trip last year?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Pacific Northwest",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of John's road trips and their timing.\n\n- Result 37 (2023-04-10): John mentions a road trip last year (approx. April 10, 2022) and says, \"We explored the coast up in the Pacific Northwest and hit some cool national parks.\" (Result 16 is Maria asking about the road trip, and John replies in Result 16.)\n\n- Result 65 (2022-12-17): John says he just got back from a family road trip yesterday (approx. Dec 16, 2022), but this is not \"last year\" relative to 2023-04-10.\n\nStep 2: Confirm the location of the road trip last year.\n\n- Result 16 (2023-04-10): John says, \"We explored the coast up in the Pacific Northwest and hit some cool national parks.\"\n\nStep 3: Cross-check for any other road trip locations mentioned by John.\n\n-",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.73,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.41
    },
    {
      "question": "What topic has John been blogging about recently?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "politics and the government",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about John's blogging topic.\n\n- Result 9 (2023-04-18): John says he has been blogging about politics and the government.\n- Result 7 (2023-04-18): John mentions digging deeper into the political system, researching policies, and writing about his thoughts and ideas.\n- Result 14 (2023-04-18): John specifies focusing on education reform and infrastructure development in his recent work.\n- Result 63 (2023-04-18): John mentions getting good feedback on his blog posts.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.\n\nJohn's recent blogging centers on politics and government, with a particular focus on education reform and infrastructure development as key policy areas.\n\nFinal answer:  \nJohn has been blogging recently about politics and government, focusing especially on education reform and infrastructure development.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.54,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.33
    },
    {
      "question": "Why did John start blogging about politics and policies?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "raise awareness and start conversations to create positive change",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: John mentions in Result 2 (2023-04-18) that since they last chatted, he has been blogging about politics and government because he cares about making a real impact.\n\nStep 2: In Result 8 (2023-02-25), John says after his last run (likely a political run), he saw the impact he could make in the community through politics, which motivated him to work towards positive changes.\n\nStep 3: In Result 23 and 50 (2023-02-05), John explains that seeing the effect of unemployment in the community made him decide to act, including starting a community food drive.\n\nStep 4: In Result 59 and 28 (2022-12-17 and 2022-12-22), John expresses passion for improving education and infrastructure, and that conversations with people fired up his passion to make education better.\n\nStep 5: In Result 3 (2023-04-18),",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.5,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.28
    },
    {
      "question": "What was the focus of John's recent research and writing on his blog?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "education reform and infrastructure development",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about John's blog and research focus.\n\n- Result 26 (2023-04-18): John mentions blogging about politics and government, focusing on education and infrastructure.\n- Result 19 (2023-04-18): John talks about education reform and infrastructure development as recent topics.\n- Result 35 (2023-04-18): John says he is digging deeper into the political system, researching policies, and writing about his thoughts and ideas.\n- Result 37 (2023-04-18): John has received good feedback on his blog posts related to these topics.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.\n\nJohn's recent blog research and writing focus on politics and government, specifically on education reform and infrastructure development, aiming to raise awareness and start conversations for positive change.\n\nFinal answer:  \nJohn's recent blog research and writing focus on politics and government, particularly education reform and infrastructure development, to raise awareness and promote positive community change.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.29,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.93
    },
    {
      "question": "What did John attend with his colleagues in March 2023?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "a tech-for-good convention",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant time frame and event.\n- The question asks about something John attended with colleagues in March 2023.\n\nStep 2: Look for mentions of John and colleagues around March 2023.\n- Result 23 [2023-04-18]: John to Maria mentions: \"My colleagues and I went to a convention together last month (approximately March 19, 2023). We're all passionate about using tech for good in our community.\"\n\nStep 3: Confirm the event details.\n- The event was a convention focused on using technology for good in the community.\n- John found it great to connect with like-minded people and found it inspiring.\n\nFinal answer:  \nJohn attended a tech-for-good convention with his colleagues in March 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.77,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.48
    },
    {
      "question": "How often does John work out with his family?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Three times a week",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about John's workout frequency with his family.\n\n- Result 3 (2023-03-06): John says, \"Yeah, we go a few times a week.\"\n- Result 30 (2023-05-04): John says, \"Three times a week; it keeps us on track.\"\n\nStep 2: Confirm consistency and timeline.\n\n- The March 6 message says \"a few times a week,\" which is consistent with the more specific \"three times a week\" stated later on May 4.\n- No contradictory information is found.\n\nFinal answer:  \nJohn works out with his family about three times a week.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.22,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.55
    },
    {
      "question": "How has John's fitness improved since starting boot camps with his family?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "More energy, gains in strength and endurance",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify when John started boot camps with his family.  \n- From Result 4 (2023-05-04), John says he started boot camps with his family last month, approximately April 4, 2023.\n\nStep 2: Look for any comments about fitness improvements since starting boot camps.  \n- Result 3 (2023-05-04) John says: \"We've had lots more energy and noticed some gains in strength and endurance.\"  \n- Result 6 (2023-05-04) John mentions the family supports each other during boot camp, which is motivating.  \n- Result 24 (2023-05-04) John says it's a \"never-ending journey of learning and growth\" and they have the right attitude to keep improving.\n\nStep 3: Summarize the improvements.  \n- John and his family have gained more energy, strength, and endurance since starting boot camps.  \n- The supportive environment helps them stay motivated and",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.12,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.04
    },
    {
      "question": "What kind of food did Maria have on her dinner spread iwth her mother?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Salads, sandwiches, homemade desserts",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant excerpt about Maria's dinner with her mother.  \n- Result 11 [2023-05-04T15:25:30] Maria to John: \"My mom and I made some dinner together last night!\"\n\nStep 2: Check if Maria described the food in that dinner spread.  \n- Result 4 [2023-05-04T15:26:30] Maria to John: \"It had lots of great things like salads, sandwiches, and homemade desserts. My favorite is the amazing banana split sundae...\"\n\nStep 3: Confirm the timing matches the dinner with her mother.  \n- Result 3 and 11 are both from May 4, 2023, and mention dinner or food made \"yesterday\" (May 3, 2023). So the spread with salads, sandwiches, and desserts likely refers to the same dinner.\n\nFinal answer:  \nMaria's dinner spread with her mother included salads, sandwiches,",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.67,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.0
    },
    {
      "question": "What activity did Maria and her mom do together in May 2023?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Made dinner together",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for any mentions of Maria and her mom or mother in May 2023.\n\nStep 2: Check the dates around May 2023 for any activities involving Maria and her mom.\n\nStep 3: Review the context for any direct references to activities with Maria's mom.\n\nAfter reviewing all excerpts, there is no explicit mention of Maria and her mom doing any specific activity together in May 2023 or any other time.\n\nFinal answer: Not enough information.",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.24,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.48
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Maria do to feel closer to a community and her faith?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "joined a nearby church",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify any mentions of Maria doing something related to community and faith.\n\nStep 2: Result 4 states that on 2023-05-06, Maria told John she joined a nearby church \"just yesterday\" (approximately May 05, 2023) to feel closer to a community and her faith.\n\nStep 3: This is the clearest and most direct evidence of what Maria did to feel closer to community and faith.\n\nFinal answer:  \nMaria joined a nearby church around May 5, 2023, to feel closer to a community and her faith.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.41,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.05
    },
    {
      "question": "Why did Maria join a nearby church recently?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "to feel closer to a community and her faith",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant excerpt about Maria joining a church.  \n- Result 4 [2023-05-06]: Maria says, \"Just yesterday (approximately May 05, 2023) I joined a nearby church. I wanted to feel closer to a community and my faith.\"\n\nStep 2: Confirm the reason given by Maria.  \n- She explicitly states the reason was to feel closer to a community and her faith.\n\nFinal answer:  \nMaria joined a nearby church recently to feel closer to a community and to her faith.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.67,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.82
    },
    {
      "question": "What did John host for the veterans in May 2023 as part of the project?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "a small party to share their stories",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the timeframe and event related to John\u2019s project for veterans in May 2023.\n\n- Result 2 (2023-05-20) mentions John working on a project to support veterans, sparked around May 13, 2023.\n- Result 6 (2023-05-20) states John had a small party where veterans were invited to share their stories.\n- Result 11 (2023-05-20) mentions the event reminded John of community and togetherness.\n- Result 27 (2023-05-20) includes a photo from last Friday (around May 12, 2023) with veterans excited about the project.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the details.\n\nJohn hosted a small party in May 2023 as part of his project to support veterans, where veterans were invited to share their stories, fostering connections and camaraderie.\n\nFinal answer:  \nJohn hosted a small party in May 2023 where veterans were invited",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.03,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.18
    },
    {
      "question": "What did John and the veterans do during the small party?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "share stories and make connections",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant excerpts about the small party with veterans.\n- Result 1 [2023-05-20]: John to Maria mentions throwing a small party and inviting veterans to share their stories.\n- Result 46 [2023-05-20]: John to Maria shares a pic from last Friday with some veterans excited about the event.\n- Result 4 [2023-05-20]: John reflects on the sense of community and togetherness from the event.\n\nStep 2: Extract details about what happened during the party.\n- Veterans shared their stories (Result 1).\n- The event created connections, camaraderie, smiles, and new friendships (Result 1).\n- It was heartwarming and reminded John of the importance of helping veterans (Result 4).\n\nStep 3: Synthesize the information.\nDuring the small party, John and the veterans shared stories, made connections, and fostered camaraderie, resulting in smiles and new friendships.\n\nFinal answer:  \n",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.76,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.06
    },
    {
      "question": "What emotions did John feel during the small party with the veterans?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "heartwarming",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant excerpts about the small party with veterans.\n\n- Result 3 [2023-05-20T19:44:00] John to Maria: \"We had a great time throwing a small party and inviting some veterans to share their stories. It was awesome seeing them make connections and find camaraderie. All the smiles and new friendships made it really heartwarming.\"\n\n- Result 1 [2023-05-20T19:45:00] John to Maria: \"It reminded me of that sense of community and togetherness. It made me realize how important it is to help veterans.\"\n\n- Result 49 [2023-05-20T19:43:00] John to Maria: \"Here's a pic from last Friday with some veterans who are really excited about this. Their support keeps me motivated.\"\n\nStep 2: Analyze the emotions John expressed.\n\n- He described the event as \"great time,\" \"awesome,\" and \"heartwarming,\"",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.99,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.66
    },
    {
      "question": "What event is Maria getting ready for at the shelter on May 25, 2023?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "fundraiser",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the date and context of Maria's message about preparing for an event at the shelter.  \n- Result 23 [2023-05-25T13:24:30] Maria to John: \"I'm busy at the shelter getting ready for a fundraiser next week. Hopefully, I can raise enough to cover basic needs for the homeless.\"\n\nStep 2: Look for any other mentions of a fundraiser or related event around that time.  \n- Result 66 [2023-05-20T19:46:30] Maria to John: \"I'm currently planning a ring-toss tournament for the homeless shelter's fundraiser later this month, I can't wait to see the impact it will make.\"\n\nStep 3: Connect the two pieces of information:  \n- On May 25, Maria is preparing for a fundraiser at the shelter.  \n- Earlier on May 20, she mentions planning a ring-toss tournament as part of the fundraiser.\n\nFinal answer:  \nMaria",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 4.22,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.48
    },
    {
      "question": "What does Maria need to spread the word about for the fundraiser for the volunteer shelter?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "chili cook-off",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Maria talking about a fundraiser related to the volunteer shelter.  \n- Result 23 (2023-05-25): Maria says she is busy at the shelter getting ready for a fundraiser next week.  \n- Result 7 (2023-05-25): Maria thanks John and says they need to get the word out about the chili cook-off at the fundraiser, and shares a poster.  \n- Result 17 (2023-05-25): Maria again thanks John and asks if he knows anyone interested in volunteering for the event.\n\nStep 2: From these, the specific thing Maria needs to spread the word about is the \"chili cook-off\" at the fundraiser.\n\nFinal answer:  \nMaria needs to spread the word about the chili cook-off event at the fundraiser for the volunteer shelter.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.8,
      "judge_latency_s": 3.24
    },
    {
      "question": "What was the name of the pet that John had to say goodbye to on 3 June, 2023?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Max",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the date and event: On 3 June 2023, John mentioned having to say goodbye to a pet.\n\nStep 2: Look for the pet's name in the context around that date.\n\n- Result 20 [2023-06-03]: John says, \"The toughest thing to deal with is that we had to say goodbye to Max.\"\n- Result 7 [2023-06-03]: Maria refers to Max and expresses sympathy.\n- Result 13 [2023-06-03]: John talks about Max and the lessons he taught.\n- Result 3 [2023-08-11]: John reminisces about Max and shares a picture.\n- Result 21 [2023-06-03]: John shares a cherished picture of Max.\n\nStep 3: Confirm that Max is the pet John had to say goodbye to on 3 June 2023.\n\nFinal answer: The pet John's family had to say goodbye to on 3",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.01,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.52
    },
    {
      "question": "How long was Max a part of John's family?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "10 years",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Max and the duration he was part of John's family.  \nStep 2: In Result 1, John says: \"He was such an important part of our family for 10 years.\"  \nStep 3: No other excerpt contradicts or modifies this information.\n\nFinal answer: Max was a part of John's family for 10 years.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.57,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.72
    },
    {
      "question": "How does John plan to honor the memories of his beloved pet?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "By considering adopting a rescue dog",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: John expresses the importance of honoring the memories of loved ones and shares a cherished picture of his pet Max (Result 4).\n\nStep 2: He talks about thinking of Max as peaceful and happy, appreciating the joy Max brought to the family (Results 7, 21).\n\nStep 3: John mentions wanting his kids to learn the values Max taught them, such as unconditional love and loyalty (Result 3).\n\nStep 4: John and Maria discuss adopting a rescue dog to give love and teach their kids responsibility and compassion, which can be seen as a way to honor Max's memory by continuing the legacy of love and care for animals (Results 8, 1, 2).\n\nFinal answer: John plans to honor the memories of his beloved pet Max by cherishing the good times and memories they shared, keeping Max's peaceful and happy image in mind, and by adopting a rescue dog to teach his kids the values Max embodied, such as love, loyalty,",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.49,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.04
    },
    {
      "question": "What important values does John want to teach his kids through adopting a rescue dog?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Responsibility and compassion",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify where John talks about adopting a rescue dog and the values he wants to teach his kids.\n\n- In Result 1 (2023-06-03), John says: \"We're considering adopting a rescue dog - for love and to teach our kids responsibility and compassion.\"\n- In Result 7 (2023-06-03), John mentions: \"He really taught us the importance of unconditional love and loyalty. I want my kids to learn that too.\"\n- In Result 50 (2023-06-03), John says about Max: \"He taught us a lot about love and loyalty.\"\n\nStep 2: Summarize the values John wants to teach his kids through adopting a rescue dog.\n\n- Love (unconditional love)\n- Responsibility\n- Compassion\n- Loyalty\n\nFinal answer:  \nJohn wants to teach his kids important values of love, responsibility, compassion, and loyalty through adopting a rescue dog.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 5.8,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.48
    },
    {
      "question": "What new activity did Maria start recently, as mentioned on 3 June, 2023?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "volunteering at a local dog shelter once a month",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the date of interest: 3 June 2023.\n\nStep 2: Look for messages around that date mentioning Maria and any new activity.\n\nStep 3: Result 30 [2023-06-12] Maria to John: \"Wow! Looks like you had fun - what happened there?\" \u2014 This is Maria asking John, not about her own activity.\n\nStep 4: Result 52 [2023-07-03] Maria to John: \"Things have been tough for her lately. She had to leave and find a new place in a hurry, which has been really stressful, but she's making progress.\" \u2014 Not about Maria's new activity.\n\nStep 5: Result 63 [2023-07-22] Maria to John: \"I wanted to make connections, laugh together and take in nature's beauty. Uplifting!\" \u2014 This is about an activity but dated July 22.\n\nStep 6: Result 45 [2023",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.94,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.41
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Maria say it was like being at the waterfall in Oregon?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Like being in a fairy tale",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of the waterfall and Oregon in the context.  \n- Result 2: Maria mentions a family road trip to Oregon.  \n- Result 4: Maria describes the experience at the waterfall.  \n- Result 26: Maria says hiking to the top and seeing the view was awesome and breath-taking.  \n- Result 1: John comments on the waterfall and bridge, asking Maria how it was being there.  \n- Result 98: John says nature has a calming effect, responding to Maria's experience.\n\nStep 2: Extract Maria's description of being at the waterfall.  \n- Result 4: \"I felt like I was in a fairy tale! The water sounded so calming and the surroundings were beautiful. It was truly magical!\"  \n- Result 26: \"Hiking to the top and seeing this was awesome! Breath-taking.\"\n\nStep 3: Synthesize the description.  \nMaria described being at the waterfall in Oregon as feeling like being in a",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.22,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.47
    },
    {
      "question": "What does Maria say she feels when doing upside-down yoga poses?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Free and light",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify where Maria talks about upside-down yoga poses.  \n- In [Result 5] (2023-06-12), Maria says: \"It's tough to pick just one, but I really enjoy the upside-down poses. They make me feel free and light.\"\n\nStep 2: Extract the feelings Maria associates with upside-down poses.  \n- She feels \"free and light.\"\n\nFinal answer:  \nMaria says that doing upside-down yoga poses makes her feel free and light.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.38,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.29
    },
    {
      "question": "What exciting news did Maria share on 16 June, 2023?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "joined a gym",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the date in question: 16 June 2023.\n\nStep 2: Look for any messages from or to Maria around that date.\n\nStep 3: Result 41 is from John to Maria on 2023-06-16 and mentions a vacation and stunning photos.\n\nStep 4: Result 69 is from Maria to John on 2023-06-12 about hiking.\n\nStep 5: Result 94 is from Maria to John on 2023-06-16 congratulating John on his promotion.\n\nStep 6: Result 99 is from Maria to John on 2023-08-13 about someone being an amazing learner.\n\nStep 7: None of these explicitly state exciting news Maria shared on 16 June 2023.\n\nStep 8: Check if any other messages from Maria around June mention exciting news.\n\nStep 9: Result 54 (2023-07-22) mentions Maria planning to explore more and volunteer next",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.26,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.92
    },
    {
      "question": "What yoga activity has Maria been trying to improve her strength and endurance?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "kundalini yoga",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Maria doing yoga or related activities.\n- Result 4 (2022-12-17): Maria mentions doing aerial yoga.\n- Result 2 (2023-06-16): Maria says she is trying kundalini yoga to get stronger and improve endurance.\n\nStep 2: Confirm which yoga activity Maria associates with improving strength and endurance.\n- Result 2 explicitly states Maria is trying kundalini yoga with the goal to get stronger and improve endurance.\n\nStep 3: Cross-check if aerial yoga is linked to strength/endurance goals.\n- Result 4 and others mention aerial yoga as great and enjoyable but do not explicitly link it to strength and endurance goals.\n\nFinal answer:  \nMaria has been trying kundalini yoga to improve her strength and endurance.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.73,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.83
    },
    {
      "question": "What did John recently get promoted to?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "assistant manager",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of John's promotion in the context.\n\n- Result 4 (2023-06-16): John tells Maria he got promoted at work.\n- Result 9 (2023-06-16): John says he is now an assistant manager.\n- Result 2 and 3 (2023-06-16): Maria congratulates John on the promotion; John talks about the challenges he faced.\n- Result 1 (2023-06-16): Maria asks about a trophy related to the promotion.\n\nStep 2: Confirm the exact title John was promoted to.\n\n- Result 9 explicitly states: \"It feels like all the hard work I've put in has paid off now that I'm an assistant manager.\"\n\nFinal answer: John was recently promoted to assistant manager.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.01,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.88
    },
    {
      "question": "What was one of the biggest challenges John faced in his journey to becoming assistant manager?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "self-doubt",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify when John talks about his promotion to assistant manager and any challenges he mentions.\n\n- Result 2 (2023-06-16): John expresses excitement about his promotion to assistant manager.\n- Result 1 (2023-06-16): John mentions facing many hurdles including tech stuff, workplace stuff, but highlights that the worst was self-doubt.\n- Result 47 (2023-06-16): Maria acknowledges the tough hurdles John faced, especially self-doubt.\n- Result 38 and 80 (2023-06-16): John talks about the challenges and how support and self-belief helped him.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.\n\nJohn faced various challenges on his path to promotion, including technical and workplace difficulties, but the biggest challenge he explicitly states was overcoming self-doubt.\n\nFinal answer:  \nOne of the biggest challenges John faced in his journey to becoming assistant manager was overcoming self-doubt.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.59,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.48
    },
    {
      "question": "How does John describe the support he received during his journey to becoming assistant manager?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "having support at home and his own grit",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about John's journey to becoming assistant manager and the support he received.\n\n- Result 1 (2023-06-16): John expresses excitement about his promotion to assistant manager and sees it as a stepping stone.\n- Result 2 (2023-06-16): John details hurdles he faced including tech, workplace issues, and especially self-doubt. He credits support at home and his own grit for helping him power through.\n- Result 4 (2023-05-04): Maria emphasizes the importance of a support system and notes John has family support.\n- Result 56 (2023-07-05): John shares a picture of his family who motivate him and remind him why he is doing his work.\n- Result 28 (2023-07-05): John acknowledges feeling like an uphill battle but appreciates people who see the value in his work, which keeps him going.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.\n\nJohn describes the support",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.16,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.78
    },
    {
      "question": "What kind of event did John and his family attend in June 2023?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "live music event",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant dates and events in June 2023 involving John and his family.\n\n- Result 9 (2023-06-27): John mentions a live music event around June 20, 2023, where his family had a blast dancing and enjoying the energy.\n- Result 14 (2023-07-17): John mentions a community event with arts and crafts, fun activities, and games for families around June 17, 2023, which he attended with family and friends.\n- Result 3 (2023-06-12): John describes a day at the park with his family, kids playing on the playground, and nice family time.\n- Result 65 (2023-06-12): Maria asks John what happened at the event where he had fun.\n- Result 27 (2023-06-12): Maria mentions hiking to the top and seeing a breathtaking view, possibly related to a family outing.\n- Result 11 (",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.44,
      "judge_latency_s": 4.44
    },
    {
      "question": "Why did Maria need to help her cousin find a new place to live?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Her cousin had to leave and find a new place in a hurry.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Maria helping her cousin find a new place.\n- Result 14 (2023-07-03): Maria says her cousin had a tough time recently (around June 26, 2023), so she is helping her find a new place.\n- Result 16 (2023-07-03): Maria adds that her cousin had to leave and find a new place in a hurry, which was stressful but she is making progress.\n- Result 7 (2023-07-03): Maria emphasizes the importance of a safe home.\n\nStep 2: Look for reasons why the cousin had to leave.\n- Result 14 mentions the cousin had a tough time recently but does not specify the exact cause.\n- Result 1 (2023-02-25) describes a woman who went through a divorce, lost her job, and became homeless, but it is unclear if this is the cousin.\n- No direct statement links the cousin's situation to divorce",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.18,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.45
    },
    {
      "question": "What event did John participate in to show support for veterans' rights?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "marching event",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of John participating in events related to veterans' rights.\n\n- Result 2 (2023-07-03): John says he participated in a marching event for veterans' rights.\n- Result 14 (2023-08-09): John mentions setting up a 5K charity run to help veterans and their families.\n- Result 59 (2023-07-17): John visited a veteran's hospital, which was meaningful but not an event.\n- Result 1 and 3 (2023-05-20): John worked on a project to support veterans, including a petition and a small party with veterans sharing stories.\n- Result 7 and 14 (2023-08-09): John talks about organizing and coordinating the 5K charity run, which raised funds for veterans.\n\nStep 2: Determine which event specifically was to show support for veterans' rights.\n\n- The marching event (Result 2) is explicitly described as \"for",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.42,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.16
    },
    {
      "question": "What inspired John to join the marching event for veterans' rights?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Respect for the military and the desire to show support",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify when John mentioned joining the marching event for veterans' rights.  \n- Result 1 (2023-07-03) John says he participated in a marching event for veterans' rights and it reminded him how much they sacrifice.\n\nStep 2: Look for what John says about his motivation or inspiration related to veterans.  \n- Result 2 (2023-07-17) John heard stories from an elderly veteran named Samuel, which inspired him and reminded him why he wanted to join the military.  \n- Result 4 (2023-05-20) John says he has always been passionate about veterans and their rights and wanted to show appreciation for what they have done.  \n- Result 5 (2023-07-03) John says he has always had great respect for the military and wanted to show support.  \n- Result 6 (2023-07-03) John says being around others who share his values and passion motivated him to make",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.65,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.38
    },
    {
      "question": "How often does John get to see sunsets like the one he shared with Maria?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "At least once a week",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about John seeing sunsets.\n\n- Result 3 [2023-07-05]: John says, \"I see them at least once a week.\"\n- Result 5 [2023-06-12]: John says, \"Yeah, plenty of times.\"\n- Result 8 [2023-05-04]: John says, \"Three times a week; it keeps us on track.\"\n- Result 6 [2023-03-06]: John says, \"Yeah, we go a few times a week.\"\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the frequency.\n\nJohn mentions seeing sunsets at least once a week, sometimes a few times a week, and specifically three times a week in May. The most consistent and specific frequency given is about 3 times a week.\n\nFinal answer: John typically sees sunsets about three times a week.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.16,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.96
    },
    {
      "question": "What natural disaster affected John's old area on 7 July, 2023?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Flood",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the date and event in question. The question asks about a natural disaster affecting John's old area on 7 July 2023.\n\nStep 2: Look for any mention of natural disasters around that date in the context.\n\nStep 3: In Result 1 (dated 2023-07-07), John tells Maria that his old area was hit by a nasty flood last week (approximately June 30, 2023). He mentions ruined homes and poor infrastructure.\n\nStep 4: No other natural disaster is mentioned around that date.\n\nFinal answer: John's old area was affected by a flood around June 30, 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.31,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.25
    },
    {
      "question": "How did the flood impact the homes in John's old area?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Lots of homes were ruined.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant excerpt about the flood in John's old area.  \n- Result 1 [2023-07-07]: John mentions his old area was hit by a nasty flood around June 30, 2023.  \n- He says the infrastructure wasn't great, so lots of homes were ruined.\n\nStep 2: Check if any other excerpts provide more details about the flood's impact on homes.  \n- Result 66 [2023-05-06] and Result 26 [2023-05-06] mention infrastructure issues but are from before the flood date.  \n- No other excerpts mention the flood or its impact on homes specifically.\n\nStep 3: Synthesize the information.  \n- The flood caused significant damage due to poor infrastructure, resulting in many homes being ruined.\n\nFinal answer:  \nThe flood severely damaged many homes in John's old area because the poor infrastructure could not withstand the flooding.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.95,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.59
    },
    {
      "question": "What motivated Maria and John to discuss potential solutions for their community on 7 July, 2023?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Flood in John's old area",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the date of interest: 7 July 2023.\n\nStep 2: Look for messages around that date to find context about their motivation.\n\n- Result 90 [2023-07-07T18:32:30] Maria to John: \"John, let's keep working together to make a difference in our community. Our actions, no matter how small, can have a big impact. Let's continue to spread kindness and inspire hope.\"\n\n- Result 95 [2023-07-07T18:30:30] Maria to John: \"Hey John, I'm down to join the meeting and contribute to making our community better. Let's do this!\"\n\n- Result 16 [2023-07-07T18:34:00] John to Maria: \"Yeah, let's work hard to help those around us. We can make a difference!\"\n\nStep 3: These messages show both are motivated by a shared desire to make a positive impact, spread kindness",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.39,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.06
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Maria plan to do later on the evening of 7 July, 2023?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "have dinner with friends from the gym",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the date in question: 7 July 2023.\n\nStep 2: Look for messages around that date for any mention of Maria's plans.\n\nStep 3: The closest relevant messages are:\n\n- [Result 73] [2023-07-07T18:31:00] John to Maria: \"Nice work, Maria! Your determination never ceases to amaze me. Let's get to work!\"\n\n- [Result 99] [2023-07-07T18:33:00] John to Maria: \"Definitely, little steps count! We can really make a difference together - let's do it!\"\n\nThese show John encouraging Maria to work together on something.\n\nStep 4: No direct message from Maria on 7 July 2023 states her specific plans for the evening.\n\nStep 5: The messages imply they planned to work together on their community efforts, but no explicit mention of what Maria planned to do later that evening.\n\nFinal answer",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 5.33,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.73
    },
    {
      "question": "What kind of activities did Maria do at the picnic with her church friends?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "played games like charades and a scavenger hunt",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant excerpt about Maria's picnic with church friends.  \n- Result 1 [2023-07-17]: Maria to John says, \"last weekend I had a picnic with some friends from church. We chilled under the trees, played games, and ate yummy food.\"\n\nStep 2: Look for details on the activities at the picnic.  \n- Maria mentions chilling under the trees, playing games, and eating yummy food.  \n- Result 18 [2023-07-17]: Maria to John adds, \"Some fun ones like charades and a scavenger hunt. We all had a good laugh!\"\n\nStep 3: Synthesize the information.  \n- At the picnic, Maria and her church friends relaxed under trees, played games including charades and a scavenger hunt, and enjoyed food.\n\nFinal answer:  \nAt the picnic with her church friends, Maria chilled under the trees, played games such as charades and a scavenger hunt, and",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.86,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.43
    },
    {
      "question": "What does John appreciate about the veteran's hospital visit?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "the resilience of the veterans and their inspiring stories",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about John's visit to the veteran's hospital.  \n- Result 19 [2023-07-17]: John says last week (around July 10, 2023) he visited a veteran's hospital and met amazing people.  \n- Result 11 [2023-07-17]: John heard inspiring and heartbreaking stories from an elderly veteran named Samuel, which filled him with hope and reminded him why he wanted to join the military.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize what John appreciated:  \n- Meeting amazing people at the hospital.  \n- Hearing inspiring and heartbreaking stories that showed resilience.  \n- Feeling filled with hope.  \n- Being reminded of his motivation to join the military.\n\nFinal answer:  \nJohn appreciated meeting amazing people at the veteran's hospital, hearing their inspiring and heartbreaking stories, which filled him with hope and reminded him why he wanted to join the military.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.96,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.33
    },
    {
      "question": "What did John take away from visiting the veteran's hospital?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "appreciation for giving back",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about John's visit to the veteran's hospital.  \n- Result 11 [2023-07-17]: John says last week (around July 10, 2023) he visited a veteran's hospital and met amazing people.  \n- Result 3 [2023-07-17]: John heard inspiring and heartbreaking stories from an elderly veteran named Samuel, which filled him with hope and reminded him why he wanted to join the military.  \n- Result 13 [2023-07-17]: Maria comments on the inspiring and heartbreaking stories of veterans filling them with hope.  \n- Result 17 [2023-07-17]: Maria asks if John learned anything cool during his visit.  \n- Result 14 [2023-08-03]: John says showing respect and appreciation for those who served was a moving experience for all of them.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.  \nJohn's visit to the veteran's hospital was eye",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.0,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.26
    },
    {
      "question": "Why did John feel inspired to join the military after the visit to the hospital?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "seeing the resilience of the veterans",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about John's visit to the veteran's hospital and his feelings about it.\n\n- Result 1 (2023-07-17): John told Maria he heard inspiring and heartbreaking stories from an elderly veteran named Samuel, which reminded him why he wanted to join the military.\n- Result 42 (2023-07-17): John said last week (around July 10, 2023) he visited a veteran's hospital, met amazing people, and it made him appreciate what we have and the need to give back.\n- Result 15 (2023-07-17): Maria said the veterans' stories were inspiring and heartbreaking but filled them with hope.\n- Result 83 (2023-07-17): Maria acknowledged the importance of making connections and enjoying simpler moments, implying the visit had a meaningful impact.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.\n\nJohn felt inspired to join the military because hearing the veterans' stories of resilience\u2014both inspiring and",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.68,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.66
    },
    {
      "question": "In what activity did Maria and her church friends participate in July 2023?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "hiking",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant time frame and participants. The question asks about an activity involving Maria and her church friends in July 2023.\n\nStep 2: Look for mentions of Maria, church friends, and July 2023 in the context.\n\n- Result 19 [2023-07-17]: Maria to John: \"Yeah, last weekend I had a picnic with some friends from church. We chilled under the trees, played games, and ate yummy food. It was great!\"\n\nStep 3: Confirm the activity and participants.\n\n- The activity was a picnic.\n- Participants were Maria and some friends from church.\n- The timing was last weekend before July 17, 2023, so approximately July 10-16, 2023.\n\nFinal answer:  \nMaria and her church friends participated in a picnic where they relaxed under the trees, played games, and ate food in July 2023.",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.06,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.6
    },
    {
      "question": "What does John think about trying new classes at the yoga studio?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Trying new classes is a fun way to switch up the exercise routine.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about John\u2019s opinion on trying new classes at the yoga studio.\n\n- Result 7 [2023-07-22]: John says the studio offers a variety of classes like yoga, kickboxing, and circuit training, which \"keeps things interesting.\"\n- Result 6 [2023-07-22]: Maria asks if they offer a variety of classes.\n- Result 14 [2023-07-22]: Maria says trying new classes sounds fun.\n- Result 15 [2023-07-22]: John mentions he has done weight training too, describing it as challenging but peaceful like yoga.\n- Result 62 [2023-06-16]: John mentions trying different workout regimes lately.\n- Result 58 [2023-05-04]: John says pushing limits and trying new things helps growth.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize John\u2019s attitude.\n\nJohn appreciates the variety of classes at the yoga studio and finds trying new classes keeps his",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.02,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.31
    },
    {
      "question": "Which activity has John done apart from yoga at the studio?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "weight training",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify activities John has done at the yoga studio.\n- John mentions going to a yoga studio often (Result 1).\n- He attends beginner yoga classes focusing on fundamentals (Result 2, 7).\n- He has done weight training as well (Result 11).\n\nStep 2: Look for other activities John has done apart from yoga at the studio.\n- John says the studio offers yoga, kickboxing, and circuit training (Result 3).\n- He specifically mentions doing kickboxing (Result 34).\n- He also mentions weight training (Result 11).\n- Additionally, John mentions taekwondo (Result 74).\n\nStep 3: Confirm these activities are apart from yoga at the studio.\n- Kickboxing is mentioned as an activity John is doing (Result 34).\n- Weight training is mentioned separately from yoga (Result 11).\n- Taekwondo is mentioned as something John is doing (Result 74).\n\nFinal answer:  \nApart from yoga, John",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.71,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.57
    },
    {
      "question": "What community service did Maria mention that she was involved in on 31 July, 2023?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "volunteered at a homeless shelter",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the date in question: 31 July 2023.\n\nStep 2: Look for any messages from or to Maria around that date.\n\nStep 3: Result 36 [2023-07-31T14:01:00] Maria to John: \"Wow, John! What was it like being part of that rescue mission?\" \u2014 This shows Maria is aware of John's rescue mission but does not mention her own service.\n\nStep 4: Result 28 [2023-07-22T18:24:30] Maria to John: \"Gonna explore more and volunteer at shelters next month. Can't wait!\" \u2014 This is about future plans to volunteer at shelters, presumably August 2023.\n\nStep 5: Result 61 [2023-08-03T18:21:30] Maria to John: \"I started volunteering here about a year ago (approximately August 03, 2022) after witnessing a family struggling on the",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.01,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.75
    },
    {
      "question": "How did Maria start volunteering at the homeless shelter?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Witnessed a family struggling on the streets and reached out to the shelter",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about how Maria started volunteering.  \n- Result 1 (2023-08-03): Maria says she started volunteering about a year ago (around August 3, 2022) after witnessing a family struggling on the streets, which motivated her to reach out to the shelter.  \n- Result 18 (2023-01-28): Maria mentions being inspired by her aunt who believed in volunteering and helped her family when they were struggling.  \n- Result 49 (2023-02-05): Maria shares that when she was younger, her family had money problems and relied on help from her aunt, which taught her the importance of helping others.  \n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.  \nMaria's direct motivation to start volunteering at the homeless shelter came from witnessing a family struggling on the streets, which inspired her to contact the shelter and offer help. Additionally, her aunt's example of volunteering and family support during hard times influenced her values",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.81,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.41
    },
    {
      "question": "What did John do the week before August 3, 2023 involving his kids?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Had a meaningful experience at a military memorial",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the date of interest: The week before August 3, 2023, is approximately July 27 to August 2, 2023.\n\nStep 2: Look for any mentions of John and his kids around that time or referring to events in that timeframe.\n\nStep 3: Result 82 [2023-08-03T18:24:00] John to Maria says: \"Last week (approximately July 27, 2023), we had a meaningful experience at a military memorial. It really made an impact on my kids.\"\n\nStep 4: This directly answers the question about what John did the week before August 3, 2023, involving his kids.\n\nFinal answer: The week before August 3, 2023, John took his kids to a military memorial, which was a meaningful experience that made an impact on them.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.62,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.77
    },
    {
      "question": "How did John describe his kids' reaction at the military memorial?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "awestruck and humbled",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about the military memorial and John's kids' reaction.\n\n- Result 6 [2023-08-03T18:24:00] John to Maria: \"Last week (approximately July 27, 2023), we had a meaningful experience at a military memorial. It really made an impact on my kids.\"\n- Result 49 [2023-08-03T18:25:00] John to Maria: \"They were awestruck and humbled.\"\n- Result 5 [2023-08-03T18:26:00] John to Maria: \"Yeah, totally! Showing them how to respect and appreciate those who served our country is important. It was a moving experience for all of us.\"\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.\n\nJohn described the experience at the military memorial as meaningful and impactful on his kids, who were \"awestruck and humbled.\" He emphasized the importance of teaching respect and appreciation for those who",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 5.06,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.51
    },
    {
      "question": "Why does Maria think it's important for younger generations to visit military memorials?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "To remember and appreciate those who served",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts where Maria talks about visiting military memorials or the importance of such visits.\n\n- Result 1 [2023-08-03]: Maria says, \"Imagining visiting a military memorial makes me feel humble too. It's important for younger generations to remember and appreciate those who served.\"\n- Result 47 [2023-08-03]: Maria says, \"Yeah John, it's super important to teach kids about veterans and what they did for us.\"\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the reasoning from these statements.\n\nMaria believes visiting military memorials is important because it helps younger generations remember and appreciate the sacrifices and service of veterans.\n\nFinal answer:  \nMaria thinks it's important for younger generations to visit military memorials so they can remember and appreciate those who served in the military.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.92,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.87
    },
    {
      "question": "What does John believe is important for children regarding veterans?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Teaching them to respect and appreciate those who served",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts where John talks about children and veterans.\n\n- Result 1 (Maria to John, 2023-08-03): Maria says it's important to teach kids about veterans and what they did.\n- Result 18 (John to Maria, 2023-08-03): John says, \"Yeah, totally! Showing them how to respect and appreciate those who served our country is important. It was a moving experience for all of us.\"\n- Result 41 (Maria to John, 2023-08-03): Maria mentions a meaningful experience at a military memorial that impacted John's kids.\n- Result 28 (John to Maria, 2023-08-09): John organized a 5K charity run to help veterans and their families, showing his active involvement.\n- Result 5 and 8 (John to Maria, 2023-07-03): John participated in a marching event for veterans' rights and emphasizes the importance of standing",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.03,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.49
    },
    {
      "question": "What happened to John's job in August 2023?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "John lost his job at the mechanical engineering company.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about John's job status in August 2023.\n\n- Result 9 [2023-08-05]: John tells Maria he lost his job at the mechanical engineering company because the company tanked.\n- Result 12 [2023-08-05]: Maria responds expressing sympathy and asks how John is holding up.\n\nStep 2: Confirm no contradictory information or additional details about the job loss.\n\n- No other excerpts contradict or add more details about the job loss in August 2023.\n\nFinal answer:  \nJohn lost his job at the mechanical engineering company in August 2023 because the company tanked.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.34,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.35
    },
    {
      "question": "What activity did Maria take up with her friends from church in August 2023?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "community work",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant time frame and activity.\n- The question asks about an activity Maria did with her friends from church in August 2023.\n\nStep 2: Look for mentions of Maria and church friends around August 2023.\n- Result 30 [2023-07-17]: Maria to John: \"Yeah, last weekend I had a picnic with some friends from church. We chilled under the trees, played games, and ate yummy food. It was great!\"\n\nStep 3: Confirm the timing.\n- The message is from July 17, 2023, and Maria says \"last weekend,\" which would be approximately July 8-9, 2023.\n- This is close to August but technically in July.\n\nStep 4: Check for any other mentions in August 2023.\n- No other direct mentions of activities with church friends in August 2023.\n- Result 60 [2023-05-06]: Maria joined a nearby church",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.47,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.37
    },
    {
      "question": "What did John do to help his community last year in his hometown?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Helped renovate a rundown community center.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the timeframe for \"last year\" relative to the conversation dates. The latest messages are from August 2023, so \"last year\" refers to 2022.\n\nStep 2: Look for mentions of John's community help activities around 2022.\n\nStep 3: In Result 2 (2023-08-05), John says: \"Last year (approximately August 05, 2022), I helped renovate a rundown community center back home.\"\n\nStep 4: This is a clear statement of what John did last year in his hometown to help the community.\n\nFinal answer:  \nLast year, John helped renovate a rundown community center in his hometown.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.47,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.39
    },
    {
      "question": "What cause did the 5K charity run organized by John support?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "veterans and their families",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of John's 5K charity run.\n- Result 1 (2023-08-09): John says he set up a 5K charity run in their neighborhood.\n- Result 11 (2023-08-09): John mentions participating in a community event to raise money for a good cause.\n- Result 12 (2023-08-09): John says they worked with a local organization that helps victims of domestic abuse and raised awareness and funds for that cause.\n- Result 46 (2023-08-09): John talks about getting sponsors and the event supporting veterans.\n- Result 10 (2023-08-16): John confirms they raised a ton and collected items like canned food, toiletries, and clothes.\n- Result 19 (2023-08-16): John says donations helped get a brand new fire truck.\n- Result 65 (2023-08-09): Maria asks John about how he organized the run",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.39,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.6
    },
    {
      "question": "Who did John work with to raise awareness and funds for victims of domestic abuse?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "a local organization",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant excerpt about John raising awareness and funds for victims of domestic abuse.\n\n- Result 1 [2023-08-09T20:10:30] John to Maria: \"Yep, we worked with a local organization that helps victims of domestic abuse. We raised awareness and funds at the event for the cause...\"\n\nStep 2: Check if the name of the organization or any specific partner is mentioned.\n\n- The excerpt only says \"a local organization that helps victims of domestic abuse\" but does not specify the name.\n\nStep 3: Review other excerpts for any mention of the organization or partner related to domestic abuse.\n\n- No other excerpts mention a specific organization name related to domestic abuse.\n\nFinal answer: John worked with a local organization that helps victims of domestic abuse, but the specific name of the organization is not provided.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.09,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.27
    },
    {
      "question": "What recognition did Maria receive at the homeless shelter in August 2023?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "a medal for volunteering",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about Maria's recognition at the homeless shelter in August 2023.\n\n- Result 4 [2023-08-09]: Maria says she volunteered at the homeless shelter last week (around August 2, 2023) and they gave her a medal.\n- Result 48 [2023-08-09]: John congratulates Maria on the recognition she received.\n- Result 60 [2023-04-18]: John praises Maria's dedication but no mention of recognition.\n- Result 100 [2023-08-09]: Maria encourages John to keep spreading positivity, no mention of recognition.\n\nStep 2: Confirm the type of recognition.\n\n- Result 4 explicitly states Maria was given a medal at the homeless shelter.\n\nStep 3: Confirm timing.\n\n- Result 4 states the medal was given last week from August 9, 2023, so approximately August 2, 2023.\n\nFinal answer:  \nMaria received a",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.55,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.99
    },
    {
      "question": "What is the name of Maria's puppy she got two weeks before August 11, 2023?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Coco",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the date two weeks before August 11, 2023, which is approximately July 28, 2023.\n\nStep 2: Look for mentions of Maria getting a puppy around that time.\n\n- Result 1 (2023-08-11): Maria says she got a puppy two weeks ago and her name is Coco.\n- Result 3 (2023-08-13): Maria says she adopted a pup last week (around August 6, 2023) but does not name her.\n- Result 37 (2023-08-13): Maria says the pup's name is Shadow and that she gets along great with her other dog.\n\nStep 3: There is a discrepancy between the names \"Coco\" (Result 1) and \"Shadow\" (Result 37) for Maria's new puppy.\n\nStep 4: Result 1 is the earliest mention (August 11) and explicitly says \"Her name's Coco.\"\n\nStep",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.41,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.07
    },
    {
      "question": "What activity did John and Max enjoy together last summer?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Camping",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of John and Max together.\n- Result 3: John to Maria on 2023-08-11 mentions \"Max and I had a blast on our camping trip last summer. We hiked, swam, and made great memories.\"\n\nStep 2: Confirm the timing.\n- \"Last summer\" from a message dated August 11, 2023, refers to summer 2022.\n\nStep 3: Extract the activities they did.\n- Camping trip\n- Hiking\n- Swimming\n\nFinal answer:  \nJohn and Max enjoyed a camping trip last summer where they hiked and swam together.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 6.0,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.9
    },
    {
      "question": "How does John describe the camping trip with Max?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Peaceful and awesome",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about John's camping trip with Max.  \n- Result 3 (2023-08-11): John says, \"Max and I had a blast on our camping trip last summer. We hiked, swam, and made great memories. It was a really peaceful and awesome experience.\"  \n- Result 6 (2023-08-11): John mentions pets lift spirits and shares a pic of Max, showing fondness.  \n- Result 39 (2023-08-11): John says the trip was like restarting his mind and spirit, peaceful and pretty, helping him savor peaceful moments.  \n- Result 68 (2023-08-11): John says it was chill, being out in nature away from noise, a nice break from everyday hustle.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize these details.  \nJohn describes the camping trip with Max as a blast where they hiked, swam, and made great memories. He found it peaceful",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.95,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.77
    },
    {
      "question": "Why does John say he feels stuck and questioning his decisions and goals?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Not feeling like making much of an impact",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: John expresses feeling \"stuck\" and questioning his decisions and goals in Result 2 (2023-08-11), saying he doesn't feel like he's making much of an impact.\n\nStep 2: In Result 31 (same date), John elaborates that he wants to positively affect people and the world but feels stuck and needs to find a better way to focus his passion and enthusiasm.\n\nStep 3: Maria responds with understanding and encouragement (Results 1, 76, 78), indicating John is going through a tough time emotionally.\n\nStep 4: John is exploring options like joining local organizations or volunteering programs to find a better focus (Result 98).\n\nStep 5: Earlier messages show John has faced self-doubt before (Result 3, 7), but this current feeling seems tied to a lack of perceived impact despite his efforts.\n\nFinal answer:  \nJohn feels stuck and questions his decisions and goals because he doesn't feel like he's making a meaningful impact",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 4.31,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.91
    },
    {
      "question": "What is the name of Maria's second puppy?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Shadow",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Maria's puppies.\n- Result 2 (2023-08-11): Maria says she got a puppy two weeks ago named Coco.\n- Result 3 (2023-08-13): Maria says she adopted a pup from a shelter last week (around August 6, 2023).\n- Result 15 (2023-08-13): Maria says the pup's name is Shadow, full of energy, and they get along great.\n\nStep 2: Confirm that Coco and Shadow are two different puppies.\n- Coco was gotten two weeks before August 11, 2023 (around late July 2023).\n- Shadow was adopted last week before August 13, 2023 (around August 6, 2023).\n- John asks if the new pup and the other dog get along (Result 1), and Maria confirms they do (Result 15).\n\nStep 3: Determine which is the second puppy.\n- Coco",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 5.52,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.82
    },
    {
      "question": "How is Maria's new puppy adjusting to its new home?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "doing great - learning commands and house training",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Maria's new puppy and its adjustment.\n\n- Result 2 (2023-08-13): Maria says she adopted a pup last week (around August 6, 2023) and that the pup brings her joy and she feels blessed.\n- Result 11 (2023-08-11): Maria says she got a puppy two weeks ago named Coco and calls her adorable.\n- Result 18 (2023-08-13): Maria says the little one is doing great, learning commands and house training.\n- Result 95 (2023-08-13): Maria says the puppy is an amazing learner, fun to work with, and has brought her much joy.\n- Result 99 (2023-08-13): Maria says she did not have pets growing up but having a furry pal brightens her days.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.\n\nMaria's new puppy, Coco, adopted around early August 2023,",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.97,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.71
    },
    {
      "question": "What is John currently doing as a volunteer in August 2023?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "mentoring students at a local school",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the timeframe: August 2023.\n\nStep 2: Look for mentions of John's volunteer activities around or in August 2023.\n\n- Result 75 [2023-08-16]: John says, \"Hey Maria! Guess what? I'm now part of the fire-fighting brigade. I'm super excited to be involved and help out my community!\"\n- Result 68 [2023-08-11]: John mentions exploring options and considering joining local organizations or volunteering programs.\n- Result 10 [2023-08-09]: John set up a 5K charity run to help veterans and their families.\n- Result 89 [2023-08-03]: John talks about showing respect and appreciation for veterans, indicating involvement in related activities.\n- Result 98 [2023-08-03]: John asked family and friends to join a virtual support group advocating for the military.\n\nStep 3: Synthesize the information.\n\nIn August 2023,",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.84,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.29
    },
    {
      "question": "What activities does John's family enjoy doing together?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "going for hikes, hanging out at the park, having picnics, playing board games, having movie nights",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of activities John\u2019s family enjoys together.\n\n- Result 1 (2022-12-22): John mentions climbing, sliding, and playing games at the playground.\n- Result 3 (2023-03-06): John says they go to the playground a few times a week for family bonding and letting kids run around.\n- Result 5 (2023-03-06): John mentions swinging and coming up with activities for his family.\n- Result 16 (2023-06-12): John says they had an awesome day at the park with playground fun and family time.\n- Result 48 (2023-08-13): John lists outdoor activities like hiking, hanging out at the park, picnics, plus board games and movie nights at home.\n- Result 54 (2023-06-27): John mentions attending a live music event with family.\n- Result 76 (2023-08-11): John talks about",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.46,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.6
    },
    {
      "question": "What did the donations help John's community acquire on 16 August, 2023?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "a brand new fire truck",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant date and context. The question asks about donations helping John's community on 16 August 2023.\n\nStep 2: Look for messages around 16 August 2023 mentioning donations and their impact.\n\n- Result 14 [2023-08-16T11:13:00] John to Maria: \"The donations even helped get a brand new fire truck!\"\n- Result 5 [2023-08-16T11:11:00] John to Maria: \"Yup, we raised a ton! We got stuff like canned food, toiletries, and clothes to help out.\"\n- Result 46 [2023-08-16T11:11:30] Maria to John: \"It's great to see the community coming together to support the local fire station.\"\n- Result 8 [2023-08-16T11:13:30] Maria to John: \"Look at that - we all donated for it, and it",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-41",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.23,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.11
    },
    {
      "question": "Is it likely that Nate has friends besides Joanna?",
      "category": 3,
      "gold_answer": "Yesteammates on hisvideo game team.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Nate mentions hanging out with \"some of the guys at the tournament\" and \"old friends and teammates from other tournaments\" (Results 4, 5, 24). This indicates he has a social circle beyond Joanna.\n\nStep 2: Nate talks about helping friends reset their high scores at an international tournament (Result 37), showing ongoing interactions with multiple friends.\n\nStep 3: Nate refers to a couple he knows and has some relationship with (Results 2, 71), again indicating other acquaintances.\n\nStep 4: Nate also mentions meeting new people who share his interests, such as board games and gaming content creation (Results 43, 18), suggesting expanding social connections.\n\nStep 5: Joanna encourages Nate to keep going and reach for his dreams, implying a supportive network, but the direct evidence of other friends is primarily from Nate's own mentions.\n\nFinal answer: Yes, it is very likely that Nate has friends besides Joanna.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.18,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.32
    },
    {
      "question": "What kind of interests do Joanna and Nate share?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Watching movies, making desserts",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify Joanna's interests from the context:\n- Joanna enjoys dramas and romance (Result 43, 78, 83, 95).\n- She likes writing (Result 53, 79).\n- She enjoys reading, watching movies, and exploring nature (Result 79).\n- She is invested in \"those little guys\" (likely pets or small animals) (Results 5, 6, 89).\n- She likes DIY projects (Result 60).\n- She appreciates creative activities and networking (Results 59, 98).\n\nStep 2: Identify Nate's interests from the context:\n- Nate enjoys video games and watching movies (Results 27, 96).\n- He is involved in gaming tournaments and creating gaming content (Results 4, 20, 55, 90).\n- He likes animals/pets (Results 1, 3, 13, 35, 57).\n- He appreciates creative projects and writing (Results 53",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 4.84,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.48
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Joanna first watch \"Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "2019",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify any mention of \"Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind\" or a similar movie in the context.  \nStep 2: In Result 1, Joanna says on 2022-01-21 that she first watched \"that movie\" around 3 years ago and got a physical copy.  \nStep 3: In Result 20, Joanna mentions a romantic drama about memory and relationships, which matches the theme of \"Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind.\"  \nStep 4: The date of the message in Result 1 is January 21, 2022. Three years before that would be around early 2019.\n\nFinal answer: Joanna first watched \"Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind\" around early 2019.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.59,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.07
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Nate win his first video game tournament?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "the week before 21Janury, 2022",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Nate winning tournaments and their dates.\n\n- Result 10 [2022-01-21]: Nate says he won his first video game tournament last week, approximately January 14, 2022.\n- Result 1 and 19-23 confirm this was his first win and the game was Counter-Strike: Global Offensive.\n\nStep 2: Confirm no earlier wins mentioned.\n\n- No earlier wins are mentioned before January 14, 2022.\n\nFinal answer: Nate won his first video game tournament around January 14, 2022.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.9,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.34
    },
    {
      "question": "What pets wouldn't cause any discomfort to Joanna?",
      "category": 3,
      "gold_answer": "Hairless cats or pigs,since they don't have fur, which is one of the main causes of Joanna's allergy.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Joanna is allergic to most reptiles and animals with fur (Result 7, 16). She also found out she is allergic to cockroaches (Result 30).\n\nStep 2: Joanna wishes she could have turtles but is allergic to cockroaches, which might be related to some reptiles or insects (Result 30).\n\nStep 3: Nate has turtles as pets, which Joanna can watch from a distance without discomfort (Result 28, 88).\n\nStep 4: Joanna has a stuffed animal dog named Tilly, which does not cause allergies (Result 9, 52).\n\nStep 5: Joanna explicitly says she is allergic to animals with fur and reptiles, so pets without fur or scales, such as stuffed animals or possibly fish or other non-furry, non-reptile pets, would not cause discomfort.\n\nFinal answer:  \nPets without fur or scales, such as turtles (viewed from a distance) and stuffed animals like her dog Tilly",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.35,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.57
    },
    {
      "question": "What are Joanna's hobbies?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Writing, watchingmovies, exploringnature, hanging withfriends.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Joanna's hobbies in the excerpts.\n\n- [Result 4] Nate asks Joanna about hobbies.\n- [Result 26] Joanna says she has been working on a project and asks Nate about hobbies.\n- [Result 54] Joanna says she enjoys writing, reading, watching movies, and exploring nature.\n- [Result 84] Joanna says she enjoys writing and hanging with friends.\n- [Result 88] Joanna says writing and creative projects help her through tough times.\n- [Result 27] Joanna mentions taking time for little friends and activities she loves.\n- [Result 91] Joanna mentions Woodhaven's past inspiring her next script, implying writing.\n- [Result 58] Joanna talks about getting invested in small things that make life nicer, which may relate to hobbies.\n- [Result 29, 35, 77] Nate talks about Joanna making desserts, implying baking as a hobby.\n\nStep 2: Summarize Joanna's hobbies",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.52,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.25
    },
    {
      "question": "How long has Nate had his first two turtles?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "three years",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of how long Nate has had his turtles.\n\n- Result 57 [2022-01-23]: Nate says, \"I've had them for 3 years now and they bring me tons of joy!\"\n- Result 5 [2022-01-23]: Nate refers to \"both\" turtles, indicating he had two turtles at that time.\n- Result 1 [2022-11-09]: Nate mentions getting a third turtle recently, implying the first two were already owned before then.\n\nStep 2: Confirm the timeline.\n\n- On January 23, 2022, Nate had two turtles and had owned them for 3 years.\n- Therefore, he got his first two turtles around early 2019.\n\nFinal answer: Nate has had his first two turtles for about 3 years as of January 2022.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.47,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.31
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Joanna finish her first screenplay?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "The Friday before 23January, 2022",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify any direct mentions of Joanna finishing her first screenplay.\n- Result 1 (2022-01-23): Joanna says she \"finally finished my first full screenplay and printed it last Friday.\"\n- Result 24 (2022-01-23): Nate responds to Joanna's excitement about finishing.\n- Result 39 (2022-01-23): Nate congratulates Joanna on finishing.\n\nStep 2: Determine the date of \"last Friday\" relative to the message date.\n- Joanna's message is dated 2022-01-23 (Sunday).\n- The Friday before 2022-01-23 is 2022-01-21.\n\nStep 3: Confirm no other earlier or conflicting information.\n- No earlier messages mention finishing the first screenplay.\n- Other messages later in 2022 refer to second and subsequent scripts.\n\nFinal answer: Joanna finished her first screenplay on Friday, January 21, 2022.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.99,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.16
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Nate get his first two turtles?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "2019",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify any direct mentions of how long Nate has had his turtles.  \n- In [Result 88] (2022-01-23), Nate says: \"I've had them for 3 years now and they bring me tons of joy!\"  \n- This message is dated January 23, 2022.\n\nStep 2: Calculate the approximate time Nate got his first two turtles.  \n- If on January 23, 2022, Nate had his turtles for 3 years, he must have gotten them around January 2019.\n\nStep 3: Confirm that these are the first two turtles.  \n- In [Result 4] (2022-01-23), Nate mentions \"The turtles might be small, but both sure have big personalities,\" indicating he had two turtles at that time.  \n- Later in [Result 1] (2022-11-09), Nate mentions getting a third turtle, confirming the first two were acquired earlier.\n\n",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.43,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.14
    },
    {
      "question": "What major achievement did Joanna accomplish in January 2022?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "finished her screenplay and printed it",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for any mentions of Joanna's achievements around January 2022.\n\nStep 2: Result 21 (2022-01-21) shows Nate telling Joanna he won his first video game tournament last week (around January 14, 2022), but this is about Nate, not Joanna.\n\nStep 3: Result 31 (2022-01-23) Nate congratulates Joanna on something that sounds like a \"wild experience\" and hopes \"they love it,\" which suggests Joanna had something significant happen.\n\nStep 4: Result 14 (2022-01-23) Nate says Joanna sounds excited, indicating something positive happened.\n\nStep 5: Result 83 (2022-10-25) Joanna says seeing her writing acted out on the big screen was an amazing experience and that this is the third time it happened, implying she had a script or project made into a movie.\n\nStep 6: Result 36 (2022-02-",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.29,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.99
    },
    {
      "question": "What emotions is Joanna feeling about  the screenplay she submitted?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Relief, excitement,worry, hope,anxiety.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Joanna's emotions about her screenplay submission.\n\n- Result 1 (2022-01-23): Joanna says she finally finished her first full screenplay and feels relief.\n- Result 22 (2022-01-23): Joanna describes feeling a rollercoaster of emotions\u2014relief, excitement, and some anxiety\u2014over finishing the project and submitting it to film festivals.\n- Result 13 (2022-02-07): Joanna mentions bouncing between crazy emotions like relief, excitement, and worry about her screenplay sent to a film festival.\n- Result 6 (2022-03-18): Joanna talks about mixed feelings of relief and anxiety about what comes next with her second script.\n- Result 41 (2022-06-03): Joanna shares feeling bummed out after a rejection letter from a major company.\n- Result 97 (2022-01-23): Joanna confirms a mix of emotions and hopes for positive feedback and new opportunities.\n\n",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 4.15,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.36
    },
    {
      "question": "What is Joanna allergic to?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Most reptiles,animals with fur,cockroaches, dairy",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Joanna mentions in [Result 2] that her face gets puffy and itchy around certain animals, so she avoids them.\n\nStep 2: In [Result 6], Joanna explicitly states she is allergic to most reptiles and animals with fur.\n\nStep 3: In [Result 11], Joanna adds that she recently found out (around March 11, 2022) she is allergic to cockroaches as well.\n\nStep 4: In [Result 5], Joanna mentions having to give up a dog due to allergies, reinforcing the fur allergy.\n\nFinal answer: Joanna is allergic to most reptiles, animals with fur, and cockroaches.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.98,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.77
    },
    {
      "question": "What underlying condition might Joanna have based on her allergies?",
      "category": 3,
      "gold_answer": "asthma",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Joanna mentions multiple allergies to animals, including most reptiles, animals with fur, and cockroaches (Results 3, 5, 29).\n\nStep 2: She experiences symptoms like a puffy and itchy face when around certain animals (Result 3).\n\nStep 3: She is also lactose intolerant (Results 70, 61).\n\nStep 4: The combination of multiple animal allergies and lactose intolerance suggests a broader underlying allergic or atopic condition.\n\nStep 5: Such a pattern is consistent with atopy, which is a genetic tendency to develop allergic diseases including allergic rhinitis, asthma, eczema, and food allergies.\n\nFinal answer: Joanna likely has an atopic condition characterized by multiple allergies and lactose intolerance.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.99,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.27
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Joanna have an audition for a writing gig?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "23 March, 2022.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify any mention of Joanna having an audition for a writing gig.  \nStep 2: Result 4 states: \"[2022-03-24T13:43:30] Joanna to Nate: Hey Nate! Been quite a ride - in a good way - had an audition yesterday (approximately March 23, 2022) for a writing gig.\"  \nStep 3: This clearly indicates Joanna had the audition on March 23, 2022.\n\nFinal answer: Joanna had an audition for a writing gig on March 23, 2022.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.8,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.4
    },
    {
      "question": "What nickname does Nate use for Joanna?",
      "category": 3,
      "gold_answer": "Jo",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for instances where Nate addresses Joanna in the conversation excerpts.\n\nStep 2: Check if Nate uses any nickname or shortened form of Joanna's name.\n\nStep 3: In multiple excerpts, Nate calls Joanna \"Jo\" (e.g., Result 28: \"Wow, that's awesome! Those both can definitely be therapeutic. It's great to have such positive relationships that make such a great impact.\" and Result 54: \"Wow, Jo, that's really cool! It's great to have something that gets those creative juices flowing.\").\n\nStep 4: No other nickname for Joanna is evident in the excerpts.\n\nFinal answer: Nate uses the nickname \"Jo\" for Joanna.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.46,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.31
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Nate get purple hair?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "The week before 15April, 2022.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Nate mentioned he dyed his hair last week in message [Result 1] dated 2022-04-15, so the hair dyeing happened approximately April 8, 2022.\n\nStep 2: Joanna responded on the same day, complimenting the new hair color and asking about the shade [Result 2].\n\nStep 3: Nate replied that he picked a bright and bold color [Result 29], which aligns with the purple hair.\n\nStep 4: No other dates or mentions contradict this timing.\n\nFinal answer: Nate got his purple hair around April 8, 2022.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.8,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.45
    },
    {
      "question": "What physical transformation did Nate undergo in April 2022?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "dyed his hair purple",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for any mention of Nate and physical changes or transformations around April 2022.\n\nStep 2: In [Result 47] dated 2022-04-15, Nate tells Joanna: \"Hey Jo, guess what I did? Dyed my hair last week (approximately April 08, 2022) - come see!\"\n\nStep 3: This is a clear mention of a physical transformation Nate underwent in April 2022.\n\nFinal answer: Nate dyed his hair around April 8, 2022.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.12,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.26
    },
    {
      "question": "What movie did Joanna watch on 1 May, 2022?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "Lord of the Rings",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify any mentions of Joanna watching movies around early May 2022.\n\nStep 2: The closest date to May 1, 2022, in the context is from early February and January, where Joanna mentions watching \"Little Women\" (Results 4, 10, 26).\n\nStep 3: There is no direct mention of Joanna watching a movie specifically on May 1, 2022.\n\nStep 4: No other movie titles or specific viewing dates around May 1, 2022, are mentioned in the context.\n\nFinal answer: Not enough information.",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.92,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.22
    },
    {
      "question": "Which outdoor spot did Joanna visit in May?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "Whispering Falls waterfall",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify messages from May mentioning Joanna's outdoor activities.  \n- Result 48 (2022-05-12): Joanna says she went hiking and found amazing trails in her town.  \n- Result 2 (2022-05-12): Joanna mentions loving a spot on the hike with soothing rushing water.  \n- Result 8 (2022-05-12): Joanna says she took a photo at a place called Whispering Falls, describing it as peaceful and serene.  \n- Result 33 (2022-05-12): Joanna describes the place as calming and beautiful nature.  \n\nStep 2: Cross-check Nate's responses for confirmation.  \n- Result 9 (2022-05-12): Nate asks where the picture was taken, noting the dark sky and green scenery.  \n- Result 5 (2022-05-12): Nate asks if Joanna took photos of the spot.  \n- Result 20 (2022-05-12",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 4.0,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.28
    },
    {
      "question": "How many times has Joanna found new hiking trails?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "twice",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify all mentions of Joanna finding new hiking trails.\n\n- Result 2 (2022-04-17): Joanna found an awesome hiking trail in her hometown \"yesterday\" (April 16, 2022).\n- Result 1 (2022-05-12): Joanna went hiking and found some more amazing trails in her town.\n- Result 5 (2022-05-12): Joanna confirms she did find a spot on the hike she loved.\n- Result 6 (2022-06-03): Joanna mentions hiking with buddies on a new trail with a waterfall.\n\nStep 2: Count distinct occasions of finding new trails.\n\n- April 16, 2022: Found a new trail in hometown.\n- By May 12, 2022: Found some more amazing trails (implying multiple new trails).\n- June 2022: Planning to check out a new trail with a waterfall.\n\nStep 3: Synthesize.\n\nJoanna",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.45,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.54
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Nate adopt Max?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "May 2022",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the earliest mention of Max.  \n- Result 2 (2022-05-20T19:50:00) Nate to Joanna: \"I just got a new addition to the family, this is Max!\"  \n- Result 3 (2022-05-20T19:51:00) Nate to Joanna: \"Thanks! It's awesome - he's adopted and so full of energy...\"\n\nStep 2: Confirm that this is the adoption time.  \n- Nate says \"I just got\" Max on 2022-05-20, indicating the adoption was very recent at that time.\n\nStep 3: No earlier mentions of Max or adoption found in the context.\n\nFinal answer: Nate adopted Max around May 20, 2022.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.99,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.6
    },
    {
      "question": "Who was the new addition to Nate's family in May 2022?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "Max",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for mentions of new additions to Nate's family around May 2022.\n\nStep 2: Result 22 [2022-05-20T19:50:00] Nate to Joanna: \"Way to go! I just got a new addition to the family, this is Max!\"\n\nStep 3: Result 33 [2022-05-20T19:51:00] Nate to Joanna: \"Thanks! It's awesome - he's adopted and so full of energy, and he's filling my life with so much joy. He's even keeping my other pets active.\"\n\nStep 4: These messages clearly identify \"Max\" as the new addition to Nate's family in May 2022.\n\nFinal answer: The new addition to Nate's family in May 2022 was a pet named Max.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 4.08,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.47
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Joanna start writing her third screenplay?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "May 2022",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Joanna's screenplays and their order.\n\n- Result 1 (2022-01-23): Joanna finished her first full screenplay last Friday (around January 14, 2022).\n- Result 74 (2022-03-18): Joanna wrapped up her second script by mid-March 2022.\n- Result 19 (2022-11-07): Joanna says she is writing another movie script (a love story), which would be her third screenplay.\n- Result 13 (2022-11-07): Joanna just finished the intro to her next movie script (likely the third).\n- Result 29 (2022-10-25): Joanna mentions seeing her work come alive on screen for the third time, implying two previous screenplays were already made into movies.\n\nStep 2: Look for when she started writing the third screenplay.\n\n- Result 19 (Nov 7, 2022) states she is currently writing the",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.97,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.29
    },
    {
      "question": "Which of Joanna's screenplay were rejected from production companies?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "first screenplay on drama and romance, third screenplay on loss identity and connection",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of screenplay rejections from production companies.\n\n- Result 2 (2022-06-03): Joanna mentions getting a rejection letter from a major company after finishing her screenplay.\n- Result 5 (2022-10-21): Joanna mentions a setback with another rejection from a production company around October 14, 2022.\n- Result 13 (2022-06-03): Joanna says the rejection letter was generic with no feedback.\n- Result 29 (2022-06-03): Nate asks if something happened with the company after the rejection.\n- Result 68 (2022-11-07): Joanna says she submitted a few more scripts last week (around October 31, 2022), expecting some rejections.\n\nStep 2: Determine which screenplays these rejections refer to.\n\n- The first rejection (Result 2) is after finishing her first full screenplay (Result 6, finished January 23, 2022",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.68,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.51
    },
    {
      "question": "When is Nate hosting a gaming party?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "The weekend after 3June, 2022.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of a gaming party by Nate.  \n- Result 8 [2022-06-03]: Nate says, \"I'm organizing a gaming party two weekends later.\"  \n- Result 26 [2022-06-24]: Nate says, \"The gaming party was a great success!\" indicating the party already happened by June 24, 2022.\n\nStep 2: Determine the date of the message where Nate mentions the party is upcoming.  \n- Result 8 is dated 2022-06-03, and Nate says the party is \"two weekends later,\" which would be approximately mid-June 2022.\n\nStep 3: Confirm the party timing from other messages.  \n- Result 42 [2022-06-24]: Nate mentions 7 people attended the party and 6 want to do it again next month, confirming the party was held before June 24, 2022.\n\nFinal answer: Nate was hosting the gaming party",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.57,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.43
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Joanna hike with her buddies?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "The weekend after 3June, 2022.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Joanna hiking.\n- Result 2 (2022-05-12): Joanna says she went hiking and found amazing trails.\n- Result 1 (2022-05-12): Joanna mentions loving a spot on the hike.\n- Result 23 (2022-05-12): Joanna invites Nate to join her on the trails sometime.\n- Result 82 (2022-05-12): Joanna describes the peacefulness of the hike.\n\nStep 2: Check if there is any mention of hiking with buddies.\n- No explicit mention of \"buddies\" hiking with Joanna in these excerpts.\n- However, Result 23 suggests Joanna invites Nate to join her, implying she might hike with others.\n\nStep 3: Look for any other mentions of hiking with friends or buddies.\n- Result 72 (2022-04-17): Nate says he's not into hiking but is curious about a trail.\n- No other direct mentions of Joanna hiking with",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.59,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.32
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Nate win his third tourney?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "The week before 3June, 2022",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Nate's tournament wins in chronological order.\n\n- Result 22 (2022-01-21): Nate won his first tournament approximately January 14, 2022.\n- Result 2 (2022-05-02): Nate won his second tournament approximately April 25, 2022.\n- Result 26 (2022-07-10): Nate won his fourth tournament on Friday (July 8, 2022).\n- Result 6 (2022-08-22): Nate won an international tournament yesterday (August 21, 2022).\n\nStep 2: Locate any mention of the third tournament win.\n\n- Result 25 (2022-11-09): Joanna asks Nate, \"Wow, what made you get a third?\" indicating Nate had a third win before November 9, 2022.\n- No direct message states the exact date of the third win.\n- Result 34 (2022-10-06",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.48,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.19
    },
    {
      "question": "What places has Joanna submitted her work to?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "film contest, film festival.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for mentions of Joanna submitting work or dealing with production companies.\n\n- Result 6 (2022-11-07): Joanna says she submitted a few more last week (around Oct 31, 2022).\n- Result 43 (2022-10-21): Joanna mentions a setback with another rejection from a production company around Oct 14, 2022.\n- Result 44 (2022-11-07): Nate asks if Joanna plans to submit more scripts soon.\n- Result 11 (2022-11-04): Nate asks how it went with producer meetings.\n- Result 90 (2022-06-03): Nate encourages Joanna not to give up after rejection.\n- Result 68 (2022-02-07): Nate talks about hoping someone likes Joanna's work enough to get it on the big screen.\n\nStep 2: Identify specific places or companies Joanna submitted to.\n\n- The only specific mention is \"production company\" (",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.19,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.28
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Nate make vegan icecream and share it with a vegan diet group?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "The Friday before 24June, 2022.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant excerpt about Nate making vegan ice cream and sharing it with a vegan diet group.\n\n- Result 1 [2022-06-24T10:58:30] Nate to Joanna: \"Thanks! On another note, I made vegan ice cream last Friday and shared it with some people in my vegan diet group. It was awesome!\"\n\nStep 2: Determine the date of the message and the referenced \"last Friday.\"\n\n- The message is dated 2022-06-24 (Friday).\n- \"Last Friday\" would be the Friday before 2022-06-24, which is 2022-06-17.\n\nFinal answer:  \nNate made vegan ice cream and shared it with his vegan diet group on Friday, June 17, 2022.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.14,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.37
    },
    {
      "question": "When is Joanna going to make Nate's ice cream for her family?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "The weekend of 24June, 2022.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Joanna making Nate's ice cream for her family.  \n- Result 17 [2022-06-24T11:00:00] Joanna to Nate: \"Awesome! I'm going to make it for my family this weekend - can't wait!\"\n\nStep 2: Check the date of this message to determine when \"this weekend\" refers to.  \n- The message is dated June 24, 2022, which is a Friday.  \n- Therefore, \"this weekend\" would be June 25-26, 2022.\n\nFinal answer: Joanna is going to make Nate's ice cream for her family on the weekend of June 25-26, 2022.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.56,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.29
    },
    {
      "question": "What kind of writings does Joanna do?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Screenplays,books, online blog posts, journal",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Joanna mentions writing as a way to express feelings and as an escape (Result 3, 76).  \nStep 2: She writes personal and emotional stories about loss, identity, connection, redemption, and forgiveness (Results 15, 33, 46, 47).  \nStep 3: Joanna has written about a thirty-year-old woman on a journey of self-discovery after a loss (Result 30).  \nStep 4: She also writes blog posts about hard moments in her life that have touched readers (Result 11).  \nStep 5: Joanna is working on creative projects and has finished writing a book (Results 45, 71, 97).  \nStep 6: Her writing includes scripts and stories with characters, and she is involved in a writing club (Results 10, 27, 68, 100).  \n\nFinal answer: Joanna writes personal, emotional stories and scripts focused on themes like loss, identity, and",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 4.62,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.22
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Nate win his fourth video game tournament?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "The Friday before 10July, 2022.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Nate's tournament wins and their order.\n\n- Result 11 (2022-01-21): Nate won his first tournament around January 14, 2022.\n- Result 3 (2022-05-02): Nate won his second tournament around April 25, 2022.\n- Result 8 (2022-06-03): Nate won another tournament around May 27, 2022 (likely his third).\n- Result 9 (2022-07-10): Nate says he won his fourth video game tournament on Friday (the message is dated July 10, 2022).\n\nStep 2: Determine the exact date of the fourth tournament win.\n\n- Result 9 is dated July 10, 2022 (Sunday).\n- Nate says he won the fourth tournament \"on Friday,\" which would be July 8, 2022.\n\nFinal answer: Nate won his fourth video game tournament on Friday, July ",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.44,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.8
    },
    {
      "question": "Where did Joanna travel to in July 2022?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "Woodhaven",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify any mentions of Joanna traveling in July 2022.\n- Result 1 (2022-07-10): Nate asks Joanna about a road trip she took, showing interest in where she went and what she discovered.\n- Result 46 (2022-04-15): Joanna mentions the sky was gorgeous and wishes she had a vacation lined up, but no specific trip mentioned.\n- Result 95 (2022-05-12): Joanna says she loved a spot on a hike with the rush of water soothing her, but this is in May, not July.\n- Result 1 and 26 and 29 (all 2022-07-10): Nate is responding to Joanna's road trip, asking what stuck out and expressing excitement about it.\n\nStep 2: Look for Joanna's direct response about the trip location.\n- No direct message from Joanna in July 2022 explicitly naming the location.\n- Result 46 (April) and 95",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.5,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.42
    },
    {
      "question": "When did someone write Joanna a touching letter?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "The week before 14August, 2022.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of a letter written to Joanna.\n\n- Result 2 (2022-08-14): Joanna says \"Last week (approximately August 07, 2022), someone wrote me a letter after reading an online blog post I made about a hard moment in my life.\"\n- Result 4 (2022-11-07): Nate refers to \"That letter\" and asks if it reminds her of childhood.\n- Result 14 (2022-11-07): Joanna says her brother wrote the letter, which brings back memories.\n\nStep 2: Confirm the timing.\n\n- Joanna's message on 2022-08-14 says the letter was received \"last week,\" approximately August 7, 2022.\n\nStep 3: Synthesize.\n\n- The touching letter was written to Joanna around August 7, 2022, after she posted a blog about a hard moment in her life.\n\nFinal answer:  \nJoanna received a touching letter around",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.14,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.5
    },
    {
      "question": "What book recommendations has Joanna given to Nate?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "\"Little Women\",'A Court of Thorns andRoses'.",
      "generated_answer": "Step-by-step analysis:\n\n1. Joanna suggests to Nate in [Result 6] (2022-08-22) that he should find a fantasy book series to read through, noting that most fiction series are great for relaxing.\n\n2. Nate responds positively to this recommendation in [Result 5] (2022-08-22), recommending a series back to Joanna, and Joanna replies in [Result 38] (2022-08-22) that she will add his recommendation to her list.\n\n3. In [Result 4] (2022-04-21), Joanna acknowledges a series Nate recommended, saying it has been on her list forever and thanks him for the recommendation.\n\n4. In [Result 39] (2022-10-06), Joanna mentions finishing her writing for her book but does not specify a book recommendation to Nate.\n\n5. No specific book titles or series names are mentioned by Joanna in the excerpts.\n\n6. Joanna also recommended the movie \"",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.11,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.76
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Nate take time off to chill with his pets?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "The weekend of 22August, 2022.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify any mentions of Nate taking time off to chill with his pets.  \nStep 2: Result 14 [2022-08-22T11:01:00] Nate to Joanna says: \"I'm taking some time off this weekend to chill with my pets.\"  \nStep 3: The date of this message is August 22, 2022, and he refers to \"this weekend,\" which would be the weekend around that date.\n\nFinal answer: Nate took time off to chill with his pets on the weekend of August 22, 2022.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.97,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.37
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Joanna share her book with her writers group?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "The week before 22August, 2022.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for mentions of Joanna sharing her book with her writers group.  \nStep 2: In [Result 26] dated 2022-08-22T10:59:30, Joanna says: \"Was super nervous last week (approximately August 15, 2022) when I shared my book with my writers group but got some great feedback.\"  \nStep 3: This clearly states the approximate date Joanna shared her book with her writers group as around August 15, 2022.\n\nFinal answer: Joanna shared her book with her writers group around August 15, 2022.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.21,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.54
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Nate win an international tournament?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "21 August, 2022",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Nate winning an international tournament.\n\n- Result 1 (2022-08-22): Nate says he won an international tournament \"yesterday,\" which would be approximately August 21, 2022.\n- Result 4 (2022-11-04): Nate mentions helping friends reset high scores at the international tournament, but no mention of winning.\n- Result 14 (2022-11-07): Nate won a big Valorant tournament final last Saturday, which would be November 5, 2022, but it is not specified as international.\n- Result 27 (2022-07-10): Nate won his fourth video game tournament on Friday, online, but no mention of international.\n- Result 45 (2022-10-06): Nate won a really big video game tournament last week (approx. Sept 29, 2022), no mention if international.\n\nStep 2: Confirm the only explicit mention of an international",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.41,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.39
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Joanna make a desert with almond milk?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "The Friday before 14September, 2022",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Joanna making desserts with almond milk.  \n- Result 9 (2022-09-14): Joanna says, \"Last Friday, I made a deeeelish dessert with almond milk - it was good!\"  \n- Result 2 (2022-09-14): Joanna describes a dessert with almond flour, coconut oil, chocolate, and raspberries, but this is about flour, not milk.  \n- Result 30 (2022-09-14): Joanna mentions a dessert with blueberries, coconut milk, and gluten-free crust, not almond milk.\n\nStep 2: Determine the date of \"Last Friday\" relative to the message date.  \n- The message is from 2022-09-14 (Wednesday).  \n- The Friday before 2022-09-14 is 2022-09-09.\n\nFinal answer: Joanna made a dessert with almond milk on Friday, September 9, 2022.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 4.88,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.21
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Nate attend a cooking show?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "The Monday before 14September, 2022",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for mentions of Nate attending or participating in a cooking show.\n\nStep 2: Result 30 [2022-09-14T13:44:30] Nate to Joanna says: \"Last Monday I got to teach people vegan ice cream recipes on my own cooking show! It was a bit nerve-wracking to put myself out there, but it was a blast.\"\n\nStep 3: The message is dated September 14, 2022, and \"last Monday\" would be September 12, 2022.\n\nFinal answer: Nate attended (and taught on) a cooking show on September 12, 2022.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.15,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.47
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Joanna's laptop crash?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "The week before 14September, 2022",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify any mention of Joanna's laptop crashing in the context.  \n- Result 1 [2022-09-14]: Joanna says her laptop crashed last week, approximately September 07, 2022.\n\nStep 2: Confirm no other conflicting or additional information about the laptop crash date.  \n- Result 5 and 6 also discuss the crash but do not contradict the date.\n\nFinal answer: Joanna's laptop crashed around September 7, 2022.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.37,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.57
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Joanna make a chocolate tart with raspberries?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "5 October, 2022",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Joanna making a chocolate tart with raspberries.\n- Result 3 (2022-09-14): Joanna says her favorite dairy-free treat is a chocolate raspberry tart with almond flour crust, chocolate ganache, and fresh raspberries.\n- Result 1 (2022-09-14): Joanna describes making it with almond flour, coconut oil, chocolate, and raspberries.\n- Result 7 (2022-09-14): Joanna mentions making a dairy-free chocolate cake with raspberries.\n\nStep 2: Confirm the date of these messages.\n- All these messages are from September 14, 2022.\n\nStep 3: Check if there is any earlier or later mention of making the tart.\n- No earlier or later specific date is given for making the tart, only the messages on 2022-09-14.\n\nFinal answer: Joanna made the chocolate tart with raspberries around September 14, 2022.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.39,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.81
    },
    {
      "question": "What movies have both Joanna and Nate seen?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "\"Little Women\", \"Lord of the Rings\"",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify movies Joanna has mentioned watching:\n- \"Little Women\" (Joanna watched it and recommended it to Nate) [Results 8, 12]\n- A classic movie Joanna watched around 3 years ago and got a physical copy of (title not specified) [Results 1, 3, 4]\n- Romantic drama about memory and relationships (title not specified) [Result 30]\n- \"The Lord of the Rings\" Trilogy (Joanna watched it after Nate recommended it) [Result 51]\n\nStep 2: Identify movies Nate has mentioned watching:\n- \"Little Women\" (Nate watched it recently, around September 29, 2022) [Result 8]\n- A classic movie (Nate loves watching classics) [Results 14, 60]\n- \"The Lord of the Rings\" Trilogy (Nate recommended it to Joanna) [Results 46, 51]\n- Iron Man (Nate's top pick)",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.58,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.64
    },
    {
      "question": "How long did it take for Joanna to finish writing her book?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "four months",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify when Joanna started writing her book.  \n- Result 9 (2022-07-10) Joanna says she started on a book recently, approximately July 3, 2022.\n\nStep 2: Identify when Joanna finished writing her book.  \n- Result 5 (2022-10-06) Joanna says she finished writing her book last week, approximately September 29, 2022.\n\nStep 3: Calculate the time between start and finish.  \n- From July 3, 2022 to September 29, 2022 is about 12 weeks or nearly 3 months.\n\nFinal answer:  \nJoanna took about three months to finish writing her book, from early July to late September 2022.",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.8,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.36
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Nate win a lot of money in a video game tournament?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "September 2022",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Nate winning money in tournaments.  \n- Result 10 (2022-10-06): Nate says he won a really big video game tournament last week (around September 29, 2022) and made a lot of money from it.  \n- Result 9 (2022-10-06): Joanna congratulates Nate on winning the tournament and earning cash.  \n- Result 35 (2022-11-07): Nate won a big Valorant tournament last Saturday (around November 5, 2022), but no mention of money.  \n- Other tournament wins mention success and pride but do not specifically mention money.\n\nStep 2: Confirm the specific time when Nate won a lot of money.  \n- The clearest mention of winning a lot of money is in Result 10, dated 2022-10-06, referring to a tournament win approximately September 29, 2022.\n\nFinal answer:  \nNate won",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.25,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.45
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Joanna finish up the writing for her book?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "The week before 6October, 2022",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify any direct mentions of Joanna finishing her book writing.  \n- Result 11 (2022-10-06) Joanna says she finished her writing for her book last week, approximately September 29, 2022.\n\nStep 2: Confirm no other conflicting or more precise dates are given.  \n- Result 18 (2022-08-22) mentions Joanna sharing her book with her writers group around August 15, 2022, implying the book was still in progress then.  \n- Result 39 (2022-07-10) Joanna says she started a book around July 3, 2022.  \n- No other messages contradict the September 29, 2022 finish date.\n\nFinal answer: Joanna finished up the writing for her book around September 29, 2022.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.06,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.42
    },
    {
      "question": "What board games has Nate played?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Chess, Catan.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of board games in the context.\n\n- Result 2 (2022-10-09): Nate mentions meeting people who played a board game he loves.\n- Result 10 (2022-10-09): Nate specifies the board game as \"Catan,\" describing it as a strategy game involving building settlements and trading resources.\n- Result 37 (2022-10-09): Joanna comments on how games bring people together, referring to the convention Nate attended where he played Catan.\n\nStep 2: Check if any other board games are mentioned.\n\n- No other board games are named in the excerpts.\n- Other games mentioned are video games (CS:GO, Street Fighter, Xeonoblade Chronicles, Cyberpunk 2077), not board games.\n\nFinal answer:  \nNate has played the board game \"Catan.\"",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.41,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.16
    },
    {
      "question": "What places has Nate met new people?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "A tournament and agaming convention.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Nate meeting new people in the context.\n\n- Result 44 [2022-10-09]: Nate says he went to a game convention last Friday where he met new people outside his normal circle.\n- Result 78 [2022-10-09]: Nate mentions meeting people who played a board game he loves and joining in with them.\n- Result 60 [2022-01-23]: Nate says he started hanging out with some people outside his circle at a tournament.\n- Result 36 [2022-06-03]: Nate mentions meeting some new people at a regional video game tournament.\n- Result 62 [2022-06-24]: Nate talks about a group of 7 people attending something, presumably a social or gaming event, with plans to meet again.\n- Result 69 [2022-01-23]: Nate mentions some people are more competitive, so he sticks with more chill people, implying socializing at tournaments or",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.96,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.43
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Nate go to a convention and meet new people?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "The Friday before 9October, 2022.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Nate going to a convention and meeting new people.\n\n- Result 21 [2022-10-09T10:58:00] Nate to Joanna: \"Something exciting happened last Friday. I went to a game convention and met new people who weren't from my normal circle.\"\n\n- Result 2 [2022-10-09T11:03:00] Nate to Joanna: \"The people at the convention were the same way!\"\n\n- Result 23 [2022-10-09T11:04:00] Nate to Joanna: \"The experience at this convention is unforgettable.\"\n\nStep 2: Determine the date of the convention.\n\n- The message about the convention is dated 2022-10-09 and says \"last Friday,\" which would be Friday, October 7, 2022.\n\nFinal answer:  \nNate went to a game convention and met new people on Friday, October 7, 2022.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.3,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.3
    },
    {
      "question": "How many times has Joanna's scripts been rejected?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Twice",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of rejections in the context.\n\n- Result 2 (2022-10-21): Joanna mentions a setback around October 14, 2022, \"another rejection from a production company.\"\n- Result 4 (2022-06-03): Joanna says she got a generic rejection letter from a company.\n- Result 6 (2022-06-03): Joanna mentions a rejection letter from a major company after finishing her screenplay.\n- Result 5 (2022-11-07): Joanna says she submitted a few more scripts last week (around October 31, 2022), expecting some rejections.\n- Result 8 (2022-10-21): Nate refers to the rejection Joanna mentioned, implying it was at least one rejection.\n- Result 70 (2022-06-03): Joanna acknowledges the rejection but says she won't let it bring her down.\n\nStep 2: Count distinct rejections mentioned explicitly.\n\n- The",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.58,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.31
    },
    {
      "question": "What is something Nate gave to Joanna that brings her a lot of joy?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "stuffed toy pup",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for mentions of Nate giving Joanna something that brings her joy.\n\nStep 2: Result 13 [2022-06-05T14:17:00] Joanna to Nate: \"Thanks, Nate! Having that picture on my cork board reminds me of the love and encouragement from them every day.\"  \nStep 3: Result 21 [2022-06-05T14:14:30] Nate to Joanna: \"Thanks Joanna! I got it because it reminded me of something I love. Its presence in my room is a good reminder to keep working on my goals. Any inspiring things in your room?\"  \nStep 4: Result 97 [2022-10-21T14:04:00] Nate to Joanna: \"That's so touching! Glad the stuffed animal means so much!\"  \nStep 5: Result 38 [2022-11-04T16:00:00] Joanna to Nate: \"Thanks, Nate",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.0,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.36
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Nate get Tilly for Joanna?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "25 May, 2022",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify who has Tilly.  \nFrom Result 16 (2022-10-21), Joanna says she still has the stuffed animal dog Nate gave her and named her Tilly.\n\nStep 2: Look for when Nate gave Tilly to Joanna.  \nResult 27 (2022-05-25) Nate says, \"Looky here, I got this new pup for you!\" which likely refers to Tilly.\n\nStep 3: Confirm no earlier mention of Tilly or the stuffed animal gift.  \nNo earlier direct mention of Tilly or the gift is found before May 25, 2022.\n\nStep 4: Conclusion.  \nNate gave Joanna the stuffed animal dog (Tilly) around May 25, 2022.\n\nFinal answer:  \nNate gave Joanna Tilly, the stuffed animal dog, around May 25, 2022.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 4.36,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.36
    },
    {
      "question": "How many of Joanna's writing have made it to the big screen?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "two",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Joanna's writing being made into movies or appearing on the big screen.\n\n- Result 2 (2022-01-23): Joanna finished her first full screenplay.\n- Result 10 (2022-10-25): Joanna says this is the third time her work has been acted out on screen.\n- Result 41 (2022-06-05): Joanna wrote bits for a screenplay that appeared on the big screen.\n- Result 39 (2022-11-07): Joanna is working on another movie script, hoping to get it on the big screen.\n- Result 42 (2022-11-07): Nate mentions at least one of Joanna's scripts will be her 3rd published movie.\n- Result 51 (2022-11-11): Nate congratulates Joanna on seeing her script come alive in a movie.\n- Result 20 (2022-11-11): An actor liked Joanna's script, indicating production progress",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.03,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.4
    },
    {
      "question": "How many times has Nate taken his turtles on a walk?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Twice.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify all mentions of Nate taking his turtles on a walk.\n\n- Result 3 [2022-10-25]: Nate says, \"I was bored today, so I just took my turtles out for a walk.\"\n- Result 31 [2022-10-25]: Nate says the turtles look tired from all the walking, implying at least one walk.\n- Result 4 [2022-11-11]: Nate says he took his turtles to the beach in Tampa yesterday (Nov 10, 2022), which is a form of outing but not explicitly called a \"walk.\"\n- Result 32 [2022-11-07]: Nate took his pets to the park, but it\u2019s not specified if this included turtles or if it was a walk.\n- Result 29 [2022-11-09]: Nate mentions giving the turtles a bath before Joanna arrives, no walk mentioned here.\n- Result 51 [2022-11-09]:",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.31,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.33
    },
    {
      "question": "When was Joanna's second movie script shown on the big screens?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "The Sunday before 25October, 2022.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Joanna's movie scripts being shown on the big screen.\n\n- Result 16 (2022-10-25): Joanna says another movie script she contributed to was shown on the big screen \"last Sunday\" for the first time.\n- Result 38 (2022-06-05): Joanna says \"yesterday\" (June 4, 2022) a screenplay she wrote appeared on the big screen.\n\nStep 2: Determine which script is the second movie script.\n\n- Result 24 (2022-03-18): Joanna mentions wrapping up her second script.\n- Result 38 (2022-06-05): The screenplay shown on June 4, 2022, is likely the second script since it is after March 18 when she finished the second script.\n- Result 16 (2022-10-25): Another script shown on the big screen \"last Sunday\" (October 16, 2022) is likely",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.97,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.56
    },
    {
      "question": "What is Joanna inspired by?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Personal experiences,her own journey ofself discovery, Nate,nature, validation,stories about findingcourage and takingrisks, people she knows, stuff she sees, imagination",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify Joanna's inspirations from the excerpts where she talks about her writing and creative process.\n\n- In [Result 20] Joanna says her story is about a woman on a journey of self-discovery after a loss, indicating personal and emotional themes inspire her.\n- In [Result 13] Joanna says she chose to write about loss, identity, and connection because it is really personal to her.\n- In [Result 25] Joanna says she gets ideas from everywhere: people she knows, things she has seen, and her imagination.\n- In [Result 64] Joanna says creating stories and watching them come alive gives her happiness and fulfillment, and writing has been a blessing.\n- In [Result 66] Joanna asks if characters have different personalities like dogs and cats, showing she thinks deeply about character traits.\n- In [Result 72] Joanna values friends who understand and appreciate her work and enjoys sharing her journey.\n- In [Result 60] Joanna agrees that stories",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.88,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.22
    },
    {
      "question": "What animal do both Nate and Joanna like?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Turtles.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify animals mentioned by Nate and Joanna.\n\n- Nate talks about turtles multiple times (Results 1, 18, 19, 38, 41, 57, 61).\n- Joanna mentions having a dog named Tilly (Results 33, 35).\n- Nate also mentions dogs and a new pup (Results 9, 15, 16).\n- Joanna mentions being allergic to some animals (Result 69), which likely excludes dogs for her.\n- Both discuss turtles positively (Results 18, 38, 41, 57, 61 for Nate; Result 72 Joanna says \"Hey Nate! Cute turtles!\").\n\nStep 2: Look for explicit mentions of shared liking.\n\n- Result 18: Nate says turtles have big personalities and recommends them for stress.\n- Result 38: Nate says he is drawn to turtles.\n- Result 41: Nate says turtles cheer him up.\n- Result 72: Joanna calls Nate's turtles",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.71,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.17
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Joanna plan to go over to Nate's and share recipes?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "5 November, 2022.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify any mention of Joanna planning to go over to Nate's place to share recipes.\n\nStep 2: Result 2 (2022-11-04T16:03:30) shows Nate inviting Joanna to come over and try a dessert he made \"yesterday\" (around November 3, 2022).\n\nStep 3: Result 48 (2022-11-04T16:06:00) is Joanna's reply on the same day, saying \"Awesome! I'll bring some of my recipes so we can both share deserts!\"\n\nStep 4: This indicates Joanna planned to go over to Nate's around early November 2022, specifically after November 3, 2022, and on or shortly after November 4, 2022.\n\nFinal answer: Joanna planned to go over to Nate's around early November 2022, shortly after November 3, 2022, to share recipes.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.67,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.67
    },
    {
      "question": "What things has Nate reccomended to Joanna?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "A pet,\"The Lord of the Rings\" movies,a dragon book series,coconut flavoring,\"Project Hail Mary\" book,Xenoblade Chronicles, dairy-free margarine, coconut oil",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify recommendations Nate made to Joanna in the excerpts.\n\n- [Result 14] Nate encourages Joanna to get more eyes on her work: \"Great idea! that should hopefully get some more eyes on it. Keep up the hard work!\"\n- [Result 17] Nate advises Joanna to keep him posted on her big projects: \"Keep me posted on how it goes, alright?\"\n- [Result 5] Nate encourages Joanna to keep going and reach for her dreams: \"Keep going and reach for your dreams. You've got tons of talent and potential!\"\n- [Result 16] Nate praises Joanna for exploring her experiences and feelings, encouraging her to keep it up.\n- [Result 83] Nate offers help and asks Joanna to let him know how things turn out: \"Glad I could help. Let me know how it turns out!\"\n- [Result 97] Nate suggests going together somewhere and even considering writing his own screenplay: \"Hey, we should go together sometime",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.72,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.19
    },
    {
      "question": "What does Joanna do to remember happy memories?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Hangs them on a corkboard, writes themin a notebook.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for mentions of Joanna's actions related to remembering happy memories.  \n- Result 14 (2022-11-07): Joanna says she started writing some of her favorite memories down.  \n- Result 26 (2022-11-07): Joanna mentions her brother wrote cute notes when they were kids, which bring back sweet memories.  \n- Result 59 (2022-05-25): Joanna reflects on tough times finishing her screenplay and how those moments bring joy and make the journey worth it, implying she values remembering those moments.  \n- Result 86 (2022-11-07): Joanna says creating stories and watching them come alive gives her happiness and fulfillment, indicating writing is a key way she processes and remembers experiences.  \n- Result 12 (2022-11-07): Joanna talks about making great memories and supporting each other, showing an active effort to create and remember positive moments.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.  \nJo",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.83,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.51
    },
    {
      "question": "What Console does Nate own?",
      "category": 3,
      "gold_answer": "A Nintendo Switch; since the game \"Xenoblade 2\" is made for this console.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for any mentions of Nate's gaming setup or consoles.\n\n- Result 7 (2022-11-07): Joanna asks Nate about his \"ice set-up\" computer for gaming.\n- Result 29 (2022-11-07): Nate says he loves his gaming setup as a \"little haven to escape into the virtual world.\"\n- Result 73 (2022-11-07): Joanna says it sounds great to have his own gaming setup at home.\n- Result 79 (2022-11-07): Nate says \"This is where I practice and compete. Sometimes I even use it when I'm playing games with friends.\" This likely refers to his gaming setup.\n- Result 80 (2022-11-07): Nate says, \"Yes it is! I'm a big fan of Nintendo games, and I've actually been wanting to play this one for a while because my friends have played it and recommended it!\" This is in response to Joanna asking about",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.8,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.52
    },
    {
      "question": "What mediums does Nate use to play games?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Gamecube, PC,Playstation.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Nate playing games and the mediums he uses.\n\n- Result 54 (2022-01-21): Nate says the game he won was Counter-Strike: Global Offensive, which is a PC game.\n- Result 18 (2022-05-02): Nate mentions usually playing CS:GO (a PC game) and also playing Street Fighter (typically a console or arcade game).\n- Result 6 and 11 (2022-11-07): Joanna asks about Nate's \"ice set-up\" computer for gaming, and Nate confirms he uses it for practice and competition.\n- Result 85 and 89 (2022-11-07): Nate talks about playing \"Xeonoblade Chronicles,\" a Nintendo game, indicating he uses a Nintendo console.\n- Result 69 (2022-07-10): Nate won an online tournament, implying use of an online gaming platform, likely PC or console.\n- Result 29 (2022",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.73,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.81
    },
    {
      "question": "How many letters has Joanna recieved?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Two",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Joanna receiving letters.\n\n- Result 5 (2022-08-14): Joanna says \"Last week (approx. August 07, 2022), someone wrote me a letter after reading an online blog post I made...\"\n- Result 3 (2022-11-07): Nate says \"That letter is really awesome! Does it remind you of your childhood?\"\n- Result 99 (2022-11-07): Joanna says \"Yeah, it does! My brother wrote it - he used to make me these cute notes when we were kids.\"\n\nStep 2: Analyze the context of these mentions.\n\n- The letter mentioned in Result 5 is from a stranger who read her blog post.\n- The letter mentioned in Results 3 and 99 is a childhood note from her brother.\n\nStep 3: Check if there are any other mentions of letters.\n\n- No other explicit mentions of letters received by Joanna are found.\n\nStep 4: Conclusion",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.08,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.44
    },
    {
      "question": "What video games does Nate play?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Valorant, Counter Strike:Global Offensive,Xenoblade Chronicles, StreetFighter, Cyberpunk 2077",
      "generated_answer": "Step-by-step analysis of the context for video games Nate plays:\n\n1. Result 3 (2022-01-21): Nate says playing video games is a main hobby.\n2. Result 19 & 39 (2022-01-21): Nate played a team shooter game called Counter-Strike: Global Offensive (CS:GO).\n3. Result 38 (2022-05-02): Nate usually plays CS:GO but also played Street Fighter in a local tournament.\n4. Result 10 & 14 (2022-10-09): Nate played the board game Catan.\n5. Result 16 & 18 (2022-11-07): Nate is currently playing \"Xeonoblade Chronicles,\" a fantasy RPG.\n6. Result 23 (2022-10-09): Nate recently played \"Cyberpunk 2077,\" a futuristic game.\n7. Result 29 (2022-03-24): Nate is participating in video game",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.61,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.46
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Nate win a big Valorant tourney?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "The Saturday before 7November, 2022",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Nate winning a Valorant tournament.  \n- Result 2 [2022-11-07]: Nate says he was in the final of a big Valorant tournament last Saturday and won.  \n- Result 26 [2022-11-09]: Nate mentions a tough tournament but didn't make finals, so this is a different event.  \n\nStep 2: Determine the date of \"last Saturday\" relative to the message date in Result 2.  \n- Result 2 is dated 2022-11-07 (Monday).  \n- The \"last Saturday\" before 2022-11-07 is 2022-11-05.  \n\nStep 3: Confirm no other Valorant wins are mentioned.  \n- No other excerpts mention a Valorant win.  \n\nFinal answer: Nate won a big Valorant tournament on Saturday, November 5, 2022.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 4.62,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.31
    },
    {
      "question": "Which torunament did Nate win in the beginning of November 2022?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "Valorant",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant time frame and event.\n- The question asks about a tournament Nate won in early November 2022.\n\nStep 2: Look for mentions of tournaments around November 2022.\n- Result 34 [2022-11-07]: Nate says he was in the final of a big Valorant tournament last Saturday and won.\n- Result 46 [2022-11-09]: Nate mentions a tough tournament but says he didn't make it to the finals (likely a different tournament or a later update).\n- Result 72 [2022-11-09]: Nate talks about a game tournament being pushed back, no win mentioned.\n- Result 14 [2022-08-22]: Nate won an international tournament in August, but this is earlier.\n\nStep 3: Confirm the tournament Nate won in early November.\n- Result 34 explicitly states: \"I was in the final of a big Valorant tournament last Saturday, and I won!\"\n-",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 4.26,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.5
    },
    {
      "question": "What alternative career might Nate consider after gaming?",
      "category": 3,
      "gold_answer": "an animalkeeper at a localzoo and workingwith turtles; as heknows a great dealabout turtles andhow to care for them,and he enjoys it.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Review the context for any mention of Nate considering a career other than gaming.\n\nStep 2: The conversations mostly focus on Nate's gaming career, tournaments, and making gaming videos.\n\nStep 3: Joanna is involved in writing and movie projects, but Nate does not mention switching to those fields.\n\nStep 4: Nate talks about making gaming content for YouTube (Result 1, 7, 17, 67), which is related to gaming but more content creation.\n\nStep 5: No explicit mention of Nate considering a non-gaming career like writing, acting, or filmmaking.\n\nStep 6: Nate is thinking about joining a new gaming team (Result 18, 100), indicating continued focus on gaming.\n\nStep 7: No direct evidence of an alternative career path outside gaming.\n\nFinal answer: Not enough information.",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.21,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.44
    },
    {
      "question": "What pets does Nate have?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "A dog and threeturtles.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Nate mentions having turtles multiple times (Results 6, 9, 19, 20, 29, 37, 45, 47, 50, 69, 79, 85). He talks about their diet, personalities, and how they bring him joy.\n\nStep 2: Nate also talks about a dog named Max (Results 3, 7, 11, 31, 38, 44, 46). Max is described as adopted, energetic, and having doggy playdates.\n\nStep 3: There is no mention of Nate having any other types of pets besides turtles and a dog.\n\nFinal answer: Nate has turtles and a dog named Max.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.9,
      "judge_latency_s": 3.92
    },
    {
      "question": "How many hikes has Joanna been on?",
      "category": 3,
      "gold_answer": "Four",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify all mentions of Joanna going hiking or talking about hikes.\n\n- Result 1 (2022-05-12): Joanna says she went hiking and found more trails in her town.\n- Result 2 (2022-05-12): Joanna mentions loving a spot on the hike with rushing water.\n- Result 13 (2022-05-12): Joanna talks about hiking opening a new world for her.\n- Result 23 (2022-05-12): Joanna invites Nate to join her on the trails sometime.\n- Result 28 (2022-06-03): Joanna says she is hiking with buddies this weekend on a new trail with a waterfall.\n- Result 67 (2022-04-17): Joanna found an awesome hiking trail in her hometown the day before (April 16, 2022).\n- Result 91 (2022-11-09): Joanna took a picture on a hike last summer near Fort Wayne.\n\nStep ",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.96,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.3
    },
    {
      "question": "How many turtles does Nate have?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Three",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: In Result 4 (2022-01-23), Nate mentions having two turtles: \"The turtles might be small, but both sure have big personalities.\"\n\nStep 2: In Result 1 (2022-11-09), Nate says the tank is big enough for three turtles and he just had to get another one: \"The tank is big enough now for three, so I figured why not!\"\n\nStep 3: In Result 10 (2022-11-09), Joanna refers to Nate getting a third turtle this year: \"I bet just last week (approximately November 02, 2022) you would have never thought you would be getting a third turtle this year!\"\n\nStep 4: In Result 46 (2022-11-09), Nate confirms getting a new friend for the turtles: \"And guess what? I got them a new friend!\"\n\nConclusion: Nate originally had two turtles and as of early November 2022, he",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 4.61,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.93
    },
    {
      "question": "What activities does Nate do with his turtles?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "takes them onwalks, holds them,feeds themstrawberries, givesthem baths.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Nate's activities with his turtles.\n- Result 2: Nate got a third turtle because the tank is big enough for three.\n- Result 9: Nate took his turtles out for a walk.\n- Result 11: Nate took his turtles to the beach in Tampa on November 10, 2022.\n- Result 16, 23, 36, 53, 63: Nate feeds his turtles a varied diet including vegetables, fruits, and insects; he enjoys watching them eat fruit and snacks.\n- Result 46: Nate took his pets to the park and enjoyed seeing their happy faces.\n- Result 54: Nate sometimes brings his turtles into the kitchen to watch him make food.\n- Result 55: After walks, turtles relax in the tank.\n- Result 57, 64: Nate observes different personalities in his turtles and enjoys their companionship.\n- Result 6: Nate appreciates their slow pace and calming nature.\n- Result ",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.98,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.43
    },
    {
      "question": "What do both Joanna and Nate appreciate the beauty of?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Nature",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of what Joanna appreciates the beauty of.\n- Result 6 (2022-05-12): Joanna says the sound of a place and the beauty of nature made her calm and peaceful.\n- Result 60 (2022-05-12): Joanna says nature totally inspires her and is calming.\n- Result 83 (2022-11-09): Joanna took a picture on a hike near Fort Wayne, appreciating the sunset and surrounding beauty.\n- Result 62 (2022-04-15): Joanna mentions a gorgeous sunset she saw while hiking, inspiring her.\n\nStep 2: Identify mentions of what Nate appreciates the beauty of.\n- Result 10 (2022-11-09): Nate says nature reminds him to appreciate beauty around us.\n- Result 76 (2022-04-17): Nate says it's crucial to find peace and remember life's beauty, which he finds in spending time with pets and hobbies.\n- Result 46 (2022",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.36,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.29
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Joanna plan on going to Nate's to watch him play with his turtles?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "10 November, 2022",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify any mentions of Joanna planning to visit Nate to see his turtles.\n\n- Result 35 [2022-11-09T18:09:00] Nate to Joanna: \"Sounds good. Well I'll make sure I give the turtles a bath before you get here so they're ready to play.\"\n- Result 81 [2022-11-04T16:03:30] Nate to Joanna: \"On another note, want to come over and try some of this? It's super yummy, just made it yesterday (approximately November 03, 2022)!\"\n- Result 58 [2022-11-04T15:56:00] Joanna to Nate: \"Wow, Nate, I'm on fire! I just set up meetings with movie producers \u2014 my dreams are comin' true!\"\n- Result 52 [2022-11-11T00:06:00] Joanna to Nate: \"Nate, can you believe it? I'm",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        true,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.02,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.33
    },
    {
      "question": "What state did Joanna visit in summer 2021?",
      "category": 3,
      "gold_answer": "Indiana",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify any mentions of Joanna's trips or travel in the context.  \nStep 2: Look for any specific locations or states mentioned in relation to Joanna.  \nStep 3: Check the dates to see if any trip corresponds to summer 2021 (June-August 2021).  \nStep 4: The earliest travel-related messages are from 2022, but Joanna mentions a trip in a message on 2022-05-12 (Result 70) describing a peaceful nature spot.  \nStep 5: No direct mention of summer 2021 trips or states visited by Joanna is found in the context.  \nStep 6: The only specific location mentioned is Tampa (Result 23), but that is Nate taking turtles to the beach in November 2022, not Joanna visiting a state in summer 2021.  \nStep 7: No explicit information about Joanna visiting any state in summer 2021 is present.\n\nFinal answer: Not enough information",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.2,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.18
    },
    {
      "question": "What recommendations has Nate received from Joanna?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "\"Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind\" movie, \"A Court of Thorns and Roses\" book, pointers for making living room comfy, starting a cork board for memories, \"Little Women\" movie",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify messages where Joanna recommends something to Nate.\n\n- Result 3 [2022-04-21]: Joanna says, \"Heard of that series! It's been on my list forever. Thanks for the recommendation, Nate. I'm definitely going to check it out!\" (This is Nate recommending to Joanna, so not relevant.)\n\n- Result 4 [2022-06-05]: Joanna says, \"I would definitely recommend it! As long as your willing to explain what it is to your friends.\" (Unclear what \"it\" is, but likely a recommendation from Joanna to Nate.)\n\n- Result 42 [2022-01-21]: Joanna says, \"A few times. It's one of my favorites! I really like the idea and the acting.\" (In response to Nate asking for movie recommendations.)\n\n- Result 72 [2022-02-07]: Nate says he'll add a recommendation Joanna gave to his list.\n\n- Result 82 [2022-",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.39,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.23
    },
    {
      "question": "What are Nate's favorite desserts?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "coconut milk icecream, dairy-free chocolate cake with berries, chocolate and mixed-berry icecream, dairy-free chocolate mousse",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Nate's favorite desserts in the context.\n\n- Result 11 (2022-02-07): Nate says he loves coconut milk, chocolate, and mixed berry flavors.\n- Result 29 (2022-02-07): Nate says a coconut milk ice cream he made was rich and creamy and might be his new favorite snack.\n- Result 38 (2022-09-14): Nate says coconut milk ice cream is one of his favorites and he also loves a dairy-free chocolate mousse.\n- Result 72 (2022-02-07): Nate mentions making coconut milk ice cream and being proud of it.\n- Result 59 (2022-06-24): Nate made vegan ice cream and shared it with his vegan diet group.\n- Result 66 (2022-08-14): Nate mentions making a creamy, rich, dairy-free new recipe (likely a dessert).\n- Result 41 (2022-11-09): Nate",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.72,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.79
    },
    {
      "question": "How has Nate tried to disburse his vegan ice-cream recipes?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "teaching others, cooking show",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Nate made vegan ice cream and shared it with people in his vegan diet group (Result 1, dated 2022-06-24).\n\nStep 2: Nate taught people vegan ice cream recipes on his own cooking show (Result 5, dated 2022-09-14).\n\nStep 3: Nate has offered to share his recipes directly with Joanna multiple times (Results 13, 24, 42, 50, 54).\n\nStep 4: Nate also invited Joanna to come over and try some of his ice cream (Result 46, dated 2022-11-04).\n\nFinal answer: Nate has disbursed his vegan ice-cream recipes by sharing them with his vegan diet group, teaching them on his cooking show, offering the recipes directly to Joanna, and inviting her to try his homemade ice cream in person.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.22,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.69
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Nate win his second tournament?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "The week before 2 May, 2022.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Nate's tournament wins and their order.\n\n- Result 18 (2022-01-21): Nate won his first tournament approximately January 14, 2022.\n- Result 1 (2022-05-02): Nate says he won his second tournament last week, approximately April 25, 2022.\n- Result 10 (2022-06-03): Nate won another regional tournament last week, approximately May 27, 2022, which would be his third or fourth.\n- Result 25 (2022-07-10): Nate won his fourth tournament on Friday (July 8, 2022).\n\nStep 2: Confirm the date of the second tournament.\n\n- Result 1 clearly states the second tournament win was last week from May 2, 2022, which is approximately April 25, 2022.\n\nFinal answer: Nate won his second tournament around April 25, 2022.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.02,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.26
    },
    {
      "question": "How many video game tournaments has Nate participated in?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "nine",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Nate winning or participating in tournaments.\n\n- Result 15 (2022-01-21): Nate won his first tournament around January 14, 2022.\n- Result 1 (2022-05-02): Nate won his second tournament around April 25, 2022.\n- Result 4 (2022-06-03): Nate won another regional tournament around May 27, 2022 (third tournament).\n- Result 10 (2022-07-10): Nate won his fourth tournament on Friday (likely July 8, 2022).\n- Result 6 (2022-08-22): Nate won an international tournament on August 21, 2022 (fifth tournament).\n- Result 34 (2022-10-06): Nate won a big tournament around September 29, 2022 (sixth tournament).\n- Result 48 (2022-11-07): Nate won a Valor",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.85,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.76
    },
    {
      "question": "How many screenplays has Joanna written?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "three",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Joanna finished her first full screenplay and printed it by January 23, 2022 (Result 1).\n\nStep 2: By March 18, 2022, Joanna had wrapped up her second script (Result 94).\n\nStep 3: By November 7, 2022, Joanna was working on another movie script, which would be her third (Results 5, 11).\n\nStep 4: Nate mentions that at least one of her scripts will be her 3rd published movie (Result 18), confirming she has at least three scripts.\n\nStep 5: Joanna also mentions submitting a few more scripts around October 31, 2022 (Result 83), indicating she has written more than three.\n\nStep 6: No exact total number is given, but evidence shows at least three completed screenplays, plus additional scripts submitted later.\n\nFinal answer: Joanna has written at least three screenplays, with additional scripts submitted beyond those three.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.72,
      "judge_latency_s": 3.63
    },
    {
      "question": "How many tournaments has Nate won?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "seven",
      "generated_answer": "Step-by-step analysis of Nate's tournament wins from the context:\n\n1. [Result 13] (Jan 21, 2022): Nate won his first video game tournament around January 14, 2022.\n2. [Result 1] (May 2, 2022): Nate won his second tournament around April 25, 2022.\n3. [Result 9] (June 3, 2022): Nate won another regional tournament around May 27, 2022. This would be his third win.\n4. [Result 4] (Aug 22, 2022): Nate won an international tournament on August 21, 2022. This is his fourth win.\n5. [Result 16] (July 10, 2022): Nate won his fourth tournament on Friday (likely July 8, 2022). This conflicts with the previous count, but since the July 10 message says \"fourth tournament",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.1,
      "judge_latency_s": 4.86
    },
    {
      "question": "What recipes has Joanna made?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "dairy free vanilla cake with strawberry filling and coconut cream frosting, parfait, strawberry chocolate cake, chocolate coconut cupcakes, chocolate raspberry tart, chocolate cake with raspberries, blueberry cheesecake bars",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Joanna making recipes or desserts.\n- [Result 6, 10, 35, 39] Joanna has been tweaking and making various desserts that work for everyone's diets, including cookies, pies, cakes.\n- [Result 2] Joanna describes a favorite dessert made with almond flour, coconut oil, chocolate, and raspberries.\n- [Result 27] Joanna mentions testing out dairy-free dessert recipes and shares a picture of a cake made around April 25, 2022.\n- [Result 40] Joanna shares a recipe for a dessert made with blueberries, coconut milk, and a gluten-free crust.\n- [Result 65] Joanna has been revising and perfecting a recipe she made for her family that turned out tasty.\n\nStep 2: Note the types of recipes Joanna has made:\n- Dairy-free desserts including cakes, cookies, pies.\n- Specific recipes with almond flour, coconut oil, chocolate, raspberries.\n- A dessert with",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 13.28,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.96
    },
    {
      "question": "What recipes has Nate made?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "coconut milk icecream, chocolate and vanilla swirl",
      "generated_answer": "Step-by-step reasoning:\n\n1. Nate mentioned making coconut milk ice cream multiple times:\n   - [Result 51] Nate discovered he can make coconut milk ice cream and tried it.\n   - [Result 27] Nate made vegan ice cream last Friday and shared it with his vegan diet group.\n   - [Result 38] Nate described his coconut milk ice cream recipe: coconut milk, vanilla extract, sugar, salt, chilled and frozen.\n   - [Result 58] Nate made homemade coconut ice cream with sprinkles.\n   - [Result 78] Nate confirmed his ice cream is lactose-free, made with coconut milk.\n\n2. Nate also mentioned making a dairy-free chocolate cake with berries:\n   - [Result 39] Nate made a dairy-free chocolate cake with berries recently.\n   - [Result 56] Nate made chocolate and vanilla swirl (likely ice cream).\n\n3. Nate taught vegan ice cream recipes on his cooking show:\n   - [Result 47] Nate taught",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.97,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.69
    },
    {
      "question": "What are the skills that Nate has helped others learn?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "coconut milk ice cream recipe, reset high scores, tips to improve gaming skills",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Nate helping others with skills.  \n- Result 6 [2022-06-03]: Nate says, \"They asked for some tips in how to improve their game, so I said I could help.\"  \n- Result 68 [2022-11-04]: Nate says, \"Just been helping some friends reset their high scores at the international tournament.\"  \n\nStep 2: Determine what \"game\" refers to.  \n- Result 31 [2022-05-02]: Nate talks about gaming focus and winning tournaments.  \n- Result 92 [2022-06-03]: Nate won a regional video game tournament.  \n- Result 37 [2022-11-09]: Nate creates gaming content for YouTube.  \n- Result 78 [2022-10-21]: Nate is practicing for his next video game tournament.  \n\nStep 3: Synthesize the information.  \nNate helps others improve their video gaming skills",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.76,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.61
    },
    {
      "question": "Was the first half of September 2022 a good month career-wise for Nate and Joanna? Answer yes or no.",
      "category": 3,
      "gold_answer": "No; because both of them faced setbacks in their career",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Check for any mentions of Nate's career or events in early September 2022.\n- Result 32 (2022-09-05) Nate mentions a recent letdown in a video game tournament around August 29, 2022, which was a setback but he is trying to stay positive. This suggests a challenge rather than a clear success in late August/early September.\n\nStep 2: Check for Joanna's career mentions around early September 2022.\n- No direct messages from or about Joanna's career specifically dated in early September 2022 are found in the context.\n\nStep 3: Consider overall tone and events near that time.\n- Nate had a setback in a tournament but is staying positive.\n- No positive or negative career events for Joanna are mentioned in that timeframe.\n\nStep 4: Since Nate had a setback and Joanna has no noted career events, the first half of September 2022 does not appear to be notably good career-wise for either.\n\n",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.27,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.49
    },
    {
      "question": "What kind of job is Joanna beginning to preform the duties of because of her movie scripts?",
      "category": 3,
      "gold_answer": "filmmaker.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Joanna has been writing movie scripts and submitting them to producers and film festivals (Results 5, 23, 29, 56).\n\nStep 2: She has had meetings with producers who liked her script and showed interest (Results 1, 13, 36, 75).\n\nStep 3: Joanna mentions that one of her scripts was shown on the big screen (Results 64, 69).\n\nStep 4: She talks about filming her own movie from a road-trip script (Result 94).\n\nStep 5: This indicates that Joanna is moving beyond just writing scripts to actually filming a movie, which involves duties of a filmmaker or movie director/producer.\n\nFinal answer: Joanna is beginning to perform the duties of a filmmaker or movie director by filming her own movie based on her scripts.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.84,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.21
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Nate take his turtles to the beach?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "10 November, 2022",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify any mentions of Nate taking his turtles to the beach.\n- Result 1 [2022-11-11]: Nate to Joanna says, \"I took my turtles to the beach in Tampa yesterday (approximately November 10, 2022)!\"\n\nStep 2: Confirm the date of the message to understand the exact day of the beach visit.\n- The message is dated 2022-11-11, and Nate says \"yesterday,\" so the beach visit was on November 10, 2022.\n\nFinal answer: Nate took his turtles to the beach on November 10, 2022.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.41,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.41
    },
    {
      "question": "What state did Nate visit?",
      "category": 3,
      "gold_answer": "Florida",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for any mentions of Nate traveling or visiting places in the conversation excerpts.\n\nStep 2: In Result 37 [2022-07-10], Joanna says to Nate: \"I went to Woodhaven, a small town in the Midwest. Got to see some lovely scenery and historic buildings. Checked out the library there, it had a cool old book collection!\" Nate responds in Result 97 [2022-07-10]: \"Thanks, Joanna! Your support means a lot to me. That road trip sounds great! Where did you go? Did you discover any interesting places?\"\n\nStep 3: This shows Joanna went to Woodhaven in the Midwest, but no direct mention of Nate visiting there.\n\nStep 4: In Result 2 [2022-11-09], Joanna says she took a picture on a hike last summer near Fort Wayne. Fort Wayne is in Indiana.\n\nStep 5: No direct mention of Nate visiting Fort Wayne or Indiana.\n\nStep",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.84,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.27
    },
    {
      "question": "What is one of Joanna's favorite movies?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "\"Eternal Sunshineof the Spotless Mind\"",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Joanna's favorite movies in the context.\n\n- Result 4 (2022-01-21): Joanna says about a movie she first watched around 3 years ago and got a physical copy.\n- Result 12 (2022-01-21): Joanna says \"A few times. It's one of my favorites! I really like the idea and the acting.\"\n- Result 21 (2022-02-07): Joanna says she just watched \"Little Women\" and it was amazing.\n- Result 15 (2022-10-06): Nate says he watched \"Little Women\" recently and it was great.\n- Result 14 (2022-01-21): Nate says he loves watching classics and might check out the movie Joanna recommended.\n- Result 61 (2022-01-21): Joanna says she likes dramas and romcoms.\n- Result 51 (2022-01-21): Joanna mentions a romantic drama about memory",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.55,
      "judge_latency_s": 4.54
    },
    {
      "question": "What color did Nate choose for his hair?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "purple",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant messages about Nate's hair color.\n\n- Result 2 (2022-04-15): Nate says he dyed his hair last week (around April 8, 2022).\n- Result 1 (2022-04-15): Joanna compliments Nate's new hair color and asks about it.\n- Result 3 (2022-04-15): Nate replies that he picked a color that is \"bright and bold - like me!\" and wanted to stand out from regular options.\n\nStep 2: Look for any specific mention of the actual color.\n\n- No direct color name is given in the excerpts.\n- The description \"bright and bold\" suggests a vivid, noticeable color.\n\nStep 3: Check if any other messages mention the hair color.\n\n- Result 29 (Joanna) mentions Nate's boldness inspired her and relates it to a gorgeous sunset, but no specific color is named.\n\nStep 4: Since no explicit color name is",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.43,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.47
    },
    {
      "question": "What is Nate's favorite movie trilogy?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Lord of the Rings",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Nate's favorite movie trilogy.  \n- Result 2: Nate says, \"This trilogy is one of my faves. The world building, battles, and storytelling always blow me away!\"  \n- Result 19: Joanna says she took Nate's recommendation and watched \"The Lord of the Rings\" Trilogy last night and thought it was awesome.  \n- Result 23: Nate says, \"It's probably the greatest trilogy of all time!\" in response to Joanna enjoying the trilogy.  \n\nStep 2: Connect the trilogy Nate refers to with the one Joanna watched.  \n- Since Joanna watched \"The Lord of the Rings\" Trilogy based on Nate's recommendation, and Nate calls it one of his favorites and the greatest trilogy, it is clear that Nate's favorite trilogy is \"The Lord of the Rings.\"\n\nFinal answer:  \nNate's favorite movie trilogy is \"The Lord of the Rings\" Trilogy.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.07,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.37
    },
    {
      "question": "What is Nate's favorite book series about?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "dragons",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Nate's favorite book series.  \n- Result 3: Nate says, \"I love this series. It has adventures, magic, and great characters - it's a must-read!\"  \n- Result 7: Nate says, \"This trilogy is one of my faves. The world building, battles, and storytelling always blow me away!\"  \n- Result 4 and 20: Nate recommends a series with \"awesome battles and interesting characters\" and \"How about this series?\"  \n- Result 53: Nate says, \"The action scenes are awesome and the plot rocks. Definitely one of my favorites!\"  \n- Result 29: Nate calls it \"probably the greatest trilogy of all time!\"\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the description of the series:  \n- It is a fantasy series with adventures, magic, great characters, awesome battles, and strong world-building.  \n- It is a trilogy.  \n- The plot is exciting and action-packed.\n\nStep",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.4,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.6
    },
    {
      "question": "What kind of lighting does Nate's gaming room have?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "red and purple lighting",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for any mentions of Nate's gaming room and its features in the context.\n\nStep 2: Result 4 (Joanna to Nate on 2022-05-02) mentions Nate's gaming room looking great and asks if he has been gaming a lot recently.\n\nStep 3: Result 16 (Joanna to Nate on 2022-11-07) asks if Nate uses his \"ice set-up\" computer for gaming, implying a cool or icy theme.\n\nStep 4: Result 79 (Nate to Joanna on 2022-10-09) says \"Wow, it's so comfy in there! I should really get a set up like that,\" referring to a living room, not specifically lighting.\n\nStep 5: No direct mention of lighting type in the gaming room is found in the excerpts.\n\nStep 6: Result 46 (Nate to Joanna on 2022-11-07) says \"Yeah, I love it",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.8,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.25
    },
    {
      "question": "What game was the second tournament that Nate won based on?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Street Fighter",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify when Nate won his second tournament.  \n- Result 3 (2022-05-02): Nate says he won his second tournament last week (around April 25, 2022).\n\nStep 2: Check what game Nate was playing around that time.  \n- Result 29 (2022-05-02): Nate says he usually plays CS:GO but tried the local Street Fighter tournament this time and did really well.\n\nStep 3: Since the second tournament win was around April 25, 2022, and Nate mentions trying Street Fighter in a local tournament at that time, it is logical that the second tournament he won was based on Street Fighter.\n\nFinal answer:  \nNate's second tournament win was based on the game Street Fighter.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.13,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.23
    },
    {
      "question": "What is Joanna's third screenplay about?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "loss, identity, and connection",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Joanna's screenplays and their topics.\n\n- Result 1 (2022-01-23): Joanna finished her first full screenplay.\n- Result 7 (2022-02-25): Joanna started writing another screenplay while waiting to hear about the first.\n- Result 29 (2022-02-25): Joanna describes a screenplay about a thirty-year-old woman on a journey of self-discovery after a loss.\n- Result 3 and 5 (2022-11-07 and 2022-11-09): Joanna is writing another movie script, a love story with challenges, which she pitched to producers.\n- Result 93 (2022-10-25): Joanna mentions another movie script she contributed to was shown on the big screen last Sunday, a surreal and satisfying moment.\n\nStep 2: Determine which screenplay is the third.\n\n- The first screenplay was finished and submitted early 2022 (Result 1).\n- The second",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.48,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.97
    },
    {
      "question": "What is Nate's favorite video game?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Xenoblade Chronicles",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Nate's favorite game or games he enjoys.\n\n- Result 10 (2022-10-09): Nate says he loves the board game Catan.\n- Result 23 (2022-11-07): Nate says he is currently playing \"Xeonoblade Chronicles,\" calls it an awesome fantasy RPG, and highly recommends it.\n- Result 24 (2022-11-07): Nate confirms \"Xeonoblade Chronicles\" is a Japanese game series and that he is a big fan of Nintendo games.\n- Result 53 (2022-01-21): Nate says the game he won a tournament in was \"Counter-Strike: Global Offensive.\"\n- Result 45 (2022-10-09): Nate mentions playing \"Cyberpunk 2077\" nonstop recently.\n- Result 19 (2022-11-07): Nate says video games are like his \"own little haven to escape into the virtual world.\"\n- Result ",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.55,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.37
    },
    {
      "question": "What type of movies does Nate enjoy watching the most?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "action and sci-fi",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify Nate's stated movie preferences from the excerpts.\n\n- Result 2 (2022-04-21): Nate says he loves fantasy and sci-fi movies.\n- Result 9 (2022-01-21): Nate mentions playing video games and watching movies as main hobbies.\n- Result 10 (2022-01-21): Nate says he loves action and sci-fi movies.\n- Result 20 (2022-04-21): Nate talks about a favorite fantasy or sci-fi movie series.\n- Result 26 (2022-04-21): Nate loves a fantasy series with adventures, magic, and great characters.\n- Result 45 (2022-08-22): Nate recommends a movie with awesome action scenes and a great plot.\n- Result 39 (2022-10-09): Nate recently saw \"Inception,\" a mind-bending sci-fi movie.\n- Result 47 (2022-04-21): Nate calls a trilogy",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 4.95,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.33
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Joanna just finish last Friday on 23 January, 2022?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "screenplay",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the date of interest: Friday, 23 January 2022.\n\nStep 2: Look for messages around that date mentioning something Joanna finished.\n\n- Result 22 [2022-01-23T14:04:30] Nate to Joanna: \"Congrats, Joanna! That sounds like a wild experience. Rock on and I hope they love it!\"\n- Result 29 [2022-01-23T14:03:30] Nate to Joanna: \"Wow, that's amazing! How do you feel now that it's finished? Do you have any new plans for it?\"\n- Result 60 [2022-01-23T14:14:30] Nate to Joanna: \"Wow, Joanna, that sounds amazing! Keep doing what you love!\"\n\nStep 3: These messages imply Joanna finished a project or something significant by that date.\n\nStep 4: Result 14 [2022-02-07T09:27:30] Nate",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.67,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.21
    },
    {
      "question": "What genre is Joanna's first screenplay?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "drama and romance",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Joanna's first screenplay and any genre clues.\n\n- Result 1 (2022-01-23): Joanna says she finished her first full screenplay last Friday.\n- Result 6 (2022-02-25): Joanna mentions starting another screenplay while waiting to hear back about the first one.\n- Result 25 (2022-02-07): Joanna talks about the screenplay she sent to a film festival, feeling relief, excitement, and worry.\n- Result 42 (2022-02-25): Joanna describes a screenplay about a thirty-year-old woman on a journey of self-discovery after a loss, somewhat similar to the last one.\n- Result 64 (2022-05-20): Joanna says she chose to write about loss, identity, and connection, a personal story.\n- Result 65 (2022-02-25): Nate asks what inspired her screenplay about important issues.\n- Result 78 (2022-03-",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.45,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.98
    },
    {
      "question": "What are Joanna's plans for her finished screenplay in January 2022?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "submit it to film festivals and get producers and directors to check it out",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts from January 2022 about Joanna's finished screenplay.\n\n- Result 2 [2022-01-23]: Joanna says she finally finished her first full screenplay and printed it last Friday.\n- Result 4 [2022-01-23]: Nate asks how she feels now that it's finished and if she has new plans.\n- Result 11 [2022-02-07]: Joanna mentions the screenplay she sent to a film festival has been on her mind, hoping a producer or director will pick it up.\n- Result 49 [2022-01-23]: Joanna expresses mixed emotions about finishing the project and says she plans to submit it to film festivals and hopes producers/directors will check it out.\n- Result 22 [2022-02-25]: Joanna thanks Nate and hopes her screenplay gets noticed and makes it to the screen.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.\n\nIn January 2022, Joanna had just finished her first",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 5.93,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.48
    },
    {
      "question": "For how long has Nate had his turtles?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "3 years",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for any direct mentions of how long Nate has had his turtles.\n\n- Result 71 [2022-01-23]: Nate says, \"I've had them for 3 years now and they bring me tons of joy!\"\n\nStep 2: Confirm no other conflicting or additional information about the duration.\n\n- No other messages contradict or specify a different duration.\n\nFinal answer: Nate has had his turtles for 3 years as of January 23, 2022.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.69,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.8
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Nate think of the coconut milk ice cream he made?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Super good, rich and creamy",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Nate making coconut milk ice cream and his opinions about it.\n\n- Result 12 (2022-02-07): Nate says he discovered he can make coconut milk ice cream and gave it a try. He says, \"It was actually pretty good, so I'm proud of myself.\"\n- Result 38 (2022-02-07): Nate says it was \"Super good! It was rich and creamy - might be my new favorite snack!\"\n- Result 11 (2022-09-14): Nate describes coconut milk ice cream as \"so smooth and creamy with a tropical coconut twist.\"\n- Result 37 (2022-08-14): Nate mentions sharing his love for dairy-free desserts and teaching people how to make this (coconut milk ice cream), implying he enjoys it.\n- Result 24 (2022-11-09): Nate shows a homemade coconut ice cream with sprinkles, indicating ongoing enthusiasm.\n- Result 27 (202",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.09,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.86
    },
    {
      "question": "Which dairy-free dessert flavors does Nate enjoy?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "chocolate and mixed berry",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Nate's favorite dairy-free dessert flavors.\n- Result 5 (2022-02-07): Nate says he loves coconut milk and enjoys chocolate and mixed berry flavors.\n- Result 22 (2022-09-14): Nate mentions coconut milk ice cream as a favorite.\n- Result 29 (2022-02-07): Nate made a dairy-free chocolate cake with berries.\n- Result 41 (2022-02-07): Nate describes a rich and creamy dessert (likely coconut milk ice cream).\n- Result 45 (2022-02-07): Nate discovered he can make coconut milk ice cream.\n- Result 57 (2022-11-09): Nate made homemade coconut ice cream.\n- Result 61 (2022-11-11): Nate talks about colorful bowls of coconut milk ice cream.\n- Result 22 and 27: Nate's coconut milk ice cream is repeatedly mentioned as a favorite.\n- Result 5",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.59,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.5
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Joanna recently watch and recommend to Nate on February 7, 2022?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "\"Little Women\"",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the date February 7, 2022, in the context.  \nStep 2: Look for Joanna's messages around that date mentioning something she watched and recommended.  \nStep 3: Result 45 [2022-02-07T09:35:00] Joanna to Nate says: \"I just watched 'Little Women' and it was amazing! It's a great story about sisterhood, love, and reaching for your dreams. Definitely a must-see!\"  \nStep 4: Nate also references this in Result 37 [2022-10-06T11:18:30], confirming the movie \"Little Women\" was watched and recommended.\n\nFinal answer:  \nJoanna recently watched and recommended the movie \"Little Women\" to Nate on February 7, 2022.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.46,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.95
    },
    {
      "question": "What is \"Little Women\" about according to Joanna?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Sisterhood, love, and reaching for your dreams",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify all mentions of \"Little Women\" and Joanna's description of it.\n\n- Result 2 (2022-02-07): Joanna to Nate says: \"I just watched 'Little Women' and it was amazing! It's a great story about sisterhood, love, and reaching for your dreams. Definitely a must-see!\"\n- Result 95 (2022-10-06): Joanna to Nate says: \"I watched it too and it really spoke to me. Themes like sisterhood, love, and chasing dreams were explored so well.\"\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the descriptions.\n\nJoanna describes \"Little Women\" as a story centered on sisterhood, love, and pursuing dreams.\n\nFinal answer: According to Joanna, \"Little Women\" is a story about sisterhood, love, and reaching or chasing dreams.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.3,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.33
    },
    {
      "question": "What flavor of ice cream did Nate make for his friend on 25 February, 2022?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "chocolate and vanilla swirl",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the date and event in question: Nate made ice cream for his friend on 25 February 2022.\n\nStep 2: Look for messages around that date mentioning ice cream flavors Nate made.\n\n- Result 61 [2022-02-25]: Nate to Joanna: \"Hey Joanna! Sorry I haven't been around. I made my friend some ice cream and they loved it!\"\n- Result 19 [2022-02-25]: Nate to Joanna: \"I whipped up some chocolate and vanilla swirl.\"\n- Result 15 [2022-02-25]: Joanna to Nate: \"That looks delicious! Unfortunately, I can't have dairy, so no ice cream for me. Do you happen to have a dairy-free recipe that I could try?\"\n- Result 85 [2022-02-25]: Nate to Joanna: \"Sure, I know one recipe using coconut milk. Would you like me to send it to you?\"\n\nStep 3: The flavor",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.74,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.93
    },
    {
      "question": "What inspired Joanna's new screenplay on 25 February, 2022?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "personal experiences and her own journey of self-discovery",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the date and context of the question: The question asks about Joanna's new screenplay inspiration on 25 February 2022.\n\nStep 2: Look for messages around that date mentioning a new screenplay and its inspiration.\n\n- Result 10 [2022-02-25]: Joanna says she started writing another screenplay while waiting to hear back about the first one.\n- Result 32 [2022-02-25]: Joanna describes the new screenplay as about a thirty-year-old woman on a journey of self-discovery after a loss.\n- Result 63 [2022-05-20]: Joanna says she chose to write about loss, identity, and connection, a story she had for ages but just got the guts to write.\n- Result 21 [2022-02-25]: Nate asks what inspired the screenplay.\n- Result 27 [2022-02-25]: Nate says he loves to hear more about it.\n- Result 79 [2022",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.02,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.6
    },
    {
      "question": "Why does Nate like turtles as pets?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Their slow pace and calming nature",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Nate mentions he has liked turtles since he was a boy and knows all about them (Result 4).\n\nStep 2: He finds turtles calming and peaceful, appreciating their slow pace as a nice change from the rush of life (Results 5, 8).\n\nStep 3: He says turtles bring him joy and peace, and watching them slowly walk around makes him happy (Results 1, 8).\n\nStep 4: He describes turtles as \"zen masters\" who remind him to slow down and appreciate small things in life (Result 10).\n\nStep 5: He enjoys their big personalities despite their small size and finds them low-maintenance and calming (Results 2, 5).\n\nStep 6: He also finds joy in watching them play and relax, and they help cheer him up during stressful times (Results 16, 68).\n\nFinal answer: Nate likes turtles as pets because they bring him joy and peace, are calming and low-maintenance,",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.11,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.39
    },
    {
      "question": "How does Nate describe the process of taking care of turtles?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Not tough; keep their area clean, feed them properly, give them enough light.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify all excerpts where Nate talks about taking care of turtles or mentions their care.\n\n- Result 34 [2022-03-18T19:02:30] Nate to Joanna: \"No, not really. Just keep their area clean, feed them properly, and make sure they get enough light. It's actually kind of fun.\"\n- Result 23 [2022-10-25T20:25:00] Nate to Joanna: \"They eat a combination of vegetables, fruits, and insects. They have a varied diet.\"\n- Result 57 [2022-10-25T20:24:00] Nate to Joanna: \"Of course! They look tired from all the walking, so they're relaxing in the tank right now.\"\n- Result 2 [2022-11-09T18:06:00] Nate to Joanna: \"The tank is big enough now for three, so I figured why not!\"\n- Result 62 [202",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.23,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.7
    },
    {
      "question": "What was Joanna's audition for?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "writing gig",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for mentions of Joanna auditioning or acting.  \n- Result 13: Nate says, \"Sounds like you had an interesting time on stage! ... Have you ever considered going back to acting?\"  \n- Result 17: Joanna says, \"A few times. It's one of my favorites! I really like the idea and the acting.\" (This is likely about a movie or play.)  \n- Result 63: Joanna talks about her first play and being nervous on stage.\n\nStep 2: Look for more specific details about the audition.  \n- Result 9 and 7 (January 23, 2022) show Nate congratulating Joanna on a \"wild experience\" and her excitement, possibly related to an audition or performance.  \n- Result 18 (November 11, 2022) Joanna mentions an actor complimenting her script, indicating she is also a writer.  \n- Result 43 and 86 (November 7 and 11,",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 5.75,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.8
    },
    {
      "question": "Why did Nate choose the hair color he did?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Bright and bold - like him",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant excerpts about Nate's hair color choice.\n\n- Result 2 (2022-04-15): Nate says he dyed his hair last week (around April 8, 2022).\n- Result 3 (2022-04-15): Nate explains he picked the color because it's bright and bold, like him, and he wanted to stand out from regular options.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.\n\nNate chose the hair color because it was bright and bold, reflecting his personality, and he wanted to stand out from typical hair color choices.\n\nFinal answer:  \nNate chose the hair color because it was bright and bold, matching his personality, and he wanted to stand out from the regular options.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.05,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.68
    },
    {
      "question": "What are the main ingredients of the ice cream recipe shared by Nate?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Coconut milk, vanilla extract, sugar, salt",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify Nate's ice cream recipe details in the context.\n- Result 1 (2022-04-17): Nate says he made ice cream with coconut milk, vanilla extract, sugar, and a pinch of salt.\n- Result 6 (2022-04-17): Nate confirms the recipe is dairy-free.\n- Result 29 (2022-09-14): Nate mentions coconut milk ice cream as a favorite, smooth and creamy with a tropical coconut twist.\n- Result 28 (2022-11-04): Nate confirms he made it with coconut milk so it's lactose-free.\n\nStep 2: Cross-check for any other ingredients mentioned by Nate.\n- No other ingredients besides coconut milk, vanilla extract, sugar, and salt are mentioned in relation to his ice cream recipe.\n\nFinal answer:  \nThe main ingredients of Nate's ice cream recipe are coconut milk, vanilla extract, sugar, and a pinch of salt.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.19,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.35
    },
    {
      "question": "What is Joanna's project called in the writers group?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "\"Finding Home\"",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Joanna's writers group and her projects related to it.\n\n- Result 35 (2022-04-21): Joanna says she just joined a writers group and feels motivated and supported.\n- Result 9 (2022-05-20): Joanna says writing and creative projects get her through tough times.\n- Result 13 (2022-05-20): Joanna says she chose to write about a story that is personal, about loss, identity, and connection, a story she had for ages but just got the guts to write.\n- Result 24 (2022-02-25): Joanna describes a project about a thirty-year-old woman on a journey of self-discovery after a loss.\n- Result 80 (2022-02-25): Joanna says the main character is dealing with loss and trying to figure out who they are, taking a road trip to heal and grow.\n- Result 29 (2022-01-23): Joanna",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 23.21,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.77
    },
    {
      "question": "What is Nate's favorite genre of movies?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Fantasy and sci-fi",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for Nate's direct statements about his favorite movie genres.\n\n- Result 2 (2022-01-21): Nate says he loves action and sci-fi movies.\n- Result 3 (2022-04-21): Nate says he loves fantasy and sci-fi movies.\n- Result 22 (2022-01-21): Nate mentions playing video games and watching movies as hobbies but no genre specified.\n- Result 44 (2022-04-21): Nate praises \"The Lord of the Rings\" trilogy, which is fantasy.\n- Result 46 (2022-08-22): Nate recommends a movie with awesome action scenes and plot.\n- Result 31 (2022-10-09): Nate mentions watching \"Inception,\" a sci-fi thriller.\n- Result 77 (2022-10-06): Nate watched \"Little Women,\" a drama, but this seems more occasional.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.\n\nNate consistently",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.42,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.53
    },
    {
      "question": "What kind of books does Nate enjoy?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Adventures and magic",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for Nate's mentions of book preferences or recommendations.\n\n- Result 10: Nate says, \"I love this series. It has adventures, magic, and great characters - it's a must-read!\" This suggests he enjoys fantasy.\n- Result 13: Nate says, \"I love fantasy and sci-fi movies, they're a great escape and get my imagination going.\" While this is about movies, it aligns with fantasy and sci-fi interests.\n- Result 23: Nate asks Joanna for book recommendations, indicating he is open to reading.\n- Result 27: Nate says, \"Yeah, for sure! This trilogy is one of my faves. The world building, battles, and storytelling always blow me away!\" This again points to fantasy or epic series.\n- Result 55: Nate mentions liking coconut milk, chocolate, and mixed berry flavors, unrelated to books.\n- Result 72: Joanna says she took Nate's recommendation and watched \"The Lord of the Rings\" trilogy",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.66,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.43
    },
    {
      "question": "What kind of films does Joanna enjoy?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Dramas and emotionally-driven films",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for Joanna's mentions of her favorite movie genres or types of films she enjoys.\n\n- Result 38: Joanna says, \"I'm all about dramas and romcoms. I love getting immersed in the feelings and plots.\"\n- Result 27: Joanna says, \"I really enjoy dramas and emotionally-driven films.\"\n- Result 67: Joanna mentions a romantic drama movie she likes.\n- Result 54: Joanna is writing a love story movie script, indicating an interest in romantic or emotional stories.\n- Result 10: Joanna watched a classic movie with a gripping story and great actors, showing appreciation for strong storytelling and acting.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.\n\nJoanna enjoys dramas, romantic comedies, emotionally-driven films, and movies with strong storytelling and emotional depth.\n\nFinal answer:  \nJoanna enjoys dramas, romantic comedies, and emotionally-driven films that immerse her in feelings and plots.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.42,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.41
    },
    {
      "question": "Which activity helps Nate escape and stimulates his imagination?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "watching fantasy and sci-fi movies",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify Nate's activities related to escape and imagination.  \n- Result 1 (2022-04-21): Nate says he loves fantasy and sci-fi movies because they are a great escape and get his imagination going.  \n- Result 9 (2022-01-21): Nate mentions playing video games and watching movies as his main hobbies.  \n- Result 24 (2022-11-07): Nate says he loves \"it\" (context suggests gaming) as his own little haven to escape into the virtual world.  \n- Result 56 (2022-04-21): Nate loves a series with adventures, magic, and great characters (likely fantasy/sci-fi).  \n- Result 84 (2022-10-21): Nate finds watching his turtles peaceful but does not mention imagination.  \n\nStep 2: Focus on the activity explicitly linked to both escape and imagination.  \n- Result 1 clearly states fantasy and sci-fi movies are a great",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 4.87,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.26
    },
    {
      "question": "What filling did Joanna use in the cake she made recently in May 2022?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "strawberry",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant time frame and message about the cake Joanna made recently in May 2022.  \n- Result 2 (2022-05-02) mentions Joanna working on dairy-free dessert recipes and sharing a picture of a cake made around April 25, 2022.  \n- Result 21 (2022-05-02) from Joanna to Nate describes the cake as \"dairy-free vanilla with strawberry filling and coconut cream frosting.\"\n\nStep 2: Confirm the filling used in that cake.  \n- Result 21 explicitly states the filling is strawberry.\n\nFinal answer: Joanna used strawberry filling in the cake she made recently in May 2022.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.95,
      "judge_latency_s": 3.41
    },
    {
      "question": "What kind of frosting did Joanna use on the cake she made recently in May 2022?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "coconut cream",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant time frame and message about the cake Joanna made recently in May 2022.  \n- Result 2 (2022-05-02) mentions Joanna made a cake recently (around April 25, 2022).  \n- Result 17 (2022-05-02) from Joanna to Nate says: \"Thanks! It's dairy-free vanilla with strawberry filling and coconut cream frosting.\"\n\nStep 2: Confirm that this frosting is linked to the cake made recently.  \n- Result 2 and Result 17 are from the same date and conversation, indicating the cake Joanna made recently has coconut cream frosting.\n\nFinal answer:  \nJoanna used coconut cream frosting on the cake she made recently in May 2022.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.92,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.41
    },
    {
      "question": "What does Nate feel he could do when out in cool places like Whispering Falls?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "write a whole movie",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant excerpt about Whispering Falls and Nate's feelings.\n\n- Result 13: Joanna mentions taking a photo at Whispering Falls.\n- Result 20: Joanna says, \"I always feel like I could write a whole movie when I'm out there in cool places like that!\"\n- Result 61: Nate responds, \"Wow, Jo, that's really cool! It's great to have something that gets those creative juices flowing.\"\n- Result 62: Nate says, \"Hey, we should go together sometime, don't you think? Maybe I'll start to think of a drama myself and publish my own screenplay.\"\n\nStep 2: From Nate's response in Result 62, he feels that being out in cool places like Whispering Falls might inspire him to think of a drama and possibly publish his own screenplay.\n\nFinal answer: Nate feels that when out in cool places like Whispering Falls, he might start to think of a drama himself and publish his own screenplay.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.45,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.29
    },
    {
      "question": "What creative activity does Nate joke about pursuing after being inspired by their hikes with Jo?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Start thinking about a drama and publish a screenplay",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Nate being inspired by hikes with Joanna (Jo).  \n- Result 1, 2, 3, 6, 19, 24, 31, 85 show Joanna talking about hiking and Nate responding.  \n- Result 16: Nate says, \"I wish I could have been there! Your hikes sound like a blast.\"  \n- Result 62: Nate says, \"I'm not really into hiking but I'm curious to see what the trail looks like!\"\n\nStep 2: Look for any mention of Nate joking about a creative activity after being inspired by hikes.  \n- No direct mention of Nate joking about a creative activity in the hiking context.  \n- However, Result 37: Joanna says, \"Cool, Nate! Sounds like a fun experience, even if I'm not into games.\"  \n- Result 50: Nate says, \"Playing video games and watching movies are my main hobbies.\"  \n- Result 49: Nate says,",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.14,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.11
    },
    {
      "question": "Who invited Nate to join her on the trails sometime?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Joanna",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify who talks about hiking and inviting Nate to join on trails.  \nStep 2: Look for messages where someone explicitly invites Nate to join on trails.  \nStep 3: In Result 20 [2022-05-12T15:43:00], Joanna says: \"Haha, now that would be something! Sure, you should come down and join me on the trails sometime!\"  \nStep 4: This clearly shows Joanna inviting Nate to join her on the trails.\n\nFinal answer: Joanna invited Nate to join her on the trails sometime.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.27,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.51
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Nate do for Joanna on 25 May, 2022?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "get her a stuffed animal",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify messages around 25 May 2022.\n\n- Result 4 [2022-05-25T15:08:00] Nate to Joanna: \"Sure, Joanna! It's all about finding those little things and cherishing them, otherwise it's easy to get down!\"\n- Result 24 [2022-05-25T15:07:00] Nate to Joanna: \"Agreed, those little things sure do make life better!\"\n- Result 85 [2022-05-25T15:10:00] Nate to Joanna: \"Can't wait to see it, Joanna! I'm here to support you.\"\n- Result 86 [2022-05-25T15:09:30] Joanna to Nate: \"Appreciating the journey and being aware of those happy moments can be a game-changer! It keeps us focused on our dreams. Can't wait to show it to you. I value your opinion!\"\n\nStep 2: Analyze",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.41,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.33
    },
    {
      "question": "How does Nate describe the stuffed animal he got for Joanna?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "A stuffed animal to remind you of the good vibes",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify all mentions of the stuffed animal Nate gave Joanna.\n- Result 7 (2022-05-25): Nate says, \"Looky here, I got this new pup for you!\"\n- Result 1 (2022-05-25): Nate says, \"Thanks! It's a stuffed animal to remind you of the good vibes.\"\n- Result 14 (2022-05-25): Nate says, \"I just really enjoy watching our pets play with one another. Its like a dream come true seeing my dog so happy.\" (less relevant)\n- Result 41 (2022-05-25): Nate says, \"Yeah! It's like having joy in your pocket. It always makes me grin when I look at it.\"\n- Result 48 (2022-05-25): Nate says, \"Sure, Joanna! It's all about finding those little things and cherishing them, otherwise it's easy to get down!\"\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.6,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.4
    },
    {
      "question": "What event is Nate organizing in June 2022?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "A gaming party",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of June 2022 in the context related to Nate organizing something.\n\n- Result 7 (2022-06-03): Nate talks about talking to guys at the tournament who want to hang out later.\n- Result 8 (2022-06-03): Nate mentions old friends and teammates from other tournaments.\n- Result 9 (2022-06-24): Nate says 7 people attended an event and 6 want to do it again next month.\n- Result 73 (2022-06-03): Joanna asks Nate if he is going to invite his tournament friends.\n- Result 55 (2022-06-03): Joanna wishes Nate the best on his party.\n- Result 56 (2022-06-03): Joanna says \"Sounds like fun, Nate! I wish you the best on your party. Have a blast!\"\n- Result 81 (2022-06-03): Joanna says \"Thanks Nate! See",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.53,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.23
    },
    {
      "question": "Who did Nate plan to invite to his gaming party in June 2022?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Tournament friends, old friends, teammates",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the date of the gaming party Nate is organizing.\n- Result 13 (2022-06-03): Nate says he is organizing a gaming party \"two weekends later,\" so the party is planned for mid-June 2022.\n\nStep 2: Look for who Nate planned to invite.\n- Result 8 (2022-06-03): Joanna asks if Nate will invite his tournament friends.\n- Result 24 (2022-06-03): Nate replies, \"Definitely! And some old friends and teammates from other tournaments.\"\n\nStep 3: Confirm the number of attendees or any other details.\n- Result 47 (2022-06-24): Nate says 7 people attended the party, and 6 want to do it again next month.\n\nFinal answer: Nate planned to invite his tournament friends, as well as some old friends and teammates from other tournaments, to his gaming party in June 2022.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.99,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.59
    },
    {
      "question": "What special items did Nate get for everyone at his gaming party?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Custom controller decorations",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the mention of a gaming party and any special items Nate got for friends.\n\nStep 2: Result 75 [2022-06-24T10:55:30] Nate to Joanna says: \"The gaming party was a great success! We even played some Chess afterward just for fun.\"\n\nStep 3: Result 25 [2022-06-24T10:56:00] Joanna to Nate asks: \"Nice! Did your friends like the controller accessories?\"\n\nStep 4: This implies Nate got controller accessories for his friends at the gaming party.\n\nNo other special items are mentioned in the context related to the gaming party.\n\nFinal answer: Nate got controller accessories for everyone at his gaming party.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.81,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.71
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Joanna write yesterday that appeared on the big screen?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "screenplay bits",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the date of the message where Joanna mentions writing something that appeared on the big screen \"yesterday.\"  \n- Result 11 [2022-06-05]: Joanna to Nate says, \"Hey Nate! Yesterday (approximately June 04, 2022) was crazy cool - I wrote a few bits for a screenplay that appeared on the big screen yesterday!\"\n\nStep 2: Confirm what Joanna wrote was a screenplay.  \n- The message explicitly states she wrote \"a few bits for a screenplay.\"\n\nStep 3: Confirm the screenplay appeared on the big screen.  \n- Joanna says it \"appeared on the big screen yesterday,\" confirming it was shown as a movie.\n\nFinal answer:  \nJoanna wrote parts of a screenplay that appeared as a movie on the big screen on June 4, 2022.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.86,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.28
    },
    {
      "question": "What superhero is Joanna a fan of?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Spider-Man",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: In Result 1, Nate notices a Spider-Man pin on Joanna's purse and asks if Spider-Man is her favorite superhero.\n\nStep 2: In Result 6, Joanna replies that Spider-Man has always been a favorite of hers, appreciating Peter Parker's struggles, but she also likes many superheroes.\n\nStep 3: No other superhero preference from Joanna is mentioned in the context.\n\nFinal answer: Joanna is a fan of Spider-Man.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.86,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.66
    },
    {
      "question": "Which superhero toy figure does Nate share a photo of?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Iron Man",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of superhero toy figures in the context.\n- Result 1: Joanna to Nate mentions loving the tech and funny jokes of Iron Man and asks Nate what made him get that figure.\n- Result 25: Joanna talks about Spider-Man being a favorite superhero and asks Nate if he has a favorite superhero.\n- Result 34: Nate to Joanna says Iron Man is his top pick, loves his tech and sarcastic humor, and that seeing these figures makes him feel invincible.\n\nStep 2: Confirm which figure Nate shared a photo of.\n- Result 1 and 34 together indicate Nate has an Iron Man figure.\n- Result 15 and 22 show Joanna asking Nate for a picture of something, and Joanna later sends a picture of her cork board, but no direct photo from Nate is shown here.\n- Result 34 explicitly mentions Nate's enthusiasm for Iron Man figures.\n\nStep 3: No other superhero figure is mentioned as being shared in a photo by Nate",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.91,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.92
    },
    {
      "question": "What is displayed on Joanna's cork board for motivation and creativity?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "inspiring quotes, photos, and little keepsakes",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about Joanna's cork board.\n- Result 1: Joanna says her cork board is full of inspiring quotes and pictures for motivation and creativity.\n- Result 2: Joanna shares a picture of her cork board, mentioning it has quotes, photos, and little keepsakes.\n- Result 4: Nate comments on a great family picture on the cork board.\n- Result 5: Joanna explains the family picture reminds her of love and encouragement every day.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize details.\nJoanna's cork board contains inspiring quotes, photos (including a family picture), and little keepsakes that serve as motivation and creativity boosters.\n\nFinal answer:  \nJoanna's cork board displays inspiring quotes, photos (including a family picture), and little keepsakes that motivate and inspire her creativity.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.5,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.34
    },
    {
      "question": "What does the photo on Joanna's cork board remind her of?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "love and encouragement from her family",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant excerpts about Joanna's cork board and the photo on it.\n\n- Result 2: Joanna shows a pic of her cork board with quotes, photos, and keepsakes.\n- Result 4: Joanna says her cork board is full of inspiring quotes and pictures for motivation and creativity.\n- Result 5: Joanna says having that picture on her cork board reminds her of the love and encouragement from them every day.\n\nStep 2: The key detail is in Result 5, where Joanna explicitly states what the photo on her cork board reminds her of.\n\nFinal answer: The photo on Joanna's cork board reminds her of the love and encouragement from her family every day.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.13,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.35
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Nate make and share with his vegan diet group?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "vegan ice cream",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Nate making and sharing something with a vegan diet group.  \n- Result 2 (2022-06-24): Nate says, \"I made vegan ice cream last Friday and shared it with some people in my vegan diet group. It was awesome!\"\n\nStep 2: Confirm what Nate made.  \n- Result 2 clearly states it was vegan ice cream.\n\nStep 3: Check if there are any other mentions that might add details or contradict this.  \n- No contradictions found; other mentions of ice cream by Nate are consistent with dairy-free or vegan ice cream.\n\nFinal answer:  \nNate made vegan ice cream and shared it with his vegan diet group.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 4.21,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.44
    },
    {
      "question": "How many people attended the gaming party hosted by Nate in June 2022?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "7",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant date and event.\n- The question asks about the gaming party hosted by Nate in June 2022.\n\nStep 2: Find excerpts mentioning a gaming party in June 2022.\n- Result 28 [2022-06-03]: Nate says he is organizing a gaming party two weekends later.\n- Result 19 [2022-06-24]: Nate says the gaming party was a great success and mentions playing Chess afterward.\n- Result 4 [2022-06-24]: Nate says 7 people attended the party, and 6 want to do it again next month.\n- Result 96 [2022-06-24]: Joanna congratulates Nate on the huge success.\n\nStep 3: Confirm the number of attendees.\n- Result 4 explicitly states: \"There were 7 people that attended.\"\n\nFinal answer: 7 people attended the gaming party hosted by Nate in June 2022.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.18,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.77
    },
    {
      "question": "What recipe Nate offer to share with Joanna?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "vegan ice cream recipe",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Nate offering recipes to Joanna.\n\n- Result 46 [2022-02-25]: Nate says, \"Sure, I know one recipe using coconut milk. Would you like me to send it to you?\"\n- Result 13 [2022-08-14]: Nate says, \"No problem, Joanna! Always happy to share them with you. Sending you the recipe now!\"\n- Result 15 [2022-08-14]: Nate mentions a \"creamy, rich, dairy-free and a new recipe\" and offers to share it.\n- Result 50 [2022-04-17]: Nate describes making ice cream with coconut milk, vanilla extract, sugar, and salt.\n- Result 43 [2022-02-07]: Nate says he made a dairy-free chocolate cake with berries.\n- Result 28 [2022-11-09]: Nate shares a homemade coconut ice cream recipe.\n- Result 61 [2022-",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.93,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.6
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Joanna plan to do with the recipe Nate promised to share?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "make it for her family",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify where Nate promised to share a recipe.  \n- Result 21 (2022-08-14): Nate says, \"No problem, Joanna! Always happy to share them with you. Sending you the recipe now!\"  \n- Result 26 (2022-04-17): Nate says, \"Thanks! It's dairy-free and so easy. Wanna get the recipe?\"  \n- Result 71 (2022-08-14): Nate says, \"I've been really into making this lately - it's creamy, rich, dairy-free and a new recipe! Wanna try it? I can share the recipe with you if you'd like!\"\n\nStep 2: Look for Joanna's response about what she planned to do with the recipe.  \n- Result 6 (2022-04-17): Joanna says, \"Wow, sounds delicious! I'm going to try making it tonight! Thank you for sharing the recipe!\"  \n- Result 5 (2022-04-17",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.71,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.74
    },
    {
      "question": "How many video game tournaments has Nate won by July 10, 2022?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Four",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify all mentions of Nate winning tournaments before or on July 10, 2022.\n\n- Result 9 (2022-01-21): Nate won his first tournament approximately January 14, 2022.\n- Result 1 (2022-05-02): Nate won his second tournament approximately April 25, 2022.\n- Result 4 (2022-06-03): Nate won another regional tournament approximately May 27, 2022. This would be his third tournament win.\n- Result 12 (2022-07-10): Nate won his fourth tournament on Friday (July 8, 2022).\n\nStep 2: Confirm no other wins before July 10, 2022.\n\nNo other tournament wins are mentioned before July 10, 2022.\n\nFinal answer: By July 10, 2022, Nate has won 4 video game tournaments.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.88,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.81
    },
    {
      "question": "Where did Joanna go for a road trip for research?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Woodhaven",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Joanna going on a road trip or hiking for research.\n- Result 5 (2022-05-12): Joanna mentions loving a spot on a hike with a soothing rush of water.\n- Result 9 (2022-05-12): Joanna says she went hiking and found amazing trails in her town.\n- Result 56 (2022-05-12): Joanna describes the place as calming, peaceful, with the sound of nature.\n- Result 93 (2022-05-12): Joanna took a photo at a place called Whispering Falls, describing it as peaceful and serene.\n\nStep 2: Check if any of these mentions are explicitly linked to a road trip for research.\n- Result 5 and 9 mention hiking and trails in her town, not explicitly a road trip.\n- Result 93 names the location as Whispering Falls, which is likely the spot she visited.\n- Result 70 (2022-04-15",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 4.46,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.64
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Joanna discover at the library in Woodhaven?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "cool old book collection",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about Joanna's visit to Woodhaven and the library.\n\n- Result 1: Joanna mentions going to Woodhaven, a small town in the Midwest, and checking out the library with a cool old book collection.\n- Result 4: Joanna says she found a super cool book from the 1900s with stories and sketches about the town and its people.\n- Result 3: Joanna notes Woodhaven's interesting past and how seeing its changes sparked ideas for her next script.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.\n\nJoanna discovered an old book from the 1900s at the Woodhaven library that contained stories and sketches about the town and its residents, which inspired her creatively.\n\nFinal answer:  \nJoanna discovered a super cool old book from the 1900s at the Woodhaven library containing stories and sketches about the town and its people.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.65,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.75
    },
    {
      "question": "What specific themes are explored in Joanna's new book?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "loss, redemption, and forgiveness",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Joanna's new book and its themes.\n\n- Result 6 (2022-10-06): Joanna mentions finishing her book around September 29, 2022.\n- Result 8 (2022-07-10): Joanna talks about a page with dialogues exploring loss, redemption, and forgiveness.\n- Result 25 (2022-05-20): Joanna says her writing is about loss, identity, and connection.\n- Result 28 (2022-02-25): Joanna describes a story about a woman on a journey of self-discovery after a loss.\n- Result 49 (2022-01-21): Joanna likes dramas and romcoms, which may influence themes.\n- Result 99 (2022-05-20): Nate notes Joanna likes writing about sadness and loss.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the themes from these excerpts.\n\nJoanna's new book explores themes of loss, identity, connection, redemption, and forgiveness",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.83,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.24
    },
    {
      "question": "What inspired Joanna's new script in July 2022?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Woodhaven's interesting past and people",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the timeframe of interest: July 2022.\n\nStep 2: Look for any messages around July 2022 that mention Joanna's new script or inspiration.\n\nStep 3: Result 60 [2022-07-10T14:37:30] Joanna to Nate says: \"Woodhaven has had an interesting past with lots of cool people. Seeing how much it changed sparked ideas for my next script.\"\n\nStep 4: This is a direct statement from Joanna about what inspired her new script around July 2022.\n\nFinal answer: Joanna's new script in July 2022 was inspired by the interesting past and changes of a place called Woodhaven.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.09,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.66
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Nate do while Joanna was on her road trip?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Won a video game tournament",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify when Joanna's road trip happened.  \n- From Result 20 (2022-02-25), Joanna describes her story about a road trip to heal and grow.  \n- Result 5 (2022-07-10) Nate asks Joanna about the road trip and where she went, indicating the trip was before July 2022.  \n- Result 9 and 13 (both 2022-05-12) Joanna talks about hiking and enjoying nature, likely during or related to the road trip timeframe.\n\nStep 2: Look for Nate's activities during that period (roughly early to mid 2022).  \n- Result 2 (2022-09-05) Nate mentions hanging with \"them\" (likely pets or friends) has been a big help recently (around August 29, 2022).  \n- Result 14, 31, 39, 63, 66 (June 2022) Nate talks about",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.27,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.59
    },
    {
      "question": "What does Nate do that he loves and can make money from?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Competing in video game tournaments",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify Nate's activities mentioned in the context.  \n- Result 17: Nate mentions playing video games and watching movies as hobbies.  \n- Result 35: Nate loves fantasy and sci-fi movies and playing video games as a creative outlet.  \n- Result 5: Nate says he creates gaming content for YouTube, which entertains people and satisfies his gaming cravings when there are no tournaments.  \n- Result 81: Nate won a tournament and earned cash, indicating competitive gaming.  \n- Result 58: Joanna congratulates Nate for winning a tournament and turning his passion into a career.  \n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.  \nNate loves playing video games and participates in tournaments, which he can win and earn money from. Additionally, he creates gaming content for YouTube, which likely generates income as well.\n\nFinal answer:  \nNate loves playing video games competitively in tournaments and creating gaming content for YouTube, both of which he can make money",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.01,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.25
    },
    {
      "question": "How did Joanna feel when someone wrote her a letter after reading her blog post?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Touched",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant excerpt about the letter Joanna received after her blog post.  \n- Result 1 [2022-08-14]: Joanna says someone wrote her a letter after reading her blog post about a hard moment in her life.  \n- She says their words touched her and it was awesome to realize her words had that kind of power.  \n- It reminded her why she loves writing.\n\nStep 2: Analyze Joanna's feelings from her own words.  \n- She felt touched by the letter.  \n- She found it awesome and inspiring.  \n- It reinforced her love for writing.\n\nFinal answer: Joanna felt touched and inspired when she received the letter, finding it awesome and a reminder of why she loves writing.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.92,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.69
    },
    {
      "question": "What kind of impact does Joanna hope to have with her writing?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "share her stories and hopefully have an impact",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Joanna describes writing as an escape and a way to express feelings, putting thoughts down to make something good out of them (Result 1).\n\nStep 2: She mentions receiving a letter from someone who found comfort in her writing about a hard moment, which reminded her why she loves writing and the power her words can have (Result 6).\n\nStep 3: Joanna says her writing can make a difference and that knowing this keeps her going even on tough days (Result 96).\n\nStep 4: She also talks about exploring personal and emotional topics like loss, identity, connection, redemption, and forgiveness, indicating she wants to touch on meaningful, deep issues (Results 7, 20).\n\nStep 5: Nate acknowledges her bravery in exploring feelings and experiences, and Joanna values the impact her stories have on others (Results 15, 34).\n\nFinal answer: Joanna hopes her writing has a healing and comforting impact on others by expressing personal, emotional experiences that can inspire",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.93,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.25
    },
    {
      "question": "What kind of content did Joanna share that someone wrote her a letter about?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "A blog post about a hard moment in her life",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify when Joanna mentioned receiving a letter.  \n- In Result 1 (2022-08-14), Joanna says someone wrote her a letter after reading an online blog post she made about a hard moment in her life.\n\nStep 2: Understand the content of that blog post.  \n- In Result 3 (2022-05-20), Joanna says she wrote about loss, identity, and connection, a personal story she had for ages but just got the courage to write.  \n- In Result 26 (2022-02-25), Joanna describes her story as about a thirty-year-old woman on a journey of self-discovery after a loss.  \n- In Result 31 (2022-05-20), Joanna mentions her writing is about personal experiences and feelings, and in Result 18 (2022-07-10), she talks about dialogues exploring loss, redemption, and forgiveness.\n\nStep 3: Confirm the letter was in response to this",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.99,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.63
    },
    {
      "question": "What motivates Joanna to keep writing even on tough days?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Knowing that her writing can make a difference",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Joanna mentions writing as an escape and a way to express feelings, helping her put thoughts down and heal (Result 1).\n\nStep 2: She was motivated by a letter from a reader who found comfort in her writing, reminding her of the power and impact of her words (Result 4).\n\nStep 3: Joanna values the support and encouragement from friends like Nate, which helps her keep going (Results 7, 86).\n\nStep 4: She finds happiness and fulfillment in creating stories and seeing them come alive (Result 20).\n\nStep 5: Joanna also writes from personal experiences and feelings, believing meaningful stories come from being true to herself, even when it's hard (Results 14, 16).\n\nStep 6: She appreciates knowing her writing can make a difference and have an impact, which keeps her going on tough days (Result 86).\n\nFinal answer: Joanna is motivated to keep writing on tough days because she knows her words have the power to",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.49,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.39
    },
    {
      "question": "What type of ice cream does Joanna mention that Nate makes and is delicious?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Coconut milk ice cream",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of ice cream Joanna talks about that Nate makes.  \n- Result 23: Joanna says, \"I love it when you make coconut milk icecream, it's so good!\"  \n- Result 44: Nate says, \"Coconut milk ice cream is at the top of my list... it's dairy-free...\" and shares a photo.  \n- Result 31: Nate mentions \"Coconut milk ice cream is one of my favorites as you might be able to tell.\"  \n- Result 26: Nate shares a photo of homemade coconut ice cream.  \n- Result 40-42, 52: Nate offers Joanna some ice cream made with coconut milk, which is lactose-free. Joanna responds positively.\n\nStep 2: Confirm Joanna's opinion on the ice cream Nate makes.  \n- Joanna explicitly says she loves Nate's coconut milk ice cream and finds it delicious (Result 23).  \n- She also expresses interest in trying his recipes and appreciates the dairy-free aspect",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.76,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.4
    },
    {
      "question": "How did Nate feel about sharing his love for dairy-free desserts with Joanna?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Happy to share",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Nate expressed appreciation and enthusiasm about sharing dairy-free dessert recipes with Joanna.  \n- In [Result 1] (2022-08-14), Nate said, \"Thanks, Joanna! Your words mean a lot. Since we last spoke, I started teaching people how to make this. Sharing my love for dairy-free desserts has been fun and rewarding.\"  \n- In [Result 24] (2022-09-14), Nate said, \"Yeah sure! Would love to share it. Let's spread the joy of dairy-free options!\"  \n- In [Result 95] (2022-08-14), Nate said, \"No problem, Joanna! Always happy to share them with you. Sending you the recipe now!\"\n\nStep 2: Nate also showed excitement and pride in his dairy-free dessert creations and teaching others, indicating positive feelings about sharing.  \n- In [Result 28] (2022-09-14), Nate mentioned teaching vegan ice cream",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.42,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.07
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Joanna share with her writers group in August 2022?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "her book",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant time frame and context. The question asks about what Joanna shared with her writers group in August 2022.\n\nStep 2: Look for mentions of Joanna, writers group, and August 2022 in the context.\n\n- Result 36 (2022-04-21) mentions Joanna joining a writers group.\n- Result 70 (2022-08-22) Joanna says: \"Was super nervous last week (approximately August 15, 2022) when I shared my book with my writers group but got some great feedback.\"\n- Result 37 (2022-08-14) Joanna says: \"Last week (approximately August 07, 2022), someone wrote me a letter after reading an online blog post I made about a hard moment in my life.\"\n- Result 67 (2022-05-20) Joanna says she wrote about \"loss, identity, and connection,\" a personal story.\n- Result 88 (202",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.27,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.88
    },
    {
      "question": "How did Joanna celebrate after sharing her book with her writers group?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "making a delicious treat",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify when Joanna shared her book with her writers group.  \n- Result 38 (2022-08-22) Joanna says she was nervous last week (around August 15, 2022) when she shared her book with her writers group and got great feedback.\n\nStep 2: Look for any mention of celebration after this event.  \n- Result 4 (2022-08-22) Nate asks Joanna if she celebrated after getting good feedback from her writers group.  \n- No direct reply from Joanna about a celebration is found in the excerpts.\n\nStep 3: Check for any indirect clues about how she felt or what she did after sharing.  \n- Result 14 (2022-08-14) Joanna talks about receiving a letter from a reader who was comforted by her writing, which motivated her love for writing, but this is before the writers group event.  \n- Result 16 (2022-08-14) Joanna describes writing as",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.59,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.98
    },
    {
      "question": "How did Nate celebrate winning the international tournament?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Taking time off to chill with pets",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify when Nate won the international tournament.  \n- Result 4 (2022-08-22) Nate says he won an international tournament \"yesterday,\" so approximately August 21, 2022.\n\nStep 2: Look for any mentions of how Nate celebrated this win.  \n- Result 43 (2022-08-22) Joanna congratulates Nate and asks if he celebrated.  \n- Result 57 (2022-08-22) Joanna says she celebrated by making a delicious treat but asks Nate about his plans for the weekend, no direct answer from Nate about his celebration.  \n- Result 45 and 12 mention Nate helping friends and old teammates after tournaments, but no direct celebration details.  \n- No explicit message from Nate describing a celebration for this specific international tournament win.\n\nStep 3: Check if any other tournament wins have celebration details that might be confused.  \n- Result 7 and 12 mention Nate talking to people and helping friends",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.87,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.92
    },
    {
      "question": "Why is Joanna experimenting with dairy-free options in her dessert recipes?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "lactose intolerance",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for mentions of Joanna's dietary needs or preferences related to dairy.  \n- Result 5: Joanna says she can't have dairy.  \n- Result 8: Joanna mentions being lactose intolerant and trying dairy-free options like coconut or almond milk.  \n- Result 4: Joanna says dairy-free is a must for her, especially for desserts.  \n\nStep 2: Confirm that her experimentation with dairy-free desserts is due to lactose intolerance or dairy sensitivity.  \n- Result 8 explicitly states Joanna is lactose intolerant and is trying dairy-free options.  \n- Result 5 also supports this by Joanna saying she can't have dairy.  \n\nStep 3: Check if there are any other reasons mentioned.  \n- No other reasons like allergies or preferences are mentioned besides lactose intolerance.  \n\nFinal answer: Joanna is experimenting with dairy-free dessert recipes because she is lactose intolerant and cannot have dairy.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.7,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.66
    },
    {
      "question": "What substitution does Nate suggest for butter in dairy-free baking?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "dairy-free margarine or coconut oil",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify where Nate talks about dairy-free baking substitutions.  \nStep 2: In Result 2 (2022-09-05T18:10:00), Nate says: \"You can use stuff like dairy-free margarine or coconut oil instead of butter.\"  \nStep 3: This is a direct answer to the question about substitutions for butter in dairy-free baking.\n\nFinal answer: Nate suggests using dairy-free margarine or coconut oil as substitutions for butter in dairy-free baking.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.9,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.33
    },
    {
      "question": "What type of show did Nate host where he taught vegan ice cream recipes?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "a cooking show",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant excerpt about Nate hosting a show teaching vegan ice cream recipes.  \n- Result 1 [2022-09-14]: Nate says, \"Last Monday I got to teach people vegan ice cream recipes on my own cooking show!\"\n\nStep 2: Note the type of show Nate hosted.  \n- He explicitly calls it \"my own cooking show.\"\n\nFinal answer: Nate hosted a cooking show where he taught vegan ice cream recipes.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.72,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.49
    },
    {
      "question": "What is Nate's favorite dish from the cooking show he hosted?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Coconut milk ice cream",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify any direct mentions of Nate's favorite dish from the cooking show.\n- Result 49 mentions Nate teaching vegan ice cream recipes on his cooking show.\n- Result 55 shows Nate made coconut milk ice cream and was proud of it.\n- Result 48 Nate says he's been really into making a creamy, rich, dairy-free new recipe (likely the coconut milk ice cream).\n- Result 20 Joanna says she loves it when Nate makes coconut milk ice cream.\n- Result 9 Nate says a dessert was rich and creamy and might be his new favorite snack (likely the coconut milk ice cream).\n- Result 28 Joanna asks Nate to share the recipe of something he made on the show.\n- Result 26 Joanna calls Nate's ice cream mouthwatering and thanks him for offering the recipe.\n- Result 27 Nate talks about making homemade coconut ice cream with sprinkles.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.\n- Nate's cooking show involved teaching vegan ice cream recipes.\n-",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.79,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.43
    },
    {
      "question": "What is one of Nate's favorite dairy-free treats besides coconut milk ice cream?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "dairy-free chocolate mousse",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify Nate's favorite dairy-free treats mentioned in the context.  \n- In [Result 3], Nate says he loves coconut milk ice cream and also a dairy-free chocolate mousse.  \n- In [Result 7], Nate mentions he loves coconut milk, chocolate, and mixed berry flavors.  \n- In [Result 26], Nate says he made a dairy-free chocolate cake with berries.  \n- In [Result 71], Nate mentions he whipped up some chocolate and vanilla swirl (likely ice cream).  \n\nStep 2: Confirm that the question asks for a favorite dairy-free treat besides coconut milk ice cream.  \n- The chocolate mousse and dairy-free chocolate cake with berries fit this criterion.  \n\nStep 3: Choose the most explicitly stated favorite treat besides coconut milk ice cream.  \n- In [Result 3], Nate explicitly says he loves dairy-free chocolate mousse, describing it as super creamy and tasting like the real thing.  \n- The chocolate cake with berries is mentioned",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.95,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.42
    },
    {
      "question": "What dessert did Joanna share a photo of that has an almond flour crust, chocolate ganache, and fresh raspberries?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "chocolate raspberry tart",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the dessert description in the context.  \n- Result 24 [2022-09-14T13:48:00] Joanna to Nate: \"Hey Nate, my favorite dairy-free treat is this amazing chocolate raspberry tart. It has an almond flour crust, chocolate ganache, and fresh raspberries - it's delicious!\"\n\nStep 2: Confirm that this dessert was shared with a photo.  \n- Result 4 [2022-05-02T11:58:00] Joanna to Nate mentions sharing a pic of a cake, but not this tart specifically.  \n- Result 24 explicitly describes the tart with the almond flour crust, chocolate ganache, and raspberries, implying it is a known favorite and likely the dessert she shared a photo of around that time (September 14, 2022).  \n- Result 7 and 11 show Nate reacting to a dessert photo from Joanna on the same date (September 14, 2022),",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 4.36,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.44
    },
    {
      "question": "What kind of cake did Joanna share a photo of that she likes making for birthdays and special days?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "chocolate cake with raspberries",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant excerpts where Joanna talks about a cake she likes making for birthdays and special days.\n\n- Result 1 (2022-05-02): Joanna mentions testing dairy-free dessert recipes and shares a photo of a cake made around April 25, 2022.\n- Result 3 (2022-09-14): Joanna says, \"I make it with almond flour, coconut oil, chocolate and raspberries. It's my favorite for birthdays and special days.\"\n- Result 47 (2022-09-14): Joanna says, \"I love making this dairy-free chocolate cake with raspberries. It's so moist and delicious - perfect sweetness level.\"\n- Result 51 (2022-05-02): Joanna describes a cake as \"dairy-free vanilla with strawberry filling and coconut cream frosting,\" but this seems to be a different cake.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.\n\nJoanna's favorite cake for birthdays and special days is a dairy-free chocolate",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.6,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.88
    },
    {
      "question": "What two main ingredients are part of the dessert Joanna shared a photo of with blueberries, coconut milk, and a gluten-free crust?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "blueberries and coconut milk",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the dessert Joanna shared with blueberries, coconut milk, and a gluten-free crust.  \n- Result 1 (2022-09-14) Joanna to Nate: \"Here's another recipe I like. It's a delicious dessert made with blueberries, coconut milk, and a gluten-free crust.\"\n\nStep 2: Look for any additional details about the ingredients in that dessert.  \n- Result 8 (2022-09-14) Joanna to Nate: \"I make it with almond flour, coconut oil, chocolate and raspberries. It's my favorite for birthdays and special days.\"  \nThis is a different dessert (with chocolate and raspberries), so not the same one with blueberries.\n\nStep 3: Check if any other messages mention the dessert with blueberries and coconut milk.  \n- No other excerpt explicitly lists ingredients for the blueberry dessert besides the gluten-free crust, coconut milk, and blueberries.\n\nStep 4: Since the crust is gluten-free, the likely main ingredient for the",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.07,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.94
    },
    {
      "question": "What movie did Nate recently watch and enjoy on October 6, 2022?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Little Women",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the date of interest: October 6, 2022.\n\nStep 2: Look for messages around that date mentioning movies Nate watched.\n\nStep 3: Result 38 [2022-10-06T11:18:30] Nate to Joanna says: \"I watched 'Little Women' recently (approximately September 29, 2022), and it was great! The acting was awesome and the story was so captivating. Definitely a good one!\"\n\nStep 4: This is the only direct mention of a movie Nate recently watched and enjoyed near October 6, 2022.\n\nFinal answer: Nate recently watched and enjoyed the movie \"Little Women\" around September 29, 2022.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.53,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.57
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Joanna make for one of the ladies at her writing club?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "a bookmark",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts mentioning Joanna making something for someone at her writing club.\n\n- Result 20 [2022-10-06T11:24:00] Joanna to Nate: \"Rest assured, it will be something I cherish! On another note, I just finished this cute little bookmark for one of the ladies at my writing club!\"\n\nStep 2: Confirm what Joanna made.\n\n- She made a \"cute little bookmark\" for one of the ladies at her writing club.\n\nFinal answer: Joanna made a cute little bookmark for one of the ladies at her writing club.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.15,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.69
    },
    {
      "question": "What game did Nate play at the game convention he attended on 9 October, 2022?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Catan",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the date of the game convention Nate attended.\n- Result 25 (2022-10-09) Nate mentions attending a game convention \"last Friday,\" which would be October 7, 2022.\n\nStep 2: Look for what game Nate played at that convention.\n- Result 19 (2022-10-09) Nate says he met people who played a board game he loves and joined in.\n- Result 32 (2022-10-09) Nate specifies the game as \"Catan,\" describing it as a strategy game involving building settlements and trading resources.\n\nStep 3: Confirm this is the game played at the convention.\n- Result 25 and 19 are from the same date and context, indicating the convention and the Catan game are linked.\n\nFinal answer: Nate played the board game Catan at the game convention he attended on October 9, 2022.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 6.0,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.18
    },
    {
      "question": "What movie has Nate recently seen that blew his mind?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "\"Inception\"",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of movies Nate has recently seen.  \n- Result 6: Nate says he recently (around October 2, 2022) saw a movie that blew his mind with twists and dream stuff, called \"Inception.\"  \n- Result 43: Nate also mentions watching \"Little Women\" recently (around September 29, 2022), but he describes it as great, not mind-blowing.  \n\nStep 2: Confirm which movie blew his mind.  \n- Result 6 explicitly states \"a movie that blew my mind with all the twists and dream stuff,\" and names it \"Inception.\"  \n\nFinal answer:  \nNate recently saw the movie \"Inception,\" which blew his mind.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.19,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.54
    },
    {
      "question": "What game has Nate been playing nonstop with a futuristic setting and gameplay on October 9, 2022?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Cyberpunk 2077",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the date and context of the question: October 9, 2022.\n\nStep 2: Look for Nate's messages around that date mentioning games with futuristic settings.\n\nStep 3: In Result 3 (2022-10-09T11:06:00), Nate says he recently saw the movie \"Inception\" and has been playing a game nonstop with a great futuristic setting and gameplay called \"Cyberpunk 2077.\"\n\nStep 4: Confirm no other game with a futuristic setting is mentioned by Nate around that time.\n\nFinal answer: Nate has been playing \"Cyberpunk 2077\" nonstop with a futuristic setting and gameplay on October 9, 2022.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.27,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.8
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Nate share a photo of when mentioning unwinding at home?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "a bookcase filled with dvds and movies",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant excerpt where Nate mentions unwinding at home.  \n- Result 12 [2022-10-09T11:05:00] Nate to Joanna: \"Mostly just chilling at home. Playing video games or watching movies helps me unwind.\"\n\nStep 2: Check if Nate shared a photo in this or nearby messages related to unwinding or video games.  \n- Result 28 [2022-10-25T20:17:00] Nate to Joanna: \"Congrats Joanna! How was it to finally see it on the big screen?\" [shares a photo holding a videogame controller]\n\nStep 3: The photo of Nate holding a videogame controller is the only photo mentioned related to gaming or unwinding at home.\n\nStep 4: Confirm no other photos are mentioned by Nate about unwinding at home or video games.\n\nFinal answer: Nate shared a photo of himself holding a videogame controller when mentioning unwinding at home.",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.36,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.22
    },
    {
      "question": "How did Joanna describe the classic movie he watched?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "gripping with great actors",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify where Joanna talks about the classic movie she watched.\n- Result 1: Joanna says she watched a classic movie \"the other day\" and describes it as \"awesome,\" with a gripping story and great actors.\n- Result 2: Joanna confirms the movie is awesome, first watched it about 3 years ago, and even bought a physical copy.\n- Result 16: Joanna rates the movie 9 or 10 out of 10, saying it was amazing and that movies can take us to different places and evoke many emotions.\n- Result 17: Joanna says she has seen it a few times and it is one of her favorites, liking the idea and acting.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the description.\nJoanna described the classic movie as awesome, gripping in story, with great acting, amazing, and one of her favorites. She rated it very highly (9 or 10 out of 10).\n\nFinal answer: Joanna described the classic movie as awesome,",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.86,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.48
    },
    {
      "question": "What does Joanna recommend to make a living room comfy like hers?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "couch for multiple people, fluffy blanket, lights that can be dimmed",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant conversation about making a living room comfy.\n- Result 6 (2022-10-09): Nate says the living room is comfy and wants a setup like that.\n- Result 1 and 2 (2022-10-09): Nate asks Joanna for pointers on making his living room comfy.\n- Result 12 (2022-10-09): Joanna responds with specific recommendations.\n\nStep 2: Extract Joanna's recommendations from Result 12:\n- Get a couch that can seat multiple people and is really fluffy.\n- Invest in a blanket that has a little bit of weight to it.\n- Get some lights that can be dimmed.\n\nFinal answer: Joanna recommends getting a fluffy multi-person couch, a weighted blanket, and dimmable lights to make a living room comfy like hers.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.4,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.61
    },
    {
      "question": "What helps Joanna stay focused and brings her joy?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "stuffed animal dog named Tilly",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for mentions of what Joanna says brings her joy or helps her focus.\n\n- Result 21 (2022-11-07): Nate notes Joanna has a \"thing for writing\" and asks where she got the idea for it.\n- Result 50 (2022-03-24): Joanna says her \"go-to place for writing inspiration\" helps her stay sharp and motivated.\n- Result 44 (2022-04-21): Joanna recalls her first play experience, emphasizing preparation and staying in the moment.\n- Result 80 (2022-05-25): Joanna mentions having a peaceful presence around helps relieve stress and aids relaxation.\n- Result 81 (2022-04-17): Joanna says small things, like spending time with little friends and doing activities she loves, are treasures that make life enjoyable.\n- Result 96 (2022-11-04): Joanna says her meetings are exciting, implying they help her.\n- Result 8 (202",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.35,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.85
    },
    {
      "question": "What does Joanna do while she writes?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "have a stuffed animal dog named Tilly with her",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for Joanna's own statements about what she does while writing.  \n- In [Result 23], Joanna says: \"Writing and hanging with friends! That way I can express myself through stories, or just have a good time with people.\"  \n- In [Result 97], Joanna says: \"Writing and creative projects are what get me through tough times. I'm also grateful for my supportive friends.\"  \n- In [Result 4], Joanna says: \"Writing has become like an escape and a way to express my feelings. It gives me a chance to put all my thoughts and feelings down and make something good out of it.\"  \n- In [Result 26], Joanna mentions receiving a letter after writing a blog post about a hard moment, showing she writes about personal experiences.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.  \nJoanna writes as a form of self-expression and emotional processing, often alongside spending time with friends for support and social interaction.\n\nFinal answer:",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 5.08,
      "judge_latency_s": 3.42
    },
    {
      "question": "Why did Joanna name the stuffed animal dog Tilly?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "after a dog she had in Michigan",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Joanna mentioned she still has the stuffed animal dog Nate gave her and named her Tilly (Result 1).\n\nStep 2: Nate asked why she named it Tilly (Result 2).\n\nStep 3: Joanna explained that she used to have a dog named Tilly back in Michigan, but had to give her away due to allergies (Result 4).\n\nStep 4: Naming the stuffed animal Tilly helps Joanna remember her old dog and the times when she could hold and squeeze an animal without allergic reactions (Result 4).\n\nStep 5: Joanna also said Tilly helps her stay focused and brings her joy (Result 3).\n\nFinal answer: Joanna named the stuffed animal dog Tilly to remember her old dog from Michigan, as a comforting reminder of when she could hold a pet without allergic reactions, and because Tilly helps her stay focused and brings her joy.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.63,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.17
    },
    {
      "question": "What does Joanna do after receiving a rejection from a production company?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "keep grinding and moving ahead",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Joanna received a rejection letter from a major company after finishing her screenplay (Result 6, dated 2022-06-03).\n\nStep 2: She expressed disappointment about the generic rejection letter without much feedback (Result 1, 2022-06-03).\n\nStep 3: Later, around October 14, 2022, she had another rejection from a production company (Result 2).\n\nStep 4: Despite these setbacks, Joanna continued submitting more scripts, as she mentioned submitting a few more around October 31, 2022 (Result 84).\n\nStep 5: She remained hopeful and valued Nate\u2019s support, showing resilience and determination to keep trying (Results 66, 84, 91).\n\nFinal answer: After receiving a rejection from a production company, Joanna stays positive and continues submitting more scripts, maintaining hope and persistence in her writing career.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.1,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.2
    },
    {
      "question": "How does Nate feel about Joanna's ability to bounce back from setbacks?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "respect Joanna for being able to bounce back",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts where Nate comments on Joanna's resilience or ability to bounce back.\n\n- Result 42 [2022-10-21]: Nate says, \"That's what I like to hear! I really respect you for that and being able to bounce back whenever something sad happens!\"\n- Result 71 [2022-06-03]: Nate encourages Joanna not to get discouraged and to keep believing in herself.\n- Result 80 [2022-03-18]: Nate says, \"Just make sure you don't quit - the path forward will show up soon. You got this!\"\n- Result 26 [2022-11-04]: Nate praises Joanna for putting herself out there and feeling hopeful and inspired.\n- Result 72 [2022-03-18]: Joanna thanks Nate for his support, indicating he has been encouraging her to keep going.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.\n\nNate clearly respects and admires Joanna's ability to recover from setbacks,",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.69,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.57
    },
    {
      "question": "What encouragement does Nate give to Joanna after her setback?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "rejections don't define her, keep grinding and she'll find the perfect opportunity",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the setback Joanna experienced.  \n- Result 23 (2022-10-21): Joanna mentions a setback around October 14, 2022, specifically a rejection from a production company.  \n- Result 56 (2022-06-03): Joanna says she received a generic rejection letter without much feedback, which was disheartening.\n\nStep 2: Find Nate's responses to Joanna's setbacks.  \n- Result 16 (2022-06-03): Nate says, \"Ugh, that's so frustrating. But don't get discouraged, just keep going.\"  \n- Result 53 (2022-06-03): Nate encourages, \"Sure, just make sure you keep going and believing in yourself. Did something happen with the company?\"  \n- Result 54 (2022-10-21): Nate says, \"That's what I like to hear! I really respect you for that and being able to bounce back whenever something sad happens!\"  \n",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.47,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.43
    },
    {
      "question": "What does Nate rely on for cheer and joy?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "his turtles",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of what brings Nate cheer and joy.\n\n- Result 14 (2022-05-20): Nate talks about an adopted pet full of energy bringing him joy and keeping his other pets active.\n- Result 40 (2022-01-23): Nate has had his pets for 3 years and they bring him tons of joy.\n- Result 56 (2022-04-17): Nate says spending time with his pets and engaging in hobbies helps him find peace and happiness.\n- Result 70 (2022-10-21): Nate mentions his turtles cheering him up during stressful tournament progress.\n- Result 85 (2022-08-22): Nate calls his pets his little buddies, always calm and peaceful, making coming home better.\n- Result 89 (2022-01-23): Nate recommends having turtles for times of stress.\n- Result 23 (2022-10-21): Nate finds joy watching his turtles slowly walk around",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.03,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.36
    },
    {
      "question": "What does Joanna use to remember her dog from Michigan?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "naming a stuffed animal dog Tilly",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Joanna's dog from Michigan.  \n- Result 1: Joanna says she used to have a dog in Michigan with a certain name but had to get rid of her due to allergies.  \n- Result 2: Joanna mentions she still has a stuffed animal dog named Tilly that Nate gave her.  \n- Result 21: Nate refers to a stuffed animal as a reminder of good vibes.  \n- Result 36: Nate acknowledges the stuffed animal means a lot to Joanna.  \n- Result 43: Joanna says Tilly (the stuffed animal) helps her stay focused and brings her joy, showing how even stuffed animals can have meaning.  \n- Result 50: Nate asks Joanna why she named the stuffed animal Tilly, implying the name is connected to her dog.  \n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.  \nJoanna uses a stuffed animal dog named Tilly, given by Nate, to remember her dog from Michigan. The name Tilly",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.3,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.91
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Joanna contribute to that was shown on the big screen on the Sunday before October 25, 2022?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "movie script",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the date of the Sunday before October 25, 2022.  \n- October 25, 2022, was a Tuesday.  \n- The Sunday before that would be October 23, 2022.\n\nStep 2: Look for any mention of Joanna's contribution shown on the big screen around that time.  \n- Result 99 (dated 2022-06-05) mentions Joanna wrote bits for a screenplay that appeared on the big screen \"yesterday\" (June 4, 2022).  \n- Result 1 (2022-10-25) Nate congratulates Joanna on finally seeing \"it\" on the big screen.  \n- Result 16 (2022-11-11) Nate congratulates Joanna on her script coming alive in a movie.  \n- Result 38 (2022-11-11) Joanna says an actor told her how much she liked her script.  \n- Result 28 (2022-",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.08,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.56
    },
    {
      "question": "What inspires Joanna to create drawings of her characters?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "visuals to help bring the characters alive in her head so she can write better",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for mentions of Joanna's inspiration for her drawings or characters.\n\n- Result 1 (Nate to Joanna, 2022-10-25): Nate asks Joanna what inspired her drawings.\n- Result 8 (Joanna to Nate, 2022-10-25): Joanna replies that she got ideas from everywhere: people she knows, things she saw, and her imagination. She finds it cool to see how an idea takes shape into a person with their own wants, worries, and wishes.\n- Result 10 (Nate to Joanna, 2022-10-25): Nate asks where she got ideas for her characters.\n- Result 26 (Joanna to Nate, 2022-10-25): Joanna says her favorite part is seeing characters she worked hard on come alive, feeling surreal.\n- Result 86 (Joanna to Nate, 2022-10-25): Joanna says the visuals of characters help bring them alive in her",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.59,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.08
    },
    {
      "question": "Where does Joanna get her ideas for the characters from?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "people she knows, things she saw, her imagination",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about Joanna's source of ideas for characters.  \n- Result 1: Nate asks Joanna where she got ideas for her characters.  \n- Result 5: Joanna replies she got ideas from everywhere: people she knows, things she saw, and her imagination.  \n- Result 22: Nate asks what inspired her drawings (likely related to characters).  \n- Result 65: Joanna says seeing her characters come alive was her favorite part, implying deep involvement in their creation.  \n\nStep 2: Synthesize the key direct answer from Joanna in Result 5, which is the clearest statement about her sources of ideas.\n\nFinal answer: Joanna gets her ideas for characters from people she knows, things she has seen, and her own imagination.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.41,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.24
    },
    {
      "question": "How did Joanna feel on October 25, 2022 about seeing her characters come alive on the big screen?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "surreal and cool",
      "generated_answer": "Step-by-step reasoning:\n\n1. The relevant date is October 25, 2022.\n2. Result 9 [2022-10-25T20:18:30] Joanna to Nate says: \"Seeing my characters I worked so hard on come alive was my favorite part. It felt like they jumped off the page and became real - it was totally surreal.\"\n3. Result 11 [2022-10-25T20:17:30] Joanna to Nate adds: \"It was an amazing experience! I'll never forget seeing all of the characters and dialogue I wrote being acted out - it was such a cool feeling. Having all the hard work and determination I put into writing pay off was definitely rewarding. I know this is the third time it's happened, but its just so awesome!\"\n4. These messages clearly express Joanna's positive and emotional reaction to seeing her characters come alive on screen, describing it as surreal, amazing, cool, and rewarding.\n\nFinal answer:  \n",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.06,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.2
    },
    {
      "question": "What type of diet do Nate's turtles have?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "combination of vegetables, fruits, and insects",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for mentions of what Nate's turtles eat.  \n- Result 1 (2022-10-25): Nate says they eat a combination of vegetables, fruits, and insects.  \n- Result 4 (2022-10-25): Joanna confirms the varied diet including insects.  \n- Result 32 (2022-10-25): Nate mentions they love eating fruit and get hyped about it.  \n- Result 34 (2022-10-25): Nate talks about watching them enjoy their favorite snacks.  \n\nStep 2: Confirm no contradictory information.  \n- No other excerpts contradict this varied diet.  \n\nFinal answer:  \nNate's turtles have a varied diet consisting of vegetables, fruits, and insects.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.1,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.2
    },
    {
      "question": "What ingredient did Nate use to make the ice cream lactose-free?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "coconut milk",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Nate making lactose-free or dairy-free ice cream.\n- Result 1: Nate says, \"Yep, I made it with coconut milk so it's lactose-free!\"\n- Result 4: Nate describes the recipe: \"I made it with coconut milk, vanilla extract, sugar, and a pinch of salt.\"\n- Result 19: Nate mentions \"Coconut milk ice cream is at the top of my list... Plus, it's dairy-free.\"\n- Result 40: Nate shows \"homemade coconut ice cream.\"\n\nStep 2: Confirm the ingredient that makes the ice cream lactose-free.\n- Multiple mentions confirm coconut milk is the key ingredient used by Nate to make the ice cream lactose-free.\n\nFinal answer: Nate used coconut milk to make the ice cream lactose-free.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.18,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.53
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Joanna find in old notebooks last week that prompted her to reflect on her progress as a writer?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "early writings",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant excerpt about Joanna finding something in old notebooks.\n- Result 7 [2022-11-04]: Joanna to Nate says, \"Last week (approximately October 28, 2022), I found these old notebooks with my early writings - it was cool to see how far I've come.\"\n\nStep 2: Understand what she found and why it prompted reflection.\n- She found her early writings in old notebooks.\n- This discovery made her reflect on her growth and progress as a writer.\n\nFinal answer:  \nJoanna found her early writings in old notebooks last week (around October 28, 2022), which prompted her to reflect on how far she has come as a writer.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.53,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.74
    },
    {
      "question": "What game is Nate currently playing and recommends to others on November 7, 2022?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "\"Xenoblade Chronicles\"",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the date of interest: November 7, 2022.\n\nStep 2: Look for messages around that date where Nate mentions a game he is playing or recommends.\n\nStep 3: On 2022-11-07T20:19:00 (Result 47), Nate says: \"Yeah, I love it. It's like my own little haven to escape into the virtual world.\"\n\nStep 4: On 2022-11-07T20:20:30 (Result 1), Joanna asks about Nate's favorite game.\n\nStep 5: On 2022-11-07T20:21:30 (Result 14), Joanna asks if the game is a Japanese series.\n\nStep 6: On 2022-11-07T20:22:00 (Result 58), Nate replies: \"Yes it is! I'm a big fan of Nintendo games, and I've actually been wanting to play this one for a while",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.76,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.45
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Joanna receive from her brother that brought back childhood memories?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "a handwritten letter",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for mentions of childhood memories and something Joanna received from her brother.\n\nStep 2: Result 14 shows Nate asking Joanna if a letter reminds her of her childhood: \"That letter is really awesome! Does it remind you of your childhood?\"\n\nStep 3: Result 1 and 3 mention childhood memories being powerful and taking us back to simpler times.\n\nStep 4: No other specific item from Joanna's brother is mentioned in the excerpts.\n\nStep 5: The letter is the only specific item linked to childhood memories in the conversation.\n\nFinal answer: Joanna received a letter from her brother that brought back childhood memories.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.69,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.6
    },
    {
      "question": "What is the type of game \"Xenoblade Chronicles\" that Nate is playing?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "fantasy RPG",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant excerpt about \"Xenoblade Chronicles.\"  \n- Result 1: Nate says he is playing \"Xenoblade Chronicles,\" calling it an awesome fantasy RPG.  \n- Result 3 and 7: Joanna confirms it is a Japanese game series, and Nate confirms he is a big fan of Nintendo games and wanted to play it because friends recommended it.  \n- Result 16 and 47: Nate mentions loving a series with adventures, magic, and great characters, which aligns with the fantasy RPG genre.\n\nStep 2: Confirm the genre from Nate's own words.  \n- In Result 1, Nate explicitly calls \"Xenoblade Chronicles\" a fantasy RPG.\n\nFinal answer:  \n\"Xenoblade Chronicles\" is a fantasy role-playing game (RPG).",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.91,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.81
    },
    {
      "question": "What dish did Nate make on 9 November, 2022?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Homemade coconut ice cream",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify messages around 9 November 2022 mentioning Nate making food.\n\n- Result 12 [2022-11-09T17:54:00] Nate to Joanna: Nate mentions trying out homemade coconut ice cream with sprinkles.\n- Result 18 [2022-11-11T00:11:00] Joanna to Nate: Joanna compliments the ice cream Nate made.\n- Result 9 [2022-11-11T00:12:00] Joanna to Nate: Joanna says the ice cream looks mouthwatering.\n- Result 87 [2022-11-11T00:11:30] Nate to Joanna: Nate offers a recipe to Joanna, likely related to the ice cream.\n\nStep 2: Confirm the dish Nate made on or around 9 November 2022.\n\n- Nate explicitly says on 2022-11-09 that he made homemade coconut ice cream with sprinkles.\n\nFinal answer:  \nNate made homemade coconut",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.25,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.95
    },
    {
      "question": "What project is Joanna working on in her notebook on November 9, 2022?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "A suspenseful thriller set in a small Midwestern town",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the date and context of the question: November 9, 2022.\n\nStep 2: Look for messages from or around November 9, 2022, where Joanna mentions working on a project or notebook.\n\n- Result 1 (2022-11-09): Nate asks Joanna what she is working on in her notebook.\n- Result 37 (2022-11-09): Joanna says she worked hard on another script, created a plan to get it made into a movie, and pitched it to producers on November 8, 2022.\n- Result 51 (2022-11-09): Joanna says she is working on a new project\u2014a suspenseful thriller set in a small Midwestern town.\n- Result 100 (2022-11-11): Joanna mentions an actor liked her script, which likely refers to the same script she pitched.\n\nStep 3: Synthesize the information:\n\n- On November 9, 2022",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.79,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.84
    },
    {
      "question": "What is Nate creating for YouTube on 9 November, 2022?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "gaming content",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the date in question: 9 November 2022.\n\nStep 2: Look for messages from or around that date mentioning Nate and YouTube.\n\nStep 3: Result 1 [2022-11-09T18:00:00] Nate to Joanna says: \"Yeah actually - creating gaming content for YouTube.\"\n\nStep 4: Result 10 [2022-11-09T18:01:30] Joanna to Nate encourages Nate about making videos and connecting with people about gaming.\n\nStep 5: Result 18 [2022-11-09T18:00:30] Joanna asks what inspired Nate to start making gaming videos.\n\nStep 6: Result 21 [2022-11-07T20:19:00] Nate says he loves it as his \"own little haven to escape into the virtual world,\" referring to gaming.\n\nConclusion: On 9 November 2022, Nate is creating gaming content for You",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.16,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.11
    },
    {
      "question": "What inspired Nate to start making gaming videos?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Love of gaming and connecting with others who enjoy it too",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about Nate starting gaming videos.  \n- Result 2 (2022-11-09): Nate says creating gaming content for YouTube is a cool way to entertain folks and satisfy his video game cravings when there are no tournaments.  \n- Result 19 (2022-11-09): Nate says he is a big fan of gaming videos and thought it would be fun to start making them himself, hoping to share his love of gaming and connect with others.  \n- Result 28 (2022-11-09): Joanna advises Nate to watch other people's videos first to understand what the audience likes, implying Nate is new to making videos.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the reasons Nate gave:  \n- He is a big fan of gaming videos.  \n- He wanted a fun way to share his love of gaming.  \n- Making videos helps him connect with others who enjoy gaming.  \n- It also satisfies his gaming cravings during downtime from tournaments.\n\nFinal",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.8,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.6
    },
    {
      "question": "What new content is Nate creating for YouTube?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Gaming videos",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Nate creating content for YouTube.\n- Result 1 (2022-11-09): Nate says he is creating gaming content for YouTube.\n- Result 72 (2022-11-09): Nate says he is a big fan of gaming videos and thought it would be fun to start making them himself to share his love of gaming and connect with others.\n\nStep 2: Confirm the type of content.\n- Both excerpts clearly state Nate is making gaming videos for YouTube.\n\nStep 3: Check for any other types of content Nate might be creating.\n- No other content types mentioned for YouTube; focus is on gaming videos.\n\nFinal answer:  \nNate is creating gaming content for YouTube, making videos to share his love of gaming and connect with others.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.54,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.46
    },
    {
      "question": "What advice does Joanna give to Nate about making YouTube videos?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Watch other people's videos to understand what the audience likes",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant excerpts where Joanna talks to Nate about making YouTube videos.\n\n- Result 1: Nate mentions creating gaming content for YouTube.\n- Result 2: Joanna advises Nate to watch other people's videos first to understand what the audience likes, so his videos don't flop.\n- Result 3: Joanna asks what inspired Nate to start making gaming videos.\n- Result 4 & 5: Nate and Joanna discuss his motivation and encouragement.\n\nStep 2: Extract the specific advice Joanna gives.\n\n- In Result 2, Joanna says: \"Make sure you watch other peoples videos first so you get a handle on what your audience likes! That way your videos don't flop when you post them.\"\n\nStep 3: Confirm no other advice is given.\n\n- No other excerpts provide additional advice about making YouTube videos.\n\nFinal answer: Joanna advises Nate to watch other people's videos first to understand what his audience likes, so his videos don't flop when he posts them.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.24,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.37
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Joanna take a picture of near Fort Wayne last summer?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Sunset",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant messages about the picture near Fort Wayne last summer.  \n- Result 1 (2022-11-09): Joanna to Nate says she took a picture on a hike last summer near Fort Wayne, describing the sunset and surrounding beauty.  \n- Result 8 (2022-11-09): Nate comments on the sunset pic and asks what inspired her to take it.  \n- Result 67 (2022-04-15): Nate mentions a sunset Joanna took and asks if there are more trips coming up.  \n- Result 40 (2022-04-15): Joanna mentions the sky was gorgeous on a hike.  \n\nStep 2: Synthesize the details.  \nJoanna took a picture of a sunset during a hike near Fort Wayne last summer, capturing the sunset and the natural beauty around it.\n\nFinal answer:  \nJoanna took a picture of a sunset and the surrounding natural beauty near Fort Wayne last summer during a hike.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.22,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.46
    },
    {
      "question": "What inspired Joanna to take a picture of the sunset in the field near Fort Wayne?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "The incredible sunset and surrounding beauty",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant excerpt about the sunset picture near Fort Wayne.  \n- Result 1: Joanna says she took the pic on a hike last summer near Fort Wayne and mentions the sunset and surrounding beauty were incredible.  \n- Result 2: Nate asks what inspired her to take the photo.  \n- Result 48: Nate comments that nature reminds us to appreciate beauty and moments like those stay with you.\n\nStep 2: Look for Joanna's explanation of her inspiration.  \n- In Result 1, Joanna highlights the incredible sunset and surrounding beauty as the reason for taking the photo.  \n- In Result 19 and 64, Joanna mentions nature inspires her and is calming, which aligns with her motivation to capture beautiful natural moments.\n\nStep 3: Synthesize the information.  \nJoanna was inspired to take the sunset photo because the incredible beauty of the sunset and the natural surroundings during her hike near Fort Wayne moved her to capture that moment.\n\nFinal answer:  \nJoanna",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.23,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.63
    },
    {
      "question": "Why did Nate get a third turtle?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "He saw another one at a pet store and wanted to get it",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Nate mentions on 2022-11-09 that the tank is big enough now for three turtles, so he figured why not get another one (Result 1).\n\nStep 2: Joanna expresses surprise that Nate got a third turtle this year and asks why (Result 13).\n\nStep 3: Nate replies that he got the third turtle because the tank could now accommodate three, implying the increased space was the reason (Result 1).\n\nStep 4: Nate also refers to turtles bringing him joy and peace, suggesting emotional reasons for expanding his turtle family (Results 1, 81).\n\nFinal answer: Nate got a third turtle because his tank was big enough to house three, so he decided to add another for more joy and companionship.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.09,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.81
    },
    {
      "question": "What does Nate want to do when he goes over to Joanna's place?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Watch one of Joanna's movies together or go to the park",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for any messages where Nate talks about going to Joanna's place or doing something together.\n\nStep 2: In Result 13 (2022-05-12), Nate says to Joanna: \"Hey, we should go together sometime, don't you think? Maybe I'll start to think of a drama myself and publish my own screenplay.\"\n\nStep 3: This suggests Nate wants to go somewhere with Joanna, possibly related to drama or creative work.\n\nStep 4: No other direct mention of Nate going to Joanna's place or what he wants to do there is found.\n\nStep 5: The closest relevant detail is that Nate wants to go together with Joanna (likely to an event or activity) and is inspired to start thinking about writing a drama.\n\nFinal answer: Nate wants to go somewhere together with Joanna, possibly to an event or activity related to drama, and is considering starting to write his own screenplay.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.74,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.38
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Nate take to the beach in Tampa?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "turtles",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for mentions of Tampa and the beach in the context.  \nStep 2: Result 1 from 2022-11-11T00:08:30 shows Nate saying: \"I took my turtles to the beach in Tampa yesterday (approximately November 10, 2022)!\"  \nStep 3: This clearly states what Nate took to the beach.\n\nFinal answer: Nate took his turtles to the beach in Tampa.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.83,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.49
    },
    {
      "question": "What does Nate love most about having turtles?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "They make him feel calm and don't require much looking after",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts where Nate talks about what he loves about having turtles.\n\n- [Result 5] Nate says: \"I'm not sure I'll ever understand why watching my turtles slowly walk around makes me so happy. But I'm very glad it does.\"\n- [Result 8] Nate says: \"Yeah, turtles are like zen masters! They always remind me to slow down and appreciate the small things in life.\"\n- [Result 16] Joanna asks Nate what he loves most about having turtles.\n- [Result 17] Nate responds: \"They always bring me peace in the craziness of life.\"\n- [Result 75] Nate says: \"I really love having them around. They're so cool and they make me feel calm. Plus, they don't require much looking after, which is great. I love seeing them soaking in the sun like this.\"\n- [Result 38] Nate says: \"Having them around brings me joy and they make great companions.\"\n- [",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.72,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.62
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Nate share a photo of as a part of his experimentation in November 2022?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "colorful bowls of coconut milk ice cream",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the timeframe: November 2022.\n\nStep 2: Look for mentions of Nate sharing photos related to experimentation or new things in November 2022.\n\nStep 3: Result 75 (2022-11-09T17:54:00) shows Nate saying: \"My game tournament got pushed back, so I tried out some cooking. Look at this homemade coconut ice cream! The sprinkles kinda changed the color this time around.\" This indicates Nate shared a photo of homemade coconut ice cream as part of his cooking experimentation.\n\nStep 4: Result 83 (2022-11-04T16:03:30) Nate invites Joanna to try something he made \"just made it yesterday (approximately November 03, 2022)\" which is likely related to his cooking experiments.\n\nStep 5: No other November 2022 results show Nate sharing photos of other experiments.\n\nFinal answer: Nate shared a photo of homemade coconut ice cream as part of",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-42",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.09,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.42
    },
    {
      "question": "what are John's goals with regards to his basketball career?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "improve shooting percentage, win a championship",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify explicit mentions of John's basketball goals.\n\n- Result 4 (2023-08-11): John says winning a championship is his number one goal and also wants to make a difference off the court through charity or inspiring people.\n- Result 2 (2023-09-21): John focuses on better shooting, making more impact on the court, being a consistent performer, helping his team, and building his brand with endorsements.\n- Result 22 (2023-05-21): John aims to improve his shooting percentage.\n- Result 79 (2023-07-16): John scored 40 points in a game, indicating a focus on performance improvement.\n- Result 14 (2023-12-26): John organized a basketball camp for kids, showing his off-court goal of inspiring youth.\n- Result 60 (2023-12-26): John works on supporting youth sports and fighting for fair chances in sports for underserved communities.\n- Result",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.58,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.88
    },
    {
      "question": "What are John's goals for his career that are not related to his basketball skills?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "get endorsements, build his brand, do charity work",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of John's non-basketball career goals in the excerpts.\n\n- Result 3 (2023-09-21): John mentions focusing on endorsements and building his brand, thinking about life after basketball.\n- Result 5 (2023-08-11): John wants to make a difference off the court through charity or inspiring people.\n- Result 26 (2023-07-16): John uses his contacts and marketing skills to get endorsements.\n- Result 49 (2023-12-26): John is working on supporting youth sports and fighting for fair chances in sports for underserved communities.\n- Result 60 (2024-01-07): John held a benefit basketball game around December 31, 2023.\n- Result 22 (2023-10-17): John finds being a role model for young athletes fulfilling.\n- Result 46, 61 (2023-10-17): John mentors younger players, providing advice and support",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.96,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.0
    },
    {
      "question": "What items does John collect?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "sneakers, fantasy movie DVDs, jerseys",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of John collecting items.\n- Result 3: John says, \"I like to collect jerseys.\"\n- Result 26: John mentions teammates gave him a signed item as a sign of friendship.\n- Result 80: John talks about his shoes having stories and symbolizing resilience and achievements.\n\nStep 2: Confirm the types of items John collects.\n- Jerseys are explicitly mentioned as a collection.\n- Shoes are described with sentimental value and stories, implying a collection or at least a meaningful set.\n- Signed items from teammates are mentioned but not explicitly called a collection.\n\nFinal answer: John collects jerseys and has a meaningful collection of shoes.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.08,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.13
    },
    {
      "question": "Would Tim enjoy reading books by C. S. Lewis or John Greene?",
      "category": 3,
      "gold_answer": "C. S.Lewis",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify Tim's favorite genres and authors from the context.  \n- Tim enjoys fantasy novels (Results 16, 29, 45, 53, 56).  \n- He admires authors like J.K. Rowling (Result 9, 75) and Patrick Rothfuss (Results 20, 21, 45, 53).  \n- He also likes books on personal development and mindset (Results 1, 54).  \n\nStep 2: Consider the styles of C. S. Lewis and John Green.  \n- C. S. Lewis is known for fantasy (The Chronicles of Narnia), which aligns with Tim's fantasy interest.  \n- John Green writes contemporary young adult fiction, often with emotional and personal growth themes, which could align with Tim's interest in personal development.  \n\nStep 3: Look for any direct mentions or hints about these authors.  \n- No direct mention of C. S. Lewis or John Green in the",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.99,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.9
    },
    {
      "question": "What books has Tim read?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Harry Potter, Game of Thrones, the Name of the Wind, The Alchemist, The Hobbit, A Dance with Dragons, and the Wheel of Time.",
      "generated_answer": "Step-by-step reasoning:\n\n1. Tim has read and written about different fantasy novels (Result 9, 56).\n2. Tim is currently reading \"The Name of the Wind\" by Patrick Rothfuss (Result 13).\n3. Tim has read the \"Game of Thrones\" (GoT) series (Result 19, 24, 70).\n4. Tim mentions Harry Potter as his favorite book (Result 42).\n5. Tim has read \"The Hobbit\" and other popular fantasy series (Result 39, 59).\n6. Tim has read \"The Alchemist\" (Result 65).\n7. Tim has read works by J.K. Rowling (Result 37, 44).\n8. Tim has read a book about how small changes can make big differences, which impacted him around November 14, 2023 (Result 53).\n9. Tim has read travel stories from around the world (Result 68).\n10. Tim has read a fantasy",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.8,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.73
    },
    {
      "question": "Based on Tim's collections, what is a shop that he would enjoy visiting in New York city?",
      "category": 3,
      "gold_answer": "House of MinaLima",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify Tim's collections and interests from the context.  \n- Tim has a notable book collection (Result 1, 16, 51, 77, 98).  \n- He also enjoys fantasy books, including Harry Potter and Game of Thrones (Results 16, 40, 92).  \n- Tim is interested in places related to Harry Potter (Result 26, 59).  \n- Tim also enjoys movies and creative inspirations from books (Results 91, 98).  \n\nStep 2: Consider what kind of shop in NYC would align with Tim's interests.  \n- Since Tim loves books, especially fantasy and Harry Potter, a bookstore or a shop related to Harry Potter or fantasy literature would be ideal.  \n- There is no direct mention of a specific shop in NYC in the excerpts, but given Tim's interests, a bookstore specializing in fantasy or a Harry Potter-themed shop would be a good fit.  \n\nStep 3: Check if any specific",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.85,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.05
    },
    {
      "question": "In which month's game did John achieve a career-high score in points?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "June 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of John achieving a career-high in points.  \n- Result 1 (2023-07-16): John says last week (around July 09, 2023) he scored 40 points, his highest ever.  \n- Result 12 (2023-12-11): John mentions a career-high in assists last Friday (around December 08, 2023), but this is assists, not points.\n\nStep 2: Confirm the career-high in points is the 40 points scored around July 09, 2023.  \nNo other mention of a higher points total is found.\n\nFinal answer:  \nJohn achieved his career-high points in a game in July 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.99,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.68
    },
    {
      "question": "Which geographical locations has Tim been to?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "California, London, the Smoky Mountains",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of places Tim has visited from the context.\n\n- Result 34 (2023-05-21): Tim mentions going to a place in London a few years ago, describing it like walking into a Harry Potter movie and going on a tour.\n- Result 67 (2024-01-07): Tim says he wants to visit The Cliffs of Moher, but this is a future plan, not a past visit.\n- Result 38 (2024-01-02): Tim is chatting about Italy being on his list of places to visit, implying he has not been there yet.\n- Result 74 (2023-08-21): Tim shares a family photo from a special day but no location mentioned.\n- No other explicit mentions of Tim visiting specific geographical locations.\n\nStep 2: Confirm no other locations are attributed to Tim.\n\n- Tim talks about travel clubs and globetrotting (Result 20, 96), but no specific places visited",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.86,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.14
    },
    {
      "question": "Which outdoor gear company likely signed up John for an endorsement deal?",
      "category": 3,
      "gold_answer": "Under Armour",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of outdoor gear endorsement deals by John.  \n- Result 7 (2023-12-19): John says he got an amazing deal with a renowned outdoor gear company around December 12, 2023.  \n- Result 11 (2023-12-19): John mentions he got some awesome hiking stuff and outdoor gear, and the photoshoot was in a forest.  \n\nStep 2: Check if the company name is explicitly mentioned.  \n- No direct company name for the outdoor gear deal is given in any excerpt.  \n\nStep 3: Consider the context of other endorsements.  \n- Earlier, John signed deals with Nike and is in talks with Gatorade (Results 4, 53).  \n- No other brand names for outdoor gear are mentioned.  \n\nStep 4: Since no specific outdoor gear company name is given, but the deal is described as \"renowned,\" it is likely a well-known outdoor brand, but the exact",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.36,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.87
    },
    {
      "question": "Which endorsement deals has John been offered?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "basketball shoes and gear deal with Nike, potential sponsorship with Gatorade, Moxie a popular beverage company, outdoor gear company",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of endorsement deals John has been offered or signed.\n\n- Result 5 (2023-07-16): John says he signed Nike for a basketball shoe and gear deal and is in talks with Gatorade about a potential sponsorship.\n- Result 11 (2024-01-12): John mentions getting an endorsement with a popular beverage company (likely Gatorade or another).\n- Result 8 (2023-12-06): John mentions having some cool endorsement deals money-wise.\n- Result 1 (2023-07-16): John says he has talked to some big names for endorsements.\n- Result 82 (2023-07-16): Tim congratulates John on deals with Nike and Gatorade.\n\nStep 2: Summarize the endorsements.\n\n- Nike (signed for basketball shoe and gear)\n- Gatorade (in talks for sponsorship)\n- A popular beverage company endorsement signed around early January 2024 (could be",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.85,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.86
    },
    {
      "question": "When was John in Seattle for a game?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "early August, 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Seattle and timing related to John\u2019s game there.\n\n- Result 3 (2023-07-16): John says, \"It's Seattle, I'm stoked for my game there next month!\" This implies the game in Seattle is expected around mid-August 2023.\n\n- Result 2 (2023-07-16): John talks about loving the city and the fans, indicating he is currently there or recently was.\n\nStep 2: Confirm if there is any mention of the game happening or after the game.\n\n- No direct message states the exact date of the game or a follow-up after the game in Seattle.\n\nStep 3: Synthesize the information.\n\n- Since on July 16, 2023, John says the game is \"next month,\" the game in Seattle likely took place in August 2023.\n\nFinal answer: John was in Seattle for a game in August 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.83,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.27
    },
    {
      "question": "What sports does John like besides basketball?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "surfing",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Review all excerpts for mentions of sports other than basketball that John likes or participates in.\n\nStep 2: Most of the conversation centers on basketball, John's career, training, and experiences.\n\nStep 3: There is no mention of John playing or liking any other sports besides basketball.\n\nStep 4: Tim mentions not being on a sports team and liking reading and fantasy novels (Result 17), but that is about Tim, not John.\n\nStep 5: No other sports are referenced as John's interests or activities.\n\nFinal answer:  \nJohn does not mention liking any sports besides basketball.",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.79,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.72
    },
    {
      "question": "What year did John start surfing?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "2018",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify when John mentioned how long he has been surfing.  \nFrom [Result 1] dated 2023-07-16, John says: \"I started surfing five years ago.\"\n\nStep 2: Calculate the year he started surfing based on the message date.  \nThe message is from mid-2023, so subtracting 5 years from 2023 gives 2018.\n\nFinal answer: John started surfing in 2018.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.0,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.06
    },
    {
      "question": "What does Tim do to escape reality?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Read fantasy books.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Tim's activities related to escaping reality.\n\n- Result 1 (2023-10-02): Tim says books fire up his imagination and take him to alternate realities, serving as his escape from reality.\n- Result 10 (2023-08-09): Tim mentions reading a fantasy book that captivates him and transports him to another world.\n- Result 25 (2023-10-21): Tim enjoys going on road trips with friends and family, exploring, hiking, playing board games, and curling up with a good book to escape reality.\n- Result 28 (2023-12-26): Tim loves getting lost in good books, describing the series as a magical world to escape to.\n- Result 31 (2024-01-02): Tim mentions having a collection of books that take him to another world.\n- Result 36 (2023-11-11): Tim says escaping through books/movies is like entering another world",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 4.12,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.46
    },
    {
      "question": "What kind of writing does Tim do?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "comments on favorite books in a fantasy literature forum, articles on fantasy novels, studying characters, themes, and making book recommendations, writing a fantasy novel",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about Tim's writing.\n\n- [Result 21] (2023-08-02): Tim says he is writing articles about fantasy novels for an online magazine.\n- [Result 7] (2023-08-02): Tim says he writes about different fantasy novels, studying characters, themes, and making book recommendations.\n- [Result 50] (2023-10-21): John asks Tim about his source of inspiration for stories, implying Tim writes stories as well.\n- [Result 46] (2023-11-06): Tim mentions having a writing issue with a plot twist, indicating he also writes fiction or creative writing.\n- [Result 54] (2023-12-11): Tim did an analysis on a series for his English lit class, showing academic writing.\n- [Result 73] (2023-10-02): Tim shares a bookshelf of favorite fantasy novels, linking to his interest in fantasy writing",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.53,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.28
    },
    {
      "question": "Who is Anthony?",
      "category": 3,
      "gold_answer": "likely John's friend, colleague or family",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Review all excerpts for any mention of \"Anthony.\"  \nStep 2: No direct mention of the name \"Anthony\" appears in any of the conversation excerpts.  \nStep 3: Check if \"Anthony\" could be a nickname or implied reference to a favorite player or person discussed. The closest references to favorite players or inspiring figures are about Aragorn (a fictional character), a favorite basketball player with an epic block in the 2016 Finals (likely Draymond Green), and mentions of endorsements and basketball career, but no explicit naming of \"Anthony.\"  \nStep 4: Since no direct or indirect reference to \"Anthony\" is found in the context, there is no information about who Anthony is.\n\nFinal answer: Not enough information.",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.12,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.05
    },
    {
      "question": "After how many weeks did Tim reconnect with the fellow Harry Potter fan from California?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "three weeks",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify when Tim first mentioned connecting with the Harry Potter fan in California.  \n- Result 25 [2023-07-16]: Tim says, \"Last week (approximately July 09, 2023), I had a nice chat with a Harry Potter fan in California.\"\n\nStep 2: Identify when Tim mentioned reconnecting with the same or another Harry Potter fan in California.  \n- Result 1 [2023-08-09]: Tim says, \"Just skyped with that Harry Potter fan I met in CA and had a great time.\"\n\nStep 3: Calculate the time between the initial chat and the Skype reconnect.  \n- Initial chat: ~July 09, 2023  \n- Skype reconnect: August 09, 2023  \n- Time difference: About 4 weeks (July 9 to August 9)\n\nFinal answer: Tim reconnected with the Harry Potter fan from California about 4 weeks after their initial chat.",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.49,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.99
    },
    {
      "question": "How many games has John mentioned winning?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "6",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify all mentions of John winning games.\n\n- Result 1 (2023-12-16): John says \"Winning was such a thrill.\"\n- Result 15 (2023-12-16): John says \"Thanks! We won! It was really close.\"\n- Result 20 (2023-12-16): John mentions a close win last week (approx. Dec 9, 2023).\n- Result 27 (2023-12-08): John says \"Winning felt amazing.\"\n- Result 69 (2023-08-09): John mentions winning a crazy intense game last week (approx. Aug 2, 2023).\n- Result 16 (2023-07-16): John says \"We pulled off a tough win!\"\n- Result 13 (2023-07-16): John scored 40 points last week (approx. July 9, 2023) and it \"feels like all my hard",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.54,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.9
    },
    {
      "question": "What authors has Tim read books from?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "J.K. Rowling, R.R. Martin, Patrick Rothfuss, Paulo Coelho, and J. R. R. Tolkien.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of authors Tim has read or talked about.\n\n- Result 13: Tim is reading \"The Name of the Wind\" by Patrick Rothfuss.\n- Result 18: Tim praises Patrick Rothfuss's work.\n- Result 19: Tim admires J.K. Rowling and her writing style.\n- Result 23: Tim has read the Game of Thrones (GoT) series by George R. R. Martin.\n- Result 34: Tim has been reading J.K. Rowling's works for a long time.\n- Result 49: Tim says Harry Potter (by J.K. Rowling) is his favorite book.\n- Result 42: Tim mentions LOTR (The Lord of the Rings) by J.R.R. Tolkien as a fantasy book he enjoys.\n- Result 91: John mentions reading \"Dune\" by Frank Herbert and asks Tim about the last book that moved him, implying Tim may have read Frank Herbert, but no direct confirmation",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.03,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.54
    },
    {
      "question": "What is a prominent charity organization that John might want to work with and why?",
      "category": 3,
      "gold_answer": "Good Sports, because they work with Nike, Gatorade, and Under Armour and they aim toprovide youth sports opportunities for kids ages 3-18 in high-need communities.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify any mention of charity or organizations John is involved with or interested in.\n\n- Result 5 (2023-08-11): John says he is teaming up with a local organization that helps disadvantaged kids with sports and school.\n- Result 3 (2023-09-21): John talks about starting a foundation and doing charity work to make a positive difference.\n- Result 50 (2023-12-26): John organized a basketball camp for kids in his hometown last summer, showing his focus on youth and sports.\n- Result 6 (2023-12-26): John speaks at charity events and uses his influence to help causes he believes in.\n\nStep 2: Look for any specific charity names or types.\n\n- No specific charity names are mentioned.\n- The focus is on disadvantaged kids, sports, education, and community impact.\n\nStep 3: Consider what kind of prominent charity aligns with these interests.\n\n- A charity focused on youth development through sports",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.65,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.77
    },
    {
      "question": "Which city was John in before traveling to Chicago?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "Seattle",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify when John mentioned being in Chicago.  \n- Result 1 (2023-08-11) John says: \"I was in Chicago, it was awesome!\"\n\nStep 2: Look for any mention of where John was before Chicago.  \n- Result 38 (2023-08-11) John says: \"Hey Tim, sorry I missed you. Been a crazy few days. Took a trip to a new place - it's been amazing. Love the energy there.\" This is likely about Chicago since it is the same date as Result 1.\n\nStep 3: Check earlier messages for any city John was in before August 11, 2023.  \n- Result 37 (2023-07-16) John talks about a city with energy, diversity, seafood, and fans at games. This is likely Seattle (confirmed by Result 98 where Tim asks John what he loves about Seattle).  \n- No other city is mentioned between July 16",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.85,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.67
    },
    {
      "question": "Which US cities does John mention visiting to Tim?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Seattle, Chicago, New York",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify all mentions of US cities in the conversation excerpts.\n\n- Result 4 (2023-08-26): John mentions a trip to New York City and shares a picture from there.\n- Result 10 (2023-08-11): John says he was in Chicago and describes the experience.\n- Result 11 (2023-08-26): John praises NYC again, emphasizing its culture and food.\n- Result 18 (2023-07-16): John talks about loving the energy, diversity, and food of a city, mentioning local seafood and fan support at games. This is likely Seattle, as confirmed in Result 85 (2023-07-16) where John explicitly says \"It's Seattle, I'm stoked for my game there next month! It's one of my favorite cities to explore.\"\n- Result 85 (2023-07-16): John explicitly mentions Seattle as a favorite city to explore.\n\nStep 2: Summarize",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.96,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.92
    },
    {
      "question": "When did John meet with his teammates after returning from Chicago?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "August 15, 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: John mentioned being in Chicago in message [Result 3] dated 2023-08-11.\n\nStep 2: John said he met back up with his teammates on the 15th after his trip in [Result 5] dated 2023-08-17, indicating the meetup was on August 15, 2023.\n\nFinal answer: John met with his teammates on August 15, 2023, after returning from Chicago.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.06,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.86
    },
    {
      "question": "When is Tim attending a book conference?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "September 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify any mention of Tim attending a book conference.  \n- In [Result 1] dated 2023-08-17, Tim says he is hoping to attend a book conference \"next month,\" which would be September 2023.\n\nStep 2: Check for any follow-up or confirmation about the conference attendance.  \n- No direct confirmation of the exact date of the conference is given, but the timing \"next month\" from August 17, 2023, clearly points to September 2023.\n\nFinal answer:  \nTim is attending a book conference in September 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.21,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.65
    },
    {
      "question": "Where was John between August 11 and August 15 2023?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "Chicago",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify messages around the date range August 11 to August 15, 2023.\n\n- Result 37 [2023-08-11T13:08:00] John to Tim: \"Hey Tim, sorry I missed you. Been a crazy few days. Took a trip to a new place - it's been amazing. Love the energy there.\"\n- Result 75 [2023-08-11T13:18:30] Tim to John: \"Glad I could help. You've got this!\"\n- Result 31 [2023-08-26T18:59:30] John to Tim: \"Last week (approximately August 19, 2023) I visited home and caught up with my family and old friends.\"\n\nStep 2: From Result 37, on August 11, John mentions he took a trip to a new place and loved the energy there, but does not specify where.\n\nStep 3: From Result 31",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.2,
      "judge_latency_s": 3.04
    },
    {
      "question": "What similar sports collectible do Tim and John own?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "signed basketball",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify any mentions of collectibles owned by John and Tim.\n\n- Result 3: John mentions collecting jerseys.\n- Result 20: Tim mentions owning a basketball signed by his favorite player, calling it his prized possession.\n- Result 24: John mentions a signed item from teammates as a sign of friendship.\n- Result 40: John shows a photo of a signed item from teammates.\n- Result 82: Tim asks John about stories behind his shoes.\n- Result 57: John talks about his lucky basketball shoes with many stories.\n- Result 95: John refers to his lucky basketball shoes as having stories.\n\nStep 2: Look for a collectible that both Tim and John own and that is similar.\n\n- Tim owns a signed basketball (Result 20).\n- John collects jerseys (Result 3).\n- John also has basketball shoes with sentimental value (Results 57, 95).\n- John has a signed item from teammates (Results 24, 40), but",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.65,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.74
    },
    {
      "question": "Which TV series does Tim mention watching?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "That, Wheel of Time",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of TV series by Tim in the context.\n\n- Result 6 (2023-12-08): Tim mentions \"Just the GoT series.\"\n- Result 20 (2023-11-11): Tim mentions \"That\" as one of his favorite fantasy shows.\n- Result 46 (2023-11-11): John confirms he saw \"That\" series.\n- Result 2 and 4 (2023-12-26): Tim talks about a new fantasy TV series coming out next month called \"The Wheel of Time.\"\n- Result 13 (2023-12-26): Tim expresses excitement about checking out \"The Wheel of Time\" series.\n\nStep 2: Summarize the TV series Tim mentions watching:\n- Game of Thrones (GoT)\n- \"That\" (a fantasy show, exact title not specified)\n- The Wheel of Time (upcoming/new series)\n\nFinal answer: Tim mentions watching the Game of Thrones series",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        true,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.57,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.66
    },
    {
      "question": "Which popular time management technique does Tim use to prepare for exams?",
      "category": 3,
      "gold_answer": "Pomodoro technique",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Tim's study or exam preparation methods in the context.\n\nStep 2: In Result 1 (2023-11-16), Tim says: \"I like breaking up my studying into smaller parts. 25 minutes on, then 5 minutes off for something fun.\" This is a clear description of the Pomodoro Technique, a popular time management method involving 25-minute focused work sessions followed by short breaks.\n\nStep 3: No other study techniques mentioned by Tim contradict or add to this.\n\nFinal answer: Tim uses the Pomodoro Technique, breaking study time into 25-minute focused sessions followed by 5-minute breaks.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.72,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.14
    },
    {
      "question": "Which popular music composer's tunes does Tim enjoy playing on the piano?",
      "category": 3,
      "gold_answer": "John Williams",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Tim playing piano and favorite songs.\n\n- Result 1 and 2 (2023-08-21): Tim says he loves playing different songs on the piano, especially a theme from a movie he enjoys that brings back memories.\n- Result 10 and 18: John asks about the film and memories; John also mentions loving the first movie and having the whole collection, implying the movie theme Tim plays is from a well-known film series.\n\nStep 2: Look for any mention of a composer or specific music style related to the movie theme.\n\n- No direct mention of the composer's name in the excerpts.\n- However, the movie theme is described as \"magical\" and a \"collection,\" which strongly suggests a famous film series with iconic music.\n\nStep 3: Check for any indirect clues about the movie or composer.\n\n- Result 45: Tim mentions loving \"The Santa Clause,\" but that is a holiday movie, unlikely the piano theme.\n-",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.83,
      "judge_latency_s": 3.29
    },
    {
      "question": "What schools did John play basketball in and how many years was he with his team during high school?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Middle school, high school, and college and he was with his high school team for 4 years.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of John's basketball history in school.\n- Result 1: John says he played basketball through middle and high school before earning a college scholarship.\n- Result 4: John says he and his teammate were teammates for four years in high school.\n\nStep 2: Check if specific school names are mentioned.\n- No specific middle school, high school, or college names are given in the excerpts.\n\nStep 3: Summarize the information.\n- John played basketball in middle school, high school, and college.\n- He was with his high school team for four years.\n\nFinal answer: John played basketball through middle school, high school, and college, and he was on his high school team for four years. No specific school names were mentioned.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.77,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.1
    },
    {
      "question": "Which cities has John been to?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Seattle, Chicago, New York, and Paris.",
      "generated_answer": "Step-by-step reasoning:\n\n1. New York City:  \n- [Result 4] John mentions a trip to New York City and shares a picture.  \n- [Results 8, 9, 30, 41, 56] Tim and John discuss NYC as an amazing city to visit.\n\n2. Chicago:  \n- [Result 11] John says he was in Chicago and describes the experience.\n\n3. European coastline (general region):  \n- [Result 15] John mentions a road trip on the European coastline with his wife.\n\n4. Italy:  \n- [Results 36, 49, 50] John talks about a trip to Italy in December 2023.\n\n5. Seattle:  \n- [Result 100] John says he is stoked for a game in Seattle next month and calls it one of his favorite cities.\n\n6. Camping in the mountains (not a city, but a location):  \n- [Results 26, 29,",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.26,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.66
    },
    {
      "question": "What month did Tim plan on going to Universal Studios?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "September, 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant messages about Universal Studios and Tim's plans.\n\n- Result 1 (2023-08-31): John asks Tim if he has been to Universal Studios.\n- Result 12 (2023-08-31): Tim says, \"Planning a trip there next month.\"\n- Result 48 (2023-08-31): Tim says, \"Nope, but it's my first time going. I'm super stoked for the Harry Potter stuff.\"\n\nStep 2: Determine the date of the message where Tim says he is planning a trip next month.\n\n- The message is dated 2023-08-31.\n- \"Next month\" after August 2023 is September 2023.\n\nStep 3: Confirm no other conflicting information.\n\n- No other messages contradict this plan.\n\nFinal answer: Tim planned on going to Universal Studios in September 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.31,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.92
    },
    {
      "question": "Which US states might Tim be in during September 2023 based on his plans of visiting Universal Studios?",
      "category": 3,
      "gold_answer": "California or Florida",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify Tim's plans related to Universal Studios in September 2023.\n\n- From [Result 1] (2023-08-31), John asks Tim if he has been to Universal Studios.\n- From [Result 98] (2023-08-31), Tim says it's his first time going and he's excited about the Harry Potter stuff there.\n\nStep 2: Determine the location of Universal Studios Tim is likely visiting.\n\n- Universal Studios has major locations in California (Universal Studios Hollywood) and Florida (Universal Studios Orlando).\n- Tim mentions adding NYC to his travel list ([Result 4], 2023-08-26), but that is unrelated to Universal Studios.\n- No direct mention of Florida or California in the context, but Tim is excited about Harry Potter attractions, which are prominent in both Universal Studios Hollywood and Orlando.\n\nStep 3: Check for any other location clues around September 2023.\n\n- No direct mention of Tim being in California or Florida",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.63,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.91
    },
    {
      "question": "When does John plan on traveling with his team on a team trip?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "October, 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of a team trip.\n- Result 1 (2023-09-21): John says, \"We're planning to take a team trip next month to explore a new city and have some fun.\"\n- Result 21 (2023-09-21): John says, \"We're still deciding on the destination.\"\n\nStep 2: Determine the date of the message and the referenced \"next month.\"\n- The message is dated September 21, 2023.\n- \"Next month\" from September 21, 2023, is October 2023.\n\nStep 3: Confirm no other conflicting or more specific dates are given.\n- No other specific dates for the team trip are mentioned.\n- The trip is planned for the month following September 21, 2023.\n\nFinal answer:  \nJohn plans to travel with his team on a trip in October 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.14,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.6
    },
    {
      "question": "What could John do after his basketball career?",
      "category": 3,
      "gold_answer": "become a basketball coach since he likes giving back and leadership",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of John's plans or thoughts about life after basketball.  \n- In Result 2 (2023-09-21), John says he is focusing on better shooting and making an impact on the court, but also looking into endorsements and building his brand, emphasizing the importance of thinking about life after basketball.  \n- In Result 91 (2023-12-26), John mentions starting seminars to help people with sports and marketing, indicating a possible post-career path.  \n- In Result 39 (2023-12-26), John talks about supporting youth sports and fighting for fair chances in sports for underserved communities, showing interest in community work.  \n- In Result 25 (2023-10-17), John mentions mentoring younger players, which could continue after his playing career.  \n- In Result 21 and 77 (early January 2024), John organized a benefit basketball game for charity, showing involvement in charitable activities.  \n\nStep 2",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.06,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.03
    },
    {
      "question": "What outdoor activities does John enjoy?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Hiking, surfing",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of outdoor activities John enjoys from the excerpts.\n\n- Result 2, 37, 43, 60: John went camping in the mountains and enjoyed the nature, fresh air, and peacefulness.\n- Result 6, 59, 96: John did a photoshoot in a forest and went hiking.\n- Result 7, 18, 39, 66: John enjoys being out in the water, surfing, and riding waves.\n- Result 20: John organized a basketball camp for kids.\n- Result 17, 27: John and his wife went on a road trip along the European coastline.\n- Result 19: After an activity (likely surfing or sports), they celebrated at a restaurant.\n- Result 33, 49: John is part of a hiking club and enjoys hiking.\n- Result 22: John found a soothing river spot while hiking.\n- Result 10: John enjoys attending games (likely basketball) and",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.75,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.84
    },
    {
      "question": "Who is Tim and John's favorite basketball player?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "LeBron James",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of favorite basketball players in the conversation.\n\n- Result 41 (Tim to John): \"The Wolves are solid and LeBron's skills and leadership are amazing.\"\n- Result 48 (John to Tim): \"Thanks! The Wolves are my team for sure. And LeBron is the man - love his skills and leadership.\"\n- Result 27 (John to Tim): \"I really admire his work ethic and dedication to the game, such an inspiration.\" (In context with LeBron)\n- Result 38 (John to Tim): \"LeBron's moments of determination and heart are incredible.\"\n- Result 99 (Tim to John): \"I just love watching LeBron. There was this Finals game a few years back with an epic block...\"\n\nStep 2: Confirm that both Tim and John admire LeBron.\n\n- Both explicitly mention LeBron as their favorite player.\n- They discuss meeting him, watching him play, and his inspiring qualities.\n\nFinal answer:  \n",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.77,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.93
    },
    {
      "question": "Which week did Tim visit the UK for the Harry Potter Conference?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "The week before October 13th, 2023.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant excerpt about Tim's visit to the UK for the Harry Potter conference.\n\n- Result 2 [2023-10-13]: Tim to John says, \"Last week (approximately October 06, 2023) I went to a Harry Potter conference in the UK.\"\n\nStep 2: Confirm the date of the message and the timing of the event.\n\n- The message is dated 2023-10-13.\n- \"Last week\" from October 13, 2023, would be the week starting Monday, October 2, 2023, to Sunday, October 8, 2023.\n\nStep 3: Conclude the week Tim visited the UK.\n\n- Tim visited the UK for the Harry Potter conference during the week of October 2 to October 8, 2023.\n\nFinal answer:  \nTim visited the UK for the Harry Potter conference during the week of October 2 to October 8, 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.91,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.7
    },
    {
      "question": "which country has Tim visited most frequently in his travels?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "UK",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Tim's travels and locations he has visited.\n\n- Result 16 (2023-05-21): Tim mentions going to a place in London a few years ago.\n- Result 60 (2023-08-26): Tim expresses interest in visiting NYC, but no indication he has been there yet.\n- Result 39 (2023-12-06): Tim mentions joining a travel club and learning new skills, no specific country.\n- Result 56 (2024-01-02): Tim joined a group of globetrotters, no specific country.\n- Result 75 (2024-01-07): Tim wants to visit The Cliffs of Moher (Ireland), but no indication he has been there.\n- Result 42 (2024-01-02): Tim asks if John has been to Paris, France, but no mention of Tim visiting.\n- Result 66 (2024-01-12): Tim responds positively",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.8,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.55
    },
    {
      "question": "What year did Tim go to the Smoky Mountains?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "2022",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant excerpt about Tim's trip to the Smoky Mountains.  \n- Result 3 [2023-10-17]: Tim to John: \"I snapped that pic on my trip to the Smoky Mountains last year (approximately October 17, 2022).\"\n\nStep 2: The message is dated October 17, 2023, and Tim says the trip was \"last year,\" which means the trip was in 2022.\n\nFinal answer: Tim went to the Smoky Mountains in 2022.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.94,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.82
    },
    {
      "question": "Has Tim been to North Carolina and/or Tennesee states in the US?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "Yes",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Review all excerpts for any mention of Tim visiting North Carolina or Tennessee.\n\nStep 2: The conversations mention Tim traveling to London, joining globetrotters, planning to visit NYC, and interest in other cities like Italy and Barcelona, but no direct mention of North Carolina or Tennessee.\n\nStep 3: No explicit statements or hints indicate Tim has been to either North Carolina or Tennessee.\n\nFinal answer: Not enough information to confirm if Tim has been to North Carolina or Tennessee.",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 9.21,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.7
    },
    {
      "question": "What kind of fiction stories does Tim write?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Fantasy stories with plot twists",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Tim mentions writing articles about fantasy novels (Result 11, 22).\n\nStep 2: Tim talks about reading and writing about fantasy novels and characters (Results 2, 6, 25).\n\nStep 3: Tim is currently reading \"The Name of the Wind,\" a fantasy novel (Results 3, 6, 83).\n\nStep 4: Tim expresses love for fantasy stories and worlds (Results 14, 45, 59).\n\nStep 5: Tim also mentions writing a story based on his experiences in the UK, which suggests some personal or real-life inspired fiction, but the main focus is fantasy (Result 40).\n\nFinal answer: Tim primarily writes fantasy fiction stories inspired by fantasy novels and worlds.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.61,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.09
    },
    {
      "question": "What has John cooked?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Soup, a slow cooker meal, and honey garlic chicken with roasted veg.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of John cooking in the context.\n\n- Result 6 (2023-08-31): John mentions making a tasty soup around August 24, 2023.\n- Result 9 (2023-08-31): John says he made the soup up on the spot, no recipe.\n- Result 58 (2023-08-31): John added sage to the soup.\n- Result 16 (2023-10-21): John mentions making honey garlic chicken with roasted vegetables often and calls it one of his favorites.\n\nStep 2: Summarize the dishes John has cooked.\n\n- A tasty soup made around August 24, 2023, with sage added.\n- Honey garlic chicken with roasted vegetables, a favorite dish he makes frequently.\n\nFinal answer: John has cooked a tasty soup with sage and often makes honey garlic chicken with roasted vegetables.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.81,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.36
    },
    {
      "question": "What does John like about Lebron James?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "His heart, determination, skills, and leadership.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of LeBron James and John's opinions about him.\n\n- Result 3: John says, \"LeBron is the man - love his skills and leadership.\"\n- Result 6: John recalls \"that epic block in Game 7 of the '16 Finals\" by LeBron, highlighting his \"determination and heart.\"\n- Result 13: John says he met LeBron a few times, describes him as \"real chill,\" and learned a lot from watching him play live.\n- Result 37: John admires LeBron's \"work ethic and dedication to the game,\" calling him \"such an inspiration.\"\n- Result 22: John says LeBron \"is a great leader and puts others first - that's why he eventually becomes king.\"\n\nStep 2: Synthesize these points.\n\nJohn likes LeBron James for his skills, leadership, determination, heart, work ethic, dedication, and selfless leadership qualities.\n\nFinal answer:  \nJohn admires LeBron James",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 4.5,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.11
    },
    {
      "question": "When did John and his wife go on a European vacation?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "November, 2023.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of John and his wife going on a European vacation.  \n- Result 2 (2023-11-06): John says to Tim, \"my wife and I just left for our European vacation!\"  \n- Result 1 (2023-11-11): John describes the trip as a road trip on the European coastline, indicating the trip was ongoing or just completed around this time.\n\nStep 2: Check for any other time references related to this trip.  \n- Result 27 and 42 (2024-01-02): Tim and John discuss John's trip to Italy \"last month (approximately December 03, 2023),\" which fits the timeline of the European vacation starting in early November and continuing into December.\n\nStep 3: Synthesize the timeline.  \n- John and his wife left for their European vacation around November 6, 2023.  \n- The trip included Italy in early December 2023.  \n- By January",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.4,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.57
    },
    {
      "question": "Which country was Tim visiting in the second week of November?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "UK",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify any mentions of Tim's travel around the second week of November (approximately November 7-13, 2023).\n\nStep 2: Result 11 [2023-11-11T15:37:00] John to Tim says: \"My wife and I were road tripping out on the European coastline, and it was amazing! The views were spectacular...\"\n\nStep 3: Result 34 [2023-11-06T11:47:30] John to Tim says: \"Speaking of special moments, my wife and I just left for our European vacation! It will be short but sweet. You've been before, any recommendations?\"\n\nStep 4: These messages indicate John and his wife were on a European vacation in early November.\n\nStep 5: There is no direct statement that Tim was visiting a country in the second week of November, but Result 84 [2023-12-06T17:38:00] Tim to John",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.16,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.33
    },
    {
      "question": "Where was Tim in the week before 16 November 2023?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "UK",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the date of interest: the week before 16 November 2023 is approximately 9\u201315 November 2023.\n\nStep 2: Look for any messages around or after 16 November 2023 that mention Tim's location or activities in the prior week.\n\nStep 3: Result 62 [2023-11-21] John to Tim mentions a date \"approximately November 14, 2023\" and talks about books, but no location.\n\nStep 4: Result 89 [2023-11-06] Tim to John mentions a writing issue on October 30, 2023, but nothing about November.\n\nStep 5: Result 27 [2023-12-11] John to Tim asks about new success stories, no location.\n\nStep 6: Result 33 [2023-12-19] John to Tim says last week (approx. December 12, 2023) he got a deal with an",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.54,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.4
    },
    {
      "question": "When did John get married at a greenhouse?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "last week of September 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of John's wedding and the greenhouse venue.  \n- Result 1 (2023-10-02): John says they found a lovely greenhouse venue for a smaller, intimate gathering and had their loved ones celebrate with them.  \n- Result 18 (2023-10-02): John mentions his girlfriend and he had an amazing and emotional wedding ceremony last week (approximately September 25, 2023).  \n- Result 7 and 19 (2023-10-02): Tim refers to the ceremony during these times and the great venue with loved ones.  \n- Result 12 (2023-10-02): John mentions their first dance at a cozy restaurant after the ceremony.\n\nStep 2: Correlate the date of the wedding with the greenhouse venue.  \n- The wedding was about a week before October 2, 2023, so around September 25, 2023.  \n- The greenhouse venue is explicitly mentioned as the",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.99,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.19
    },
    {
      "question": "When did John get an ankle injury in 2023?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "around November 16, 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of John's ankle injury and timing.\n\n- Result 1 (2023-11-21): John says \"Last season, I had a major challenge when I hurt my ankle.\"\n- Result 5 (2023-12-16): John says \"Yeah, I injured myself not too long ago.\"\n- Result 9 (2023-11-16): John mentions \"Oh man, it's been a tough week for me with this injury.\"\n- Result 19 (2023-11-16): John says \"The doctor said it's not too serious.\"\n- Result 22 (2023-12-16): John says \"Last Friday, I had a milestone moment at the gym. I was able to jog a bit with no pain.\"\n- Result 17 (2023-12-16): John says \"After being out for so long, jogging without any pain was a huge success.\"\n\nStep 2: Determine when \"last season\" was.\n\n",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.23,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.91
    },
    {
      "question": "How many times has John injured his ankle?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "two times",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of John injuring his ankle or injury related to his ankle.\n\n- Result 1 (2023-11-21): John says, \"Last season, I had a major challenge when I hurt my ankle. It required some time off and physical therapy.\"\n- Result 5 (2023-12-16): John says, \"Yeah, I injured myself not too long ago. It sucked because I had to miss some games and couldn't help my team.\" This likely refers to the same injury mentioned earlier.\n- Result 8 (2023-11-16): John mentions a tough week with \"this injury,\" likely the same ankle injury.\n- Result 21 (2023-12-16): John says last Friday he jogged with no pain after being out for a while, indicating recovery from the injury.\n- Result 12 (2023-12-16): John says jogging without pain was a huge success after being out for so long.\n",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.32,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.68
    },
    {
      "question": "Which book was John reading during his recovery from an ankle injury?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "The Alchemist",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify when John mentioned his ankle injury and recovery.  \n- Result 1 (2023-11-21): John talks about his ankle injury last season and recovery.  \n- Result 44 (2023-12-16): John mentions injuring himself not too long ago and missing games.  \n- Result 56 (2023-12-16): John says he is doing physical therapy exercises every day.  \n- Result 82 (2023-12-16): John had a milestone jogging without pain.\n\nStep 2: Look for mentions of books John was reading around or after his injury.  \n- Result 77 (2023-11-21): John finished rereading \"The Alchemist\" around November 14, 2023, and found it inspiring.  \n- Result 16 (2023-11-21): John says \"that book\" really helped motivate him to keep chasing dreams and trust the process.  \n- Result 32",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.78,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.5
    },
    {
      "question": "What kind of yoga for building core strength might John benefit from?",
      "category": 3,
      "gold_answer": "Hatha Yoga",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: John mentions enjoying specific yoga poses that help with strength and balance, such as Warrior II and a pose that aids balance and stability (Result 11).\n\nStep 2: He holds poses typically for 30-60 seconds to build strength and stability (Result 30).\n\nStep 3: John highlights that yoga has helped him improve strength, flexibility, focus, and balance during workouts (Result 1).\n\nStep 4: Tim asks about specific poses, and John shares a photo of a pose that works legs and core (Result 12).\n\nStep 5: Since John is focusing on core strength and stability, yoga styles that emphasize holding poses and core engagement, such as Hatha or Vinyasa yoga with balance-focused poses, would be beneficial.\n\nFinal answer:  \nJohn would benefit from yoga styles like Hatha or Vinyasa that include poses such as Warrior II and balance-focused postures held for 30-60 seconds, which effectively build core strength and stability.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.77,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.98
    },
    {
      "question": "What does John do to supplement his basketball training?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Yoga, strength training",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of John's basketball training and any additional activities he does alongside it.\n\n- Result 5 (2023-08-21): John says strength training is important for basketball because it builds muscle, increases power, prevents injuries, helps him become more explosive, and boosts athleticism.\n- Result 3 (2023-08-21): John says incorporating strength training improved his shooting accuracy, agility, and speed.\n- Result 6 (2023-08-21): John talks about balancing basketball practice and strength training, listening to his body, and giving it enough rest.\n- Result 39 (2023-08-21): Tim asks why John includes strength training in his routine, indicating it is a supplement.\n- Result 12 (2023-08-21): John mentions adapting and tweaking his routine to find the right balance between basketball and strength training.\n- Result 73 (2023-12-16): John mentions doing rehab and physical therapy exercises",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.9,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.91
    },
    {
      "question": "What other exercises can help John with his basketball performance?",
      "category": 3,
      "gold_answer": "Sprinting, long-distance running, and boxing.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: John emphasizes strength training as a key exercise to improve basketball performance, helping with muscle building, power, explosiveness, shooting accuracy, agility, and speed (Results 1, 3, 5).\n\nStep 2: John also mentions yoga as beneficial for strength, flexibility, focus, and balance during workouts (Results 32, 76, 90). He enjoys poses like Warrior II that build strength and stability.\n\nStep 3: John does physical therapy exercises and rehab to recover from injury, which helps maintain fitness and strength (Results 57, 68).\n\nStep 4: John uses jogging as part of his recovery and conditioning, noting a milestone of jogging without pain (Results 30, 68).\n\nStep 5: John uses motivational strategies like writing quotes and strategies on a whiteboard to stay focused during tough workouts (Result 28).\n\nFinal answer: Besides strength training, John benefits from yoga for strength, flexibility, and balance, physical therapy exercises for",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.1,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.57
    },
    {
      "question": "When did John take a trip to the Rocky Mountains?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "2022",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of the Rocky Mountains trip.  \n- Result 1 (2023-12-01): John mentions going camping in the mountains.  \n- Result 2 (2023-12-01): John clarifies this was his Rocky Mountains trip last year, approximately December 01, 2022.\n\nStep 2: Confirm the timing.  \n- The message from John on 2023-12-01 says the trip was \"last year,\" which means around December 1, 2022.\n\nFinal answer:  \nJohn took his trip to the Rocky Mountains around December 1, 2022.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.05,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.22
    },
    {
      "question": "When did John start playing professionally?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "May, 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify any direct statements about when John started playing professionally.  \n- Result 1 (2023-12-06): John says, \"I've been playing professionally for just under a year now.\"  \n- Result 4 (2023-12-06): Tim asks John how long he has been playing professionally, and John answers shortly after (Result 1).  \n\nStep 2: Determine the approximate start date based on the \"just under a year\" statement from December 6, 2023.  \n- \"Just under a year\" as of early December 2023 suggests John started playing professionally around late 2022 or early 2023.  \n\nStep 3: Check for any other relevant time references.  \n- Result 18 (2023-08-11): John mentions being drafted after college, but no exact date.  \n- Result 35 (2023-05-21): John says he just signed with a new team, indicating he",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.49,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.96
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Tim start playing the violin?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "August 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Tim learning the violin.\n- Result 1 (2023-12-06): Tim says, \"I'm learning how to play the violin now.\"\n- Result 2 (2023-12-06): Tim says he \"Recently (approximately November 29, 2023) started learning an instrument.\"\n\nStep 2: Confirm the instrument is the violin.\n- Result 1 confirms the instrument is the violin.\n- Result 2 says \"Recently (approx. Nov 29, 2023) started learning an instrument,\" which aligns with the violin mentioned in Result 1.\n\nStep 3: Check for any other timing details.\n- Result 28 (2023-12-06) Tim says, \"I've been playing for about four months now,\" which fits starting around late November 2023.\n\nFinal answer: Tim started playing the violin around November 29, 2023.",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.7,
      "judge_latency_s": 3.85
    },
    {
      "question": "What instruments does Tim play?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "piano, violin",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of instruments Tim plays.\n- Result 1: Tim recently started learning an instrument around November 29, 2023.\n- Result 4: Tim says he is learning to play the violin now.\n- Result 5: Tim mentions he loves playing different songs on the piano.\n- Result 25: Tim has been playing the violin for about four months as of December 6, 2023.\n- Result 6: John asks how long Tim has been playing the piano, implying Tim has been playing piano for some time.\n- Result 67: Tim mentions he started learning piano earlier and is making progress.\n\nStep 2: Summarize findings.\n- Tim plays the piano and has been doing so for a while.\n- Tim started learning the violin recently (around late November 2023) and has been playing it for about four months by early December 2023.\n\nFinal answer:  \nTim plays the piano and has recently started learning the violin",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 5.51,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.88
    },
    {
      "question": "When did John attend the Harry Potter trivia?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "August 2023.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of John attending Harry Potter trivia.  \n- Result 1 (2023-08-02): John to Tim mentions a charity event with Harry Potter trivia with Anthony.  \n- Result 3 (2023-12-08): John references telling Tim last August about the charity event with Harry Potter trivia.\n\nStep 2: Confirm the timing of the event.  \n- Result 3 explicitly says \"Last August I told you about my fun time at a charity event with Harry Potter trivia.\"  \n- The message is dated 2023-12-08, so \"last August\" refers to August 2023.\n\nFinal answer:  \nJohn attended the Harry Potter trivia at a charity event in August 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.77,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.8
    },
    {
      "question": "Which career-high performances did John achieve in 2023?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "highest point score, highest assist",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of career-high performances by John in 2023.\n\n- Result 78 [2023-12-11T20:29:00] John to Tim: \"By the way, I had a career-high in assists last Friday in our big game against our rival.\"\n\nStep 2: Check if there are any other mentions of career-high performances.\n\n- No other explicit mentions of career-high performances found in the context.\n\nStep 3: Summarize the information.\n\nJohn achieved a career-high in assists during a big game against their rival in early December 2023.\n\nFinal answer:  \nIn 2023, John achieved a career-high in assists during a big game against their rival in early December.",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.55,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.32
    },
    {
      "question": "When did John achieve a career-high assist performance?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "December 11, 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for mentions of a career-high assist performance by John.  \nStep 2: Result 4 [2023-12-11T20:29:00] John to Tim says: \"By the way, I had a career-high in assists last Friday in our big game against our rival.\"  \nStep 3: The message is dated December 11, 2023, which is a Monday. The \"last Friday\" before December 11, 2023, would be December 8, 2023.\n\nFinal answer: John achieved his career-high assist performance on Friday, December 8, 2023.",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.83,
      "judge_latency_s": 4.48
    },
    {
      "question": "What books has John read?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "inpsiring book on dreaming big, The Alchemist, fantasy series, non-fiction books on personal development, Dune",
      "generated_answer": "Step-by-step analysis of the books John has read based on the conversation excerpts:\n\n1. From [Result 31] and [Result 79], John has \"The Alchemist\" on his bookshelf and has read it, finding it inspiring.\n2. From [Result 89], John finished an amazing fantasy series with many twists (not named explicitly).\n3. From [Result 75], John is currently reading \"Dune\" by Frank Herbert.\n4. From [Result 37], John has read another popular fantasy series (not named explicitly, but likely different from \"The Hobbit\").\n5. From [Result 55], John mentions \"The Hobbit\" as one of his favorites.\n6. From [Result 98], John recently reread \"The Alchemist.\"\n7. From [Result 39], John is reading a book by Patrick Rothfuss recommended by Tim (likely \"The Name of the Wind\" as per [Result 24] and [Result 59]).\n8",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.84,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.21
    },
    {
      "question": "What does John do to share his knowledge?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "gives seminars, mentors younger players.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of John sharing knowledge or mentoring.  \n- Result 89 (2023-10-17): John says he is mentoring younger players on his team, sharing skills and knowledge.  \n- Result 14 (2023-10-17): John mentions some see him as a mentor and he provides advice and support on and off the court.  \n- Result 95 (2023-12-26): John talks about seminars he conducted for aspiring professionals, sharing knowledge and helping out.  \n- Result 7 (2023-10-17): John mentions gaining experience, adapting, motivating, encouraging, and watching others develop and reach goals.  \n- Result 48 (2023-12-06): John encourages using personal experiences to inspire others and offers help.  \n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.  \nJohn shares his knowledge primarily by mentoring younger players on his team, providing advice and support both on and off the court, and conducting seminars for",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 4.75,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.01
    },
    {
      "question": "When did John organize a basketball camp for kids?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "summer 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant excerpt about the basketball camp for kids.  \n- Result 1 [2023-12-26]: John says he organized a basketball camp for kids in his hometown last summer.\n\nStep 2: Determine the timing of \"last summer\" relative to the message date.  \n- The message is dated December 26, 2023.  \n- \"Last summer\" from December 2023 would be summer 2023.\n\nFinal answer:  \nJohn organized the basketball camp for kids in the summer of 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.85,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.51
    },
    {
      "question": "Which month was John in Italy?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "December, 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of John being in Italy.  \n- Result 3 (2024-01-02): John says he had a blast in Italy last month (approximately December 03, 2023).  \n- Result 2 (2024-01-02): John confirms Italy was awesome and talks about a book he got there.  \n- Result 1 (2024-01-02): Tim asks John about his trip to Italy last month (around December 03, 2023).\n\nStep 2: The conversation date is January 2, 2024, and John refers to \"last month\" as the time he was in Italy, which would be December 2023.\n\nFinal answer: John was in Italy in December 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.37,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.36
    },
    {
      "question": "What fantasy movies does Tim like?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Lord of the Rings, Harry Potter, and Star Wars.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Tim's favorite fantasy movies in the context.\n\n- Result 3 (2024-01-02): Tim says, \"Definitely Star Wars! It's my favorite and never gets old.\"\n- Result 39 (2023-12-26): Tim shares a pic of his favorite, \"Lord of the Rings.\"\n- Result 28 (2024-01-02): Tim says, \"Harry Potter is my favorite book,\" and Result 43 (2023-12-26) John asks if Tim has seen all the Harry Potter movies, implying Tim likes those too.\n- Result 81 (2023-08-21): Tim mentions watching \"Elf\" during the holidays.\n- Result 34 (2023-08-21): Tim says they watch \"Home Alone\" during Thanksgiving, which is more of a holiday comedy than fantasy, so less relevant.\n- Result 99 (2023-12-26): Tim is excited about a new",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.52,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.94
    },
    {
      "question": "What is a Star Wars book that Tim might enjoy?",
      "category": 3,
      "gold_answer": "Star Wars: Jedi Apprentice by Judy Blundell and David Farland. It is a highly rated and immersive series about his favorite movies.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify Tim's favorite genres and authors. Tim enjoys fantasy novels, especially those with immersive world-building and strong characters. He likes Patrick Rothfuss's \"The Name of the Wind\" and is a fan of Harry Potter and Lord of the Rings.\n\nStep 2: Tim appreciates books that transport him to other worlds and inspire creativity.\n\nStep 3: The question is about a Star Wars book Tim might enjoy. While no specific Star Wars book is mentioned in the conversation, Tim's tastes suggest he would like a Star Wars novel with rich world-building and character development.\n\nStep 4: A well-known Star Wars book fitting this description is \"Star Wars: Heir to the Empire\" by Timothy Zahn, which is highly regarded for its storytelling and character depth.\n\nStep 5: Since no specific Star Wars book is mentioned in the context, the best answer is to suggest a Star Wars novel that aligns with Tim's interests.\n\nFinal answer:  \nTim might enjoy \"Star Wars",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.67,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.43
    },
    {
      "question": "What would be a good hobby related to his travel dreams for Tim to pick up?",
      "category": 3,
      "gold_answer": "Writing a travel blog.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify Tim's travel dreams and interests.\n- Tim enjoys traveling, exploring new cities, and reading fantasy books that transport him to different worlds (Results 6, 11, 16, 40, 50).\n- He recently joined a travel club and is learning new skills, including starting to learn an instrument around November 29, 2023 (Result 2).\n- He likes road trips, hiking, and spending time with friends and family (Result 6).\n- He is interested in fantasy novels and uses reading as a way to escape and explore cultures and landscapes (Results 45, 47, 50).\n\nStep 2: Look for hobbies Tim has or is considering.\n- Learning an instrument (Result 2).\n- Reading fantasy books (Results 45, 50).\n- Writing articles combining reading and sharing stories (Result 42).\n\nStep 3: Consider hobbies that align with travel dreams.\n- Since Tim loves exploring new places and cultures,",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.88,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.7
    },
    {
      "question": "What day did Tim get into his study abroad program?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "Januarty 5, 2024",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for any mention of Tim joining or starting a study abroad program or something similar.\n\nStep 2: Result 1 (2023-12-06) from Tim to John says: \"Joined a travel club and, like I said, working on studies. Also picked up new skills. Recently (approximately November 29, 2023) started learning an instrument.\"\n\nStep 3: No direct mention of study abroad in Result 1, but Tim mentions joining a travel club and working on studies.\n\nStep 4: Result 71 (2024-01-02) John to Tim mentions: \"By the way, have you been to Italy? I had a blast there last month (approximately December 03, 2023).\"\n\nStep 5: Result 17 (2024-01-07) John to Tim: \"Congrats, Tim! That's amazing news. So, where are you going to stay?\" This suggests Tim got accepted or confirmed for",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 7.48,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.85
    },
    {
      "question": "When will Tim leave for Ireland?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "February, 2024",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Tim mentions on 2024-01-07 that he got into a study abroad program and will be going to Ireland next month (Result 3).\n\nStep 2: \"Next month\" from January 7, 2024, means February 2024.\n\nStep 3: Tim confirms he will stay in Galway, Ireland (Result 1).\n\nFinal answer: Tim will leave for Ireland in February 2024.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.52,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.89
    },
    {
      "question": "Which Star Wars-related locations would Tim enjoy during his visit to Ireland?",
      "category": 3,
      "gold_answer": "Skellig Michael, Malin Head, Loop Head, Ceann Sib\u00e9al, and Brow Head because they are Star Wars filming locations.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify if there is any direct mention of Star Wars-related locations in Ireland in the conversation excerpts.  \n- There is no explicit mention of Star Wars locations in Ireland in the provided context.\n\nStep 2: Check Tim's interests related to Star Wars and travel.  \n- Tim mentions loving Star Wars and fantasy stories (Result 23, 44, 92).  \n- Tim is going to Ireland for a semester (Result 72).  \n- Tim wants to visit The Cliffs of Moher in Ireland (Result 45).  \n- No direct mention of Star Wars-related sites in Ireland.\n\nStep 3: Consider known Star Wars filming or related locations in Ireland.  \n- The conversation does not mention any specific Star Wars filming locations or attractions in Ireland.\n\nStep 4: Check if any other fantasy or magical places Tim is interested in are mentioned in Ireland.  \n- Tim is interested in Edinburgh, Scotland for its Harry Potter connection (Result 20), but that is",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.73,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.69
    },
    {
      "question": "Which team did John sign with on 21 May, 2023?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "The Minnesota Wolves",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the date of signing.\n- Result 5 [2023-05-21]: John says he just signed with a new team.\n- Result 1 [2023-05-21]: Tim asks which team John signed with.\n\nStep 2: Look for the team name mentioned around that date.\n- Result 38 [2023-05-21]: John says, \"The Minnesota Wolves! I can't wait to play with them!\"\n\nStep 3: Confirm no conflicting information.\n- No other team names mentioned for the signing on that date.\n\nFinal answer: John signed with the Minnesota Wolves on 21 May, 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.38,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.69
    },
    {
      "question": "What is John's position on the team he signed with?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "shooting guard",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify where John mentions his position on the team.  \nStep 2: In [Result 59] dated 2023-05-21T19:51:00, John tells Tim: \"I'm a shooting guard for the team and our season opener is next week - so excited!\"  \nStep 3: This directly answers the question about John's position on the team he signed with.\n\nFinal answer: John plays as a shooting guard on the team he signed with.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.34,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.71
    },
    {
      "question": "What challenge did John encounter during pre-season training?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "fitting into the new team's style of play",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of pre-season training challenges by John.  \n- Result 2 (2023-05-21): John says, \"Fitting into the new team's style of play was a challenge during pre-season.\"  \n- Result 15 (2023-08-21): John mentions overcoming the hurdle of adapting and tweaking his routine at the gym during training.  \n\nStep 2: Confirm the specific challenge related to pre-season.  \n- Result 2 explicitly states the challenge was fitting into the new team's style of play during pre-season.  \n- Result 15 supports this by mentioning adapting his routine, which aligns with fitting into a new style.  \n\nFinal answer:  \nJohn's challenge during pre-season training was fitting into the new team's style of play.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.52,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.91
    },
    {
      "question": "What aspects of the Harry Potter universe will be discussed in John's fan project collaborations?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "characters, spells, magical creatures",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about John's fan project collaborations with Tim.\n\n- Result 2 (2023-05-21): Tim mentions discussing collaborations for a Harry Potter fan project.\n- Result 1 (2023-05-21): Tim says they will be discussing various aspects of the Harry Potter universe, like characters, spells, and magical creatures.\n\nStep 2: Confirm that these aspects are linked to the fan project collaborations.\n\n- Result 1 directly follows Result 2, indicating that the aspects Tim mentions (characters, spells, magical creatures) are part of the fan project discussions.\n\nFinal answer:  \nThe fan project collaborations will discuss various aspects of the Harry Potter universe, including characters, spells, and magical creatures.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.26,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.62
    },
    {
      "question": "What forum did Tim join recently?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "fantasy literature forum",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Tim joining any group or forum.\n- Result 45 [2024-01-02]: Tim says he joined a group of globetrotters who share his interests.\n- Result 24 [2023-08-02]: Tim mentions writing articles about fantasy novels for an online magazine, but this is about writing, not joining a forum.\n- Result 22 [2023-08-09]: Tim talks about Skyping with a Harry Potter fan he met in CA, possibly related to a fan project, but no mention of joining a forum.\n- No other explicit mentions of Tim joining a forum or group.\n\nStep 2: The closest to a \"forum\" or group is the \"group of globetrotters\" Tim joined, mentioned on 2024-01-02.\n\nStep 3: No specific name of the forum or group is given, only that it is a group of globetrotters with shared interests.\n\nFinal",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.23,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.52
    },
    {
      "question": "What kind of picture did Tim share as part of their Harry Potter book collection?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "MinaLima's creation from the Harry Potter films",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Tim sharing pictures related to Harry Potter or his book collection.\n\n- Result 1: Tim to John mentions a picture from MinaLima, creators of Harry Potter props, saying it feels like having a piece of the wizarding world at home.\n- Result 13: John asks Tim about a picture of a bookshelf.\n- Result 99: Tim shares his book collection.\n- Result 84: Tim shares his bookshelf with favorites.\n- Result 14: Tim mentions reorganizing his bookshelf.\n- Result 1 specifically links a picture to MinaLima's Harry Potter props.\n\nStep 2: Confirm the nature of the picture.\n\n- Result 1 clearly states the picture is from MinaLima, who created all the props for the Harry Potter films.\n- Tim says it\u2019s like having a piece of the wizarding world at home, implying the picture shows Harry Potter-related props or items from MinaLima.\n\nStep 3: No other picture related to",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.64,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.88
    },
    {
      "question": "What was the highest number of points John scored in a game recently?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "40 points",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of John scoring points in games.\n\n- Result 2 (2023-07-16): John says last week (around July 09, 2023) he scored 40 points, his highest ever.\n- Result 1 (2023-07-16): John thanks Tim and mentions scoring points in a tough win, but no specific number.\n- Result 61 (2023-08-09): John mentions a crazy intense game last week (around August 02, 2023) but no points number.\n- No other results mention a higher point total.\n\nStep 2: Confirm if any other point totals are mentioned that exceed 40.\n\n- No other excerpts mention a higher point total than 40.\n\nFinal answer: The highest number of points John scored recently was 40 points in a game around July 09, 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.94,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.26
    },
    {
      "question": "What did John celebrate at a restaurant with teammates?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "a tough win",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of John celebrating at a restaurant with teammates.  \n- Result 1 (2023-07-16): John says, \"We were all exhausted but so happy. After that, we celebrated at a restaurant, laughing and reliving the intense moments - it felt amazing!\"  \n- Result 2 (2023-09-21): John mentions attending a local restaurant with new teammates last week (around Sept 14, 2023) to get to know them better, but this is more of a social gathering, not a celebration.  \n- Result 5 and 69 mention team dinners and camaraderie but not a specific celebration at a restaurant.  \n- Result 12 and 42 mention a dance and a ceremony at a restaurant, but those seem related to a wedding or special event, not a team celebration.  \n\nStep 2: What was the reason for the celebration in Result 1?  \n- Result 6 (Tim to John) asks",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.9,
      "judge_latency_s": 3.0
    },
    {
      "question": "What kind of deals did John sign with Nike and Gatorade?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "basketball shoe and gear deal with Nike, potential sponsorship deal with Gatorade",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of deals with Nike and Gatorade.  \n- Result 1 (2023-07-16): John says he signed Nike for a basketball shoe and gear deal and is in talks with Gatorade about a potential sponsorship.  \n- Result 3 (2023-07-16): John expresses excitement about Nike and Gatorade deals.  \n- Result 5 (2023-07-16): John mentions talking to big names, implying endorsements.  \n- Result 6 (2023-06-15): John is considering sports brands like Nike and Under Armour for collaborations.  \n- Result 14 (2023-07-16): John used contacts and marketing skills to make connections for endorsements.  \n- Result 21 (2023-07-16): Tim asks about endorsements John got through networking.  \n- Result 29 (2023-07-16): Tim asks how John connected with big companies.  \n- Result 30",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 5.65,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.54
    },
    {
      "question": "Which city is John excited to have a game at?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Seattle",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of John being excited about a game in a specific city.  \n- Result 2 (2023-07-16): John says to Tim, \"It's Seattle, I'm stoked for my game there next month! It's one of my favorite cities to explore - super vibrant!\"  \n- Result 1 (same date) also mentions John loving the energy, diversity, and food of \"this city,\" referring to Seattle.  \n- Result 35 (Tim to John) confirms Seattle is a great city and wishes John good luck.\n\nStep 2: Check if any other city is mentioned with excitement about a game.  \n- Result 22 (2023-08-11): John mentions being in Chicago and enjoying it, but no explicit excitement about a game there.  \n- Result 28 and 39 mention NYC as a great place to explore, but no direct mention of a game there.  \n- No other city is explicitly linked to John being excited about",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.23,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.23
    },
    {
      "question": "How long has John been surfing?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "five years",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about John surfing.  \n- Result 2 (2023-07-16): John says he started surfing five years ago.  \n- Result 3 (2023-07-16): John talks about an awesome summer surfing with friends.  \n- Result 6 (2023-07-16): John describes the feeling of being out in the water surfing.\n\nStep 2: Confirm the date of the statement about surfing duration.  \n- The statement \"I started surfing five years ago\" is from 2023-07-16.\n\nStep 3: Calculate the approximate start year.  \n- If John said in mid-2023 that he started surfing five years ago, he began around 2018.\n\nFinal answer:  \nJohn has been surfing for about five years as of July 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.04,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.77
    },
    {
      "question": "How does John feel while surfing?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "super exciting and free-feeling",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify all excerpts where John talks about surfing or related feelings.\n\n- [Result 4] John to Tim (2023-07-16): \"I had an awesome summer with my friends, surfing and riding the waves. The feeling was unreal!\"\n- [Result 3] John to Tim (2023-07-16): \"I started surfing five years ago and it's been great. I love the connection to nature.\"\n- [Result 6] John to Tim (2023-07-16): \"Yup! Being out in the water can be amazing. The waves, the wind, it's super exciting and free-feeling. Nature's pretty special.\"\n- [Result 55] John to Tim (2023-07-16): \"Cool! We all find our own way to escape and feel free!\" (implying surfing is his way)\n- [Result 39] John to Tim (2023-07-16): \"Yeah!",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.75,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.86
    },
    {
      "question": "What kind of articles has Tim been writing about for the online magazine?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "different fantasy novels, characters, themes, and book recommendations",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about Tim's writing.\n\n- Result 2 (2023-08-02): Tim says he is writing articles about fantasy novels for an online magazine.\n- Result 29 (2023-08-02): Tim elaborates that he has been writing about different fantasy novels, studying characters, themes, and making book recommendations.\n- Result 73 (2023-08-11): Tim mentions writing more articles combining his love for reading and sharing great stories.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.\n\nTim writes articles focused on fantasy novels, including analysis of characters and themes, and book recommendations for an online magazine.\n\nFinal answer:  \nTim has been writing articles about fantasy novels, analyzing characters and themes, and making book recommendations for an online magazine.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.85,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.09
    },
    {
      "question": "Which two fantasy novels does Tim particularly enjoy writing about?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Harry Potter and Game of Thrones",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of specific fantasy novels Tim enjoys writing about.\n\n- Result 3 (2024-01-07): Tim is currently reading \"The Name of the Wind\" by Patrick Rothfuss and praises it.\n- Result 16 (2023-08-09): Tim recommends \"The Name of the Wind\" to John.\n- Result 54 (2024-01-02): Tim says Harry Potter is his favorite book.\n- Result 17 (2023-10-21): Tim praises J.K. Rowling's writing (author of Harry Potter).\n- Result 19 (2023-12-08): Tim mentions just the GoT (Game of Thrones) series.\n- Result 29 (2023-12-01): Tim mentions \"The Hobbit\" and another popular fantasy series (likely GoT).\n- Result 56 (2023-12-01): Tim talks about books that take them to different worlds, including \"The Hobbit.\"\n-",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.92,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.31
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Anthony and John end up playing during the charity event?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "an intense Harry Potter trivia contest",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of a charity event involving John and possibly Anthony.  \n- Result 26: John mentions holding a benefit basketball game last week (around Dec 31, 2023).  \n- Result 1: John says \"The game turned out to be a total success! Lots of people showed up and had a great time, plus we were able to raise some money for charity.\"  \n- Result 17: Tim praises John for organizing the event and making a difference.  \n- Result 22: John comments on how basketball brings people together and creates a positive impact.  \n\nStep 2: Check if Anthony is mentioned in the context of the charity event or the game.  \n- No direct mention of Anthony in the charity event excerpts.  \n- However, the question implies Anthony and John played together during the charity event.  \n\nStep 3: Determine what sport was played at the charity event.  \n- Multiple references to basketball in the context of John\u2019s activities and",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.16,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.94
    },
    {
      "question": "What did John share with the person he skyped about?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Characters from Harry Potter",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant excerpt about John skyping with someone.  \n- Result 71 [2023-08-09T10:29:00] Tim to John: \"Hey John! Long time no see! Been super busy lately. Guess what? Just skyped with that Harry Potter fan I met in CA and had a great time. We talked characters and maybe collab-ing - so cool to talk to someone who gets it. You? Anything new going on?\"\n\nStep 2: Check if John responded with what he shared during his Skype.  \n- No direct response from John about what he shared on Skype is found in the excerpts.\n\nStep 3: Look for any other mentions of Skype or related conversations about Harry Potter or collaborations.  \n- Result 43 [2023-12-08T19:42:00] Tim to John: \"Hey John! Long time no see! I just got back from the coolest Harry Potter party. Met lots",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.64,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.16
    },
    {
      "question": "How did John describe the team bond?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Awesome",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify all excerpts where John talks about the team bond.\n\n- Result 1 (2023-08-09): \"Our team bond is awesome and it makes all the hard work worth it.\"\n- Result 3 (2023-07-16): \"Being surrounded by teammates who are equally passionate creates a strong bond. We push each other to be our best and the love for the game is infectious. It's like having a second family.\"\n- Result 2 (2023-12-19): \"Our team has seen the most growth in communication and bonding. It has really helped our performances by allowing us to understand each other's strengths and weaknesses.\"\n- Result 18 (2023-08-09): \"Having a strong team/support is key - it's like a family away from home. We push each other to improve, and I'm so thankful for them.\"\n- Result 99 (2023-08-09): \"They encourage me when I'm down too. It's",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.7,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.69
    },
    {
      "question": "How did John get introduced to basketball?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Dad signed him up for a local league",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for any mention of how John started playing basketball or got introduced to the game.\n\nStep 2: Result 4 [2023-08-11T13:14:00] John to Tim says: \"Basketball has been a part of my life ever since I was a kid. I'd watch NBA games with my dad and dream of playing on those big courts. When I turned ten, dad signed me up for a local league, and I've been playing ever since.\"\n\nStep 3: This clearly states that John got introduced to basketball by watching NBA games with his dad and then his dad signed him up for a local league when he was ten.\n\nFinal answer: John was introduced to basketball by watching NBA games with his dad, who then signed him up for a local league when he was ten years old.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.3,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.66
    },
    {
      "question": "What is John's number one goal in his basketball career?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Winning a championship",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts where John talks about his goals in basketball.\n\n- Result 4 [2023-08-11]: John says, \"Winning a championship is my number one goal.\"\n- Result 5 [2023-09-21]: John focuses on better shooting, making an impact, and life after basketball, but does not contradict the number one goal.\n- Result 13 [2023-05-21]: John wants to improve shooting percentage, a more specific skill goal.\n- Result 51 [2023-09-21]: Tim asks about specific targets; John confirms goals on and off the court but no change to number one goal.\n- Result 14 [2023-12-26]: John organized a basketball camp, showing off-court goals but not replacing the number one goal.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.\n\nJohn explicitly states his number one goal is winning a championship (Result 4). Other goals like improving skills, endorsements,",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.69,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.31
    },
    {
      "question": "What organization is John teaming up with for his charity work?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "A local organization helping disadvantaged kids with sports and school",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about John's charity work.\n\n- Result 4 [2023-08-11]: John says he is teaming up with a local organization that helps disadvantaged kids with sports and school.\n- Result 30 [2023-12-26]: John mentions organizing a basketball camp for kids in his hometown last summer.\n- Result 29 [2023-12-26]: John talks about doing seminars helping people with sports and marketing.\n\nStep 2: Check if the name of the organization is mentioned.\n\n- Result 4 only says \"a local organization that helps disadvantaged kids with sports and school\" but does not name it.\n- No other excerpt provides a specific name for the organization.\n\nStep 3: Conclusion\n\nThe context states John is working with a local organization helping disadvantaged kids with sports and school, but no specific name is given.\n\nFinal answer: John is teaming up with a local organization that helps disadvantaged kids with sports and school; the organization's name is not",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.74,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.05
    },
    {
      "question": "When did John meet back up with his teammates after his trip in August 2023?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Aug 15th",
      "generated_answer": "John met back up with his teammates on August 15, 2023, after his trip, as he mentioned in the message dated 2023-08-17T19:54:00 that he met back up with them on the 15th after his trip. \n\nFinal answer: John met back up with his teammates on August 15, 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.31,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.14
    },
    {
      "question": "What did John's teammates give him when they met on Aug 15th?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "a basketball with autographs on it",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the date of the meeting with teammates: John mentions meeting back up with his teammates on August 15th after his trip (Result 12).\n\nStep 2: Look for what the teammates gave him around that time:  \n- Result 3 (Aug 17): John says \"They signed it to show our friendship and appreciation.\"  \n- Result 21 (Aug 17): John shows a photo of what his teammates gave him when they met, calling it a sign of friendship and love.  \n- Result 4 (Aug 17): Tim asks if they signed it for a special reason.  \n- Result 42 (Aug 17): John talks about having something like \"this ball\" to remind him of the bond and support from teammates.\n\nStep 3: Synthesize: The teammates gave John a signed basketball as a symbol of their friendship and appreciation when they met on August 15th.\n\nFinal answer: John's teammates gave him a basketball signed by them",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.78,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.92
    },
    {
      "question": "Why did John's teammates sign the basketball they gave him?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "to show their friendship and appreciation",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about the signed basketball.\n\n- Result 4: John says the ball reminds him of the bond and support from teammates, motivating him.\n- Result 10: John says they signed it to show friendship and appreciation, a reminder of their bond.\n- Result 99: John shows a photo of what teammates gave him as a sign of friendship and love.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.\n\nJohn\u2019s teammates signed the basketball as a symbol of their friendship, appreciation, and the strong bond they share. It serves as a meaningful reminder of their support and connection.\n\nFinal answer:  \nJohn's teammates signed the basketball to show their friendship and appreciation, making it a meaningful reminder of their bond and support.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.08,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.92
    },
    {
      "question": "What is the main intention behind Tim wanting to attend the book conference?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "to learn more about literature and create a stronger bond to it",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant excerpt about Tim's intention for attending the book conference.  \n- Result 1 [2023-08-17]: Tim says he hopes to attend a book conference next month.  \n- He describes it as a gathering of authors, publishers, and book lovers where they talk about favorite novels and new releases.  \n- He is excited because it will help him learn more about literature and create a stronger bond to it.\n\nStep 2: Summarize the main intention based on Tim's own words.  \n- The main intention is to deepen his knowledge of literature and strengthen his connection to books.\n\nFinal answer:  \nTim wants to attend the book conference to learn more about literature and create a stronger bond with it.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.08,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.07
    },
    {
      "question": "What new activity has Tim started learning in August 2023?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "play the piano",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of new activities Tim started learning around August 2023.\n\n- Result 48 (2023-08-21): Tim says he has started learning how to play the piano, describing it as a learning curve but satisfying.\n- Result 2 (2023-12-06) mentions Tim started learning an instrument recently (around November 29, 2023), which aligns with the piano learning mentioned earlier.\n- No other new activities started by Tim in August 2023 are mentioned.\n\nStep 2: Confirm timing and activity.\n\n- The piano learning is explicitly mentioned in August 2023 (Result 48).\n- This is the only new activity Tim started learning around that time.\n\nFinal answer:  \nTim started learning to play the piano in August 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 4.22,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.13
    },
    {
      "question": "Which movie's theme is Tim's favorite to play on the piano?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "\"Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone\"",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify where Tim mentions his favorite piano theme.  \n- In [Result 1], Tim says: \"my favorite one to jam to is a theme from a movie I really enjoy. It brings back lots of great memories.\"\n\nStep 2: Look for clues about which movie this might be.  \n- In [Result 3], John says: \"I love that first movie too, I even have the whole collection! It was so magical! Must've been a dream watching it with your family.\"  \n- In [Result 18], Tim says: \"Watching that movie with my family was awesome, we'd all get comfy with snacks and a blanket and be totally absorbed. Such a special memory!\"  \n- In [Result 13], John calls \"The Santa Clause\" a classic and mentions it as a holiday favorite.  \n- In [Result 28], Tim says: \"We love 'The Santa Clause' too- it's so heartwarming and gets us all feeling",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.45,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.92
    },
    {
      "question": "What special memory does \"Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone\" bring to Tim?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Watching it with his family",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about \"Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone\" and Tim's memories.\n\n- Result 1 (2023-08-21): Tim says the movie is special to him because it was the first in the series and brings back great memories. Watching it with his family was amazing and magical.\n- Result 48 (2023-08-21): Tim elaborates that watching the movie with his family was a dream come true; they would get comfy with snacks and a blanket and be totally absorbed.\n- Result 14 (2023-08-21): John acknowledges Tim's memory, saying it must have been a dream watching it with family.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.\n\nTim's special memory associated with \"Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone\" is watching the first movie of the series with his family, where they would get comfortable with snacks and blankets, fully absorbed in the magical experience. This family time was a dream come",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.16,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.63
    },
    {
      "question": "Which movie does Tim mention they enjoy watching during Thanksgiving?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "\"Home Alone\"",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Thanksgiving and movies Tim enjoys watching during that time.\n\n- Result 2: Tim says Thanksgiving is special, prepping feast, talking about thankfulness, and watching movies afterwards.\n- Result 3: Tim specifically mentions watching \"Home Alone\" during Thanksgiving, saying it brings lots of laughs.\n- Result 13: Tim also mentions watching \"Elf\" during the holidays.\n- Result 18: Tim mentions loving \"The Santa Clause\" during the holidays.\n\nStep 2: Focus on which movie Tim explicitly associates with Thanksgiving.\n\n- Result 3 is the clearest: Tim says \"During Thanksgiving, we usually watch a few movies. We love 'Home Alone' - it always brings lots of laughs!\"\n\nStep 3: Confirm no other movie is explicitly tied to Thanksgiving by Tim.\n\n- \"Elf\" and \"The Santa Clause\" are mentioned as holiday movies but not specifically Thanksgiving.\n\nFinal answer: Tim mentions that they enjoy watching \"Home Alone\" during Thanksgiving.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.34,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.83
    },
    {
      "question": "What tradition does Tim mention they love during Thanksgiving?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Prepping the feast and talking about what they're thankful for",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Thanksgiving and traditions in the context.  \n- Result 1: Tim says Thanksgiving is special, they love prepping the feast and talking about what they're thankful for, plus watching movies afterwards.  \n- Result 3: Tim says during Thanksgiving they usually watch a few movies, especially \"Home Alone.\"  \n- Result 8: Tim mentions loving \"The Santa Clause\" too during holidays.  \n- Result 10: Tim also mentions watching \"Elf\" during the holidays.  \n- Result 63: Tim describes watching \"Home Alone\" with family as a special memory during Thanksgiving.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the main tradition Tim highlights.  \nTim emphasizes that during Thanksgiving, they love prepping the feast, sharing what they are thankful for, and watching holiday movies together, especially \"Home Alone.\"\n\nFinal answer:  \nTim's favorite Thanksgiving tradition is prepping the feast, sharing gratitude, and watching holiday movies like \"Home Alone\" with family.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.84,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.02
    },
    {
      "question": "How long did John and his high school basketball teammates play together?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Four years",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about John and his high school basketball teammates.\n\n- Result 2 [2023-08-26]: John to Tim says, \"We were teammates for four years in high school, so we've played together for quite some time.\"\n\nStep 2: Confirm no conflicting information.\n\n- No other excerpt contradicts this duration.\n\nFinal answer: John and his high school basketball teammates played together for four years.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.21,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.72
    },
    {
      "question": "How was John's experience in New York City?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Amazing",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify all excerpts mentioning John's experience in New York City.\n\n- Result 4 (Tim to John): Tim asks John how NYC was.\n- Result 5 (John to Tim): John says NYC was amazing, with something new and exciting everywhere, and trying all the restaurants was awesome. He calls it a must-visit.\n- Result 1 (John to Tim): John says NYC is amazing with culture, food, and an unforgettable adventure.\n- Result 6 (John to Tim): John shares a picture from one of his trips to NYC.\n- Result 44 (John to Tim): John mentions having some trouble figuring out the subway at first but then it was easy after someone helped explain it.\n\nStep 2: Summarize the details.\n\nJohn's experience in NYC was very positive overall. He found the city amazing with lots to explore, especially the culture and food. He enjoyed trying many restaurants and found the city full of new and exciting things. He had a",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.14,
      "judge_latency_s": 3.6
    },
    {
      "question": "What did John say about NYC, enticing Tim to visit?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "It's got so much to check out - the culture, food - you won't regret it.",
      "generated_answer": "John described NYC as amazing with a lot to check out, highlighting its culture and food as unforgettable. He said everywhere you go there's something new and exciting, exploring the city and trying all the restaurants was awesome, and called it a must-visit adventure that Tim wouldn't regret.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.31,
      "judge_latency_s": 3.25
    },
    {
      "question": "What kind of soup did John make recently?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "tasty soup with sage",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: John mentioned making a tasty soup around August 24, 2023 (Result 2).\n\nStep 2: Tim asked for the recipe and spices used (Results 1 and 3).\n\nStep 3: John said he made it up on the spot and didn't have a recipe (Result 6).\n\nStep 4: John later added that he used sage for flavor (Result 44).\n\nStep 5: No other specific ingredients or type of soup were mentioned.\n\nFinal answer: John made a homemade soup flavored with sage, but he created it spontaneously and did not specify a particular kind of soup.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.88,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.13
    },
    {
      "question": "What spice did John add to the soup for flavor?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "sage",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant excerpts about the soup and spices.\n- Result 2: John mentions making a tasty soup around August 24, 2023.\n- Result 9: John says he made the soup up on the spot and doesn't have a recipe.\n- Result 12: John says he added some sage for a nice flavor.\n\nStep 2: Confirm that the spice mentioned is sage.\n- Result 12 explicitly states John added sage for flavor.\n\nFinal answer: John added sage to the soup for flavor.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.23,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.82
    },
    {
      "question": "What is Tim excited to see at Universal Studios?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "The Harry Potter stuff",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Universal Studios and Tim's excitement about it.\n- Result 1 (2023-08-31): John asks Tim if he has been to Universal Studios.\n- Result 90 (2023-08-31): Tim says, \"Thanks! Excited to try this. Love experimenting with spices. By the way, have you been to Universal Studios? Planning a trip there next month.\"\n- Result 61 (2023-08-31): Tim says, \"Nope, but it's my first time going. I'm super stoked for the Harry Potter stuff. Can't wait!\"\n\nStep 2: From Result 61, Tim explicitly states he is \"super stoked for the Harry Potter stuff\" at Universal Studios.\n\nFinal answer:  \nTim is excited to see the Harry Potter stuff at Universal Studios.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.06,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.35
    },
    {
      "question": "Where are John and his teammates planning to explore on a team trip?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "a new city",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about the team trip plans.\n\n- Result 1 (2023-09-21): John says they are planning a team trip next month to explore a new city but the destination is still undecided (Result 4).\n- Result 4 (2023-09-21): John asks Tim for suggestions on the destination.\n- Result 64 (2023-09-21): John mentions Edinburgh as a place worth considering for the trip, responding to Tim's suggestion.\n- Result 95 (2023-08-26): Tim asks how long John and his group played together, but no destination info.\n- No other excerpts specify a confirmed destination.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.\n\n- The trip was planned around late September 2023 for the next month (October 2023).\n- The destination was undecided as of September 21, 2023.\n- Edinburgh was suggested by Tim and considered by John as a possible destination",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.4,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.76
    },
    {
      "question": "What city did Tim suggest to John for the team trip next month?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Edinburgh, Scotland",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify when the team trip was mentioned.  \n- Result 1 (2023-09-21): John says they are planning a team trip next month.  \n- Result 7 (2023-09-21): John says they are still deciding on the destination and asks Tim for suggestions.  \n- Result 52 (2023-09-21): Tim responds, \"That sounds great! Exploring new cities is always so much fun. Where are you headed?\" \u2014 no suggestion yet.\n\nStep 2: Look for any city suggestions from Tim after 2023-09-21.  \n- Result 67 (2023-08-26): Tim says, \"Wow! That skyline looks amazing - I've been wanting to visit NYC. How was it?\" This is before the trip planning.  \n- Result 28 (2023-08-26): Tim says, \"Adding NYC to my travel list, sounds like a great adventure!\" Also before the trip",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.59,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.64
    },
    {
      "question": "What does John want to do after his basketball career?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "positively influence and inspire others, potentially start a foundation and engage in charity work",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about John's plans for life after basketball.\n\n- Result 1 (2023-09-21): John says he is focusing on better shooting and making an impact on the court, but also looking into endorsements and building his brand, emphasizing the importance of thinking about life after basketball.\n- Result 6 (2023-09-21): Tim asks John about his thoughts on life after basketball.\n- Result 72 (2023-12-06): John mentions improving his game, getting endorsement deals, and learning to market himself and boost his brand.\n- Result 75 (2023-12-26): John talks about doing seminars to help people with sports and marketing.\n- Result 37 (2023-12-26): John is working on supporting youth sports and fighting for fair chances in sports for underserved communities.\n- Result 4 (2023-08-11): John wants to make a difference off the court through charity or inspiring people.\n",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.47,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.78
    },
    {
      "question": "What advice did Tim give John about picking endorsements?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Ensure they align with values and brand, look for companies that share the desire to make a change and help others, make sure the endorsement feels authentic",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about endorsements and advice from Tim to John.\n\n- Result 1 (2023-09-21): Tim advises John to pick endorsements that align with his values and brand, emphasizing authenticity and shared desire to make a change and help others.\n\nStep 2: Confirm no other conflicting or additional advice from Tim is present.\n\n- Other mentions of endorsements mostly come from John describing his progress or Tim asking questions, but no other direct advice from Tim is found.\n\nFinal answer:  \nTim advised John to choose endorsements that align with his values and brand, ensuring the endorsement feels authentic to his followers and comes from companies that share his desire to make a positive change.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.18,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.84
    },
    {
      "question": "What book recommendation did Tim give to John for the trip?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "A fantasy novel by Patrick Rothfuss",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the time frame and context of the recommendation related to a trip.  \n- Result 1 (2023-09-21): John asks Tim for book recommendations for his trip.  \n- Result 26 (2023-09-21): Tim recommends a fantasy novel by Patrick Rothfuss, saying it\u2019s great for traveling.  \n- Result 22 (2023-08-09): Tim mentions a book by Patrick Rothfuss and praises it.  \n- Result 44 (2024-01-07): Tim says he is currently reading \"The Name of the Wind\" by Patrick Rothfuss.  \n- Result 50 (2024-01-07): John acknowledges \"The Name of the Wind\" and adds it to his list.  \n\nStep 2: Confirm the book title and author.  \n- Tim\u2019s recommendation is a fantasy novel by Patrick Rothfuss.  \n- The specific title mentioned later is \"The Name of the Wind",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.64,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.93
    },
    {
      "question": "What type of venue did John and his girlfriend choose for their wedding ceremony?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Greenhouse",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about John and his girlfriend's wedding venue.\n\n- Result 6: John mentions having an amazing and emotional wedding ceremony around September 25, 2023.\n- Result 4: John says they found a lovely greenhouse venue for a smaller, more intimate gathering.\n- Result 44: John says it was a great day with everyone celebrating, including some hiking club friends.\n- Result 12: John mentions their first dance was at a cozy restaurant with music and candlelight.\n\nStep 2: Focus on the venue for the ceremony itself.\n\n- Result 4 explicitly states the venue was a \"lovely greenhouse\" for an intimate gathering.\n- Other mentions (cozy restaurant) relate to the first dance, not the ceremony venue.\n\nFinal answer: John and his girlfriend chose a lovely greenhouse venue for their wedding ceremony.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.58,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.21
    },
    {
      "question": "What was the setting for John and his wife's first dance?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Cozy restaurant",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about John and his wife's first dance.  \n- Result 1: John to Tim mentions their first dance was at a cozy restaurant, dreamy with music and candlelight.  \n- Result 10: John to Tim recalls seeing his wife walking down the aisle as a magical moment.  \n- Result 75 and 66: John mentions celebrating at a restaurant with friends and family, having everyone there made it special.  \n- Result 81: John says they found a lovely greenhouse venue for a smaller, intimate gathering for the ceremony.\n\nStep 2: Focus on the first dance setting specifically.  \n- Result 1 clearly states the first dance was at a cozy restaurant with music and candlelight.  \n- Other mentions of venues (greenhouse) relate to the ceremony, not the dance.\n\nFinal answer:  \nJohn and his wife's first dance took place at a cozy restaurant with music and candlelight.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.69,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.65
    },
    {
      "question": "Which basketball team does Tim support?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "The Wolves",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Tim's favorite basketball team or player.  \n- In [Result 16] Tim says: \"The Wolves are solid and LeBron's skills and leadership are amazing.\"  \n- In [Result 55] Tim mentions he loves fantasy novels but no team info there.  \n- In [Result 26] John confirms: \"The Wolves are my team for sure. And LeBron is the man - love his skills and leadership.\"  \n- In [Result 42] John says: \"The Minnesota Wolves! I can't wait to play with them!\"  \n- In [Result 2] Tim asks John about favorite team/player, and in [Result 16] Tim reveals his own favorite team/player.\n\nStep 2: The \"Wolves\" mentioned are likely the Minnesota Wolves, as John is playing for them ([Result 42]). Tim supports the Wolves and admires LeBron.\n\nFinal answer:  \nTim supports the Minnesota Wolves basketball team.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.03,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.05
    },
    {
      "question": "What passion does Tim mention connects him with people from all over the world?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "passion for fantasy stuff",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Tim's passions and connections with people from different backgrounds.\n\n- Result 20 (2023-12-06): John says, \"Hey Tim! That's cool! I love learning about different cultures. It's really cool to meet people with different backgrounds. My teammates come from all over.\"\n- Result 16 (2024-01-02): John encourages Tim with \"Keep it up with German!\" and mentions communicating with different cultures.\n- Result 78 (2023-08-17): Tim says, \"Wow, John, that sounds amazing! I'm so happy they gave you a warm welcome back. It's such a special feeling when you realize that you share the same passions and talents with others. It's like finding your true place in the world.\"\n- Result 38 (2023-08-09): Tim says, \"It's incredible how a team creates such strong ties. Having support like that is so important.\"\n- Result 20 and 16 together",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        true,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.92,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.87
    },
    {
      "question": "How does John describe the game season for his team?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "intense with tough losses and great wins",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify all excerpts where John talks about the game season or how the season went.\n\n- Result 13 (2023-10-13): John says, \"It was an intense season with both tough losses and great wins. Overall, I'd say we did pretty well.\"\n- Result 29 (2023-10-13): John says, \"Thanks! We faced tough opponents but that's what drives us to get better. We back each other up and won't quit.\"\n- Result 34 (2023-12-19): John says, \"Things have been going great on the court. We've been putting in a lot of work and achieving our goals, which is awesome.\"\n- Result 88 (2023-10-13): John says, \"Yeah, it feels great! All that hard work and effort was totally worth it. We even won a trophy!\"\n- Result 89 (2023-12-08): John says, \"Thanks! The best part",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.84,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.89
    },
    {
      "question": "How does John say his team handles tough opponents?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "by backing each other up and not quitting",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify excerpts where John talks about handling tough opponents.\n\n- Result 5 [2023-10-13]: John says, \"We faced tough opponents but that's what drives us to get better. We back each other up and won't quit.\"\n- Result 30 [2023-10-13]: John mentions, \"It was an intense season with both tough losses and great wins. Overall, I'd say we did pretty well.\"\n- Result 56 [2023-10-13]: Tim asks John how they handled tough games, and John responds in Result 5.\n- Result 58 [2023-12-08]: John says, \"Been having some wild games lately, we played a top team and it was tough, but we fought hard and got the win! It's awesome having my team to push us all.\"\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.\n\nJohn emphasizes that tough opponents motivate the team to improve, they support each other, never quit, and",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.71,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.72
    },
    {
      "question": "What motivates John's team to get better, according to John?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "facing tough opponents",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts where John talks about what motivates his team.\n\n- Result 2 (2023-12-19): John says the team has grown most in communication and bonding, which helps performance by understanding strengths and weaknesses.\n- Result 15 (2023-10-17): John mentions challenges due to differences but finds it rewarding to watch teammates develop and reach goals.\n- Result 14 (2023-07-16): John says being surrounded by passionate teammates creates a strong bond and infectious love for the game.\n- Result 31 (2023-08-09): John says the team bond is awesome and makes hard work worth it.\n- Result 50 (2023-10-13): John says winning a trophy feels great and all hard work was worth it.\n- Result 10 (2023-10-21): John says his teammates believing in him and his love for improving skills keep him going.\n- Result 7 (2023-08",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.25,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.99
    },
    {
      "question": "What did John's team win at the end of the season?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "a trophy",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of winning or achievements at the end of the season.\n\n- Result 1 (2023-10-13): John says the season was intense with tough losses and great wins, overall pretty well.\n- Result 23 (2023-10-13): John says \"We even won a trophy!\"\n- Result 60 (2023-10-13): Tim congratulates John on the trophy.\n- Result 49 (2023-12-06): Tim congratulates John on the trophy.\n- Result 21 (2023-12-08): John says winning felt amazing and was worth the hard work.\n- Result 20 (2023-12-16): John confirms \"We won! It was really close, but we made it!\"\n- Result 19 (2023-12-16): John mentions a real battle last week (Dec 9, 2023) and a close win.\n- Result 40 (2023-",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.46,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.82
    },
    {
      "question": "Where did Tim capture the photography of the sunset over the mountain range?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Smoky Mountains",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Tim taking photos of nature or mountains.  \n- Result 6: Tim to John says he snapped a pic on his trip to the Smoky Mountains last year (around October 17, 2022).  \n- Result 19: Tim to John says he took a pic last summer (summer 2023) and it was stunning.  \n- Result 27: Tim to John says a picture reminds him of a trip he took last summer.  \n- Result 30: Tim to John asks John where he went camping, no direct info about Tim's sunset photo.  \n\nStep 2: Look for any mention of a sunset photo by Tim.  \n- Result 21: John to Tim mentions a sunset photo he took during practice, so that is John's photo, not Tim's.  \n- No direct mention of Tim's sunset photo in the excerpts.  \n\nStep 3: The question is about Tim's photography of a sunset over a mountain range",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.6,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.56
    },
    {
      "question": "How does John feel about being seen as a mentor by some of the younger players?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "It feels great",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about John being seen as a mentor.  \n- Result 3: John says some younger players see him as a mentor, which he finds really rewarding.  \n- Result 5: John feels great to have their trust and admiration and finds being a role model fulfilling.  \n- Result 1 and 2: John expresses that mentoring is awesome, fulfilling, and he enjoys making a positive impact.  \n- Result 6: Tim asks if any see John as a mentor, and John confirms positively in Result 3.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize John's feelings.  \nJohn feels honored, fulfilled, and rewarded by being seen as a mentor. He values the trust and admiration from the younger players and enjoys providing advice, support, and being a positive role model.\n\nFinal answer:  \nJohn feels honored and fulfilled to be seen as a mentor by the younger players, finding it rewarding to have their trust and admiration and to positively impact their growth.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.24,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.88
    },
    {
      "question": "What does John find rewarding about mentoring the younger players?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Seeing their growth, improvement, and confidence",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about John's mentoring experience.\n\n- Result 1: John says mentoring has been awesome, seeing their growth, improvement, and confidence is fulfilling.\n- Result 2: John finds mentoring super rewarding, loves sharing skills and knowledge, and staying involved in the game.\n- Result 4: John tries to provide advice and support on and off the court, enjoys being a positive role model.\n- Result 5: John feels great to have their trust and admiration, finds being a role model fulfilling, glad to help shape their future and inspire them.\n- Result 13: John acknowledges challenges but finds it awesome to motivate and encourage everyone and watch them develop and reach goals.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize these points.\n\nJohn finds mentoring rewarding because he enjoys seeing the younger players grow, improve, and gain confidence. He values their trust and admiration, likes providing advice and support both on and off the court, and feels fulfilled being a positive role model who can inspire and",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.26,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.6
    },
    {
      "question": "What has John been able to help the younger players achieve?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "reach their goals",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about John mentoring younger players and their achievements.\n\n- Result 4 (2023-10-17): John mentions mentoring younger players, sharing skills and knowledge, and staying involved in the game.\n- Result 6 (2023-10-17): John feels fulfilled being a role model and inspiring young athletes to pursue their dreams.\n- Result 10 (2023-10-17): John talks about motivating and encouraging everyone, watching them develop and reach their goals.\n- Result 14 (2023-12-26): John organized a basketball camp for kids, inspiring them and witnessing personal growth.\n- Result 34 (2023-10-17): Some younger players see John as a mentor; he provides advice and support on and off the court.\n- Result 73 (2023-10-17): Tim acknowledges it must be an honor to have their trust and admiration as a positive role model.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.42,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.94
    },
    {
      "question": "What genre is the novel that Tim is writing?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Fantasy",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify what Tim is writing about.  \n- From Result 29 (2023-08-02), Tim says: \"I'm writing articles about fantasy novels for an online mag.\"  \n- From Result 2 (2023-08-02), Tim says: \"I've been writing about different fantasy novels, studying characters, themes, and making book recommendations.\"  \n- From Result 95 (2023-11-06), Tim mentions a writing issue with a plot twist, indicating he is writing fiction, likely in the same genre he reads and discusses.\n\nStep 2: Confirm the genre focus.  \n- Tim consistently talks about fantasy novels (Results 1, 4, 25, 38, 46, 66, 72, 78, 91).  \n- He mentions fantasy authors like Patrick Rothfuss and J.K. Rowling, and fantasy series like \"The Wheel of Time\" and \"Game of Thrones.\"\n\nStep 3: S",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.48,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.58
    },
    {
      "question": "Who is one of Tim's sources of inspiration for writing?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "J.K. Rowling",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Tim's sources of inspiration for writing.  \n- Result 2: Tim mentions books, movies, real-life experiences, and specifically reading about castles in the UK as inspiration.  \n- Result 3 and 7: Tim specifically names J.K. Rowling as an inspiring writer whose style he studies and who has been with him for a long time.  \n- Result 23 and 71: Tim still favors fantasy books like Harry Potter and Game of Thrones, indicating ongoing inspiration from these works.  \n\nStep 2: Confirm the most explicitly named individual source of inspiration.  \n- J.K. Rowling is repeatedly mentioned by Tim as a favorite and inspiring author (Results 3, 7).  \n\nStep 3: Other inspirations like \"him\" mentioned in Results 5, 8, 10, 24, 28, 49, 55 refer to a male figure or character, but these are not explicitly linked to Tim's writing inspiration.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.43,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.82
    },
    {
      "question": "What J.K. Rowling quote does Tim resonate with?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "\"Turn on the light - happiness hides in the darkest of times.\"",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify where Tim mentions a J.K. Rowling quote.  \n- In [Result 3], Tim says: \"Yeah! There's a quote by J.K. Rowling that I really like: 'Turn on the light - happiness hides in the darkest of times.' That's how I keep hope alive during tough times.\"\n\nStep 2: Confirm that this is the quote Tim resonates with.  \n- Tim explicitly states he likes this quote and uses it to keep hope alive during tough times.\n\nFinal answer:  \nTim resonates with the J.K. Rowling quote: \"Turn on the light - happiness hides in the darkest of times.\"",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.43,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.77
    },
    {
      "question": "What does John write on the whiteboard to help him stay motivated?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "motivational quotes and strategies",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about the whiteboard and motivation.\n\n- Result 1 [2023-10-21]: John to Tim says he wrote down \"some motivational quotes and strategies\" on the whiteboard to help him stay focused and push through tough workouts.\n- Result 4 [2023-10-21]: John mentions a plaque on his desk as a physical reminder to believe in himself.\n- Result 31 [2023-10-21]: John says his teammates believing in him and his love for improving skills keep him going.\n- Result 34 and 49 [2023-10-21]: Tim and John mention motivational quotes, including one by J.K. Rowling.\n\nStep 2: Focus on the whiteboard specifically.\n\n- Result 1 is the only direct mention of the whiteboard content: \"motivational quotes and strategies\" to stay focused and push through tough workouts.\n\nStep 3: No specific quotes or exact strategies are detailed, only the general",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.28,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.77
    },
    {
      "question": "What hobby is a therapy for John when away from the court?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Cooking",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of John's activities away from the court.\n- Result 40: John says, \"And when I'm away from the court, cooking is therapy for me. It's a good way to be creative and experiment with flavors while taking a break.\"\n\nStep 2: Confirm no other hobbies are described as therapy for John.\n- No other hobby is explicitly described as therapy for John in the context.\n\nFinal answer: Cooking is therapy for John when he is away from the court.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.83,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.6
    },
    {
      "question": "What type of meal does John often cook using a slow cooker?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "honey garlic chicken with roasted veg",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of John cooking with a slow cooker or a specific meal he often makes.\n\n- Result 2: John mentions cooking as therapy and shares a photo of a meal he cooked.\n- Result 10: John says he often makes \"honey garlic chicken with roasted veg\" and is open to sharing recipes.\n- Result 1 and 3: Tim refers to a \"slow cooker meal\" John made and asks for the recipe.\n- Result 4, 5, 9, 64: John made a tasty soup recently (around August 24, 2023) but says he made it up on the spot and doesn't have a recipe; he used sage as a spice.\n\nStep 2: Determine if the \"slow cooker meal\" is the honey garlic chicken or the soup.\n\n- Tim calls it a \"slow cooker meal\" (Result 1).\n- John mentions honey garlic chicken with roasted veg as a favorite he makes often (Result 10).\n",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.69,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.49
    },
    {
      "question": "How will John share the honey garlic chicken recipe with the other person?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "write it down and mail it",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Tim expresses interest in John's honey garlic chicken recipe (Result 2, 2023-10-21).\n\nStep 2: John confirms he often makes the honey garlic chicken and is open to sharing recipes or suggestions (Result 1, 2023-10-21).\n\nStep 3: Tim thanks John for sharing the recipe and looks forward to trying it (Result 4, 2023-10-21).\n\nStep 4: John does not explicitly say how he will share the recipe, but since Tim thanks him for sharing it, it implies John either sent or will send the recipe directly in their conversation.\n\nFinal answer: John will share the honey garlic chicken recipe directly with Tim through their conversation, likely by sending the recipe text or details.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.52,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.98
    },
    {
      "question": "What was Tim's huge writing issue last week,as mentioned on November 6, 2023?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "He got stuck on a plot twist",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the date of the message mentioning the writing issue: Result 6 is from 2023-11-06, where Tim says \"Last week (approximately October 30, 2023), I had a huge writing issue.\"\n\nStep 2: Look at the details Tim provides about the issue: He \"got stuck on a plot twist and couldn't find my way out,\" which was \"crazy frustrating,\" but he eventually overcame it.\n\nFinal answer:  \nTim's huge writing issue last week (around October 30, 2023) was getting stuck on a plot twist and being unable to find his way out of it.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.77,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.2
    },
    {
      "question": "What does Tim have that serves as a reminder of hard work and is his prized possession?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "a basketball signed by his favorite player",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Tim's prized possession or something that reminds him of hard work.  \nStep 2: Result 65 states: Tim to John: \"I have something special too - this is my prized possession, a basketball signed by my favorite player. It serves as a reminder of all the hard work.\"  \nStep 3: This is a direct and clear statement about Tim's prized possession and its significance.\n\nFinal answer:  \nTim's prized possession is a basketball signed by his favorite player, which serves as a reminder of all the hard work.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.25,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.66
    },
    {
      "question": "Why do Tim and John find LeBron inspiring?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "LeBron's determination and the epic block in Game 7 of the '16 Finals",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Tim mentions an epic block by LeBron in a Finals game a few years back that changed the game and inspired him because it showed determination and never giving up (Result 2).\n\nStep 2: John elaborates on that block in Game 7 of the 2016 Finals where LeBron chased down Iguodala and pinned the ball, highlighting LeBron's determination and heart as reasons for loving basketball (Result 7).\n\nStep 3: Both Tim and John admire LeBron's skills, leadership, work ethic, and dedication to the game (Results 3, 5, 14).\n\nStep 4: John also notes LeBron as a great leader who puts others first, which is why he eventually becomes king (Result 57).\n\nStep 5: Tim appreciates how LeBron's moments of determination and heart are incredible and inspiring (Results 1, 70).\n\nFinal answer:  \nTim and John find LeBron inspiring because of his incredible determination, heart",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.48,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.23
    },
    {
      "question": "How did John describe the views during their road trip out on the European coastline?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Spectacular",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant excerpt about John's road trip on the European coastline.  \n- Result 1 [2023-11-11]: John to Tim says, \"My wife and I were road tripping out on the European coastline, and it was amazing! The views were spectacular...\"\n\nStep 2: Extract how John described the views.  \n- John described the views as \"spectacular.\"\n\nFinal answer: John described the views during their road trip on the European coastline as \"spectacular.\"",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.94,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.26
    },
    {
      "question": "What is one of Tim's favorite fantasy TV shows, as mentioned on November 11, 2023?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "\"That\"",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the date and context of the question: November 11, 2023.\n\nStep 2: Look for messages around that date mentioning Tim's favorite fantasy TV shows.\n\nStep 3: Result 5 (Nov 11, 2023) - John says he finished an amazing fantasy series.\n\nStep 4: Result 7 (Nov 11, 2023) - Tim responds: \"Same here. There's something special about being lost in an awesome fantasy realm... 'That' is one of my favorite fantasy shows. Have you seen it?\"\n\nStep 5: Result 20 (Nov 11, 2023) - John replies: \"Yeah, I saw 'That'! It's amazing...\"\n\nStep 6: The show Tim refers to as \"That\" is not explicitly named here, but from the context and other mentions, the only fantasy TV series explicitly named by Tim around this time is \"Game of Thrones\" (Result 38 on Dec",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.73,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.65
    },
    {
      "question": "How does Tim stay motivated during difficult study sessions?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Visualizing goals and success",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts where Tim talks about his study motivation or strategies.\n\n- Result 1 (2023-11-16): Tim says he is putting in his best effort and feeling optimistic.\n- Result 9 (2023-11-16): Tim explains he breaks studying into smaller parts: 25 minutes on, 5 minutes off for something fun, which makes it less overwhelming and keeps him on track.\n- Result 35 (2023-08-26): Tim mentions juggling studying with his fantasy reading hobby as a way to manage stress.\n- Result 29 (2023-08-31): Tim talks about tackling a new challenge (presentation) and feeling progress, which can be motivating.\n- Result 10 (2023-12-01): Tim reflects on a tough exam and turning it into a learning experience, showing resilience and determination.\n- Result 47 & 50 (2023-11-21): Tim and John discuss how books help motivate",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.12,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.13
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Tim say about his injury on 16 November, 2023?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "The doctor said it's not too serious",
      "generated_answer": "On 16 November 2023, Tim expressed sympathy and support about John's injury, saying \"Ouch, bummer about the injury. Hang tight\" (Result 2), \"Thanks! Appreciate your support. I hope your injury heals soon\" (Result 7), and \"Take care! Keep pushing on. Talk soon\" (Result 22). He also compared the injury to a serious limitation by saying, \"It's like if I couldn't read due to an injury\" (Result 1). \n\nFinal answer: On 16 November 2023, Tim acknowledged the injury as a bummer, expressed hope for John's recovery, appreciated John's support, and likened the injury to a serious impairment like not being able to read.",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.3,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.66
    },
    {
      "question": "What was the setback Tim faced in his writing project on 21 November, 2023?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Story based on experiences in the UK didn't go as planned",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the date and context of the setback.\n- Result 65 [2023-11-21T10:23:00] Tim to John mentions a setback last week (approximately November 14, 2023).\n- Result 5 [2023-11-06T11:41:00] Tim to John also mentions a writing issue around October 30, 2023, but this is earlier and a different event.\n\nStep 2: Understand the nature of the setback.\n- In Result 65, Tim says he tried writing a story based on his experiences in the UK, but it \"didn't go the way I wanted.\"\n- He asks John for advice on improving storytelling, indicating difficulty with the story's development or execution.\n\nStep 3: Confirm the timing.\n- The message is dated November 21, 2023, and refers to the setback happening \"last week,\" which aligns with approximately November 14, 2023.\n\nFinal",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.04,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.95
    },
    {
      "question": "How did John overcome his ankle injury from last season?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "stayed focused on recovery and worked hard to strengthen his body",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: John mentioned he had a major ankle injury last season that required time off and physical therapy (Result 1).\n\nStep 2: He stayed focused on his recovery and worked hard to strengthen his body (Result 1).\n\nStep 3: He did physical therapy exercises every day and tried to stay active during rehab (Results 44, 31).\n\nStep 4: After consistent rehab and physical therapy, he was able to jog without pain, marking a milestone in his recovery (Results 31, 28).\n\nStep 5: John emphasized patience, perseverance, and staying positive as key mental approaches to overcoming the injury (Results 1, 21, 76).\n\nFinal answer: John overcame his ankle injury by staying focused on recovery, doing daily physical therapy exercises, working hard to strengthen his body, and maintaining patience and perseverance throughout the process.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.94,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.35
    },
    {
      "question": "What motivated Tim to keep pushing himself to get better in writing and reading?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Love for writing and reading",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify Tim's sources of motivation related to writing and reading from the excerpts.\n\n- In [Result 1], Tim says books, movies, and real-life experiences fire up his creativity, and connecting with things he loves makes writing fun.\n- In [Result 5] and [Result 16], Tim mentions J.K. Rowling as an inspiring writer whose storytelling and style he admires and learns from.\n- In [Result 24], Tim says when things get tough, remembering why he loves writing and reading helps him stay motivated and push himself to improve.\n- In [Result 25], Tim enjoys getting lost in fantasy stories and learning ways to better himself through books on growth and psychology.\n- In [Result 42], Tim recently read a book (around Nov 14, 2023) that made a big impact on him about how small changes can make big differences, changing how he does things.\n- In [Result 31], Tim expresses a personal love for",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.95,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.69
    },
    {
      "question": "How did John overcome a mistake he made during a big game in basketball?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Worked hard to get better and focused on growth",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant excerpt about John's mistake in a big game.  \n- Result 1 [2023-11-21]: John says he messed up during a big game and found it hard to accept.  \n- Result 41 [2023-11-21]: Tim praises John for admitting mistakes and using them to improve.  \n- Result 12 [2023-11-21]: John mentions that difficult times are part of life and he remembers his passion for basketball to stay motivated.  \n- Result 28 [2023-11-21]: John reflects on challenges and tries to find ways to improve after setbacks.\n\nStep 2: Understand how John dealt with the mistake.  \n- He did not get stuck in the moment (Result 1).  \n- He worked hard to get better (Result 1).  \n- He reflected on what went wrong and how to improve (Result 28).  \n- He stayed motivated by remembering his love and enthusiasm for basketball",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.36,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.66
    },
    {
      "question": "What book did John recently finish rereading that left him feeling inspired and hopeful about following dreams?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "The Alchemist",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of John finishing or rereading a book that inspired him about following dreams.  \nStep 2: Result 12 states: \"[2023-11-21T10:31:30] John to Tim: I recently (approximately November 14, 2023) finished rereading 'The Alchemist' - it was really inspiring. It made me think again about following dreams and searching for our own personal legends. I felt really motivated and hopeful after reading it.\"\n\nThis directly answers the question.\n\nFinal answer:  \nJohn recently finished rereading \"The Alchemist,\" which left him feeling inspired and hopeful about following dreams.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 5.62,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.72
    },
    {
      "question": "How did \"The Alchemist\" impact John's perspective on following dreams?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "made him think again about following dreams and searching for personal legends",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of \"The Alchemist\" and John's reflections on it.\n\n- Result 1 (2023-11-21): John says rereading \"The Alchemist\" was inspiring, made him think about following dreams and searching for personal legends, and he felt motivated and hopeful.\n- Result 9 (2023-11-21): John says the book helped motivate him to keep chasing his dreams and trust the process.\n- Result 2 (2023-09-21): John says he read the book, loved it, and it made him think about life and the importance of following one's dreams.\n- Result 42 (2023-11-21): Tim says he read it a while back and it changed his perspective on goals; John agrees it had the same impact on him.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.\n\nJohn found \"The Alchemist\" inspiring and motivating, reinforcing the importance of following dreams and trusting the journey. It gave him hope",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.79,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.05
    },
    {
      "question": "What is John trying out to improve his strength and flexibility after recovery from ankle injury?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "yoga",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of John's recovery and activities after his ankle injury.  \n- Result 1 (2023-11-21): John talks about recovering from a major ankle injury.  \n- Result 10 (2023-12-16): John mentions doing physical therapy exercises daily during recovery.  \n- Result 12 (2023-12-16): John reports jogging without pain, a milestone in recovery.  \n\nStep 2: Look for mentions of activities John is trying to improve strength and flexibility after recovery.  \n- Result 16 (2023-12-01): John says yoga has been really awesome for improving strength, flexibility, focus, and balance during workouts.  \n- Result 33 (2023-12-01): John mentions trying yoga for extra strength and flexibility, calling it challenging but worth it.  \n- Result 48 (2023-12-01): John describes holding yoga poses for 30-60 seconds to build strength and stability.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 4.24,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.9
    },
    {
      "question": "How long does John usually hold the yoga pose he shared with Tim?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "30-60 seconds",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant excerpts about John's yoga pose duration.\n\n- Result 4 [2023-12-01T09:56:30] John to Tim: \"I typically hold it for 30-60 seconds. It really helps with building strength and stability!\"\n\nStep 2: Confirm this is the direct answer to the question.\n\nYes, John explicitly states how long he holds the yoga pose.\n\nFinal answer: John usually holds the yoga pose he shared with Tim for 30 to 60 seconds.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.27,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.84
    },
    {
      "question": "Where was the forest picture shared by John on December 1,2023 taken?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "near his hometown",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant messages about the forest picture shared by John on December 1, 2023.\n\n- Result 1 [2023-12-01T10:05:30] John to Tim: \"The photo is from a forest near my hometown. It's so tranquil.\"\n\nStep 2: Confirm the date and content match the question.\n\n- The message is from December 1, 2023.\n- John says the photo is from a forest near his hometown.\n\nStep 3: Check if there is any more specific location mentioned for that forest.\n\n- No other message specifies the exact location of the forest photo John shared on December 1, 2023.\n- Other forest mentions (e.g., Result 4, 14, 39) talk about a gorgeous forest for a photoshoot or a peaceful river spot, but no direct link to the December 1 photo or a more precise location.\n\nStep 4: Synthesize the information.\n\n- The",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.86,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.26
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Tim recently start learning in addition to being part of a travel club and working on studies?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "an instrument",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify when Tim mentioned joining a travel club and working on studies.  \n- From Result 1 and Result 58 (both dated 2023-12-06), Tim says he joined a travel club and is working on studies.\n\nStep 2: Look for what new skill Tim started learning recently.  \n- Result 1 states Tim \"Recently (approximately November 29, 2023) started learning an instrument.\"  \n- Result 84 (2023-08-21) also mentions Tim started learning how to play the piano, which is an instrument.\n\nStep 3: Confirm the instrument Tim is learning.  \n- Result 84 explicitly says \"I've also started learning how to play the piano.\"\n\nStep 4: Synthesize the timeline and details.  \n- Tim joined a travel club and is working on studies as of early December 2023.  \n- Around November 29, 2023, he started learning piano.\n\nFinal answer:  \nTim recently",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.35,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.55
    },
    {
      "question": "What instrument is Tim learning to play in December 2023?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "violin",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant time frame: December 2023.\n\nStep 2: Look for mentions of Tim learning an instrument around that time.\n\n- Result 1 (2023-12-06): Tim says he recently (around Nov 29, 2023) started learning an instrument.\n- Result 5 (2023-12-06): Tim specifies he is learning the violin now.\n- Result 10 (2023-12-06): Tim says he has been playing for about four months, consistent with starting late November.\n- Result 2 and 6 show John asking about the instrument and piano, but Tim clarifies violin in Result 5.\n\nStep 3: Confirm no conflicting information.\n\n- Earlier (Result 90, 2023-08-21), Tim was learning piano.\n- By December 2023, Tim is learning violin as a new instrument.\n\nFinal answer:  \nTim is learning to play the violin in December 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.54,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.99
    },
    {
      "question": "How long has Tim been playing the piano for, as of December 2023?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "about four months",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify when Tim started learning the piano.  \n- From Result 2 (dated 2023-12-06T17:38:00), Tim says he \"Recently (approximately November 29, 2023) started learning an instrument.\"  \n- From Result 32 (2023-12-06T17:39:00), Tim clarifies he is learning the violin now, but earlier messages indicate piano as well.\n\nStep 2: Check if Tim mentions piano specifically and for how long.  \n- Result 24 (2023-08-21T16:34:30) Tim says: \"I've also started learning how to play the piano - it's a learning curve, but it's so satisfying seeing the progress I make! Life's good.\" This indicates he was learning piano as of August 21, 2023.  \n- Result 6 (2023-12-06T17:40:00) Tim says: \"I've been",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.1,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.81
    },
    {
      "question": "What book did Tim just finish reading on 8th December, 2023?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "\"A Dance with Dragons\"",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify messages around December 8, 2023, mentioning Tim reading or finishing a book.\n\n- Result 11 [2023-12-08T19:46:30] John to Tim: John says he is currently reading a book he enjoys.\n- Result 15 [2023-12-08T19:49:00] Tim to John: Tim says \"Just the GoT series. Have you tried reading any of them?\"\n- Result 16 [2023-12-08T19:49:30] John to Tim: John replies he hasn't read them yet but will check them out.\n- Result 24 [2023-12-08T19:48:30] John to Tim: John asks if Tim has read all of George R. R. Martin's books.\n- Result 43 [2023-11-21T10:32:00] Tim to John: Tim says he read a book a while back",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.79,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.62
    },
    {
      "question": "Which book did Tim recommend to John as a good story on 8th December, 2023?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "\"A Dance with Dragons\"",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the date and relevant messages around December 8, 2023.\n\n- Result 6 [2023-12-08T19:48:30] John to Tim: \"That's cool! I've heard it's such an inspiring book. Have you read all of George R. R. Martin's books?\"\n- Result 8 [2023-12-08T19:46:30] John to Tim: \"Thanks! I'm currently reading a book that I really enjoy. I highly recommend it!\"\n- Result 12 [2023-12-08T19:49:00] Tim to John: \"Just the GoT series. Have you tried reading any of them?\"\n- Result 13 [2023-12-08T19:49:30] John to Tim: \"No, I haven't read them yet but I'll definitely check them out. Cheers!\"\n- Result 69 [2023-12-08T19:46:00",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.89,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.8
    },
    {
      "question": "What is the topic of discussion between John and Tim on 11 December, 2023?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Academic achievements and sports successes",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify all messages dated 11 December 2023:\n- [Result 3] Tim to John: \"Definitely. We both have so much potential! Let's keep supporting each other on our journey towards our dreams.\"\n- [Result 40] Tim to John: \"Wow! It's really important to do our own thing and follow our dreams. Keep it up, you're gonna do amazing things!\"\n- [Result 43] John to Tim: \"Hey Tim, great to see you! Any new success stories?\"\n- [Result 55] Tim to John: \"Hey John, I had a tough time with my English lit class. Did an analysis on this series and I think it went ok!\"\n- [Result 60] John to Tim: \"Your encouragement means a lot. Let's keep pushing and following our dreams - we can make a difference!\"\n- [Result 68] Tim to John: \"Thanks, it means a lot. Let's keep each other motivated.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.48,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.91
    },
    {
      "question": "What kind of game did John have a career-high in assists in?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "basketball",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of John's career-high in assists.  \n- Result 1 (2023-12-11): John says to Tim, \"I had a career-high in assists last Friday in our big game against our rival.\"\n\nStep 2: Determine the type of game.  \n- The phrase \"our big game against our rival\" suggests it was a significant competitive basketball game, likely a regular season or rivalry match.\n\nStep 3: Confirm the sport.  \n- Throughout the conversation, John talks about basketball, his basketball career, and games. So the game with the career-high assists is a basketball game.\n\nFinal answer:  \nJohn had a career-high in assists in a big basketball game against their rival team.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.32,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.33
    },
    {
      "question": "What was John's way of dealing with doubts and stress when he was younger?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "practicing basketball outside for hours",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for mentions of John's experiences with doubts and stress when he was younger.\n\nStep 2: In [Result 15] (2023-12-11), John says: \"Yeah, that pic reminds me of when I was younger. I'd practice basketball outside for hours, dreaming of playing in big games. It was my way of dealing with doubts and stress.\"\n\nStep 3: This clearly states that John's way of dealing with doubts and stress when he was younger was practicing basketball outside for hours and dreaming of playing in big games.\n\nFinal answer:  \nJohn dealt with doubts and stress when he was younger by practicing basketball outside for hours and dreaming of playing in big games.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.31,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.36
    },
    {
      "question": "How did John feel about the atmosphere during the big game against the rival team?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "electric and intense",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about the big game against the rival team and the atmosphere.\n\n- Result 3 [2023-12-11T20:30:00] John to Tim: \"The atmosphere in the arena was really electric and playing against our rivals added an extra level of intensity. It was a memorable night!\"\n- Result 4 [2023-10-02T15:12:30] John to Tim: \"The energy was crazy and everyone was so hyped.\"\n- Result 5 [2023-12-11T20:31:00] John to Tim: \"The atmosphere was incredible and it was such a thrilling experience.\"\n- Result 46 [2023-12-11T20:31:30] Tim to John: \"Moments like that make us love sports, huh? I still think about this pic you sent me a while back.\"\n- Result 35 [2023-12-11T20:29:",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.52,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.36
    },
    {
      "question": "How did John feel after being able to jog without pain?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "It was a huge success.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about John jogging without pain.  \n- Result 5 (2023-12-16): John says, \"Last Friday, I had a milestone moment at the gym. I was able to jog a bit with no pain, which was such a relief!\"  \n- Result 2 (2023-12-16): John says, \"It was great! After being out for so long, jogging without any pain was a huge success.\"  \n- Result 63 (2023-12-16): John says, \"Yeah, it really does. It keeps me motivated to keep putting in the effort and makes all the tough times worth it.\"\n\nStep 2: Synthesize feelings expressed.  \nJohn felt relief, success, and motivation after jogging without pain. It was a milestone and a huge success after a long recovery.\n\nFinal answer:  \nJohn felt relieved, successful, and motivated after being able to jog without pain, seeing it as a significant milestone",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.84,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.18
    },
    {
      "question": "What kind of deal did John get in December?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Deal with a renowned outdoor gear company",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of deals John got in December.\n- Result 41 (2023-12-19): John tells Tim he got an amazing deal with a renowned outdoor gear company around December 12, 2023.\n- Result 18 (2024-01-12): John mentions an endorsement with a popular beverage company around January 5, 2024, which is after December.\n\nStep 2: Confirm the timing and type of deal in December.\n- The deal in December is specifically with an outdoor gear company, described as \"amazing\" and \"renowned.\"\n- The beverage company endorsement happened in January, so it is not the December deal.\n\nFinal answer:  \nIn December, John got an amazing deal with a renowned outdoor gear company.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.03,
      "judge_latency_s": 3.54
    },
    {
      "question": "Where was the photoshoot done for John's gear deal?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "In a gorgeous forest",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the message about John's gear deal and photoshoot.  \n- Result 24 (2023-12-19): John says he got a deal with a renowned outdoor gear company.  \n- Result 3 (2023-12-19): John mentions he got hiking and outdoor gear and the photoshoot went well in a gorgeous forest.  \n- Result 4 (2023-12-01): John says the photo is from a forest near his hometown.  \n- Result 9 (2023-12-01): Tim asks where the magical forest photo was taken.  \n- Result 53 (2023-12-19): John sends a photo and says nature energizes him.  \n- Result 37 (2023-12-01): John mentions camping in the mountains, but this is separate from the photoshoot.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the location details.  \n- The photoshoot for the gear was done in a \"gorgeous forest",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.96,
      "judge_latency_s": 3.1
    },
    {
      "question": "In which area has John's team seen the most growth during training?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Communication and bonding",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about team growth during training.\n\n- Result 3 [2023-12-19T10:10:30] John to Tim: \"Our team has seen the most growth in communication and bonding. It has really helped our performances by allowing us to understand each other's strengths and weaknesses.\"\n\nStep 2: Confirm no conflicting information.\n\n- No other excerpt contradicts this; other mentions of growth focus on individual skills or mentoring.\n\nFinal answer: John's team has seen the most growth in communication and bonding during training.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.74,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.66
    },
    {
      "question": "What type of seminars is John conducting?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Sports and marketing seminars",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify all mentions of seminars by John.  \n- Result 5 (2023-12-26): John says he started doing seminars helping people with their sports and marketing.  \n- Result 1 (2023-12-26): John mentions seminars went well with aspiring profs eager and motivated.  \n- Result 43 (2023-12-26): John talks about using his influence and resources to help causes, showing he is involved in impactful activities, possibly related to seminars.\n\nStep 2: Combine details:  \n- The seminars involve helping people with sports and marketing (Result 5).  \n- The audience includes aspiring professionals (Result 1).  \n\nStep 3: No other seminar types or topics are mentioned.\n\nFinal answer:  \nJohn is conducting seminars focused on sports and marketing, aimed at helping aspiring professionals.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.89,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.85
    },
    {
      "question": "What activity did Tim do after reading the stories about the Himalayan trek?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "visited a travel agency",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Tim mentioned reading stories about two hikers trekking through the Himalayas (Result 2).\n\nStep 2: The book described the trek as tough but rewarding, with challenges like altitude sickness and bad weather (Result 3).\n\nStep 3: Tim said the stories really motivated him (Result 3).\n\nStep 4: Tim also said he is using these traveler stories to plan his next adventure (Result 30).\n\nFinal answer: After reading the stories about the Himalayan trek, Tim was motivated and started using them to plan his next adventure.",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.02,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.74
    },
    {
      "question": "What is one cause that John supports with his influence and resources?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "youth sports and fair chances in sports",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of causes John supports.  \n- Result 1: John says he uses his influence and resources to help causes he believes in.  \n- Result 7: Tim asks John what causes he is working on.  \n- Result 29: John says he wants to use his platform to make a positive difference and inspire others, maybe start a foundation and do charity work.  \n- Result 63: John says he is teaming up with a local organization that helps disadvantaged kids with sports and school, hoping to have a positive impact on the community.  \n- Result 44, 50, 51: Tim encourages John about charity work and making a difference.  \n- Result 61: Tim says making a difference to those kids was great, praising John's passion for helping others.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.  \nJohn supports disadvantaged kids by teaming up with a local organization that helps them with sports and school, using his platform to positively impact the community.\n\n",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.58,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.82
    },
    {
      "question": "What new fantasy TV series is Tim excited about?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "\"The Wheel of Time\"",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify where Tim mentions a new fantasy TV series.  \n- In [Result 1] (2023-12-26), Tim says: \"There's a new fantasy TV series coming out next month - can't wait!\"  \n- In [Result 5] (2023-12-26), Tim specifies: \"I'm really excited to watch this new show that's coming out called 'The Wheel of Time'. It's based on a book series that I love.\"\n\nStep 2: Confirm no other new fantasy TV series is mentioned by Tim.  \n- No other new series names appear in the context.\n\nFinal answer:  \nTim is excited about the new fantasy TV series called \"The Wheel of Time.\"",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.1,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.36
    },
    {
      "question": "Which language is Tim learning?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "German",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Tim learning a language.  \n- Result 4: Tim says, \"I'm learning German now - tough but fun.\"  \n- Result 5: Tim says, \"Learning German has been tough but worth it.\"  \n- Result 1: Tim says, \"That app is great. Learning another language is tough...\" (context of German)  \n- Result 8: Tim asks John about resources for learning Spanish but is using an app himself (likely for German).  \n- Result 6: John acknowledges Tim learning German and knows a bit of it himself.  \n\nStep 2: Confirm no other language is mentioned as Tim's current learning focus.  \n- John is learning Spanish (Result 3).  \n- Tim is learning German (multiple mentions).  \n\nFinal answer: Tim is learning German.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.88,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.12
    },
    {
      "question": "What language does Tim know besides German?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Spanish",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Tim mentions learning German and says it is easier because he took French in high school (Result 6: \"it's much easier when I took French in high school\").\n\nStep 2: There is no direct statement that Tim is currently fluent in French, but he has studied it before.\n\nStep 3: No other languages besides German and French are mentioned as known by Tim.\n\nFinal answer: Besides German, Tim knows French from high school.",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.85,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.27
    },
    {
      "question": "What book did Tim get in Italy that inspired him to cook?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "a cooking book",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Italy and books related to cooking or inspiration.\n\n- Result 1 (2024-01-02): John says to Tim, \"Italy was awesome! ... I even got this awesome book while I was there and it's been giving me some cooking inspiration.\"\n- Result 20 and 40 (2024-01-02): Tim asks John about his trip to Italy last month (December 2023).\n- No direct mention from Tim about a book he got in Italy.\n\nStep 2: Check if Tim mentions any book he got in Italy or a book inspiring his cooking.\n\n- Result 25 (2024-01-07): Tim says he is reading \"The Name of the Wind\" by Patrick Rothfuss, a fantasy novel.\n- Result 4 and 64: Patrick Rothfuss's book is mentioned as a fantasy novel, not related to cooking.\n- No direct mention of Tim getting a cooking book in Italy.\n\nStep 3",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 4.19,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.71
    },
    {
      "question": "What is John's favorite book series?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Harry Potter",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for mentions of John\u2019s favorite books or series in the excerpts.\n\nStep 2: In [Result 29] (2024-01-02), John says: \"I'm a huge fan of Lord of the Rings! The adventure, the world, and the characters are awesome.\"\n\nStep 3: In [Result 30] (2024-01-02), John mentions watching the movies and his favorite character is Aragorn, which aligns with Lord of the Rings.\n\nStep 4: In [Result 39] (2023-12-01), John says: \"The Hobbit is one of my favorites too. What an amazing journey!\" The Hobbit is part of the Lord of the Rings universe.\n\nStep 5: No other series is explicitly stated as John\u2019s favorite series.\n\nFinal answer: John's favorite book series is Lord of the Rings.",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.84,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.86
    },
    {
      "question": "According to John, who is his favorite character from Lord of the Rings?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Aragorn",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify where John mentions his favorite character from Lord of the Rings.\n- In [Result 3] (2024-01-02T17:37:30), John says: \"My favorite character is Aragorn, he grows so much throughout the story.\"\n- In [Result 8] (2024-01-02T17:38:30), John explains why Aragorn is his favorite: \"He's a great leader and puts others first - that's why he eventually becomes king.\"\n- In [Result 9] (2024-01-02T17:40:30), John further praises Aragorn's qualities: \"Aragorn's brave, selfless, down-to-earth attitude is what inspired me. He never gives up and always stands up for justice.\"\n- In [Result 89] (2024-01-02T17:39:30), John says: \"Yeah. His journey is really inspiring. I have a painting",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.78,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.32
    },
    {
      "question": "Why does John like Aragorn from Lord of the Rings?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "brave, selfless, down-to-earth attitude",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify all mentions of John talking about Aragorn and why he likes him.\n\n- Result 4: John says Aragorn is his favorite character because he grows so much throughout the story.\n- Result 7: John says Aragorn is a great leader and puts others first, which is why he eventually becomes king.\n- Result 2: John says Aragorn's brave, selfless, down-to-earth attitude inspires him; he never gives up and always stands up for justice.\n- Result 58: John has a painting of Aragorn in his room to remind him to stay true and be a leader.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize these points.\n\nJohn admires Aragorn for his growth, leadership, selflessness, bravery, and commitment to justice. Aragorn's journey from ranger to king and his qualities as a leader who puts others first inspire John personally.\n\nFinal answer:  \nJohn likes Aragorn because he is a brave, selfless leader who grows significantly throughout the",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.94,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.78
    },
    {
      "question": "What kind of painting does John have in his room as a reminder?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "a painting of Aragorn",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of John having a painting in his room.  \n- Result 1: John to Tim says, \"I have a painting in my room to remind me to stay true and be a leader in everything I do.\"\n\nStep 2: Look for details about the painting's subject or style.  \n- Result 1 mentions the painting is inspiring and connected to \"his journey,\" but does not specify who \"he\" is or what the painting depicts.  \n- Result 17 and 26 show Tim asking John why \"he\" is inspiring and why \"he\" is John's favorite, implying the painting is of a person John admires.  \n- Result 74: Tim mentions fantasy books like LOTR and getting lost in another world, but no direct link to the painting.  \n- No other results describe the painting's image or style.\n\nStep 3: Synthesize the information.  \n- The painting is of a person John finds inspiring, serving as a reminder",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.85,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.18
    },
    {
      "question": "What is the painting of Aragorn a reminder for John to be in everything he does?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "be a leader",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant excerpt about the painting of Aragorn.  \n- Result 3 [2024-01-02T17:39:30] John to Tim: \"Yeah. His journey is really inspiring. I have a painting in my room to remind me to stay true and be a leader in everything I do.\"\n\nStep 2: Understand what the painting reminds John to be.  \n- John says the painting reminds him \"to stay true and be a leader in everything I do.\"\n\nFinal answer:  \nThe painting of Aragorn is a reminder for John to stay true and be a leader in everything he does.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.77,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.07
    },
    {
      "question": "What map does Tim show to his friend John?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "a map of Middle-earth from LOTR",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant messages about the map Tim shows to John.\n\n- Result 1 (2024-01-02): John asks Tim about the map.\n- Result 17 (2024-01-02): Tim replies, \"It's a map of Middle-earth from LOTR - it's really cool to see all the different realms and regions.\"\n\nStep 2: Confirm no conflicting information.\n\n- No other messages contradict this.\n- The map is clearly identified as Middle-earth from \"LOTR\" (Lord of the Rings).\n\nFinal answer:  \nTim shows John a map of Middle-earth from the Lord of the Rings (LOTR).",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.91,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.84
    },
    {
      "question": "Where will Tim be going for a semester abroad?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Ireland",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant excerpt about Tim's study abroad plans.  \n- Result 2 [2024-01-07T17:24:00] Tim to John: \"Next month, I'm off to Ireland for a semester.\"  \n- Result 42 [2024-01-07T17:25:00] Tim to John: \"Thanks! I'm gonna stay in Galway, it's great for its arts and Irish music.\"\n\nStep 2: Confirm the location for the semester abroad.  \n- Tim explicitly states he is going to Ireland for a semester and will stay in Galway.\n\nFinal answer:  \nTim will be going to Ireland for a semester abroad, staying in Galway.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.42,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.84
    },
    {
      "question": "Which city in Ireland will Tim be staying in during his semester abroad?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Galway",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant messages about Tim's study abroad in Ireland.  \n- Result 2 (2024-01-07): Tim says he got into the study abroad program and will be in Ireland next month for a semester.  \n- Result 1 (2024-01-07): Tim says he will stay in Galway, praising its arts and Irish music.  \n- Result 4 (2024-01-07): John confirms Galway looks amazing and asks what Tim wants to check out there.  \n- Result 78 (2024-01-07): Tim mentions wanting to visit The Cliffs of Moher, which is near Galway.\n\nStep 2: Confirm the city Tim will stay in.  \nTim explicitly states he will stay in Galway.\n\nFinal answer:  \nTim will be staying in Galway during his semester abroad in Ireland.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.65,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.63
    },
    {
      "question": "What charity event did John organize recently in 2024?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "benefit basketball game",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of charity events organized by John in the context.\n\n- Result 25 (2023-12-26): John mentions organizing a basketball camp for kids in his hometown last summer (summer 2023), describing it as an awesome experience.\n\n- Result 13 (2024-01-07): John says the game turned out to be a total success, with lots of people showing up and raising money for charity.\n\n- Result 3 (2024-01-07): Tim congratulates John on organizing the event, saying it\u2019s really making a difference.\n\nStep 2: Correlate the timing and details.\n\n- The basketball camp was last summer (2023), so not recent in 2024.\n\n- The \"game\" mentioned by John on 2024-01-07 is described as a successful event that raised money for charity, implying it is a recent charity event in 2024.\n\nStep 3: Conclusion.\n\nThe recent charity event",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.87,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.05
    },
    {
      "question": "What achievement did John share with Tim in January 2024?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "endorsement with a popular beverage company",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for messages from January 2024 mentioning achievements by John.  \nStep 2: In Result 19 (2024-01-12), John tells Tim about a \"wild\" and \"incredible\" event from last week (around January 5, 2024), revealing he got an endorsement with a popular beverage company.  \nStep 3: Tim congratulates him and asks how it felt to seal the deal (Result 21).  \nStep 4: This endorsement is the specific achievement John shared in January 2024.\n\nFinal answer:  \nJohn shared with Tim that he secured an endorsement deal with a popular beverage company in early January 2024.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.0,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.22
    },
    {
      "question": "What was Johns's reaction to sealing the deal with the beverage company?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "crazy feeling, sense of accomplishment",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant messages about the deal with the beverage company.  \n- Result 2 (2024-01-12): John says last week (around Jan 5, 2024) was wild and a total dream come true because he got an endorsement with a popular beverage company.  \n- Result 4 (2024-01-12): John says it felt crazy and that it was not just about signing but about feeling all the hard work paid off.  \n- Result 1 (2024-01-12): Tim congratulates John and asks how it felt to seal the deal.  \n- Result 50 (2023-07-16): Tim congratulates John on deals with Nike and Gatorade, showing excitement about his endorsements.\n\nStep 2: Summarize John's reaction.  \nJohn described sealing the deal as a \"total dream come true,\" \"crazy,\" and a feeling that all his hard work and training hours were worth it.\n\n",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.39,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.9
    },
    {
      "question": "Which city did John recommend to Tim in January 2024?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Barcelona",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify messages from January 2024 where John recommends a city to Tim.  \nStep 2: Result 70 [2024-01-12T13:46:30] John to Tim says: \"Barcelona is a must-visit city! You'll love exploring the culture, admiring the architecture, and tasting the amazing food in each neighborhood. Plus, the nearby beaches are great for soaking up the sun. Definitely add it to your travel list!\"  \nStep 3: This is a clear recommendation of Barcelona in January 2024.\n\nFinal answer: John recommended Barcelona to Tim in January 2024.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-43",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.88,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.57
    },
    {
      "question": "Which year did Audrey adopt the first three of her dogs?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "2020",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Audrey's dogs and their ages.\n\n- Result 4 (2023-07-03): Audrey says \"They're all 3-year-old and they are a great pack.\"\n- Result 58 (2023-08-16): Audrey mentions having four dogs total, implying the first three were already there before the fourth.\n\nStep 2: Determine the date of the conversation and calculate the approximate adoption year.\n\n- The message about the dogs being 3 years old is from July 3, 2023.\n- If the dogs were 3 years old in mid-2023, they were likely adopted or born around 2020.\n\nStep 3: Check for any earlier mentions of the dogs.\n\n- Result 6 (2023-04-02) mentions adopting another puppy called Pixie, implying Pixie is a later addition.\n- Result 24 (2023-07-27) mentions Max as a childhood dog, so Max is not",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 64.55,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.55
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Andrew start his new job as a financial analyst?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "The week before March 27, 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant excerpt mentioning Andrew's new job.  \n- Result 1 [2023-03-27]: Andrew says he started a new job as a Financial Analyst last week, approximately March 20, 2023.\n\nStep 2: Confirm no other conflicting or additional information about the job start date is present.  \n- No other excerpts mention a different start date.\n\nFinal answer: Andrew started his new job as a Financial Analyst around March 20, 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.96,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.52
    },
    {
      "question": "What kind of indoor activities has Andrew pursued with his girlfriend?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "boardgames, volunteering at pet shelter, wine tasting, growing flowers",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Andrew and his girlfriend doing activities together indoors.  \nStep 2: Look for specific indoor activities mentioned in the context.  \nStep 3: Check for any direct statements from Andrew about indoor activities with his girlfriend.\n\nFrom the context:  \n- Result 36 [2023-10-13]: Andrew mentions a \"Friday night's board game session\" as a nice break, which implies an indoor activity.  \n- Result 1 and 71 [2023-04-16]: Andrew and his girlfriend enjoy discovering new cafes and trying pastries, which is more of an outing but could be indoor.  \n- Result 75 [2023-11-04]: Andrew and his girlfriend went on a bike ride and to a park, which is outdoor.  \n- No other direct mentions of indoor activities with his girlfriend.\n\nFinal answer:  \nAndrew has pursued indoor board game sessions with his girlfriend as an indoor activity.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.5,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.17
    },
    {
      "question": "What kind of places have Andrew and his girlfriend checked out around the city?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "cafes, new places to eat, open space for hikes, pet shelter, wine tasting event, park",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Andrew and his girlfriend exploring places around the city.\n- Result 2 (2023-04-16): Andrew says he and his girlfriend love discovering new places to eat around town.\n- Result 63 (2023-10-13): Andrew mentions a new spot that just opened recently with a great view and vibe.\n- Result 65 (2023-04-16): Andrew mentions finding an awesome cafe with amazing pastries.\n- Result 24 (2023-06-02): Andrew is still hunting for a pet-friendly spot in the city.\n- Result 52 (2023-05-06): Andrew is looking for a place near a park or woods to stay close to nature.\n- Result 71 (2023-11-04): Andrew and his girlfriend went on a bike ride and found a cool park outside of town.\n- Result 75 (2023-10-01): Andrew says he and his girlfriend are planning a beach",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.49,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.41
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Audrey make muffins for herself?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "The week of April 3rd to 9th",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Audrey making muffins or pastries.  \n- Result 14 [2023-04-16]: Audrey says she made some of her favorite treats last week (approximately April 09, 2023).  \n- Result 1 and 5 [2023-04-16]: Andrew talks about having croissants, muffins, and tarts, which Audrey responds to with excitement about pastries.\n\nStep 2: Confirm the date Audrey made the muffins.  \n- Audrey explicitly states in Result 14 that she made the treats last week, approximately April 09, 2023, and the message is dated April 16, 2023.\n\nFinal answer: Audrey made muffins for herself around April 9, 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.04,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.62
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Audrey see a hummingbird?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "first week of May 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Audrey seeing a hummingbird.  \n- Result 2 (2023-05-03): Audrey says \"Last week (approximately April 26, 2023) I finally went on a hike and had this amazing experience with a hummingbird.\"  \n- Result 1 (2023-05-03): Andrew references the hummingbird Audrey mentioned.\n\nStep 2: Confirm the date of the hummingbird sighting.  \n- Audrey explicitly states it was \"last week\" from her message dated May 3, 2023, which places the hummingbird sighting around April 26, 2023.\n\nFinal answer: Audrey saw the hummingbird around April 26, 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.16,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.23
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Audrey adopt Pixie?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "around April 2, 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Pixie's adoption.\n- Result 2 (2023-04-02T14:42:00) Audrey to Andrew: \"We adopted another puppy called Pixie.\"\n- Result 1 (2023-04-02T14:44:00) Audrey to Andrew: Pixie is fitting in great, implying recent adoption.\n- Result 46 (2023-04-02T14:45:00) Audrey to Andrew: Pepper took a bit to get used to Pixie, again indicating Pixie is new.\n\nStep 2: The earliest mention of Pixie is on April 2, 2023, and Audrey talks about the adoption as a recent event.\n\nStep 3: No earlier messages mention Pixie, so the adoption likely happened very shortly before April 2, 2023.\n\nFinal answer: Audrey adopted Pixie around early April 2023, just before April 2, 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.64,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.48
    },
    {
      "question": "How many years passed between Audrey adopting Pixie and her other three dogs?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "three years",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify when Audrey adopted Pixie.\n- Result 3 (2023-04-02): Audrey says, \"We adopted another puppy called Pixie.\"\n- This indicates Pixie was adopted around early April 2023.\n\nStep 2: Identify the age of the other three dogs.\n- Result 5 (2023-07-03): Audrey says, \"They're all 3-year-old and they are a great pack.\"\n- This means the other three dogs were 3 years old as of July 2023.\n\nStep 3: Calculate the difference in years between Pixie's adoption and the other dogs' age.\n- If the other dogs were 3 years old in mid-2023, they were born around 2020.\n- Pixie was adopted in 2023.\n- The difference is approximately 3 years.\n\nFinal answer: About 3 years passed between Audrey adopting Pixie and her other three dogs.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.61,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.05
    },
    {
      "question": "Did Andrew have a pet dog during March 2023?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "No",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for any direct mentions of Andrew having a dog around March 2023.\n\n- Result 6 (2023-03-27): Andrew to Audrey says, \"No, no pets right now. But I do love animals.\" This clearly indicates Andrew did not have a pet dog at that time.\n\nStep 2: Check if there is any contradictory information around that time.\n\n- No other messages from March 2023 or earlier suggest Andrew had a dog.\n\nStep 3: Later messages mention Andrew adopting a dog around October 2023 (Result 73), confirming he did not have a dog earlier in the year.\n\nFinal answer: Andrew did not have a pet dog during March 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.89,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.36
    },
    {
      "question": "What kind of classes or groups has Audrey joined to take better care of her dogs?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "positive reinforcement training workshop to bond with pets, dog training course, agility training course, grooming course, dog-owners group",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of classes or groups Audrey joined related to dog care.\n\n- Result 2 (2023-05-11): Audrey mentions a positive reinforcement training class.\n- Result 18 (2023-07-03): Audrey says she is taking a dog training course.\n- Result 22 (2023-08-19): Audrey took a dog grooming course.\n- Result 33 (2023-11-04): Audrey joined a dog owners group around October 28, 2023, to learn how to better take care of her dogs.\n\nStep 2: Summarize the types of classes/groups.\n\nAudrey has joined a positive reinforcement training class, a dog training course, a dog grooming course, and a dog owners group.\n\nFinal answer:  \nAudrey has joined a positive reinforcement training class, a dog training course, a dog grooming course, and a dog owners group to better care for her dogs.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.31,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.49
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Audrey's positive reinforcement training course for dogs take place?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "June, 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step-by-step reasoning:\n\n1. Audrey mentions seeing a workshop flyer about positive reinforcement training on 2023-05-11 (Result 1).\n2. On 2023-07-03, Audrey says she is taking a dog training course that is challenging but rewarding (Result 4).\n3. On the same day, she also mentions the dog-training course has been a big time sink but has paid off (Result 20).\n4. On 2023-05-11, Audrey talks about positive reinforcement as an important training method (Results 1, 5, 12).\n5. The timeline suggests she saw the flyer in early May, then by early July she is actively taking the course.\n\nFinal answer: Audrey's positive reinforcement training course took place between May and early July 2023, with her actively taking it by early July 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.49,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.0
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Andrew go rock climbing?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "June 11, 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Andrew going rock climbing.  \n- Result 6 (2023-06-13): Andrew says \"Last Sunday was awesome - my friends and I took a rock climbing class and I made it to the top!\"  \n- Result 1, 2, 4, and 60 (all on 2023-06-13) discuss the rock climbing experience in detail, confirming it was recent and a big achievement.\n\nStep 2: Determine the date of \"Last Sunday\" relative to the message date.  \n- The message is dated 2023-06-13 (Tuesday).  \n- The Sunday before June 13, 2023, was June 11, 2023.\n\nFinal answer: Andrew went rock climbing on Sunday, June 11, 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.7,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.37
    },
    {
      "question": "What outdoor activities has Andrew done other than hiking in nature?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "rock climbing, fishing, camping",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of outdoor activities Andrew has done besides hiking.\n\n- Result 4 and Result 9 (both dated 2023-06-13) mention Andrew doing rock climbing, describing it as awesome, challenging, and satisfying.\n- Result 16 (2023-06-13) also confirms Andrew took a rock climbing class and made it to the top.\n- Result 4 also mentions Andrew wanting to try kayaking and bungee jumping, but these are future plans, not activities already done.\n- Result 91 (2023-11-04) mentions Andrew going on a bike ride with his girlfriend, which is another outdoor activity.\n\nStep 2: Summarize the activities.\n\nAndrew has done rock climbing and biking in addition to hiking. Kayaking and bungee jumping are planned but not yet done.\n\nFinal answer:  \nAndrew has done rock climbing and biking in nature besides hiking.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 4.26,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.36
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Audrey move to a new place?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "June 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for any direct mentions of Audrey moving or finding a new place.  \nStep 2: Review the context for any timeline or date references related to Audrey's living situation.  \nStep 3: Check if Audrey or Andrew mention a move or new residence explicitly.\n\nReviewing the context:  \n- There are multiple mentions of Andrew looking for a dog-friendly place (Results 10, 14, 24, 57, 60, 91), but no direct mention of Audrey moving.  \n- Audrey talks about her pets and daily life but does not mention moving or changing residence.  \n- No messages indicate Audrey discussing a move or new place.\n\nConclusion: There is no information in the provided conversation excerpts about Audrey moving to a new place.\n\nFinal answer: Not enough information.",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.55,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.2
    },
    {
      "question": "What is something that Andrew really misses while working in the city?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "being in nature",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of what Andrew misses in the city.\n- Result 1: Andrew says he misses connection and companionship.\n- Result 5: Andrew says he hasn't been to the beach in a while and misses being outdoors.\n- Result 7: Andrew says he misses nature a lot.\n- Result 15: Andrew says sometimes it feels like he's missing out.\n- Result 17: Andrew says he misses moments exploring with a dog.\n- Result 27: Andrew says exploring nature was his escape and he feels a void without it.\n- Result 30: Andrew says he misses the peace and feeling of freedom from hiking.\n- Result 45: Andrew says he misses the peacefulness of being out on a hike.\n- Result 21: Andrew says nature calms him down and relaxes his mind, a break from city craziness.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.\nAndrew consistently expresses missing nature, outdoor activities like hiking, and the peace and freedom that come",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.68,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.04
    },
    {
      "question": "What is a shared frustration regarding dog ownership for Audrey and Andrew?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Not being able to find pet friendly spots.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of frustrations related to dog ownership by Audrey and Andrew.\n\n- Andrew mentions difficulty finding a place to live that is dog-friendly (Results 48, 92).\n- Audrey also mentions that places that allow dogs are really hard to find (Result 59).\n- Both discuss the challenge of finding dog-friendly spots or places to live with dogs (Results 48, 59, 92).\n- Andrew says \"Having two dogs is already a lot to take care of\" (Result 14), but this is more about workload than frustration shared with Audrey.\n- Audrey mentions the challenge of taking care of dogs in the city but says it is doable (Result 70).\n- Both mention the importance of safety and care but no direct frustration there.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the shared frustration.\n\nBoth Audrey and Andrew express frustration about the difficulty of finding dog-friendly housing or places to take their dogs, which is a significant challenge for them as dog owners.\n\nFinal answer:",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.95,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.21
    },
    {
      "question": "When is Andrew going to go hiking with Audrey?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "August",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of planned hikes between Andrew and Audrey.\n- Result 19 (2023-10-28): Audrey suggests picking a date to go hiking.\n- Result 20 (2023-10-19): Audrey says, \"I can't wait for our hike with the furry friends next month.\"\n- Result 21 (2023-10-01): Andrew says, \"Can't wait for the coming up hike!\"\n- Result 23 (2023-10-19): Andrew confirms he will take both dogs to the trails soon.\n- Result 35 (2023-10-28): Andrew suggests planning a hike soon at a dog-friendly trail.\n- Result 39 (2023-07-11): Audrey is counting down days until their hike.\n- Result 38 (2023-07-08): Andrew is looking forward to hiking next month (August).\n- Result 78 (2023-10-01): Andrew says he can't wait for the hike",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.18,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.27
    },
    {
      "question": "How many times did Audrey and Andew plan to hike together?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "three times",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify explicit mentions of planning hikes together.\n\n- Result 11 (2023-07-11): Audrey says \"Counting down the days 'til our hike! Gotta get them ready soon!\" \u2014 indicates a planned hike.\n- Result 15 (2023-07-08): Audrey says \"That'd be awesome! I can't wait to take them hiking. Fingers crossed we find a spot with a great view...\" \u2014 shows intention/planning.\n- Result 19 (2023-07-08): Andrew says \"Yep! I can't wait to see them have fun on the hike. Super excited!\" \u2014 confirms planning.\n- Result 46 (2023-07-08): Andrew says \"Looking forward to seeing them have fun hiking. Let's get planning for next month! Here's the map for the trail.\" \u2014 explicit planning.\n- Result 42 (2023-10-28): Audrey says \"Hmmm sure! Let's pick a date and go hike. It",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.88,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.74
    },
    {
      "question": "Where did Audrey get Pixie from?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "breeder",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Pixie and any details about her origin.  \n- Result 3 (2023-04-02): Audrey says, \"We adopted another puppy called Pixie.\"  \n- Result 1 and 19 mention Pixie fitting in and getting along with other dogs, but no origin details.  \n- No other results specify where Pixie was adopted from (e.g., shelter, breeder).\n\nStep 2: Check if \"adopted\" is clarified further anywhere.  \n- Andrew mentions adopting a pup from a shelter in October 2023 (Result 6), but that is about his own new dog, not Pixie.  \n- Audrey only says \"adopted\" for Pixie, no mention of shelter or breeder.\n\nStep 3: Since Audrey says \"We adopted another puppy called Pixie,\" the most specific information is that Pixie was adopted, but the source (shelter, breeder, etc.) is not specified.\n\nFinal",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.9,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.37
    },
    {
      "question": "What is an indoor activity that Andrew would enjoy doing while make his dog happy?",
      "category": 3,
      "gold_answer": "cook dog treats",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify Andrew's interests and what he wants for his dog.  \n- Andrew appreciates activities that keep dogs mentally stimulated (Result 14).  \n- He is interested in trying activities Audrey suggested for her dogs (Result 1).  \n- Andrew is looking for ways to keep dogs happy in the city (Result 41, 58).  \n- Audrey mentions indoor activities like puzzles, training, and hide-and-seek to keep dogs busy (Result 19).  \n\nStep 2: Look for specific indoor activities Andrew might enjoy.  \n- Andrew shows interest in mental stimulation activities (Result 14).  \n- Audrey suggests puzzles, training, and hide-and-seek as indoor activities (Result 19).  \n- Andrew thanks Audrey for ideas and plans to try them (Result 1).  \n\nStep 3: Synthesize the information.  \nAndrew would likely enjoy engaging in indoor games such as puzzles, training sessions, or hide-and-seek with his dog to keep the dog",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.63,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.52
    },
    {
      "question": "Which meat does Audrey prefer eating more than others?",
      "category": 3,
      "gold_answer": "chicken",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for mentions of Audrey's favorite recipes or preferred ingredients related to meat.\n\n- In [Result 32], Audrey says her favorite recipe is Chicken Pot Pie.\n- In [Result 14], Audrey describes a recipe she likes that includes chicken, garlic, lemon, and herbs, calling it her favorite comfort meal.\n- In [Result 25], Audrey mentions Roasted Chicken as one of her favorites and offers to send the recipe.\n\nStep 2: No other meats are mentioned as favorites by Audrey in the context.\n\nStep 3: The repeated references to chicken dishes and Audrey calling them favorites indicate she prefers chicken more than other meats.\n\nFinal answer: Audrey prefers eating chicken more than other meats.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.05,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.06
    },
    {
      "question": "What are the classes that Audrey took for her dogs to?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Positive reinforcement training class for bonding, dog training course, agility class",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of classes Audrey took for her dogs.\n\n- Result 5 (2023-05-11): Audrey mentions a \"positive reinforcement training class.\"\n- Result 7 (2023-08-04): Audrey says she started \"agility classes\" with her pups at a dog park.\n- Result 13 (2023-07-03): Audrey mentions taking a \"dog training course.\"\n- Result 9 (2023-08-19): Audrey took a \"dog grooming course.\"\n\nStep 2: Summarize the types of classes.\n\nAudrey took a positive reinforcement training class, agility classes, a dog training course, and a dog grooming course.\n\nFinal answer: Audrey took positive reinforcement training, agility, dog training, and dog grooming classes for her dogs.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.94,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.49
    },
    {
      "question": "Where did Andrew go during the first weekend of August 2023?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "camping with girlfriend",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the timeframe: The first weekend of August 2023 would be August 5-6, 2023.\n\nStep 2: Look for any messages around early August 2023 mentioning Andrew's activities or trips.\n\nStep 3: Result 10 [2023-08-04T11:08:30] Audrey to Andrew mentions a hike that took two hours with stunning views.\n\nStep 4: Result 11 [2023-08-04T11:15:00] Andrew to Audrey responds about taking \"him\" hiking, implying a dog or companion.\n\nStep 5: Result 18 [2023-08-04T11:08:00] Andrew to Audrey asks how long the trail was, indicating he was involved in a hike around that time.\n\nStep 6: Result 87 [2023-08-04T11:07:00] Andrew to Audrey says \"Btw look at the trail that I was just",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.01,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.85
    },
    {
      "question": "What are some problems that Andrew faces before he adopted Toby?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Finding the right dog and pet-friendly apartments close to open spaces",
      "generated_answer": "Step-by-step reasoning:\n\n1. Andrew mentions in [Result 72] (2023-04-16) that city living makes it hard to have the connection and companionship he desires with a pet, implying difficulty in providing outdoor time or space for a dog.\n\n2. In [Result 66] (2023-09-06), Audrey asks Andrew if he found a dog-friendly place to live yet, indicating that finding suitable housing for a dog was a challenge.\n\n3. Andrew also talks about work piling up and being stuck inside in [Result 11] (2023-07-11), which could limit his time for outdoor activities with a dog.\n\n4. In [Result 96] (2023-05-06), Andrew says he has been looking for a dog to adopt by browsing websites, visiting shelters, and asking friends, describing the process as both fun and annoying, indicating some difficulty in finding the right dog.\n\n5. In [Result 43] (202",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.33,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.42
    },
    {
      "question": "Did Audrey and Andrew grow up with a pet dog?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Yes",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for any mention of childhood pets for Audrey or Andrew.\n\nStep 2: In Result 27 and Result 96, Audrey mentions a childhood dog named Max. She describes Max as her childhood dog with lots of energy and fond memories of walking and bonding with him.\n\nStep 3: For Andrew, there is no direct mention of a childhood pet dog in the excerpts. He talks about loving animals and wanting a dog, but no mention of having one growing up.\n\nFinal answer: Audrey grew up with a pet dog named Max, but there is no information indicating that Andrew had a pet dog during his childhood.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.15,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.81
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Andrew and his girlfriend go fishing?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "weekend before August 24, 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Andrew mentioned going fishing with his girlfriend \"last weekend\" in a message dated 2023-08-24 (Result 1). Therefore, they went fishing the weekend just before August 24, 2023. \n\nFinal answer: Andrew and his girlfriend went fishing the weekend before August 24, 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.3,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.56
    },
    {
      "question": "What is the biggest stressor in Andrew's life besides not being able to hike frequently?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "work",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Andrew's stressors in the conversation excerpts.\n\n- Result 1 (2023-07-11): Audrey notes Andrew is really stressed with non-stop work.\n- Result 21 (2023-07-11): Andrew says work has been piling up and he's stuck inside.\n- Result 49 (2023-09-06): Andrew says work's been tough and stressful, outdoor activities have taken a backseat.\n- Result 77 (2023-09-06): Andrew acknowledges it's tough, implying work stress.\n- Result 11 (2023-10-04): Andrew mentions job and living in the city make it harder to get the feeling of peace from nature, and he feels a void.\n- Result 3 (2023-10-04): Andrew says it's hard to find open spaces in the city and work-life balance is challenging.\n- Result 16 (2023-09-06): Audrey acknowledges work is tough and finding",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.05,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.74
    },
    {
      "question": "How does Andrew feel about his current work?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Stressful",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify messages where Andrew talks about work or his feelings related to it.\n\n- [Result 9] (2023-07-11): Andrew says, \"Since we last talked, work has been piling up and I've been stuck inside. I miss the peace and feeling of freedom that comes with going for a hike.\"\n- [Result 18] (2023-10-04): Andrew says, \"Yeah, it's been tough. Exploring nature was my escape - a way to find peace. But with my job and living here, it's been harder to get that feeling back. I feel a void in my heart.\"\n- [Result 73] (2023-09-06): Audrey responds to Andrew about work being tough and finding balance, implying Andrew mentioned work stress.\n- [Result 21] (2023-09-06): Andrew says, \"Nah, still working on that. It's been a bit challenging.\" This likely refers to balancing work and other",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.42,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.34
    },
    {
      "question": "What is something that Audrey often dresses up her dogs with?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Hats",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for mentions of Audrey dressing up her dogs in the context.\n\nStep 2: Result 41 mentions: \"The hats don't bother them, they just put them on for fun and treats.\"\n\nStep 3: Result 24 and 77 mention sweaters: Andrew says, \"Aww, they look so sweet in that sweater!\" and \"My pup Toby is German Shephard and loves cute sweaters!\"\n\nStep 4: Result 81: Andrew says, \"Woah! They look so cute! What is going on here? They look ready for an adventure.\" This likely refers to dressing up.\n\nStep 5: Combining these, Audrey often dresses up her dogs with hats and sweaters.\n\nFinal answer: Audrey often dresses up her dogs with hats and sweaters.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.93,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.15
    },
    {
      "question": "What are the names of Audrey's dogs?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Pepper, Precious, Panda, and Pixie",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Audrey's dogs' names in the context.\n\n- Result 37 (2023-03-27): Audrey says, \"I've had them for 3 years! Their names are Pepper, Precious and Panda.\"\n- Result 2 (2023-04-02): Audrey mentions a new puppy named Pixie.\n- Result 30 (2023-04-02): Audrey says, \"We adopted another puppy called Pixie.\"\n- Result 68 (2023-08-16): Audrey mentions Pepper, Pixie, Precious, and Panda having their favorite spots.\n- Result 60 (2023-08-16): Audrey says she has four dogs, implying Pepper, Pixie, Precious, and Panda.\n- Result 29 (2023-09-24): Audrey refers to \"one of my pups,\" consistent with having multiple dogs.\n\nStep 2: Confirm no other dog names from Audrey are mentioned.\n\n- Result 26 mentions Max,",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.36,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.69
    },
    {
      "question": "When is Andrew planning to go to the beach with his girlfriend?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "November 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Andrew planning a beach trip with his girlfriend.  \n- Result 4 (2023-10-01): Andrew says, \"Got some great news - the gf and I are hitting the beach next month with Toby!\"  \n- Result 1 and 2 (2023-10-04) show Andrew talking about the beach trip as if it is upcoming or recent, but no specific date is given.  \n\nStep 2: Determine the timing of \"next month\" from the date of the message.  \n- The message about the beach trip is from 2023-10-01, so \"next month\" refers to November 2023.  \n\nStep 3: Confirm no other conflicting information about the beach trip date.  \n- No other messages specify a different date for the beach trip with his girlfriend.  \n\nFinal answer:  \nAndrew is planning to go to the beach with his girlfriend in November 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.5,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.49
    },
    {
      "question": "What has Andrew done with his dogs?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Taking walks and hiking",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Andrew and his dogs or pets in the conversation excerpts.\n\n- [Result 9] Andrew mentions having a German Shepherd named Toby.\n- [Result 12] Andrew says Toby is doing great in his new home and is still getting used to the environment and other dogs.\n- [Result 29] Andrew shares a photo of himself hiking with his dog, showing the dog happy.\n- [Result 46] Andrew says they haven't taken the dogs to the groomer yet but mentions adopting another dog recently.\n- [Result 64] Andrew introduces Toby, his puppy, and talks about city living.\n- [Result 68] Andrew hopes to take Toby hiking, calling them great hiking buddies.\n- [Result 97] Andrew expresses excitement about bonding better with Toby.\n- [Result 80] Andrew is looking for a place near a park or woods to give his dog space to run.\n- [Result 15] Andrew says he'll take good care of his",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.77,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.25
    },
    {
      "question": "What kind of tattoo does Audrey have on her arm?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Tattoos of her four dogs.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Audrey mentions getting tattoos of her dogs on her arm multiple times (Results 3, 6, 4).  \nStep 2: She says the tattoos represent her love for her pups and nature's beauty (Result 9).  \nStep 3: She also mentions adding more drawings to the tattoo of her four dogs (Result 4).  \n\nFinal answer: Audrey has tattoos of her four dogs on her arm that represent her love for her pups and nature's beauty.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.47,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.84
    },
    {
      "question": "What can Andrew potentially do to improve his stress and accomodate his living situation with his dogs?",
      "category": 3,
      "gold_answer": "Change to a hybrid or remote job so he can move away from the city to the suburbs to have a larger living space and be closer to nature.",
      "generated_answer": "Step-by-step reasoning:\n\n1. Andrew has expressed stress from work and a desire to get outdoors and hike (Results 49, 60).\n2. He has a puppy named Toby and is adjusting to city living with him (Results 8, 30, 76).\n3. Andrew is actively searching for a dog-friendly place to live near parks or nature to give his dog space to run (Results 26, 33, 40, 59).\n4. Audrey suggests making sure to take care of current dogs first before adding more (Results 9, 15, 25).\n5. Andrew is interested in bonding and training techniques, including positive reinforcement (Results 16, 45, 56).\n6. Audrey recommends activities like agility classes, dog parks, and setting up play areas to keep dogs active and happy (Results 53, 74, 91).\n7. Andrew is considering adopting another dog but is cautious about managing multiple dogs (Results 96,",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.31,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.27
    },
    {
      "question": "How many months passed between Andrew adopting Toby and Buddy?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "three months",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify when Andrew adopted Toby.  \n- From [Result 11] dated 2023-07-11, Andrew introduces Toby as his new puppy, indicating he adopted Toby around or before July 11, 2023.\n\nStep 2: Identify when Andrew adopted Buddy.  \n- From [Result 39] dated 2023-10-19, Andrew says he recently adopted another pup \"approximately October 12, 2023,\" and from [Result 4] on the same date, he names the new pup Buddy.\n\nStep 3: Calculate the time between the two adoptions.  \n- Toby adoption: around July 11, 2023  \n- Buddy adoption: around October 12, 2023  \n- From July 11 to October 12 is about 3 months.\n\nFinal answer:  \nApproximately 3 months passed between Andrew adopting Toby and Buddy.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.19,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.73
    },
    {
      "question": "What are the names of Andrew's dogs?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Toby, Scout, Buddy",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for mentions of Andrew's dogs' names in the conversation excerpts.\n\nStep 2: In [Result 46], Audrey asks Andrew, \"Btw, I never really asked, what breed is Toby?\" This indicates Andrew has a dog named Toby.\n\nStep 3: In [Result 89], Andrew says, \"My pup Toby is German Shephard and loves cute sweaters!\" confirming Toby is Andrew's dog.\n\nStep 4: In [Result 37], Andrew mentions, \"Still getting used to Toby and the new environment. Toby needs some time to get along with him too.\" This suggests Andrew has at least one other dog besides Toby.\n\nStep 5: In [Result 39], Audrey says, \"Maybe you want to take care of Toby and Buddy first.\" This implies Andrew has a dog named Buddy as well.\n\nStep 6: In [Result 52], Andrew says, \"I can't help myself but to adopt another dog the other day,\"",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.82,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.27
    },
    {
      "question": "What are some foods that Audrey likes eating?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "chicken pot pie, chicken roast, blueberry muffins, sushi",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Audrey's food preferences or foods she likes in the conversation excerpts.\n\nStep 2: In Result 4 and Result 5, Audrey talks about cooking and enjoying food, mentioning she loves trying new recipes and cooking as a form of self-care.\n\nStep 3: In Result 44, Audrey says she loves Mediterranean flavors and mentions a favorite comfort meal with chicken, garlic, lemon, and herbs.\n\nStep 4: In Result 82, Audrey states garlic is her go-to ingredient because she loves the smell and taste it adds to dishes.\n\nStep 5: In Result 11, Audrey mentions making pastries (her favorite treats) around April 9, 2023.\n\nStep 6: In Result 23 and Result 33, Audrey talks about ordering sushi and appreciating it.\n\nStep 7: In Result 9, Audrey refers to a family recipe that reminds her of her grandma's kitchen, implying she enjoys traditional family dishes.\n\nStep 8:",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.31,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.15
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Audrey get into an accident in the park?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "between October 19 and 24, 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify any mention of an accident involving Audrey in the park.  \nStep 2: Result 2 [2023-09-24T17:53:30] Audrey to Andrew mentions: \"last Friday at the park one of my pups saw something and pulled so hard the leash busted. Scared that she might run off and get hurt, so I had to chase after her.\" This describes a scary incident but not a physical accident to Audrey herself.  \nStep 3: No other results mention Audrey having an accident in the park or any injury. The incident in Result 2 is the closest to an accident scenario but involves the dog and a broken leash, not Audrey getting hurt.  \n\nFinal answer:  \nAudrey did not report having an accident in the park; the closest incident was on Friday before September 24, 2023, when her dog's leash broke, but Audrey was not injured.",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.71,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.4
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Andrew and his girlfriend go on a wine tasting trip?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "the weekend before October 24, 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant excerpt about the wine tasting trip.  \n- Result 3 [2023-10-24]: Andrew to Audrey mentions, \"My girlfriend and I went to this awesome wine tasting last weekend.\"\n\nStep 2: Determine the date of the message and the timing of the trip.  \n- The message is dated 2023-10-24.  \n- \"Last weekend\" relative to 2023-10-24 would be the weekend of 2023-10-14 to 2023-10-15.\n\nFinal answer:  \nAndrew and his girlfriend went on the wine tasting trip during the weekend of October 14-15, 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.38,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.88
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Audrey get wtih having so many dogs?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Companionship",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Audrey having many dogs.  \n- Result 31 (2023-08-16): Audrey says she has four dogs and that four is enough for now because they keep her busy and she wants to give each attention.  \n- Result 57 (2023-07-27): Audrey refers to her \"four fur babies\" as very important to her.  \n- Result 30 (2023-08-04): Audrey calls her pets her \"good ol' buddies\" during tough times and says they make her very happy.  \n- Result 55 (2023-08-24): Audrey says her dogs make her really happy and she loves them a lot, emphasizing a strong bond.  \n- Result 19 (2023-07-27): Audrey talks about pets bringing joy, comfort, and love, and being friends and confidantes.  \n\nStep 2: Summarize what Audrey gained from having many dogs.  \n- They bring her",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.05,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.64
    },
    {
      "question": "What is a good place for dogs to run around freely and meet new friends?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "The dog park",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of places where dogs can run freely and socialize.  \n- Result 3 (2023-05-03): Audrey mentions doggie playdates in the park where dogs chase balls/frisbees and meet other dog owners.  \n- Result 14 (2023-05-03): Audrey describes a park with lots of trees and benches where dogs play.  \n- Result 51 (2023-05-03): Audrey says the dog park is a great place to start, where dogs can run and mingle with other pooches.  \n- Result 17 (2023-10-13): Audrey calls the dog park \"like paradise\" for dogs to socialize and exercise.  \n- Result 50 (2023-10-13): Audrey says her dogs love running around and meeting other pups at the park.  \n- Result 39 (2023-10-01): Audrey mentions a dog park nearby with a big grassy area for play and",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.5,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.23
    },
    {
      "question": "What are the breeds of Audrey's dogs?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Mongrel mixed with Lab for Pepper and Panda. Mongrel mixed with Chihuahua for Precious and Pixie.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Audrey's dogs' breeds in the context.\n\n- Result 34 (2023-07-03): Audrey says, \"They're all mutts. Two of them are Jack Russell mixes and the other two are Chihuahua mixes.\"\n- Result 68 (2023-09-24): Audrey confirms again, \"They're all mutts. Two of them are Jack Russell mixes and the other two are Chihuahua mixes.\"\n\nStep 2: Check for any contradictory or additional breed information.\n\n- No other breed information about Audrey's dogs contradicts this.\n- Audrey also mentions a puppy named Pixie (Result 37, 2023-04-02), but no breed is specified for Pixie.\n- Andrew's dog Toby is a German Shepherd (Results 7, 33, 80), but Toby is Andrew's dog, not Audrey's.\n\nStep 3: Summarize.\n\nAudrey's dogs are all mixed breeds: two Jack Russell mixes and two",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.23,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.99
    },
    {
      "question": "What technique is Audrey using to discipline her dogs?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Positive reinforcement",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for mentions of Audrey's approach to training or disciplining her dogs.\n\n- Result 1 (2023-05-11): Audrey says punishment is never the proper way for pets and emphasizes positive reinforcement.\n- Result 3 (2023-05-11): Audrey talks about attending a positive reinforcement training class.\n- Result 22 (2023-05-11): Andrew notes positive reinforcement helps bond with dogs, referring to Audrey's method.\n- Result 39 (2023-10-28): Andrew asks how the dogs are doing with the new approach, implying Audrey uses positive reinforcement.\n- Result 89 (2023-10-28): Audrey mentions using positive reinforcement techniques after advice from the behaviorist.\n\nStep 2: Confirm no contradictory information about discipline methods.\n\n- No mention of punishment or negative methods.\n- Audrey explicitly rejects punishment (Result 1, 8).\n\nFinal answer: Audrey uses positive reinforcement techniques to discipline her dogs.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.75,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.53
    },
    {
      "question": "Which US state do Audrey and Andrew potentially live in?",
      "category": 3,
      "gold_answer": "Minnesota",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for any direct mentions of locations or clues about geography.\n\n- Result 61 (2023-07-08): Audrey mentions hiking a spot last year that was a 3-hour drive away with an amazing sunset.\n- Result 35 and 58 (2023-10-28): Andrew mentions a national park he visited \"a while ago.\"\n- Result 21 (2023-11-04): Andrew talks about a bike ride to a cool park outside of town, implying they live near natural areas but also a city.\n- Result 70 (2023-06-26): Audrey got a new place with a bigger backyard, suggesting suburban or semi-rural living near a city.\n- Result 53 (2023-10-01): Audrey mentions a beach trip with pups playing in the ocean, indicating proximity to a coast.\n- Result 16 (2023-03-27): Audrey says \"They're city dogs and we explore all the time,\"",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.52,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.88
    },
    {
      "question": "Which national park could Audrey and Andrew be referring to in their conversations?",
      "category": 3,
      "gold_answer": "Voyageurs National Park",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of national parks in the conversation excerpts.\n\n- Result 4 (2023-10-28): Andrew mentions a national park he went to \"a while ago\" and shares a picture.\n- Result 23 (2023-05-06): Audrey mentions a road trip last Friday to a beautiful national park where her dogs had a blast.\n- Result 49 (2023-05-03): Andrew asks Audrey where \"it\" is located, likely referring to the national park Audrey mentioned.\n- Result 69 (2023-05-03): Andrew mentions finding a new open space to hike nearby, refreshing but no specific park name.\n- Result 50 (2023-03-27): Andrew mentions Fox Hollow as a great trail with awesome views.\n- Result 58 (2023-07-08): Audrey mentions hiking a trail last year (July 8, 2022), 3 hours away, with an amazing sunset.\n- Result",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.03,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.51
    },
    {
      "question": "How many pets will Andrew have, as of December 2023?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "three",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: In early 2023 (March), Andrew had no pets (Result 2).\n\nStep 2: By October 12, 2023, Andrew adopted a new pup from a shelter named Scout (Results 68, 100).\n\nStep 3: Andrew also mentions Toby, who is adjusting to the new pup Scout (Results 3, 46, 48).\n\nStep 4: Andrew refers to \"my dogs\" in plural several times after October, indicating he has at least two dogs: Toby and Scout (Results 3, 16, 46, 100).\n\nStep 5: There is no mention of Andrew having more than these two dogs by November 2023.\n\nFinal answer: As of December 2023, Andrew has two pets (dogs): Toby and Scout.",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.94,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.14
    },
    {
      "question": "How many pets did Andrew have, as of September 2023?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "one",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for mentions of Andrew's pets around or before September 2023.\n\n- Result 2 (2023-03-27): Andrew says \"No, no pets right now.\"\n- Result 97 (2023-05-06): Andrew is looking to adopt a dog.\n- Result 60 (2023-08-24): Andrew mentions \"Can't wait till Toby and I bond better,\" indicating he has a dog named Toby by late August.\n- Result 47 (2023-08-04): Audrey wishes Andrew good luck with Toby, confirming Toby is Andrew's dog by early August.\n- Result 50 (2023-10-19): Andrew says he recently (approx. October 12, 2023) adopted another pup, so this is after September.\n- Result 5 (2023-10-19): Andrew talks about \"He's doing great in his new home. Still getting used to Toby and the new environment,\" indicating he adopted",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.58,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.19
    },
    {
      "question": "How many months passed between Andrew adopting Buddy and Scout",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "one month",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify when Andrew adopted Buddy.  \n- Result 28 (2023-10-19): Andrew says he recently adopted another pup \"approximately October 12, 2023.\" This pup is Buddy (confirmed by Result 11 and others).\n\nStep 2: Identify when Andrew adopted Scout.  \n- Result 3 (2023-11-22): Andrew talks about deciding on the name Scout for their pup, implying Scout was adopted by then.  \n- Result 31 (2023-11-22): Andrew mentions taking Scout, Toby, and Buddy to the park, confirming Scout was adopted by November 22, 2023.  \n- No exact adoption date for Scout is given, but it is after Buddy's adoption in October 2023 and before November 22, 2023.\n\nStep 3: Calculate the time between Buddy's adoption (approx. October 12, 2023) and Scout's adoption (before or by November 22",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.37,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.31
    },
    {
      "question": "What does Andrew view his pets as?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Family",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for Andrew's direct statements about pets and how he views them.\n\n- Result 1 (2023-07-27): Andrew says pets are more than just pets; they become friends and confidantes who listen and provide comfort.\n- Result 6 (2023-08-16): Andrew says pets bring joy and feel like family; he can't imagine life without them.\n- Result 12 (2023-03-27): Andrew says he loves animals but had no pets at that time.\n- Result 24 (2023-06-13): Andrew says nature makes us and our pets happy.\n- Result 48 (2023-08-16): Andrew shares a photo of Toby at his favorite spot, showing affection.\n- Result 83 (2023-10-19): Andrew says pets really can make our lives better.\n- Result 60 (2023-11-22): Andrew says dogs are always there for us and calls them family members",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.17,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.36
    },
    {
      "question": "What does Audrey view her pets as?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Family",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Review Audrey's statements about her pets in the context.\n\n- [Result 3] Audrey: \"pets are family.\"\n- [Result 6] Audrey: \"They're like family to people.\"\n- [Result 12] Audrey: \"My pets have been my good ol' buddies during all the tough times! They make me so happy and I love them so much.\"\n- [Result 26] Audrey: \"I'm blessed to have my furry friends in my life. They're my companions and always make my day better.\"\n- [Result 44] Audrey: Describes each pet having their own cozy spot, showing care and affection.\n- [Result 60] Audrey: \"my dogs make me really happy. I love them so much and I want to make them as happy as possible. We have a strong bond.\"\n- [Result 77] Audrey: \"They really do, bringing loads of love and happiness. They are everything to me.\"\n- [Result ",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.91,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.5
    },
    {
      "question": "What is a skill that Audrey learned to take care of her dogs?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Grooming",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for mentions of Audrey learning new skills related to dog care.  \nStep 2: In Result 1 and Result 3 (both dated 2023-08-19), Audrey mentions taking a dog grooming course and learning techniques such as grooming slowly and gently, paying attention to sensitive areas like ears and paws, and staying patient and positive.  \nStep 3: No other specific skill learning is mentioned as clearly as the grooming course.\n\nFinal answer: Audrey learned dog grooming techniques, including how to groom gently and patiently while paying attention to sensitive areas like ears and paws.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.96,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.42
    },
    {
      "question": "What items has Audrey bought or made for her dogs?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "dog tags, toys, dog beds, collars",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of items Audrey bought or made for her dogs.\n\n- Result 52 (2023-10-19): Audrey bought toys for her dogs at a pet store.\n- Result 98 (2023-03-27): Audrey got new collars and tags for her dogs.\n- Result 19 (2023-06-26): Audrey set up a doggy play area in the backyard with agility stuff and toys.\n- Result 81 (2023-08-19): Audrey took a dog grooming course and learned techniques to groom her dogs herself.\n- Result 61 (2023-11-04): Audrey entertains her dogs in the house with toys and games.\n- Result 86 (2023-08-19): Audrey offers grooming tips, implying she grooms her dogs herself.\n\nStep 2: Summarize the items.\n\nAudrey has bought toys, collars, and tags for her dogs, set up a backyard play area with agility equipment",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.49,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.64
    },
    {
      "question": "What is something that Andrew could do to make birdwatching hobby to fit in his city schedule?",
      "category": 3,
      "gold_answer": "Install a bird feeder outside where he can see the birds without going outdoors.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Andrew mentions missing nature and finding it hard to get out due to city life and work-life balance (Results 27, 74).\n\nStep 2: He enjoys birdwatching and hiking but hasn't gone specifically for birdwatching recently (Results 4, 29).\n\nStep 3: Audrey suggests ways to appreciate nature even in the city, such as getting plants or visiting parks on weekends (Result 41).\n\nStep 4: Andrew offers to share his favorite birdwatching routes near the river, which are presumably accessible from the city (Result 75).\n\nStep 5: Audrey and Andrew discuss planning birdwatching trips together and checking schedules to fit it in (Results 2, 8, 10).\n\nStep 6: Andrew also reads books about ecological systems and birds, which can be done at home or in limited time (Result 6, 62).\n\nFinal answer: Andrew could fit birdwatching into his city schedule by visiting nearby parks or",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.55,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.36
    },
    {
      "question": "What is a career that Andrew could potentially pursue with his love for animals and nature?",
      "category": 3,
      "gold_answer": "Park ranger or a similar position working for the National Park Services.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Andrew expresses a strong interest in animals, nature, ecosystems, and ecological systems (Results 1, 4, 32, 75).\n\nStep 2: He enjoys hiking, birdwatching, and spending time outdoors with dogs (Results 3, 9, 10, 18, 28, 79).\n\nStep 3: Andrew has volunteered at an animal shelter and finds it rewarding (Results 16, 23, 61).\n\nStep 4: He is knowledgeable about animals and ecosystems and shows a desire to learn more (Results 1, 4, 16).\n\nStep 5: Combining his love for animals, nature, and volunteering, a career related to animal care, wildlife conservation, or ecological/environmental science would fit well.\n\nFinal answer: Andrew could potentially pursue a career in wildlife conservation, ecological research, or animal care such as working as a wildlife biologist, conservationist, or animal shelter professional.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 4.34,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.62
    },
    {
      "question": "What activity do Audrey's dogs like to do in the dog park?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Play fetch with ball and frisbee, run around and meet other dogs",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Audrey's dogs' activities at the dog park.\n- Result 1: Dogs love socializing with other pups and getting exercise, running around and smelling.\n- Result 4: They play fetch with a ball or frisbee and have doggie playdates.\n- Result 10: Dogs run and mingle with other pooches at the dog park.\n- Result 31: Dogs go crazy for Fetch and Frisbee, love to run around and meet other pups.\n- Result 93: Audrey takes them to the park twice a week for agility practice, which is a physical and mental workout.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.\nAudrey's dogs enjoy running around, socializing with other dogs, playing fetch and frisbee, and participating in agility activities at the dog park.\n\nFinal answer:  \nAudrey's dogs like to run around, play fetch and frisbee, socialize with other dogs, and practice agility at the dog park.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.14,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.48
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Andrew make his dogs a fun indoor area?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "few days before November 22, 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify any mention of Andrew creating or having an indoor play area for his dogs.\n\nStep 2: In Result 6 [2023-06-26T13:54:30], Andrew says to Audrey: \"This is the doggy daycare near me, it has a big indoor space for dogs to play.\"\n\nStep 3: This indicates Andrew has access to or knows of a doggy daycare with a big indoor play area, but it does not say he made it himself.\n\nStep 4: There is no other mention of Andrew making or setting up a fun indoor area for his dogs.\n\nStep 5: Audrey mentions in Result 5 [2023-06-26T13:53:00] that she set up a doggy play area in her backyard, but this is about Audrey, not Andrew.\n\nStep 6: No other context shows Andrew making an indoor area for his dogs.\n\nFinal answer:  \nNot enough information to determine when Andrew made",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.0,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.61
    },
    {
      "question": "Has Andrew moved into a new apartment for his dogs?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "No",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Andrew has been searching for a dog-friendly place to live for a while, as seen in messages from early 2023 (Results 3, 29, 54, 55).\n\nStep 2: Andrew adopted a new pup named Toby around October 12, 2023 (Results 52, 18).\n\nStep 3: Andrew mentions Toby is \"doing great in his new home\" in mid-October 2023 (Results 8, 24), indicating he has moved into a new place by then.\n\nStep 4: There is no explicit mention of the exact date Andrew moved, but the phrase \"new home\" strongly implies he has found and moved into a new apartment suitable for his dogs.\n\nFinal answer: Yes, Andrew has moved into a new apartment for his dogs by October 2023.",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.6,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.74
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Andrew adopt Scout?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "few days before November 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Scout and adoption timing.  \n- Result 3 (2023-11-22T09:05:30) Andrew says they decided on the name Scout for their pup.  \n- Result 29 (2023-11-22T09:05:00) Audrey asks about the pup's name, and Andrew replies with Scout shortly after.  \n- Result 66 (2023-10-19T18:16:30) Andrew mentions adopting another pup around October 12, 2023, but that pup is named Buddy (Result 67), not Scout.  \n- Result 45 (2023-11-22T09:06:30) Andrew talks about taking Scout, Toby, and Buddy to a park, indicating Scout was already adopted by November 22, 2023.  \n\nStep 2: No earlier direct mention of Scout's adoption date is found. The earliest clear mention of Scout by name is on November",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.68,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.38
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Audrey eat for dinner on October 24, 2023?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "sushi",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for any messages from or to Audrey around October 24, 2023, that mention dinner or food.\n\nStep 2: Result 6 [2023-10-24T10:15:30] Audrey to Andrew says: \"Thanks! Appreciate it, feeling better each day. And wow that Sushi looks phenomenal. I know what to get for dinner tonight.\"\n\nStep 3: Result 17 [2023-10-24T10:20:30] Audrey to Andrew says: \"Enjoy! Now I'm gonna order some sushi for tonight. Thanks!\"\n\nStep 4: These messages indicate Audrey planned to eat sushi for dinner on October 24, 2023.\n\nFinal answer: Audrey ate sushi for dinner on October 24, 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.65,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.21
    },
    {
      "question": "How long has it been since Andrew adopted his first pet, as of November 2023?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "4 months",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify when Andrew first mentioned adopting a pet.  \n- Result 67 (2023-07-11): Andrew says, \"meet Toby, my puppy.\" This indicates he adopted Toby by at least early July 2023.\n\nStep 2: Confirm no earlier pet adoption by Andrew.  \n- Result 5 (2023-03-27): Andrew says, \"No, no pets right now.\" So before late March 2023, he had no pets.  \n- Result 9 (2023-05-06): Andrew is still looking for a dog to adopt.  \n- Result 67 (2023-07-11): He introduces Toby, so adoption happened between May and July 2023.\n\nStep 3: Determine the approximate adoption date of Toby.  \n- Result 18 (2023-08-04): Audrey wishes Andrew good luck with Toby, implying Toby was adopted before August 4.  \n- Result 30 (2023",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.12,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.41
    },
    {
      "question": "How many dogs does Andrew have?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "3",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Andrew's dogs.\n\n- Result 9 (2023-08-04): Andrew says \"He's a German Shepherd\" referring to a dog named Toby.\n- Result 18 (2023-08-04): Audrey wishes Andrew good luck with Toby, implying Andrew has at least one dog named Toby.\n- Result 19 (2023-11-04): Audrey mentions Toby and Buddy, suggesting Andrew has two dogs named Toby and Buddy.\n- Result 26 (2023-10-19): Andrew talks about a new dog adjusting to Toby, indicating he has at least two dogs.\n- Result 49 (2023-11-22): Andrew says he adopted another dog recently, showing he has added a third dog.\n- Result 86 (2023-10-19): Andrew confirms adopting another pup around October 12, 2023.\n- Result 93 (2023-11-22): Andrew mentions feeling lucky to have Scout,",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.31,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.49
    },
    {
      "question": "Which specific type of bird mesmerizes Andrew?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Eagles",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Andrew's favorite or mesmerizing birds in the context.\n\nStep 2: In [Result 14] (2023-03-27), Andrew says: \"Eagles have always mesmerized me; they're so strong and graceful!\"\n\nStep 3: No other specific bird type is mentioned as mesmerizing Andrew.\n\nFinal answer: Eagles mesmerize Andrew.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.35,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.61
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Andrew express missing about exploring nature trails with his family's dog?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "The peaceful moments",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts where Andrew talks about missing nature trails with his family's dog.\n\n- Result 17 [2023-04-02]: Andrew says, \"Got me thinking of my old hiking pics and how much I miss exploring nature trails with my family's dog. Ah, the peaceful moments out in nature!\"\n- Result 31 [2023-04-02]: Andrew says, \"Definitely! I miss those moments. I need to find a dog-friendly spot soon so I can get exploring again!\"\n\nStep 2: Analyze what Andrew specifically misses.\n\n- He misses the peaceful moments out in nature.\n- He misses exploring nature trails with his family's dog.\n- He longs to find a dog-friendly spot to resume exploring.\n\nFinal answer: Andrew expressed missing the peaceful moments and the experience of exploring nature trails with his family's dog.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.1,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.54
    },
    {
      "question": "What kind of pastries did Andrew and his girlfriend have at the cafe?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "croissants, muffins, and tarts",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant messages about the pastries Andrew and his girlfriend had at the cafe.\n\n- Result 1: Andrew mentions an awesome cafe with amazing pastries.\n- Result 3: Andrew says he got the pastries and shares a photo.\n- Result 7: Andrew specifies they had croissants, muffins, and tarts.\n- Result 10: Audrey talks about making her favorite treats and suggests a pastry party.\n- Result 19: Andrew agrees to the pastry party.\n\nStep 2: Confirm the specific types of pastries mentioned.\n\n- Result 7 clearly states: \"We had some delicious croissants, muffins, and tarts! It was amazing!\"\n\nNo other pastry types are mentioned by Andrew or Audrey in the context.\n\nFinal answer: Andrew and his girlfriend had croissants, muffins, and tarts at the cafe.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.98,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.4
    },
    {
      "question": "What kind of flowers does Audrey have a tattoo of?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "sunflowers",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Audrey mentions getting tattoos of something that means the world to her on her arm (Result 4).\n\nStep 2: Andrew asks what made her get the tattoo (Result 2), and Audrey explains it represents her love for her pups and nature's beauty (Result 10).\n\nStep 3: Audrey also says she has a tattoo of her four dogs (Result 7).\n\nStep 4: The question is about flowers specifically. Audrey identifies the flowers Andrew shows her as Peruvian Lilies (Result 14).\n\nStep 5: However, there is no direct statement that Audrey has a tattoo of flowers, only that her tattoo represents her love for her pups and nature's beauty.\n\nStep 6: Since Audrey says the tattoo represents her love for her pups and nature's beauty (Result 10), it is implied that the tattoo includes flowers as part of nature's beauty.\n\nStep 7: No specific flower type is explicitly stated as being tattooed, only that the",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.32,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.24
    },
    {
      "question": "What does Audrey do during dog playdates in the park?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "chat with people while dogs make new friends",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of dog playdates in the park by Audrey.\n\n- Result 1 (2023-05-03): Audrey says during outings, they play fetch with a ball or frisbee and meet other dog owners for doggie playdates, which is a great way for her to chat with people and for the dogs to make friends.\n- Result 9 (2023-05-03): Audrey mentions the dog park is a great place to start playdates.\n- Result 25 (2023-07-03): Audrey mentions having a doggy playdate last Friday, describing it as a bit crazy but lots of fun.\n- Result 99 (2023-11-04): Audrey says she tries to meet up with other dog owners once a week for tips and so the dogs can play together.\n\nStep 2: What does Audrey do during these playdates?\n\n- She plays fetch with her dogs using balls or frisbees.\n- She chats with other",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.78,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.98
    },
    {
      "question": "What type of dog was Andrew looking to adopt based on his living space?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "smaller dog",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Andrew mentioned he lives in an apartment and is looking for a dog that fits his living space and lifestyle.  \nStep 2: In Result 50 (2023-05-06), Andrew says: \"For me, a person living in an apartment, a smaller dog would be best, but if one is active, consider getting one that loves to play and run.\"  \nStep 3: This indicates Andrew was looking for a smaller dog suitable for apartment living, ideally one that is active and enjoys play and exercise.\n\nFinal answer: Andrew was looking to adopt a smaller, active dog suitable for apartment living.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.19,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.05
    },
    {
      "question": "Where does Andrew want to live to give their dog a large, open space to run around?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "near a park or woods",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Andrew mentions on 2023-05-06 that he is looking for a place near a park or woods to stay close to nature and give the dog a large open space to run around (Result 1).\n\nStep 2: He also talks about the difficulty of finding a pet-friendly place in the city and wanting a place with open areas for dogs to run and play (Results 7, 15, 26).\n\nStep 3: Andrew is specifically interested in living near natural environments like parks or woods rather than just any city location, to provide ample space for his dog.\n\nFinal answer: Andrew wants to live near a park or woods to give his dog a large, open space to run around.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.56,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.42
    },
    {
      "question": "Why did Audrey sign up for a workshop about bonding with pets?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Strengthen the bond with her pets",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant excerpt about Audrey signing up for a workshop.  \n- Result 72 [2023-05-11]: Audrey says she signed up for a workshop about bonding with her pets next month and is excited to learn new stuff and strengthen her bond with her pets.\n\nStep 2: Look for any explanation or motivation for signing up.  \n- Result 2 [2023-05-11]: Audrey mentions seeing a flyer for a positive reinforcement training class at a local pet store and wanting to give it a shot.  \n- Result 70 [2023-05-11]: Audrey says she is sure the workshop is a must-learn for any dog owner.\n\nStep 3: Synthesize the information.  \nAudrey signed up for the workshop because she wanted to learn positive reinforcement training techniques and strengthen her bond with her pets, seeing it as an important and valuable learning opportunity for a dog owner.\n\nFinal answer:  \nAudrey signed up for the workshop to",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.76,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.94
    },
    {
      "question": "How did Audrey hear about the workshop on bonding with pets?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Saw a workshop flyer at the local pet store",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant excerpts about the workshop on bonding with pets.  \n- Result 1: Andrew asks Audrey where she heard about the workshop.  \n- Result 3: Audrey replies she saw the workshop flyer at her local pet store.  \n- Result 61: Audrey mentions signing up for a workshop about bonding with her pets next month.\n\nStep 2: Confirm Audrey's source of information about the workshop.  \n- In Result 3, Audrey clearly states: \"I saw this workshop flyer at my local pet store.\"\n\nFinal answer: Audrey heard about the workshop on bonding with pets from a flyer at her local pet store.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.96,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.81
    },
    {
      "question": "What type of training was the workshop Audrey signed up for in May 2023?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Positive reinforcement training",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant date and message about the workshop Audrey signed up for.  \n- Result 1 [2023-05-11]: Audrey mentions a workshop flyer at her local pet store.  \n- She says it was a \"positive reinforcement training class.\"\n\nStep 2: Confirm the type of training from the exact quote.  \n- Audrey: \"It was a positive reinforcement training class and I wanted to give it a shot.\"\n\nFinal answer:  \nAudrey signed up for a positive reinforcement dog training workshop in May 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.11,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.4
    },
    {
      "question": "How did Audrey describe she dog he met at the pet store?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Friendly and playful",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant excerpt about Audrey meeting a dog at the pet store.  \n- Result 15 [2023-05-11T14:04:30] Audrey to Andrew: \"I saw this workshop flyer at my local pet store. It was a positive reinforcement training class and I wanted to give it a shot. The volunteer in the store was nice enough to let me meet their dog \u2013 he was so friendly and playful!\"\n\nStep 2: Extract Audrey's description of the dog she met.  \n- She described the dog as \"so friendly and playful.\"\n\nFinal answer: Audrey described the dog she met at the pet store as \"so friendly and playful.\"",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.87,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.42
    },
    {
      "question": "Why did Audrey think positive reinforcement training is important for pets?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "To have pets learn how to behave in a positive way",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Audrey mentions in Result 1 that she saw a workshop flyer for positive reinforcement training and wanted to try it.\n\nStep 2: In Result 2, Audrey explains her belief that pets should learn to behave through positive reinforcement because punishment is never the proper way for pets.\n\nStep 3: In Result 31, Audrey expresses that the thought of hurting her dogs causes her pain, reinforcing her preference for positive, gentle methods.\n\nStep 4: Andrew agrees in Result 43 that punishment is undesirable for dogs.\n\nFinal answer: Audrey thinks positive reinforcement training is important because she believes punishment is never the proper way to train pets and she wants to avoid hurting her dogs, focusing instead on gentle, positive methods.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.45,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.9
    },
    {
      "question": "What challenge is Andrew facing in their search for a pet?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Finding a pet-friendly spot in the city",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Andrew searching for a pet.  \n- Result 10 (2023-05-06): Andrew says he's been looking for a dog to adopt, browsing websites, visiting shelters, and asking friends.  \n- Result 21 (2023-06-02): Andrew mentions it's tough finding a pet-friendly spot in the city.  \n- Result 36 (2023-05-06): Andrew says finding a pet-friendly place to live has been tough, contacting landlords and checking neighborhoods.  \n- Result 39 (2023-07-08): Andrew wishes he could get a dog but says it's tough to find a place and the right dog.  \n- Result 52 (2023-09-06): Audrey asks if Andrew found a dog-friendly place to live yet.  \n- Result 27 (2023-09-06): Andrew says he'll keep searching for the perfect place for dogs.  \n\nStep 2: Summarize the challenge.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.43,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.54
    },
    {
      "question": "How does Andrew feel about their search for a pet-friendly place?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Discouraged but determined",
      "generated_answer": "Step-by-step reasoning:\n\n1. Early in the year (April to June), Andrew expresses difficulty and discouragement in finding a pet-friendly place:\n   - [Result 8, 2023-06-02]: \"I'm still on the hunt, but it's tough finding a pet-friendly spot in the city... A bit discouraged but I'm determined...\"\n   - [Result 68, 2023-07-03]: \"Still can't seem to find any dog-friendly spots to rent. That's a bummer.\"\n\n2. Despite the challenges, Andrew remains determined and hopeful:\n   - [Result 14, 2023-09-06]: \"Thanks! I appreciate the help. I'll keep searching for that perfect place for dogs!\"\n   - [Result 75, 2023-04-02]: \"Thanks! Fingers crossed for the apartment and that furry friend.\"\n\n3. By October, Andrew mentions having a dog (Toby) and a new home:\n   - [Result ",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.47,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.01
    },
    {
      "question": "What outdoor activities does Andrew plan on trying after the rock climbing class?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "kayaking and bungee jumping",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify Andrew's mention of outdoor activities after the rock climbing class.  \n- In Result 3 (2023-06-13), Andrew says he took a rock climbing class and is hooked, planning to do more outdoor activities every week.  \n- In Result 1 (2023-06-13), Andrew specifically mentions rock climbing was awesome and that it encouraged him to try more outdoor activities like kayaking and maybe bungee jumping.\n\nStep 2: Confirm these activities are planned and not just mentioned casually.  \n- Andrew explicitly says \"It has definitely encouraged me to try more outdoor activities like kayaking and maybe bungee jumping?\" indicating plans or intentions.\n\nFinal answer:  \nAndrew plans on trying kayaking and maybe bungee jumping after the rock climbing class.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.04,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.57
    },
    {
      "question": "How long does Audrey typically walk her dogs for?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "about an hour",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about walking duration.  \n- Result 19 [2023-06-13]: Audrey says, \"Varies depending on the day, but usually for about an hour. We let them explore at their own pace.\"\n\nStep 2: Check for any other mentions that might specify or contradict this.  \n- No other excerpt gives a specific typical duration for walks.\n\nFinal answer: Audrey typically walks her dogs for about an hour, though it varies depending on the day.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.47,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.58
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Audrey set up in the backyard for their dogs on June 26, 2023?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "a doggy play area with agility stuff and toys",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the date and speaker related to the question: June 26, 2023, Audrey to Andrew.\n\nStep 2: Look for messages from Audrey on or around June 26, 2023, mentioning the backyard or something set up for dogs.\n\nStep 3: Result 4 [2023-06-26T13:53:00] Audrey to Andrew says: \"Yep, I set up a doggy play area in the backyard with agility stuff and toys - they're loving it!\"\n\nStep 4: This directly answers the question about what Audrey set up in the backyard on June 26, 2023.\n\nFinal answer: Audrey set up a doggy play area in the backyard with agility equipment and toys for their dogs on June 26, 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 4.65,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.32
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Audrey and her friends stumble across during a hike a few years back, as mentioned on June 26, 2023?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "a stunning lake in the mountains",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant excerpt mentioning a hike a few years back and what was found.\n\n- Result 35 [2023-06-26T14:00:00] Audrey to Andrew: \"So a few years back my friends and I went on a hike and stumbled across this stunning lake in the mountains. We sat by it, chat and admiring the peacefulness of nature. I'll never forget those moments.\"\n\nStep 2: Extract the key details from this message.\n\n- Audrey and her friends stumbled across a stunning lake in the mountains during a hike a few years ago.\n\nFinal answer:  \nAudrey and her friends stumbled across a stunning lake in the mountains during a hike a few years back.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.48,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.63
    },
    {
      "question": "What is Audrey's favorite recipe that she shares with Andrew on 3 July, 2023?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Chicken Pot Pie",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant date and messages about the recipe shared on July 3, 2023.  \n- Result 7 (2023-07-03T20:39:00) Audrey to Andrew: She mentions sending a recipe soon, says it's her family's recipe, reminds her of her grandma's kitchen, and hopes Andrew likes it.  \n- Result 3, 4, 5, 13, 20, 25, 37, 38, 97 also contain messages around the same time discussing the recipe and cooking.\n\nStep 2: Look for the name or type of the recipe.  \n- None of the excerpts explicitly name the recipe.  \n- Audrey calls it \"my family's recipe that's been around for years\" and mentions the flavors remind her of her grandma's kitchen.  \n- Andrew comments on it looking nice, delicious, healthy, and expresses excitement to try it.\n\nStep 3: Check if any specific dish or ingredients are mentioned",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.9,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.59
    },
    {
      "question": "What dish is one of Audrey's favorite dishes that includes garlic and is shared with Andrew on 3 July, 2023?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Roasted Chicken",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the date and context of the dish shared by Audrey with Andrew.\n- On 2023-07-03, Audrey and Andrew discuss a recipe Audrey loves (Results 4, 6, 7, 20, 22, 24, 70).\n\nStep 2: Look for details about the dish and ingredients.\n- Audrey mentions the recipe is a family recipe with Mediterranean flavors, including chicken, garlic, lemon, and herbs (Result 20).\n- Garlic is Audrey's go-to ingredient in the kitchen (Result 24).\n- Andrew expresses excitement to try the recipe (Results 3, 22, 70).\n\nStep 3: Confirm the dish is one of Audrey's favorites.\n- Audrey calls it her favorite comfort meal (Result 20).\n\nFinal answer:  \nAudrey's favorite dish shared with Andrew on July 3, 2023, is a Mediterranean-flavored chicken dish made with garlic, lemon, and herbs.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.71,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.96
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Andrew and his GF do on the Monday before July 24, 2023?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "volunteered at a pet shelter",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the date range: The Monday before July 24, 2023, is July 17, 2023.\n\nStep 2: Look for any messages around mid-July 2023 mentioning Andrew and his girlfriend's activities.\n\nStep 3: The closest relevant message is from 2023-06-26 (Result 49 and 81), where Andrew mentions hiking with friends last Friday (which would be June 23, 2023), but this is not about his girlfriend.\n\nStep 4: No direct mention of Andrew and his girlfriend's activities on or near July 17, 2023, is found.\n\nStep 5: The closest mention involving Andrew and his girlfriend is on 2023-10-01 (Result 32), where Andrew says they are hitting the beach next month with Toby, but this is after July.\n\nStep 6: No explicit information about what Andrew and his girlfriend did on the Monday before July 24,",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.6,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.77
    },
    {
      "question": "What is the name of Audrey's childhood dog?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Max",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Audrey's childhood dog in the context.  \nStep 2: In Result 7 [2023-07-27T15:55:30], Audrey says: \"Thanks! That one is Max, my childhood dog. He had lots of energy and loved a game of fetch.\"  \nStep 3: No other childhood dog name is mentioned for Audrey.\n\nFinal answer: Audrey's childhood dog's name is Max.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.41,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.93
    },
    {
      "question": "What special memories does Audrey have with her childhood dog, Max?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Long walks in the neighborhood, exploring new paths, sharing worries and hopes",
      "generated_answer": "Audrey's special memories with her childhood dog Max include taking long walks together in the neighborhood, exploring new paths while Max sniffed and marked his territory. She grew very close to him, sharing her worries and hopes, and Max was a great listener who was always there for her. These days are some of her favorite memories.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.37,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.5
    },
    {
      "question": "What are some of the personalities of Audrey's four fur babies?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "oldest is relaxed, second is playful, third can be naughty but loves cuddles, youngest is full of life",
      "generated_answer": "Step-by-step reasoning:\n\n1. Audrey has four fur babies: Pepper, Precious, Panda, and Pixie (Results 24, 37, 50).\n2. In Result 59, Audrey describes their personalities:\n   - The oldest one is the most relaxed, like a wise old sage.\n   - The second one is always ready for a game.\n   - The third one can be naughty but loves a good cuddle.\n   - The youngest one is full of life and always up for an adventure.\n3. Result 37 adds some details about their favorite spots, showing their individual preferences and comfort zones:\n   - Pepper loves lounging on the couch.\n   - Pixie curls up in her bed.\n   - Precious has her chair.\n   - Panda loves to relax on his rug.\n\nFinal answer:  \nAudrey's oldest fur baby is relaxed and wise, the second is playful and ready for games, the third is a bit naughty but loves cuddles, and the youngest is lively",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.31,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.46
    },
    {
      "question": "What type of classes did Audrey start with her pups recently on 4 August, 2023?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Agility classes",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the date and context of Audrey's recent classes with her pups.  \nStep 2: Look for any mention of classes or training around early August 2023.  \nStep 3: Result 19 [2023-08-04T11:05:30] Audrey to Andrew states: \"I just started agility classes with my pups at a dog park.\"  \n\nThis directly answers the question about the type of classes Audrey started recently on August 4, 2023.\n\nFinal answer: Audrey started agility classes with her pups on August 4, 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.67,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.04
    },
    {
      "question": "How often does Audrey take her pups to the park for practice?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Twice a week",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for mentions of Audrey taking her pups to the park for practice specifically.\n\nStep 2: In [Result 16] (2023-08-04), Audrey says: \"I take them to the park twice a week for practice - it's been a great bonding experience.\"\n\nStep 3: No other excerpt contradicts or provides a different frequency for park practice.\n\nFinal answer: Audrey takes her pups to the park for practice twice a week.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.88,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.46
    },
    {
      "question": "How long did the trail hike that Audrey went on with her pups take?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Two hours",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Audrey hiking with her pups and any time duration details.\n\n- Result 2 (2023-08-04): Audrey says the hike took two hours.\n- Result 51 (2023-06-02): Audrey mentions a hike to a national park peak last week (around May 26, 2023), but no duration given.\n- Result 31 and 96 (2023-07-08): Audrey mentions a hike last year (July 8, 2022) but no duration.\n- Result 52 (2023-08-04): Audrey shares a pic on a trail hike but no duration.\n- Result 6 (2023-06-02): Audrey talks about a park visit but not a hike duration.\n- Result 11 (2023-09-24): Incident at the park, no hike duration.\n- Result 51 (2023-06-02): Mentions a hike to a peak but no",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.3,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.96
    },
    {
      "question": "What advice did Audrey give to Andrew regarding grooming Toby?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Grooming slowly and gently, paying attention to sensitive areas like ears and paws. And remember to stay patient and positive throughout the grooming process.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify messages where Audrey talks about grooming advice.\n- Result 7 (2023-08-19): Audrey says she took a dog grooming course and offers tips.\n- Result 2 (2023-08-19): Audrey advises grooming slowly and gently, paying attention to sensitive areas like ears and paws, and staying patient and positive.\n- Result 1 (2023-08-19): Andrew acknowledges the tips and says he'll remember them if he ever grooms Toby.\n- Result 11 (2023-08-24): Audrey offers more tips on taking care of Toby if needed.\n\nStep 2: Summarize the advice given.\n- Groom slowly and gently.\n- Pay attention to sensitive areas such as ears and paws.\n- Stay patient and positive throughout the grooming process.\n\nFinal answer:  \nAudrey advised Andrew to groom Toby slowly and gently, paying special attention to sensitive areas like ears and paws, while staying patient and positive throughout the grooming process.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.22,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.56
    },
    {
      "question": "What is essential to keep the dogs looking good according to Audrey?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Daily brushing, regular baths, nail trims, and lots of love",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of dog grooming or care related to appearance in Audrey's messages.\n\n- Result 6 (2023-08-19): Audrey mentions taking a dog grooming course and learning lots of techniques.\n- Result 2 (2023-08-19): Audrey advises grooming slowly and gently, paying attention to sensitive areas like ears and paws, and staying patient and positive throughout the grooming process.\n- Result 84 (2023-08-19): Audrey talks about learning a new skill in August related to grooming, making sure dogs are pampered and happy, and that they look cute post-grooming.\n- Result 60 (2023-11-22): Audrey mentions taking her dogs to the pet salon and how excited they were.\n- Result 96 (2023-11-22): Andrew asks for pictures of the dogs groomed up, implying grooming is important.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the key points Audrey emphasizes for keeping dogs looking good.\n\n-",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 4.32,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.53
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Audrey organize with the neighbors' dogs?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "a doggy playdate",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for mentions of activities involving Audrey's dogs and other dogs or neighbors' dogs.\n\nStep 2: Result 34 mentions Audrey taking her dogs out to play fetch and meeting other dog owners in the park, having a doggie playdate.\n\nStep 3: Result 23 from Andrew says \"Doggy playdates sound like a lot of fun. Glad they all get along.\"\n\nStep 4: Result 58 from Audrey says \"They're all 3-year-old and they are a great pack. We had a doggy playdate last Friday. It was a bit crazy but still lots of fun!\"\n\nStep 5: These references indicate Audrey organized doggy playdates with neighbors' dogs.\n\nFinal answer: Audrey organized doggy playdates with the neighbors' dogs.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.12,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.26
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Audrey do to give her dogs extra comfort as the weather cooled down?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Got new beds for them",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for mentions of weather changes or cooling down and how Audrey responded to that with her dogs.\n\nStep 2: In Result 13 (2023-10-13), Andrew comments on dogs looking sweet in a sweater, and Audrey responds in Result 19 (same date) about the dog park, but no direct mention of sweaters or warmth.\n\nStep 3: In Result 46 (2023-08-16), Audrey shares a photo of lying on the grass with her dogs, showing closeness but no mention of extra comfort for cold weather.\n\nStep 4: In Result 80 (2023-08-16), Andrew notes the dogs look cozy sleeping together, and Audrey in Result 100 (same date) says \"Yeah, they sure know how to get comfy! Here's a pic of them snuggling on my favorite blanket.\"\n\nStep 5: This indicates Audrey provides extra comfort by letting her dogs snuggle on her favorite blanket as the weather cools",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.32,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.36
    },
    {
      "question": "How does Audrey describe the new beds for her dogs?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Super cozy and comfy",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about new beds for Audrey's dogs.  \n- Result 81 (2023-09-06): Audrey says she got new beds for her dogs last week (around August 30, 2023) to give them extra comfort as the weather cooled down.  \n- Result 23 (2023-09-06): Audrey says the dogs \"absolutely love it\" and \"curl up and snuggle like they're in a cloud - it's adorable!\"  \n\nStep 2: Synthesize the description.  \nAudrey describes the new beds as providing extra comfort, especially with cooler weather, and the dogs love them so much they snuggle up like being in a cloud.\n\nFinal answer:  \nAudrey describes the new beds as providing extra comfort for her dogs, who absolutely love them and snuggle up like they're in a cloud.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.84,
      "judge_latency_s": 4.3
    },
    {
      "question": "How did Audrey calm down her dog after the leash incident?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Petted, hugged, spoke calmly and slowly walked the dog",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant excerpt about the leash incident.  \n- Result 1 mentions the leash incident where Audrey's pup pulled so hard the leash busted and she had to chase after her.  \n- Result 9 directly answers how Audrey calmed her dog after the incident: \"I petted and hugged her, spoke calmly, and slowly walked her to relax.\"\n\nStep 2: Confirm no conflicting information or additional details elsewhere.  \n- No other excerpts contradict or add to this calming method.\n\nFinal answer: Audrey calmed her dog by petting and hugging her, speaking calmly, and slowly walking her to help her relax.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.95,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.79
    },
    {
      "question": "How often does Audrey take her dogs for walks?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Multiple times a day",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for direct mentions of how often Audrey walks her dogs.\n\n- Result 22 (2023-09-24): Audrey says, \"Very often, multiple times a day even, it's a great exercise for them and great bonding time for us.\"\n- Result 30 (2023-09-24): Andrew asks how often she takes them for walks.\n- Result 20 (2023-06-13): Andrew asks how long she usually walks them, and Audrey replies in Result 65 that walks vary but usually last about an hour.\n- Result 41 (2023-04-16): Audrey mentions walking dogs in the park helps her recharge, implying regular walks.\n- Result 17 (2023-05-03): Audrey describes activities during walks but does not specify frequency.\n- Result 15 (2023-09-24): Audrey recounts a recent walk incident, indicating she walks them regularly.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.\n\nAud",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.74,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.64
    },
    {
      "question": "What kind of flowers does Audrey take care of?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Peruvian Lilies",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of flowers Audrey takes care of.  \n- Result 5 (Andrew to Audrey, 2023-09-24): Andrew shows flowers he has been taking care of.  \n- Result 12 (Audrey to Andrew, 2023-09-24): Audrey mentions she has a small garden as well.  \n- Result 28 (Audrey to Andrew, 2023-09-24): Audrey names the flowers \"Peruvian Lilies\" and describes them as having bright colors and delicate petals.  \n- Result 30 (Audrey to Andrew, 2023-09-24): Audrey says her flowers are looking great and her veggie patch is coming along.\n\nStep 2: Confirm the flower type Audrey specifically names.  \n- Result 28 is the clearest direct answer from Audrey about the flower type she takes care of: Peruvian Lilies.\n\nFinal answer:  \nAudrey takes care of Peruvian Lilies.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 4.42,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.55
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Andrew learn from reading books about ecological systems?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "about animals, plants, and ecosystems and how they work together",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about Andrew reading books on ecological systems.  \n- Result 2: Andrew says he enjoys watching birds and has read some books about ecological systems.  \n- Result 1: Andrew says he learned a lot about animals, plants, and ecosystems and finds it fascinating how it all works together.  \n- Result 10: Andrew mentions that nature is all connected and humans need to look after it.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.  \nAndrew learned about the interconnections between animals, plants, and ecosystems, finding it fascinating how everything works together, and he recognizes the importance of humans taking care of nature.\n\nFinal answer:  \nAndrew learned about the connections between animals, plants, and ecosystems and found it fascinating how they all work together, emphasizing the need for humans to take care of nature.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 4.99,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.56
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Andrew suggest as a way to reduce carbon footprint?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "biking or using public transport",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about reducing carbon footprint.  \n- Result 1: Andrew to Audrey suggests \"reducing our carbon footprint by biking or using public transport.\"  \n- Result 5: Andrew agrees biking is a great way to help the planet and train the body.  \n\nStep 2: Confirm Andrew's specific suggestions.  \n- He specifically mentions biking and using public transport as ways to reduce carbon footprint.\n\nFinal answer: Andrew suggested reducing the carbon footprint by biking or using public transport.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.71,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.41
    },
    {
      "question": "How does Andrew suggest helping the planet while also training the body?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "by biking",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of helping the planet and training the body in Andrew's messages.\n\nStep 2: In Result 10 (2023-10-01T19:25:00), Andrew suggests reducing carbon footprint by biking or using public transport, which helps the planet.\n\nStep 3: In Result 1 (2023-10-01T19:26:00), Andrew agrees that this is a great way to help the planet and also train the body.\n\nFinal answer: Andrew suggests helping the planet and training the body by reducing carbon footprint through biking or using public transport.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.78,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.54
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Audrey do with her pups over the weekend before 4th October, 2023?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Took them to the beach",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the date of the question reference: \"over the weekend before 4th October, 2023\" means the weekend of September 30 - October 1, 2023.\n\nStep 2: Look for any messages from Audrey around early October 2023 mentioning weekend activities with her pups.\n\nStep 3: Result 17 [2023-10-04] Audrey to Andrew: \"Hey Andrew! It's been a wild ride! I did something fun with my pups over the weekend, took them to the beach and it was so fun to see them playing in the ocean.\"\n\nThis message directly states what Audrey did with her pups over the weekend before October 4, 2023.\n\nFinal answer: Audrey took her pups to the beach over the weekend before October 4, 2023, and enjoyed watching them play in the ocean.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.72,
      "judge_latency_s": 3.95
    },
    {
      "question": "What was the reason Audrey couldn't walk her dogs for a period of time?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Knee injury",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for any mention of Audrey not being able to walk her dogs or a reason for it.  \nStep 2: In Result 72 (2023-10-06), Audrey says: \"It reminded me of when I couldn't walk my dogs because of a knee injury.\"  \nStep 3: This is a direct statement explaining why she couldn't walk her dogs for a period of time.\n\nFinal answer: Audrey couldn't walk her dogs for a period of time due to a knee injury.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.36,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.36
    },
    {
      "question": "What type of jewelry does Audrey make?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Jewelry made from recycled objects",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Audrey's jewelry making in the context.\n\n- Result 3: Andrew recalls Audrey making jewelry with recycled objects.\n- Result 5: Audrey confirms she makes jewelry out of recycled stuff like bottle caps, buttons, and broken jewelry, turning them into one-of-a-kind pieces.\n- Result 1: Audrey mentions she started making jewelry as a hobby and then selling it, donating a portion of profits to a cause.\n- Result 17: Audrey says she makes the jewelry herself, wanting each piece to be special and fit personalities.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize details.\n\nAudrey makes jewelry primarily from recycled materials such as bottle caps, buttons, and broken jewelry, creating unique, one-of-a-kind pieces that hold special stories.\n\nFinal answer:  \nAudrey makes unique jewelry crafted from recycled materials like bottle caps, buttons, and broken jewelry, creating one-of-a-kind pieces with special stories.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.73,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.63
    },
    {
      "question": "Why does Audrey make jewelry out of recycled objects?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "To show love for creativity and sustainability",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Audrey mentions she loves making jewelry out of recycled stuff as a way to show her love of creativity and sustainability (Result 1).\n\nStep 2: She hunts down items like bottle caps, buttons, and broken jewelry to turn them into unique pieces, each holding a special story (Result 1).\n\nStep 3: She started making jewelry as a hobby and then began selling it, donating a portion of her profits to a cause she cares about, combining her passions for jewelry and making a difference (Results 4 and 11).\n\nStep 4: This indicates her motivation is both creative expression and environmental sustainability, along with supporting a meaningful cause.\n\nFinal answer: Audrey makes jewelry out of recycled objects to express her creativity and commitment to sustainability, while also supporting a cause she cares about by donating part of her profits.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.71,
      "judge_latency_s": 3.66
    },
    {
      "question": "What organization does Audrey donate a portion of his profits to?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Animal shelter",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify where Audrey talks about donating profits.  \n- In Result 3, Audrey says she donates a portion of her jewelry profits to a cause close to her heart.  \n- In Result 2, Audrey specifies that she donates to an animal shelter.\n\nStep 2: Confirm that the cause she donates to is the animal shelter.  \n- Result 2 explicitly states she donates to an animal shelter, which aligns with her passion for pets and animals mentioned throughout the conversation.\n\nFinal answer: Audrey donates a portion of her profits to an animal shelter.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 4.87,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.09
    },
    {
      "question": "How does Audrey help out the animal shelter?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "By donating a portion of his profits frmo selling jwelery",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for any direct mentions of Audrey helping or volunteering at an animal shelter.  \n- Result 5 (2023-07-27): Audrey expresses interest in volunteering someday but does not say she currently volunteers.  \n- Result 18 (2023-10-06): Andrew says it's inspiring how dedicated Audrey is to making a difference even though she can't volunteer at the shelter anymore, implying she used to volunteer but stopped.  \n- Result 30 (2023-10-06): Audrey says she donates to an animal shelter as her way of helping out.  \n\nStep 2: Check if there are any other ways Audrey helps the shelter besides volunteering and donating.  \n- No other explicit mentions of activities like fostering, fundraising, or other direct help are found.  \n\nStep 3: Synthesize the information.  \nAudrey used to volunteer at the animal shelter but currently cannot. Instead, she donates to the shelter to support their work.\n\nFinal answer:  \n",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.06,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.88
    },
    {
      "question": "What type of games do Audrey's dogs like to play at the park?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Fetch and Frisbee",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of games Audrey's dogs like to play at the park.\n\n- Result 2 (2023-05-03): Audrey says they usually play fetch with a ball or frisbee.\n- Result 16 (2023-10-13): Audrey says her dogs go crazy for Fetch and Frisbee and love to run around and meet other pups.\n- Result 68 (2023-05-03): Audrey says her dogs have tons of energy and love meeting new pals at playdates, excited when she brings out toys.\n- Result 49 (2023-05-03): Andrew asks what else they do when walking, Audrey replies with fetch and frisbee.\n- Result 24 (2023-11-04): Audrey mentions activities like puzzles, training, hide-and-seek, but these seem more indoor or general activities, not specifically at the park.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.\n\nAudrey's dogs enjoy playing fetch with a ball",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.37,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.53
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Audrey make to thank her neighbors?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Goodies",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant excerpt mentioning Audrey making something for her neighbors.  \n- Result 85 [2023-10-13]: Audrey says, \"I made some goodies recently (approximately October 06, 2023) to thank my neighbors for their pup-friendly homes.\"\n\nStep 2: Determine what \"goodies\" refers to in this context.  \n- The term \"goodies\" typically means treats or small gifts, often edible.\n\nStep 3: Confirm no other details specify the exact type of goodies.  \n- No further details in the context specify what kind of goodies Audrey made.\n\nFinal answer: Audrey made some goodies (likely treats or small gifts) to thank her neighbors for their pup-friendly homes.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.74,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.7
    },
    {
      "question": "How do Audrey's dogs react to snow?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Confused",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify any mentions of snow and Audrey's dogs' reactions to it in the context.\n\nStep 2: In Result 1 (2023-10-13), Audrey says her dogs hate snow and were confused when taken to a snowy park last winter.\n\nNo other excerpts mention snow or reactions to it.\n\nFinal answer: Audrey's dogs dislike snow and were confused when taken to a snowy park last winter.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.41,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.4
    },
    {
      "question": "How does Audrey describe her dogs' response to snow?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "They definitely prefer nice, sunny days in the grass.",
      "generated_answer": "Audrey describes her dogs' response to snow as confused and not liking it. She mentions taking them to a snowy park last winter where they were very confused and that they definitely prefer nice, sunny days in the grass.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.1,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.06
    },
    {
      "question": "What kind of experiences are Audrey's dogs the best companions for?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Exploring the great outdoors",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Audrey's dogs and the types of experiences they share with her.\n\n- Result 3 (2023-08-04): Audrey mentions starting agility classes with her pups, enjoying watching them learn and build relationships with other dogs, and seeing them face and conquer challenges.\n- Result 5 (2023-08-04): Audrey says her pets have been her good buddies during tough times, providing happiness and love.\n- Result 22 (2023-05-03): Audrey talks about playing fetch and frisbee with her dogs, meeting other dog owners, and having doggie playdates.\n- Result 47 (2023-06-02): Audrey describes taking her pups to the park to run and play off-leash, which brings her peace and joy.\n- Result 53 (2023-10-01): Audrey mentions taking her dogs to a dog park with grassy and shaded areas where they had a great time.\n- Result 57 (202",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.32,
      "judge_latency_s": 3.3
    },
    {
      "question": "What activity do Andrew and Buddy enjoy doing together?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Walking",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Andrew and Buddy together in the context.\n\n- Result 13: Andrew named his dog Buddy because he's his buddy.\n- Result 2: Andrew says he and Buddy have a great time doing walks.\n- Result 33: Andrew says Buddy loves checking out new hiking trails with them.\n- Result 67: Andrew says he will be taking both Buddy and Toby to the trails soon.\n- Result 3: Andrew mentions taking Buddy hiking with him.\n- Result 17: Audrey says they walk very often, multiple times a day.\n- Result 19: Audrey mentions dogs cuddling up together, showing close bond.\n- Result 58: Andrew says Buddy is doing great in his new home and getting used to Toby.\n\nStep 2: Summarize the main activity Andrew and Buddy enjoy.\n\n- The clearest direct statement is in Result 2: \"Buddy and I have a great time doing walks.\"\n- Result 33 and 67 also mention hiking",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.06,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.37
    },
    {
      "question": "What do Andrew and Buddy like doing on walks?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Checking out new hiking trails",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Andrew and Buddy together in the context.\n\n- Result 1 (2023-10-19): Andrew says, \"Yeah, Buddy and I have a great time doing walks. It's a nice way to spend time together and get some fresh air.\"\n- Result 4 (2023-10-19): Audrey asks Andrew about favorite activities with Buddy.\n- Result 7 (2023-10-19): Andrew says, \"Yep, he loves checking out new hiking trails with us. It's awesome to see him so stoked and interested in everything nature has to offer.\"\n- Result 38 (2023-10-19): Andrew says, \"I named him Buddy because he's my buddy and I hope him and Toby become buddies!\"\n- Result 59 (2023-10-19): Audrey says, \"Nice! Buddy seems to be having a great time! It's nice to spend time together and get some fresh air.\"\n- Result 84 (",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.27,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.43
    },
    {
      "question": "What cuisine did Andrew recently try at a new spot in town?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "sushi",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Andrew trying new food or visiting new spots.\n- Result 27 (2023-10-24): Andrew mentions trying a new spot in town that serves sushi.\n- Result 15 (2023-10-24): Andrew talks about going with a California or salmon roll and trying sauces, which are sushi items.\n- Result 53 (2023-10-24): Audrey recommends California or salmon rolls for sushi.\n\nStep 2: Confirm the cuisine type.\n- Sushi is Japanese cuisine.\n\nFinal answer: Andrew recently tried Japanese cuisine (sushi) at a new spot in town.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.66,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.42
    },
    {
      "question": "Which type of sushi did Audrey suggest trying first to someone new to sushi?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "California or salmon roll",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant conversation about sushi between Audrey and Andrew.  \nStep 2: Look for Audrey's specific sushi recommendations for a beginner.  \nStep 3: In Result 4, Audrey says: \"Definitely try a California or salmon roll first when trying sushi - they're easier.\"  \nStep 4: This is confirmed again in Result 13 where Andrew repeats the plan to try California or salmon roll based on Audrey's tips.\n\nFinal answer: Audrey suggested trying a California roll or salmon roll first to someone new to sushi.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.91,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.83
    },
    {
      "question": "What type of date is Andrew going on Sunday?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "picnic date",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant excerpt mentioning Andrew's plans for Sunday.  \n- Result 1 [2023-10-28T14:45:30] Andrew to Audrey: \"Because on Sunday I am going on a picnic date with my girlfriend.\"\n\nStep 2: Confirm the type of date from the message.  \n- Andrew explicitly states it is a \"picnic date.\"\n\nFinal answer: Andrew is going on a picnic date with his girlfriend on Sunday.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.6,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.87
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Andrew and Audrey plan to do on the Saturday after October 28, 2023?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Go hiking",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the date of the conversation mentioning Saturday plans.  \n- Result 99 [2023-10-28T14:46:00] Audrey to Andrew: \"Saturday works for me! I'm going to bring some snack. Super excited!\"\n\nStep 2: Check the context around this message for what they planned.  \n- Result 68 [2023-10-28T14:45:00] Audrey to Andrew: \"Hmmm sure! Let's pick a date and go hike. It should be good!\"  \n- Result 40 [2023-10-28T14:57:30] Andrew to Audrey: \"Same here. Let's make it an epic and fun hike!\"  \n- Result 37 [2023-10-28T14:47:30] Andrew to Audrey: \"I bet! Where do you guys plan to explore?\"  \n- Result 16 [2023-10-28T14:58:00] Audrey",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.35,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.5
    },
    {
      "question": "What aspect of autumn does Andrew find beautiful?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "The autumn colors",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of autumn and what Andrew says about it.  \n- In [Result 1] (2023-10-28), Andrew says: \"How about going there the next trip? The autumn colors are so beautiful!\"  \n- Audrey responds positively about the autumn colors in [Result 3].\n\nStep 2: Understand what Andrew finds beautiful about autumn.  \n- Andrew specifically mentions \"autumn colors\" as beautiful.\n\nFinal answer:  \nAndrew finds the autumn colors beautiful.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.14,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.65
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Audrey do in November 2023 to better take care of her dogs?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Joined a dog owners group",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify any mentions of November 2023 activities by Audrey related to her dogs.\n\nStep 2: In Result 70 (dated 2023-11-04), Audrey mentions that she recently (approximately October 28, 2023) joined a dog owners group to learn how to better take care of her dogs.\n\nStep 3: This is the only specific action mentioned in November 2023 that relates to improving care for her dogs.\n\nFinal answer:  \nIn late October 2023, Audrey joined a dog owners group to learn how to better take care of her dogs.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.66,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.89
    },
    {
      "question": "How often does Audrey meet up with other dog owners for tips and playdates?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Once a week",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about Audrey meeting other dog owners.\n\n- Result 1 (2023-05-03): Audrey mentions meeting other dog owners in the park for playdates.\n- Result 3 (2023-11-04): Audrey says she tries to meet up with other dog owners once a week for tips and so the dogs can play together.\n- Result 27 (2023-07-03): Mentions a doggy playdate last Friday.\n- Result 50 (2023-05-03): Mentions dogs love meeting new pals at playdates.\n\nStep 2: The most specific frequency is in Result 3, where Audrey explicitly states she tries to meet up once a week.\n\nStep 3: Other excerpts support that these playdates happen regularly but do not specify frequency as clearly.\n\nFinal answer: Audrey meets up with other dog owners about once a week for tips and playdates.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.09,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.35
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Audrey share to show ways to keep dogs active in the city?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "photography of a basket full of stuffed animals",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Audrey sharing ways to keep dogs active in the city.\n- Result 8 (2023-11-04): Audrey mentions entertaining her dogs in the house with toys and games.\n- Result 75 and 76 (2023-11-04): Audrey advises Andrew to focus on taking care of his current dogs first before getting more.\n- Result 38 (2023-06-26): Audrey set up a doggy play area in the backyard with agility stuff and toys.\n- Result 23 (2023-08-04): Audrey started agility classes with her pups at a dog park.\n- Result 36 and 58: Audrey talks about playing fetch and frisbee, meeting other dog owners for playdates.\n- Result 96 (2023-11-04): Audrey meets up with other dog owners weekly for tips and dog playdates.\n\nStep 2: Summarize the key ways Audrey shared to keep dogs active in the city:\n",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.5,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.91
    },
    {
      "question": "What type of activities does Audrey suggest for mental stimulation of the dogs?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "puzzles, training, hide-and-seek",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify where Audrey talks about activities for mental stimulation.  \n- Result 7 (2023-11-04): Audrey says, \"We give them lots of activities to keep them busy - puzzles, training, hide-and-seek - they love it all!\"  \n- Result 2 (2023-11-04): Andrew asks Audrey about activities to stay mentally stimulated, and Audrey responds in Result 7.  \n- Result 10 (2023-08-04): Audrey mentions agility classes at a dog park, which is a form of mental and physical stimulation.  \n- Result 17 (2023-06-26): Audrey set up a doggy play area with agility stuff and toys.  \n- Result 23 (2023-05-03): Audrey mentions playing fetch and doggie playdates, which provide mental and social stimulation.  \n- Result 49 (2023-10-13): Audrey says her dogs love fetch and frisbee and meeting",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.78,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.11
    },
    {
      "question": "What is Andrew planning to do with Scout, Toby, and Buddy?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Take them to a nearby park",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Scout, Toby, and Buddy together in the context.  \n- Result 5 (2023-11-22): Andrew says, \"We're gonna take Scout, Toby, and Buddy to a nearby park.\"  \n- Result 18 (2023-11-22): Andrew mentions naming the pup Scout.  \n- Result 2 and 3 (2023-10-19): Andrew talks about Buddy and Toby getting used to each other.  \n\nStep 2: Look for details on what Andrew plans to do with them.  \n- Result 5 explicitly states taking all three to a nearby park for fun and fresh air.  \n- Result 14 (Audrey) advises starting small and keeping them leashed, implying a cautious introduction.  \n- Result 52 (2023-10-19): Andrew plans to take Buddy and Toby to trails soon, indicating outdoor activities.  \n\nStep 3: Synthesize the information.  \nAndrew is planning to",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.55,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.16
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Andrew get for Scout to create a safe and fun space for them?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "essentials like a bed, toys, and puppy pads",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant conversation about Scout and creating a safe and fun space.  \n- Result 3 [2023-11-22T09:08:00] Audrey to Andrew mentions creating a safe and fun space for Scout.  \n- Result 63 [2023-11-22T09:07:30] Andrew to Audrey talks about keeping Scout on a leash and mentions getting essentials for comfort and entertainment.\n\nStep 2: Extract details from Andrew's message in Result 63:  \n- They got a bed, toys, and some puppy pads for Scout.  \n- These items are described as essentials for Scout's comfort and entertainment, making a \"little safe haven.\"\n\nStep 3: Confirm no other conflicting or additional details are present.  \n- No other messages specify different items for Scout's safe space.\n\nFinal answer:  \nAndrew got Scout a bed, toys, and puppy pads to create a safe and fun space for them.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-44",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.09,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.94
    },
    {
      "question": "What are John's suspected health problems?",
      "category": 3,
      "gold_answer": "Obesity",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Review all excerpts for any mention of John's health or health problems.\n\nStep 2: In Result 80, John mentions being \"super busy at work\" with \"deadlines all over the place\" and describes it as \"really hectic lately,\" which suggests stress but not a health problem.\n\nStep 3: In Result 89, John says, \"this week has been chaotic with everything going on,\" again indicating stress or a busy period.\n\nStep 4: In Result 41, John says, \"I need some chill vibes too because it's been crazy for me lately,\" which again points to stress or feeling overwhelmed.\n\nStep 5: There is no direct mention of any specific health problems or symptoms John is experiencing.\n\nStep 6: No other excerpts indicate John has any diagnosed or suspected health issues.\n\nFinal answer: Not enough information to determine any suspected health problems for John.",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.17,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.76
    },
    {
      "question": "Which recreational activity was James pursuing on March 16, 2022?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "bowling",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the date in question: March 16, 2022.\n\nStep 2: Look for any messages around that date mentioning James and his activities.\n\nStep 3: Result 22 [2022-03-17T15:59:30] James to John says: \"By the way, yesterday (approximately March 16, 2022) I went bowling and got 2 strikes. I love bowling!\"\n\nStep 4: This clearly states that on March 16, 2022, James was bowling.\n\nFinal answer: On March 16, 2022, James was pursuing bowling.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.2,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.01
    },
    {
      "question": "Which places or events have John and James planned to meet at?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "VR Club, McGee's, baseball game",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of planned meetups or events between John and James.\n\n- Result 3 (2022-04-20): James suggests going somewhere together next year.\n- Result 4 (2022-09-04): John agrees to go somewhere together, calling it a fun experience.\n- Result 44 (2022-08-26): John suggests meeting but questions why Starbucks, proposing a beer somewhere instead.\n- Result 60 (2022-08-26): James suggests going to McGee's pub for a beer, mentioning they serve a great stout.\n- Result 56 (2022-10-31): James mentions renting an apartment near McGee's bar.\n- Result 59 (2022-06-19): John asks James to take him to a spot this weekend.\n- Result 35 (2022-06-19): James agrees to do something together.\n- Result 49 (2022-04-20): James says he'll",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.84,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.76
    },
    {
      "question": "Do both James and John have pets?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "No",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Check if James has pets.\n- Multiple messages confirm James has dogs: \n  - Result 13: James mentions having three dogs at home.\n  - Result 48: James talks about introducing Max, Daisy, and a new pup Ned.\n  - Result 82: James adopted a pup named Ned.\n  - Result 94: James describes Max as his dog.\n  - Result 4, 68, 96: James mentions dogs named Daisy and Max.\n- Conclusion: James definitely has pets (dogs).\n\nStep 2: Check if John has pets.\n- Result 9: John says he wants a pet but is \"not there yet.\"\n- Result 38: John says he doesn't have pets but will get one someday.\n- Result 7, 34, 62: John talks about James's pets but never mentions having his own.\n- Conclusion: John does not currently have pets.\n\nFinal answer: James has pets (dogs), but John does",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.83,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.9
    },
    {
      "question": "When did John resume playing drums in his adulthood?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "February 2022",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of John playing drums.\n- Result 3 (2022-09-18): John says he used to play drums when younger but hasn't in a while.\n- Result 1 (2022-09-18): John reminisces about playing drums when younger.\n- Result 2 (2022-03-27): John says \"I play drums too!\" and shares a pic of his set.\n\nStep 2: Check if \"I play drums too!\" in Result 2 (March 27, 2022) indicates current playing.\n- The message is from John to James on 2022-03-27.\n- John says \"I play drums too!\" which suggests he was playing drums at that time.\n\nStep 3: Compare with Result 3 (September 18, 2022) where John says he \"used to play drums when younger, but haven't in a while.\"\n- This suggests that by September 2022, John was",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.1,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.61
    },
    {
      "question": "What are John and James' favorite games?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "John's favorite game is CS:GO, and James's is Apex Legends.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of favorite games by James:\n- [Result 12] James mentions \"Apex Legends\" as having awesome graphics and fast-paced gameplay.\n- [Result 40] James says he has always loved playing strategy games like \"Civilization\" and \"Total War.\"\n- [Result 66] James recalls playing \"Super Mario\" and \"The Legend of Zelda\" as his first gaming system favorites.\n- [Result 74] James was inspired by \"Witcher 3\" for creating his own game.\n- [Result 99] James recently tried \"Cyberpunk 2077\" and found it great and addictive.\n\nStep 2: Identify mentions of favorite games by John:\n- [Result 15] John has been playing strategy and RPG games instead of his usual shooters.\n- [Result 81] John mentions playing his favorite \"CS:GO\" in an intense tournament.\n- [Result 62] John is playing a new RPG with a cool",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.97,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.09
    },
    {
      "question": "Does James live in Connecticut?",
      "category": 3,
      "gold_answer": "Likely yes",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for any direct mention of James's location or residence.  \n- Result 4 and 5 mention a trail near James's house, but no state is specified.  \n- Result 6, 18, 23, 27 mention James renting an apartment near McGee's bar, but no location is given.  \n- Result 11 mentions a dog shelter near John's street, not James's.  \n- Result 2 and 14 mention James planning to visit Vancouver and Toronto, indicating travel but not residence.  \n- No explicit mention of Connecticut or any other state as James's residence is found.\n\nStep 2: Check if any indirect clues suggest James's location.  \n- No references to Connecticut landmarks, cities, or addresses linked to James.  \n- The conversations mostly focus on activities, travel, and pets, without specifying James's home state.\n\nStep 3: Conclusion  \n- There is no information in the context that confirms or denies James living in Connecticut",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.61,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.36
    },
    {
      "question": "In which state is the shelter from which James adopted the puppy?",
      "category": 3,
      "gold_answer": "Connecticut.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the message where James mentions adopting a puppy and the location of the shelter.  \n- Result 19 [2022-04-12]: James says, \"I adopted a pup from a shelter in Stamford last week (approximately April 05, 2022).\"\n\nStep 2: Determine the state of Stamford.  \n- Stamford is a city in the state of Connecticut.\n\nFinal answer:  \nJames adopted the puppy from a shelter in Stamford, Connecticut.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.83,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.2
    },
    {
      "question": "How many pets does James have?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Three dogs.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: From [Result 1] (2022-11-07), James says he already has three dogs at home and thinks having more than three is too much.\n\nStep 2: From [Result 6] (2022-08-10), James mentions taking his three dogs to a beach outing.\n\nStep 3: From [Result 48] (2022-04-12), James adopted a pup named Ned in early April 2022.\n\nStep 4: From [Result 63] (2022-06-19), James says he introduced Max, Daisy, and the new pup Ned, indicating he has at least these three dogs.\n\nStep 5: From [Result 37] (2022-03-17), James names two dogs: Max and Daisy.\n\nStep 6: From [Result 4] (2022-05-04), Daisy is a Labrador, one of James's dogs.\n\nStep 7: From [",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.03,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.02
    },
    {
      "question": "What are the names of James's dogs?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Ned, Daisy, Max",
      "generated_answer": "Step-by-step reasoning:\n\n1. In [Result 9], James mentions one dog named Daisy, a Labrador.\n2. In [Result 56], James names two dogs: Max and Daisy.\n3. In [Result 42], James says he adopted a pup named Ned.\n4. In [Result 77], James mentions Max, Daisy, and the new pup Ned.\n5. In [Result 39], John says the name of the dog in the picture is Luna, and in [Result 57], James agrees Luna is a great name.\n6. In [Result 2], John clarifies that a dog shown is his cousin's dog, so Luna is likely not James's dog.\n7. In [Result 31], John asks the name of James's pup, and in [Result 39], John answers \"Luna,\" but this seems to be about a dog in a picture John saw, possibly not James's dog.\n8. The consistent names James himself",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.87,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.59
    },
    {
      "question": "When did James adopt Ned?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "first week of April 2022",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Ned's adoption.\n- Result 3 (2022-04-12): James says he adopted a pup named Ned \"last week,\" approximately April 05, 2022.\n- Result 1 and 2 (2022-08-26): They confirm Ned's name and that James adopted him.\n\nStep 2: Confirm the date of adoption.\n- The earliest direct mention is in Result 3, dated April 12, 2022, where James says he adopted Ned about a week earlier, around April 5, 2022.\n\nFinal answer: James adopted Ned around April 5, 2022.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.17,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.27
    },
    {
      "question": "How was John feeling on April 10, 2022?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "seeking solitude",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify messages around April 10, 2022, for clues about John's feelings.\n\n- Result 74 [2022-04-12]: John mentions a game with some lag and errors, referencing an issue from \"yesterday\" (approx. April 11, 2022), indicating some technical frustration but no direct emotional state.\n- Result 79 [2022-07-09]: John talks about feeling \"determined and passionate on one hand, but feeling overwhelmed and stressed on the other,\" but this is from July, not April.\n- Result 10 [2022-04-23]: John says he needs \"some chill vibes\" because \"it's been crazy for me lately,\" suggesting stress or overwhelm around late April.\n- Result 21 [2022-04-23]: John greets James casually, no emotional detail.\n- Result 47 [2022-04-23]: James offers support to John, implying John might have been going through",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.67,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.79
    },
    {
      "question": "Did James have a girlfriend during April 2022?",
      "category": 3,
      "gold_answer": "Presumably not",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for any mention of James having a girlfriend or romantic relationship around April 2022.\n\n- Result 1 (2022-08-10): James met a beautiful girl and plans to call her.\n- Result 17 (2022-08-10): The girl's name is Samantha.\n- Result 14 (2022-09-04): James says he asked Samantha to be his girlfriend recently (around September 3, 2022).\n- Result 45 (2022-10-31): James and Samantha decided to move in together.\n- No earlier messages before August 2022 mention James having a girlfriend.\n\nStep 2: Check messages from April 2022 for any mention of a girlfriend.\n\n- Results from April 2022 (Results 2, 3, 9, 13, 16, 19, 21, 35, 48, 53, 55, 56, 58, 59,",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 5.81,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.02
    },
    {
      "question": "When did James visit Italy?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "In 2021",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify any direct mentions of James visiting Italy.  \n- Result 2: James to John on 2022-04-20 says, \"Last year (approximately April 20, 2021) I visited Italy, for example.\"\n\nStep 2: Confirm no other conflicting or additional dates about Italy visits.  \n- No other messages specify a different time for James's Italy visit.\n\nFinal answer: James visited Italy around April 20, 2021.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.79,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.98
    },
    {
      "question": "When did James buy himself a new adventure book?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "April 26, 2022",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant excerpt about James buying an adventure book.  \n- Result 1 [2022-04-29T14:41:00] James to John: \"By the way, three days ago I bought myself an adventure book with fantasy novels and cool arts.\"\n\nStep 2: The message is dated 2022-04-29, and James says he bought the book three days ago.  \nStep 3: Calculate the date three days before April 29, 2022, which is April 26, 2022.\n\nFinal answer: James bought himself a new adventure book on April 26, 2022.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.78,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.05
    },
    {
      "question": "When did James start playing Civilization VI?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "March 2022",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for any mentions of Civilization VI or similar strategy games and when James started playing them.\n\nStep 2: In Result 23 (2022-04-29), James describes playing a \"high-quality turn-based strategy game\" involving managing resources and armies, which fits Civilization VI's style. In Result 32 (2022-04-29), James says he has been playing it for a month.\n\nStep 3: Since these messages are dated April 29, 2022, and James says he has been playing for a month, he likely started playing Civilization VI around late March 2022.\n\nStep 4: There is no earlier direct mention of Civilization VI, but James expresses interest in strategy games earlier (Result 6 on 2022-08-26 mentions wanting to create a strategy game like Civilization, implying familiarity).\n\nStep 5: The best evidence is from April 29, 2022, saying he has played for a month, so",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.71,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.65
    },
    {
      "question": "What is the game with different colored cards that was John talking about with James?",
      "category": 3,
      "gold_answer": "UNO",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant excerpt describing the game with different colored cards.\n\n- Result 5 [2022-04-29T14:52:30] John to James: \"There were multi-colored cards with numbers. You can only place a card with the same color or number on your opponent's card. Sometimes you trade cards, sometimes you need to draw a few extra from the deck or skip a turn.\"\n\nStep 2: Check if James or John named the game or gave a hint about it.\n\n- Result 1 [2022-04-29T14:53:00] James to John: \"I can't remember such a game. Maybe you have some other interesting games?\"\n- Result 6 [2022-04-29T14:54:00] James to John: \"Sounds cool! I've heard of that game, been meaning to try it out.\"\n\nStep 3: The description matches the rules of the card game \"Uno,\" which involves",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.32,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.72
    },
    {
      "question": "What is the board game where you have to find the imposter that John mentions to James?",
      "category": 3,
      "gold_answer": "Mafia",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of a board game involving finding an impostor.  \n- Result 3 (2022-04-29): John to James says, \"I've been playing one more game with friends these days. It's a game to figure out who the impostors are and it's super fun.\"\n\nStep 2: Check if the name of the game is given anywhere.  \n- No explicit name is mentioned in the excerpts for this impostor-finding board game.\n\nStep 3: Consider common knowledge and context.  \n- The description \"a game to figure out who the impostors are\" strongly suggests the game \"Among Us,\" which is a popular social deduction game involving impostors. However, the conversation only says \"board game,\" and \"Among Us\" is primarily a digital game, but there are board game adaptations.\n\nStep 4: Verify if any other excerpt clarifies the name.  \n- No other excerpt names the game directly.\n\nFinal answer:  \nJohn mentions a",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.41,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.95
    },
    {
      "question": "Which books has John recommended to James?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "The Name of the Wind, Stormlight Archive, Kingkiller Chronicles, Expanse",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify where John recommends books to James.\n\n- Result 16 [2022-06-16T17:11:30] John to James: \"Definitely! Two of my favorites are 'The Stormlight Archive' and 'Kingkiller Chronicle'. If SF is your thing, check out 'The Expanse' series. It's epic!\"\n\n- Result 19 [2022-04-29T14:42:30] John to James: \"Cool! Heard of 'The Name of the Wind'? It's another great novel with awesome writing.\"\n\nStep 2: Summarize the recommendations.\n\nJohn recommended the following books/series to James:\n- The Stormlight Archive\n- Kingkiller Chronicle\n- The Expanse series (science fiction)\n- The Name of the Wind\n\nFinal answer:  \nJohn recommended \"The Stormlight Archive,\" \"Kingkiller Chronicle,\" \"The Expanse\" series, and \"The Name of the Wind\" to James.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.41,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.03
    },
    {
      "question": "Was James feeling lonely before meeting Samantha?",
      "category": 3,
      "gold_answer": "Most likely yes, because he mentioned that the only creatures that gave him joy are dogs and he was actively trying to date.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for any mention of James's feelings before meeting Samantha.  \n- Result 7 (2022-04-20) shows James describing seeing a stranger during a walk and feeling like he fell in love at first sight but not approaching her. This suggests some longing or loneliness.  \n- Result 2 (2022-09-04) mentions James asking Samantha to be his girlfriend and that they had been through good and bad times, implying some emotional ups and downs before their relationship.  \n- Result 26 and 42 (2022-09-01) show John supporting James during difficult times, which could imply James was struggling emotionally before or around the time he started dating Samantha.  \n- No explicit statement says James was lonely, but the context of emotional ups and downs, longing from Result 7, and needing support from John suggests he may have felt lonely or emotionally unsettled before meeting Samantha.\n\nFinal answer: Yes, James was likely feeling lonely or emotionally unsett",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.01,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.93
    },
    {
      "question": "How many charity tournaments has John organized till date?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "two",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of John organizing charity tournaments.\n\n- Result 2 (2022-05-08): John says they put together a tournament for CS:GO and raised money for charity.\n- Result 1 and 15 (2022-05-08): James praises John for organizing a charity tournament.\n- Result 28 and 37 (2022-05-08): John confirms the goal was to raise money for a dog shelter.\n- Result 6, 21, 26, 88, 97 (2022-10-31): John organized a gaming tournament for a children's hospital, playing Fortnite, Overwatch, Apex Legends, raising money for charity.\n\nStep 2: Check if these are separate events.\n\n- The first charity tournament (CS:GO) was mentioned around May 8, 2022.\n- The second charity tournament (children's hospital) was mentioned around October 31, 2022.\n- The games and causes differ",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.1,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.11
    },
    {
      "question": "When did John first organize a charity tournament with his friends?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "May 7, 2022",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of John organizing a charity tournament with friends.  \n- Result 70 (2022-05-08): John says he was organizing something with friends \"yesterday,\" approximately May 7, 2022.  \n- Result 2 and 15 (2022-05-08): John confirms they put together a tournament for CS:GO that raised money for charity.  \n- Result 25 (2022-05-08): John says the money raised was sent to a dog shelter near his home.  \n- Result 1 and 6 (2022-05-08 and 2022-10-31): James praises John for organizing a charity gaming tournament.  \n- Result 11 (2022-05-08): John expresses interest in doing more events like that.  \n\nStep 2: Confirm the earliest date of this event.  \n- The conversation about organizing the tournament is dated May 8, 2022, and John",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.69,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.58
    },
    {
      "question": "Who or which organizations have been the beneficiaries of John's charity tournaments?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "animal shelter, homeless, children's hospital",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of charity tournaments organized by John and the beneficiaries.\n\n- Result 3: John mentions organizing a tournament for CS:GO and raising money for charity.\n- Result 28: John says the main goal was to raise money for a dog shelter near where he lives.\n- Result 41: John confirms the dog shelter was the main beneficiary and that they succeeded.\n- Result 5, 29, 44, 70, 15: John and James discuss a gaming tournament for a children's hospital, with games like Fortnite, Overwatch, and Apex Legends played, raising money for the hospital.\n\nStep 2: Summarize the beneficiaries.\n\n- One beneficiary is a dog shelter near John's home.\n- Another beneficiary is a children's hospital.\n\nFinal answer:  \nJohn's charity tournaments have benefited a local dog shelter near his home and a children's hospital.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.43,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.69
    },
    {
      "question": "When will John start his new job?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "In July, 2022",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify when John got the job offer.  \n- Result 1 (2022-06-13): John says he got his dream job.  \n- Result 31 (2022-06-13): John says he is starting next month.\n\nStep 2: Determine the month John refers to as \"next month\" from June 13, 2022.  \n- The next month after June is July 2022.\n\nStep 3: Confirm if there is any other information about the start date.  \n- Result 5 (2022-08-06): John mentions he left his previous IT job around July 30, 2022, and is happy with the new job, implying he started around or after that date.\n\nFinal answer:  \nJohn will start his new job in July 2022.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.58,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.93
    },
    {
      "question": "What kind of games has James tried to develop?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "football simulator, virtual world inspired by Witcher 3",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of James developing games.\n- [Result 3] (2022-03-17): John asks James what made him decide to create his own game.\n- [Result 8] (2022-10-13): James says creating his own game was special, inspired by Witcher 3.\n- [Result 18] (2022-09-01): James says he loves strategy games like Civilization and Total War and decided to create one of his own.\n- [Result 22] (2022-08-26): James mentions trying different genres and wanting to create a strategy game like Civilization.\n- [Result 45] (2022-10-13): James says it was fulfilling to see players engage with the game he created.\n- [Result 49] (2022-10-13): James is ready to make more games in different genres.\n- [Result 36] (2022-03-17): James",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.82,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.18
    },
    {
      "question": "Are John and James fans of the same football team?",
      "category": 3,
      "gold_answer": "No, James is a Liverpool fan and John is a Manchester City fan.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify football teams mentioned by James and John.\n- James says: \"no club better than Liverpool! I don't miss a single match of theirs!\" (Result 12)\n- John says: \"As a Manchester City fan, I can't agree with you. You'll see, our two teams will fight for the championship, and mine will win!\" (Result 7)\n\nStep 2: Check if they support the same team.\n- James supports Liverpool.\n- John supports Manchester City.\n\nStep 3: Confirm they have different team loyalties.\n- They explicitly disagree on which team will win the championship (Results 7 and 18).\n\nFinal answer: No, John and James are fans of different football teams; James supports Liverpool, and John supports Manchester City.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.02,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.89
    },
    {
      "question": "Which countries has James visited?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Italy, Mexico, Turkey, Canada, Greenland",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: From [Result 6], James visited Italy around April 20, 2021.  \nStep 2: From [Result 2], besides Italy, James has been to Turkey and Mexico.  \nStep 3: From [Result 3], James visited Nuuk, which is in Greenland, adding another country to his list.  \nStep 4: From [Result 7] and [Result 8], James plans to visit Canada (Vancouver and Toronto), but this is a future plan, not a past visit.  \n\nFinal answer: James has visited Italy, Turkey, Mexico, and Greenland.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.13,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.88
    },
    {
      "question": "What kind of classes has James joined?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "game design course, cooking classes",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for any mentions of James joining classes or courses.  \n- Result 19: John asks James if he chose a course because he loves football, implying James joined a course related to football.  \n- Result 52: James mentions attending tutorials and developer interviews to improve his game dev skills, indicating he joined some kind of game development learning sessions.  \n- Result 86: James says he joined an online gaming tournament (not a class, but an event).  \n- Result 61: James talks about combining gaming and storytelling and creating his own project, which may imply some learning but no explicit class mentioned.  \n- Result 100: James mentions programming experience from college, but this is past experience, not a current class.\n\nStep 2: Summarize the types of classes or learning James has joined:  \n- A course related to football (Result 19).  \n- Tutorials and developer interviews for game development skills (Result 52).\n\nNo other explicit mentions of",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.18,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.79
    },
    {
      "question": "When did James volunteer at an organization?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "May 2022",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of James volunteering.\n- Result 6 (2022-06-19): James says he volunteered with an organization providing necessary items to less fortunate people.\n- Result 13 (2022-06-19): James mentions volunteering last month (approximately May 20, 2022).\n\nStep 2: Confirm the date of volunteering.\n- Result 13 explicitly states James volunteered \"last month\" relative to June 19, 2022, which places the volunteering around May 20, 2022.\n\nStep 3: Cross-check for any other volunteering dates by James.\n- No other specific dates for James volunteering are mentioned.\n\nFinal answer: James volunteered at an organization around May 20, 2022.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.59,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.13
    },
    {
      "question": "When did James depart for his trip to Canada?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "July 11, 2022",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant messages about James's trip to Canada.\n\n- Result 10 [2022-07-09T17:17:00] James to John: \"By the way, I bought air tickets to Toronto, and I\u2019m leaving the day after tomorrow evening.\"\n- Result 9 [2022-07-09T17:19:00] James to John: \"I plan to return on July 20...\"\n- Result 3 [2022-07-09T17:17:30] John to James: \"Will you only be in Toronto, or will you be visiting somewhere else?\"\n- Result 1 [2022-07-09T17:18:00] James to John: \"I also plan to visit Vancouver...\"\n\nStep 2: Determine the date of the message where James says he is leaving \"the day after tomorrow evening.\"\n\n- The message is timestamped 2022-07-09 at 17:17:",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.56,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.94
    },
    {
      "question": "Which country did James book tickets for in July 2022?",
      "category": 3,
      "gold_answer": "Canada",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant time frame and message about booking tickets in July 2022.  \n- Result 2 [2022-07-09]: James says he bought air tickets to Toronto and is leaving the day after tomorrow evening.  \n- Result 6 [2022-07-09]: James plans to return on July 20.  \n- Result 10 [2022-07-09]: John notes this is the fourth country James will visit and asks if he will only be in Toronto or elsewhere.  \n- Result 11 [2022-07-09]: James plans to visit Vancouver as well, which is also in Canada.\n\nStep 2: Toronto and Vancouver are cities in Canada.  \nStep 3: No other country is mentioned in relation to the July 2022 ticket booking.\n\nFinal answer: James booked tickets to Canada in July 2022.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.01,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.98
    },
    {
      "question": "How many days did James plan to spend on his trip in Canada?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "19 days",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: James mentioned on 2022-07-09 that he bought air tickets to Toronto and was leaving the day after tomorrow evening (Result 2).\n\nStep 2: On the same day, 2022-07-09, James said he planned to return on July 20 (Result 18).\n\nStep 3: From the departure date (approximately July 11, 2022, since \"day after tomorrow\" from July 9 is July 11) to the return date July 20, the trip duration is about 9 days.\n\nFinal answer: James planned to spend about 9 days on his trip in Canada.",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.99,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.82
    },
    {
      "question": "Where was James at on July 12, 2022?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "Toronto, Canada",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for any messages around July 12, 2022, or references to that time.\n\nStep 2: Result 32 (2022-07-22) James to John says: \"Everything went great! In addition, I even managed to get out to another country. The city of Nuuk, if you know. I stayed there quite a bit...\"\n\nStep 3: Result 69 (2022-07-09) James to John says: \"I plan to return on July 20...\"\n\nStep 4: Result 70 (2022-07-22) James to John says: \"That's my sister and my dogs. We were just chilling together yesterday (approximately July 21, 2022)...\"\n\nStep 5: From these, James was abroad in Nuuk before July 20 and planned to return on July 20. So on July 12, 2022, he was likely still in Nuuk.\n\nFinal answer: On July ",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.86,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.72
    },
    {
      "question": "Did John and James study together?",
      "category": 3,
      "gold_answer": "Yes",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Review the conversation excerpts for any mention of studying together or attending school/college together.\n\nStep 2: The excerpts mostly discuss gaming, projects, family, events, and personal experiences, but there is no direct mention of studying or education.\n\nStep 3: There are no messages indicating that John and James studied together or attended classes together.\n\nStep 4: The conversations focus on shared interests and support but do not reference joint academic activities.\n\nFinal answer: Not enough information to determine if John and James studied together.",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.97,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.79
    },
    {
      "question": "Which countries did James visit in July 2022?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Canada, Greenland",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of James traveling in July 2022.\n\n- Result 3 (2022-07-09): John mentions the \"fourth country\" James will visit and asks if he will only be in Toronto or elsewhere.\n- Result 6 (2022-07-22): James says he managed to get out to another country, the city of Nuuk.\n- Result 8 (2022-07-09): James plans to visit Vancouver and maybe somewhere else.\n- Result 17 (2022-07-09): James plans to return on July 20.\n- Result 66 (2022-07-22): James took many shots on July 21.\n- Result 86 (2022-07-22): James brought souvenirs from his trip.\n\nStep 2: Determine which countries these cities belong to.\n\n- Toronto and Vancouver are cities in Canada.\n- Nuuk is the capital of Greenland, which is an autonomous territory within the Kingdom of Denmark",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.11,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.81
    },
    {
      "question": "What additional country did James visit during his trip to Canada?",
      "category": 3,
      "gold_answer": "Greenland",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: James mentions in [Result 33] on 2022-07-09 that he bought tickets to Toronto, Canada, and is leaving soon.\n\nStep 2: In [Result 1] on the same day, James says he plans to visit Vancouver as well, indicating multiple cities in Canada.\n\nStep 3: In [Result 3] on 2022-07-22, James says he managed to get out to another country during the trip, specifically mentioning the city of Nuuk.\n\nStep 4: Nuuk is the capital of Greenland, which is a separate country/territory from Canada.\n\nFinal answer: During his trip to Canada, James also visited Greenland (the city of Nuuk).",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.43,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.88
    },
    {
      "question": "Who is Jill?",
      "category": 3,
      "gold_answer": "Most likely John's partner.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for mentions of Jill in the context.\n\n- Result 1: John to James: \"Thank you very much, Jill will be delighted!\"\n- Result 2: James to John: \"Certainly! And not only impressions, I also brought souvenirs. For both you and your Jill!\"\n\nStep 2: Analyze the context around these mentions.\n\n- These messages are from July 22, 2022, and seem to be about James giving something to John and Jill.\n- Jill is mentioned as someone who would be delighted by the souvenirs or impressions James brought.\n- No other direct information about Jill's identity or relationship to John is given.\n\nStep 3: Check if Jill is mentioned elsewhere.\n\n- No other excerpts mention Jill.\n- No indication Jill is a pet or a friend; the phrasing \"your Jill\" suggests she is a person close to John.\n\nStep 4: Synthesize.\n\n- Jill is someone close to John, likely a friend or family member,",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.77,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.32
    },
    {
      "question": "When did John spend time with his sister and dogs?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "July 21, 2022",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of John spending time with his sister and dogs.\n\n- Result 2 (2022-07-22): James to John says, \"That's my sister and my dogs. We were just chilling together yesterday (approximately July 21, 2022)...\"\n- Result 5 (2022-07-22): John to James responds positively about spending time with his sister and furry friends.\n- Result 12 (2022-07-22): James to John again mentions being blessed to have a close bond with his sister and their furry friends.\n- Result 26 (2022-07-22): John to James talks about being grateful for the connection with his siblings.\n\nStep 2: Check if John specifically mentions spending time with his sister and dogs.\n\n- Result 2 is from James, talking about his own sister and dogs.\n- Result 5 and 26 are John responding about family and pets in general, but no direct mention of him spending",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.0,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.32
    },
    {
      "question": "What happened to John's job situation in 2022?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "quit his IT Job, secured his dream job, aspires to become an eSports competition organizer",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about John's job situation in 2022.\n\n- Result 61 [2022-08-06]: John says he left his IT job after 3 years around July 30, 2022, because he wanted something more meaningful.\n- Result 25 [2022-06-13]: John says he finally got his dream job after many interviews and late nights.\n- Result 76 [2022-06-19]: John is thinking about his career and future, showing motivation and passion.\n- Result 60 [2022-11-05]: John mentions a great accomplishment on a recent Tuesday, likely related to his new job.\n- Result 95 [2022-09-20]: James congratulates John on a major career milestone and asks about creating a mobile game, implying John is working on a mobile game in his new job.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the timeline and details.\n\n- By June 13, 2022,",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.94,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.13
    },
    {
      "question": "When did John start his job in IT?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "2019",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify when John got the job.\n- In Result 6 (2022-06-13), John says: \"I finally got my dream job! After lots of interviews and late nights, I got the offer and was ecstatic. Can't wait to start my journey!\"\n- In Result 55 (2022-06-13), James asks John: \"When do you start?\"\n\nStep 2: Look for any mention of the start date.\n- There is no direct answer from John about the exact start date in the provided excerpts.\n- The closest mention is that John \"can't wait to start\" as of June 13, 2022.\n\nStep 3: Check for any later messages that might indicate the start.\n- No explicit message states the exact start date or confirms that John has started.\n\nConclusion: John got the job offer by June 13, 2022, but no exact start date is given in the conversation.\n\nFinal answer: John got his IT",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.19,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.2
    },
    {
      "question": "What kind of tricks do James's pets know?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "swimming, catching frisbees, balancing on a skateboard, sit, stay, paw, and rollover",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of James's pets and their tricks.\n- Result 4 (2022-03-20): James says his dogs can do tricks like sit, stay, paw, and rollover.\n- Result 12 (2022-03-20): James refers to his two dogs as his best buds.\n- Result 55 (2022-03-17): James mentions Max and Daisy, his dogs.\n- No other specific tricks are mentioned in the context.\n\nStep 2: Confirm the specific tricks listed.\n- Sit\n- Stay\n- Paw\n- Rollover\n\nStep 3: No contradictory or additional trick information is found.\n\nFinal answer:  \nJames's pets know tricks such as sit, stay, paw, and rollover.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.3,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.33
    },
    {
      "question": "When did James meet Samantha?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "August 9, 2022",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the earliest mention of Samantha.\n- Result 6 (2022-08-10): James says he met a beautiful girl and got her phone number, planning to call her tomorrow.\n- Result 1 (2022-08-10): James tells John her name is Samantha and he will call her.\n\nStep 2: Confirm the timeline of their relationship development.\n- Result 7 (2022-09-04): James says that \"yesterday\" (approximately September 3, 2022) he asked Samantha to be his girlfriend and she agreed.\n- Result 3 and 5 (2022-09-04): They have been spending time together, including going to a baseball game and a bar.\n\nStep 3: The initial meeting must have been before August 10, 2022, since by that date James already had Samantha's number and planned to call her.\n\nStep 4: No exact date of meeting is given, but the",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.14,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.22
    },
    {
      "question": "When did James take his 3 dogs to the beach?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "August 9, 2022",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of James taking his dogs to the beach.\n- Result 1 (2022-08-10): James says \"Yesterday (approximately August 09, 2022) I took my three dogs to a beach outing.\"\n- Result 16 (2022-06-16): James mentions usually hitting the beach or lake with his puppy, but no specific date.\n- Result 24 (2022-08-26): James mentions his dog came to him while playing on the console, no beach mention.\n- Result 8 (2022-07-22): James mentions chilling with his sister and dogs \"yesterday (approximately July 21, 2022)\" but no beach specifically.\n- Result 88 (2022-07-22): James mentions traveling to Nuuk, no beach mention.\n\nStep 2: Confirm the exact date of the beach outing with three dogs.\n- Result 1 is the clearest and most specific: On August ",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.96,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.83
    },
    {
      "question": "When did John plan his next meeting with his siblings?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "In September, 2022",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of John planning something with his siblings.  \n- Result 2 (2022-08-21): John says they try to plan gaming nights when they hang out.  \n- Result 13 (2022-08-21): James asks if John still plays with his siblings.  \n- Result 16 (2022-08-21): John says, \"Yep, I'm organizing one with my siblings next month. We're stoked! Can't wait!\"\n\nStep 2: Note the date of the message where John mentions organizing the meeting: August 21, 2022.  \nStep 3: John says the meeting is planned for \"next month,\" which would be September 2022.\n\nFinal answer: John planned his next meeting with his siblings for September 2022.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.33,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.83
    },
    {
      "question": "Why didn't John want to go to Starbucks?",
      "category": 3,
      "gold_answer": "Possibly because he likes to drink beer on his days off.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: James initially suggested meeting at Starbucks (Result 2).\n\nStep 2: John responded that he didn't mind meeting up but questioned why Starbucks, suggesting maybe having a beer somewhere instead (Result 1).\n\nStep 3: James then proposed going to McGee's pub (Result 3).\n\nStep 4: John agreed but mentioned he doesn't like dark beer, asking if there was something else there (Result 11).\n\nStep 5: James reassured that there are also light beers (Result 59).\n\nStep 6: John finally agreed to meet at McGee's Pub (Result 37).\n\nFrom this, it appears John didn't want to go to Starbucks because he preferred a place where they could have a beer and a more social atmosphere, rather than just coffee.\n\nFinal answer: John didn't want to go to Starbucks because he preferred meeting somewhere they could have a beer, like McGee's pub, rather than just coffee.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.3,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.81
    },
    {
      "question": "What kind of beer does McGee's bar serve?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Stout, lager",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: From Result 1, James mentions McGee's pub serves a great stout, which is a type of dark beer.\n\nStep 2: From Result 4, James adds that there are also light beers available at McGee's.\n\nStep 3: From Result 3, James says Samantha loves a good lager beer at McGee's bar.\n\nStep 4: From Result 7, John says he doesn't like dark beer, implying there are other options.\n\nSynthesis: McGee's bar serves a variety of beers including stout (dark beer), light beers, and lager.\n\nFinal answer: McGee's bar serves stout, light beers, and lager.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.44,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.0
    },
    {
      "question": "When did John and James meet at McGee's bar?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "August 27, 2022",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of McGee's bar/pub in the context.\n- Result 2 (2022-08-26): James suggests going to McGee's pub.\n- Result 3 (2022-08-26): John agrees to meet at McGee's Pub \"tomorrow.\"\n- Result 4 (2022-09-04): James mentions he and Samantha were at McGee's bar.\n- Result 18 (2022-10-31): John comments on James loving to spend time at McGee's bar.\n- Result 1 (2022-10-31): James says they rented an apartment not far from McGee's bar.\n\nStep 2: Pinpoint the actual meeting date.\n- On 2022-08-26, James proposes going to McGee's pub.\n- John replies the same day agreeing to meet \"tomorrow\" (2022-08-27).\n- This is the clearest direct mention of a planned",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.0,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.86
    },
    {
      "question": "When did James ask Samantha to be his girlfriend?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "September 3, 2022",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about James and Samantha's relationship progression.\n\n- Result 3 (2022-08-10): James met a beautiful girl (Samantha) and planned to call her.\n- Result 1 (2022-08-10): James confirms her name is Samantha and he will call her.\n- Result 5 (2022-09-04): James says \"Yesterday (approximately September 03, 2022), when we were at the theater, Samantha loves theater, I asked her to become my girlfriend, and she agreed.\"\n\nStep 2: Confirm the date James asked Samantha to be his girlfriend.\n\n- Result 5 explicitly states the date as \"Yesterday (approximately September 03, 2022)\" relative to the message timestamp of 2022-09-04.\n\nFinal answer: James asked Samantha to be his girlfriend on September 3, 2022.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.79,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.12
    },
    {
      "question": "When did James, Samantha and John go to the baseball game together?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "September 11, 2022",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of the baseball game involving James, Samantha, and John.\n\n- Result 1 [2022-09-04]: James invites John to a baseball game next Sunday and says he'll show John what Samantha looks like.\n- Result 4 [2022-09-04]: James mentions that Samantha and he were at McGee's bar and they have much in common.\n- Result 79 [2022-09-04]: John agrees to join the baseball game next Sunday.\n\nStep 2: Determine the date of the baseball game.\n\n- The invitation was sent on 2022-09-04 (Sunday).\n- James says \"next Sunday,\" so the game would be on Sunday, 2022-09-11.\n\nStep 3: Confirm that John joined.\n\n- John replies positively in Result 79, indicating he will join.\n\nStep 4: Check if Samantha was present.\n\n- James says he will show John what Samantha looks like at the game",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.56,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.94
    },
    {
      "question": "What gaming equipments did John buy or refurbish?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Sennheiser headphones, Logitech mouse, gaming desk",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify all mentions of John buying or refurbishing gaming equipment.\n\n- Result 1 (2022-09-04): John says he bought new gaming equipment to improve his skills, specifically mentioning new headphones.\n- Result 2 (2022-08-21): John mentions buying some new devices and refurbishing his gaming desk.\n- Result 5 (2022-09-04): James asks John which company he chose and what other devices he bought, implying John bought multiple devices.\n- Result 60 (2022-09-04): James hopes the new devices will improve John's skill.\n- Result 34 (2022-08-21): John describes his current setup including a gaming PC with a powerful graphics card, headset, gaming chair, and keyboard.\n\nStep 2: Summarize the equipment John bought or refurbished.\n\n- New headphones (Result 1)\n- New devices (unspecified, but plural) (Result 2)\n- Refurbished",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.89,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.06
    },
    {
      "question": "When did James start taking cooking classes?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "September 2, 2022",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about James taking cooking classes.  \n- Result 1 (2022-09-04): James says \"Yes, two days ago I signed up for a cooking class.\"  \n- Result 3 (2022-09-04): James talks about what he cooked in the first lesson.\n\nStep 2: Determine the date of the message where James says he signed up.  \n- The message is dated 2022-09-04 at 21:29:00.  \n- He says \"two days ago,\" so he started the cooking class on 2022-09-02.\n\nFinal answer: James started taking cooking classes on September 2, 2022.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.72,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.8
    },
    {
      "question": "Which new games did John start play during the course of the conversation with James?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "AC Valhalla, Witcher 3, FIFA 23, Dungeons of the Dragons, futuristic dystopian game",
      "generated_answer": "Step-by-step analysis of the conversation excerpts for new games John started playing:\n\n1. Early in the conversation (Result 8, 2022-04-04), John asks James about new games he has been playing, indicating interest in new games.\n\n2. Result 10 (2022-08-10) John says he has been playing different genres like strategy and RPG games instead of his usual shooters.\n\n3. Result 14 (2022-08-10) John mentions he is hooked on a new RPG with amazing storytelling and characters.\n\n4. Result 57 (2022-04-12) John says he is playing a new RPG with a cool story and a futuristic dystopia world.\n\n5. Result 63 (2022-09-18) John says he started getting into board games and tried one last week (around Sept 11, 2022).\n\n6. Result 26 (2022-11-07) John says he collaborated to create an online",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.07,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.83
    },
    {
      "question": "When did John start working on his 2D Adventure mobile game?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "approximately summer of 2022",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify when John first mentioned working on the 2D adventure mobile game.\n\n- Result 1 (2022-09-20): John says he achieved a major career milestone by making his first mobile game, launching next month.\n- Result 10 (2022-09-20): John says he has been working on this for the past few months and is proud of how it turned out. He describes it as a 2D adventure game with puzzles and exploration.\n\nStep 2: Determine the approximate start time based on \"past few months\" from September 20, 2022.\n\n- \"Past few months\" before September 20, 2022, likely means John started working on the game around early to mid-2022, possibly between May and July 2022.\n\nStep 3: Check for any earlier mentions of this game or development.\n\n- No earlier direct mentions of John working on this specific 2D adventure mobile game are found before September",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 11.85,
      "judge_latency_s": 3.07
    },
    {
      "question": "How long did it take for James to complete his Witcher-inspired game?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "six months",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify when James started working on the Witcher-inspired game.  \n- Result 75 (2022-03-17): James mentions working on a project inspired by his childhood sketches, turning it into a computer game, excited about it.  \n- Result 8 (2022-04-20): James talks about working with a gaming pal on a programming project creating a virtual world inspired by Witcher 3.  \nThis suggests active development was happening at least by mid-April 2022.\n\nStep 2: Identify when James completed and released the game.  \n- Result 68 (2022-10-13): James says he made his first game and released it recently (around October 6, 2022).  \n- Result 1 and 35 (2022-10-13): James talks about the fulfillment of seeing players engage with the game he created, confirming the game was completed and released by early October 2022.\n\nStep 3",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.83,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.8
    },
    {
      "question": "What kind of programming-related events has John hosted?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "online programming competition, programming seminar",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of John hosting or organizing programming-related events.\n\n- Result 3 (2022-10-21): John says he organized a programming seminar around October 14, 2022.\n- Result 28 (2022-10-21): John says the seminar went well with a great turnout.\n- Result 33 (2022-10-13): John mentions organizing an online programming competition around October 6, 2022.\n- Result 10 (2022-10-31): James refers to John organizing a gaming tournament for a children's hospital.\n- Result 82 (2022-05-08): John mentions organizing something with friends around May 7, 2022, hinted to be an event.\n- Result 99 (2022-10-03): John says he was asked to be a programming mentor for game developers, teaching coding and assisting projects (not an event but related to mentoring).\n\nStep 2: Summarize the",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 4.51,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.76
    },
    {
      "question": "When did John and his programming friends host an online programming competition?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "Last week before 13 October 2022.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of an online programming competition organized by John and his programmer friends.\n\n- Result 13 [2022-10-13]: John says he had a blast last week (approximately October 06, 2022) when his programmer friends and he organized an online competition.\n- Result 1 [2022-10-21]: John mentions organizing a programming seminar last week (around October 14, 2022), but this is a seminar, not a competition.\n- No other results mention a programming competition specifically.\n\nStep 2: Confirm the date of the competition.\n\n- Result 13 clearly states the competition was organized last week from October 13, 2022, which is approximately October 06, 2022.\n\nFinal answer:  \nJohn and his programming friends hosted an online programming competition around October 6, 2022.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.88,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.05
    },
    {
      "question": "Which of James's family members have visited him in the last year?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "mother, sister",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of James's family visiting him or being with him in the last year (2021-2022).\n\nStep 2: Result 52 (2022-11-07) says James and his family are currently on a road trip visiting friends Josh and Mark.\n\nStep 3: Result 19 (2022-11-07) mentions visiting an animal sanctuary on the road trip with family.\n\nStep 4: Result 71 (2022-11-05) says James started a road trip with family and dogs on November 4, 2022.\n\nStep 5: Result 12 and 13 (2022-07-22) mention James having a close bond with his sister and dogs, chilling together on July 21, 2022.\n\nStep 6: No other family members are explicitly mentioned as visiting James.\n\nFinal answer: James's sister and his family (including dogs) have visited or been with him in the last year.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.47,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.69
    },
    {
      "question": "When did James' mother and her friend visit him?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "October 19, 2022",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify any mention of James' mother and her friend visiting him.\n\n- Result 81 [2022-10-21T19:45:00] John to James: \"By the way, my mother came to see me with her army friend two days ago. We had fun.\"\n\nStep 2: The message is from John to James on 2022-10-21, and John says \"my mother came to see me with her army friend two days ago.\"\n\nStep 3: Since John is the sender, \"my mother\" refers to John's mother, not James'. So this is about John's mother visiting John, not James' mother visiting James.\n\nStep 4: Check if there is any other mention of James' mother visiting him.\n\n- Result 39 [2022-10-21T19:46:00] James to John: \"Yes, she is still serving. But she retired a long time ago. They used to tell me stories",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.76,
      "judge_latency_s": 3.09
    },
    {
      "question": "When did James try Cyberpunk 2077 game?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "October 20, 2022",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of James trying Cyberpunk 2077.\n- Result 1 (2022-10-21): James says, \"By the way, yesterday (approximately October 20, 2022) I tried Cyberpunk 2077.\"\n\nStep 2: Confirm the date of the message to understand the \"yesterday\" reference.\n- The message is dated 2022-10-21, so \"yesterday\" refers to 2022-10-20.\n\nFinal answer: James tried Cyberpunk 2077 on October 20, 2022.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.44,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.85
    },
    {
      "question": "When did John and his gaming friends organize the charity tournament?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "On the night of October 30 to 31, 2022",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of the charity tournament organized by John and his gaming friends.\n\n- Result 2 (2022-05-08): John says they put together a tournament for CS:GO and raised money for charity.\n- Result 18 (2022-05-08): John confirms the event was awesome and wants to do more.\n- Result 44 (2022-05-08): John says it took planning and coordination.\n- Result 95 (2022-05-08): John says the main goal was to raise money for a dog shelter near his home, and they succeeded.\n- Result 3 and 19 and 32 (2022-10-31): John talks about holding a gaming tournament last night (October 30, 2022) with friends, playing Fortnite and other games, raising money for a children's hospital.\n\nStep 2: Distinguish between two different charity tournaments.\n\n- The May 8, 2022 messages refer",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 4.4,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.1
    },
    {
      "question": "What games has John played with his friends at charity tournaments?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "CS:GO, Fortnite, Overwatch and Apex Legends",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of John organizing or participating in charity tournaments with friends.\n\n- Result 61 (2022-10-31): John says he held a gaming tournament with buddies last night, playing Fortnite and a few other games, raising money for a children's hospital.\n- Result 73 (2022-10-31): John mentions playing Overwatch and Apex Legends with his gaming pals at the charity tournament.\n- Result 50 (2022-10-31): John shares a photo from the tournament and mentions the great atmosphere and cause.\n- Result 12 and 35 also reference the charity tournament context but no new games.\n\nStep 2: Summarize the games John played with friends at charity tournaments.\n\n- Fortnite\n- Overwatch\n- Apex Legends\n- Plus \"a few other games\" (not specified)\n\nStep 3: Confirm no contradictory or additional games mentioned.\n\n- Earlier tournaments mentioned by John involved CS:GO (Results 3, 6,",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.08,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.65
    },
    {
      "question": "What was James' big moment with Samantha in October 2023?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "They decided to live together and rented an apartment not far from McGee's bar.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the timeline of James and Samantha's relationship from the context.\n- On September 3, 2022, James asked Samantha to be his girlfriend, and she agreed (Result 4).\n- By October 31, 2022, James told John that he and Samantha decided to move in together (Result 5).\n\nStep 2: Check if there is any mention of October 2023.\n- The latest date in the context is November 7, 2022.\n- There is no information or messages from or about October 2023.\n\nStep 3: Since the question asks about October 2023, but the context only goes up to November 2022, there is no information about James' big moment with Samantha in October 2023.\n\nFinal answer: Not enough information.",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.12,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.9
    },
    {
      "question": "How long did James and Samantha date for before deciding to move in together?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "nearly three months",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: James asked Samantha to be his girlfriend around September 3, 2022 (Result 2).\n\nStep 2: By October 31, 2022, James told John that he and Samantha decided to move in together (Result 1).\n\nStep 3: The time between early September and the end of October is about 2 months.\n\nFinal answer: James and Samantha dated for approximately two months before deciding to move in together.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.07,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.76
    },
    {
      "question": "When did James, his family and his dogs start on a road trip together?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "November 4, 2022",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of a road trip involving James, his family, and dogs.\n- Result 7 [2022-11-05]: James to John says, \"Yesterday (approximately November 04, 2022), we started on a road trip. It was fun spending time with the family and my dogs.\"\n- Result 52 [2022-11-07]: James to John says, \"Me and my family are currently on the road trip!\"\n\nStep 2: Confirm the date of the start of the road trip.\n- Result 7 clearly states the road trip started \"yesterday\" relative to November 5, 2022, which is November 4, 2022.\n\nFinal answer:  \nJames, his family, and his dogs started their road trip together on November 4, 2022.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.9,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.81
    },
    {
      "question": "How long did John practice chess for before winning the chess tournament?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "nearly four months",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify when John started playing chess.\n- Result 7 (2022-07-22): John says he \"just started playing chess\" to get better at strategy.\n- Result 3 and 5 (2022-07-22): John talks about his early interest and enjoyment of chess.\n\nStep 2: Identify when John won the chess tournament.\n- Result 2 (2022-11-05): John says he won the regional chess tournament.\n\nStep 3: Calculate the time between starting chess and winning.\n- John \"just started\" chess around July 22, 2022.\n- He won the tournament by November 5, 2022.\n- This is approximately 3.5 months of practice.\n\nFinal answer: John practiced chess for about three and a half months before winning the regional chess tournament.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.4,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.55
    },
    {
      "question": "When did James and his family visit Mark and Josh?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "November 7, 2022",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of James visiting Mark and Josh.\n- Result 3 (2022-11-07T20:57:00): James says, \"Me and my family are currently on the road trip! We`ve already visited my friends Josh and Mark and had such a great time!\"\n- Result 1 (2022-11-07T21:01:00): James says, \"By the way, we did one good thing on the way to Mark and Josh.\"\n\nStep 2: Note the date of these messages.\n- Both messages are from November 7, 2022, around 20:57 to 21:01.\n\nStep 3: Additional context about the road trip.\n- Result 42 (2022-11-05T17:20:00): James says, \"Yesterday (approximately November 04, 2022), we started on a road trip.\"\n\nStep 4: Synthesis.\n- The road trip started",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.43,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.2
    },
    {
      "question": "When did John work with a game developer on a project?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "November 5-6, 2022",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of John working with a game developer on a project.\n\n- Result 1 (2022-11-07): John to James: \"I collaborated with a game developer to create an online board game - it's a fun and unique experience!\"\n- Result 50 (2022-11-07): John to James: \"I had a super fun weekend - I worked with a game developer on a project and it was great to see my ideas come to life. It was an incredible experience!\"\n\nStep 2: Both messages are from the same date, November 7, 2022, and mention the collaboration as a recent event (\"super fun weekend\").\n\nStep 3: No other dates or mentions indicate a different time for this collaboration.\n\nFinal answer: John worked with a game developer on a project during the weekend before November 7, 2022.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.53,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.03
    },
    {
      "question": "What programming languages has James worked with?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Python and C++",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about James's programming languages.\n\n- Result 28 [2022-03-17T15:50:30] James to John: \"I've worked with Python and C++. I've built a website and also created some game mods.\"\n\n- Result 1 [2022-03-17T15:51:30] James to John: \"I haven\u2019t worked with any other programming languages, but I hope to work in the future.\" (This suggests he only worked with the languages mentioned before.)\n\nStep 2: Cross-check if any other languages are mentioned.\n\nNo other programming languages are mentioned in the context for James.\n\nFinal answer: James has worked with Python and C++.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.47,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.36
    },
    {
      "question": "What type of mobile application does James plan to build with John?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "An app for dog walking and pet care",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for mentions of James and John planning to build a mobile application together.\n\n- Result 2 [2022-03-17T15:52:00] John to James: \"Maybe in the future we will develop mobile applications together? Do you like the idea?\"\n- Result 86 [2022-03-17T15:52:30] James to John: \"It would be cool! For example, we could write some kind of application for dogs. By the way, my dogs.\"\n\nStep 2: Identify the specific type of app James suggests.\n\n- In Result 86, James specifically mentions \"some kind of application for dogs.\"\n\nStep 3: Confirm no other types of apps are mentioned as plans between them.\n\n- No other specific app types are mentioned as planned projects between James and John.\n\nFinal answer: James plans to build a mobile application related to dogs with John.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.47,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.73
    },
    {
      "question": "How does James plan to make his dog-sitting app unique?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "By allowing users to customize their pup's preferences/needs",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant excerpts about James's dog-sitting app idea.  \n- Result 1 and 2: James mentions building an app for dog walking and pet care to connect pet owners with reliable dog walkers and provide helpful information.  \n- Result 6: James explains the personal touch that sets the app apart \u2014 users can add their pup's preferences and needs, customizing the app uniquely for each owner and dog.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.  \nJames plans to make the app unique by allowing users to customize it with their dog's individual preferences and needs, giving a personalized experience rather than a generic one.\n\nFinal answer:  \nJames plans to make his dog-sitting app unique by allowing users to customize it with their dog's specific preferences and needs, creating a personalized experience for each pet owner and their dog.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.49,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.87
    },
    {
      "question": "What has John mostly found with the metal detector so far?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "bottle caps",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about John's metal detector hobby.\n- Result 1: John mentions buying a metal detector around March 13, 2022.\n- Result 2: John says he mostly finds bottle caps, but also coins and once a gold ring.\n\nStep 2: Confirm no contradictory or additional information elsewhere.\n- No other excerpts provide different details about what John found.\n\nFinal answer: John has mostly found bottle caps with the metal detector so far.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.93,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.76
    },
    {
      "question": "What did James offer to do for John regarding pets?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "help find the perfect pet",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about James offering help to John regarding pets.\n\n- Result 5 [2022-03-20]: James to John: \"A pet would truly be great for you! ... If you're interested, I can help find the perfect one for you - you'd make a great pet parent!\"\n- Result 38 [2022-03-17]: John to James asks about pets and plans for an app, indicating James had mentioned pets before.\n- Result 21 [2022-03-17]: James suggests trying something different, possibly related to pets or an app.\n- Result 87 [2022-03-17]: James mentions Max and Daisy and talks about building an app for dog walking and pet care, connecting pet owners with dog walkers and providing pet care info.\n\nStep 2: Focus on direct offers of help.\n\nThe clearest direct offer is in Result 5, where James offers to help John find the perfect pet if John is interested.\n\n",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.27,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.69
    },
    {
      "question": "What instrument is John learning to play as of 27 March, 2022?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Drums",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for mentions of John playing or learning an instrument around the date 27 March 2022.\n\nStep 2: In [Result 6] (2022-03-27), John says to James: \"Thanks, James! I play drums too! Here's a pic of my set.\" This indicates John plays drums.\n\nStep 3: In [Result 2] and [Result 4] (both 2022-09-18), John mentions he used to play drums when younger but hasn't in a while.\n\nStep 4: There is no direct statement that John is currently learning a new instrument as of 27 March 2022, but he confirms playing drums.\n\nStep 5: James mentions learning an instrument in [Result 1] (2022-03-27), but John does not mention learning a new instrument.\n\nConclusion: As of 27 March 2022, John is playing drums (not necessarily learning a new instrument), and",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.88,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.71
    },
    {
      "question": "How long has John been playing the drums as of 27 March, 2022?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "One month",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant messages about John playing drums before or on March 27, 2022.\n\n- Result 2 [2022-03-27]: John to James: \"Thanks, James! I play drums too! Here's a pic of my set.\"\n- Result 5 [2022-09-18]: John to James: \"I used to play drums when I was younger, but haven't in a while.\"\n- Result 1 [2022-09-18]: John to James: \"Playing drums when I was younger was a fun way to let off steam.\"\n- Result 14 [2022-09-18]: John to James: \"I've jammed with friends before, it was a lot of fun!\"\n\nStep 2: From these, the only direct mention of duration or length of playing is missing. John says he played drums when he was younger but hasn't played in a while (Result 5 and 1). No specific length of time is",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.94,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.47
    },
    {
      "question": "What game did John play in an intense tournament at the gaming convention in March 2022?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "CS:GO",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the time and event.\n- The question asks about a game John played in an intense tournament at a gaming convention in March 2022.\n\nStep 2: Look for mentions of March 2022 and gaming conventions or tournaments.\n- Result 7 [2022-03-27]: John mentions attending a gaming convention, trying out games, meeting developers, and taking part in a tournament.\n- Result 1 [2022-03-27]: John says he played his favorite CS:GO game in an intense tournament.\n- Result 4 [2022-05-08]: John clarifies the tournament was for CS:GO.\n- Result 19 [2022-03-27]: John says watching skilled players inspired him to improve his gaming skills.\n- Result 6 and 3 [2022-03-27]: James asks what game it was, and John confirms it was CS:GO.\n\nStep 3: Synthesize the information.\n-",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.75,
      "judge_latency_s": 3.91
    },
    {
      "question": "What game was James playing in the online gaming tournament in April 2022?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Apex Legends",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the date of the online gaming tournament James participated in April 2022.  \n- Result 5: James mentions joining an online gaming tournament \"yesterday\" on April 4, 2022, so the tournament was around April 3, 2022.\n\nStep 2: Look for mentions of the game James played in that tournament.  \n- Result 14: James says he has been playing his favorite game called Apex Legends with his team.  \n- Result 23: James says he did well in the tournament, made it to the semis, and shares a screenshot of his character. This is in the same April 4, 2022 conversation.  \n- Result 24: James praises Apex Legends for its graphics and gameplay, indicating it is the game he was playing around that time.\n\nStep 3: Confirm that the tournament James referred to in April 2022 was indeed for Apex Legends.  \n- The timing and context strongly suggest the",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.9,
      "judge_latency_s": 4.2
    },
    {
      "question": "How does James communicate with his gaming team?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "voice chat",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about James's communication with his gaming team.\n\n- Result 1 (John to James): John emphasizes the importance of communication and teamwork.\n- Result 2 (James to John): James says he usually uses voice chat to communicate with his team because it's fast and effective.\n- Result 28 (James to John): James mentions the importance of communicating correctly with the team and not putting ego above team success.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.\n\nJames explicitly states that he uses voice chat to communicate with his team, highlighting its speed and effectiveness. He also values proper communication and teamwork.\n\nFinal answer: James communicates with his gaming team primarily using voice chat because it is fast and helps them work together effectively.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.45,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.79
    },
    {
      "question": "What advice did James receive from the famous players he met at the tournament?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "never put your ego above team success",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant conversation about James meeting famous players at a tournament.  \n- Result 4: James to John mentions meeting the whole team and receiving gaming tips from one of them.  \n- Result 5: James to John shares the most important advice he remembers: \"you always need to communicate correctly with the team and never put your ego above team success.\"  \n- Result 11: James to John adds that the whole team gave him autographs and he was very happy.\n\nStep 2: Confirm the advice content.  \n- The key advice James recalls is about communication and humility in teamwork.\n\nFinal answer:  \nJames received advice to always communicate correctly with the team and never put his ego above the team's success.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.61,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.08
    },
    {
      "question": "What did James adopt in April 2022?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "a pup",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for any mention of James adopting something in April 2022.\n\nStep 2: Result 3 (2022-08-06) mentions James took his puppy to the clinic \"yesterday,\" which is approximately August 5, 2022. This implies James had a puppy by August.\n\nStep 3: Result 92 (2022-06-16) James introduces \"Max,\" a lovable and playful dog who brings him joy.\n\nStep 4: Result 42 (2022-08-06) John asks James what happened to his puppy, indicating James had a puppy by August.\n\nStep 5: No direct mention of the exact adoption date, but Result 3 and 42 imply James had a puppy by early August.\n\nStep 6: Check earlier messages in April for any mention of a new pet.\n\nStep 7: Result 93 (2022-03-20) James talks about pets in general but no adoption.\n\nStep ",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.54,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.96
    },
    {
      "question": "What is the name of the pup that was adopted by James?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Ned",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of James adopting a pup.\n- Result 18 (2022-04-12): James says he adopted a pup from a shelter in Stamford around April 5, 2022, and named it Ned.\n- Result 57 (2022-08-26): James refers to a pup named Ned that he adopted.\n- Result 56 (2022-06-19): James mentions introducing Max, Daisy, and the new pup Ned.\n\nStep 2: Confirm the name of the adopted pup.\n- Multiple results (18, 56, 57) consistently name the adopted pup as Ned.\n\nFinal answer: The pup adopted by James is named Ned.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.27,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.9
    },
    {
      "question": "Why did James embody the appearance of the game character from the woman he saw during a walk?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "He found her appearance and eyes amazing.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: From Result 1, James explains that during a walk with his dogs two weeks prior, he saw a stranger woman whose eyes and appearance amazed him so much that it felt like love at first sight.\n\nStep 2: He regrets not approaching her but at least remembered her appearance.\n\nStep 3: James then embodied her appearance in the game, likely as a way to capture the strong impression she made on him and to immortalize that moment creatively.\n\nFinal answer: James embodied the woman's appearance in the game because he was deeply impressed and felt love at first sight when he saw her during a walk, and although he didn't approach her, he wanted to remember and express that feeling through his game character.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.01,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.34
    },
    {
      "question": "What inspired James to create the game character in the virtual world?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Appearance of a woman he saw during a walk",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: James mentions in [Result 18] (2022-03-17) that he has been working on something he wanted to do since he was a kid, including sketches of the main character from his childhood comic drawings, now wanting to turn it into a computer game.\n\nStep 2: In [Result 15] (2022-04-20), James says he worked with a gaming pal on a programming project creating a virtual world inspired by Witcher 3.\n\nStep 3: In [Result 1] (2022-10-13), James explicitly states that Witcher 3 gave him a ton of inspiration with its amazing world and story, pushing him to create something cool.\n\nStep 4: In [Result 2] (2022-04-20), James talks about the effort in creating the game character and how rewarding it was.\n\nSynthesis: James was inspired by his childhood passion for storytelling and character sketches, combined with the immersive",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.01,
      "judge_latency_s": 3.14
    },
    {
      "question": "Which country did James visit in 2021?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Italy",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify any mention of James visiting a country in 2021.\nStep 2: In Result 5, James says: \"Last year (approximately April 20, 2021) I visited Italy, for example.\"\nStep 3: This clearly states that James visited Italy in 2021.\n\nFinal answer: James visited Italy in 2021.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.36,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.33
    },
    {
      "question": "What impresses John about Japan?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Technologically advanced megacities and tasty street food",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about Japan and John's impressions.\n\n- Result 1 [2022-04-20T21:39:00] John to James: \"This was Japan. The megacities of this country impress me, everything there is so technologically advanced, the huge screens on the buildings are mesmerizing. And, of course, very tasty street food.\"\n\nStep 2: Summarize what John specifically mentions as impressive.\n\n- Megacities\n- Technological advancement\n- Huge screens on buildings\n- Tasty street food\n\nFinal answer:  \nJohn is impressed by Japan's megacities, their technological advancement, the huge mesmerizing screens on buildings, and the very tasty street food.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.15,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.02
    },
    {
      "question": "What kind of assignment was giving John a hard time at work?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Coding assignment",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about John's work difficulties.\n\n- Result 24 [2022-04-23]: John to James: \"Ugh, this project is giving me a hard time. It's a difficult assignment that involves coding and I'm stuck on it.\"\n- Result 5 [2022-04-23]: John to James: \"Been super busy at work. Deadlines all over the place and so much to do. It's just been really hectic lately.\"\n- Result 18 [2022-04-23]: James to John: \"Yeah, it's really frustrating when a project doesn't go as planned. What specifically is giving you trouble?\"\n- Result 10 [2022-04-23]: James to John: \"Gotcha, what's the problem with the project? Need a hand figuring out some ideas?\"\n- Result 20 [2022-05-04]: James to John: \"Last Friday, something happened on my project that I've been working on for weeks",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 4.26,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.71
    },
    {
      "question": "What breed is Daisy, one of James' dogs?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Labrador",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Daisy and her breed in the context.  \n- Result 1 states: \"One of them, Daisy, is a Labrador.\"  \n- Result 24 has John asking about the other two dogs, guessing shepherds, implying Daisy is not a shepherd.  \n- Result 2 and others mention Daisy but do not specify breed again.\n\nStep 2: Confirm no conflicting information about Daisy's breed.  \n- No other excerpt contradicts Daisy being a Labrador.\n\nFinal answer:  \nDaisy is a Labrador.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.37,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.57
    },
    {
      "question": "What type of pizza is James' favorite?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Pepperoni",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify where James mentions his favorite pizza.  \n- In Result 4, James to John says: \"Pepperoni of course! An amazing combination of spicy salami and cheese.\"\n\nStep 2: Confirm no other pizza type is stated as James' favorite.  \n- In Result 2, James also mentions liking cheese pizza and prosciutto, but does not say these are his favorites.  \n- Result 4 explicitly states \"Pepperoni of course!\" indicating it is his favorite.\n\nFinal answer: James' favorite pizza is pepperoni.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.78,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.84
    },
    {
      "question": "What type of pizza is John's favorite?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Hawaiian",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify where John mentions his favorite pizza.  \nStep 2: In Result 1, John says, \"my favorite thing is Hawaiian pizza.\"  \nStep 3: No other excerpt contradicts or changes this preference.\n\nFinal answer: John's favorite pizza is Hawaiian pizza.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.1,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.99
    },
    {
      "question": "What did John organize with his friends on May 8, 2022?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "A tournament for CS:GO",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant date and messages around May 8, 2022.\n\n- Result 6 (2022-05-08): John says he organized something with friends \"yesterday\" (approx. May 7, 2022).\n- Result 25 (2022-05-08): John says it took planning and coordination, and it was rewarding to see everyone come together for a good cause.\n- Result 26 (2022-05-08): James refers to John organizing a tournament for charity.\n- Result 54 (2022-05-08): John says the main goal was to raise money for a dog shelter near his home, and they succeeded.\n- Result 11 (2022-05-08): John says he wants to do more events like that, combining interests and helping the community with friendly competition.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.\n\nJohn organized a charity tournament with his friends on May 7, 2022",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.25,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.72
    },
    {
      "question": "What did John and his friends do with the remaining money after helping the dog shelter?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Bought groceries and cooked food for the homeless",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant excerpts about the money raised and what was done with it.\n\n- Result 1: John says their main goal was to raise money for a dog shelter near his home, and they succeeded.\n- Result 2: John says they still had some money left after helping the shelter, and they decided to use this money to buy groceries and cook food for the homeless, who were very happy.\n- Result 5: James asks where the collected money was sent.\n- Result 7: James emphasizes helping animals is important.\n- Result 55: James praises John for helping those in need.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.\n\nJohn and friends raised money for a dog shelter. After donating to the shelter, they had leftover funds, which they used to buy groceries and cook food for homeless people.\n\nFinal answer:  \nJohn and his friends used the remaining money after helping the dog shelter to buy groceries and cook food for the homeless.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 4.17,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.33
    },
    {
      "question": "What was the main goal of the money raised from the charity tournament organized by John and his friends in May 2022?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Raise money for a dog shelter",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant conversation about the charity tournament in May 2022.  \n- Result 3 (2022-05-08): John mentions organizing a tournament for CS:GO to raise money for charity.  \n- Result 8 (2022-05-08): John specifies the main goal was to raise money for a dog shelter near his street.  \n- Result 52 (2022-05-08): John adds that after helping the shelter, leftover money was used to buy groceries and cook food for the homeless.\n\nStep 2: Confirm the main goal.  \n- The primary stated goal was raising money for a dog shelter.\n\nStep 3: Note additional use of funds but not the main goal.  \n- Leftover funds were used for groceries for the homeless, but this was secondary.\n\nFinal answer:  \nThe main goal of the money raised from the charity tournament in May 2022 was to support a dog shelter near John's street.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 4.07,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.37
    },
    {
      "question": "What did the system John created help the charitable foundation with?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "tracking inventory, resources, and donations",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of John creating a system or software for a charitable foundation.  \n- Result 11 (2022-05-11): John volunteered his programming skills and made a software tool for a charitable foundation to streamline their operations and make them run more smoothly.  \n- Result 4 (2022-05-11): John shared a screenshot of the system that helps track inventory, resources, and donations, and generates reports for analysis.  \n- Result 14 (2022-05-11): John said the experience showed him the power of tech to make positive changes beyond his own enjoyment.  \n- Result 21 (2022-05-11): John was inspired by the foundation's passion for helping kids and wanted to contribute with coding skills.  \n- Result 62 (2022-05-11): James asked to see visual examples of the impact of John's software.\n\nStep 2: Summarize the system's purpose based on these details.  \nThe",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.97,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.73
    },
    {
      "question": "What did John create for the charitable foundation that helped generate reports for analysis?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "computer application on smartphones",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of John creating something for a charitable foundation.\n- Result 21 (2022-05-11): John volunteered programming skills for a social cause, making a software tool for a charitable foundation to streamline operations.\n- Result 1 (2022-05-11): John shared a screenshot of the system that helps track inventory, resources, and donations, and generates reports for analysis.\n- Result 52 (2022-05-11): John explained the foundation previously used paper records and manual inventory; he made an application that structured their work, consolidating inventory on a smartphone app.\n\nStep 2: Confirm the nature of the creation.\n- The creation is a software application for the foundation.\n- It helps track inventory, resources, and donations.\n- It generates reports for analysis.\n- It replaced manual paper records with a smartphone app.\n\nFinal answer: John created a software application for the charitable foundation that streamlined their inventory, resources, and donations tracking, and generated",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.77,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.3
    },
    {
      "question": "What did John receive for achieving second place in the tournament?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "money and a trophy",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant messages about John's second place in a tournament.  \n- Result 3 (2022-05-23): John says he took second place in a local tournament last Friday.  \n- Result 1 (2022-05-23): John says he didn't win but received some money for 2nd place.  \n- Result 17 (2022-05-23): John mentions he also got a trophy for this achievement.\n\nStep 2: Summarize what John received for second place.  \n- He received some money as a prize.  \n- He also received a trophy.\n\nFinal answer: John received some money and a trophy for achieving second place in the tournament.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.11,
      "judge_latency_s": 4.32
    },
    {
      "question": "What project is James working on in his game design course?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "a new part of the football simulator, collecting player databases",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of James's game design course or projects related to game design.\n\n- Result 4 (2022-03-17): James talks about working on a project he's wanted to do since childhood, turning sketches of a main character from comics into a computer game.\n- Result 10 (2022-03-17): James mentions combining gaming and storytelling in his project.\n- Result 21 (2022-10-13): James says Witcher 3 inspired him to create his own game with an amazing world and story.\n- Result 23 (2022-08-26): James is trying different game genres and wants to create a strategy game like Civilization.\n- Result 26 (2022-04-29): James describes a high-quality turn-based strategy game where you manage resources, lead armies, and conquer territories.\n- Result 31 (2022-03-27): James is getting into RPGs and strategy games.\n- Result 35 (",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.04,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.22
    },
    {
      "question": "Who does James support in football matches?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Liverpool",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of James's football team support in the excerpts.\n\n- Result 3 (2022-06-13): James says, \"there is no sport better than football, no club better than Liverpool! I don't miss a single match of theirs!\"\n- Result 6 (2022-06-13): John notes, \"It looks like you really root for this team!\" referring to Liverpool.\n- Result 7 (2022-06-13): James confirms, \"Absolutely! They are forever in my heart, they are a great team. I hope they become champions next season!\"\n- Result 30 (2022-06-13): James criticizes Manchester City, showing he does not support them.\n- Result 27 and 48 (2022-06-13): James and John banter about Liverpool vs Manchester City standings, confirming James supports Liverpool.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.\n\nJames clearly supports Liverpool football club and is a passionate",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.87,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.35
    },
    {
      "question": "Which football club does John support?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Manchester City",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for mentions of John\u2019s football club preference in the context.\n\n- Result 4 [2022-06-13]: John says, \"As a Manchester City fan, I can't agree with you.\"\n- Result 28 [2022-06-13]: John defends Manchester City\u2019s manager.\n- Result 2 [2022-06-13]: James criticizes Manchester City\u2019s form and transfer policy, implying John supports them.\n- Result 13 [2022-06-13]: John asks about Liverpool vs Chelsea match, showing interest but no direct support.\n- Result 50 [2022-06-13]: James says \"I bet we'll be higher than you in the final standings!\" indicating rivalry between James\u2019s team and John\u2019s.\n\nStep 2: Confirm John\u2019s club.\n\nJohn explicitly states he is a Manchester City fan in Result 4.\n\nFinal answer: John supports Manchester City football club.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.51,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.58
    },
    {
      "question": "What disagreement do James and John have about their football teams?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "debating on which team will perform better in the championship",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of football teams and opinions about them.\n\n- Result 21: James says Liverpool is the best club and he doesn't miss a single match.\n- Result 22: James talks about staying active with \"them\" (likely his team).\n- Result 8: John says he is a Manchester City fan and predicts his team will win the championship.\n- Result 12: James says Manchester City are in bad form and their transfer policy is terrible.\n- Result 55: John defends the City manager, saying he can handle it.\n- Result 78: James bets Liverpool will finish higher than Manchester City.\n- Result 70: John accepts the bet and says it will be a great battle.\n\nStep 2: Summarize the disagreement.\n\nJames supports Liverpool and believes they are superior, criticizing Manchester City's current form and transfer policy. John supports Manchester City and is confident they will win the championship and that their manager can handle challenges.\n\nFinal answer:  \nJames supports",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.51,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.83
    },
    {
      "question": "What is Max good at doing according to James?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "catching frisbees in mid-air",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Max and what James says about him.\n- Result 2: James says Max is lovable and playful.\n- Result 4: James says Max cheers him up and enjoys cuddles.\n- Result 5: James says Max is a real go-getter and is awesome at catching frisbees in mid-air, never misses.\n- Result 9: James says Max and he love taking walks on a nearby trail.\n\nStep 2: Focus on what Max is specifically \"good at\" according to James.\n- Result 5 explicitly states Max is \"awesome at catching frisbees in mid-air - never misses!\"\n\nStep 3: Confirm no other specific talents or skills are mentioned.\n- Other mentions are about Max being playful, lovable, and enjoying walks, but the only specific skill is catching frisbees.\n\nFinal answer: According to James, Max is good at catching frisbees in mid-air and never misses.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.62,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.91
    },
    {
      "question": "What is the main focus of the organization that James volunteered with?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "providing necessary items to those who are less fortunate",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about James's volunteering.\n\n- Result 6: James says he volunteered with an organization that provides necessary items to those who are less fortunate.\n- Result 63: James mentions a volunteer experience where he saw how little gifts can do so much.\n- Result 1: John asks James about the organization he volunteered with.\n- Result 42: James says no interview is required, just a desire to help people, implying a friendly, helping organization.\n\nStep 2: Confirm the main focus.\n\nJames's organization provides necessary items to less fortunate people, focusing on helping those in need through gifts or donations.\n\nFinal answer:  \nThe main focus of the organization James volunteered with is providing necessary items and support to people who are less fortunate.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.21,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.91
    },
    {
      "question": "Will there be an interview required to volunteer with the organization James volunteered for?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "No",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant messages about volunteering and interview requirements.\n\n- Result 1 (2022-06-19): John asks James if an interview is required.\n- Result 4 (2022-06-19): James replies that no interview is necessary, only friendliness, politeness, and desire to help.\n\nStep 2: Confirm the organization James volunteered with.\n\n- Result 5 and 13 mention James volunteering with an organization providing necessary items to less fortunate people.\n- Result 4's answer about no interview is in direct response to John's question about volunteering with that organization.\n\nStep 3: Synthesize the information.\n\nJames clearly states that no interview is required to volunteer with the organization he volunteered for.\n\nFinal answer:  \nNo, there will not be an interview required to volunteer with the organization James volunteered for.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.18,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.54
    },
    {
      "question": "How did John relax in his free time on 9 July, 2022?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Reading",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the date in question: 9 July 2022.\n\nStep 2: Look for any messages around that date that mention John and his activities or relaxation.\n\nStep 3: The closest relevant messages are:\n- [Result 25] [2022-07-09T17:18:30] John to James: When are you coming back?\n- [Result 37] [2022-07-09T17:20:30] John to James: Take care, bye!\n- [Result 32] [2022-07-22T10:06:30] James to John: I have to go, I'm tired over the last two days. Bye!\n\nStep 4: None of these messages explicitly mention how John relaxed on 9 July 2022.\n\nStep 5: Check other messages for general mentions of John's relaxation habits:\n- [Result 38] [2022-04-23T11:08:00",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.76,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.18
    },
    {
      "question": "What did James enjoy doing on cold winter days?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Reading while snuggled under the covers",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about James's activities or preferences in winter.\n\nStep 2: Result 5 (2022-07-09) states James: \"I also love to read, especially while snuggled under the covers on a cold winter day.\"\n\nStep 3: This is a direct statement of what James enjoys doing on cold winter days.\n\nFinal answer: James enjoys reading while snuggled under the covers on cold winter days.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.66,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.26
    },
    {
      "question": "What new hobby did James become interested in on 9 July, 2022?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Extreme sports",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for any messages around or on 9 July 2022 mentioning James and a new hobby.\n\nStep 2: Result 15 [2022-07-22T09:51:30] James to John: \"Wow, looks intense! What sparked your interest in chess?\" This suggests chess was a topic around July but not necessarily a new hobby for James.\n\nStep 3: Result 12 [2022-07-09T17:15:30] John to James: \"Wow, how cool! What other extreme sport have you tried?\" This implies James tried an extreme sport by that date.\n\nStep 4: Result 70 [2022-06-16T17:16:30] John to James: \"He looks so happy - this is a great achievement of yours!\" and Result 30 [2022-06-16T17:16:00] James to John: \"He has a blast! Always a joy to",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.86,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.87
    },
    {
      "question": "Where did James plan to visit after Toronto?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Vancouver",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify when James mentioned his travel plans to Toronto.  \n- In [Result 3], James says he bought air tickets to Toronto and is leaving the day after tomorrow evening (dated 2022-07-09).\n\nStep 2: Look for any mention of where James planned to go after Toronto.  \n- In [Result 1], James says, \"I also plan to visit Vancouver. Maybe, I'll go somewhere else.\" This message is also from 2022-07-09, shortly after the Toronto ticket mention.\n\nStep 3: Confirm no other specific places after Toronto are mentioned.  \n- No other specific destinations after Toronto are mentioned besides Vancouver and a vague \"somewhere else.\"\n\nFinal answer: James planned to visit Vancouver after Toronto, with a possibility of going somewhere else.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.84,
      "judge_latency_s": 3.1
    },
    {
      "question": "When did James plan to return from his trip to Toronto and Vancouver?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "July 20",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: James mentioned buying air tickets to Toronto and leaving the day after tomorrow evening on 2022-07-09 (Result 2).\n\nStep 2: John asked when James was coming back (Result 4).\n\nStep 3: James replied he planned to return on July 20 (Result 6).\n\nStep 4: James also mentioned planning to visit Vancouver and maybe somewhere else (Result 1), but no separate return date was given for Vancouver.\n\nStep 5: Since the return date of July 20 is given after the mention of both Toronto and Vancouver trips, it is reasonable to conclude that July 20 is the planned return date from the entire trip including Toronto and Vancouver.\n\nFinal answer: James planned to return from his trip to Toronto and Vancouver on July 20, 2022.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.04,
      "judge_latency_s": 4.08
    },
    {
      "question": "What online game did John start playing recently for improving strategy?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Chess",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of John playing games to improve strategy.  \n- Result 24 (2022-07-22): John says he just started playing chess to get better at strategy.  \n- Result 59 (2022-07-22): John mentions playing mostly online but also joined a chess club and practices with others.  \n- Result 9 (2022-07-22): John says he's drawn to strategy games and believes chess improves decision-making skills.  \n\nStep 2: Confirm if any other online game is mentioned as recently started for strategy improvement.  \n- No other specific online game is mentioned by John as recently started for strategy improvement besides chess.  \n- Chess is both an online and offline game, and John mentions playing online and in a club.\n\nFinal answer:  \nJohn recently started playing chess, including online, to improve his strategy skills.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.29,
      "judge_latency_s": 3.05
    },
    {
      "question": "What made John leave his IT job?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "to focus on things that align with his values and passions",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about John leaving his IT job.  \n- Result 7 (2022-08-06): John says he left his IT job after 3 years around July 30, 2022.  \n- Result 55 (2022-08-06): John says it was scary at first but he needed to make a change and focus on things that align with his values and passions.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.  \nJohn left his IT job because he wanted a change and to pursue work that aligned better with his values and passions, seeking something that made a difference.\n\nFinal answer:  \nJohn left his IT job because he wanted to focus on work that aligned with his values and passions and make a meaningful difference.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.13,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.22
    },
    {
      "question": "Which game tournaments does John plan to organize besides CS:GO?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Fortnite competitions",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of John\u2019s plans for organizing tournaments besides CS:GO.\n\n- Result 3 (2022-08-06): John says he wants to become an organizer of tournaments for various computer games in their state, for example CS:GO, indicating CS:GO is one example.\n- Result 4 (2022-08-10): John mentions playing different genres like strategy and RPG games instead of shooters and is already thinking about making competitions for them too.\n- Result 13 (2022-08-06): John says he can also host Fortnite competitions and has made connections to help with this.\n- Result 50 (2022-04-04): John talks about RPGs and MOBAs as games to experience engaging stories or epic multiplayer fights, implying interest in those genres.\n- Result 25 (2022-08-10): James asks John about standout games in different genres, supporting the idea John is exploring other genres for competitions.\n\nStep 2",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.75,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.49
    },
    {
      "question": "What happened to James's puppy during the recent visit to the clinic?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "routine examination and vaccination",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant messages about the puppy's clinic visit.\n- Result 2 (2022-08-06): James says he took his puppy to the clinic yesterday (August 5, 2022).\n- Result 3 (2022-08-06): John asks what happened to the puppy and if it is okay.\n- Result 1 (2022-08-06): James replies it was just a routine examination and that the puppy was vaccinated to prevent seasonal canine disease.\n- Result 8 (2022-08-06): John expresses relief that the puppy is okay and praises James for caring about his pets.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.\n- The puppy was taken to the clinic for a routine check-up.\n- The puppy received a vaccination to prevent seasonal canine disease.\n- There was no indication of illness or injury; the puppy is fine.\n\nFinal answer:  \nJames's puppy was taken to the clinic for a routine examination and received",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.66,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.02
    },
    {
      "question": "What game genre did John start exploring instead of shooters?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "strategy and RPG games",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of John changing or expanding his game genre interests.  \n- Result 1 (2022-08-10): John says he has been playing different genres like strategy and RPG games instead of his usual shooters.  \n- Result 30 (2022-08-10): John thanks James for encouraging him to try new game genres.  \n- Result 5 (2022-04-12): John mentions playing a new RPG with a cool story.  \n- Result 39 (2022-08-10): John is playing \"The Witcher 3,\" an RPG.  \n\nStep 2: Confirm the genres John is exploring.  \n- Result 1 explicitly states John is playing strategy and RPG games instead of shooters.  \n- Result 5 and 39 confirm RPGs as part of his new interests.  \n- Result 1 also mentions strategy games.  \n\nFinal answer:  \nJohn started exploring strategy and RPG game genres instead of shooters.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 4.15,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.85
    },
    {
      "question": "Which RPG game is John playing and enjoying on 10 August, 2022?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "The Witcher 3",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the date and the relevant messages around 10 August 2022.\n\n- Result 2 [2022-08-10]: John to James mentions being hooked on a new RPG with amazing storytelling and characters.\n- Result 7 [2022-08-10]: John to James says he\u2019s been playing strategy and RPG games lately.\n- Result 14 [2022-08-10]: James asks John what RPG he is playing and about favorite characters.\n- Result 74 [2022-08-10]: John to James says he is playing \"The Witcher 3\" and is totally hooked on it.\n\nStep 2: Confirm that \"The Witcher 3\" is the RPG John is playing and enjoying on 10 August 2022.\n\n- Result 74 explicitly states John is playing \"The Witcher 3\" and is hooked.\n- Result 2 and 7 mention RPGs but do not specify the title.\n- Result ",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.41,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.76
    },
    {
      "question": "What aspect of \"The Witcher 3\" does John find immersive?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "shaping the world with choices",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of John talking about \"The Witcher 3\" and what he finds immersive.\n\n- Result 3 (2022-08-10): John says, \"I'm playing 'The Witcher 3'! There's this awesome monster hunter with a cool story, and I'm totally hooked, trying to make the right choices to shape the world. It's really immersive.\"\n- Result 8 (2022-04-12): John says, \"Even with minor bugs, the game still looks great. The graphics are awesome and the gameplay is super immersive.\"\n- Result 12 (2022-10-03): John says, \"Yeah, I played it - it's awesome! Such an immersive world and an amazing story.\"\n- Result 62 (2022-10-21): John says, \"The most difficult thing is to make the right choice. After all, even from the choice of lines in dialogues with characters, everything can go wrong. The choices here",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.95,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.77
    },
    {
      "question": "Whose phone number did James receive during the beach outing?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Samantha",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the beach outing date and context.  \n- Result 1: James took his dogs to a beach outing on August 9, 2022.  \n- Result 3: James mentions meeting a beautiful girl at the beach outing and that she left her phone number.  \n- Result 14: James reveals the girl's name is Samantha and that he will call her.  \n- Result 15: John asks for the girl's name, and James confirms it is Samantha.\n\nStep 2: Confirm the phone number belongs to Samantha.  \n- The conversation clearly states the girl James met at the beach outing is Samantha, and she left her phone number.\n\nFinal answer:  \nJames received Samantha's phone number during the beach outing.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.24,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.14
    },
    {
      "question": "What is James planning to do after receiving Samantha's phone number?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "call her",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify when James received Samantha's phone number.  \n- Result 6 [2022-08-10T09:22:30] James to John: \"Yes, we had fun and I even met one beautiful girl. I'm thinking of asking her out on a date! She left me her phone number, I think I'll call tomorrow.\"\n\nStep 2: Determine what James plans to do after receiving the number.  \n- He plans to call her the next day and ask her out on a date.\n\nFinal answer:  \nAfter receiving Samantha's phone number, James planned to call her the next day to ask her out on a date.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.72,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.89
    },
    {
      "question": "What is John organizing with his siblings?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "a gaming night",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of John organizing something with his siblings.  \n- Result 6 [2022-08-21]: John says, \"Yep, I'm organizing one with my siblings next month. We're stoked! Can't wait!\"  \n- Result 19 [2022-08-21]: John says, \"Me and my siblings don't hang out much since we live far apart, but when we do we always try to plan a gaming night.\"  \n- Result 5 [2022-08-26]: James says, \"It's great to hear that your siblings signed up for programming.\"  \n- Result 21 [2022-09-01]: John says, \"They're starting small, making basic games and stories.\"  \n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.  \nJohn is organizing an event with his siblings next month (from August 21, 2022, so the event is in September 2022). They plan gaming nights and are involved in programming,",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.31,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.44
    },
    {
      "question": "What type of beer does John not like?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "dark beer",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify where John mentions his beer preference.  \n- In [Result 1] (2022-08-26), John says: \"Great idea, except I don't like dark beer.\"\n\nStep 2: Confirm the type of beer John dislikes.  \n- John explicitly states he does not like dark beer.\n\nStep 3: Check if there is any contradictory information.  \n- No contradictory statements found; James suggests light beers as alternatives ([Result 2]).\n\nFinal answer: John does not like dark beer.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.41,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.88
    },
    {
      "question": "What were some difficulties James faced during the development of his game?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "balancing mechanics and ensuring fairness",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about James' game development difficulties.\n\n- Result 26: James hit a major snag\u2014a bug in the code messed up game mechanics, and he couldn't solve it despite hours of debugging.\n- Result 88: James said it was challenging to balance mechanics and ensure fairness, but he managed it with trial and error.\n- Result 60: James mentioned perseverance, patience, feedback, and collaboration were key to overcoming difficulties.\n- Result 65: John asked if James managed to solve the bug issue, implying it was a significant problem.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the difficulties.\n\nJames faced technical challenges such as bugs that disrupted game mechanics and the difficulty of balancing the game to be fair and enjoyable. These required perseverance, patience, and collaboration to overcome.\n\nFinal answer:  \nJames faced difficulties with bugs that disrupted game mechanics and the challenge of balancing the game to ensure fairness, which required perseverance, patience, and collaboration to resolve.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.9,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.94
    },
    {
      "question": "What has John been teaching his siblings?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "coding",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about John teaching his siblings.  \n- Result 4 (2022-09-01): John says he has been teaching his siblings coding, and they are already creating their own programs.  \n- Result 30 (2022-08-26): John mentions helping his younger siblings with programming since they joined a programming course.  \n- Result 24 (2022-09-04): John says his parents just started learning coding from him, indicating he is teaching coding skills within his family.  \n- Result 62 (2022-09-01): James asks what kind of programs John's siblings are making, confirming the teaching is about programming/coding.  \n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.  \nJohn has been teaching his siblings coding/programming, helping them learn and create their own programs.  \n\nFinal answer:  \nJohn has been teaching his siblings coding and programming.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.39,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.99
    },
    {
      "question": "What kind of programs are John's siblings making?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "basic games and stories",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of John's siblings and their programming activities.\n\n- Result 6 (2022-09-01): John says he's been teaching his siblings coding and they are already creating their own programs.\n- Result 5 (2022-09-01): John says they are starting small, making basic games and stories.\n- Result 42 (2022-08-26): John says they are playing a simple, text-based adventure game to work on coding skills.\n- Result 49 (2022-08-26): John says they are working on a cool project together that involves coding, a game helping them learn.\n- Result 2 and 3 (2022-08-26): James asks about siblings, John confirms they signed up for programming.\n- Result 4 (2022-09-01): James comments on how fast they learn and will soon create complex projects.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.\n\nJohn's siblings are learning programming and",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.9,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.85
    },
    {
      "question": "Which company's headphones did John choose for gaming?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Sennheiser",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant excerpts about John's headphones purchase.  \n- Result 1: John mentions buying new gaming equipment including headphones.  \n- Result 2: John specifies he chose headphones from Sennheiser.\n\nStep 2: Confirm no conflicting information about the headphone brand.  \n- No other excerpts mention a different headphone brand.\n\nFinal answer: John chose headphones from Sennheiser for gaming.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.15,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.9
    },
    {
      "question": "What did James and Samantha discover they both enjoy at McGee's bar?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Lager beer",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of James and Samantha at McGee's bar.\n- Result 1 (2022-09-04): James says Samantha loves a good lager beer and that they have much in common.\n- Result 3 and 4 (2022-08-26): They discuss going to McGee's pub, mentioning different types of beer.\n- Result 43 (2022-08-26): James mentions there are light beers at McGee's.\n- Result 49 (2022-08-26): John says he doesn't like dark beer, implying other options exist.\n- Result 9 and 31 (2022-10-31): James and Samantha decided to move in together near McGee's bar, showing their fondness for the place.\n\nStep 2: What do James and Samantha both enjoy at McGee's bar?\n- Result 1 explicitly states Samantha loves a good lager beer.\n- James says they have much in common, implying he",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.68,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.07
    },
    {
      "question": "How much does James pay per cooking class?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "$10",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about James's cooking class and cost.\n- Result 3 (2022-09-04T21:29:00): James mentions signing up for a cooking class two days ago.\n- Result 1 (2022-09-04T21:30:00): James says \"At only $10 per class, it's very cheap!\"\n\nStep 2: Confirm the cost mentioned is per class.\n- Result 1 explicitly states \"$10 per class.\"\n\nFinal answer: James pays $10 per cooking class.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.56,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.81
    },
    {
      "question": "What did James learn to make in the cooking class besides omelette and meringue?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Dough",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify what James learned in the cooking class from the excerpts.\n- From Result 1, James mentions he prepared several simple dishes including a great omelette.\n- From Result 2, James says he made meringue and they taught how to make dough.\n\nStep 2: Determine what else James learned besides omelette and meringue.\n- Result 2 explicitly states \"they taught us how to make the dough.\"\n\nFinal answer: Besides omelette and meringue, James learned how to make dough in the cooking class.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.35,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.79
    },
    {
      "question": "Why did James sign up for a cooking class?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "He wanted to learn something new",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant excerpt about James signing up for a cooking class.  \n- Result 1 [2022-09-04T21:29:00] James to John: \"Yes, two days ago I signed up for a cooking class. I never liked cooking, but I felt that I wanted to learn something new.\"\n\nStep 2: Extract the reason James gave for signing up.  \n- James explicitly states he never liked cooking but wanted to learn something new.\n\nFinal answer:  \nJames signed up for a cooking class because, although he never liked cooking, he wanted to learn something new.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.3,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.82
    },
    {
      "question": "What did James prepare for the first time in the cooking class?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Omelette",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant excerpts about James's cooking class experience.  \n- Result 1: James says two days ago he signed up for a cooking class and at the first lesson they prepared several simple dishes. He specifically mentions he got a great omelette the first time.  \n- Result 3: James also mentions making meringue and learning to make dough, but this seems to be beyond the first lesson.\n\nStep 2: Focus on what James prepared for the first time in the cooking class.  \n- The key detail is in Result 1: \"I got a great omelette the first time!\"\n\nFinal answer:  \nJames prepared a great omelette for the first time in the cooking class.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.19,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.86
    },
    {
      "question": "What is the name of the board game John tried in September 2022?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Dungeons of the Dragon",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant time frame and message about John trying a board game in September 2022.\n\n- Result 11 [2022-09-18]: John to James says he tried a board game last week (around September 11, 2022) and found it fun.\n- Result 1 [2022-09-18]: James asks John what kind of board game it is.\n- Result 75 [2022-09-18]: James describes a medieval castle with a labyrinth full of puzzles and traps, comparing it to a video game in real life.\n- No direct message states the name of the board game explicitly.\n\nStep 2: Look for any mention of a specific board game name around that time.\n\n- No direct name of the board game is mentioned in the excerpts.\n- The description of the game involving a medieval castle with labyrinth, puzzles, and traps (Result 75) might hint at the type or theme but not the name.\n\nStep",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 6.94,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.11
    },
    {
      "question": "Where does James get his ideas from?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "books, movies, dreams",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about James's sources of ideas.  \n- Result 37 [2022-09-18T18:03:30] James to John: \"Thanks, John! I get them from various sources like books, movies, and even dreams.\"\n\nStep 2: Confirm no other contradicting or additional information is present.  \n- No other excerpts specify James's sources of ideas.\n\nFinal answer: James gets his ideas from various sources including books, movies, and even dreams.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.82,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.76
    },
    {
      "question": "What kind of dream did James have recently?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "a dream with a medieval castle full of puzzles and traps",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of James having a dream.  \n- Result 2: James says, \"A few weeks ago I had this crazy dream that led to some creative ideas. It was so vivid I woke up with some interesting thoughts!\"  \n- Result 1 and 3: John asks about the dream and its details, but James does not provide specifics in the excerpts.  \n- Result 4: John mentions a \"castle dream\" in relation to a sketch, possibly connected to James's dream.  \n\nStep 2: Look for any details about the dream's content.  \n- No direct description of the dream's content is given by James.  \n- John references a \"castle dream\" in Result 4, which might be related to James's dream.  \n\nStep 3: Synthesize the information.  \n- James had a recent vivid and creative dream a few weeks before 2022-09-18.  \n- The dream inspired creative ideas.  \n- John",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.86,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.19
    },
    {
      "question": "What kind of music does John like?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "electronic and rock music",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about John's music preferences.\n\n- Result 18 [2022-09-18T18:08:00] John to James: \"Cool! I'm into electronic and rock music. I used to play drums when I was younger, but haven't in a while.\"\n\n- Result 7 [2022-09-18T18:07:00] John to James: \"Nice sketch! Do you like music, or is it related to your castle dream?\" (less relevant)\n\n- Result 9 [2022-09-18T18:09:00] John to James: \"Playing drums when I was younger was a fun way to let off steam.\"\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.\n\nJohn explicitly states he likes electronic and rock music and used to play drums.\n\nFinal answer: John likes electronic and rock music.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.84,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.0
    },
    {
      "question": "What instrument did James used to play when he was younger?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "guitar",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of James playing an instrument.  \n- Result 3: James to John says, \"I used to play a guitar when I was younger but haven't in a while.\"  \n- Result 13: James mentions learning an instrument recently but does not specify what it is.  \n- No other results mention James playing a different instrument.\n\nStep 2: Confirm no contradictions or other instruments mentioned.  \n- No other instruments are attributed to James in the context.  \n- The only instrument James explicitly says he used to play is guitar.\n\nFinal answer: James used to play the guitar when he was younger.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.37,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.96
    },
    {
      "question": "What did John use to play when he was younger to let off steam?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "drums",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for mentions of John's gaming habits or activities when he was younger.\n\nStep 2: Result 95 [2022-08-21T16:03:00] John to James says: \"Gaming marathons are the best. When I was younger, my siblings threw me one and it was awesome! We stayed up all night playing games and it really bonded us.\"\n\nStep 3: This indicates that John used to play games in marathons with his siblings to let off steam.\n\nStep 4: No other specific mentions of what exact games or devices John used when younger, but the emphasis is on gaming marathons with siblings.\n\nFinal answer:  \nJohn used to play gaming marathons with his siblings when he was younger to let off steam.",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.57,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.82
    },
    {
      "question": "What career milestone did John achieve recently in September 2022?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "making his first mobile game",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the timeframe and milestone mentioned for John in September 2022.  \n- Result 17 (2022-09-20): John says, \"I just achieved a major career milestone - making my first mobile game! It's launching next month.\"  \n- Result 3 (2022-09-20): James congratulates John on a major career milestone and asks about creating a mobile game.  \n- Result 6 (2022-09-20): James references a big moment recently (around September 13, 2022).  \n- Result 28 (2022-09-20): James asks John what new has happened in his life.  \n- Result 60 (2022-09-20): James praises John's dedication and learning.\n\nStep 2: Confirm the milestone is related to a mobile game.  \n- Result 17 explicitly states the milestone is making his first mobile game, launching next month (October 2022).  \n- Result ",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.32,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.57
    },
    {
      "question": "What type of game is John's upcoming mobile game?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "2D adventure",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of John's upcoming mobile game.  \n- Result 1 (2022-09-20): John says he made his first mobile game launching next month.  \n- Result 61 (2022-09-20): John describes it as a \"2D adventure game with puzzles and exploration\" and shares a screenshot.  \n- Result 98 (2022-09-20): James expresses interest in 2D adventure games with puzzles like The Legend of Zelda and asks to see or help test John's game.  \n\nStep 2: Confirm no conflicting descriptions.  \n- No other descriptions contradict the 2D adventure with puzzles and exploration genre.  \n\nFinal answer:  \nJohn's upcoming mobile game is a 2D adventure game featuring puzzles and exploration.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.27,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.26
    },
    {
      "question": "What does John do to stay informed and constantly learn about game design?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "watch tutorials and keep up with developer forums",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts where John talks about how he stays informed and learns about game design.\n\n- Result 2 [2022-09-20T21:02:00] John to James: \"It is filled with awesome tips and insights on game design. I also watch tutorials and keep up with developer forums for information and ideas. Basically, staying informed and constantly learning is key!\"\n\n- Result 48 [2022-09-20T21:03:00] John to James: \"I read it, too. This magazine has been great for me too. Tutorials, interviews with developers, and tips - all really helpful.\"\n\n- Result 32 [2022-10-21T19:40:30] John to James: \"I gained insight into various programming approaches and techniques. It was interesting to hear other developers' ideas and strategies.\"\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.\n\nJohn stays informed and constantly learns about game design by watching tutorials, reading",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.43,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.9
    },
    {
      "question": "What kind of gig was John offered at the game dev non-profit organization?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "programming mentor for game developers",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about John's gig at the game dev non-profit.\n\n- Result 3 (2022-10-03): John mentions he got an email about a volunteer gig at a game dev non-profit combining gaming and helping.\n- Result 13 (2022-10-03): John specifies they asked him to be a programming mentor for game developers, teaching coding and assisting with projects.\n- Result 1 and 68: James asks about the gig and expresses excitement about mentoring.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.\n\nJohn was offered a volunteer position as a programming mentor at a game development non-profit, where he would teach coding and assist developers with their projects.\n\nFinal answer:  \nJohn was offered a volunteer gig as a programming mentor at a game development non-profit, where he would teach coding and assist game developers with their projects.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.65,
      "judge_latency_s": 3.78
    },
    {
      "question": "What does John feel about starting the journey as a programming mentor for game developers?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "excited and inspired",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about John starting as a programming mentor.  \n- Result 2 (2022-10-03): John says, \"They asked me to be a programming mentor for game developers. I'll be teaching coding and assisting with projects. I'm really excited to share my knowledge and motivate people who are passionate about gaming.\"  \n- Result 74 (2022-10-03): John says, \"I'm so excited and inspired! It's a great chance to help them and boost my own skills. I love sharing what I know and seeing others reach their potential - it's so rewarding!\"  \n- Result 1 (2022-10-03): James asks John how he feels about starting this journey, implying the conversation is about the start of this mentoring role.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize John's feelings.  \nJohn expresses excitement, inspiration, and a sense of reward in sharing knowledge and helping others grow. He also sees it as an opportunity to boost his own skills.\n\n",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.21,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.89
    },
    {
      "question": "What kind of games is James excited to play with his new video card?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "RPGs",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of James getting a new video card.  \n- Result 42 (2022-10-03): James says he got a cool video card last week (around September 26, 2022) and is excited to jump into it again.  \n- Result 83 (2022-10-03): James says he is super into RPGs and excited about getting the video card to play new games. He specifically asks about Cyberpunk 2077, indicating interest in that RPG.  \n\nStep 2: Look for what game genres James is excited about playing with the new video card.  \n- Result 83 explicitly states James is super into RPGs and excited to play new games with the video card.  \n- Result 13 (2022-10-21) mentions James tried Cyberpunk 2077 recently and found it addictive, which aligns with his RPG interest.  \n\nStep 3: Confirm no other genres are mentioned in relation to the new",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.82,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.54
    },
    {
      "question": "What inspired James to create his game?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Witcher 3",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about James's inspiration for creating his game.\n\n- Result 2 (2022-10-13): James says Witcher 3 gave him a ton of inspiration with its amazing world and story.\n- Result 20 (2022-09-01): James says he has always loved playing strategy games like Civilization and Total War, so he decided to challenge himself and create one of his own.\n- Result 38 (2022-03-17): James mentions he has wanted to do this since he was a kid, making sketches of the main character and drawing comics, now turning it into a computer game.\n- Result 24 (2022-10-21): James recalls playing Super Mario and The Legend of Zelda as a kid, which sparked his passion for gaming.\n- Result 42 (2022-08-26): James says he has been trying out different genres and is dying to create a strategy game like Civilization because he loves how complicated",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.27,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.87
    },
    {
      "question": "What sparked James' passion for gaming when he was a kid?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Super Mario and The Legend of Zelda games",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about James' early gaming experiences and what sparked his passion.\n\n- Result 4 [2022-10-21]: James to John says he had a blast with his first gaming system as a kid, playing Super Mario and The Legend of Zelda for hours, which totally sparked his passion for gaming.\n- Result 45 [2022-10-21]: James mentions those games introduced him to gaming and he's been hooked ever since.\n- Result 35 and 36 [2022-10-21]: John asks James if he had fun with Nintendo when he was a kid and wants to see a picture of his old gaming setup, implying James' early gaming was on Nintendo.\n- Result 44 [2022-03-17]: James talks about working on a game inspired by childhood sketches, showing early interest in gaming and storytelling.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.\n\nJames' passion for gaming was sparked by playing on his first gaming system as",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 5.43,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.57
    },
    {
      "question": "What did James lose progress on due to a power outage?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "a game",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of power outage and lost progress.\n- Result 2: James says his apartment lost power three days ago, which was annoying because he had just gotten to the big reveal in a game.\n- Result 6: James confirms the power outage definitely messed up his progress and that he lost some progress because he forgot to save.\n\nStep 2: Determine what the progress was related to.\n- Both excerpts (Results 2 and 6) mention the progress lost was in a game.\n\nStep 3: Confirm no other context contradicts or adds detail.\n- No other results mention losing progress due to power outage except these.\n\nFinal answer: James lost progress in a game due to a power outage at his apartment.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.28,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.76
    },
    {
      "question": "What games were played at the gaming tournament organized by John on 31 October, 2022?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Fortnite, Overwatch, Apex Legends",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the date and event in question: John organized a gaming tournament on 31 October 2022.\n\nStep 2: Look for messages around that date mentioning the tournament and games played.\n\n- Result 1 (2022-10-31): James to John asks about the tournament for a children's hospital.\n- Result 33 (2022-10-31): John to James says he held a gaming tourney with buddies last night, played Fortnite and a few other games, raised money for a children's hospital.\n- Result 50 (2022-10-31): John to James adds they also played Overwatch and Apex Legends at the tournament.\n- Result 21 (2022-10-31): John to James shares a photo from the tournament, mentions the hype and good cause.\n- Result 16 (2022-10-31): James to John asks if there are photos from the tournament.\n- Result 29 (2022-05-08",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.61,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.2
    },
    {
      "question": "What was the purpose of the gaming tournament organized by John on 31 October, 2022?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "To raise money for a children's hospital",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the date and event in question: The gaming tournament organized by John on 31 October 2022.\n\nStep 2: Look for relevant excerpts mentioning a tournament around that date.\n\n- Result 2 (2022-10-31): James to John congratulates John on organizing a gaming tournament for a children's hospital and asks for more details.\n- Result 12 (2022-10-31): John to James mentions a great shot at the tournament, the hype, and playing for a good cause.\n- Result 39 (2022-10-31): John to James says they played Fortnite, Overwatch, and Apex Legends, had a blast raising money for the kids' hospital, and the atmosphere was awesome.\n- Result 47 (2022-10-31): John to James says he held a gaming tourney with buddies last night, played Fortnite and other games, and raised a decent amount for a children's hospital.\n- Result 79 (202",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.63,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.77
    },
    {
      "question": "What decision did James and Samantha make on 31 October, 2022?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "To move in together",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the date and relevant messages around 31 October 2022.\n\n- Result 4 [2022-10-31T00:40:30] James to John: \"I actually have something new, Samantha and I have decided to move in together!\"\n- Result 2 [2022-10-31T00:41:00] John to James: \"Wow, that's a really big decision! I hope you both have weighed the pros and cons. Where are you going to live?\"\n- Result 66 [2022-10-31T00:41:30] James to John: \"Of course, this was a mutual and informed decision. We rented an apartment not far from McGee's bar.\"\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.\n\nOn 31 October 2022, James told John that he and Samantha decided to move in together and that they rented an apartment near McGee's bar.\n\nFinal answer:  \nOn 31",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.32,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.06
    },
    {
      "question": "Where did James and Samantha decide to live together on 31 October, 2022?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "In an apartment not far from McGee's bar",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the date and event - On 31 October 2022, James told John that he and Samantha decided to move in together (Result 1).\n\nStep 2: Look for details about where they decided to live - In the same timeframe, John asked where they were going to live (Result 4).\n\nStep 3: James responded that it was a mutual and informed decision and that they rented an apartment not far from McGee's bar (Result 37).\n\nStep 4: Earlier messages mention that James and Samantha like McGee's bar (Result 8), supporting the location choice.\n\nFinal answer: James and Samantha decided to live together in an apartment rented not far from McGee's bar.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.39,
      "judge_latency_s": 4.39
    },
    {
      "question": "Why did James and Samantha choose an apartment near McGee's bar?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "They love spending time together at the bar",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about James and Samantha's apartment choice near McGee's bar.\n\n- Result 8 (2022-10-31): James announces moving in together with Samantha.\n- Result 1 (2022-10-31): James says the decision was mutual and informed; they rented an apartment not far from McGee's bar.\n- Result 4 (2022-10-31): James states they love McGee's bar and that one of the criteria for choosing their apartment was having this particular bar nearby.\n- Result 13 (2022-10-31): John comments on James loving spending time at the bar.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.\n\nJames and Samantha chose their apartment near McGee's bar because they love the bar, and having it nearby was a key factor in their apartment choice.\n\nFinal answer:  \nJames and Samantha chose an apartment near McGee's bar because they love the bar, and its proximity was an important criterion",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.41,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.8
    },
    {
      "question": "What game is John hooked on playing on 5 November, 2022?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "FIFA 23",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the date in question: 5 November 2022.\n\nStep 2: Look for messages from or to John around that date mentioning what game he is hooked on.\n\nStep 3: Result 12 [2022-11-05T17:26:30] John to James says: \"I'm hooked on this great game called FIFA 23. This is a great football game with the ability to play online with other players from all over the world! Enjoy!\"\n\nStep 4: This message directly states the game John is hooked on as of 5 November 2022.\n\nFinal answer: John is hooked on playing FIFA 23 on 5 November 2022.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.48,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.06
    },
    {
      "question": "What did John suggest James practice before playing FIFA 23 together?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Control with a gamepad and timing",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of FIFA 23 or playing together in the context.  \nStep 2: Look for any advice or suggestions John gave to James about preparation or practice before playing.  \nStep 3: Result 1 (2022-11-05T17:27:30) shows John telling James: \"You need to practice a little first, and then we can play together.\"  \nStep 4: Result 64 (2022-11-05T17:28:30) John adds: \"Not at all, all you need is a gamepad and a sense of timing.\"  \nStep 5: Combining these, John suggested James practice a little first, focusing on timing and using a gamepad before playing together.\n\nFinal answer:  \nJohn suggested that James practice a little first, emphasizing having a gamepad and a sense of timing before they play FIFA 23 together.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.17,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.71
    },
    {
      "question": "What project did John work on with a game developer by 7 November, 2022?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "An online board game",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the date and relevant messages around 7 November 2022.\n\n- Result 3 [2022-11-07T20:58:00] James to John asks about John's project.\n- Result 4 [2022-11-07T20:58:30] John to James replies: \"I collaborated with a game developer to create an online board game - it's a fun and unique experience!\"\n- Result 49 [2022-11-07T20:57:30] John to James: \"I had a super fun weekend - I worked with a game developer on a project and it was great to see my ideas come to life. It was an incredible experience!\"\n\nStep 2: Confirm the project details.\n\nJohn worked with a game developer to create an online board game.\n\nFinal answer:  \nBy 7 November 2022, John worked with a game developer to create an online board game.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 4.4,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.28
    },
    {
      "question": "What is the name of John's cousin's dog?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Luna",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of John's cousin's dog.  \n- Result 2 (2022-11-07): John says, \"By the way, here is my cousin's dog.\"  \n- Result 1 (2022-11-07): James asks, \"This pup is so adorable! What's their name?\"  \n- Result 52 (2022-11-07): John replies, \"Their name is Luna.\"  \n- Result 44 and 52 confirm the dog's name is Luna.\n\nStep 2: Confirm no other dog names are linked to John's cousin.  \n- Other dog names mentioned are Daisy, Max, Ned, but these belong to James or his family.  \n- Luna is specifically named by John in response to the question about the cousin's dog.\n\nFinal answer:  \nJohn's cousin's dog's name is Luna.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-47",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.41,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.94
    },
    {
      "question": "What kind of project was Jolene working on in the beginning of January 2023?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "electricity engineering project",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Jolene's project around January 2023.\n\n- Result 29 [2023-02-04]: Jolene mentions a major milestone last week (approx. January 28, 2023) that went really well, calling it a huge accomplishment as an engineer.\n- Result 67 [2023-01-23]: Jolene asks Deborah what inspired her to go down a certain route, indicating some engineering or technical interest.\n- Result 12 [2023-06-06]: Jolene refers to a tough engineering project she wrapped up in May 2023.\n- Result 28 [2023-03-28]: Jolene talks about a breakthrough with her engineering project on a Friday.\n- Result 39 [2023-06-06]: Jolene says the project had a positive impact and stoked her love of engineering.\n- Result 59 [2023-06-06]: Jolene says the best part was applying what",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.24,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.49
    },
    {
      "question": "Which of Deborah`s family and friends have passed away?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "mother, father, her friend Karlie",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Deborah's family or friends who have passed away.\n\n- Result 1: Deborah says \"she passed away a few years ago\" referring to her mom.\n- Result 10: Deborah says \"my dad passed away two days ago\" (dated 2023-01-27), so her dad died in late January 2023.\n- Result 29: Mentions Anna has a pendant in memory of her mother, but Anna is likely a family member, not Deborah herself.\n- Result 78: Deborah mentions losing a friend last week (around February 15, 2023).\n- Result 2: Jolene's mother passed away last year (2022), but this is Jolene's family, not Deborah's.\n\nStep 2: Summarize the findings.\n\nDeborah's mother passed away a few years ago (before 2023), her father passed away in January 2023, and she lost a friend around mid-February",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.73,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.54
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Deborah`s mother pass away?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "a few years before 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Deborah mentions her mother passed away \"a few years ago\" in Result 2 (2023-01-23).\n\nStep 2: Jolene says her own mother passed away \"last year\" around January 23, 2022 (Result 3), which is distinct from Deborah's mother.\n\nStep 3: Deborah's father passed away two days before January 27, 2023 (Result 59), so Deborah's mother had already passed before then.\n\nStep 4: Since Deborah's mother passed \"a few years ago\" as of early 2023, this suggests at least 2-3 years before 2023, so approximately 2020 or earlier.\n\nNo exact date is given, but the phrase \"a few years ago\" in early 2023 implies Deborah's mother passed around 2020 or earlier.\n\nFinal answer: Deborah's mother passed away approximately around 2020 or earlier, a few years before early 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.3,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.45
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Jolene`s mother pass away?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "in 2022",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify any direct mentions of Jolene's mother's passing.\n\n- Result 6 [2023-01-23]: Jolene says her mother passed away last year (approximately January 23, 2022).\n\nStep 2: Confirm the timeline.\n\n- The message is dated January 23, 2023.\n- \"Last year\" from that date would be 2022.\n\nNo other messages contradict or specify a different date.\n\nFinal answer: Jolene's mother passed away in 2022.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.59,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.35
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Jolene's mom gift her a pendant?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "in 2010",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Jolene's pendant and when it was gifted.\n\n- Result 2 (2023-01-23): Jolene says the pendant reminds her of her mother, who gave it to her in 2010 in Paris.\n- Result 38 (2023-01-27): Jolene says she bought \"it\" a year ago (approximately January 27, 2022) in Paris. This likely refers to a different item, as the pendant was gifted by her mother in 2010.\n- Result 4 (2023-01-23): Deborah confirms she also has a pendant reminding her of her mother, asking Jolene what is special about her jewelry.\n\nStep 2: Clarify the timeline.\n\n- Jolene's mother gave her the pendant in 2010 in Paris (Result 2).\n- Jolene bought something else a year ago in Paris (Result 38), but this is not the pendant from her mother.\n\nFinal",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.36,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.51
    },
    {
      "question": "In what country did Jolene's mother buy her the pendant?",
      "category": 3,
      "gold_answer": "In France",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Jolene's pendant and its origin.  \n- Result 2: Jolene says the pendant reminds her of her mother, who gave it to her in 2010 in Paris.  \n- Result 16: Jolene confirms she bought it about a year ago (January 27, 2022) in Paris.\n\nStep 2: Paris is a city in France, so the pendant was bought in France.\n\nFinal answer: Jolene's mother bought her the pendant in France.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.0,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.28
    },
    {
      "question": "What symbolic gifts do Deborah and Jolene have from their mothers?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "pendants",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify Deborah's symbolic gift from her mother:\n- Result 6 (2023-02-04): Deborah mentions Anna has a pendant worn in memory of her mother.\n- Result 53 (2023-01-23): Deborah confirms she also has a pendant that reminds her of her mother.\n- Result 75 (2023-02-04): Deborah talks about an amulet from her mother that she brings when she visits a special place, which brings her comfort and a feeling of closeness.\n\nStep 2: Identify Jolene's symbolic gift from her mother:\n- Result 17 (2023-01-23): Jolene says she has a pendant from her mother, given in 2010 in Paris.\n- Result 53 (2023-01-23): Jolene asks Deborah about her pendant and shares about her own jewelry's special meaning.\n\nStep 3: Summarize:\n- Deborah has a pendant and an amulet from her mother",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.38,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.17
    },
    {
      "question": "Which country were Jolene and her mother visiting in 2010?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "France",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify any mentions of travel or trips involving Jolene and her mother.  \nStep 2: Look for any specific country or place names linked to Jolene and her mother, especially around 2010.  \nStep 3: Check if there is any direct mention of a trip in 2010 or a country visited by Jolene and her mother.\n\nReviewing the context:  \n- There are mentions of Jolene adopting a pet two years ago (2021), but no direct mention of a 2010 trip.  \n- Deborah mentions her mom's passions including travel and cooking but no specific country.  \n- Jolene talks about a country she visited recently with yoga and cafes (Result 57), but this is not linked to 2010 or her mother.  \n- Jolene mentions buying something in Paris in 2022 (Result 95), unrelated to 2010 or her mother.  \n- No explicit mention of a country visited by Jolene and her",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.85,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.03
    },
    {
      "question": "What helped Deborah find peace when grieving deaths of her loved ones?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "yoga, old photos, the roses and dahlias in a flower garden, nature",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Deborah's coping methods for grief.\n\n- Result 29 (2023-01-23): Deborah says yoga helped her find peace during a rough time and she is passionate about sharing it with others.\n- Result 14 (2023-04-09): Deborah finds solace in artwork, which brings back powerful emotions and reminds her of those she lost.\n- Result 42 (2023-02-22): Deborah spent time in her garden with roses and dahlias to find comfort after losing a friend.\n- Result 50 (2023-07-09): Deborah says nature helps her find peace every day.\n- Result 39 (2023-08-21): Deborah mentions taking it slow, seeing beauty, and finding joy.\n- Result 11 (2023-08-30): Deborah describes soothing vibes and nice views as ideal for reflecting and letting go.\n- Result 32 (2023-01-27): Deborah finds peace sitting in",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.57,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.81
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Deborah's father pass away?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "January 25, 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant excerpt about Deborah's father's passing.  \n- Result 9 [2023-01-27T09:49:00] Deborah to Jolene: \"Hey Jolene, sorry to tell you this but my dad passed away two days ago.\"\n\nStep 2: Note the date of this message: January 27, 2023.  \nStep 3: Calculate the date of the father's passing: two days before January 27, 2023, is January 25, 2023.\n\nFinal answer: Deborah's father passed away on January 25, 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.93,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.66
    },
    {
      "question": "When was Deborah's parents' wedding?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "in 1993",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for any mention of Deborah's parents' wedding date in the context.  \nStep 2: In Result 1, Deborah says: \"This is my parents' wedding in 1993.\"  \nStep 3: No other messages contradict or specify a different date.\n\nFinal answer: Deborah's parents' wedding was in 1993.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.22,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.72
    },
    {
      "question": "Is Deborah married?",
      "category": 3,
      "gold_answer": "yes",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for any direct mentions of Deborah's marital status.\n\n- Result 28 (2023-01-27): Deborah says, \"My husband and I are trying to be as good a family as my parents were!\"\n- Result 8 (2023-02-25): Jolene says, \"We're not married yet but we've been together for three years,\" indicating this is about Jolene, not Deborah.\n- Result 14 (2023-02-25): Jolene asks Deborah, \"How long have you been married?\" which implies Deborah is married.\n- Result 27 (2023-02-25): Deborah responds to Jolene about her relationship, but no direct answer about marriage length is given here.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.\n\nDeborah refers to \"my husband\" in Result 28, confirming she is married. Jolene's question about how long Deborah has been married (Result 14) further supports this.\n\nFinal answer:",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.39,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.29
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Deborah receive an appreciation letter from her community?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "January 26, 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify any mention of Deborah receiving a letter of appreciation.  \n- Result 47 [2023-01-27T09:52:00] Deborah to Jolene: \"Look what letter I received yesterday (approximately January 26, 2023)!\"\n\nStep 2: Confirm the date of the message and the reference to \"yesterday.\"  \n- The message is dated January 27, 2023, so \"yesterday\" refers to January 26, 2023.\n\nStep 3: Check if the letter is described as an appreciation letter from her community.  \n- The context implies it is a letter that Deborah values and shares with Jolene, consistent with an appreciation letter.\n\nFinal answer:  \nDeborah received the appreciation letter from her community on January 26, 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.05,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.25
    },
    {
      "question": "What places give Deborah peace?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "sitting in a spot by the window in her Mom's house, sitting by the beach, Bali, forest trail in a nearby park",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of places Deborah finds peaceful.\n\n- Result 7 (2023-01-27): Deborah says her old home is a place she visits for her mom who passed away, and sitting by the window there gives her peace.\n- Result 17 (2023-01-27): Deborah says \"This is one of the places where I do it,\" referring to a peaceful spot.\n- Result 36 (2023-01-27): Deborah feels her mom's presence when she sits there, which comforts her.\n- Result 31 (2023-08-21): Deborah talks about a place full of memories where she brought flowers.\n- Result 34 (2023-08-30): Deborah mentions relaxing outside a place that brought back fond memories.\n- Result 61 (2023-02-25): Deborah shares a photo taken while reflecting outdoors, a reminder to find peace even in chaos.\n- Result 88 (2023-02-22",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.13,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.27
    },
    {
      "question": "What were Deborah's mother's hobbies?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "reading, traveling, art, cooking",
      "generated_answer": "Step-by-step reasoning:\n\n1. From [Result 8] (2023-01-27), Deborah says her mother loved to sit by the window every night with a book and a smile, indicating reading was one of her hobbies.\n\n2. From [Result 12] (2023-01-27), Deborah states that travel was also her mother's great passion.\n\n3. From [Result 5] (2023-08-21), Deborah mentions her mother really loved flowers and appreciated simple things in life.\n\n4. From [Result 41] (2023-04-09), Deborah says her mother was interested in art and believed art could evoke strong emotions and connect people.\n\n5. From [Result 6] and [Result 86] (2023-01-23 and 2023-01-27), the mother had a special bench by the window where she liked to sit and take in the view, which suggests enjoying peaceful moments and nature.\n\nSynthes",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.55,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.95
    },
    {
      "question": "What pets does Jolene have?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "snakes",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Jolene's pets in the excerpts.\n\n- Result 4 (2023-07-09): Jolene says she was fascinated by reptiles and has a reptile pet.\n- Result 5 (2023-06-26): Jolene got \"her\" last year (June 26, 2022), a pet that cheers her up and brings peace.\n- Result 12 (2023-07-09): Jolene mentions a \"snake adventure\" with her pet snake that escaped and was found under the bed.\n- Result 18 (2023-01-27): Jolene mentions playing video games while her pet snake Seraphim slinked out and coiled next to her.\n- Result 25 (2023-08-01): Jolene says Susie really helps when times get tough.\n- Result 29 (2023-08-26): Jolene says her snakes like watching her chill and bring calm.\n-",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.96,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.49
    },
    {
      "question": "What are the names of Jolene's snakes?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Susie, Seraphim",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Jolene's snakes and their names in the context.\n\n- Result 1 (2023-01-27): Jolene introduces one snake named Susie.\n- Result 4 (2023-01-27): Jolene mentions a second snake named Seraphim.\n- Result 11 (2023-08-26): Jolene asks about the second snake's name, implying she has at least two.\n- Result 33 (2023-09-15): Jolene refers to Susie as a great companion.\n- Result 82 (2023-09-15): Jolene confirms she has had Susie for two years.\n\nStep 2: Confirm no other snake names are mentioned.\n\nNo other snake names appear in the excerpts.\n\nFinal answer: Jolene's snakes are named Susie and Seraphim.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.92,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.95
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Jolene buy her pet Seraphim?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "in 2022",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Jolene's pet Seraphim in the context.  \n- Result 3 (2023-03-02): Jolene took Seraphim to the park last Sunday.  \n- Result 4 (2023-06-26): Jolene says she got Seraphim last year, approximately June 26, 2022.  \n- Result 8 (2023-01-27): Jolene mentions her second snake Seraphim.  \n- Result 11 (2023-06-26): Jolene shares new photos of Seraphim in a new aquarium.  \n- Result 15 (2023-07-09): Jolene talks about a \"snake adventure\" with Seraphim.  \n- Result 58 (2023-08-01): Jolene mentions Susie, another pet, but not Seraphim's purchase date.  \n- Result 70 (2023-09-15): Jolene says",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.83,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.46
    },
    {
      "question": "In what country did Jolene buy snake Seraphim?",
      "category": 3,
      "gold_answer": "In France",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant messages about where Jolene bought her snake Seraphim.  \n- Result 16 [2023-01-27]: Jolene says, \"I bought it a year ago (approximately January 27, 2022) in Paris.\"  \n- Result 1 [2023-01-27]: Jolene mentions her second snake Seraphim.  \n- Result 9 [2023-06-26]: Jolene shares photos of Seraphim in a new aquarium.  \n- Result 20 [2023-06-26]: Jolene says she got her last year (June 26, 2022), referring to Seraphim.\n\nStep 2: Paris is the capital city of France, so buying Seraphim in Paris means she bought the snake in France.\n\nFinal answer: Jolene bought her snake Seraphim in France.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.57,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.82
    },
    {
      "question": "How many times has Jolene been to France?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "two times",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for any mentions of Jolene traveling to France or Paris specifically.  \n- Result 2: Jolene says she bought something about a year ago in Paris (January 27, 2022). This confirms at least one trip to France.\n\nStep 2: Check if there are any other mentions of Jolene traveling to France or multiple trips.  \n- No other explicit mentions of Jolene visiting France or Paris are found in the excerpts.\n\nStep 3: Consider if any other travel mentions by Jolene imply France.  \n- Result 4 and others mention travel but do not specify France or Paris.\n\nFinal conclusion: Jolene has been to France once, as indicated by her purchase in Paris about a year ago from January 27, 2023.\n\n**Final answer:** Jolene has been to France once.",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.71,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.68
    },
    {
      "question": "Which games have Jolene and her partner played together?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Detroit, Walking Dead, Battlefield 1, It Takes Two, Overcooked 2",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of games Jolene and her partner played together.\n\n- Result 1 (2023-02-01): Planned to play console games with her partner.\n- Result 30 (2023-01-27): Played \"Detroit\" on the console around January 20, 2023.\n- Result 8 (2023-07-09): They love playing \"It Takes Two\" together.\n- Result 26 (2023-01-27): Planning to play \"Walking Dead\" next Saturday.\n- Result 22 (2023-07-09): Mentions gaming together and bonding.\n- Result 2 and 7 (2023-08-19): They prefer detective games together (implying a genre preference).\n\nStep 2: Summarize the specific game titles mentioned:\n- \"Detroit\"\n- \"It Takes Two\"\n- Planning to play \"Walking Dead\"\n\nStep 3: Note the genre preference for detective games, but",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.09,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.67
    },
    {
      "question": "When do Jolene and her partner plan to complete the game \"Walking Dead\"?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "Saturday after 27 January, 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of \"Walking Dead\" and related plans.\n- Result 1 (2023-01-27): Jolene says they are planning to play \"Walking Dead\" next Saturday.\n- Result 2 (2023-02-01): Jolene says they planned to play the console with her partner.\n- Result 13 (2023-09-12): Jolene looks forward to meeting Deborah and playing this game.\n- Result 22 (2023-09-17): Jolene suggests planning for next month and will check her schedule.\n- Result 99 (2023-09-08): Jolene mentions a camping trip with her partner.\n\nStep 2: Analyze timing.\n- The initial plan to play \"Walking Dead\" was around late January 2023 (next Saturday from 2023-01-27).\n- Later, in September 2023, Jolene is still talking about playing the game with Deborah and planning to meet and play",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.93,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.7
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Deborah meet Anna?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "31 January, 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify any direct mentions of Deborah meeting Anna.  \n- Result 23 (2023-02-01): Deborah says she met her new neighbor Anna \"yesterday,\" which is approximately January 31, 2023.\n\nStep 2: Confirm no other earlier meeting date is mentioned.  \n- No other earlier date for meeting Anna is found in the context.\n\nFinal answer: Deborah met Anna on January 31, 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.37,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.41
    },
    {
      "question": "Why did Jolene sometimes put off doing yoga?",
      "category": 3,
      "gold_answer": "She's more interested in playing video games",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for mentions of Jolene putting off yoga or reasons for delay.  \nStep 2: Check for any references to obstacles, hesitations, or reasons for not doing yoga immediately.  \nStep 3: Review relevant excerpts for clues about Jolene's attitude or circumstances around yoga.\n\n- Result 68 [2023-09-17]: Jolene says, \"How cool! But I never decided to try it.\" This suggests she considered yoga but had not committed to trying it at that time.  \n- Result 4 [2023-02-01]: Deborah asks Jolene if she ever thought about resuming yoga, implying Jolene had stopped or paused yoga before.  \n- Result 13 [2023-01-27]: Jolene asks Deborah where she most often does yoga, indicating interest but no clear commitment yet.  \n- Result 38 [2023-08-01]: Jolene says she is trying to prioritize self-care like yoga and meditation",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.56,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.76
    },
    {
      "question": "What new yoga poses did Deborah try?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Warrior II, Dancer Pose (Natarajasana), Tree pose",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Deborah trying new yoga poses.\n- Result 16 (2023-06-26): Deborah tried a new pose called Dancer Pose (Natarajasana).\n- Result 7 (2023-06-26): Deborah mentions trying a new yoga pose called the tree pose.\n- Result 15 (2023-02-04): Deborah mentions trying different dance poses, including Warrior II.\n\nStep 2: Confirm these are all Deborah's new poses.\n- Dancer Pose (Natarajasana) and tree pose are explicitly mentioned by Deborah as new.\n- Warrior II is mentioned as a dance pose tried by Deborah.\n\nFinal answer: Deborah tried the Dancer Pose (Natarajasana), the tree pose, and Warrior II as new yoga poses.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.84,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.55
    },
    {
      "question": "What are Jolene's favorite books?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Sapiens, Avalanche by Neal Stephenson",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for any direct mentions of Jolene's favorite books or types of books she likes.\n\n- Result 3: Deborah asks Jolene if she has had a favorite book lately.\n- Result 13: Jolene shares her bookshelf with Deborah.\n- Result 52: Jolene says a book \"takes me to another world when I read it!\"\n- Result 23 and 27: Jolene talks about a special book that speaks to her and helps with self-discovery, and she really likes it but never decided to try something (possibly a related activity).\n- Result 4 and 6: Deborah talks about a special book that helps with self-discovery and having a cozy nook to chill.\n- Result 2 and 26: Deborah asks Jolene to grab some interesting books; Jolene plans to sort out books from her bookcase.\n\nStep 2: Identify any specific titles or genres mentioned.\n\n- No specific book titles are mentioned in the excerpts.\n- The",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.61,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.99
    },
    {
      "question": "Which book did Jolene read in January 2023?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "Avalanche by Neal Stephenson",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify any mentions of books Jolene read around January 2023.\n\nStep 2: Result 78 (dated 2023-02-04) shows Jolene saying: \"Two weeks ago I read 'Avalanche' by Neal Stephenson in one sitting!\"\n\nStep 3: Since this message is from early February 2023, \"two weeks ago\" would place the reading in mid to late January 2023.\n\nStep 4: No other specific book titles read by Jolene in January 2023 are mentioned.\n\nFinal answer: Jolene read \"Avalanche\" by Neal Stephenson in January 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.14,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.39
    },
    {
      "question": "When was Jolene in Bogota?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "in summer 2022",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the message mentioning Bogota.  \n- Result 18 [2023-02-04]: Jolene to Deborah says, \"Here's a picture I took on vacation last summer in Bogota.\"\n\nStep 2: Determine the timeframe of \"last summer\" relative to the message date.  \n- The message is dated February 4, 2023.  \n- \"Last summer\" would refer to summer 2022 (approximately June to August 2022).\n\nFinal answer:  \nJolene was in Bogota during the summer of 2022.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.56,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.15
    },
    {
      "question": "In what country was Jolene during summer 2022?",
      "category": 3,
      "gold_answer": "Colombia",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify any mentions of Jolene's location or travel around summer 2022.\n\nStep 2: Result 9 (2023-01-27) states Jolene bought something in Paris about a year ago, approximately January 27, 2022, which is winter, not summer.\n\nStep 3: Result 52 (2023-06-26) says Jolene got a pet last year (approximately June 26, 2022), but no location is mentioned.\n\nStep 4: Result 40 (2023-08-01) says Jolene adopted \"her\" two years ago (approximately August 1, 2021), no location given.\n\nStep 5: No direct mention of Jolene's country in summer 2022 is found.\n\nStep 6: However, Result 9 places Jolene in Paris in January 2022, but no evidence she stayed there through summer.\n\nStep 7: No other explicit location for Jol",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.28,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.36
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Jolene have a mini-retreat to reflect on her career?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "Wednesday before 9 February, 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of a retreat or mini-retreat related to Jolene reflecting on her career.\n\n- Result 14 (2023-09-12): Jolene says, \"At the retreat, I had time to reflect on what makes me happy. It made me realize the importance of incorporating relaxation, self-care, and balance in life alongside my engineering studies.\"\n- Result 12 (2023-09-12): Deborah asks Jolene, \"Was there anything from the retreat that stood out to you?\"\n- Result 60 (2023-09-12): Jolene elaborates on a session at the retreat about releasing expectations and savoring the present.\n\nStep 2: The date of these messages is September 12, 2023, indicating the retreat happened shortly before or around this date.\n\nStep 3: No earlier or later specific dates for the retreat are mentioned, so the best inference is that Jolene's mini-retreat to reflect on her career occurred",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 9.65,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.22
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Jolene have a dinner and drinks with her friends?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "21 February, 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant excerpt mentioning Jolene's dinner and drinks with friends.  \n- Result 32 [2023-02-22T16:12:00] Jolene to Deborah: \"Hey Deborah, totally buzzing! Had a great night out last night - dinner, and drinks with my friends. So glad I got to let my hair down. You?\"\n\nStep 2: Determine the date of the message and the timing of the event.  \n- The message is dated 2023-02-22 and says \"Had a great night out last night,\" which means the dinner and drinks happened the night before, on 2023-02-21.\n\nFinal answer: Jolene had dinner and drinks with her friends on the evening of February 21, 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.23,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.58
    },
    {
      "question": "When was the last photo of Deborah and Karlie taken?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "in summer 2022",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of the last photo of Deborah and Karlie.\n- Result 1 (2023-02-22): Deborah says the last photo with Karlie was taken last summer when they hiked.\n- Result 3 (2023-01-23): Deborah says it was their last photo together and Karlie passed away a few years ago.\n\nStep 2: Determine the date of \"last summer\" relative to the message date.\n- The message in Result 1 is dated 2023-02-22.\n- \"Last summer\" from February 2023 would be summer 2022.\n\nStep 3: Confirm no conflicting information.\n- No other dates contradict this.\n\nFinal answer: The last photo of Deborah and Karlie was taken in the summer of 2022.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.49,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.12
    },
    {
      "question": "When was Deborah in Bali?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "in 2022",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify any mention of Deborah being in Bali.  \n- Result 1 [2023-02-22]: Deborah says, \"Bali last year (approximately February 22, 2022) was one of my favs.\"\n\nStep 2: Confirm the timing based on the date of the message.  \n- The message is dated February 22, 2023, and Deborah refers to Bali \"last year,\" which would be 2022.\n\nFinal answer: Deborah was in Bali around February 2022.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.98,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.41
    },
    {
      "question": "How long have Jolene and her partner been together?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "for three years",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for any direct mentions of the length of Jolene's relationship with her partner.\n\nStep 2: In Result 35 (2023-02-25), Jolene says: \"We're not married yet but we've been together for three years.\"\n\nStep 3: This is the clearest and most direct statement about the duration of their relationship.\n\nFinal answer: Jolene and her partner have been together for three years as of February 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.08,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.73
    },
    {
      "question": "Which year did Jolene and her partner start dating?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "2020",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about Jolene and her partner's relationship timeline.\n\n- Result 74 [2023-02-25]: Jolene says, \"We're not married yet but we've been together for three years.\"\n- The message is dated February 25, 2023.\n\nStep 2: Calculate the approximate start year.\n\n- If they had been together for three years as of early 2023, they likely started dating around 2020.\n\nFinal answer: Jolene and her partner started dating in 2020.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.57,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.35
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Deborah go for her first morning jog in a nearby park?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "24 February, 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify any mention of Deborah going for a morning jog in a nearby park.  \nStep 2: Result 8 states Deborah said on 2023-02-25 that \"yesterday (approximately February 24, 2023) I went for a morning jog for the first time in a nearby park.\"  \nStep 3: This clearly indicates the date of her first morning jog in a nearby park.\n\nFinal answer: Deborah went for her first morning jog in a nearby park on February 24, 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.29,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.15
    },
    {
      "question": "How old is Jolene?",
      "category": 3,
      "gold_answer": "likely no more than 30; since she's in school",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for any direct statements about Jolene's age.  \nNo direct mention of Jolene's age is found in the excerpts.\n\nStep 2: Look for indirect clues about Jolene's age or timeline references.  \n- Jolene adopted a pet two years ago around August 1, 2021 (Result 2).  \n- Jolene mentions learning to play on her own as a child (Result 8), indicating she is now an adult or at least older.  \n- Jolene has a partner (Result 51), suggesting she is likely an adult.  \n- Jolene's mother passed away last year (around January 23, 2022) (Result 80), which might imply Jolene is an adult dealing with family loss.  \n- Jolene is involved in projects and social activities (Results 53, 74), consistent with adult responsibilities.\n\nStep 3: No explicit age or birth year is given, and no direct age-related clues",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.53,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.29
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Jolene take Seraphim to the park?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "Sunday before 2 March, 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Jolene taking Seraphim to the park.  \n- Result 1 [2023-03-02]: Jolene to Deborah says, \"I did take Seraphim to the park last Sunday.\"\n\nStep 2: Determine the date of the message to find the exact \"last Sunday.\"  \n- The message is dated 2023-03-02 (Thursday).  \n- The Sunday before 2023-03-02 would be 2023-02-26.\n\nFinal answer: Jolene took Seraphim to the park on Sunday, February 26, 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.64,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.27
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Deborah start the yoga class in the neighborhood?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "Friday before 13 March, 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Deborah starting a yoga class in the neighborhood.  \n- Result 5 [2023-03-13]: Deborah says, \"I started this yoga class in the neighborhood - it's such a good feeling!\"  \n- Result 2 [2023-03-13]: Deborah mentions hosting a yoga class for neighbors on Friday (which would be March 10, 2023, if the message is on March 13).  \n- Result 3 [2023-02-01]: Deborah mentions \"It happened at yoga in the park,\" indicating yoga activities were happening earlier.  \n- Result 18 [2023-02-04]: Deborah talks about teaching yoga and bonding with Anna during a yoga class on February 3, 2023.  \n\nStep 2: Narrow down the timeframe.  \n- By early February 2023, Deborah was already teaching yoga classes (Result 18).  \n- By March 13, 2023, she",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.26,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.25
    },
    {
      "question": "What time management techniques do Deborah and Jolene use?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "the Pomodoro Technique - 25 minutes work and 5-minute break, scheduler or to-do list, The Eisenhower Matrix, bullet journal",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify Deborah's time management techniques:\n- Deborah creates a daily schedule or to-do list (Result 18).\n- She uses a method to figure out what is important and urgent to stay organized (Result 28).\n- She suggests breaking down tasks or prioritizing them (Result 23).\n\nStep 2: Identify Jolene's time management techniques:\n- Jolene started using a bullet journal around August 9, 2023, to track tasks and stay organized (Result 7).\n- She tries out various time management strategies (Result 7).\n- She finds breaking down tasks and prioritizing helpful, as discussed with Deborah (Results 23, 21).\n- Jolene appreciates creating a to-do list but finds it overwhelming sometimes (Results 19, 58).\n\nStep 3: Synthesize:\nBoth use task prioritization and breaking down tasks. Deborah emphasizes daily schedules and distinguishing urgent vs. important tasks, while Jolene uses a bullet journal and tries different strategies",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.54,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.32
    },
    {
      "question": "Does Deborah live close to the beach or the mountains?",
      "category": 3,
      "gold_answer": "beach",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Deborah mentions a favorite beach that is very special to her (Result 3), where she got married and discovered her love for surfing.\n\nStep 2: Deborah also talks about a park near her house that has a forest trail and a beach, which she visits for yoga and reflection (Result 48).\n\nStep 3: The presence of a beach near her house and her frequent visits to it for activities like yoga and surfing suggest she lives close to the beach.\n\nStep 4: There is no direct mention of mountains near her home or that she lives close to mountains.\n\nFinal answer: Deborah lives close to the beach.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.94,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.54
    },
    {
      "question": "What ways do Deborah and Jolene use to enhance their yoga practice?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "candles, music, essential oils",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of ways Deborah enhances her yoga practice:\n- Deborah hosts yoga classes and workshops to share and deepen practice (Results 7, 26, 53).\n- She uses scents like candles and essential oils (lavender, rosemary) to add warmth and calm (Results 42, 60).\n- She practices mindful breathing and meditation as part of yoga (Results 1, 63).\n- She incorporates nature and peaceful environments, such as parks and retreats, to enhance reflection and connection (Results 34, 50, 100).\n- She uses yoga props to improve sessions (Result 41).\n- She enjoys running and group fitness to stay motivated and connected (Results 83, 87).\n\nStep 2: Identify mentions of ways Jolene enhances her yoga practice:\n- Jolene creates a serene yoga space with candles and oils for chill vibes (Result 70).\n- She uses essential oils and soft, soothing music to create a peaceful atmosphere (Results ",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.39,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.8
    },
    {
      "question": "What music pieces does Deborah listen to during her yoga practice?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Savana, Sleep",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify all mentions of music Deborah listens to during yoga.\n\n- Result 10 (2023-03-28): Deborah mentions liking instrumental tracks with mellow melodies and rhythms, specifically a track called \"Savana.\"\n- Result 48 (2023-03-28): Deborah mentions listening to an album called \"Sleep,\" which is great for meditation and deep relaxation.\n\nStep 2: Check if there are any other music pieces or artists mentioned by Deborah.\n\n- No other specific music pieces or artists are mentioned by Deborah in the context.\n\nFinal answer: Deborah listens to instrumental tracks with mellow melodies like the track \"Savana\" and the album \"Sleep\" during her yoga practice.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.24,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.41
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Deborah go for a bicycle ride with Anna?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "first week of April, 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Deborah going biking or cycling with Anna.  \n- Result 21 (2023-04-09): Deborah says she had a blast biking nearby with her neighbor last week (approximately April 02, 2023).  \n- Result 4 (2023-07-09): Deborah mentions starting a running group with Anna, but no biking mentioned here.  \n\nStep 2: Confirm Anna is the neighbor Deborah biked with.  \n- Result 54 (2023-02-01): Deborah met her new neighbor Anna around January 31, 2023.  \n- Result 4 (2023-07-09): Deborah started a running group with Anna, confirming they are connected.  \n\nStep 3: The biking happened \"last week\" before April 9, 2023, so around April 2, 2023.  \n\nFinal answer: Deborah went for a bicycle ride with Anna around April 2, 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 13.68,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.43
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Deborah go to an art show with Anna?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "on 9 April, 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Deborah going to an art show and any connection to Anna.\n\n- Result 1 (2023-04-09): Deborah talks about her mom's interest in art and going to an art show, feeling connected to her mom.\n- Result 2 and 3 (2023-02-04): Deborah mentions Anna having a pendant in memory of her mother, which brought them closer.\n- Result 11 (2023-07-09): Deborah mentions starting a running group with Anna.\n- Result 27 (2023-02-01): Deborah met her new neighbor Anna around January 31, 2023.\n- Result 22 (2023-04-09): Jolene asks Deborah about the art show and photo, Deborah responds about appreciating art slowly (Result 10).\n- Result 13 (2023-04-09): Deborah talks about finding ways to keep her mom's memory alive through artwork.\n\nStep 2: Look for",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.33,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.32
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Jolene finish her robotics project?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "May 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Jolene mentions starting the robotics project in early February 2023 (Result 4, 2023-02-01).\n\nStep 2: She had a major milestone around January 28, 2023, related to the project (Result 6).\n\nStep 3: On June 6, 2023, Jolene says she wrapped up the tough engineering project last month, approximately May 7, 2023 (Result 7).\n\nStep 4: Deborah congratulates Jolene on wrapping up the project on June 6, 2023 (Result 56).\n\nStep 5: Jolene confirms a big breakthrough and completion around late May 2023 (Results 18, 43).\n\nFinal answer: Jolene finished her robotics project around early May 2023, approximately May 7, 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.34,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.45
    },
    {
      "question": "How long did Jolene work on the robotics project given to her by her Professor?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "four months",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify when Jolene first mentioned the robotics project.\n- On 2023-02-01 (Result 1), Jolene says her engineering professor gave them a huge robotics project.\n\nStep 2: Find when she had a breakthrough or progress updates.\n- On 2023-03-28 (Result 3), Jolene mentions having a breakthrough on Friday with the project.\n- On 2023-02-04 (Result 24), she mentions a major milestone last week (around January 28, 2023), which is before the first message about the project, so likely unrelated or a different milestone.\n\nStep 3: Find when she completed the project.\n- On 2023-06-06 (Result 2), Jolene says she wrapped up the project last month, approximately May 07, 2023.\n\nStep 4: Calculate the duration.\n- From early February 2023 (when she first mentioned the project) to early",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.15,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.78
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Jolene do yoga at Talkeetna?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "on 5 June, 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant excerpt mentioning yoga at Talkeetna.  \n- Result 24 [2023-06-06T16:03:00] Jolene to Deborah: \"Yeah, I`m trying to do it. Here's an example of how I spent yesterday (approximately June 05, 2023) morning, yoga on top of mount Talkeetna.\"\n\nStep 2: Confirm the date of the message and the referenced \"yesterday.\"  \n- The message is dated June 6, 2023, so \"yesterday\" refers to June 5, 2023.\n\nFinal answer:  \nJolene did yoga at Talkeetna on the morning of June 5, 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.94,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.84
    },
    {
      "question": "Which US state did Jolene visit during her internship?",
      "category": 3,
      "gold_answer": "Alaska",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Review all excerpts mentioning Jolene's internship or travel during that time.\n\n- Result 23 (2023-06-06): Jolene says she is interning at a well-known engineering firm.\n- Result 10 (2023-06-26): Jolene mentions being busy with internship.\n- Result 94 (2023-09-12): Jolene talks about a retreat during her internship, appreciating nature.\n- Result 16 (2023-02-22): Jolene asks Deborah about other travel places.\n- Result 19 (2023-02-22): Jolene says she'll keep Deborah posted if she decides to go \"there\" (likely a travel destination).\n- Result 8 and 21 (2023-08-30): Jolene and Deborah discuss architecture and history of a place Jolene visited.\n- Result 97 (2023-08-30): Jolene asks Deborah about a spot she picked to relax.\n\nStep 2",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.1,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.21
    },
    {
      "question": "How long has Jolene been doing yoga and meditation?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "about 3 years",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify direct mentions of how long Jolene has been doing yoga and meditation.\n\n- Result 26 [2023-08-21]: Jolene says, \"Been doing it for 3 years. It's a great way to escape studying and work stress.\"\n- Result 53 [2023-06-06]: Jolene shows an example of doing yoga on June 5, 2023, indicating she was actively practicing then.\n- Result 28 [2023-08-26]: Jolene mentions being into yoga and meditation lately, implying ongoing practice.\n- Result 21 [2023-02-25]: Jolene says yoga seriously saved her, indicating she had been practicing before February 2023.\n\nStep 2: Cross-check for any contradictory or additional time frames.\n\n- No contradictions found.\n- The 3-year duration mentioned in August 2023 aligns with her ongoing practice.\n\nFinal answer: Jolene has been doing yoga and meditation for about 3",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.01,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.45
    },
    {
      "question": "Which year did Jolene start practicing yoga?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "2020",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify any direct mentions of how long Jolene has been doing yoga.\n\n- Result 37 [2023-08-21]: Jolene says, \"Been doing it for 3 years.\"\n- Result 47 [2023-08-01]: Jolene mentions adopting \"her\" two years ago (likely a pet), which is unrelated to yoga start date.\n\nStep 2: Determine the date of the message where Jolene says she has been doing yoga for 3 years.\n\n- The message is dated 2023-08-21.\n\nStep 3: Calculate the approximate start year.\n\n- If Jolene has been doing yoga for 3 years as of August 21, 2023, she likely started around 2020.\n\nStep 4: Check for any contradictory or additional information.\n\n- No other messages specify a different start year for Jolene's yoga practice.\n\nFinal answer: Jolene started practicing yoga around the year 2020.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.12,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.61
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Jolene buy a new aquarium for Seraphim?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "24 June, 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant excerpt about the aquarium purchase.  \n- Result 1 [2023-06-26]: Jolene says she bought a new aquarium \"the day before yesterday,\" approximately June 25, 2023.\n\nStep 2: Confirm no other conflicting or additional information about the aquarium purchase date.  \n- No other excerpts mention a different date for the aquarium purchase.\n\nFinal answer: Jolene bought the new aquarium for Seraphim on June 25, 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.57,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.33
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Jolene lose a lot of progress in her work?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "last week of July 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for any mention of Jolene losing progress or setbacks in her work.\n\nStep 2: The closest relevant information is in Result 6 (2023-09-08), where Deborah says to Jolene: \"Hey Jolene, had a tough week. Storm forced us to cancel our yoga getaway.\" Jolene responds in Result 87 (2023-09-08): \"Sorry to hear about it. How are you feeling now?\" This is about Deborah's tough week, not Jolene losing progress.\n\nStep 3: In Result 80 (2023-06-06), Jolene says: \"Honestly, finding that balance has been tough. I've been slogging away and it's been hard to make time for my hobbies and chilling out.\" This indicates struggle but not losing progress.\n\nStep 4: In Result 30 (2023-06-26), Jolene says: \"Things have been intense lately. I'm really pushing myself to succeed, and",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.71,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.33
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Jolene adopt her snake Susie?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "in 2021",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Jolene adopting Susie.\n- Result 8 (2023-08-01): Jolene says she adopted Susie two years ago, approximately August 01, 2021.\n- Result 11 (2023-09-15): Jolene says she has had Susie for two years now.\n- Result 13 (2023-06-26): Jolene says she got her last year, approximately June 26, 2022, but this conflicts with the other dates.\n- Result 84 (2023-01-27): Jolene says she bought \"it\" a year ago (January 27, 2022) in Paris, but this likely refers to a different pet or item, not Susie.\n\nStep 2: Resolve conflicting dates.\n- The most consistent and repeated date is from Result 8 and Result 11, both stating Jolene adopted Susie about two years ago from mid-2023,",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.16,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.13
    },
    {
      "question": "Which pet did Jolene adopt first - Susie or Seraphim?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "Susie",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify when Jolene got Susie and Seraphim.\n\n- Result 5 (2023-08-01): Jolene says she adopted Susie two years ago (approx. August 1, 2021).\n- Result 4 (2023-06-26): Jolene says she got \"her\" last year (approx. June 26, 2022). The \"her\" here refers to Seraphim, as confirmed by other messages mentioning Seraphim's new aquarium photos around June 2023 (Result 29).\n\nStep 2: Compare the dates.\n\n- Susie was adopted around August 1, 2021.\n- Seraphim was acquired around June 26, 2022.\n\nStep 3: Conclusion.\n\nJolene adopted Susie first, then Seraphim about a year later.\n\nFinal answer: Jolene adopted Susie first, around August 2021, and Seraphim later, around June",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.9,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.28
    },
    {
      "question": "Which pet did Jolene adopt more recently - Susie or Seraphim?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "Seraphim",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify when Jolene got Susie.  \n- Result 10 (2023-08-01): Jolene says she adopted Susie two years ago, approximately August 1, 2021.  \n- Result 5 (2023-06-26): Jolene says she got Susie last year, approximately June 26, 2022.  \nThere is a slight discrepancy, but the more precise date given is August 1, 2021, which is consistent with \"two years ago\" from 2023.\n\nStep 2: Identify when Jolene got Seraphim.  \n- Result 22 (2023-06-26): Jolene mentions buying a new aquarium for Seraphim on June 25, 2023, implying Seraphim was already her pet by then.  \n- Result 14 (2023-01-27): Jolene talks about Seraphim as her second snake, indicating she had Seraph",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.87,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.39
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Deborah lead a meditation session during the sunset?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "week before 16 August, 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for any mention of Deborah leading meditation or yoga sessions, especially around sunset.\n\nStep 2: Result 4 (2023-08-19) Deborah talks about cherishing memories with \"her\" at a spot where they watched a beautiful sunset together in silence.\n\nStep 3: Result 86 (2023-09-06) Deborah mentions recently (around August 30, 2023) seeing a wonderful sunrise again, but this is sunrise, not sunset.\n\nStep 4: Result 23 (2023-02-01) Deborah mentions \"It happened at yoga in the park,\" but no direct mention of sunset or meditation session.\n\nStep 5: Result 57 (2023-08-12) Deborah says she made a meditation guide for her yoga retreat, but no specific date or sunset mention.\n\nStep 6: No explicit mention of Deborah leading a meditation session specifically during sunset is found in the excerpts.\n\nStep 7: However, Result",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.49,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.8
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Jolene gift her partner a new console?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "17 August, 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for any mention of a console or gaming in the context.  \n- Result 1 (2023-02-01): Jolene says, \"we planned to play the console with my partner.\"  \n- Result 22 (2023-07-09): Jolene talks about playing games and bonding with her partner.  \n- Result 97 (2023-01-27): Jolene mentions playing video games and her pet snake.  \n\nStep 2: Check if there is any mention of gifting a console.  \n- No explicit mention of Jolene gifting a console to her partner is found in any excerpt.  \n- The conversation only mentions playing the console together or gaming experiences, but no gifting event or date is specified.\n\nStep 3: Confirm if any date or event related to gifting a console is mentioned.  \n- No date or event about gifting a console is present.\n\nFinal answer: Not enough information.",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.75,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.74
    },
    {
      "question": "What games does Jolene recommend for Deborah?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Zelda BOTW for Switch , Animal Crossing: New Horizons, Overcooked 2",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify any mentions of games Jolene recommends or talks about to Deborah.\n\n- Result 10 (2023-01-27): Jolene mentions planning to play \"Walking Dead\" next Saturday.\n- Result 9 (2023-08-19): Jolene asks Deborah about her favorite game to play with a certain person, but no direct recommendation.\n- Result 13 (2023-09-03): Jolene mentions her mom played games with her but no specific game recommended.\n- Result 2 (2023-07-09): Jolene talks about the benefits of playing games together but no specific game named.\n- Result 3 (2023-08-19): Deborah says they prefer detective games together, but no direct recommendation from Jolene.\n- Result 58 (2023-09-17): Jolene says \"I think not, I really like it!\" but no game named.\n- Result 85 (2023-08-19):",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.33,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.89
    },
    {
      "question": "What do Deborah and her husband do together?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "play detective games together, spend time outdoors and explore nature",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for mentions of Deborah and her husband doing activities together.  \nStep 2: In Result 18 [2023-01-27T09:51:00], Deborah says, \"My husband and I are trying to be as good a family as my parents were!\" This indicates a focus on family life together.  \nStep 3: In Result 94 [2023-02-25T16:52:00], Jolene mentions, \"He started joining me sometimes, which is nice for bonding and relaxing. It's brought us closer.\" This suggests Deborah's husband joins her in some relaxing activity, though the exact activity is not specified here.  \nStep 4: No other explicit details about specific activities Deborah and her husband do together are found in the excerpts.\n\nFinal answer: Deborah and her husband focus on building a strong family together and sometimes join in relaxing activities for bonding.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.95,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.31
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Deborah go to a yoga retreat near her mom's place?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "a week before 24 August,2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Deborah going to a yoga retreat near her mom's place.  \n- Result 8 [2023-08-24]: Deborah says, \"last week (approximately August 17, 2023) I got to go to this yoga retreat near my mom's place.\"  \n- Result 79 [2023-08-30]: Deborah mentions visiting her mom's house last month (approximately July 31, 2023), but this is about the house, not the retreat.\n\nStep 2: Confirm no other conflicting or additional dates for the retreat near her mom's place.  \n- No other results specify a different date for that retreat.\n\nFinal answer: Deborah went to a yoga retreat near her mom's place around August 17, 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.49,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.15
    },
    {
      "question": "What projects is Jolene planning for next year?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "developing renewable energy finding ways to supply clean water to those with limited access",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the timeline for \"next year.\" The latest messages are from September 2023, so \"next year\" refers to 2024.\n\nStep 2: Look for any mentions of Jolene's future plans or projects for 2024.\n\nStep 3: In [Result 44] (2023-08-26), Jolene says she is aiming to work on projects that make a real difference to communities, focusing on sustainable initiatives, renewable energy, and social causes.\n\nStep 4: In [Result 10] (2023-08-26), Jolene specifies interest in two projects, one focused on developing renewable energy like solar to help communities and reduce dependence on non-renewables.\n\nStep 5: Earlier in the year, Jolene mentioned teaming up with local schools/centers to do workshops and inviting engineers as guest speakers ([Result 25], 2023-02-09).\n\nStep 6: No other explicit plans for ",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.3,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.35
    },
    {
      "question": "Where did Deborah get her cats?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Luna is from the shelter and Max is her mother's cat",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Deborah's cats and their origins.\n- Result 2: Deborah says Max is her mother's cat, and she took him when her mother passed away.\n- Result 27: Deborah says she took Luna from the shelter.\n\nStep 2: Confirm no other sources contradict or add to this.\n- Result 42: Deborah mentions she has cats because she doesn't like dogs, but no other origin details.\n- Result 89: Deborah mentions Max brings joy and peace to their home, consistent with Result 2.\n\nStep 3: Synthesize the information.\n- Deborah got Max by taking him from her mother after her mother passed away.\n- Deborah got Luna from a shelter.\n\nFinal answer: Deborah got Max from her mother after she passed away, and she adopted Luna from a shelter.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.09,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.24
    },
    {
      "question": "How old are Deborah's cats?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Max is 8 years old and Luna is 5 years old",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify Deborah's cats and their ages from the context.\n\n- From [Result 2] and [Result 98], Max is Deborah's mother's cat, now Deborah's cat.\n- From [Result 4], Max is 8 years old.\n- From [Result 1], Deborah says \"She is younger, she is 5 years old,\" referring to another cat.\n- From [Result 67], Deborah mentions Luna, a cat sitting on the left.\n- From [Result 5], Jolene asks how old Luna is.\n- From [Result 1], Deborah answers Luna is 5 years old.\n- From [Result 91], Deborah says she took Luna from the shelter.\n\nStep 2: Summarize ages:\n- Max is 8 years old.\n- Luna is 5 years old.\n\nFinal answer: Deborah's cats are Max, who is 8 years old, and Luna, who is 5 years old.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.51,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.31
    },
    {
      "question": "Does Deborah like cats?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Yes",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for any direct statements about Deborah's feelings toward cats.  \n- Result 3: Deborah says, \"I don't like dogs, that's why I have cats.\" This implies she prefers cats over dogs.  \n- Result 41: Deborah says, \"I really love cats, and they also need a home, love, and care!\" This is a clear positive statement about cats.  \n- Result 69: Deborah mentions Max, her mother's cat, and refers to him with care, indicating affection for cats.  \n\nStep 2: Check for any contradictory statements.  \n- No statements contradict Deborah liking cats.  \n\nStep 3: Synthesize the information.  \nDeborah explicitly states she loves cats and prefers them over dogs, and she cares for cats including Max and Luna.  \n\nFinal answer:  \nYes, Deborah likes cats and even prefers them over dogs.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.36,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.47
    },
    {
      "question": "Which country was Jolene located in during the last week of August 2023?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "Brazil",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify any messages around the last week of August 2023 that mention Jolene's location or activities.\n\n- Result 38 [2023-09-03]: Deborah mentions attending a cool event last week (approx. August 27, 2023) and asks Jolene if she has been connecting with anyone lately.\n- Result 27 [2023-09-06]: Deborah says she recently (approx. August 30, 2023) saw a wonderful sunrise again.\n- Result 18 [2023-09-06]: Jolene says a shot reminded her of her last beach getaway, describing it as chill and nice.\n- Result 23 and 54 [2023-08-30]: Jolene and Deborah discuss architecture and history of a place Jolene visited, with Deborah sharing a photo and Jolene commenting on the interesting architecture and history.\n- Result 64 [2023-08-30]: Jolene asks Deborah \"What was it",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.23,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.32
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Jolene and her partner return home from Rio de Janeiro?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "29 August, 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify any mentions of Rio de Janeiro or a trip related to it in the context.\n\nStep 2: Look for any dates or time references around such mentions.\n\nStep 3: Check if Jolene or Deborah mention returning home from Rio de Janeiro.\n\nReviewing the context:\n\n- Result 95 [2023-09-20]: Deborah to Jolene comments on a gorgeous shot and asks about a trip and what Jolene will never forget, implying Jolene recently went on a trip.\n\n- Result 61 [2023-09-06]: Jolene to Deborah says, \"That shot was like a reminder of my last beach getaway. So chill and nice.\"\n\n- No explicit mention of Rio de Janeiro in the excerpts.\n\n- No direct statement about when Jolene and her partner returned from Rio.\n\n- No date or message explicitly stating their return.\n\nConclusion: There is no explicit information about when Jolene and her partner returned home from Rio de Janeiro.\n\nFinal answer: Not",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.13,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.55
    },
    {
      "question": "What was Jolene doing with her partner in Rio de Janeiro?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "they went on excursions, checked out some cool yoga classes, visited a lot of delicious cafes, visited an old temple",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Rio de Janeiro and Jolene's activities there.  \n- Result 1 (2023-08-30): Jolene to Deborah says, \"Here is one more photo from Rio de Janeiro. We went on many excursions there.\"  \n- Result 5 (2023-08-30): Deborah to Jolene says, \"Wow, exploring those temples must have been incredible! Three years ago I was also in Rio de Janeiro, I took a beautiful photo on one of the excursions.\"  \n- Result 77 (2023-09-20): Deborah to Jolene says, \"Wow, what a gorgeous shot! It looks so tranquil and serene. You two look very happy together. Trips create awesome memories that we can share. Where did you go on your trip and what's something you'll never forget?\" (implying Jolene shared a photo from a trip, likely Rio)  \n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information:  \n- Jolene",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.57,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.88
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Deborah visit Brazil?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "2020",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Deborah visiting Brazil or Rio de Janeiro.  \n- Result 4 [2023-08-30]: Deborah says, \"Three years ago I was also in Rio de Janeiro, I took a beautiful photo on one of the excursions.\"  \n- Result 1 and 10 [2023-08-30]: Jolene talks about excursions in Rio de Janeiro, but no specific date for Deborah's visit.  \n- No other direct mentions of Deborah visiting Brazil.\n\nStep 2: Determine the date of the conversation mentioning \"three years ago.\"  \n- The message is dated 2023-08-30.  \n- \"Three years ago\" from 2023-08-30 is approximately 2020.\n\nFinal answer: Deborah visited Brazil (Rio de Janeiro) around the year 2020.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.29,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.51
    },
    {
      "question": "Have Deborah and Jolene been to Rio de Janeiro?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "yes",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Jolene mentions in [Result 1] (2023-08-30) that she has photos from Rio de Janeiro and went on many excursions there.\n\nStep 2: Deborah responds in [Result 2] (2023-08-30) that three years ago she was also in Rio de Janeiro and took a beautiful photo on one of the excursions.\n\nStep 3: Jolene further discusses the architecture and history of Rio in [Result 17] (2023-08-30), indicating her experience there.\n\nStep 4: Deborah also shares reflections about the place in [Result 35] and [Result 38] (2023-08-30 and 2023-08-21), showing personal connection and memories.\n\nConclusion: Both Deborah and Jolene have been to Rio de Janeiro, with Deborah visiting about three years before 2023 (around 2020) and Jolene more recently in 2023.\n\nFinal answer: Yes",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.74,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.79
    },
    {
      "question": "Is the friend who wrote Deborah the motivational quote no longer alive?",
      "category": 3,
      "gold_answer": "likely yes",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the quote and the friend who wrote it.  \n- Result 2 (2023-08-30) Deborah says: \"This was written to me by a friend who, unfortunately, will never be able to support me. I miss him here.\" She then quotes \"Let go of what no longer serves you.\"\n\nStep 2: Analyze the phrase \"will never be able to support me\" and \"I miss him here.\"  \n- This strongly implies the friend is no longer alive.\n\nStep 3: Check for any contradictory information.  \n- No other results contradict this; several messages (e.g., Result 15) show Deborah dealing with loss and grief.\n\nFinal answer: Yes, the friend who wrote Deborah the motivational quote is no longer alive.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.83,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.38
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Deborah go to a community meetup?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "last week of August 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify any mention of Deborah attending a community meetup.  \n- Result 29 [2023-09-03T14:15:00] Deborah to Jolene: \"I was busy too - went to a community meetup last Friday.\"\n\nStep 2: Determine the date of the message and the referenced \"last Friday.\"  \n- The message is dated 2023-09-03 (Sunday).  \n- The \"last Friday\" before 2023-09-03 would be 2023-09-01.\n\nFinal answer: Deborah went to a community meetup on Friday, September 1, 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.7,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.35
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Jolene's parents give her first console?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "when she was 10",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify any mention of Jolene's first console or when she started playing video games.  \n- Result 37: Jolene says, \"When I was 10, my parents got me that and it was the start of my passion for video games.\"  \n- Result 2: Jolene says, \"I taught myself, but my dad was always supportive and my mom would play games with me.\"  \n- Result 4: Jolene says, \"Even as a child I learned to play on my own.\"  \n- Result 60: Jolene mentions playing video games with her pet snake nearby.\n\nStep 2: Determine the timing of Jolene being 10 years old.  \n- No explicit birth year is given, but the conversation is in 2023.  \n- Since Jolene refers to receiving the console at age 10, and this is a past event, it likely happened years ago.\n\nStep 3: Confirm the question is about when Jolene",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.76,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.45
    },
    {
      "question": "Did Jolene teach herself how to play the console?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "yes",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for any direct statements about how Jolene learned to play the console.  \n- Result 2 (2023-09-03): Jolene says, \"I taught myself, but my dad was always supportive and my mom would play games with me.\"  \n- Result 3 (2023-01-27): Jolene says, \"Even as a child I learned to play on my own.\"  \n- Result 5 (2023-01-27): Deborah asks, \"Did your boyfriend teach you to play?\"  \n- Result 8 (2023-09-03): Deborah asks, \"Did you learn on your own or did they teach you?\"  \n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.  \nJolene explicitly states she taught herself to play the console, with support from her dad and playing with her mom, but not being taught by her boyfriend or others.\n\nFinal answer:  \nYes, Jolene taught herself how to play the console",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.94,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.48
    },
    {
      "question": "What do Deborah and Jolene plan to try when they meet in a new cafe?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "coffee and fresh pastries",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant excerpts about the cafe meeting and what they plan to try.\n\n- Result 1 (2023-09-08): Jolene to Deborah: \"Wanna meet up at that cafe next Monday? Let's try fresh pastries.\"\n- Result 2 (2023-09-08): Deborah to Jolene: \"Sounds good, Jolene! When did you have in mind? That cafe rocks.\"\n- Result 21 (2023-09-08): Deborah to Jolene: \"Sounds great! Let's set up a coffee date and talk about it!\"\n- Result 10 (2023-09-08): Jolene to Deborah: \"How about Wednesday at 4? Can't wait to catch up over coffee!\"\n- Result 66 (2023-09-08): Deborah to Jolene: \"Maybe just grab me some interesting books!\" (less relevant)\n- Result 12 (2023-09-08): Jolene to Deborah: \"",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.24,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.4
    },
    {
      "question": "What card game is Deborah talking about?",
      "category": 3,
      "gold_answer": "Exploding Kittens",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant excerpt where Deborah mentions a card game.  \n- In Result 17 (2023-09-12), Deborah says: \"I recently (approximately September 05, 2023) played a game. I don't remember what it's called. This is a card game about cats, where you take cards one by one from a deck, and then you can attack your opponent with them.\"\n\nStep 2: Analyze the description of the card game.  \n- It is a card game involving cats.  \n- Players take cards one by one from a deck.  \n- Players can attack their opponent with the cards.\n\nStep 3: Check if any other excerpts mention the name of this card game or provide more details.  \n- No other excerpt explicitly names the card game.\n\nStep 4: Based on the description, the card game is about cats, involves drawing cards, and attacking opponents. This matches the popular card game \"Exploding Kittens,\" which is",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.61,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.28
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Jolene and her partner try scuba diving lessons?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "Friday before 17 September, 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant excerpt about scuba diving lessons.  \n- Result 2 [2023-09-17T13:25:30] Jolene to Deborah: \"We tried a scuba diving lesson last Friday and had an awesome time!\"\n\nStep 2: Determine the date of the message to find the exact date of the lesson.  \n- The message was sent on 2023-09-17 (Sunday).  \n- \"Last Friday\" before 2023-09-17 is 2023-09-15.\n\nFinal answer:  \nJolene and her partner tried scuba diving lessons on Friday, September 15, 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.17,
      "judge_latency_s": 3.47
    },
    {
      "question": "Where did Jolene and her partner find a cool diving spot?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Phuket",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant excerpt about scuba diving and the cool dive spot.\n- Result 3 [2023-09-17T13:25:30] Jolene to Deborah: \"We tried a scuba diving lesson last Friday and had an awesome time! We found a cool dive spot we can explore together.\"\n\nStep 2: Check if the location of the dive spot is mentioned anywhere else.\n- No other excerpt specifies the exact location of the dive spot.\n\nStep 3: Confirm if Jolene or Deborah mention the place or give clues.\n- Result 5 [2023-07-09T19:54:00] Deborah to Jolene: \"Why did you choose that spot? It looks so calm.\"\n- Result 23 [2023-08-30T11:52:00] Jolene to Deborah: \"Looks great! What made you pick that spot?\"\n- These refer to other spots but not specifically the dive spot.\n\nStep 4:",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.84,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.72
    },
    {
      "question": "Where did Jolene and her partner spend most of September 2023?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "Phuket",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for any mentions of Jolene and her partner's activities or location in September 2023.\n\nStep 2: The closest relevant messages are from early September 2023:\n- [Result 79] (2023-09-06) Jolene to Deborah: \"That shot was like a reminder of my last beach getaway. So chill and nice.\"\n- [Result 70] (2023-09-06) Jolene to Deborah: \"Maybe one day we will be able to watch the sunrise together!\"\n- [Result 96] (2023-09-08) Jolene to Deborah: \"Now I'll see when it's more convenient for me.\"\n- [Result 64] (2023-09-08) Deborah to Jolene: \"Hey Jolene, had a tough week. Storm forced us to cancel our yoga getaway.\"\n- [Result 93] (2023-02-01) Jolene to Deborah: \"Well...",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.71,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.45
    },
    {
      "question": "Has Deborah tried surfing?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "yes",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for any direct mentions of Deborah trying surfing.  \n- Result 4: Deborah says the beach is special because she got married there and discovered her love for surfing, implying she has surfed before.  \n- Result 24: Jolene asks Deborah if she has ever tried surfing.  \n- Result 26: Deborah asks Jolene if she has ever been interested in scuba diving, no mention of surfing here.  \n- No explicit statement from Deborah saying she has tried surfing recently, but the phrase \"discovered my love for surfing\" strongly suggests she has surfed before.\n\nStep 2: Check if Deborah expresses any hesitation or lack of experience with surfing.  \n- No indication Deborah has not tried surfing; rather, she talks about loving it and the beach where she got married and discovered surfing.\n\nFinal answer:  \nYes, Deborah has tried surfing and has a love for it, as she discovered her passion for surfing at the beach where she got married.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.7,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.23
    },
    {
      "question": "Has Jolene tried surfing?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "no",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Early in the conversation on 2023-03-22, Jolene expresses interest in learning to surf and gathering information but does not mention having tried it yet (Results 2, 5, 11, 17).\n\nStep 2: Deborah asks Jolene if she has ever tried surfing (Result 17), and Jolene responds that she never decided to try it (Result 11).\n\nStep 3: There is no later mention of Jolene actually taking a surfing lesson or trying surfing.\n\nFinal answer: No, Jolene has not tried surfing yet.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.58,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.23
    },
    {
      "question": "When did the Deboran and Jolene agree to go surfing?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "in October 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of surfing plans or agreements between Deborah and Jolene.\n\n- Result 3 (2023-03-22): Deborah encourages Jolene about surfing and asks about steps to take.\n- Result 5 (2023-03-22): Jolene thinks about when she'll learn to surf.\n- Result 1 and 2 (2023-03-22): Jolene talks about gathering info and being pumped to try surfing.\n- No explicit mention of Deborah and Jolene agreeing to go surfing together on or around March 22.\n\nStep 2: Check later dates for any direct agreement or plan to surf together.\n\n- Result 7 (2023-09-17): Jolene asks Deborah if she has ever tried surfing, no agreement mentioned.\n- Result 40 (2023-09-17): Jolene mentions trying scuba diving last Friday, no surfing agreement.\n- Result 62 (2023-07-09): Jolene says \"We'll definitely",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.1,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.35
    },
    {
      "question": "Which locations does Deborah practice her yoga at?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "at her mother's old home, park, yoga studio, beach",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Deborah's yoga practice locations in the excerpts.\n\n- Result 9 (2023-02-01): Deborah says, \"It happened at yoga in the park.\"\n- Result 30 (2023-08-19): Deborah says, \"I love going to this park near my house - it has a nice forest trail and a beach. It's a peaceful spot where I can do some yoga and reflect.\"\n- Result 55 (2023-01-27): Deborah says, \"This is one of the places where I do it,\" referring to yoga.\n- Result 77 (2023-01-27): Deborah mentions her old home where she goes to sit by a special bench, connected to her mom, which is a place of peace but not explicitly for yoga.\n- Result 22 (2023-08-24): Deborah mentions attending a yoga retreat near her mom's place.\n- Result 38 (2023-08-19):",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.11,
      "judge_latency_s": 4.8
    },
    {
      "question": "What kind of professional activities does Jolene participate in to gain more experience in her field?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "present work at virtual conference, attend workshops  and intern at firms",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Jolene's professional activities or experience-building efforts.\n\n- Result 27 (2023-06-06): Jolene says she is interning at a well-known engineering firm, gaining real-world experience and meeting new colleagues.\n- Result 31 (2023-06-06): Jolene mentions the internship has positively impacted her life and encouraged her to keep striving for her dreams.\n- Result 38 (2023-06-06): Deborah asks how the internship has impacted Jolene.\n- Result 47 (2023-06-06): Deborah asks if Jolene has found a good work-life balance during the internship.\n- Result 73 (2023-08-24): Jolene talks about focusing on studying and gaining more experience, considering more internships to enhance her skills.\n- Result 94 (2023-02-04): Jolene describes a project providing clean water to the community, which gave her a sense of purpose and satisfaction in",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.79,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.43
    },
    {
      "question": "What kind of engineering projects has Jolene worked on?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "electrical engineering, robotics, sustainable water purifier, productive and affordable aerial surveillance system",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of engineering projects Jolene has worked on.\n\n- Result 3 (2023-02-04): Jolene talks about a project providing clean water to a community, which was very satisfying and purposeful.\n- Result 5 (2023-03-28): Jolene had a breakthrough on a tough engineering project.\n- Result 8 (2023-06-06): Jolene wrapped up a tough engineering project around May 7, 2023.\n- Result 15 (2023-02-04): Jolene wants to work on sustainable solutions to positively impact communities.\n- Result 25 (2023-08-26): Jolene is interested in sustainable initiatives and innovative solutions for environmental issues.\n- Result 35 (2023-08-26): Jolene is keen on projects developing renewable energy like solar to help communities and reduce dependence on non-renewables.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.\n\nJolene has worked on",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.07,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.64
    },
    {
      "question": "Which community activities have Deborah and Anna participated in?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "yoga, running",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Deborah and Anna together in community activities.\n\n- Result 8 (2023-07-09): Deborah says she started a running group with Anna, connecting with people who care about fitness.\n- Result 2 (2023-07-09): Deborah describes workshops and events involving yoga, meditation, and self-reflection aimed at self-awareness and well-being.\n- Result 4 and 23 (2023-07-09): Jolene asks about workshops and events, and Deborah confirms these activities help people connect and grow.\n- Result 84 (2023-07-09): Deborah mentions the workshops bring people together and support each other, witnessing growth and transformation.\n- Result 87 (2023-02-01): Deborah mentions meeting her new neighbor Anna around January 31, 2023.\n- No other direct mentions of Anna participating in other community activities with Deborah.\n\nStep 2: Summarize the community activities involving Deborah and Anna.\n\n",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.0,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.62
    },
    {
      "question": "What gifts has Deborah received?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "an appreciate letter from her community, a flower bouqet from her friend, a motivational quote from a friend",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of gifts Deborah received.\n\n- Result 20 (2023-02-04): Deborah says, \"My friend gave me this bouquet when I was struggling, and it gives me hope and courage.\"\n- Result 3 (2023-02-04): Deborah mentions Anna has a pendant she wears in memory of her mother, and Deborah herself also has a pendant (Result 24).\n- Result 71 (2023-02-04): Deborah refers to an amulet from her mother that she brings with her for comfort.\n- Result 77 (2023-08-26): Deborah mentions Max, presumably a pet, bringing joy and peace to their home.\n- Result 60 (2023-08-26): Deborah says Max is 5 years old, implying Max is a pet she owns.\n- Result 34 (2023-08-01): Deborah acknowledges the comfort pets provide, in response to Jolene's mention of Susie.\n\n",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.64,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.55
    },
    {
      "question": "Which countries has Deborah traveled to?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Thailand, Brazil",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Review all excerpts mentioning travel or trips by Deborah.\n\n- Result 1 (2023-01-27): Deborah mentions travel was a great passion.\n- Result 15 (2023-01-27): Deborah shows a place where she does something (likely meditation or reflection).\n- Result 19 (2023-08-30): Deborah talks about exploring historical places and learning their stories.\n- Result 61 (2023-01-27): Deborah mentions her old home where she goes for her mom.\n- Result 63 (2023-08-21): Deborah talks about bringing flowers to a place full of memories.\n- Result 96 (2023-08-30): Deborah mentions soothing vibes and nice views ideal for reflecting.\n\nStep 2: Look for any explicit country names Deborah traveled to.\n\n- Result 75 (2023-08-30): Jolene shares a photo from Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, but this is about Jolene's trip",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.02,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.38
    },
    {
      "question": "What activities does Deborah pursue besides practicing and teaching yoga?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "biking, going to art shows, running, organizing workshops to practice mindfulness and self-care, surfing, gardening",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Deborah's activities besides yoga practice and teaching.\n\n- Result 33: Deborah mentions running along with yoga/meditation and organizing workshops and events for mindfulness and self-care.\n- Result 35: Deborah meditates, does yoga, teaches classes, and recently started morning jogging.\n- Result 37: Deborah also goes out for walks and stays mindful.\n- Result 38: Deborah focuses on teaching yoga and spending time with the community, organizing a yoga event.\n- Result 53: Deborah enjoys going to a park with a forest trail and beach for yoga and reflection.\n- Result 60: Exercise in general is important to Deborah for feeling connected to her body.\n- Result 69 & 100: Deborah tries new yoga poses, indicating ongoing learning and practice.\n- Result 87: Deborah mentions a symbol of peace and enlightenment, possibly related to her mindfulness or meditation interests.\n\nStep 2: Summarize the activities besides yoga practice and teaching.\n\nDeborah",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.64,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.47
    },
    {
      "question": "What are the names of Jolene's snakes?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Susie, Seraphim",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Jolene's snakes and their names in the context.\n\n- Result 1 (2023-01-27): Jolene introduces one snake named Susie.\n- Result 4 (2023-01-27): Jolene mentions a second snake named Seraphim.\n- Result 11 (2023-08-26): Jolene asks about the second snake's name, implying she has at least two.\n- Result 33 (2023-09-15): Jolene refers to Susie as a great companion.\n- Result 82 (2023-09-15): Jolene confirms she has had Susie for two years.\n\nStep 2: Confirm no other snake names are mentioned.\n\nNo other snake names appear in the context.\n\nFinal answer: Jolene's snakes are named Susie and Seraphim.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.34,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.49
    },
    {
      "question": "What are Jolene's favorite books?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Sapiens, Avalanche by Neal Stephenson",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for any direct mentions of Jolene's favorite books or books she likes.\n\n- Result 13 shows Jolene sharing her bookshelf with Deborah.\n- Result 3 and 6 show Deborah asking Jolene about favorite books or books that moved her.\n- Result 52: Jolene says, \"It takes me to another world when I read it!\" (referring to a special book Deborah mentioned).\n- Result 23: Jolene says, \"How cool! But I never decided to try it.\" (likely about a book or reading-related activity Deborah mentioned).\n- Result 27: Jolene says, \"I think not, I really like it!\" (possibly about a book or reading nook).\n- Result 2: Deborah asks Jolene to grab some interesting books.\n- Result 26: Jolene suggests meeting Friday to sort out books from her bookcase.\n\nStep 2: Check if any specific book titles or genres are mentioned.\n\n- No specific book titles",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.01,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.67
    },
    {
      "question": "What music pieces does Deborah listen to during her yoga practice?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Savana, Sleep",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify all mentions of music Deborah listens to during yoga.\n\n- Result 10 (2023-03-28): Deborah mentions liking instrumental tracks with mellow melodies and rhythms, specifically a track called \"Savana.\"\n- Result 48 (2023-03-28): Deborah mentions listening to an album called \"Sleep,\" which is great for meditation and deep relaxation.\n\nStep 2: Check if there are any other music pieces or artists mentioned by Deborah.\n\n- No other specific music pieces or artists are mentioned by Deborah in the context.\n\nFinal answer: Deborah listens to instrumental tracks with mellow melodies like the track \"Savana\" and the album \"Sleep\" during her yoga practice.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.1,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.98
    },
    {
      "question": "What games does Jolene recommend for Deborah?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Zelda BOTW for Switch , Animal Crossing: New Horizons, Overcooked 2",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify any mentions of games Jolene recommends or talks about to Deborah.\n\n- Result 10 (2023-01-27): Jolene says, \"We are planning to play 'Walking Dead' next Saturday.\"\n- Result 9 (2023-08-19): Jolene asks Deborah about favorite games to play together, but no direct recommendation.\n- Result 2 (2023-07-09): Jolene talks about the fun of tackling challenges in games but no specific game mentioned.\n- Result 3 (2023-08-19): Deborah says they prefer detective games.\n- Result 13 (2023-09-03): Jolene mentions her mom played games with her but no specific game named.\n- Result 14 (2023-09-17): Jolene says she never decided to try \"it\" (likely a game or activity), but no name given.\n- Result 58 (2023-09-17): Jolene says",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.98,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.47
    },
    {
      "question": "What projects is Jolene planning for next year?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "developing renewable energy finding ways to supply clean water to those with limited access",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Jolene's future project plans.\n- Result 44 (2023-08-26): Jolene says she aims to work on projects that make a real difference to communities, focusing on sustainable initiatives, renewable energy, environmental issues, and social causes.\n- Result 10 (2023-08-26): Jolene is keen on two projects, one focused on renewable energy like solar to help communities and reduce dependence on non-renewables.\n- Result 25 (2023-02-09): Jolene is thinking of teaming up with local schools/centers to do workshops and invite engineers as guest speakers.\n- Result 47 (2023-02-04): Jolene wants to keep working in engineering and make a positive impact on communities by creating sustainable solutions.\n\nStep 2: Consider the timeline.\n- The latest detailed future plans are from August 2023, which would be relevant for next year (2024).\n- The plans include",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.32,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.83
    },
    {
      "question": "Where did Deborah get her cats?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Luna is from the shelter and Max is her mother's cat",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Deborah's cats and their origins.  \n- Result 2: Deborah says Max is her mother's cat, and she took him when her mother passed away.  \n- Result 27: Deborah says she took Luna from the shelter.\n\nStep 2: Confirm no other sources contradict or add to this.  \n- Result 42: Deborah mentions she has cats because she doesn't like dogs, but no other origin details.  \n- Result 89: Deborah mentions Max brings joy and peace to their home, consistent with Result 2.\n\nStep 3: Synthesize the information.  \nDeborah got Max by taking him from her mother after her mother passed away, and she adopted Luna from a shelter.\n\nFinal answer:  \nDeborah got Max from her mother when she passed away and adopted Luna from a shelter.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.19,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.84
    },
    {
      "question": "How old are Deborah's cats?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Max is 8 years old and Luna is 5 years old",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify Deborah's cats and their ages from the context.\n\n- From [Result 2] and [Result 98], Max is Deborah's mother's cat, now Deborah's cat.\n- From [Result 4], Max is 8 years old.\n- From [Result 67], Deborah mentions she still has cats and Luna is one of them.\n- From [Result 5] and [Result 1], Luna is 5 years old.\n\nStep 2: Summarize the ages.\n\n- Max is 8 years old.\n- Luna is 5 years old.\n\nFinal answer: Deborah's cats are Max, who is 8 years old, and Luna, who is 5 years old.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.96,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.34
    },
    {
      "question": "What was Jolene doing with her partner in Rio de Janeiro?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "they went on excursions, checked out some cool yoga classes, visited a lot of delicious cafes, visited an old temple",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Rio de Janeiro and Jolene's activities there.\n- Result 1 (2023-08-30): Jolene to Deborah says they went on many excursions in Rio de Janeiro.\n- Result 5 (2023-08-30): Deborah mentions she was also in Rio three years ago and took a photo on one of the excursions.\n- Result 77 (2023-09-20): Deborah asks Jolene about a trip and what she will never forget, implying a recent trip.\n\nStep 2: Confirm that Jolene was with her partner in Rio.\n- Result 77: Deborah says \"You two look very happy together,\" referring to a photo Jolene shared from the trip, indicating Jolene was with her partner.\n\nStep 3: Determine what Jolene and her partner were doing.\n- Result 1: Jolene says they went on many excursions.\n- Result 5: Deborah refers to exploring temples during excursions.\n- Result ",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.21,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.79
    },
    {
      "question": "Have Deborah and Jolene been to Rio de Janeiro?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "yes",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Rio de Janeiro in the conversation excerpts.\n\n- Result 1 (2023-08-30): Jolene to Deborah mentions a photo from Rio de Janeiro and many excursions there.\n- Result 2 (2023-08-30): Deborah to Jolene says she was also in Rio de Janeiro three years ago and took a photo on one of the excursions.\n- Result 17 (2023-08-30): Jolene to Deborah talks about the architecture and history in Rio and assumes Deborah liked the places she visited.\n- Result 51 (2023-08-30): Deborah to Jolene talks about exploring historical places and learning their stories, sharing a photo (likely related to Rio).\n\nStep 2: Confirm both have been there.\n\n- Jolene clearly states she went on many excursions in Rio (Result 1).\n- Deborah confirms she was in Rio three years ago (Result 2).\n\nStep 3: Conclusion.\n\nBoth Deborah and Jol",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.02,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.44
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Jolene's parents give her first console?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "when she was 10",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify any mention of Jolene's first console or when she started playing video games.  \nStep 2: Result 37 states: \"When I was 10, my parents got me that and it was the start of my passion for video games.\" This implies Jolene's parents gave her the console when she was 10 years old.  \nStep 3: There is no direct mention of Jolene's current age or birth year in the excerpts, so the exact calendar year cannot be determined.  \nStep 4: The best specific answer is that Jolene's parents gave her the first console when she was 10 years old.\n\nFinal answer: Jolene's parents gave her the first console when she was 10 years old.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.49,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.16
    },
    {
      "question": "What do Deborah and Jolene plan to try when they meet in a new cafe?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "coffee and fresh pastries",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant excerpts about the cafe meeting.\n- Result 1 (2023-09-08): Jolene suggests meeting at a cafe next Monday to try fresh pastries.\n- Result 2 (2023-09-08): Deborah agrees and says the cafe rocks.\n- Result 21 (2023-09-08): Deborah suggests setting up a coffee date.\n- Result 10 (2023-09-08): Jolene proposes Wednesday at 4 for coffee.\n- Result 12 (2023-09-08): Jolene mentions telling more about \"it\" when they meet, maybe next time they\u2019ll be there.\n- Result 66 (2023-09-08): Deborah says maybe Jolene can grab her some interesting books.\n- Result 97 (2023-09-08): Jolene expresses excitement for their coffee date.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the plan.\n- They plan to meet at a cafe.\n- Jolene",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.82,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.43
    },
    {
      "question": "What project did Jolene finish last week before 23 January, 2023?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "an electrical engineering project",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the date of the message mentioning the milestone \"last week\" before January 23, 2023.  \n- Result 4 [2023-02-04]: Jolene says, \"I had a major milestone last week (approximately January 28, 2023) and it went really well.\"\n\nStep 2: The milestone was around January 28, 2023, so \"last week\" refers to the week before that, approximately January 21, 2023.\n\nStep 3: Determine what project or milestone Jolene refers to.  \n- Result 4 states it was a \"huge accomplishment for me as an engineer.\"  \n- Result 34 [2023-02-09] Jolene says, \"Yep! I achieved so much more than I imagined. It was a real confidence boost.\"  \n- Result 6 [2023-02-25] Jolene mentions teaming up for projects, indicating ongoing engineering work.\n\nStep",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.39,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.28
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Jolene buy her pet snake?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "A year ago",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of when Jolene got her pet snake.  \n- Result 20: Jolene says she bought it a year ago (from Jan 27, 2023), so approximately January 27, 2022, in Paris.  \n- Result 10: Jolene says she got \"her\" last year (from June 26, 2023), so approximately June 26, 2022.  \n- Result 16: Jolene says she adopted \"her\" two years ago (from August 1, 2023), so approximately August 1, 2021.\n\nStep 2: Clarify which snake these dates refer to.  \n- Result 7 and 56 mention a snake named Susie.  \n- Result 4 and 67 mention a second snake named Seraphim.  \n- Result 20 (bought a snake in Paris a year ago) likely refers to Susie (Result 81 says Jolene has",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 5.35,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.38
    },
    {
      "question": "What project was Jolene working on as of 1 February, 2023?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Robotics project",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the date in question: 1 February 2023.\n\nStep 2: Look for messages around that date that mention Jolene's project.\n\n- Result 15 [2023-02-04]: Jolene mentions a major milestone last week (around January 28, 2023) that went well and was a huge accomplishment as an engineer.\n- Result 4 [2023-02-25]: Jolene says teaming up for these projects feels great.\n- Result 56 [2023-02-01]: Deborah asks Jolene about a challenging project that is putting her creative and problem-solving skills to the test.\n- Result 90 [2023-02-04]: Jolene says a small thing can make a real difference.\n- Result 98 [2023-04-09]: Jolene mentions working on a big project that is tough but cool to watch take shape.\n\nStep 3: From these, the project Jolene was working on",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.39,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.46
    },
    {
      "question": "Where did Deborah meet her new neighbor Anna?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "yoga in the park",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant messages about Deborah meeting Anna.  \n- Result 11 [2023-02-01]: Deborah says, \"I met my new neighbor Anna yesterday (approximately January 31, 2023)!\"  \n- Result 63 [2023-07-09]: Deborah says, \"I started a running group with Anna - it's awesome connecting with people who care about fitness!\"\n\nStep 2: Look for any mention of the place or context where Deborah met Anna.  \n- No direct mention of the exact place where Deborah met Anna is given.  \n- The only clue is that Anna is Deborah's neighbor, so presumably they met near Deborah's home or neighborhood.\n\nStep 3: No explicit location is stated in the excerpts.\n\nFinal answer: Deborah met her new neighbor Anna near her home or neighborhood, but the exact place is not specified.",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.47,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.51
    },
    {
      "question": "What activity did Jolene and her partner plan to do together instead of resuming yoga?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "play the console",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant excerpts about Jolene and her partner's plans related to yoga or other activities.\n\n- Result 3 (2023-02-01): Deborah asks Jolene if she has thought about resuming yoga.\n- Result 75 (2023-02-01): Jolene replies, \"Well... we planned to play the console with my partner.\"\n- Result 20 (2023-02-25): Deborah asks if Jolene's partner does yoga with her.\n- Result 70 (2023-02-25): Jolene says her partner started joining her sometimes for yoga.\n- Result 26 (2023-08-26): Jolene mentions sharing yoga and meditation with her partner and planning a meditation retreat together.\n- Result 1 (2023-09-08): Jolene says she and her partner plan a camping trip to connect with nature and practice yoga.\n\nStep 2: Focus on the question: What activity did Jolene and",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.0,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.65
    },
    {
      "question": "What milestone did Jolene achieve recently on 4 February, 2023?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Design and build a sustainable water purifier for a rural community",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the date and milestone reference.  \n- Result 1 (2023-02-04) Jolene to Deborah mentions a major milestone last week (around January 28, 2023) that went really well and was a huge accomplishment as an engineer.  \n- Result 66 and 67 (2023-06-06) Jolene and Deborah discuss wrapping up a tough engineering project around May 7, 2023, which is after the milestone mentioned in February.  \n\nStep 2: Understand the nature of the milestone.  \n- Result 1 and 3 indicate the milestone was a significant engineering accomplishment that boosted Jolene's confidence.  \n- Result 54 (2023-06-06) Jolene says the milestone had a positive impact on her life and stoked her love of engineering.  \n- Result 65 (2023-06-06) Deborah congratulates Jolene on wrapping up \"your with it\" (likely a typo",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.69,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.47
    },
    {
      "question": "What is Jolene's favorite book which she mentioned on 4 February, 2023?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "\"Sapiens\"",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the date and relevant messages around 4 February 2023.\n\n- On 2023-02-04, Deborah asks Jolene about her favorite book (Result 2).\n- Jolene responds with \"Sounds really hard! Here's my bookshelf!\" (Result 11) and \"That's really sweet. Such a small thing can make a real difference.\" (Result 98).\n- Deborah also comments on stories being powerful (Result 8).\n\nStep 2: Look for any mention of a specific book title or description from Jolene around that date.\n\n- There is no direct mention of a book title or a clear favorite book named by Jolene on or near 2023-02-04.\n- Jolene asks about a book she is not familiar with on 2023-03-22 (Result 14), but that is later and does not specify a favorite book from February.\n\nStep 3: Check if any other messages mention a favorite book from Jol",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.33,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.64
    },
    {
      "question": "What does Deborah bring with her whenever she comes to reflect on her mom?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "amulet",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for mentions of Deborah reflecting on her mom and what she brings with her.\n\nStep 2: In [Result 72] Deborah says: \"Do you remember this amulet from her? Whenever I come here, I bring it with me. It's how I feel her love and stay close to her. Holding it brings me comfort.\"\n\nStep 3: This clearly states Deborah brings an amulet that belonged to her mom when she comes to reflect.\n\nNo other item is mentioned as something Deborah brings consistently for reflection.\n\nFinal answer: Deborah brings an amulet that belonged to her mother with her whenever she comes to reflect on her mom.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.8,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.07
    },
    {
      "question": "What new outlook did Jolene gain after her mini retreat on 9 February, 2023?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "A confidence boost",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the date of the mini retreat and related messages.  \n- The question references a mini retreat on 9 February 2023.  \n- Result 9 (2023-02-09) Deborah asks Jolene if she gained any new insights from the retreat.  \n- Result 84 (2023-02-09) Deborah praises Jolene for stepping outside her comfort zone and asks what cool stuff she accomplished at the retreat.  \n- Result 18 (2023-02-09) Deborah says \"Let's go into more detail,\" indicating a follow-up on the retreat insights.\n\nStep 2: Look for Jolene's response about her new outlook or insights.  \n- There is no direct message from Jolene on 9 February explicitly stating her new outlook.  \n- However, Result 2 (2023-02-04) and Result 62 (2023-02-04) show earlier conversations about reflection and small things making a difference, which",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.81,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.77
    },
    {
      "question": "What cool stuff did Jolene accomplish at the retreat on 9 February, 2023?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Came up with neat solutions for her engineering project",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the date and event in question: The retreat on 9 February 2023.\n\nStep 2: Look for messages around that date mentioning the retreat and accomplishments.\n\n- Result 2 (2023-02-09): Deborah asks Jolene about cool stuff accomplished at the retreat.\n- Result 31 (2023-02-09): Jolene replies she achieved much more than imagined and it was a confidence boost.\n- Result 20 (2023-09-12): Jolene reflects on the retreat, mentioning time to reflect on happiness, importance of relaxation, self-care, balance, and inspiration from nature.\n- Result 43 (2023-02-09): Deborah asks if Jolene gained new insights from reflecting at the retreat.\n- Result 70 (2023-02-09): Deborah wants more detail.\n\nStep 3: Synthesize the accomplishments Jolene mentioned:\n\n- Achieved more than imagined.\n- Gained a real confidence boost.\n",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 4.1,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.61
    },
    {
      "question": "What idea did Jolene have to help underprivileged kids learn about STEM subjects on 9 February, 2023?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "A volunteer program where engineers teach STEM to underprivileged kids",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the date and topic in question: 9 February 2023, Jolene's idea to help underprivileged kids learn STEM.\n\nStep 2: Look for messages from or to Jolene on 9 February 2023 related to STEM and helping kids.\n\nStep 3: Result 1 [2023-02-09T21:06:00] shows Jolene saying: \"Green tech could really make a difference in disadvantaged areas... a volunteer program where engineers teach STEM to underprivileged kids.\"\n\nStep 4: Result 6 [2023-02-09T21:07:00] Jolene adds: \"Haven't finished planning yet but I'm thinking of teaming up with local schools/centers to do workshops. We could even invite engineers as guest speakers to show kids their career options.\"\n\nStep 5: Result 3 and 35 show Deborah's positive responses and questions about plans and outreach.\n\nFinal answer:  \nOn ",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.85,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.39
    },
    {
      "question": "How does Jolene plan to involve local engineers in her idea of teaching STEM to underprivileged kids?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "As guest speakers for workshops",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Jolene initially proposed a volunteer program where engineers teach STEM to underprivileged kids (Result 1).\n\nStep 2: She planned to team up with local schools and centers to conduct workshops (Result 2).\n\nStep 3: Jolene suggested inviting engineers as guest speakers to show kids their career options (Result 2).\n\nStep 4: Deborah acknowledged that having guest speakers would give kids a real-world view and asked if Jolene had reached out to schools yet (Result 20).\n\nStep 5: Jolene replied she had not reached out yet but wanted to solidify the plan first (Result 30).\n\nFinal answer:  \nJolene plans to involve local engineers by inviting them as guest speakers in workshops held at local schools and centers, providing underprivileged kids with exposure to engineering careers.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.16,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.36
    },
    {
      "question": "What gave Deborah peace in the garden she visited?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Roses and dahlias",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Deborah visiting a garden or similar place for peace.\n\n- Result 17 (2023-02-22): Deborah mentions roses and dahlias bring her peace and that she has been spending time in the garden to find comfort after losing a friend.\n- Result 48 (2023-02-04): Deborah says a friend gave her a bouquet when she was struggling, which gives her hope and courage.\n- Result 6 and 7 (2023-08-21): Deborah talks about bringing flowers to a place and her mom loving flowers, appreciating simple things.\n- Result 41 (2023-04-09): Deborah finds peace in artwork that reminds her of her mom.\n- Result 72 (2023-08-19): Deborah finds peace and gratitude sitting at a spot by a window in her mom's old home.\n\nStep 2: Focus on the garden specifically.\n\n- Result 17 is the clearest about the garden: Deborah finds",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.94,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.95
    },
    {
      "question": "Why did Deborah spend time in the garden?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "to find comfort after losing a friend",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for mentions of Deborah spending time in the garden.  \nStep 2: Result 51 states Deborah said: \"The roses and dahlias bring me peace. I lost a friend last week (approximately February 15, 2023), so I've been spending time in the garden to find some comfort.\"  \nStep 3: This clearly explains the reason Deborah spent time in the garden was to find comfort after losing a friend recently.\n\nFinal answer: Deborah spent time in the garden to find comfort after losing a friend around February 15, 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.89,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.39
    },
    {
      "question": "How did Jolene and her partner initially meet?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "In an engineering class in college",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for any direct mentions of how Jolene and her partner met.  \nStep 2: Result 40 states: \"We actually met in an engineering class in college and quickly became friends. It eventually blossomed into something more and it's been great!\" This is a direct answer from Jolene to Deborah.  \nStep 3: No other excerpts contradict or provide a different story about their initial meeting.\n\nFinal answer: Jolene and her partner initially met in an engineering class in college, where they quickly became friends before their relationship blossomed into something more.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.8,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.23
    },
    {
      "question": "What activity does Deborah incorporate into her daily routine after going for a morning jog in the park?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "spending time with loved ones",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify when Deborah first mentions going for a morning jog in the park.  \n- In Result 2 (2023-02-25), Deborah says she went for a morning jog for the first time in a nearby park yesterday (around Feb 24, 2023) and will now incorporate this into her daily routine.\n\nStep 2: Determine what activity she incorporates into her daily routine after that jog.  \n- She explicitly states she will incorporate the morning jog into her daily routine.\n\nStep 3: Confirm if any other activities are mentioned as part of her daily routine.  \n- In Result 2, Deborah also mentions meditating, doing yoga, and teaching classes in the morning, but the jog is newly added.\n\nFinal answer: Deborah incorporates a morning jog in the park into her daily routine after trying it for the first time.",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.57,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.44
    },
    {
      "question": "According to Jolene, what does exercise help her to feel?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "connected to her body",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify all mentions of exercise and Jolene's feelings about it.\n\n- Result 4 (2023-09-08): Jolene says self-care activities like yoga and meditation help her stay balanced and relax.\n- Result 12 (2023-06-06): Jolene says yoga and meditation have helped her with stress and kept her centered.\n- Result 13 (2023-08-26): Jolene says it helps with challenges, giving balance and strength.\n- Result 22 (2023-08-30): Jolene says it helps her make sense of everything and relieves stress, like a restart.\n- Result 31 (2023-09-06): Jolene says taking beach walks relaxes her.\n- Result 39 (2023-08-21): Jolene says she's been doing it for 3 years and it's a great way to escape studying and work stress.\n- Result 57 (2023-09-03): Jol",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        true,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.0,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.81
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Deb share a photo of, which brought a smile to Jolene's face?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "a yellow coffee cup with a handwritten message",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Deborah sharing a photo that brought a smile to Jolene.\n\n- Result 14 [2023-03-02T19:29:00] Deborah to Jolene: \"Thanks, Jolene! Glad I could bring a smile to your face. Take care and make sure to give yourself some time to relax. Bye!\"\n\nStep 2: Look for what photo Deborah shared before this message.\n\n- Result 12 [2023-02-22T16:15:30] Deborah to Jolene: \"Memories keep our loved ones close. This is the last photo with Karlie which was taken last summer when we hiked. It was our last one. We had such a great time! Every time I see it, I can't help but smile.\"\n\nStep 3: Connect the two: Deborah shared a photo of her last photo with Karlie from a hike last summer, which brought a smile to Jolene.\n\nFinal answer:  \nDeb",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.98,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.37
    },
    {
      "question": "What is one of Jolene's favorite dishes?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "lasagna",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify any mentions of Jolene's favorite dishes in the context.  \nStep 2: In Result 2, Jolene says to Deborah: \"One of my favorite dishes is lasagna!\"  \nStep 3: No other favorite dishes of Jolene are mentioned explicitly.\n\nFinal answer: One of Jolene's favorite dishes is lasagna.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.3,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.05
    },
    {
      "question": "What picture did Jolene share related to feeling overwhelmed?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "a photo of a desk with a notebook and a computer monitor",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Jolene feeling overwhelmed.  \n- Result 17 (2023-03-02): Jolene says, \"Exams and deadlines got me feeling overwhelmed. Just look at my to-do list! It seems never-ending...\"  \n- Result 34 (2023-08-30): Jolene asks Deborah, \"What was it like?\" in response to a photo Deborah shared.  \n- Result 69 (2023-03-02): Jolene says, \"I did take Seraphim to the park last Sunday. She loved it and here's a pic.\"  \n- Result 66 (2023-02-25): Jolene mentions, \"He started joining me sometimes, which is nice for bonding and relaxing. It's brought us closer. This is just our random photo.\"  \n- Result 17 specifically mentions a to-do list photo related to feeling overwhelmed.\n\nStep 2: Confirm which picture Jolene shared related to feeling overwhelmed.  \n-",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.0,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.57
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Jolene and Deb discuss as a helpful strategy for studying and time management?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "breaking tasks into smaller pieces and setting goals, using planners or schedulers",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of studying and time management strategies in the excerpts.\n\n- Result 1 (2023-03-02): Jolene asks Deborah for tips on studying or time management.\n- Result 8 (2023-03-02): Deborah suggests breaking tasks into smaller pieces, setting goals, and using planners or schedulers.\n- Result 16 & 21 & 60 (2023-03-22): Deborah talks about a method to prioritize tasks based on importance and urgency, asking if Jolene knows about it.\n- Result 25 (2023-03-22): Jolene shows interest in learning more about that method.\n- Result 90 (2023-03-22): Jolene mentions using the Pomodoro Technique (25 minutes work, 5-minute break) but still struggles with prioritizing.\n- Result 94 (2023-03-22): Deborah shares that she creates a daily schedule or to-do list as an example.\n- Result",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.84,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.48
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Jolene ask Deb to help with on 13 March, 2023?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "time management",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify messages from 13 March 2023 involving Jolene asking Deborah for help.\n\n- Result 27 [2023-03-13T11:28:00] Deborah to Jolene: \"What's up? I'm listening. We'll figure it out.\"\n- Result 41 [2023-03-13T11:23:30] Jolene to Deborah: \"Congrats. How did you do this?\"\n- Result 25 [2023-03-13T11:29:00] Deborah to Jolene: \"Sure, Jolene. Let's find a time that works for both of us.\"\n- Result 48 [2023-03-13T11:25:30] Jolene to Deborah: \"Wow, Deb! It's awesome when we can share something we love and make things better for others.\"\n- Result 82 [2023-03-13T11:26:30] Jolene to Deborah: \"That's really motivating.",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.99,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.53
    },
    {
      "question": "What method does Deb suggest Jolene to try for organizing tasks based on importance and urgency?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "The Eisenhower Matrix",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify where Deborah suggests a method for organizing tasks by importance and urgency.  \n- Result 1 (2023-03-22): Deborah mentions a method to figure out what's important and urgent.  \n- Result 7 (2023-03-22): Deborah offers to explain the method that helps organize tasks by importance and urgency.  \n- Result 12 (2023-03-22): Deborah explicitly names the method as the Eisenhower Matrix, which sorts tasks into four boxes based on urgency and importance.\n\nStep 2: Confirm Jolene's interest in the method.  \n- Result 38 (2023-03-22): Jolene asks Deborah to tell her more about it, indicating interest.\n\nStep 3: Summarize the method Deborah suggests.  \n- The Eisenhower Matrix categorizes tasks into four quadrants based on urgency and importance, helping prioritize effectively.\n\nFinal answer:  \nDeborah suggests Jolene try the Eisenhower Matrix, a method that",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.6,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.78
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Jolene and Anna discuss while watching the sunset by the sea?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "They realized they inspire each other",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant excerpt about Jolene and Anna watching the sunset by the sea.  \n- Result 1 (2023-03-22) Deborah to Jolene mentions: \"Recently (approximately March 15, 2023), Anna and I were sitting by the sea, watching the sunset and talking about each other. And we realized that we inspire each other.\"\n\nStep 2: Extract what they discussed.  \n- They talked about each other and realized they inspire each other.\n\nNo other excerpts provide additional details about their conversation during the sunset.\n\nFinal answer:  \nJolene and Anna discussed each other and realized that they inspire each other while watching the sunset by the sea.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.31,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.94
    },
    {
      "question": "How does Jolene plan to pursue her dream of learning to surf?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "gathering information, watching videos, getting a beginners' guide",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Jolene expresses interest in learning to surf and is thinking about when she can find spare time for it (Result 2).\n\nStep 2: She has been gathering information, watching videos, and even got a beginners' guide to surfing (Result 3).\n\nStep 3: Jolene mentions she just needs to find the right time and place to get a lesson (Result 3).\n\nStep 4: Later, she says she has just started learning but hasn't gone surfing yet and invites Deborah to come with her sometime (Result 80).\n\nFinal answer:  \nJolene plans to pursue her dream of learning to surf by gathering information and resources like beginner guides and videos, then finding the right time and place to take a lesson; she has just started learning and hopes to go surfing soon, inviting Deborah to join her.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.81,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.64
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Deborah buy to enhance her yoga practice besides the props?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "candle",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Deborah buying items for yoga practice.\n- Result 10 (2023-03-28): Deborah mentions buying new props for the yoga class.\n- Result 97 (2023-03-28): Deborah mentions buying a candle to improve her yoga practice atmosphere.\n\nStep 2: Confirm the item besides props.\n- Props are one item.\n- Candle is another item Deborah bought to enhance her yoga practice.\n\nFinal answer:  \nDeborah bought a candle to enhance her yoga practice atmosphere besides the props.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.47,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.82
    },
    {
      "question": "What type of music does Deborah find helpful during her yoga practice?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "instrumental tracks with mellow melodies and rhythms",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of music Deborah likes for yoga or meditation.\n\n- Result 22 (2023-03-28): Deborah says she finds instrumental tracks with mellow melodies and rhythms helpful for creating a peaceful vibe. She mentions a favorite track called \"Savana.\"\n- Result 40 (2023-03-28): Deborah mentions listening to an album called \"Sleep,\" which is great for meditation and deep relaxation.\n- Result 31 (2023-09-20): Deborah talks about music at a festival being magical and freeing, but this is more about a social event than yoga practice.\n- Result 53 (2023-03-28): Deborah likes scents but also mentions calming rituals, no direct music mention here.\n- Result 89 (2023-03-28): Jolene mentions liking Nils Frahm and Olafur Arnalds, asking Deborah for similar recommendations. Deborah does not directly respond here, but from Result 22 and 40, we know",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.77,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.47
    },
    {
      "question": "Who are the musicians mentioned by Jolene that she enjoys listening to during her yoga practice?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Nils Frahm and Olafur Arnalds",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify messages where Jolene mentions musicians she likes for yoga practice.\n\nStep 2: In Result 68 [2023-03-28T16:07:00], Jolene says: \"I love listening to Nils Frahm and Olafur Arnalds during my practice.\"\n\nStep 3: No other musicians are mentioned by Jolene in the context.\n\nFinal answer: Jolene enjoys listening to Nils Frahm and Olafur Arnalds during her yoga practice.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.05,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.56
    },
    {
      "question": "What album does Deborah recommend for meditation and deep relaxation?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "'Sleep'",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify any mentions of albums recommended by Deborah for meditation and relaxation.\nStep 2: In Result 1 (2023-03-28), Deborah says: \"I'm listening to an album called 'Sleep,' which is great for meditation and deep relaxation.\"\nStep 3: No other albums are mentioned by Deborah as recommendations for meditation and deep relaxation.\n\nFinal answer: Deborah recommends the album called \"Sleep\" for meditation and deep relaxation.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.97,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.85
    },
    {
      "question": "Which show did Deborah go to with a friend on 9 April, 2023?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "an art show",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify any mention of a show or event around 9 April 2023 in the context.\n\nStep 2: Check messages dated near 9 April 2023 for relevant details.\n\n- Result 14 [2023-04-09T16:36:30] Jolene to Deborah: Take care!\n- Result 27 [2023-04-09T16:33:30] Jolene to Deborah: It brings us closer together!\n- Result 76 [2023-03-28T16:09:30] Deborah to Jolene: Take care and keep up the good work!\n\nNo direct mention of a show on 9 April 2023.\n\nStep 3: Look for any mention of shows or events Deborah attended with a friend.\n\n- Result 79 [2023-01-27T10:03:30] Jolene to Deborah: We are planning to play \"Walking Dead\" next Saturday.\n\nThis suggests a plan to",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.02,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.5
    },
    {
      "question": "What does Deborah find comforting about going to art shows?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "It makes her feel like she's still experiencing it with her mom",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Deborah mentions her mom was interested in art and believed it could connect people emotionally (Result 1).\n\nStep 2: Deborah says that when she goes to an art show, it feels like they are still experiencing it together even though her mom is gone, which is hard but comforting (Result 1).\n\nStep 3: She also finds peace in keeping her mom\u2019s memory alive through art, as it brings back powerful emotions and reminds her of her mom (Result 2).\n\nStep 4: Deborah notes that this kind of comfort is helpful when times get tough (Result 35).\n\nFinal answer: Deborah finds going to art shows comforting because it allows her to feel connected to her late mother by experiencing art together in spirit, which brings her peace and helps keep her mother\u2019s memory alive.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.18,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.7
    },
    {
      "question": "How does Jolene describe the time spent with her snakes and partner?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Valuable and relaxing",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Jolene describing time with her snakes and partner.\n\n- Result 1 (2023-08-26): Jolene says her snakes bring a sense of calm and are great company.\n- Result 6 (2023-01-27): Jolene says snakes always calm her down and make her happy.\n- Result 31 (2023-04-09): Jolene says even though snakes can't chat or understand, time together is valuable and teaches her to be in tune with herself. She also mentions playing video games with her partner after a long day is a great way to relax.\n- Result 2 (2023-07-09): Jolene recalls a \"snake adventure\" where she searched for her escaped snake and felt love and relief when she found her.\n- Result 63 (2023-06-26): Jolene says she got her snake last year, and spending time with her is comforting and brings peace.\n- Result 3",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.84,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.07
    },
    {
      "question": "What does Jolene enjoy doing with her partner after a long day?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Playing video games",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Jolene's activities with her partner.\n- Result 22 (2023-02-01): Jolene says, \"Well... we planned to play the console with my partner.\"\n- Result 60 (2023-04-09): Jolene says, \"Similarly, playing video games with my partner after a long day is a great way for me to relax.\"\n- Result 46 (2023-07-09): Jolene says, \"Yeah, we love playing 'It takes two' together! It's a fun team-strategy game and it's competitive. Plus, it's a great way for us to bond.\"\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.\nJolene enjoys playing video games, specifically the console game \"It takes two,\" with her partner after a long day as a way to relax and bond.\n\nFinal answer:  \nJolene enjoys playing video games, especially the team-strategy game \"It takes two,\" with her partner",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.94,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.7
    },
    {
      "question": "What is Jolene currently doing in June 2023?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "interning at a well-known engineering firm",
      "generated_answer": "Step-by-step reasoning:\n\n1. Look for messages around June 2023 to see what Jolene is doing.\n2. Result 29 (2023-06-26) mentions Jolene got a pet last year (June 2022) and that the pet cheers her up and brings peace.\n3. Result 63 (2023-06-26) shows Jolene saying things have been intense lately, she is pushing herself to succeed, sometimes overwhelmed but determined to overcome obstacles and achieve goals.\n4. Result 34 (2023-06-26) Jolene tells Deborah she had a big breakthrough with a project, which was exciting and rewarding.\n5. Result 23 and 39 (2023-06-26) show Jolene and Deborah exchanging quick messages, indicating ongoing communication.\n6. Result 15 (2023-06-26) Deborah congratulates Jolene on her project working out.\n7. Result 27 (2023-06-06)",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.88,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.28
    },
    {
      "question": "For how long has Jolene had Seraphim as a pet?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "one year",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Seraphim and when Jolene got her.\n\n- Result 3 (2023-06-26): Jolene says she got Seraphim last year, approximately June 26, 2022.\n- Result 13 (2023-08-01): Jolene says she adopted \"her\" two years ago, approximately August 1, 2021, but this likely refers to a different pet (possibly Susie).\n- Result 26 (2023-09-15): Jolene says she has had Susie for two years now, so Susie is different from Seraphim.\n- Result 9 (2023-01-27): Jolene refers to Seraphim as her second snake, indicating Seraphim is a snake.\n- Result 7 (2023-06-26): Jolene mentions new photos of Seraphim in a new aquarium bought around June 25, 2023.\n\nStep 2",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.46,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.55
    },
    {
      "question": "How does Jolene feel when spending time with Seraphim?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "comforted",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Jolene's feelings about Seraphim.\n- Result 17 (2023-07-09): Jolene says seeing Seraphim snuggled under the bed made her feel \"so much love and gratitude\" and realize how important Seraphim is to her.\n- Result 37 (2023-08-26): Jolene says her snakes like watching her chill, and Seraphim is \"great company\" and \"always brings a sense of calm.\"\n- Result 64 (2023-06-26): Jolene says she got Seraphim last year and that Seraphim \"always cheers me up and brings a sense of peace\" and that spending time with her is \"so comforting.\"\n- Result 53 (2023-06-26): Jolene shares photos of Seraphim in a new aquarium, indicating care and attention.\n- Result 44 (2023-01-27): Jolene describes a funny moment",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.98,
      "judge_latency_s": 4.43
    },
    {
      "question": "Which new yoga pose did Deborah share a photo of?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "tree pose",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Deborah sharing photos of new yoga poses.\n- Result 1 (2023-06-26): Deborah mentions a new yoga pose called \"tree pose\" and sharing a photo.\n- Result 17 (2023-06-26): Deborah mentions trying a new pose called \"Dancer Pose (Natarajasana)\" and asks for a rating.\n\nStep 2: Check if Deborah shared photos of these poses.\n- Result 1 explicitly says \"I'd rather show you a photo. This is also a new yoga pose that we tried. It is a tree pose.\"\n- Result 17 mentions the Dancer Pose but does not explicitly say a photo was shared.\n\nStep 3: Since the question asks which new yoga pose Deborah shared a photo of, the clearest evidence is from Result 1, where Deborah says she would rather show a photo of the tree pose.\n\nFinal answer: Deborah shared a photo of the new yoga pose called the tree pose.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.99,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.53
    },
    {
      "question": "What group activity did Deborah start with Anna?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "running group",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for mentions of Deborah and Anna doing something together.\nStep 2: In Result 2 (2023-07-09), Deborah says: \"I started a running group with Anna - it's awesome connecting with people who care about fitness!\"\nStep 3: This clearly states the group activity Deborah started with Anna.\n\nFinal answer: Deborah started a running group with Anna.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.85,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.42
    },
    {
      "question": "What made being part of the running group easy for Deborah to stay motivated?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "helping and pushing each other during runs",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify Deborah's comments about the running group and motivation.  \n- In Result 9 (2023-07-09), Deborah says: \"We help and push each other during our runs, which makes it so much easier to stay motivated.\"  \n- In Result 36 (2023-07-09), Deborah mentions running in the park every morning and evening, showing commitment.  \n- In Result 93 (2023-07-09), Deborah notes the importance of having people who cheer you on and give advice.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.  \nDeborah finds it easier to stay motivated in the running group because they help and push each other, providing mutual support and encouragement.\n\nFinal answer:  \nBeing part of the running group made it easy for Deborah to stay motivated because the members help and push each other during their runs, offering mutual support and encouragement.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.2,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.39
    },
    {
      "question": "Why did Jolene decide to get a snake as a pet?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "fascinated by reptiles and it felt like the perfect pet",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about Jolene's reason for getting a snake.\n\n- Result 2 (2023-07-09): Jolene says she was fascinated by reptiles and felt a snake was the perfect pet. She also mentions that taking care of it is calming and connects her with nature.\n- Result 14 (2023-06-26): Jolene says she got her snake last year (around June 26, 2022) and that the snake cheers her up and brings peace.\n- Result 27 (2023-08-01): Jolene says she adopted her snake two years ago (around August 1, 2021) when she was feeling lonely and wanted company.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.\n\nJolene was fascinated by reptiles, found snakes calming, and chose one as a pet to connect with nature. Additionally, she adopted her snake when feeling lonely and wanting companionship.\n\nFinal answer:  \nJolene decided to get",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 4.83,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.51
    },
    {
      "question": "What is the favorite game Jolene plays with her partner?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "It takes two",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of games Jolene plays with her partner.  \n- Result 9 (2023-07-09): Jolene says, \"Yeah, we love playing 'It takes two' together! It's a fun team-strategy game and it's competitive. Plus, it's a great way for us to bond.\"  \n- Result 52 (2023-08-19): Jolene mentions \"Overcooked 2\" as a good co-op game she plays with her partner, often for bets.  \n- Result 26 (2023-01-27): Jolene shares a photo of her and her partner gaming, playing \"Detroit\" on the console.  \n- Result 18 (2023-01-27): Jolene says they are planning to play \"Walking Dead\" next Saturday.\n\nStep 2: Determine which game is described as the favorite.  \n- In Result 9, Jolene explicitly says \"we love playing 'It takes two'",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.95,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.4
    },
    {
      "question": "What activity does Deborah do with her cats?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "take them out for a run in the park every morning and evening",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Deborah's cats and any activities related to them.  \n- Result 8: Deborah mentions Max, her mother's cat, which she took after her mother passed away.  \n- Result 37: Deborah says she has cats because she doesn't like dogs.  \n- Result 52: Deborah says she took Luna from the shelter.  \n- Result 76: Deborah says having a pet around is calming and mentions Luna sitting on the left.  \n\nStep 2: Look for any specific activities Deborah does with her cats.  \n- Result 19: Deborah describes activities she does (yoga, meditation, self-reflection) but does not explicitly link them to her cats.  \n- Result 76: Deborah says having a pet around is calming and brings comfort, implying she enjoys their company during calm moments.  \n- No direct mention of playing or other active engagement with cats is found.  \n\nStep 3: Synthesize the information.  \nDeborah finds comfort and",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 4.67,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.47
    },
    {
      "question": "How does Jolene describe the feeling of finding her snake snuggled under the bed after it got out?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "It really showed how much she loves her.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about the snake getting out and being found.\n\n- Result 1 (2023-07-09): Jolene mentions the \"snake adventure\" where her snake got out and she spent hours searching, feeling relieved when she found her snuggling under the bed.\n- Result 4 (2023-07-09): Jolene says seeing the snake snuggled under the bed made her feel \"so much love and gratitude\" and realize how important the snake is to her.\n- Result 12 (2023-07-09): Deborah asks what it was like when Jolene found her, imagining the relief.\n- Result 1 and 4 together show Jolene's feelings of relief, love, and gratitude upon finding the snake.\n\nStep 2: Summarize Jolene's description of the feeling.\n\nJolene describes feeling relieved, full of love, and gratitude when she found her snake snuggled under the bed after it got out.\n\n",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.56,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.25
    },
    {
      "question": "Why does Deborah take her cats out for a run in the park every day?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Exercise and nature are important to her",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about Deborah taking her cats out for a run.\n- Result 5 [2023-07-09]: Deborah says, \"Exercise and nature are really important to me, so I make sure to take them out for a run in the park every morning and evening.\"\n- Result 56 [2023-07-09]: Jolene asks how often Deborah takes them out, implying it is a regular activity.\n\nStep 2: Understand Deborah's motivation.\n- Deborah explicitly states that exercise and nature are very important to her.\n- Taking the cats out for a run aligns with her values of exercise and being in nature.\n\nStep 3: No other reasons are given for this activity.\n\nFinal answer: Deborah takes her cats out for a run in the park every day because exercise and nature are very important to her.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.57,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.49
    },
    {
      "question": "How did Jolene come to have her pet, Susie?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "She adopted her two years ago when feeling lonely.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Susie and how Jolene got her.  \n- Result 3: Jolene says she has had Susie for two years as of 2023-09-15, implying she got Susie around 2021.  \n- Result 12: Jolene says she adopted Susie two years ago (around August 1, 2021) when she was feeling lonely and wanted some company.  \n- Result 11: Jolene says she got \"her\" last year (around June 26, 2022), but this conflicts with the two-year timeline; likely this refers to a different pet or is an approximation.  \n- Result 8: Jolene mentions Susie helps when times get tough and that pets have been great company.  \n- Result 9 and 16: Jolene shares a story about Susie escaping and being found under the bed, showing her affection.  \n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.  \n",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.49,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.85
    },
    {
      "question": "What activities have been helping Jolene stay distracted during tough times?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Video games and spending time with her pet, Susie",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of activities Jolene uses to stay distracted or cope during tough times.\n\n- Result 30 (2023-08-01): Jolene mentions pets and video games as a nice distraction.\n- Result 18 (2023-02-25): Jolene uses breathing and meditation to feel calmer and clearer.\n- Result 8 (2023-06-06): Jolene says yoga and meditation have helped her with stress and kept her centered.\n- Result 44 (2023-09-03): Jolene says \"It's my way to de-stress and take a break from life,\" referring to an activity (likely meditation or yoga).\n- Result 17 (2023-08-21): Jolene has been doing \"it\" for 3 years as a way to escape studying and work stress (likely yoga/meditation).\n- Result 65 (2023-07-09): Jolene recalls a memory involving her pet snake, showing emotional",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.56,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.36
    },
    {
      "question": "What kind of yoga routine does Deborah recommend to Jolene?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "A gentle flow routine focused on breathing and grounding",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify messages where Deborah recommends or describes yoga routines to Jolene.\n\n- Result 18 [2023-08-01]: Deborah says, \"One of my favorite yoga routines is a gentle flow that's all about breathing and grounding. It helps me find my chill. I'll send you a tutorial video with the poses.\"\n\n- Result 39 [2023-08-01]: Deborah offers to suggest some routines to Jolene.\n\nStep 2: Confirm the nature of the recommended routine.\n\n- The routine Deborah mentions is a \"gentle flow\" focusing on \"breathing and grounding,\" aimed at helping find calmness (\"find my chill\").\n\nStep 3: Check if there are other mentions of specific routines Deborah recommends.\n\n- No other specific routine recommendations from Deborah to Jolene are found.\n\nFinal answer: Deborah recommends a gentle flow yoga routine focused on breathing and grounding to help find calm and relaxation.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.31,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.7
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Jolene design inspired by their love for space and engines?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Notebooks",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant excerpt about Jolene's design inspired by space and engines.  \n- Result 72 [2023-08-12T20:52:30] Jolene to Deborah: \"Thanks, Deb! I was inspired by my love for space and engines, so I designed these notebooks with elements like galaxies and circuitry. I think they turned out really cool!\"\n\nStep 2: Extract the specific item designed by Jolene.  \n- Jolene designed notebooks.\n\nStep 3: Note the inspiration and design elements.  \n- Inspired by love for space and engines.  \n- Design elements include galaxies and circuitry.\n\nFinal answer:  \nJolene designed notebooks inspired by their love for space and engines, featuring elements like galaxies and circuitry.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.51,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.35
    },
    {
      "question": "What journal has Jolene been using to help track tasks and stay organized?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "bullet journal",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Jolene using a journal for organization.\n- Result 1 (2023-08-16): Jolene says she started using a bullet journal around August 9, 2023, which has been helpful for tracking tasks and staying organized.\n\nStep 2: Confirm no other journal types are mentioned.\n- No other journal types or names appear in the context.\n\nFinal answer:  \nJolene has been using a bullet journal to help track tasks and stay organized.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.85,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.36
    },
    {
      "question": "What game did Jolene recommend for being calming and cute?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Animal Crossing: New Horizons",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify where Jolene talks about game recommendations related to calming and cute qualities.  \nStep 2: In [Result 42], Jolene says: \"I have a few game recommendations. Zelda BOTW for Switch is an awesome open-world game. Animal Crossing: New Horizons is really calming and cute.\"  \nStep 3: This directly answers the question about a calming and cute game recommendation.\n\nFinal answer: Jolene recommended \"Animal Crossing: New Horizons\" as a calming and cute game.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.63,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.26
    },
    {
      "question": "What game did Jolene suggest as an awesome open-world game for the Nintendo Switch?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Zelda BOTW",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify where Jolene mentions game recommendations for the Nintendo Switch.  \nStep 2: In Result 1 (2023-08-19), Jolene says: \"Zelda BOTW for Switch is an awesome open-world game.\"  \nStep 3: This directly answers the question about an awesome open-world game for the Switch suggested by Jolene.\n\nFinal answer: Jolene suggested \"Zelda BOTW\" (The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild) as an awesome open-world game for the Nintendo Switch.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.13,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.62
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Deborah and her husband use to play to bond and make memories?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "video games",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant excerpt about Deborah and her husband playing together.  \n- Result 54 [2023-08-19T00:57:00] Deborah to Jolene: \"Reminds me of when I used to play games with my husband. We'd take turns and it was a great way to bond and make memories. Gaming really can bring people closer, right?\"\n\nStep 2: Analyze the content.  \n- Deborah mentions \"playing games\" with her husband as a bonding activity.\n\nStep 3: Confirm no other specific games or activities are mentioned.  \n- No other excerpts specify the exact type of games.\n\nFinal answer:  \nDeborah and her husband used to play games together, taking turns, to bond and make memories.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.24,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.28
    },
    {
      "question": "What is special about the bench at the park near Deborah's house?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "It holds special memories of conversations with her mom",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Deborah mentions a park near her house with a special bench where she does yoga and reflects (Result 1).\n\nStep 2: Deborah connects this bench to her mom's house, where there was a special bench near the window that her mom loved to sit at every morning (Results 2, 4, 7).\n\nStep 3: Deborah says sitting at the bench in the park helps her feel connected to her mom, who passed away a few years ago, and it comforts her (Results 2, 4, 7).\n\nStep 4: Jolene acknowledges the bench holds sentimental value and asks about memories, to which Deborah replies it brings back fond memories and peace (Results 8, 23).\n\nStep 5: Deborah also mentions that the bench and the spot in the park are peaceful and ideal for reflection and letting go (Results 1, 33, 79).\n\nFinal answer:  \nThe bench at the park near Deborah's house is special",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.28,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.45
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Deborah and her mom chat about at their special bench in the park?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "dreams and life",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of the special bench and what Deborah and her mom did there.\n\n- Result 1: Deborah mentions a special bench near the window at her mom's house, but this is not the park bench.\n- Result 11: Deborah talks about a special bench in a park near her house where she does yoga and reflects.\n- Result 17: Deborah says the bench holds special memories where she and her mom would come and chat about dreams and life.\n- Result 75: Deborah recalls watching a beautiful sunset with her mom at this spot and feeling peace and gratitude.\n- Result 67: Deborah mentions sitting on a bench where they used to chat and it brought back emotions.\n- Result 16: Deborah feels her mom's presence when sitting there, which comforts her.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.\n\nDeborah and her mom used to sit on the special bench in the park and chat about dreams and life, sharing meaningful conversations that left lasting memories for Deborah",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.81,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.44
    },
    {
      "question": "What feeling does Deborah get when she thinks about the time spent with her mom at their special spot?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "peace and gratitude",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify references to Deborah's feelings about the special spot with her mom.\n\n- Result 6 (2023-01-27): Deborah says, \"I can feel her presence when I sit there and it comforts me.\"\n- Result 23 (2023-08-19): Deborah says, \"Every time I go back, I feel so much peace and gratitude for the time I spent with her.\"\n- Result 41 (2023-01-27): Deborah says, \"Sitting in that spot by the window gives me peace.\"\n- Result 39 (2023-08-19): Deborah says the spot \"holds a lot of special memories\" and is \"full of good moments.\"\n- Result 25 (2023-08-30): Deborah says the spot's \"soothing vibes and nice views made it ideal for reflecting and letting go.\"\n- Result 34 (2023-08-30): Deborah says, \"It brought back fond memories as",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.73,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.51
    },
    {
      "question": "What habits does Jolene practice to feel balanced?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "yoga, meditation, walks, and mindfulness",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of habits Jolene practices for balance.\n- Result 1: Jolene mentions having a routine with schedule for classes, studying, personal time, and self-care activities like yoga and meditation.\n- Result 3: Jolene and Deborah both mention yoga and meditation help find balance and inner peace.\n- Result 8: Jolene prioritizes self-care like yoga and meditation to stay balanced and grounded.\n- Result 9: Jolene tries to do more yoga and meditation to relax and stay focused.\n- Result 11: At a retreat, Jolene reflected on importance of relaxation, self-care, and balance alongside studies.\n- Result 12: Yoga and meditation help Jolene with stress and keep her centered.\n- Result 19: Jolene takes breaks, does breathing exercises or meditation to feel calmer and clearer.\n- Result 26: Jolene relaxes in her room, her haven for peace and rest.\n- Result 37: Meditation helps Jolene make",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.38,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.57
    },
    {
      "question": "Which yoga pose is Jolene a fan of for rest and calmness?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "savasana (the corpse pose)",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Jolene's favorite or preferred yoga poses related to rest and calmness.\n\nStep 2: In Result 23 (2023-08-21), Jolene says: \"I'm a fan of savasana - aka the corpse pose. It's so calming and helps me just let go and surrender.\"\n\nStep 3: This is a direct statement from Jolene about a yoga pose she favors for rest and calmness.\n\nFinal answer: Jolene is a fan of savasana (the corpse pose) for rest and calmness.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.48,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.54
    },
    {
      "question": "How long has Jolene been doing yoga?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "3 years",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify direct mentions of how long Jolene has been doing yoga.\n\n- In [Result 29] (2023-08-21), Jolene says: \"Been doing it for 3 years.\"\n- In [Result 97] (2023-06-06), Jolene says: \"I've been doing them sporadically for about 3 years now.\"\n\nStep 2: Confirm no contradictory information.\n\n- No other messages contradict this duration.\n\nStep 3: Synthesize the information.\n\n- Jolene has been practicing yoga for about 3 years as of mid-2023.\n\nFinal answer: Jolene has been doing yoga for about 3 years.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.97,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.55
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Jolene participate in recently that provided her with a rewarding experience?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "presenting at a virtual conference",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Jolene participating in something recently that was rewarding.\n\n- Result 9 (2023-02-09): Jolene says she achieved more than imagined and it was a confidence boost.\n- Result 12 (2023-09-12): Jolene talks about a retreat where she learned to release expectations and savor the present.\n- Result 27 (2023-09-12): Jolene reflects on the retreat, mentioning relaxation, self-care, balance, and inspiration from nature.\n- Result 50 (2023-02-09): Deborah asks Jolene what cool stuff she accomplished at the retreat.\n- Result 65 (2023-09-12): Jolene says she is experiencing a new level of joy and happiness.\n- Result 48 (2023-08-24): Deborah asks Jolene about what she has achieved.\n- Result 14 (2023-08-24): Deborah congratulates Jolene on her achievements.\n-",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.85,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.82
    },
    {
      "question": "How did Jolene feel after receiving positive feedback at the virtual conference?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "thrilled and rewarded",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant excerpt about the virtual conference and feedback.  \n- Result 1 (2023-08-24): Jolene mentions presenting at a virtual conference around August 17, 2023, and receiving positive feedback.  \n- Result 3 (2023-02-09): Jolene says she achieved more than imagined and it was a confidence boost, which likely relates to positive feedback or success.  \n- Result 2 and 31 show Deborah's reactions to Jolene's success and feedback.  \n- Result 60 (2023-02-09) Deborah encourages Jolene for stepping outside her comfort zone and asks about accomplishments at the retreat, which is related but not the conference.  \n\nStep 2: Focus on Jolene's feelings after the positive feedback.  \n- Result 1: Jolene says the experience was great and confirmed she is on the right track.  \n- Result 3: She says it was a real confidence boost.  \n\n",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.68,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.58
    },
    {
      "question": "What kind of event did Jolene present at recently?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "virtual conference",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Jolene presenting or achieving something recently.\n- Result 23 (2023-08-24): Deborah praises Jolene's achievement and offers help.\n- Result 24 & 27 (2023-07-09): Jolene and Deborah discuss workshops and events Deborah is involved in, but not Jolene presenting.\n- Result 37 (2023-03-13): Jolene congratulates Deborah on something.\n- Result 80 (2023-08-24): Deborah asks Jolene about what she achieved.\n- Result 88 (2023-09-12): Jolene mentions experiencing a new level of joy and happiness.\n- Result 55 (2023-09-03): Deborah mentions attending a cool event last week (around August 27, 2023) to support each other, inspiring.\n- Result 61 (2023-07-09): Deborah talks about workshops and events she is part of.\n- Result 82",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.02,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.51
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Jolene's mom stress the value of, which she wants to keep in mind for her engineering projects?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Helping others",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify where Jolene talks about her mom's values related to her engineering projects.  \nStep 2: In [Result 1] (2023-08-26), Jolene says: \"Going further, my mom stressed the value of helping others and that's something I want to keep in mind for my engineering projects.\"\n\nFinal answer: Jolene's mom stressed the value of helping others, which Jolene wants to keep in mind for her engineering projects.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.57,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.59
    },
    {
      "question": "What type of projects is Jolene interested in getting involved in the future?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Sustainable initiatives and developing innovative solutions for environmental issues",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about Jolene's future project interests.\n\n- Result 11 (2023-08-26): Jolene wants to work on projects that make a real difference to communities, focusing on sustainable initiatives and innovative solutions for environmental issues, and social causes.\n- Result 10 (2023-08-26): Jolene is keen on two projects, one focused on developing renewable energy like solar to help communities and reduce dependence on non-renewables.\n- Result 33 (2023-02-04): Jolene wants to keep working in engineering to make a positive impact on communities by creating sustainable solutions.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.\n\nJolene is interested in future projects that involve sustainable and renewable energy solutions, environmental innovation, and social causes that positively impact communities.\n\nFinal answer:  \nJolene is interested in future projects focused on sustainable initiatives, renewable energy development (such as solar), and innovative solutions addressing environmental and social causes to make",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.21,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.84
    },
    {
      "question": "How did Deborah get Luna, one of her cats?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "From the shelter",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the question - How did Deborah get Luna, one of her cats?\n\nStep 2: Look for mentions of Deborah and Luna in the context.\n\n- Result 1: Jolene asks Deborah how she got Luna.\n- Result 2: Deborah replies she took Luna from the shelter.\n- Result 27: Deborah says Luna is 5 years old.\n- Result 7: Deborah mentions she still has cats, Luna is sitting on the left.\n- Result 6: Deborah mentions Max is her mother's cat, taken after her mother passed away, but this is about Max, not Luna.\n\nStep 3: Confirm no conflicting information about how Deborah got Luna.\n\nNo other statements contradict that Deborah took Luna from the shelter.\n\nFinal answer: Deborah got Luna by taking her from the shelter.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.76,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.45
    },
    {
      "question": "How old is Max?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "8 years old",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Max's age in the context.  \n- Result 1: Deborah says Max is already old, he is 8 years old.\n\nStep 2: Confirm no conflicting information about Max's age.  \n- No other messages contradict this.\n\nFinal answer: Max is 8 years old.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.6,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.65
    },
    {
      "question": "What type of classes did Jolene and her partner check out during their trip to Rio de Janeiro on 30 August, 2023?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Yoga classes",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the date and trip details.  \n- Result 2 states that on 2023-08-30, Jolene told Deborah they got back from a trip to Rio de Janeiro \"yesterday\" (approximately August 29, 2023).  \n- Result 2 also mentions they checked out some cool yoga classes.\n\nStep 2: Confirm the type of classes.  \n- Result 43 further supports this by mentioning Jolene said they learned about different kinds of yoga and their backgrounds during the trip.\n\nFinal answer:  \nJolene and her partner checked out yoga classes during their trip to Rio de Janeiro on August 29, 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.79,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.25
    },
    {
      "question": "What type of place does Jolene visit to meditate?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "A tranquil spot by a pond",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of where Jolene meditates.  \n- Result 1 (2023-08-30): Jolene says she goes to a nearby place to meditate by a tranquil spot.  \n- Result 9 (2023-09-06): Jolene signed up for a meditation course at a retreat near a lake.  \n- Result 29 (2023-09-12): Jolene mentions traveling to a meditation retreat in Phuket for a few weeks.  \n- Result 22 (2023-09-12): Jolene reflects on the retreat, describing it as surrounded by nature and inspiring.  \n- Result 6 (2023-09-15): Jolene says in her room she relaxes and feels at ease, but this is more about her personal space at home.  \n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.  \nJolene meditates both at a nearby tranquil spot and at a meditation retreat near a lake (specifically in Phuket",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.25,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.75
    },
    {
      "question": "What was the new plant Jolene got used as a reminder for on 30 August, 2023?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "To nurture herself and embrace fresh starts",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant date and message about the new plant from Jolene on 30 August 2023.  \n- Result 1 [2023-08-30T11:59:00] Jolene to Deborah: \"Yep, Deborah! It's about creating a good atmosphere to help us grow and improve. By the way, I have a new plant.\"  \n- Result 76 [2023-08-30T11:58:30] Deborah to Jolene: \"Surrounding ourselves with good stuff and striving to improve is key.\"  \n- Result 12 [2023-08-30T11:56:00] Jolene to Deborah: \"By the way, what did that paper have written on it in the photo?\"  \n- Result 36 [2023-02-04T10:02:00] Jolene to Deborah: \"That's really sweet. Such a small thing can make a real difference.\" (general about reminders",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.6,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.65
    },
    {
      "question": "Why did Jolene get the new plant on 30 August, 2023?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "As a reminder to nurture herself and embrace fresh starts",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the message about Jolene's new plant on 30 August 2023.  \n- Result 1 [2023-08-30T11:59:00] Jolene to Deborah: \"Yep, Deborah! It's about creating a good atmosphere to help us grow and improve. By the way, I have a new plant.\"\n\nStep 2: Understand the reason Jolene gives for getting the new plant.  \n- She says it is \"about creating a good atmosphere to help us grow and improve.\"\n\nStep 3: Check if there is any other relevant context explaining the motivation behind the new plant.  \n- Result 97 [2023-08-30T11:58:30] Deborah to Jolene: \"Surrounding ourselves with good stuff and striving to improve is key.\" This aligns with Jolene's reasoning.\n\nNo other direct explanation is given.\n\nFinal answer:  \nJolene got the new plant to create a good atmosphere that helps",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 5.19,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.8
    },
    {
      "question": "What has Jolene been focusing on lately besides studying?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "relationship with her partner",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Jolene's activities besides studying.\n- Result 19 (2023-06-06): Jolene talks about hanging out with people who love what they do, which inspires her to stay focused and work towards goals.\n- Result 44 (2023-06-06): Jolene says her internship has had a positive impact and encouraged her to keep striving for her dreams.\n- Result 45 (2023-06-06): Jolene mentions struggling to balance hobbies and chilling out while pushing herself.\n- Result 66 (2023-09-03): Jolene says her way to de-stress and take a break from life is something she does besides studying.\n- Result 35 (2023-09-12): Jolene reflects on a retreat where she focused on relaxation, self-care, and balance alongside her engineering studies.\n- Result 70 (2023-09-03): Jolene mentions having finals but also thinking about taking a",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.33,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.71
    },
    {
      "question": "How did Deborah's mom support her yoga practice when she first started?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "attended classes with her",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Deborah's mom in relation to yoga practice.  \n- Result 1: Deborah says her mum was her biggest fan and source of motivation and often came to her yoga classes with her.  \n- Result 44: Jolene mentions Deborah taught herself yoga but her dad was supportive and her mom played games with her (less directly related to yoga).  \n- Result 27 and 64: Deborah talks about a special bench at her mom's house where she feels connected to her mom, but this is more about reflection than direct yoga support.\n\nStep 2: Focus on direct support related to yoga practice.  \n- The clearest direct support is from Result 1: Deborah's mom was her biggest fan and source of motivation and attended her yoga classes.\n\nFinal answer:  \nDeborah's mom supported her yoga practice by being her biggest fan and source of motivation, often attending her yoga classes with her.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.62,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.43
    },
    {
      "question": "What was the video game console that Jolene's parents got her at age 10?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "nintendo game console",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Jolene mentions that when she was 10, her parents got her \"that\" which started her passion for video games (Result 1).\n\nStep 2: There is no direct mention of the specific console name in the excerpts.\n\nStep 3: Jolene talks about playing games like \"Monster Hunter: World\" (Result 12) and \"Detroit\" (Result 8) on a console, but these are modern games and likely not the console from when she was 10.\n\nStep 4: No explicit name or brand of the console from her childhood is given anywhere in the conversation.\n\nFinal answer: Not enough information.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.94,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.05
    },
    {
      "question": "What was one of Jolene's favorite games to play with her mom on the nintendo wii game system?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Monster Hunter: World",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Jolene's favorite games and her mom playing games with her.  \n- Result 2: Jolene says her mom would play games with her.  \n- Result 11: Jolene mentions \"Monster Hunter: World\" as one of her favorites, but this is not specified as a Wii game or played with her mom.  \n- Result 1: Deborah asks Jolene about her favorite game to play with her mom, but Jolene's direct answer is not in the excerpts.  \n- No direct mention of a specific Nintendo Wii game Jolene played with her mom is found.\n\nStep 2: Check if any Nintendo Wii game is named in the context.  \n- No Nintendo Wii game titles are explicitly mentioned in the conversation excerpts.\n\nStep 3: Confirm if any favorite game with mom on Wii is stated.  \n- There is no explicit statement of a favorite Nintendo Wii game Jolene played with her mom.\n\nFinal answer: Not enough information.",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.99,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.55
    },
    {
      "question": "What course did Jolene sign up for on 6 September 2023?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "meditation",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify any mention of a course or sign-up around 6 September 2023.\n\n- Result 7 [2023-09-17T13:36:00] Deborah to Jolene: \"Certainly! Here's the confirmation.\"\n- Result 29 [2023-09-06T20:39:30] Deborah to Jolene: \"An offer I can't refuse!\"\n- Result 44 [2023-09-06T20:36:00] Jolene to Deborah: \"What have you been doing lately?\"\n- Result 2 [2023-09-06T20:33:30] Deborah to Jolene: \"Glad to hear it, Jolene. How's the project going?\"\n\nStep 2: Look for any direct mention of a course or related confirmation.\n\n- Result 7 is a confirmation from Deborah to Jolene on 17 September 2023, likely related to something Jolene signed up for.\n- Result 34",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.47,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.4
    },
    {
      "question": "Why did Jolene have to reschedule their meeting with Deborah on September 8, 2023?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Jolene already had plans",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant date and messages about the meeting on September 8, 2023.  \n- Result 20 [2023-09-08T19:46:00] Deborah to Jolene: \"Sorry, I remembered that I already have plans for this day.\"  \n- Result 50 [2023-09-08T19:39:30] Jolene to Deborah: \"Sorry to hear about it. How are you feeling now?\"  \n- Result 57 [2023-09-08T19:45:30] Jolene to Deborah: \"Tell me more about it when we meet, maybe next time we\u2019ll be there.\"  \n- Result 80 [2023-09-08T19:46:30] Jolene to Deborah: \"Now I'll see when it's more convenient for me.\"\n\nStep 2: From Deborah's message (Result 20), she says she already has plans for that day, which implies Deborah",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.65,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.67
    },
    {
      "question": "Where did Jolene and her partner travel for a few weeks in September 2023?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Phuket",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for any mentions of travel by Jolene and her partner around September 2023.  \nStep 2: Check for any direct references to a trip or location in that timeframe.  \nStep 3: Review the context for any clues about where they went or what they did.\n\nReviewing the context:  \n- Result 30 (2023-09-06) mentions Jolene referring to a \"last beach getaway\" which was \"so chill and nice.\"  \n- Result 22 (2023-08-30) Jolene asks Deborah \"What was it like?\" possibly about a trip or experience.  \n- Result 14 (2023-07-09) Jolene says \"We'll definitely go there together sometime!\" indicating a future trip planned, not a past one.  \n- No explicit mention of a specific location or destination for a trip in September 2023 is found in the excerpts.  \n- Result 94 (2023-09-20",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.07,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.7
    },
    {
      "question": "What was the main focus of the session that stood out to Jolene during the retreat?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "releasing expectations and judgments and savoring the present",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify where Jolene talks about the session that stood out to her at the retreat.  \n- Result 11 (2023-09-12): Jolene mentions reflecting on happiness, relaxation, self-care, balance, and nature's beauty.  \n- Result 16 (2023-09-12): Jolene specifically says the session that stood out was about \"releasing expectations and judgments and just savoring the present,\" emphasizing appreciating the journey rather than just the finish line.\n\nStep 2: Confirm the main focus from the direct quote in Result 16, which is the clearest and most specific description of the session's focus.\n\nFinal answer:  \nThe main focus of the session that stood out to Jolene was about releasing expectations and judgments and savoring the present moment, reminding her to appreciate the journey rather than just the end goals.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 5.8,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.49
    },
    {
      "question": "How did Jolene feel about her progress in practicing mindfulness and gratitude?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "experiencing a new level of joy and happiness",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Jolene's feelings about mindfulness and gratitude.\n\n- Result 1 (Deborah to Jolene, 2023-09-12): Deborah praises Jolene for practicing mindfulness and gratitude, implying Jolene is engaged positively.\n- Result 7 and 9 (Deborah to Jolene, 2023-08-16): Deborah notes mindfulness is a huge part of her life and encourages Jolene, who is willing to try mindfulness.\n- Result 55 (Jolene to Deborah, 2023-09-12): Jolene says, \"I'm experiencing a new level of joy and happiness!\" which suggests positive feelings about her mindfulness journey.\n- Result 19 (Jolene to Deborah, 2023-09-12): Jolene reflects on a session about releasing expectations and savoring the present, showing insight and appreciation for mindfulness.\n- Result 6 and 16 (Jolene and Deborah, August 2023): Jol",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.24,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.43
    },
    {
      "question": "What positive change did Jolene experience during the retreat?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "finding inner peace",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about Jolene's experience at the retreat.  \n- Result 2: Jolene reflected on what makes her happy, realizing the importance of relaxation, self-care, and balance alongside her studies.  \n- Result 19: Jolene mentioned a session about releasing expectations and judgments, savoring the present, and appreciating the journey rather than just the finish line.  \n- Result 75 and 91: Deborah and Jolene discuss mindfulness and gratitude changing day-to-day life, with Jolene experiencing a new level of joy and happiness.  \n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.  \nJolene's positive change involved gaining insight into balancing life with relaxation and self-care, learning to release pressures and judgments, and developing mindfulness and gratitude that brought her greater joy and happiness.\n\nFinal answer:  \nJolene experienced a positive change of embracing relaxation, self-care, and balance, learning to release expectations and judgments, and cultivating mindfulness and gratitude, which led to",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 4.27,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.39
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Jolene recently play that she described to Deb?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "a card game about cats",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Jolene playing something recently.  \n- Result 27 (2023-01-27): Jolene says, \"We are planning to play 'Walking Dead' next Saturday.\"  \n- Result 15 (2023-07-09): Jolene talks about playing games with Deborah, describing the experience of tackling challenges and bonding.  \n- Result 4 (2023-02-01): Jolene mentions planning to play the console with her partner.  \n- Result 66 (2023-08-26): Jolene mentions her snakes watching her chill, but this is not about playing a game.  \n- Result 63 (2023-09-12): Jolene says, \"I look forward to meeting you and playing this game!\" (likely referring to a game with Deborah).  \n- Result 29 (2023-09-15): Jolene says, \"Susie is a great companion,\" which is unrelated to playing.  \n",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.65,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.47
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Deborah do with their mom's old friends?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "reminisced and looked through photos",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about Deborah and her mom's old friends.\n\n- Result 2 (2023-09-15): Deborah reconnected with her mom's old friends.\n- Result 8 (2023-09-15): Deborah describes hearing stories from her mom's friends as emotional, both happy and sad, and comforting.\n- Result 6 (2023-09-15): Deborah says it was special, giving a glimpse into her mom's life beyond what she knew, and she appreciates her more through their eyes.\n- Result 31 (2023-09-15): Deborah says they reminisced and looked through her mom's photos, describing it as really sweet.\n- Result 13 (2023-09-15): Jolene asks what they did on that day with the mom's friends, implying they spent time together.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.\n\nDeborah reconnected with her mom's old friends, spent time reminiscing, heard",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.83,
      "judge_latency_s": 3.31
    },
    {
      "question": "Where did Deborah get married?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "on the beach",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for any direct mention of Deborah's marriage or wedding location.  \n- Result 40: Jolene asks Deborah how long she has been married, implying Deborah is married.  \n- Result 39: Jolene says she is not married yet, so this is about Jolene, not Deborah.  \n- Result 47: Deborah mentions her husband and trying to be a good family like her parents.  \n- Result 52: Deborah shares a photo of her parents' wedding in 1993, but no mention of her own wedding location.  \n- Result 49: Deborah talks about her old home where her mom passed away, but no mention of marriage there.  \n- No other results mention Deborah's wedding or marriage location.\n\nStep 2: Check if there is any indirect clue about the wedding place.  \n- No mention of a wedding venue, city, or place related to Deborah's marriage in any excerpt.  \n- The conversation focuses more on family memories,",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.64,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.61
    },
    {
      "question": "What does yoga on the beach provide for Deborah?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "a peaceful atmosphere",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of yoga on the beach related to Deborah.\n\n- Result 17 (2023-09-15): Deborah says, \"Oh yeah! Doing this on the beach is so peaceful - the ocean, sand, and fresh air create a super relaxing atmosphere. The perfect way to take care of myself.\"\n- Result 40 (2023-09-15): Deborah mentions the beach is special to her, filled with joy and peace.\n- Result 39 (2023-09-08): Deborah mentions a canceled yoga getaway due to a storm, implying she values such trips.\n- Result 13 and 90 mention Deborah's connection to nature and her mom, but not specifically about beach yoga.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.\n\nDeborah finds yoga on the beach peaceful and relaxing due to the natural elements (ocean, sand, fresh air). It provides a relaxing atmosphere and is a perfect way for her to take care of herself, bringing joy and",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.09,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.32
    },
    {
      "question": "How does Jolene describe their home room?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "little haven for peace and rest",
      "generated_answer": "Jolene describes her home room as a place full of memories, similar to Deborah's mom's house, and mentions it is a space where she has many memories (Result 48). She also says her room does the job for relaxing and tuning out (Result 21). Overall, Jolene's room is a comforting, memory-filled space that helps her relax.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.51,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.65
    },
    {
      "question": "What new activity did Deborah and her neighbor organize for the community on 16 September, 2023?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Free gardening class",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the date and activity mentioned in the context related to Deborah and her neighbor.\n- Result 30 [2023-09-17]: Deborah to Jolene says, \"Yesterday (approximately September 16, 2023), me and my neighbor ran a free gardening class for the community, it was awesome!\"\n\nStep 2: Confirm the nature of the activity.\n- The activity was a \"free gardening class\" for the community.\n\nFinal answer:  \nDeborah and her neighbor organized a free gardening class for the community on September 16, 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.96,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.77
    },
    {
      "question": "What was Deborah's mom passionate about?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Cooking",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Deborah's mom's passions or hobbies in the excerpts.\n\n- Result 5 (2023-08-21): Deborah says her mom really loved flowers.\n- Result 9 (2023-01-27): Deborah says travel was her mom's great passion.\n- Result 30 (2023-04-09): Deborah says her mom was interested in art and believed art could give out strong emotions and uniquely connect people.\n- Result 32 (2023-01-27): Deborah says reading was one of her mom's hobbies; she loved sitting by the window with a book.\n- Result 15 (2023-01-23): Deborah mentions her mom had a special bench near the window where she loved to sit every morning and take in the view.\n\nStep 2: Summarize the passions mentioned.\n\nDeborah's mom was passionate about flowers, travel, art, and reading.\n\nFinal answer:  \nDeborah's mom was passionate about",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.92,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.84
    },
    {
      "question": "What food did Deborah's mom make for her on birthdays?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Pineapple cakes",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify any mentions of food Deborah's mom made, especially related to birthdays.  \nStep 2: In Result 12, Deborah says: \"I loved it when she would bake pineapple birthday cakes for me when I was a kid.\"  \nStep 3: This is a direct and specific answer about birthday food made by Deborah's mom.\n\nFinal answer: Deborah's mom made pineapple birthday cakes for her on birthdays.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.72,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.58
    },
    {
      "question": "What kind of cookies did Jolene used to bake with someone close to her?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Chocolate chip cookies",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Jolene mentions baking cookies with someone close to her (Result 1).\n\nStep 2: Jolene describes the cookies as having warm, gooey chocolate and being soft and buttery (Result 2).\n\nStep 3: Deborah asks what kind of cookie Jolene likes to make (Result 3), but Jolene does not specify a different type.\n\nStep 4: Deborah later says she wants to eat \"this\" now, referring to the cookie Jolene described (Result 25).\n\nNo other cookie types are mentioned by Jolene in the context.\n\nFinal answer: Jolene used to bake warm, gooey chocolate, soft, buttery cookies with someone close to her.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.64,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.16
    },
    {
      "question": "What outdoor activity did Jolene suggest doing together with Deborah?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Surfing",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for mentions of outdoor activities suggested by Jolene to Deborah.  \nStep 2: In Result 5 (2023-09-08), Jolene says: \"My partner and I plan a camping trip to connect with nature and practice yoga.\" This indicates camping and yoga as outdoor activities.  \nStep 3: In Result 77 (2023-07-09), Jolene says: \"We'll definitely go there together sometime!\" referring to a retreat or nature spot, implying a plan to do an outdoor activity together.  \nStep 4: No other explicit suggestions of outdoor activities by Jolene to Deborah are found.  \n\nFinal answer: Jolene suggested going on a camping trip together to connect with nature and practice yoga.",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.03,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.24
    },
    {
      "question": "What activity did Deborah enjoy at the music festival with their pals on September 20, 2023?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Dancing and bopping around",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant excerpt about Deborah at the music festival on September 20, 2023.  \n- Result 2 [2023-09-20T10:17:00] Deborah to Jolene: \"I had a great time at the music festival with my pals! The vibes were unreal and the music was magical. It was so freeing to dance and bop around.\"\n\nStep 2: Extract the activity Deborah enjoyed.  \n- Deborah specifically mentions dancing and bopping around as the freeing activities she enjoyed.\n\nFinal answer:  \nDeborah enjoyed dancing and bopping around with her pals at the music festival on September 20, 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.1,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.46
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Deborah find freeing at the music festival?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Dancing and bopping around",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant excerpt about the music festival.  \n- Result 1 [2023-09-20]: Deborah said, \"I had a great time at the music festival with my pals! The vibes were unreal and the music was magical. It was so freeing to dance and bop around.\"\n\nStep 2: Extract what Deborah found freeing.  \n- Deborah explicitly states that \"It was so freeing to dance and bop around.\"\n\nFinal answer: Deborah found dancing and bopping around at the music festival freeing.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-48",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.67,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.82
    },
    {
      "question": "What kind of car does Evan drive?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Prius",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Evan's car in the context.\n\n- Result 10 (2023-12-05): Evan mentions a \"new Prius\" that he just bought but it broke down.\n- Result 16 (2023-12-05): Evan confirms the new Prius is the car he was counting on.\n- Result 11 (2023-12-31): Evan says they took the Prius for a long drive recently.\n- Result 26 (2023-05-18): Evan mentions his old Prius broke down, he repaired and sold it.\n- Result 72 (2023-11-21): Evan mentions taking his car out for a spin to stay in shape.\n- Result 92 (2023-08-07): Evan talks about a trip to Canada but no car model mentioned here.\n- Result 49 (2023-05-24): Evan talks about a road trip but no car model mentioned.\n- Result 10 and 16",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.79,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.28
    },
    {
      "question": "What kinds of things did Evan have broken?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "His old Prius and his new Prius.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of things Evan had broken or that broke related to him.\n\n- Result 53 [2023-12-05]: Sam to Evan mentions \"Dealing with a new car breaking down is such a hassle, especially when it's your main mode of transport.\" This implies Evan had a new car that broke down.\n\n- Result 50 and 68 [2024-01-10]: Evan describes a pee accident involving someone's roses, but this is not about something broken, more of a minor incident.\n\n- No other direct mentions of broken items related to Evan.\n\nStep 2: Confirm if there are other broken things mentioned.\n\n- Result 45 [2023-12-17]: Evan mentions his son had an accident falling off a bike, but no mention of broken bike or broken bones.\n\n- Result 14 and 16 [2023-08-15]: Evan talks about his son's ankle injury, but no mention of broken bones, just soreness.\n\n- No",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.33,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.61
    },
    {
      "question": "Where has Evan been on roadtrips with his family?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Rockies, Jasper",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Evan's road trips with family.  \n- Result 51 (2023-05-24): Evan mentions taking his family on a road trip to Jasper, driving through Icefields Parkway with glaciers and lakes.  \n- Result 6 (2023-05-24): Sam asks Evan about his road trip to Jasper.  \n- Result 28 (2023-12-09): Evan mentions a trip to Banff with family, showing a framed sign from that trip.  \n- Result 61 (2023-08-19): Sam asks if Evan took advantage of skiing in Banff, implying Evan has been there.  \n- Result 75 (2024-01-06): Evan mentions a honeymoon trip to Canada (not necessarily with family).  \n- Result 67 (2023-12-31): Evan mentions a long drive to the mountains with Sam, but no family mentioned.  \n\nStep 2: Confirm locations of family road trips",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.64,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.86
    },
    {
      "question": "How many Prius has Evan owned?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "two",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: In Result 1 (2023-05-18), Evan mentions his \"old Prius\" broke down and he decided to repair and sell it, implying he had at least one older Prius.\n\nStep 2: In Result 6 (2023-05-18), Evan says he just got back from a trip in his \"new Prius,\" indicating he acquired a second Prius after the old one.\n\nStep 3: In Results 2 and 3 (2023-12-05), Evan talks about his \"new Prius, the one I just bought,\" which broke down, suggesting he bought another Prius after the one mentioned in May.\n\nStep 4: The timeline suggests:\n- First Prius: old one that broke down before May 2023.\n- Second Prius: new one he had in May 2023.\n- Third Prius: new one he bought by December 2023.\n\nTherefore, Evan has owned three Priuses in total.\n\nFinal answer: Evan",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.19,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.78
    },
    {
      "question": "Which hobby did Sam take up in May 2023?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "painting",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for mentions of Sam starting or engaging in hobbies around May 2023.\n\nStep 2: Result 5 (2023-05-18) shows Evan asking Sam: \"What other hobbies have you found for yourself?\" indicating Sam had some hobbies by then.\n\nStep 3: Result 30 (2023-05-18) Sam says: \"We hiked a good distance - quite a feat for me back then. It's definitely a great memory.\" This suggests hiking was a hobby or activity Sam was doing around that time.\n\nStep 4: Result 50 (2023-05-18) Evan says: \"We all hiked the trails last week (approximately May 11, 2023) - the views were amazing!\" confirming hiking activity in early May 2023.\n\nStep 5: No other specific hobby is mentioned for Sam in May 2023.\n\nFinal answer:  \nSam took up hiking as a hobby in May 2023",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.81,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.25
    },
    {
      "question": "Which country was Evan visiting in May 2023?",
      "category": 3,
      "gold_answer": "Canada",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify any mentions of trips or travel by Evan around May 2023.\n\n- Result 41 [2023-05-18]: Evan to Sam: \"We all hiked the trails last week (approximately May 11, 2023) - the views were amazing!\"\n- Result 67 [2023-05-24]: Evan to Sam: \"It was great - fresh air, peacefulness and a cozy cabin surrounded by mountains and forests made it feel like a real retreat.\"\n- Result 76 [2023-05-24]: Sam to Evan: \"Hey Evan, looks amazing! I've never been to Jasper, but it looks breathtaking. Tell me more about your road trip. Was it relaxing?\"\n\nStep 2: Note that Jasper is mentioned by Sam in Result 76, referring to Evan's road trip.\n\nStep 3: Jasper is a well-known location in Canada (Jasper National Park).\n\nStep 4: No other country is mentioned in",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.5,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.61
    },
    {
      "question": "How many roadtrips did Evan take in May 2023?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "two",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of road trips by Evan in May 2023.\n\n- Result 2 [2023-05-18]: Evan says, \"We all hiked the trails last week (approximately May 11, 2023) - the views were amazing!\" This is a hiking trip, not a road trip.\n\n- Result 57 [2023-05-24]: Evan says, \"Last weekend, I took my family on a road trip to Jasper. It was amazing! We drove through the Icefields Parkway and the glaciers and lakes were gorgeous.\" This confirms one road trip in May 2023.\n\nStep 2: Check if there are any other road trips mentioned in May 2023.\n\n- Result 1 and 5 mention road trips but are dated August 2023.\n\n- No other May 2023 messages mention road trips.\n\nFinal answer: Evan took one road trip in May 2023.",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.7,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.69
    },
    {
      "question": "What new hobbies did Sam consider trying?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Painting, kayaking, hiking, cooking, running",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Sam considering new hobbies.\n- [Result 22] (2023-05-18): Sam says, \"Nothing so far, but I was thinking about trying painting.\"\n- [Result 12] (2023-10-14): Sam asks Evan for suggestions about trying something different outdoors.\n- [Result 95] (2023-09-11): Evan offers to help Sam get started with painting.\n- [Result 90] (2024-01-10): Sam mentions hoping for positive changes from a healthier diet and yoga.\n- [Result 44] (2024-01-10): Sam watched The Godfather and was motivated to keep up with routine (not a hobby but related to motivation).\n- [Result 72] (2023-08-19): Sam asks about skiing opportunities, showing interest in winter sports.\n- [Result 37] (2023-08-27): Sam talks about being adaptable and",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.0,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.42
    },
    {
      "question": "What hobby did Evan start practicing a few years ago that he enjoys?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Watercolor painting",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for mentions of hobbies Evan enjoys and when he started them.  \nStep 2: In [Result 40] (2023-05-18), Evan says: \"Yep, it's a great stress-buster. I started doing this a few years back.\" This is in response to Sam's interest in painting ([Result 15], [Result 27]).  \nStep 3: In [Result 64] (2023-08-19), Evan mentions he started painting classes a few days ago and enjoys it.  \nStep 4: In [Result 65], Evan says he loves painting landscapes and shares a recent work.  \nStep 5: In [Result 77], Sam asks Evan how he got into watercolor painting, indicating Evan's hobby is painting.  \nStep 6: The phrase \"started doing this a few years back\" in [Result 40] refers to painting, which Evan enjoys and has been practicing for some time.\n\nFinal",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.36,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.38
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Evan go to Jasper with his family?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "weekend before May 24, 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant excerpt about Evan's trip to Jasper.  \n- Result 1 [2023-05-24]: Evan says, \"Last weekend, I took my family on a road trip to Jasper.\"\n\nStep 2: Determine the date of the message to find the exact timing of the trip.  \n- The message is dated 2023-05-24.  \n- \"Last weekend\" relative to May 24, 2023, would be the weekend of May 20-21, 2023.\n\nFinal answer:  \nEvan went to Jasper with his family on the weekend of May 20-21, 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.6,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.53
    },
    {
      "question": "Which type of vacation would Evan prefer with his family, walking tours in metropolitan cities or camping trip in the outdoors?",
      "category": 3,
      "gold_answer": "camping trip in the outdoors",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for mentions of Evan's vacation preferences with family.\n\n- Result 49 (2023-05-24): Evan took his family on a road trip to Jasper, enjoying nature with glaciers, lakes, and mountains.\n- Result 19 (2023-11-09): Evan mentions a peaceful place close to home where he goes to relax and unwind.\n- Result 41 (2023-11-21): Evan calls a little island where he grew up his happy place, peaceful and serene.\n- Result 81 (2023-08-19): Evan loves being in nature and reminisces about road trips in his car.\n- Result 64 (2024-01-06): Evan is going on a honeymoon trip to Canada to enjoy snowy landscapes.\n- Result 83 (2024-01-10): Evan enjoys beach sunsets for exercise and calming.\n- Result 92 (2023-10-06): Evan had an adventure helping a lost tourist in",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.86,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.45
    },
    {
      "question": "What health issue did Sam face that motivated him to change his lifestyle?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Weight problem",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Sam's health issues and motivation to change.\n\n- [Result 82] (2023-07-27): Sam says friends mocked his weight last Friday, which hurt and made him realize he needs to make changes.\n- [Result 87] (2023-10-08): Sam had a check-up where the doctor said his weight is a serious health risk and he needs to make changes soon.\n- [Result 49] (2023-10-17): Sam had a health scare last weekend with severe stomachache, diagnosed as gastritis, which was a wake-up call to prioritize health.\n- [Result 15] (2023-11-21): Sam mentions discomfort limiting his movement, trying to make diet changes.\n- [Result 36] (2023-11-21): Sam says fitness goals have been hard to reach.\n- [Result 87] and [Result 82] show weight-related health concerns as a",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.4,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.93
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Sam first go to the doctor and find out he had a weight problem?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "A few days before May 24, 2023.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Sam going to the doctor and weight issues.\n\n- Result 5 [2023-05-24]: Sam says he had a check-up a few days ago and the weight \"wasn't great,\" which was eye-opening.\n- Result 7 [2023-10-08]: Sam mentions a check-up on Monday (which would be October 2, 2023) where the doctor said his weight is a serious health risk.\n- Result 11 [2023-07-27]: Sam talks about friends mocking his weight last Friday (July 21, 2023), which made him realize he needs to make changes, but no doctor visit mentioned here.\n- Result 60 [2023-08-15]: Sam mentions a doc's appointment that was a wake-up call to take better care of himself.\n- Result 68 [2023-12-17]: Sam is struggling with weight and motivation but no new doctor visit mentioned.\n-",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.56,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.84
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Evan have his sudden heart palpitation incident that really shocked him up?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "first week of June 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the mention of Evan's sudden heart palpitation incident.  \n- In Result 3 [2023-06-06], Evan says he had a health scare last week, approximately May 30, 2023, describing it as a sudden heart palpitation incident that shook him up.\n\nStep 2: Confirm no other conflicting dates or mentions.  \n- Result 45 mentions a health scare in November 2023, but that was a different incident involving a hospital check-up.  \n- The specific heart palpitation incident is only mentioned in Result 3 with the date around May 30, 2023.\n\nFinal answer:  \nEvan had his sudden heart palpitation incident around May 30, 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.22,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.24
    },
    {
      "question": "What is Evan's favorite food?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Ginger snaps",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for any mentions of Evan's favorite food or foods he particularly enjoys.\n\nStep 2: In [Result 38] (2023-08-07), Evan says: \"Ginger snaps are my weakness for sure!\" This indicates a strong liking for ginger snaps.\n\nStep 3: In [Result 20] (2024-01-06), Evan mentions starting a new diet limiting himself to just two ginger snaps a day, showing he values them but is trying to control intake.\n\nStep 4: No other food is mentioned with similar enthusiasm or described as a favorite.\n\nFinal answer: Evan's favorite food is ginger snaps.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.46,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.54
    },
    {
      "question": "What kind of unhealthy snacks does Sam enjoy eating?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "soda, candy",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Sam's unhealthy snack preferences in the context.\n\n- Result 34 (2023-06-06): Sam says, \"Still enjoying my soda and candy, although I know it's not the best habit to have.\"\n- Result 42 (2023-07-27): Sam says, \"I'm reducing my soda and candy intake.\"\n- Result 59 (2023-08-19): Sam says, \"I'm on a diet and living healthier! Been tough, but I'm determined,\" implying previous habits were less healthy.\n- Result 68 (2023-10-14): Sam admits to buying some unhealthy snacks recently but does not specify which.\n- Result 63 (2023-08-07): Evan mentions ginger snaps as his weakness, but no direct mention that Sam enjoys them.\n- Result 37 (2023-06-06): Evan asks Sam if he has made any changes to his diet, mentioning his own effort to eat less sugary",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.35,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.86
    },
    {
      "question": "What recurring issue frustrates Sam at the grocery store?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Malfunctioning self-checkout machines.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of grocery store or supermarket issues in the context.\n\n- Result 5 (2023-06-06): Sam mentions a frustrating issue at the supermarket where the self-checkout machines were all broken, which ruined their mood.\n- Result 4 (2023-12-31): Sam again mentions having issues with the self-checkout at the store, calling it a \"regular annoyance.\"\n- Result 44 (2023-12-31): Evan responds that he has never had a problem with the self-checkout.\n- Result 46 (2023-12-31): Sam jokes about attracting that kind of situation at the store.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.\n\nSam repeatedly experiences problems with the self-checkout machines at the grocery store, describing it as a recurring frustration or annoyance.\n\nFinal answer:  \nSam is repeatedly frustrated by issues with the self-checkout machines at the grocery store.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.6,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.64
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Sam's friends mock him for being overweight?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "Friday before 27 July 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant excerpt about Sam's friends mocking him for his weight.  \n- Result 2 [2023-07-27T10:52:00] Sam to Evan: \"My friends were mocking my weight last Friday and it hurt.\"\n\nStep 2: Determine the date of \"last Friday\" relative to the message date.  \n- The message was sent on 2023-07-27 (Thursday).  \n- \"Last Friday\" before 2023-07-27 would be 2023-07-21.\n\nFinal answer:  \nSam's friends mocked him for being overweight on Friday, July 21, 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.92,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.34
    },
    {
      "question": "What kind of healthy food suggestions has Evan given to Sam?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "flavored seltzer water, dark chocolate with high cocoa content, air-popped popcorn and fruit, veggies, healthy sandwich snacks, energy balls, grilled chicken salad with avocado",
      "generated_answer": "Step-by-step review of Evan's healthy food suggestions to Sam from the context:\n\n- Result 11 (2023-07-27): Evan mentions cutting down on sugary snacks and eating more veggies and fruit.\n- Result 14 (2023-07-27): Suggests flavored seltzer with air-popped popcorn or fruit as a healthy snack.\n- Result 17 & 23 (2023-12-31): Shares a recipe for energy balls and healthy cookies.\n- Result 28 & 80 (2023-08-19): Shows interest in Sam\u2019s homemade sauce and recipes.\n- Result 31 (2023-08-15): Evan asks about Sam\u2019s roasted vegetable recipe and shares his own healthy cooking experiences.\n- Result 38 & 49 (2023-12-05): Talks about smoothie bowls and recommends yoga for stress relief and flexibility.\n- Result 43 (2024-01-10): Suggests low-impact exercises like swimming, yoga,",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 4.17,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.46
    },
    {
      "question": "Considering their conversations and personal growth, what advice might Evan and Sam give to someone facing a major life transition or challenge?",
      "category": 3,
      "gold_answer": "Evan and Sam would likely advise embracing small, consistent changes\u200b\u200b, finding stress-relieving activities like hiking\u200b\u200b, painting, and road trips\u200b\u200b, and the importance of friendship and support in navigating challenges\u200b\u200b.",
      "generated_answer": "Step-by-step reasoning from the conversation excerpts:\n\n1. Both Evan and Sam emphasize the importance of taking small steps and being consistent (Results 1, 8, 26, 45, 68, 94).\n2. They acknowledge that progress takes time and encourage patience and perseverance (Results 21, 26, 45, 68).\n3. They highlight the value of supportive relationships, especially family and friends, during tough times (Results 2, 5, 6, 9, 10, 13, 22, 28, 37).\n4. They suggest trying new things and stepping out of comfort zones to find new opportunities and growth (Results 7, 14, 23, 24, 79).\n5. They recognize that setbacks and challenges can lead to new opportunities and personal growth (Results 12, 23, 63).\n6. They stress the importance of mindset shifts, such as focusing on progress over perfection and",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.02,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.85
    },
    {
      "question": "In light of the health and dietary changes discussed, what would be an appropriate gift for both Evan and Sam to encourage their healthy lifestyles?",
      "category": 3,
      "gold_answer": "a cookbook with healthy recipes or a subscription to a healthy meal delivery service.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Both Evan and Sam are focused on healthier eating and lifestyle changes, including diet, exercise, and stress relief (Results 1, 3, 4, 7, 11, 27, 42, 44, 54, 61, 75, 90).\n\nStep 2: They share interest in healthy snacks and recipes (Results 1, 3, 9, 14, 19, 33, 47, 58, 69, 95).\n\nStep 3: They are exploring low-impact exercises like yoga, swimming, walking, and gym workouts (Results 4, 13, 30, 42, 54, 61, 67, 75, 90).\n\nStep 4: Family support and bonding through activities like hiking and gatherings are important to them (Results 25, 26, 37, 41, 52, 55, 65, 83,",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        true,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.72,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.66
    },
    {
      "question": "How does Evan describe the woman and his feelings for her that he met in Canada?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "He says she's cool, incredible, like something out of a movie, and that he feels alive around her. Every moment with her is fun and energetic, also Evan feels really lucky to have someone who gets him.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Evan first mentions meeting an \"awesome Canadian woman\" during his trip to Canada around July 31, 2023, describing her as \"incredible\" and that being with her \"makes me feel alive\" (Result 2).\n\nStep 2: Later, Evan confirms to Sam that the woman is indeed the one from Canada and expresses strong feelings by saying, \"I was in love with her at first sight!\" (Result 15).\n\nStep 3: Evan also describes love as \"truly amazing,\" bringing \"so much happiness and fulfillment, like a beautiful sunset that lights up our lives and brings peace\" (Result 35).\n\nStep 4: Sam acknowledges Evan's feelings as \"love at first sight\" and calls it \"something straight out of a fairy tale\" (Result 14).\n\nFinal answer:  \nEvan describes the woman he met in Canada as \"incredible\" and says being with her makes him feel alive; he fell in love with her",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.41,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.78
    },
    {
      "question": "When Evan did meet his future wife?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "week before August 7, 2023.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Evan mentioned meeting an \"awesome Canadian woman\" during a trip to Canada last week, approximately July 31, 2023 (Result 34).\n\nStep 2: Later, Evan said he got married last week, approximately December 19, 2023 (Result 17).\n\nStep 3: Evan also expressed that he was in love with her at first sight (Result 1), which aligns with meeting her during that July 2023 trip.\n\nFinal answer: Evan met his future wife around the end of July 2023 during his trip to Canada.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.39,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.85
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Sam start working out at the gym?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "July 28, 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify any direct mentions of Sam starting gym workouts.  \n- Result 2 (2023-07-27): Sam says, \"Starting tomorrow, I will go to the gym and exercise regularly.\" This indicates Sam planned to start gym workouts on July 28, 2023.  \n- Result 58 (2023-08-27): Sam says, \"I started a new diet and exercise routine last Monday,\" which is approximately August 20, 2023. This suggests a new or renewed routine starting then, but not necessarily the first gym start.  \n- Result 5 (2023-10-17): Evan mentions going to the gym \"yesterday,\" indicating ongoing gym activity by mid-October.  \n- Result 3 and 4 (2023-11-21): They discuss fitness goals, implying Sam has been working on fitness for some time.\n\nStep 2: Confirm no earlier gym start mentioned.  \n- No earlier explicit mention of",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.97,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.35
    },
    {
      "question": "What significant event happened in Sam's life towards the end of summer 2023?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "He fell in love with a Canadian woman",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the timeframe \"towards the end of summer 2023,\" which would be around August 2023.\n\nStep 2: Look for any messages around August 2023 mentioning significant events in Sam's life.\n\nStep 3: In Result 18 [2023-08-19], Evan says to Sam: \"Wow, Sam, that's great news! Making changes to live healthier can be challenging, how has it been going?\" This suggests Sam shared some positive news about health or lifestyle changes.\n\nStep 4: In Result 27 [2023-08-19], Sam responds: \"Yeah, maybe. It's hard with that, you know. But who knows? Thanks for the understanding, Evan - it really means a lot.\" This is somewhat vague but indicates a personal challenge or change.\n\nStep 5: No explicit mention of a major life event like marriage or pregnancy for Sam in late summer 2023.\n\nStep 6: Check if any other",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.87,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.37
    },
    {
      "question": "Which year did Evan start taking care of his health seriously?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "2021",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify any direct mentions of when Evan started focusing on his health.\n\n- Result 10 (2023-07-27): Evan mentions he struggled with his health \"a few years ago\" but stuck with it.\n- Result 75 (2023-08-07): Evan says, \"My healthy road has been a long one. I've been working on it for two years now.\"\n- Result 93 (2023-10-25): Evan says he went through a similar phase \"a twoyears ago\" (likely a typo for \"two years ago\").\n\nStep 2: Determine the timeline from these statements.\n\n- The messages from 2023 indicate Evan has been working on his health for about two years as of mid-2023.\n- Two years before 2023 is 2021.\n\nStep 3: Confirm no other contradictory information.\n\n- No other messages specify a different start year.\n- The \"few years ago\" in Result 10 is",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.06,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.66
    },
    {
      "question": "What motivates Evan to take care of his health?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "family, fitness tracker, thirst for adventure on interesting hikes",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for mentions of Evan's motivation for health in the excerpts.\n\n- Result 4 (2023-08-07): Evan says his family motivates him to stay healthy.\n- Result 40 (2023-08-07): Evan mentions a gym membership card symbolizes strength and resilience, motivating him to keep going through tough times.\n- Result 78 (2023-08-07): Evan says his healthy road has been a long one (two years), with ups and downs, but he is doing his best.\n- Result 88 (2023-08-07): Evan says dealing with health issues has been tough but made him appreciate good moments more, and those moments bring joy even through hard times.\n- Result 64, 66, 71, 72 (2024-01-06): Evan talks about family support being important, bringing love, happiness, and comfort.\n- Result 57 (2023-08-07): Evan says finding",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 6.81,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.99
    },
    {
      "question": "What electronic device could Evan gift Sam to help him keep up with his fitness goals?",
      "category": 3,
      "gold_answer": "fitness tracker",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of devices or tools related to fitness motivation or tracking in the conversation.\n\n- Result 7 (2023-08-07): Evan mentions \"It tracks my progress really well and serves as a constant reminder to keep going.\" This implies Evan uses some kind of tracking device.\n- Result 46 (2023-08-07): Evan says, \"I got this because it symbolizes strength and resilience. Taking care of it motivates me to keep going through tough times.\" This likely refers to the same device.\n- Result 31 (2023-08-07): Evan says, \"It's been awesome, Sam! That visual reminder has been really motivating.\" This supports the idea of a device that tracks progress and serves as a reminder.\n\nStep 2: Determine what kind of device this might be.\n\n- The context suggests a fitness tracker or smartwatch that tracks progress and motivates.\n- No explicit device name is given, but the description fits a fitness tracker or smartwatch.\n\n",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.53,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.54
    },
    {
      "question": "What kind of writing does Sam do to relax and cope with his health issues?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "journalling, creative writing",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about Sam's writing and coping with health issues.\n\n- Result 11 [2023-10-06]: Evan asks Sam what kind of writing he enjoys.\n- Result 62 [2023-10-06]: Sam replies that writing in his journal and doing creative writing is a good way to express his innermost thoughts and feelings.\n- Result 18 [2023-10-06]: Evan encourages Sam, saying writing can be therapeutic and a place to express oneself.\n\nStep 2: Confirm that this writing is connected to coping with health issues.\n\n- Result 62 explicitly links writing to expressing innermost thoughts and feelings, which aligns with coping.\n- Result 11 and 18 frame writing as a way to express and cope.\n\nFinal answer: Sam does journal writing and creative writing to relax and cope with his health issues.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.46,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.48
    },
    {
      "question": "Who did Evan meet on his trip to Canada, and who did he come back from Canada with?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Evan met the woman he fell in love with and returned with her.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify who Evan met on his trip to Canada.  \n- From Result 2 (2023-08-07), Evan says he went on a trip to Canada around July 31, 2023, and met \"this awesome Canadian woman.\"  \n- From Result 1 (2023-12-26), Sam asks if that woman is from Canada, confirming the woman is Canadian.  \n- From Result 39 (2023-08-13), Evan mentions he just got back from a vacation in Canada with his new SO (significant other), confirming the woman he met is his partner.\n\nStep 2: Identify who Evan came back from Canada with.  \n- Result 39 confirms Evan came back with his new SO.  \n- Result 3 (2024-01-06) mentions Evan and his partner are going to Canada next month for their honeymoon, indicating they are now a couple.  \n- Result 55 (2024-01-06",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.48,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.76
    },
    {
      "question": "When Evan get back from a vacation with his SO?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "August 13, 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Evan's vacation with his SO.  \n- Result 6 (2024-01-06): Sam mentions \"Skiing, trying local dishes, and enjoying the breathtaking views - the perfect honeymoon.\"  \n- Result 7 (2024-01-06): Sam asks Evan to share details about it.  \n- Result 24 (2024-01-06): Evan responds about the trip, indicating it is ongoing or just happened.  \n- Result 62 (2024-01-06): Sam wishes Evan a great trip, implying Evan is still away or just about to leave.\n\nStep 2: Look for any messages after 2024-01-06 that indicate Evan is back.  \n- Result 5 and 53 (2024-01-10): Sam asks Evan \"What happened? Let me know.\" and \"What's up with that incident? All good now?\"  \n- Result 36 and 97 (2024",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.56,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.32
    },
    {
      "question": "How might Evan and Sam's experiences with health and lifestyle changes influence their approach to stress and challenges?",
      "category": 3,
      "gold_answer": "Their experiences likely lead them to view challenges as opportunities for growth and change. They both have embraced healthier lifestyles, indicating a proactive approach to managing stress and challenges.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Both Evan and Sam have faced health challenges that served as wake-up calls (Evan\u2019s heart palpitation around May 30, 2023 [Result 21], Sam\u2019s gastritis and discomfort limiting movement [Results 35, 33]).\n\nStep 2: They have both committed to healthier lifestyles involving diet changes, exercise, and stress management (Evan cutting sugary snacks, eating more veggies/fruits, lifting weights for a year, and doing yoga [Results 10, 69, 8]; Sam on a diet, trying yoga, and adopting healthier habits [Results 26, 8, 89]).\n\nStep 3: They emphasize taking small steps and progress over perfection, which helps them stay motivated and reduce pressure (Sam\u2019s quote about progress over perfection [Results 25, 99], Evan\u2019s advice to focus on well-being rather than quick results [Result 17]).\n\nStep 4: Both find nature and hobbies like painting,",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.9,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.54
    },
    {
      "question": "What recurring frustration does Evan experience?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Evan consistently misplaces his keys every week.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of frustrations or difficulties Evan experiences.\n\n- Result 6 (2023-08-27): Sam expresses sympathy about Evan's body not cooperating, implying health issues.\n- Result 67 (2023-08-07): Evan mentions dealing with health issues has been tough.\n- Result 91 (2023-11-21): Evan acknowledges health holding him back is tough.\n- Result 3 & 14 & 18 & 25 & 45 & 77 (2024-01-10 & 2024-01-11 & 2023-12-31): Evan talks about an embarrassing incident/accident he was involved in, which caused embarrassment and a need to be more careful.\n- Result 41 & 31 (2023-11-09 & 2023-11-21): Sam mentions Evan's job troubles, implying stress or frustration related to work.\n- Result 67 & 6 & 91: Health",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.44,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.27
    },
    {
      "question": "What is the recurring dream that Sam keeps having?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "he's flying over a cityscape.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Sam's recurring dream in the context.  \n- Result 3 (2024-01-10): Sam says, \"I had that recurring dream again where I'm flying over skyscrapers!\"  \n- Result 8 (2023-08-13): Sam mentions having \"this amazing dream last night where I was soaring over skyscrapers.\"  \n- Result 4 (2024-01-10): Evan responds to Sam's flying dream, indicating it is recurring and that Sam might learn to control it.\n\nStep 2: Confirm the content of the recurring dream.  \nBoth excerpts clearly describe the dream as flying or soaring over skyscrapers.\n\nFinal answer:  \nSam's recurring dream is about flying or soaring over skyscrapers.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.33,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.48
    },
    {
      "question": "What accidents has Evan's son faced lately?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "injured at a soccer game, fell off his bike",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Evan's son and accidents.\n- Result 2 (2023-08-15): Evan says his son had a soccer accident last Saturday and hurt his ankle.\n- Result 3 (2023-12-17): Evan says his son had an accident last Tuesday, fell off his bike, and it was rough.\n\nStep 2: Confirm details and timing.\n- The soccer accident happened around mid-August 2023 (last Saturday before 2023-08-15).\n- The bike accident happened mid-December 2023 (last Tuesday before 2023-12-17).\n\nStep 3: Summarize the accidents.\n- One was a soccer accident causing an ankle injury.\n- The other was a bike fall that was rough but the son is doing better now.\n\nFinal answer:  \nEvan's son recently had two accidents: a soccer accident in mid-August 2023 that injured his ankle, and a bike fall in",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.78,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.83
    },
    {
      "question": "When was Evan's son injured at soccer?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "Saturday before August 15, 2023.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Evan's son being injured at soccer.  \n- Result 1 (2023-08-15): Evan says his son had a soccer accident \"last Saturday.\"  \n- Result 3 (2023-08-15): Evan confirms the ankle is still sore but getting better.  \n- Result 28 (2023-12-17): Evan mentions his son had an accident last Tuesday but it was a bike accident, so different incident.\n\nStep 2: Determine the date of \"last Saturday\" relative to the message date.  \n- The message in Result 1 is dated 2023-08-15 (Tuesday).  \n- The \"last Saturday\" before 2023-08-15 would be 2023-08-12.\n\nStep 3: Confirm no conflicting information about the soccer injury date.  \n- No other messages contradict this date for the soccer injury.\n\nFinal answer:  \nEvan's son was injured at soccer on",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 5.33,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.95
    },
    {
      "question": "What kind of foods or recipes has Sam recommended to Evan?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "grilled vegetables, grilled chicken and veggie stir-fry, poutine",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Sam recommending foods or recipes to Evan.\n\n- Result 21 (2023-08-15): Sam offers a tasty and easy roasted vegetable recipe.\n- Result 53 (2023-08-15): Sam describes marinating and grilling a dish with veggies and offers to share more recipes from a cooking class.\n- Result 42 (2023-08-19): Sam shares a recipe for a flavorful and healthy grilled chicken and veggie stir-fry.\n- Result 14 (2023-08-19): Sam shares a recipe (likely related to the sauce mentioned in Result 32).\n- Result 32 (2023-08-19): Sam offers the recipe for a homemade sauce.\n- Result 13 & 93 (2023-12-31): Sam is interested in healthy snacks and discusses recipes with Evan.\n- Result 54 (2023-12-31): Sam mentions taking friends on a hiking trip, implying an active lifestyle",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 4.36,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.67
    },
    {
      "question": "What kind of healthy meals did Sam start eating after getting a health scare?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "salad, grilled salmon and vegetables, grilled chicken and veggie stir-fry, Beef Merlot, fruit bowl, smoothie bowl",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify when Sam had a health scare.  \n- Result 22 (2023-10-17) mentions Sam had a health scare last weekend with gastritis, which was a wake-up call to prioritize health with a nutritious diet and regular exercise.\n\nStep 2: Look for mentions of what healthy meals Sam started eating after this scare.  \n- Result 28 (2023-08-15) mentions Sam taking a cooking class to learn healthier meals, but this is before the October scare.  \n- Result 87 (2023-08-15) Sam mentions learning awesome recipes in the cooking class and making a yummy grilled dish.  \n- Result 4 and 31 (2023-08-15) Evan asks about recipes and Sam offers a roasted vegetable recipe.  \n- Result 16 and 42 (2023-08-19) Sam talks about feeling more energy and less sluggishness after eating healthier.  \n- Result 24 and 38 (",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.9,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.84
    },
    {
      "question": "What role does nature and the outdoors play in Evan and Sam's mental well-being?",
      "category": 3,
      "gold_answer": "Nature and outdoor activities seem to be significant stress relievers and sources of joy for both Evan and Sam. These activities likely contribute positively to their mental well-being.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Multiple excerpts show Evan and Sam discussing nature as calming, peaceful, and rejuvenating (Results 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 7, 9, 10, 11, 20, 22, 24, 32, 40, 41).\n\nStep 2: They mention nature helping them relax, reset their minds, find peace and clarity, and feel connected to something bigger (Results 1, 4, 5, 7, 11, 20, 32).\n\nStep 3: Evan uses nature in his art to express feelings and capture peacefulness, which supports his mental well-being (Results 9, 12, 30, 58, 86, 98).\n\nStep 4: Both see outdoor activities like hiking, kayaking, and road trips as ways to bond with nature and improve health and mood (Results 6, 10, 17, 18",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.34,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.49
    },
    {
      "question": "How many months lapsed between Sam's first and second doctor's appointment?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "three months",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify Sam's first doctor's appointment.\n- Result 65 [2023-05-24]: Sam says, \"had a check-up with my doctor a few days ago,\" referring to a recent appointment around May 21-24, 2023.\n\nStep 2: Identify Sam's second doctor's appointment.\n- Result 2 [2024-01-10]: Sam says, \"I'm going to make an appointment soon,\" implying a new appointment planned but not yet done.\n- No explicit mention of a second completed appointment after May 2023.\n\nStep 3: Check if there is any other mention of a completed second appointment.\n- No direct evidence of a second completed appointment after May 2023.\n- Sam mentions a health scare in October 2023 (Result 74), but no direct mention of a doctor visit date.\n- Evan asks in Result 1 and 31 (2024-01-10) about advice from the doctor, and Sam plans",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.08,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.47
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Evan start taking painting classes?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "Few days before 19 August, 2023.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about Evan starting painting classes.\n\n- Result 3 (2023-08-19): Evan says, \"I also started taking a painting classes few days ago and I'm really enjoying it.\"\n- Result 7 (2023-08-19): Evan explains how he started painting after a friend gave him a painting, and he joined classes to find like-minded people.\n- Result 6 (2023-08-19): Evan talks about what they are learning in painting classes.\n\nStep 2: The date of these messages is August 19, 2023, and Evan says he started classes \"a few days ago,\" which implies early to mid August 2023.\n\nStep 3: No earlier mention of painting classes is found before August 2023.\n\nFinal answer: Evan started taking painting classes in early August 2023, a few days before August 19, 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.47,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.15
    },
    {
      "question": "Which classes did Evan join in mid-August 2023?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "painting classes",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the timeframe: mid-August 2023.\n\nStep 2: Look for mentions of Evan joining classes around that time.\n\n- Result 6 [2023-08-19]: Sam asks Evan why he decided to join a class and about his painting start years ago.\n- Result 2 [2023-08-19]: Sam asks if Evan took any other classes.\n- Result 63 [2023-08-19]: Evan says he has been painting with \"these\" (likely watercolor or art supplies) for now but might look into other classes.\n- Result 40 [2023-08-19]: Evan mentions enjoying skiing, snowboarding, and ice skating as winter activities.\n- Result 61 [2023-08-19]: Evan drove somewhere fun last month (July 20, 2023).\n\nStep 3: From these, the clearest direct mention of classes is Evan painting and taking painting classes.\n\nStep 4: No",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.63,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.56
    },
    {
      "question": "How did Evan get into painting?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "His friend got him into it by gifting him a painting and giving him some advice. The painting inspired Evan.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for mentions of how Evan started painting.  \n- Result 27 (2023-08-19): Evan says he started painting when a friend gave him a painting that inspired him a lot.  \n- Result 76 (2023-05-18): Evan says a friend got him into painting and gave him some advice, and he was hooked right away.  \n- Result 8 (2023-08-19): Sam asks why Evan started painting years ago, and Evan's reply in Result 27 explains the inspiration from a friend's painting.  \n\nStep 2: Confirm the timeline and motivation.  \n- Evan was inspired by a friend's painting, which motivated him to start painting himself.  \n- He also joined painting classes to find like-minded people and improve his skills (Result 27).  \n\nFinal answer:  \nEvan got into painting after a friend gave him a painting that inspired him, and with that encouragement and advice, he started painting and joined classes",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.06,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.97
    },
    {
      "question": "How often does Sam get health checkups?",
      "category": 3,
      "gold_answer": "every three months",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for any direct mentions of Sam's health checkups or doctor visits.\n\n- Result 60 (2023-10-08): Sam mentions a recent check-up on Monday (October 2, 2023) where the doctor warned about weight being a serious health risk.\n- Result 63 (2024-01-10): Sam says they haven't seen a doctor in a while but plan to make an appointment soon.\n- Result 62 (2024-01-10): Sam plans to ask the doctor about a balanced diet and low-impact exercises.\n- Result 17 (2023-10-17): Sam had a health scare last weekend (around October 7-8, 2023) and went to the ER for gastritis, which is a medical visit but not a routine checkup.\n- No other explicit mentions of regular or frequent checkups.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.\n\n- Sam had a check-up in early October ",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.81,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.3
    },
    {
      "question": "What kind of subjects does Evan enjoy painting?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "nature landscapes, portraits, abstract minimalism",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Evan's painting subjects in the excerpts.\n\n- Result 3 (2023-08-19): Evan says he loves painting landscapes and nature's beauty.\n- Result 22 (2023-10-06): Evan says he usually paints what's on his mind or something he's feeling, including good memories or places he wants to go.\n- Result 5 (2023-12-17): Evan describes a contemporary figurative painting emphasizing emotional states.\n- Result 7 (2023-12-26): Evan talks about a painting with spontaneous strokes and bold colors reflecting joy and freedom.\n- Result 23 (2023-12-26): Evan mentions a painting made with mixed emotions (sad, mad, hopeful).\n- Result 83 (2023-10-06): Evan mentions a sunset painting inspired by a vacation and a cactus painting from a road trip.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.\n\nEvan enjoys painting landscapes and nature scenes,",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.89,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.52
    },
    {
      "question": "Which places in Canada was Evan visiting in July 2023?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "Banff, Rocky Mountains",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Evan's trips to Canada in July 2023.\n\n- Result 5 (2023-08-07): Evan says last week (approx. July 31, 2023) he went on a trip to Canada and met a Canadian woman.\n- Result 9 (2023-08-19): Evan says last month (approx. July 20, 2023) he drove somewhere fun with amazing views.\n- Result 14 (2023-08-27): Evan mentions a road trip last month (approx. July 28, 2023) with stunning scenery.\n- Result 26 (2023-05-24): Evan mentions a family road trip to Jasper, but this was in May, not July.\n\nStep 2: Look for specific place names in Canada related to July 2023.\n\n- Result 26 mentions Jasper, but that was in May.\n- No direct mention of Jasper or other specific places in July",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.41,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.68
    },
    {
      "question": "How do Evan and Sam use creative outlets to cope with life's challenges?",
      "category": 3,
      "gold_answer": "Evan and Sam use creative activities, like painting and writing, as therapeutic tools to express themselves and cope with stress.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of creative outlets used by Evan and Sam.\n- Evan frequently talks about painting and art as a way to express emotions and cope (Results 3, 5, 6, 26, 34, 54, 62, 81).\n- Sam mentions writing in a journal and creative writing as a way to express innermost thoughts and feelings (Result 9, 95).\n- Sam is also interested in trying painting as a hobby to de-stress (Results 36, 99, 87).\n- Both mention how art helps them recognize and handle emotions (Results 3, 34, 62).\n- Evan encourages trying new things and stepping out of comfort zones to feel accomplishment and cope (Results 8, 18).\n- Sam uses writing and is inspired by Evan\u2019s passion for painting (Results 87, 9).\n\nStep 2: Understand the emotional and coping benefits they describe.\n- Evan describes painting as therapeutic,",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.57,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.46
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Evan go skiing in Banff?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "July 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Evan skiing in Banff.\n- Result 1 (2023-08-19): Sam asks Evan if he took advantage of skiing in Banff.\n- Result 2 (2023-08-19): Evan confirms he skied in Banff and had a great time.\n- Result 29 (2023-12-09): Evan references a trip to Banff with a family motto sign in a photo.\n\nStep 2: Look for any date or time references about the Banff skiing trip.\n- Result 42 (2023-08-19): Evan mentions driving somewhere fun last month (approx. July 20, 2023) with amazing views.\n- Result 48 (2023-08-27): Evan mentions a road trip last month (approx. July 28, 2023) with stunning scenery.\n- Result 92 (2023-08-07): Evan says last week (approx. July 31",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.46,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.78
    },
    {
      "question": "What new diet and lifestyle change did Sam adopt over time?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Healthy eating, exercise routine, running, hiking",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Early in the conversation (May-June 2023), Sam was still enjoying soda and candy and had not made significant changes (Results 43, 65).\n\nStep 2: On 2023-07-27, Sam decided to reduce soda and candy intake and start exercising regularly (Results 39, 72).\n\nStep 3: By August 2023, Sam started a new diet and exercise routine, feeling great and motivated (Results 21, 32, 36, 60).\n\nStep 4: Sam also began incorporating yoga and low-impact exercises by early 2024 (Results 3, 33, 44, 52).\n\nStep 5: Sam attended a Weight Watchers meeting in December 2023 and later became a Weight Watchers coach (Results 53, 67).\n\nStep 6: Sam focused on healthier eating, reducing sugary snacks, and increasing physical activity including hiking and swimming (Results 70, 68",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.99,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.71
    },
    {
      "question": "Who was injured in Evan's family?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Evan's son and Evan himself",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of injury in Evan's family.\n\n- Result 13 (2023-08-15): Evan says his son had a soccer accident last Saturday and hurt his ankle.\n- Result 3 (2023-08-15): Evan confirms the son's ankle is getting better but still sore.\n- Result 64 (2023-12-17): Evan mentions his son had an accident last Tuesday, fell off his bike, and it was rough but he's doing better now.\n\nStep 2: Confirm the injured person is Evan's son.\n\n- Both incidents (soccer accident and bike fall) refer to Evan's son.\n- No other family member is mentioned as injured.\n\nFinal answer: Evan's son was injured in two separate accidents\u2014a soccer accident in August 2023 and a bike fall in December 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.29,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.55
    },
    {
      "question": "What kind of hobbies does Evan pursue?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "painting, hiking, reading books, biking, skiing, snowboarding, ice skating, swimming, camping, kayaking",
      "generated_answer": "Step-by-step reasoning:\n\n1. Evan mentions enjoying winter sports such as skiing, snowboarding, and ice skating (Result 16, 49).\n2. Evan is involved in painting, specifically landscapes and watercolor painting, and has taken classes to improve his skills (Results 43, 60, 65, 97, 100).\n3. Evan enjoys hiking and outdoor adventures, motivated by a thirst for adventure on interesting hikes (Results 39, 44, 53, 56, 83).\n4. Evan also mentions trying new activities and staying active, including indoor activities and traveling (Results 3, 10, 18, 21).\n5. Evan values creative expression through art and journaling (Results 20, 52, 58).\n6. Evan is motivated by finding hobbies that keep him happy and motivated (Results 1, 2, 6, 68).\n\nFinal concise answer:\n\nEvan pursues hobbies including painting (especially landscapes and",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.01,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.59
    },
    {
      "question": "What challenges does Sam face in his quest for a healthier lifestyle, and how does he address them?",
      "category": 3,
      "gold_answer": "Sam faces challenges like maintaining motivation and making dietary changes. He addresses them by enrolling in cooking classes and seeking support from friends like Evan.",
      "generated_answer": "Step-by-step analysis:\n\n1. Sam faces health problems that limit his movement and cause discomfort (Result 54).\n2. He struggles with cravings for sugary drinks and snacks, which are tempting and hard to resist (Results 21, 29).\n3. He feels pressured by his family regarding his health goals (Result 50).\n4. Sam experiences a mix of emotions, including concern about his health but also motivation to make positive changes (Result 24).\n5. Despite challenges, Sam is determined and takes things one step at a time (Results 22, 24).\n6. He is trying to reduce soda and candy intake (Result 55) and has started a diet and healthier eating (Results 22, 61).\n7. Sam is incorporating low-impact exercises like swimming and yoga to accommodate his physical limitations (Results 99, 6, 40).\n8. He plans to ask his doctor for advice on a balanced diet and low-impact exercises (Results 40,",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 4.88,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.72
    },
    {
      "question": "Which activity do Evan and Sam plan on doing together during September 2023?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "painting",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for any mentions of plans or activities involving Evan and Sam around September 2023.\n\nStep 2: Result 36 [2023-09-11T09:34:00] Evan to Sam says: \"Yeah, Sam - let's do it! Let's get everything ready and paint next Saturday. Can't wait!\"\n\nStep 3: This indicates they planned a painting activity together in September 2023, specifically the Saturday after September 11, 2023.\n\nStep 4: No other specific activities planned for September 2023 are mentioned in the context.\n\nFinal answer: Evan and Sam planned to do a painting activity together in September 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.61,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.91
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Evan and Sam decide to paint together?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "Saturday after 11 September, 2023.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for mentions of planning to paint together.\n- Result 3 (2023-09-11): Sam to Evan says, \"Can't wait to paint with you next Saturday.\"\n- Result 8 (2023-09-11): Evan to Sam replies, \"Let's do it! Let's get everything ready and paint next Saturday.\"\n- Result 11 (2023-09-11): Sam to Evan says, \"Can you help me pick out the stuff? Let's plan a painting session soon.\"\n\nStep 2: The date of these messages is September 11, 2023, and they refer to painting \"next Saturday,\" which would be September 16, 2023.\n\nStep 3: No earlier or later specific date for deciding to paint together is found.\n\nFinal answer: Evan and Sam decided to paint together on September 11, 2023, planning to paint the following Saturday, September 16, 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 4.61,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.88
    },
    {
      "question": "What personal health incidents does Evan face in 2023?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "heart palpitations, twisted ankle, twisted ankle",
      "generated_answer": "Step-by-step analysis of Evan's personal health incidents in 2023 based on the context:\n\n1. Around May 30, 2023, Evan had a sudden heart palpitation incident that was a serious wake-up call about his lifestyle. (Result 3)\n\n2. Around September 29, 2023, Evan had a knee injury playing basketball with his kids, which made it tough to stay active. (Result 82)\n\n3. Around November 14, 2023, Evan had a health scare that required a hospital visit where something suspicious was found but later determined to be a misunderstanding. (Result 5, 7, 24)\n\n4. There is also mention of an accident around the end of 2023 (December 31), which was minor but caused some embarrassment and a promise to be more careful. (Result 15, 27, 34, 65)\n\nSummary: Evan faced a heart palpitation incident in late May, a knee injury",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.86,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.6
    },
    {
      "question": "What recurring adventure does Evan have with strangers?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Helping lost tourists and experiencing unexpected adventures in the city.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for mentions of Evan and any recurring adventures or activities involving others, especially strangers.\n\nStep 2: Review relevant excerpts:\n\n- Result 28 (2024-01-10): Evan mentions trying snowshoeing with his partner as part of a new adventure.\n- Result 41 (2023-08-19): Evan talks about painting landscapes, which is a solo activity.\n- Result 86 (2023-08-19): Evan invites Sam to join him in winter activities like skiing, snowboarding, and ice skating.\n- Result 63 (2023-05-18): Evan mentions hiking trails with others (likely friends).\n- Result 36 (2023-05-18): Evan says a friend got him into a hobby and gave advice.\n- Result 7 (2023-08-07): Evan says he is motivated by a thirst for adventure on interesting hikes.\n- Result 68 (2023-08-27): Evan suggests going",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.81,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.51
    },
    {
      "question": "What is Sam's persistent problem with his phone?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "His new phone malfunctioning, particularly with the navigation app.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Sam's phone issues in the context.\n\n- Result 27 (2023-10-17): Sam mentions his phone has been giving him a hard time, adding to stress.\n- Result 98 (2023-10-06): Sam says his new phone's navigation app keeps malfunctioning, making getting around a challenge.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.\n\nSam's persistent problem with his phone is that the navigation app malfunctions, causing difficulty in using it for directions and adding to his stress.\n\nFinal answer:  \nSam's persistent problem with his phone is that the navigation app keeps malfunctioning, making it difficult for him to get around.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.9,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.34
    },
    {
      "question": "Which US state was Sam travelling in during October 2023?",
      "category": 3,
      "gold_answer": "California",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Review all excerpts mentioning travel or locations in October 2023.\n\nStep 2: Excerpts around October 2023 mostly talk about hiking, gym, painting, and health progress, but no direct mention of a US state.\n\nStep 3: The closest travel-related mentions in October are:\n- [Result 73] (2023-10-06): Evan talks about a recent adventure helping a lost tourist in the city.\n- [Result 68] (2023-10-14): Evan recommends a place with clear water and gorgeous views.\n- [Result 79], [Result 49], [Result 60]: Plans for hiking with Sam.\n- No explicit mention of a US state or specific location in October 2023.\n\nStep 4: Other travel mentions are mostly about Canada (July, December, January), and road trips in mountains or Jasper (Canada), but no US state is named.\n\nStep 5: Sam's travel in October ",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 15.8,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.54
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Evan start lifting weights?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "October 2022",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant excerpt about Evan starting lifting weights.  \n- Result 1 [2023-10-08]: Evan says, \"I started lifting weights one year ago.\"\n\nStep 2: Determine the date of the message to calculate the approximate start date.  \n- The message is dated 2023-10-08.  \n- One year before that would be around October 2022.\n\nFinal answer:  \nEvan started lifting weights around October 2022.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.51,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.16
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Sam and his friend decide to try kayaking?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "October 14, 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of kayaking and timing around it.\n\n- [Result 1] (2023-10-14): Evan asks Sam if he has tried kayaking.\n- [Result 2] (2023-10-14): Sam says kayaking sounds awesome and he is considering trying it.\n- [Result 5] (2023-10-14): Sam says \"my mate and I are just around the corner from kayaking on the lake, we're going to try that now!\"\n- [Result 4] (2023-10-14): Sam mentions traveling through Lake Tahoe, which is great for kayaking.\n- [Result 6] (2023-10-14): Evan offers to plan a kayaking trip together.\n\nStep 2: The conversation about trying kayaking happens on 2023-10-14, with Sam saying they are about to try kayaking \"now\" (Result 5).\n\nStep 3: No earlier mention of kayaking attempts by Sam or",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.54,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.47
    },
    {
      "question": "Which new activity does Sam take up in October 2023?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "kayaking",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for mentions of new activities Sam started around October 2023.\n\nStep 2: In [Result 33] dated 2023-07-27, Sam says: \"Starting tomorrow, I will go to the gym and exercise regularly.\" This is July, so gym is not new in October.\n\nStep 3: In [Result 47] (2023-10-17), Sam says to Evan: \"Sounds awesome, Evan! Can't wait to go on a hike with you.\" Also in [Result 50] (2023-10-17), Sam says: \"Super excited to get fit with ya. Let's hit the trails soon!\" This suggests hiking is a new or renewed activity in October.\n\nStep 4: In [Result 84] (2023-12-17), Sam says: \"I used to love hiking, but it's been a while since I had the chance to do it.\" This implies Sam is returning to hiking after",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.26,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.67
    },
    {
      "question": "What kind of stress was Sam dealing with in October 2023?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "work-related stress",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for mentions of Sam's stress or challenges around October 2023.\n\nStep 2: Result 5 (2023-10-14) shows Evan asking Sam about work stress and suggesting hobbies to de-stress.\n\nStep 3: Result 67 (2023-10-14) shows Evan checking in with Sam, implying some ongoing issues.\n\nStep 4: Result 31 and 44 (2023-10-25) show Evan talking about letting go of unrealistic expectations and focusing on well-being, which could relate to stress management.\n\nStep 5: Result 21 (2023-11-09) mentions Evan losing his job, but that is about Evan, not Sam.\n\nStep 6: No direct mention of other types of stress for Sam in October besides work stress.\n\nFinal answer: In October 2023, Sam was dealing with work-related stress.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.0,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.82
    },
    {
      "question": "What health scares did Sam and Evan experience?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Sam faced a health scare with stomach pains that turned out to be gastritis, prompting him to rethink his health habits. Evan, on the other hand, experienced two separate incidents: a sudden heart palpitation incident and a different event involving a misunderstanding during a medical check-up. These experiences have significantly influenced their perspectives on health and well-being.",
      "generated_answer": "Step-by-step analysis:\n\n1. Evan's health scares:\n   - On 2023-05-30 (mentioned in message from 2023-06-06), Evan had a sudden heart palpitation incident that shook him up (Result 4).\n   - On approximately November 14, 2023, Evan had a health scare that required a hospital visit due to something suspicious found during a check-up, but it turned out to be a misunderstanding (Results 9, 14, 18).\n\n2. Sam's health scares:\n   - On the weekend before 2023-10-17, Sam had a severe stomachache and ended up in the ER; diagnosed with gastritis (Result 22).\n   - Sam has also been dealing with discomfort limiting movement and has been trying to improve health through diet and lifestyle changes (Results 1, 10).\n\nFinal concise answer:\n\nEvan experienced a sudden heart palpitation around May 30, 2023, and a",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.11,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.95
    },
    {
      "question": "When was Sam in the ER?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "weekend before 17 October, 2023.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for any mention of Sam having a health scare or being in the hospital/ER.\n\nStep 2: Result 65 [2023-11-21T19:30:30] Evan to Sam says: \"Last week (approximately November 14, 2023), I had a health scare and had to go to the hospital.\" This is about Evan, not Sam.\n\nStep 3: No other results mention Sam being in the ER or hospital.\n\nStep 4: Sam talks about fitness goals, health journeys, and supporting each other but no direct mention of Sam being in the ER.\n\nFinal answer: Not enough information.",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.59,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.88
    },
    {
      "question": "Which ailment does Sam have to face due to his weight?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "gastritis",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Sam's health issues related to weight.  \n- Result 7 (2023-10-08): Sam says his doctor said his weight is a serious health risk and it can get worse if he doesn't make changes.  \n- Result 10 (2023-05-24): Sam had a check-up and the weight was \"not great,\" eye-opening.  \n- Result 36 (2023-12-17): Sam is struggling with weight affecting his confidence and motivation.  \n- Result 26 (2023-10-17): Sam had a health scare with severe stomachache, diagnosed as gastritis, which was alarming and a wake-up call to prioritize health.  \n- Result 7 and 26 together suggest weight is a serious health risk and Sam had gastritis.  \n\nStep 2: Check if the ailment due to weight is explicitly stated.  \n- The doctor warned about weight being a serious health risk (Result 7).",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.42,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.65
    },
    {
      "question": "Does Evan live close to a beach or mountains?",
      "category": 3,
      "gold_answer": "beach",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for mentions of Evan's location or places he frequently visits.  \n- Result 5: Evan says, \"Yeah, it's this peaceful place close to my home. I often go there to relax and unwind.\" (referring to a beach spot)  \n- Result 11: Evan says, \"This little island is where I grew up and it's my happy place.\" (likely the beach spot)  \n- Result 42 and 50: Evan describes the place as \"a little slice of paradise,\" \"so peaceful and serene,\" and \"that place shaped me.\"  \n- Result 55: Evan mentions a favorite spot by the beach where he watches sunsets.  \n- Result 33 and 39: Evan talks about a road trip to the Rocky Mountains and mentions the mountains as a place he visits, but not necessarily near home.  \n- Result 49: Evan says the peaceful place is \"only a two-hour drive from here,\" implying the beach spot is close",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.73,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.27
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Evan lose his job?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "end of October 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the messages about Evan losing his job.  \n- Result 1 (2023-11-09): Sam asks Evan about his job loss.  \n- Result 4 (2023-11-09): Evan explains the company downsized and he was part of that.  \n- Result 5 (2023-11-09): Sam responds sympathetically about the job loss.  \n- Result 6 (2023-12-05): Sam comments on the setback from the job loss.  \n\nStep 2: The earliest mention of the job loss is on 2023-11-09, when Evan says the company downsized and he was part of that. This implies Evan lost his job around or shortly before November 9, 2023.\n\nStep 3: There is no earlier mention of the job loss in the context, so the job loss likely happened in early November 2023 or just before November 9, 2023.\n\nFinal",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.9,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.65
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Evan and Sam planned a trip to the beach together?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "December, 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for mentions of a beach trip planned by Evan and Sam.\n\nStep 2: In Result 78 [2023-11-09T21:22:30], Evan says to Sam: \"That picture was actually taken last Friday at my favorite spot by the beach... We should definitely plan to go together someday.\"\n\nStep 3: This is the only explicit mention of planning a beach trip together.\n\nStep 4: The message is dated November 9, 2023, and Evan refers to planning a future trip \"someday,\" indicating no specific date was set yet.\n\nFinal answer:  \nEvan and Sam discussed planning a trip to the beach together around November 9, 2023, but no specific date was set.",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.95,
      "judge_latency_s": 4.33
    },
    {
      "question": "What was Sam doing on December 4, 2023?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "Attending a Weight Watchers meeting",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for any direct mention of Sam's activities around December 4, 2023.  \nStep 2: The closest relevant message is from 2023-12-31 (Result 86), where Sam says: \"Hey Evan! I\u2019m really getting into this healthier lifestyle\u2014just took my friends on an epic hiking trip last Friday!\"  \nStep 3: December 31, 2023, was a Sunday. The \"last Friday\" before that would be December 29, 2023, so this hiking trip was after December 4.  \nStep 4: No other messages mention Sam's activities specifically on or around December 4, 2023.  \nStep 5: No direct or indirect information about Sam's activity on December 4, 2023, is found in the context.\n\nFinal answer: Not enough information.",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.47,
      "judge_latency_s": 3.74
    },
    {
      "question": "Which two significant life events occur in Evan's life in December 2023 with his partner?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "his partner gets pregnant and they get married",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Evan's significant life events in December 2023.\n\n- Result 21 (2023-12-26): Evan tells Sam he got married last week, approximately December 19, 2023.\n- Result 41 (2023-12-26): Evan confirms the woman he married is the Canadian woman he met earlier and expresses his love for her.\n- Result 99 (2024-01-06): Evan says he and his partner told their extended family about their marriage yesterday (January 5, 2024), indicating the marriage was recent and the announcement was a separate event.\n\nStep 2: Summarize the two significant life events in December 2023.\n\n- Evan got married around December 19, 2023.\n- Evan and his partner shared the news of their marriage with their extended family shortly after, around early January 2024, but the marriage itself was in December.\n\nStep 3: Confirm no other major",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.66,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.1
    },
    {
      "question": "How long did Evan and his partner date before getting married?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "four months",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Evan met the Canadian woman around the end of July 2023 (Result 33: \"Last week (approximately July 31, 2023) I went on a trip to Canada and met this awesome Canadian woman\").\n\nStep 2: Evan got married last week before December 26, 2023, which is approximately December 19, 2023 (Result 4).\n\nStep 3: The time between meeting (around July 31, 2023) and marriage (around December 19, 2023) is about 3.5 months.\n\nStep 4: There is no other information suggesting a longer or shorter dating period.\n\nFinal answer: Evan and his partner dated for about three and a half months before getting married.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.18,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.46
    },
    {
      "question": "Which major holiday season conincides with Evan's wedding?",
      "category": 3,
      "gold_answer": "Christmas",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify when Evan's wedding was announced or discussed.  \n- Result 16 (2024-01-06) says Evan told his extended family about the marriage \"yesterday,\" approximately January 5, 2024.  \n- Result 3 and 9 (2023-12-31) mention a minor accident related to the marriage and telling work friends about it, indicating the marriage happened before or around late December 2023.  \n- Result 4 and 18 (2023-12-26) show Evan talking about his partner and love, suggesting the marriage was recent by late December 2023.\n\nStep 2: Look for holiday season references around the time of the marriage.  \n- The messages around late December 2023 (Results 3, 4, 18, 38) coincide with Christmas and New Year holidays.  \n- Result 3 (2023-12-31) references the marriage and a mishap, indicating",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 4.25,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.58
    },
    {
      "question": "Which activity did Sam resume in December 2023 after a long time?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "hiking",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for mentions of activities Sam did or resumed around December 2023.\n\nStep 2: In Result 80 (2023-12-17), Sam says to Evan: \"I used to love hiking, but it's been a while since I had the chance to do it.\"\n\nStep 3: In Result 71 (2023-12-31), Sam tells Evan: \"I\u2019m really getting into this healthier lifestyle\u2014just took my friends on an epic hiking trip last Friday!\"\n\nStep 4: The \"last Friday\" before 2023-12-31 would be December 22, 2023.\n\nStep 5: This shows Sam resumed hiking in December 2023 after a long time.\n\nFinal answer: Sam resumed hiking in December 2023 after a long time.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.22,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.7
    },
    {
      "question": "When is Evan planning a big family reunion?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "Summer 2024",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of a big family reunion in the context.  \n- Result 1 [2023-12-09]: Evan to Sam says, \"we're planning a big family reunion next summer.\"\n\nStep 2: Determine the date of the message to understand which summer \"next summer\" refers to.  \n- The message is from December 9, 2023.  \n- \"Next summer\" from December 2023 would be summer 2024.\n\nFinal answer:  \nEvan is planning a big family reunion for summer 2024.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.76,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.53
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Evan's son fall off his bike?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "Thursday before December 17, 2023.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant excerpt about Evan's son falling off his bike.  \n- Result 2 [2023-12-17]: Evan says, \"my son had an accident last Tuesday, he fell off his bike and it was rough.\"\n\nStep 2: Determine the date of \"last Tuesday\" relative to the message date.  \n- The message is dated 2023-12-17 (Sunday).  \n- The Tuesday before 2023-12-17 is 2023-12-12.\n\nFinal answer: Evan's son fell off his bike on Tuesday, December 12, 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.34,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.72
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Evan announce his marriage to his extended family?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "January 5, 2024",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the message where Evan mentions telling his extended family about the marriage.  \n- Result 5 [2024-01-06T13:32:00] Evan to Sam: \"My partner and I told our extended fam about our marriage yesterday (approximately January 05, 2024) \u2013 it was so special!\"\n\nStep 2: Confirm the date of the announcement.  \n- The message is dated January 6, 2024, and Evan says \"yesterday,\" which means the announcement was made on January 5, 2024.\n\nFinal answer:  \nEvan announced his marriage to his extended family on January 5, 2024.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.84,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.8
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Evan finish the painting that's hanging in the exhibit?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "few days before 17 December, 2023.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the painting hanging in the exhibit.\n- Result 2 (2023-12-17): Evan says the painting was published in the exhibition.\n- Result 3 (2023-12-17): Evan says he finished a contemporary figurative painting a few days ago, which is likely the one in the exhibit.\n\nStep 2: Determine when Evan finished the painting.\n- Result 3 is dated 2023-12-17 and says the painting was finished \"a few days ago.\"\n- \"A few days ago\" from December 17, 2023, would be around December 14-15, 2023.\n\nFinal answer: Evan finished the painting hanging in the exhibit around mid-December 2023, a few days before December 17, 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.36,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.75
    },
    {
      "question": "How does Evan spend his time with his bride after the wedding?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "family get-together, honeymoon in Canada to see snowy landscapes, ski, taste local cuisine and do some snowshoeing",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Evan's activities with his bride after the wedding.\n\n- Result 5 (2024-01-06): Sam to Evan mentions \"Skiing, trying local dishes, and enjoying the breathtaking views - the perfect honeymoon.\"\n- Result 66 (2024-01-06): Sam asks Evan about plans for the trip, implying they are on a honeymoon or trip.\n- Result 7 (2024-01-06): Evan says they told their extended family about the marriage on January 5, 2024, indicating the wedding was recent.\n- Result 3 and 49 (2023-12-26 and 2023-12-25): Evan mentions being in love and that he got married last week (around December 19, 2023).\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.\n\nEvan and his bride are spending time skiing, trying local dishes, and enjoying scenic views, which Sam describes as a perfect honeymoon.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.62,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.15
    },
    {
      "question": "Who did Evan tell about his marriage?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "To Sam, to his friends from work, and to his and his wife's families.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Evan telling others about his marriage.\n\n- Result 3 (2024-01-06): Evan told his extended family about the marriage on January 5, 2024.\n- Result 11 (2023-12-31): Evan mentions telling his work friends about getting married.\n- Result 32 (2023-12-26): Evan says he got married last week (around December 19, 2023), implying the marriage was recent.\n- Result 49 (2024-01-06): Evan mentions their families are happy for them.\n- Result 1 (2023-12-31): Sam references a mishap but says \"they\" were thrilled to hear about Evan's marriage, likely referring to family or friends.\n\nStep 2: Summarize who Evan told.\n\nEvan told his extended family (Result 3), his work friends (Result 11), and his families (Result 49) about his marriage",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.33,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.69
    },
    {
      "question": "When will Evan and his partner have their honeymoon in Canada?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "February 2024",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify any direct mentions of the honeymoon timing.  \n- Result 1 (2024-01-06): Evan says, \"We're off to Canada next month for our honeymoon.\"  \n- Result 7 (2023-11-09): Evan says, \"Let's plan it for next month,\" referring to a trip to Canada.  \n- Result 23 (2023-12-26): Evan says he got married last week (around December 19, 2023).  \n- Result 9 (2024-01-06): Evan says they told extended family about their marriage \"yesterday\" (around January 5, 2024).\n\nStep 2: Determine the date of the conversation mentioning the honeymoon trip.  \n- The honeymoon mention is on 2024-01-06, saying \"next month,\" which would be February 2024.\n\nStep 3: Confirm no conflicting information.  \n- Earlier mentions of planning a trip \"next month",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.22,
      "judge_latency_s": 4.65
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Evan have a drunken night with his friends?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "January 9, 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Evan having a drunken night.\n- Result 1 (2024-01-10): Evan says \"Yesterday (approximately January 09, 2024) I went out with my friends and had a bit too much to drink.\"\n- Result 25 (2024-01-10): Evan mentions a pee accident near some roses during that night.\n- Result 26 (2024-01-11): Evan refers to apologizing to his partner for that drunken night.\n- Result 4 and 85 (2024-01-10): Evan confirms the incident happened recently and he was embarrassed.\n\nStep 2: Confirm the date of the drunken night.\n- Since the message on 2024-01-10 says \"Yesterday (approximately January 09, 2024),\" the drunken night was on January 9, 2024.\n\nFinal answer:  \nEvan had the drunken night with his friends on January 9, 2024",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.97,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.93
    },
    {
      "question": "What is a stress reliever for Evan?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Drawing, traveling, places with a beautiful view, yoga, sunsets or something comfortable for Evan",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Evan's stress relievers in the excerpts.\n\n- Result 1 (2023-05-18): Evan says he started \"doing this\" a few years back as a stress-buster (context suggests a hobby).\n- Result 2 (2023-09-11): Evan mentions painting and going for a drive help him de-stress.\n- Result 26 (2023-08-07): Evan talks about something symbolizing strength and resilience that motivates him.\n- Result 29 (2024-01-10): Evan mentions low-impact exercises like going on beach sunsets as calming and good for exercise.\n- Result 43 (2023-10-06): Evan says PT (physical therapy) helps, and he does easy exercises.\n- Result 76 (2023-10-08): Evan started lifting weights one year ago as part of his health journey.\n- Result 72 (2023-11-09): Evan mentions a peaceful",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.11,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.61
    },
    {
      "question": "What is a stress reliever for Sam?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Unhealthy snacks, sweets, yoga, places with beautiful views",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of stress relief or de-stressing activities related to Sam.\n\n- Result 5 (2023-09-11): Sam admires Evan's painting as a stress reliever and considers trying painting or another calming hobby.\n- Result 50 (2023-05-24): Sam asks Evan if painting will help de-stress.\n- Result 78 (2023-09-11): Sam expresses interest in trying painting and asks for supplies.\n- Result 22 (2024-01-11): Sam says being in nature helps them relax and get fresh air away from the city.\n- Result 27 (2024-01-11): Sam agrees that being in nature is calming.\n- Result 29 (2024-01-10): Sam hopes for positive changes from a healthier diet and yoga.\n- Result 26 (2023-11-21): Sam says nature can be soul-calming.\n- Result 63 (2023-09",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.78,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.83
    },
    {
      "question": "What type of car did Evan get after his old Prius broke down?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "new Prius",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: From Result 1 (2023-05-18), Evan mentions his old Prius broke down and he decided to get it repaired and sell it.\n\nStep 2: In Result 3 (2023-12-05), Evan says he bought a new Prius, which then broke down.\n\nStep 3: Result 2 (2023-12-05) confirms Evan was counting on his new Prius to be reliable.\n\nStep 4: No other car type is mentioned as a replacement.\n\nFinal answer: Evan got a new Prius after his old Prius broke down.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.53,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.7
    },
    {
      "question": "How did Evan get into watercolor painting?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "friend's advice",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for mentions of how Evan started watercolor painting.  \n- Result 66: Evan says, \"My friend got me into it and gave me some advice, and I was hooked right away!\"  \n- Result 27: Evan says, \"It all started when a friend of mine gave me this painting one day, it inspired me a lot and that's when I started painting.\"  \n- Result 24: Evan mentions starting painting classes a few days ago (in 2023-08), indicating he took formal classes after initial interest.  \n- Result 2 and 89: Evan talks about painting classes and learning watercolors, but the initial interest came from a friend and inspiration from a painting.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.  \nEvan got into watercolor painting because a friend gave him a painting that inspired him, and that friend also gave him advice which hooked him immediately. Later, he joined painting classes to improve and connect with like-minded people.\n\nFinal",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.21,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.66
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Evan start doing a few years back as a stress-buster?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "watercolor painting",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about Evan's stress-buster habits.\n\n- Result 1 (2023-05-18): Evan says, \"Yep, it's a great stress-buster. I started doing this a few years back.\"\n- Result 54 (2023-07-27): Evan mentions struggling with health a few years ago and shows his gym membership card, implying exercise.\n- Result 85 (2023-10-06): Evan says painting is a great stress reliever and shares what he did recently.\n- Result 13 (2023-09-11): Evan mentions painting or going for a drive helps when stressed.\n\nStep 2: Connect the dots.\n\n- Evan started a stress-buster a few years ago (Result 1).\n- He has a gym membership and made lifestyle changes a few years ago (Result 54).\n- He also uses painting as a stress reliever (Results 13, 85).\n- Since Result 1 is a",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.43,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.9
    },
    {
      "question": "What advice did Evan give Sam about finding a passion?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "keep trying new things until something sparks excitement",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts where Evan talks about finding passion or trying new things.\n\n- Result 1 (2023-12-17): Evan encourages stepping out of comfort zone and trying something new, even if small.\n- Result 3 (2023-12-17): Evan says trying something new and succeeding gives a great feeling of accomplishment.\n- Result 12 (2023-05-18): Evan advises to keep trying new things until something sparks excitement.\n- Result 6 (2023-12-26): Evan encourages Sam to keep trying new things and find their own version of love.\n- Result 41 (2023-12-17): Evan asks Sam if they have hobbies or activities that make them happy.\n- Result 59 (2023-08-07): Evan mentions family motivates him to stay healthy, implying motivation can come from personal sources.\n- Result 95 (2023-08-19): Evan shares how a friend inspired him to start",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.79,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.63
    },
    {
      "question": "Where did Evan take his family for a road trip on 24 May, 2023?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Jasper",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the date of the road trip mentioned by Evan around May 24, 2023.  \n- Result 52 [2023-05-24T19:11:00] Evan to Sam: \"Last weekend, I took my family on a road trip to Jasper. It was amazing! We drove through the Icefields Parkway and the glaciers and lakes were gorgeous.\"\n\nStep 2: Confirm the location of the road trip.  \n- The location is clearly stated as Jasper, with specific mention of the Icefields Parkway, glaciers, and lakes.\n\nStep 3: Cross-check for any other mentions of the same trip.  \n- Result 17 [2023-05-24T19:11:30] Sam to Evan: \"Hey Evan, looks amazing! I've never been to Jasper, but it looks breathtaking. Tell me more about your road trip. Was it relaxing?\"  \n- This confirms the location as Jasper.\n\nFinal answer:  \nEvan took",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.36,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.66
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Evan find relaxing about his road trip to Jasper?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "fresh air, peacefulness, cozy cabin surrounded by mountains and forests",
      "generated_answer": "Evan found the road trip to Jasper relaxing because of the fresh air, peacefulness, and staying in a cozy cabin surrounded by mountains and forests, which made it feel like a real retreat (Result 9). Additionally, he mentioned the gorgeous glaciers and lakes along the Icefields Parkway that contributed to the amazing experience (Result 2). \n\nFinal answer: Evan found the fresh air, peacefulness, and a cozy cabin surrounded by mountains and forests relaxing during his road trip to Jasper.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.36,
      "judge_latency_s": 3.15
    },
    {
      "question": "What habit is Sam trying to change in terms of diet?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "consuming soda and candy",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Sam's diet habits and changes.\n\n- Result 29 (2023-06-06): Sam says no changes, still enjoying soda and candy.\n- Result 20 (2023-07-27): Sam says reducing soda and candy intake.\n- Result 9 (2023-09-11): Sam struggles with cravings for sugary drinks and snacks.\n- Result 36 (2023-07-27): Sam motivated to make changes after friends mocked weight.\n- Result 70 (2023-10-08): Sam's doctor warned about weight as a serious health risk.\n- Result 39 (2023-08-19): Sam on a diet and living healthier.\n- Result 5 (2024-01-10): Sam mentions healthier diet and yoga.\n- Result 13 (2024-01-10): Sam plans to ask doctor about balanced diet and low-impact exercises.\n- Result 78 (2023-08-15",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.4,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.19
    },
    {
      "question": "What new suggestion did Evan give to Sam regarding his soda and candy consumption?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "try flavored seltzer water and dark chocolate with high cocoa content",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant excerpts where Evan talks about soda and candy consumption and suggests alternatives.\n\n- Result 10 (2023-07-27): Evan mentions cutting down on sugary snacks and eating more veggies and fruit, and asks Sam if he has considered any changes.\n- Result 54 (2023-06-06): Evan suggests swapping soda for flavored seltzer water as a bubbly, tasty alternative without sugar, and replacing candy with dark chocolate with high cocoa content as a healthier option.\n- Result 6 and 11 (2023-07-27): Evan suggests flavored seltzer water as a great alternative to soda and pairs it with air-popped popcorn or fruit as low-calorie snacks.\n\nStep 2: Confirm Sam's response to these suggestions.\n\n- Result 12 (2023-07-27): Sam says he has tried flavored seltzer before and asks for more low-calorie snack ideas.\n- Result 54 shows Evan's detailed suggestion about",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.49,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.69
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Sam agree to try instead of soda and candy?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "flavored seltzer water and dark chocolate with high cocoa content",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Sam's habits with soda and candy.  \n- Result 2 (2023-06-06): Sam says no changes yet, still enjoying soda and candy.  \n- Result 3 (2023-07-27): Sam says he is reducing soda and candy intake.  \n- Result 17 (2023-07-27): Sam says he has tried flavored seltzer before and asks for low-calorie snack ideas to pair with it.  \n- Result 10 (2023-06-06): Evan suggests swapping soda for flavored seltzer water and candy for dark chocolate.  \n- Result 1 & 6 (2023-07-27): Evan encourages Sam to try flavored seltzer water as a soda alternative and suggests healthy snacks like air-popped popcorn or fruit.  \n- Result 58 (2023-07-27): Evan encourages healthy swaps and small steps.  \n\nStep 2: Confirm what Sam agreed",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.44,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.58
    },
    {
      "question": "What frustrating issue did Sam face at the supermarket?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "broken self-checkout machines",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify any mention of Sam facing a frustrating issue at the supermarket.  \nStep 2: Check the context for details about what specifically happened.\n\nFrom Result 28 [2023-06-06T16:02:30], Sam says to Evan: \"Cool, can't wait! Thank you. By the way, I'm coming from the shop and I had a frustrating issue at the supermarket. The self-checkout machines were all broken, my mood is terrible now!\"\n\nThis clearly states the frustrating issue Sam faced was that all the self-checkout machines at the supermarket were broken.\n\nFinal answer:  \nSam was frustrated because all the self-checkout machines at the supermarket were broken.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.85,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.38
    },
    {
      "question": "What novel is Evan reading that he finds gripping?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "The Great Gatsby",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Evan reading a novel.  \n- In [Result 25] (2023-07-27), Evan mentions: \"Btw I can't stop thinking about that new mystery novel I started. It's so gripping!\"  \n- In [Result 8] (2023-08-27), Evan says: \"By the way, remember that book I was talking about? It just gets better with every page, can't let it out of my hands!\"\n\nStep 2: Check if the novel's title or name is given anywhere.  \n- No specific title or name of the novel is mentioned in any excerpt.\n\nStep 3: Confirm the novel is described as gripping and a mystery.  \n- Evan calls it a \"new mystery novel\" and \"so gripping\" in [Result 25].\n\nFinal answer:  \nEvan is reading a new mystery novel that he finds very gripping, but the specific title is not mentioned.",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.17,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.92
    },
    {
      "question": "What kind of water does Evan suggest Sam try as an alternative to soda?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Flavored seltzer water",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Evan suggesting an alternative to soda.  \n- In Result 8 (2023-06-06), Evan suggests swapping soda for flavored seltzer water.  \n- In Result 1 (2023-07-27), Evan again suggests flavored seltzer water as a great alternative to soda.  \n- In Result 6 (2023-07-27), Evan mentions flavored seltzer with snacks as a healthy option.\n\nStep 2: Confirm the exact type of water suggested.  \nEvan consistently recommends \"flavored seltzer water\" as the alternative.\n\nFinal answer:  \nEvan suggests Sam try flavored seltzer water as an alternative to soda.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.13,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.52
    },
    {
      "question": "What does the smartwatch help Evan with?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "tracks progress and serves as a constant reminder to keep going",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of a smartwatch or similar device in the context.  \n- Result 12 [2023-08-07T19:56:00] Evan to Sam: \"My family motivates me to stay healthy. Well, it helps a lot with my health goals. It tracks my progress really well and serves as a constant reminder to keep going.\"  \n- Result 40 [2023-08-07T19:57:00] Evan to Sam: \"It's been awesome, Sam! That visual reminder has been really motivating.\"\n\nStep 2: From these excerpts, the \"it\" refers to something that tracks progress and serves as a reminder, which aligns with a smartwatch's typical function.\n\nStep 3: The smartwatch helps Evan by tracking his health progress and motivating him to keep going with his health goals.\n\nFinal answer:  \nThe smartwatch helps Evan by tracking his health progress and serving as a constant motivating reminder to stay on track with his health goals.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.82,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.28
    },
    {
      "question": "What does the bonsai tree symbolize for Evan?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "strength and resilience",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant excerpt about the bonsai tree.  \n- Result 1 [2023-08-07]: Evan says he got the bonsai tree because it symbolizes strength and resilience.  \n\nStep 2: Confirm the meaning Evan attributes to the bonsai tree.  \n- He mentions it motivates him to keep going through tough times, reinforcing the symbolism of strength and resilience.  \n\nFinal answer:  \nThe bonsai tree symbolizes strength and resilience for Evan, motivating him to persevere through tough times.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.54,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.46
    },
    {
      "question": "Why did Evan decide to get the bonsai tree?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "motivates him to keep going through tough times",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about the bonsai tree.\n\n- Result 1 (Sam to Evan, 2023-08-07): \"Nice! What made you decide to get that?\"\n- Result 8 (Evan to Sam, 2023-08-07): \"I got this because it symbolizes strength and resilience. Taking care of it motivates me to keep going through tough times.\"\n- Result 42 (Evan to Sam, 2023-08-07): \"Yep, that's it. Find something that motivates you and makes you happy, whether it's large or tiny. It'll help us conquer the struggles we encounter.\"\n- Result 68 (Sam to Evan, 2023-08-07): \"Wow, it's amazing! So powerful yet so simple.\"\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.\n\nEvan got the bonsai tree because it symbolizes strength and resilience, and caring for it serves as motivation to persevere through difficult times.\n\nFinal answer",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.83,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.13
    },
    {
      "question": "According to Sam, what is more important than perfection?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "progress",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts where Sam talks about perfection or related concepts.\n\n- Result 3 (2023-08-13): Sam says, \"It reminds me that progress is more important than perfection.\"\n- Result 57 (2023-08-13): Sam quotes, \"Don't fear it, just take the first step. It's been helping me move forward to healthier habits!\"\n- Result 58 (2023-07-27): Sam says, \"That reminder is inspiring. Thanks for reminding me to focus on progress, not perfection.\"\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.\n\nSam clearly states that progress is more important than perfection and focuses on taking small steps forward rather than fearing the process.\n\nFinal answer: According to Sam, progress is more important than perfection.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.96,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.42
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Evan suggest Sam to check out for insights into his dream?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "dream interpretation book",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant conversation about Sam's dream.  \n- Result 97 (2023-08-13) Sam mentions an amazing dream about soaring over skyscrapers.  \n- Result 1 (2023-08-13) Evan responds to Sam's dream by suggesting something for insight.\n\nStep 2: Check what Evan suggested.  \n- Result 1: Evan says, \"Maybe you should check out a dream interpretation book; it could offer some insights.\"\n\nStep 3: Confirm no other suggestions contradict or add to this.  \n- Result 22 and 9 mention the dream again but no other suggestions from Evan about insight.\n\nFinal answer:  \nEvan suggested that Sam check out a dream interpretation book for insights into his dream.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.1,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.88
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Evan mention he had been searching for fruitlessly for half an hour?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "his keys",
      "generated_answer": "I carefully reviewed all the conversation excerpts provided. There is no mention anywhere in the context of Evan searching fruitlessly for anything for half an hour, let alone fruit.\n\nTherefore, the answer is:\n\nNot enough information.",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.15,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.55
    },
    {
      "question": "What class is Sam taking to learn how to make healthier meals?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "cooking class",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Sam taking a class related to healthy meals.\n- Result 9 (2023-08-15): Sam says, \"The cooking class has been great, I've learned awesome recipes.\"\n- Result 12 (2023-08-15): Evan refers to \"the class you're taking is packed with healthy recipes.\"\n\nStep 2: Confirm the type of class.\n- The phrase \"cooking class\" in Result 9 directly indicates the class is about cooking.\n- The context of learning recipes and healthy meals supports this.\n\nFinal answer:  \nSam is taking a cooking class to learn how to make healthier meals.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.72,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.15
    },
    {
      "question": "What dish did Sam make on 18 August, 2023 that turned out flavorful?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "grilled dish with salmon and vegetables",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the date close to August 18, 2023, when Sam mentioned making a dish.  \nStep 2: Result 39 [2023-08-15T16:22:30] Sam to Evan says: \"Thanks, Evan! I marinated it with a few different ingredients and grilled it with some veggies. It turned out really flavorful!\"  \nStep 3: This message is just a few days before August 18, 2023, and refers to a grilled dish with marinade and veggies that turned out flavorful.  \nStep 4: Result 36 [2023-08-19T18:20:00] Sam to Evan says: \"Sure, I'm loving this recipe I found. It's a flavorful and healthy grilled chicken and veggie stir-fry. Wanna give it a go?\"  \nStep 5: This confirms the dish is a grilled chicken and veggie stir-fry, described as flavorful.  \nStep 6: The question",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.37,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.39
    },
    {
      "question": "What kind of recipe did Evan request from Sam on 19 August, 2023?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "recipes with more vegetables",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the date and relevant messages around 19 August 2023.\n\n- Result 3 [2023-08-19T18:22:00] Sam to Evan: \"Sure thing! Here's the recipe. Let me know how it went!\"\n- Result 4 [2023-08-19T18:20:30] Evan to Sam: \"Mmm, looks yummy! Is the sauce a family secret? I'm always down to try new recipes!\"\n- Result 5 [2023-08-19T18:21:30] Evan to Sam: \"Yeah, I'd love to! Thanks for sharing the recipe.\"\n- Result 6 [2023-08-19T18:21:00] Sam to Evan: \"Nah, it's just my homemade sauce. Want the recipe?\"\n- Result 14 [2023-08-19T18:17:00] Sam to Evan: \"Hey Evan, some big news: I'm",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.51,
      "judge_latency_s": 3.29
    },
    {
      "question": "What food did Sam share a photo of on 19 August, 2023?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "bowl of spinach, avocado, and strawberries",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the date and relevant messages around 19 August 2023.\n\n- Result 25 [2023-08-19T18:19:30] Evan to Sam: Mentions healthy meals and asks for favorite recipes.\n- Result 35 [2023-08-19T18:22:00] Sam to Evan: \"Sure thing! Here's the recipe. Let me know how it went!\"\n- Result 56 [2023-08-19T18:21:00] Sam to Evan: \"Nah, it's just my homemade sauce. Want the recipe?\"\n- Result 41 [2023-08-15T16:21:30] Sam to Evan: Mentions a cooking class and a yummy grilled dish made last night (Aug 14).\n- Result 12 [2023-08-19T18:20:30] Evan to Sam: Asks if the sauce is a family secret, showing interest in a dish Sam",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.78,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.01
    },
    {
      "question": "What type of painting classes did Evan start taking in 2023?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "watercolor painting classes",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify when Evan started taking painting classes.  \n- Result 7 (2023-08-19): Evan says he started taking painting classes a few days ago and is enjoying it.  \n- Result 12 (2023-08-19): Evan mentions that in painting classes, they have been learning about watercolors.  \n\nStep 2: Confirm the type of painting taught in the classes.  \n- Result 12 explicitly states the classes focus on watercolors, with an emphasis on observing nature and painting what they see.  \n- Result 6 and 11 (October 2023) also mention Evan doing watercolor painting, consistent with the class focus.  \n\nStep 3: Synthesize the information.  \nEvan started taking painting classes around mid-August 2023, and these classes focus on watercolor painting techniques.  \n\nFinal answer:  \nEvan started taking watercolor painting classes in 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 9.52,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.76
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Evan start painting years ago due to being inspired by a friend's gift?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "forest scene",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant excerpts about Evan starting painting and being inspired by a friend's gift.\n\n- Result 13 [2023-08-19]: Evan says, \"It all started when a friend of mine gave me this painting one day, it inspired me a lot and that's when I started painting.\"\n- Result 14 [2023-08-19]: Sam asks why Evan started painting years ago.\n- Result 79 [2023-05-24]: Evan mentions he has been painting for a few years now and that painting helps him find peace.\n\nStep 2: Determine what type of painting Evan started with.\n\n- Result 7 [2023-08-19]: Evan says, \"I love painting landscapes. Nature's beauty captivates me and brings me peace. Here's one of my recent works.\"\n- Result 25 [2023-08-19]: Evan mentions learning about watercolors in painting classes.\n- Result 79 [2023-05-24",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.66,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.09
    },
    {
      "question": "What nature concept do watercolor painting classes emphasize according to Evan?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "observing nature and painting what is seen",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about watercolor painting classes and nature concepts.\n\n- Result 1 [2023-08-19]: Evan says, \"In painting classes, we've been learning about watercolors. The instructor stresses observing nature and painting what we see.\"\n- Result 16 [2023-08-19]: Evan says, \"I aim to capture the vibe of nature in my paintings, conveying the peacefulness of being outdoors.\"\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.\n\nThe watercolor painting classes emphasize closely observing nature and painting what is actually seen, focusing on capturing the vibe and peacefulness of nature.\n\nFinal answer:  \nWatercolor painting classes emphasize observing nature carefully and painting what is seen to capture the peacefulness and vibe of the outdoors.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 5.69,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.51
    },
    {
      "question": "What type of landscapes does Evan love painting the most?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "sunsets over the ocean",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about Evan's painting preferences.  \n- Result 1: Evan says, \"I love painting landscapes. Nature's beauty captivates me and brings me peace.\"  \n- Result 6: Sam asks how Evan captures the tranquil beauty of nature in his paintings.  \n- Result 15: Evan replies, \"I aim to capture the vibe of nature in my paintings, conveying the peacefulness of being outdoors.\"  \n- Result 7: Evan mentions learning watercolors in painting classes, focusing on observing nature and painting what they see.  \n- Result 33: Evan says he started painting after a friend gave him a painting that inspired him, and he joined classes to find like-minded people.  \n- Result 39: Evan talks about going to the Rocky Mountains and feeling relaxed by the stunning views.  \n- Result 71: Evan mentions a road trip with stunning scenery that chilled him out.  \n- Result 46 & 55: Evan talks about nature",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.86,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.6
    },
    {
      "question": "What fun activity did Evan mention doing in July 2023?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "skiing",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of activities Evan did in July 2023.  \n- Result 9 (2023-08-19): Evan says he drove somewhere fun last month, approximately July 20, 2023, and the views were amazing.  \n- Result 53 (2023-08-27): Evan mentions a road trip last month (approximately July 28, 2023) with stunning scenery and nature that chilled him out.\n\nStep 2: Confirm the nature of the activity.  \n- Both excerpts describe a road trip or driving somewhere fun with great views and nature.\n\nStep 3: Check if any other fun activity in July 2023 is mentioned by Evan.  \n- No other specific fun activity in July 2023 is mentioned.\n\nFinal answer:  \nEvan mentioned taking a road trip with amazing views and enjoying nature in July 2023.",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.85,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.23
    },
    {
      "question": "What injury did Evan suffer from in August 2023?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Twisted knee",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of injuries related to Evan in August 2023.\n\n- Result 9 [2023-08-13]: Evan tells Sam his son had a soccer accident last Saturday (which would be around August 5, 2023) and hurt his ankle.\n- Result 4 [2023-08-15]: Evan confirms his son's ankle is getting better but still sore.\n- Result 1 [2023-08-15]: Sam acknowledges the son's ankle is getting better.\n- Result 55 [2023-12-17]: Evan mentions his son had an accident last Tuesday (December), fell off his bike, but this is a different incident and date.\n- Result 12 [2023-08-27]: Sam expresses sympathy for Evan's injury, but no specific injury mentioned here.\n- Result 33 [2023-10-06]: Sam mentions Evan's knee, but this is in October, not August.\n\nStep 2: Check",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.87,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.01
    },
    {
      "question": "What sports activity has Evan been doing to stay active while dealing with the knee injury?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Swimming",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Evan's knee injury and how he stays active.\n\n- Result 2 (2023-08-27): Evan twisted his knee last Friday and it's painful, making it tough to stay consistent with fitness.\n- Result 3 (2023-08-27): Evan says PT is planned, and meanwhile he is \"just keeping it low-key and swimming to stay active.\"\n- Result 5 (2023-08-27): Sam agrees swimming is a good low-impact choice.\n- Result 8 (2023-10-06): Evan says PT has helped, he can't do intense workouts but does easy exercises.\n- Result 17 (2023-10-06): Evan had a setback with his knee around Sept 29, 2023, making it tough to stay active.\n- Result 41 (2023-10-17): Evan mentions going to the gym and hiking.\n- Result 22 and 59 (2024-01",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.67,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.84
    },
    {
      "question": "What suggestion did Sam give to Evan to help with his knee issue?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Consider low-impact exercises or physical therapy",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the messages where Evan talks about his knee issue.  \n- Result 4 (2023-08-27): Evan twisted his knee last Friday and it's painful, making it hard to stay consistent with fitness.  \n- Result 5 (2023-08-27): Evan mentions physical therapy (PT) is planned and he is swimming to stay active.  \n- Result 3 (2023-10-06): Sam asks Evan if there are ways to stay active while he heals.  \n- Result 8 (2023-08-27): Sam responds that swimming is a good choice because it is low-impact and easy on the joints.\n\nStep 2: Look for any direct suggestions from Sam to Evan about managing the knee issue.  \n- Result 8 is a direct suggestion from Sam to Evan: \"Swimming is a good choice, Evan. It's low-impact and easy on the joints, plus it's refreshing. Keep up with the active lifestyle!\"\n\nStep ",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.78,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.54
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Evan suggest Sam try as a calming hobby?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Painting",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of calming hobbies suggested by Evan to Sam.  \n- Result 35 (2023-09-11): Evan says when stressed, he turns to comforting things like painting or going for a drive.  \n- Result 88 (2023-09-11): Evan explicitly suggests painting as a calming activity and offers to help Sam get started with supplies.  \n- Result 30 (2023-10-06): Evan mentions expressing yourself (likely through art) as therapeutic.  \n- Result 26 (2023-10-17): Evan suggests hiking as a way to bond with nature and push themselves.  \n- Result 56 (2024-01-10): Evan suggests low-impact exercises like going on beach sunsets for exercise and calming.  \n\nStep 2: Focus on calming hobbies specifically suggested by Evan. Painting is repeatedly mentioned as calming and therapeutic, with Evan offering to help Sam start it. Hiking is also suggested as calming and fun.  \n\nStep",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 4.44,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.74
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Evan recommend Sam acquire to get started with painting?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Acrylic paints, brushes, canvas/paper, palette",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant excerpts where Evan talks about helping Sam get started with painting.\n\n- Result 2 (2023-09-11): Evan offers to help Sam get started and recommend supplies.\n- Result 11 (2023-09-11): Evan lists specific supplies: \"Get some acrylic paints, brushes, a canvas/paper, and a palette to mix colors.\"\n- Result 70 (2023-09-11): Sam asks for basic supplies to get started.\n- Result 15 and 18 (2023-09-11): They plan a painting session.\n\nStep 2: Confirm the exact items Evan recommended.\n\nFrom Result 11: \"Get some acrylic paints, brushes, a canvas/paper, and a palette to mix colors.\"\n\nStep 3: No conflicting information found; this is the clearest and most detailed list.\n\nFinal answer:  \nEvan recommended Sam acquire acrylic paints, brushes, a canvas or paper, and a palette to mix",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.27,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.27
    },
    {
      "question": "What activity does Evan do to keep himself busy while healing his knee?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Watercolor painting",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Evan's knee injury and his activities during recovery.\n\n- Result 3 (2023-08-27): Evan twisted his knee last Friday and is having trouble staying consistent with fitness.\n- Result 2 (2023-08-27): Evan says PT is planned, and until then he is keeping it low-key and swimming to stay active.\n- Result 5 (2023-08-27): Sam encourages swimming as a good low-impact activity.\n- Result 12 (2023-10-06): Evan says PT has helped, he can't do intense workouts but is doing easy exercises.\n- Result 6 (2024-01-10): Evan mentions swimming, yoga, and walking as good low-impact exercises.\n\nStep 2: Focus on the specific activity Evan mentions doing while waiting for PT and healing.\n\n- The clearest direct statement is in Result 2: \"Till then, just keeping it low-key and swimming to stay active.\"\n\n",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.28,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.83
    },
    {
      "question": "What painting did Evan share with Sam in October?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "a cactus in the desert",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the timeframe for October conversations about paintings.  \n- Result 16 (2023-10-06): Sam asks Evan how he decides what to paint.  \n- Result 20 (2023-10-06): Sam asks about Evan's watercolor painting progress.  \n- Result 24 (2023-10-06): Evan mentions a painting he did last week (around Sept 29, 2023).  \n- Result 26 (2023-10-06): Evan explains he paints what\u2019s on his mind or feelings.  \n- Result 33 (2023-10-06): Evan talks about a recent adventure and doing watercolor painting.  \n- Result 63 (2023-10-06): Sam asks where Evan got inspiration for his paintings.  \n- Result 74 (2023-10-06): Evan says the sunset painting was inspired by a vacation a few years back, and the cactus painting came from a road trip last month",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.42,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.41
    },
    {
      "question": "What kind of writing does Sam enjoy as a form of expression?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "creative writing",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Sam's writing preferences in the context.\n\n- Result 32 (2023-10-06): Sam says, \"I love expressing myself through writing. It's therapeutic and helps me sort out my feelings.\"\n- Result 8 (2023-10-06): Sam to Evan says, \"Writing in my journal and doing creative writing is a good way for me to express my innermost thoughts and feelings.\"\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.\n\nSam enjoys writing in a journal and doing creative writing as forms of self-expression. This writing is therapeutic and helps Sam process feelings.\n\nFinal answer:  \nSam enjoys journaling and creative writing as ways to express thoughts and feelings.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.14,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.47
    },
    {
      "question": "What electronics issue has been frustrating Sam lately?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "malfunctioning navigation app on the new phone",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of electronics or devices in the context.  \nStep 2: Look for Sam's messages describing frustrations or problems with electronics.  \nStep 3: In Result 57 (2023-10-17), Sam mentions having a health scare and adds, \"On top of that, my phone's been giving me a hard time, adding to the stress.\"  \nStep 4: This is the only direct mention of an electronics issue related to Sam.  \n\nFinal answer:  \nSam has been frustrated lately because their phone has been giving them trouble.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.26,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.47
    },
    {
      "question": "What activity did Evan start one year ago?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "lifting weights",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the timeframe for \"one year ago.\" The latest messages are from early January 2024, so one year ago would be around January 2023.\n\nStep 2: Look for any mentions of Evan starting an activity around early 2023 or references to \"one year ago.\"\n\nStep 3: Review relevant excerpts about Evan's activities and when he started them.\n\n- Result 64 (2023-05-18): Evan says he got into watercolor painting because a friend got him into it and gave advice, and he was hooked right away.\n- Result 59 (2023-10-06): Sam asks Evan how his watercolor painting is going.\n- Result 8 (2023-08-19): Evan mentions skiing, snowboarding, and ice skating as winter activities he enjoys.\n- Result 48 (2023-10-17): Evan mentions going to the gym recently (October 16, 2023).\n- Result 74 (202",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.84,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.93
    },
    {
      "question": "What advice did Evan give to Sam to avoid injuries while starting weightlifting?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Find a trainer",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant excerpt about weightlifting advice from Evan to Sam.  \n- Result 1 (2023-10-08): Evan mentions starting weightlifting a year ago and offers to help Sam try it.  \n- Result 6 (2023-10-08): Evan advises Sam to start with good form and technique, find a trainer to avoid injuries, start small, increase intensity gradually, and stay consistent.\n\nStep 2: Extract the specific advice related to avoiding injuries.  \n- \"It's important to start out with good form and technique.\"  \n- \"Find a trainer who can help you avoid injuries while you build your strength.\"  \n- \"Start with something small, and as you get stronger, the intensity can increase.\"\n\nFinal answer:  \nEvan advised Sam to start weightlifting with good form and technique, find a trainer to help avoid injuries, begin with light weights, and gradually increase intensity as strength improves.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.58,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.82
    },
    {
      "question": "Where did Sam and his mate plan to try kayaking?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Lake Tahoe",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Sam and kayaking plans.  \n- Result 4: Sam to Evan says, \"my mate and I are just around the corner from kayaking on the lake, we're going to try that now!\"  \n- Result 5: Sam to Evan says, \"We're traveling through Lake Tahoe! I heard it's great for kayaking.\"  \n\nStep 2: Connect the location with kayaking plans.  \n- Sam mentions traveling through Lake Tahoe and that it is great for kayaking.  \n- Sam and his mate are about to try kayaking on a lake nearby, which aligns with the mention of Lake Tahoe.  \n\nFinal answer:  \nSam and his mate planned to try kayaking on Lake Tahoe.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.14,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.78
    },
    {
      "question": "What digestive issue did Sam experience lately?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Gastritis",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for mentions of Sam experiencing any digestive issues in the context.\n\nStep 2: In Result 29 [2023-10-17], Sam mentions having a health scare last weekend with a severe stomachache, which was diagnosed as gastritis.\n\nStep 3: In Result 36 [2023-10-17], Evan responds to Sam's gastritis, confirming the digestive issue.\n\nNo other digestive issues for Sam are mentioned.\n\nFinal answer:  \nSam recently experienced gastritis, which caused a severe stomachache and led to a health scare.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.69,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.29
    },
    {
      "question": "What adventurous theme is emerging in Evan's life as mentioned by Sam?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "helping lost tourists",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of adventure related to Evan in the context.\n\n- Result 23 (2023-08-07): Evan says he is motivated by a thirst for adventure on interesting hikes.\n- Result 19 (2023-12-05): Evan is trying to see life as a chance to explore other ways of staying active and traveling, maybe trying something different.\n- Result 7 (2024-01-06): Sam mentions Evan skiing, trying local dishes, and enjoying breathtaking views on a honeymoon, which is adventurous.\n- Result 85 (2023-08-19): Evan enjoys skiing, snowboarding, and ice skating as fun winter activities.\n- Result 92 (2023-10-14): Evan asks Sam if she is ready for an adventure and where she will go.\n- Result 65 (2023-11-09): Evan is excited about planning a trip with Sam next month.\n- Result 67 (2023-08-27",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.77,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.58
    },
    {
      "question": "What does Evan mention about his progress at the gym to Sam?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "gaining strength",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify all mentions of Evan's gym progress in the context.\n\n- Result 4 (2023-10-17): Evan says he was just at the gym yesterday (Oct 16, 2023) and is gaining strength.\n- Result 34 (2023-10-08): Evan mentions he started lifting weights one year ago, it was a struggle at first, but he's seeing some gains.\n- Result 55 (2023-10-25): Evan says letting go of unrealistic expectations was liberating physically and mentally, implying progress.\n- Result 100 (2023-10-25): Evan mentions going through a similar phase two years ago, changing diet and walking regularly.\n- Result 69 (2023-08-07): Evan talks about a visual reminder symbolizing strength and resilience that motivates him to keep going.\n- Result 40 (2023-08-07): Evan says the visual reminder has been really motivating.\n- Result 30",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.92,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.67
    },
    {
      "question": "How did Evan start his transformation journey two years ago?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Changed his diet and started walking regularly",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify when Evan started his transformation journey.  \n- Result 74 (2023-08-07) mentions Evan has been working on his healthy road for two years.  \n- Result 100 (2023-10-25) says Evan went through a similar phase two years ago and changed his diet, started walking regularly, etc.\n\nStep 2: Look for details on how Evan started.  \n- Result 100 states Evan changed his diet and started walking regularly as initial steps.  \n- Result 14 and 40 (2023-10-25) mention focusing on well-being and letting go of pressure, but these seem like mindset shifts after starting.  \n- Result 62 (2023-07-27) mentions focusing on healthy swaps and small steps, consistent with initial changes.\n\nFinal answer:  \nEvan started his transformation journey two years ago by changing his diet and beginning to walk regularly as part of adopting healthier habits.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.5,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.73
    },
    {
      "question": "What gift did Evan receive from a close friend?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "1968 Kustom K-200A vintage guitar",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of gifts from close friends in the context.  \n- Result 4 [2023-12-17]: Evan to Sam says, \"That's a close friend of mine who helped me get this painting published in the exhibition!\"  \n- Result 15 [2023-12-26]: Sam to Evan shares a painting that inspired them at an exhibit, but this is not a gift to Evan.  \n- Result 79 [2023-12-17]: Sam to Evan comments on a painting in the background of a photo, likely related to the exhibition painting.\n\nStep 2: Confirm the gift is the painting published in the exhibition, helped by a close friend.\n\nFinal answer:  \nEvan received help from a close friend to get a painting published in an exhibition.",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.84,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.96
    },
    {
      "question": "Why had Evan been going through a tough time lately?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Lost their job due to downsizing",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Evan going through tough times.  \n- Result 1 (2023-12-17): Sam says \"Same here, it's been tough lately.\"  \n- Result 23 (2023-12-17): Evan mentions his son had an accident last Tuesday (around 2023-12-12), which was rough but son is better now.  \n- Result 87 (2023-11-09): Evan says company downsized and he was part of that, currently job hunting and it's been tough.  \n- Result 10 (2023-12-31): Evan refers to an accident being minor, implying some recent incident.  \n- Result 25 (2023-08-15): Evan talks about his son having a soccer accident last Saturday (around 2023-08-12), hurting his ankle, which was tough.  \n- Result 95 (2023-06-06): Evan had a health scare (heart palp",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.05,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.89
    },
    {
      "question": "How does Evan describe the island he grew up on?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "A happy place",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify where Evan talks about the island he grew up on.  \n- Result 1: Evan to Sam: \"This little island is where I grew up and it's my happy place.\"  \n- Result 5: Evan to Sam: \"Yeah, it was. That place shaped me and will always hold a special place in my heart.\"  \n- Result 43: Evan to Sam: \"Yeah, it's like a little slice of paradise. I always feel so peaceful and serene when I'm there.\"\n\nStep 2: Synthesize these descriptions.  \nEvan describes the island as his \"happy place,\" a place that \"shaped\" him and holds a \"special place\" in his heart, and as a \"little slice of paradise\" where he feels \"peaceful and serene.\"\n\nFinal answer:  \nEvan describes the island he grew up on as his happy place, a little slice of paradise that shaped him and where he always feels peaceful and serene.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.68,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.55
    },
    {
      "question": "What was the main reason for Evan's frustration with his new Prius breaking down?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "He relied on it for his active lifestyle and road trips",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Evan's new Prius breaking down and his feelings about it.  \n- Result 2 (2023-12-05): Evan says his new Prius broke down and it is a stressor because he relies on it for his active lifestyle and road trips.  \n- Result 1 (2023-12-05): Evan expresses frustration because he was counting on the new Prius to be reliable, but it had unexpected issues.  \n- Result 15 and 16 (2023-12-05): Sam acknowledges how rough it is when a new car breaks down, especially as a main mode of transport, and how plans get derailed.  \n- Result 3 and 10 (2023-12-31): Evan mentions taking the Prius on a long drive and having a minor accident, but this is after the breakdown and seems separate.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the reason for frustration.  \nEvan's main frustration stems from the fact that the",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.38,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.79
    },
    {
      "question": "How did Sam suggest Evan view the setback with his broken Prius?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "As a chance to explore other ways of staying active and traveling",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the messages about Evan's broken Prius and Sam's responses.\n\n- Evan mentions his new Prius broke down (Result 3, 2023-12-05).\n- Evan expresses frustration about the new car breaking down (Result 2).\n- Sam responds with empathy about the hassle of a new car breaking down (Result 51).\n- Sam also says, \"It's tough when your plans get derailed by something like this. But hey, sometimes these setbacks lead to new opportunities.\" (Result 12).\n\nStep 2: Summarize Sam's suggestion.\n\nSam acknowledges the difficulty but encourages Evan to see the setback as potentially leading to new opportunities.\n\nFinal answer:  \nSam suggested that Evan view the setback with his broken Prius as a tough but common challenge that can sometimes lead to new opportunities.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.52,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.67
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Sam suggest Evan try for stress relief and flexibility?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Yoga",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of stress relief and flexibility in the context.  \n- Result 3 (2023-12-05): Sam to Evan says, \"Yoga's a great choice, it's done wonders for my flexibility and stress levels. You should definitely try it.\"  \n- Result 7 (2023-12-05): Evan asks Sam about yoga for stress relief and flexibility.  \n- Result 8 (2024-01-10): Sam mentions combining a healthier diet and yoga for positive changes.  \n- Result 20 (2024-01-10): Evan lists low-impact exercises including yoga.  \n- Result 77 (2024-01-10): Evan confirms yoga helped him with stress and flexibility.  \n- Result 71 (2023-12-05): Sam offers yoga tips to Evan.\n\nStep 2: Confirm what Sam specifically suggested to Evan.  \nSam explicitly recommended yoga as a great choice for stress relief and flexibility (Result 3).",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.84,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.95
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Sam offer Evan regarding yoga?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Support and tips",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of yoga in the conversation excerpts involving Sam and Evan.\n\n- Result 2 (2023-12-05): Sam says to Evan, \"If you need any yoga tips or anything else, just let me know.\"\n- Result 8 (2023-12-05): Sam encourages Evan to try yoga, saying it has done wonders for flexibility and stress.\n- Result 6 (2023-12-05): Sam says, \"Definitely. Take care, and let me know how the yoga goes.\"\n- Result 1 (2024-01-10): Sam mentions hoping for positive changes between a healthier diet and yoga.\n- Result 86 (2024-01-10): Evan confirms yoga helped him with stress and flexibility, and Sam had recommended it.\n- Result 72 (2024-01-11): Evan asks Sam if she has found any low-impact exercises she enjoys, referencing yoga as an option.\n\nStep 2: Summar",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.51,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.23
    },
    {
      "question": "What news did Evan share with Sam on 9th December 2023?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "partner is pregnant",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify messages from or around 9th December 2023.\n\n- Result 23 [2023-12-09T13:45:00] Evan to Sam: \"Hey Sam, hope you're doing good. Wanted to share some amazing news - my partner is pregnant! We're so excited! It's been a while since we had a kiddo around.\"\n\n- Result 52 [2023-12-09T13:46:30] Sam to Evan: Responds to Evan's news about family.\n\n- Result 66 [2023-12-09T13:48:30] Sam to Evan: Also responds to Evan's message.\n\nStep 2: Confirm the news Evan shared on that date.\n\nEvan told Sam that his partner is pregnant, and they are very excited about it.\n\nFinal answer:  \nOn 9th December 2023, Evan shared with Sam that his partner is pregnant and they are very excited about expecting a child.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 4.06,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.99
    },
    {
      "question": "What family event is Evan planning for next summer?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "big family reunion",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of family events planned by Evan for next summer.  \nStep 2: In Result 4 (2023-12-09), Evan tells Sam: \"Yeah, we're planning a big family reunion next summer.\"  \nStep 3: Sam acknowledges this in Result 2 and Result 1, showing the event is a big family reunion.  \n\nFinal answer:  \nEvan is planning a big family reunion for next summer.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.96,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.84
    },
    {
      "question": "What is the motto of Evan's family?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "'Bring it on Home'",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify where the motto is mentioned.  \nIn [Result 2] (2023-12-09), Evan tells Sam about a sign from their trip to Banff that says \"Bring it on Home,\" which is described as their family's motto.\n\nStep 2: Confirm the motto is indeed linked to Evan's family.  \nEvan explicitly says it is their family's motto, reminding them of the importance of togetherness.\n\nFinal answer:  \nEvan's family motto is \"Bring it on Home.\"",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.3,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.44
    },
    {
      "question": "According to Evan, what is important for Sam to believe in concerning his weight?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Your worth is not defined by your weight",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts where Evan talks about Sam's weight or self-belief.\n\n- Result 1 (2023-12-17): Evan says, \"it's important to believe in yourself and take it one day at a time, Sam. Your worth is not defined by your weight.\"\n- Result 9 (Sam says he is struggling with weight and motivation).\n- Result 85 (Evan encourages Sam to be patient and stay upbeat, \"Your health matters, and I believe in you.\")\n- Result 16 (Evan talks about his own health journey and offers encouragement).\n- Result 42 (Evan shares his own experience with health changes).\n\nStep 2: Synthesize Evan's key message about belief related to Sam's weight.\n\nEvan emphasizes that Sam should believe in himself, not let his weight define his worth, and take things one day at a time.\n\nFinal answer:  \nEvan believes it is important for Sam to believe in himself and understand that his",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.95,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.56
    },
    {
      "question": "Who helped Evan get the painting published in the exhibition?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "a close friend",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant excerpt about the painting published in the exhibition.  \n- Result 1 [2023-12-17T18:56:00] Evan to Sam: \"That's a close friend of mine who helped me get this painting published in the exhibition!\"\n\nStep 2: Check if the name of the friend is mentioned anywhere else.  \n- No other excerpt specifies the name of the friend who helped Evan.\n\nStep 3: Since Evan refers to \"a close friend of mine\" but does not name them, and no other context provides the name, the identity remains unknown.\n\nFinal answer:  \nA close friend of Evan helped him get the painting published, but their name is not mentioned.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.97,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.2
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Sam recently start enjoying to clear his head?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "running in the mornings",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for mentions of Sam doing activities to clear his head or manage stress.  \nStep 2: In [Result 35] (2023-09-11), Evan says when stressed he turns to painting or going for a drive.  \nStep 3: In [Result 26] (2023-08-13), Sam shares a quote about taking the first step to healthier habits, indicating some new positive changes.  \nStep 4: In [Result 70] (2024-01-10), Sam mentions hoping for positive changes between a healthier diet and yoga.  \nStep 5: In [Result 39] (2023-12-05), Evan talks about trying yoga for stress relief and asks Sam's take on it.  \nStep 6: In [Result 76] (2024-01-11), Sam says being in nature helps him relax and get fresh air away from the city.  \nStep 7: In [",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.49,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.31
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Sam suggest Evan should do with his keys?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "put a GPS sensor on them",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Evan losing his keys.  \n- Result 1 (2023-08-13): Evan is searching for keys.  \n- Result 2 (2023-12-26): Evan says he lost his keys again, weekly ritual.  \n- Result 57 (2023-08-13): Evan mentions losing keys weekly and needing cheering.  \n- Result 72 (2023-12-26): Sam suggests putting a GPS sensor on Evan's keys.\n\nStep 2: Find Sam's suggestion about the keys.  \n- Result 72 is the only direct suggestion from Sam regarding the keys: \"Ooh, Evan, I'd put a GPS sensor on your keys!\"\n\nFinal answer:  \nSam suggested that Evan should put a GPS sensor on his keys.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.19,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.79
    },
    {
      "question": "How did Evan feel when he painted the piece with the bird flying over it?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "a sense of joy and freedom",
      "generated_answer": "To find how Evan felt when he painted the piece with the bird flying over it, I need to identify the relevant conversation about that painting.\n\n- Result 3 (2023-12-26T16:30:00) Sam to Evan: \"Such a minimalistic and stunning piece of work, I wonder what inspired the artist to create it.\"\n- Result 7 (2023-12-26T16:30:30) Evan to Sam: \"The painting is mine, I made it when I was a mix of emotions - sad, mad, and hopeful. Art is amazing how it can portray feelings without words.\"\n- Result 1 (2023-12-26T16:32:30) Evan to Sam: \"I painted this with a sense of joy and freedom. The spontaneous strokes and bold colors reflect a playful and liberated mood, embracing the creative process without restraint.\"\n- Result 5 (2023-12-26T16:31:30)",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.73,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.7
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Evan suggest Sam should keep doing to find his own version of love?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Keep trying new things",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about Evan's advice to Sam regarding finding love.\n\n- Result 1 (2023-12-26): Evan says, \"Like your morning runs, they're a step towards something good, right? Keep trying new things, Sam, and you might find your own version of love in the most unexpected places.\"\n- Result 7 (2023-05-18): Evan says, \"You'll find it, just keep trying new things until something sparks your excitement.\"\n- Result 2 (2023-12-17): Evan encourages Sam to \"try something new, even if it's just a little thing.\"\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the advice.\n\nEvan consistently suggests that Sam should keep trying new things and stepping out of his comfort zone as a way to find his own version of love.\n\nFinal answer:  \nEvan suggested that Sam should keep trying new things and stepping out of his comfort zone to find his own version of love.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.27,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.44
    },
    {
      "question": "How did Evan describe the process of creating the painting with the bird flying over it?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "embracing the creative process without restraint",
      "generated_answer": "The painting with the bird flying over it is described by Evan in Result 1 and Result 13. In Result 1 (2023-12-26), Evan says he painted it with a sense of joy and freedom, using spontaneous strokes and bold colors to reflect a playful and liberated mood, embracing the creative process without restraint. In Result 13, he adds that he made the painting when he was feeling a mix of emotions\u2014sad, mad, and hopeful\u2014and notes how art can portray feelings without words.\n\nFinal answer:  \nEvan described creating the painting with the bird flying over it as a joyful and free process, using spontaneous strokes and bold colors to express a playful, liberated mood, while also reflecting a mix of emotions\u2014sadness, anger, and hopefulness\u2014through the art.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.43,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.87
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Evan want to share with his work friends?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "getting married",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify any mentions of Evan sharing news with work friends.  \n- Result 69: Evan to Sam mentions a \"minor accident\" that \"put a bit of a damper on telling my work friends about getting married.\"  \n- Result 63: Evan tells Sam that he and his partner told their extended family about their marriage on approximately January 5, 2024.  \n- Result 75: Sam to Evan says \"I bet they were thrilled to hear about your marriage, despite the mishap!\" referring to Evan's work friends.  \n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.  \nEvan wanted to share the news of his marriage with his work friends, but a minor accident (related to the rose bushes incident) made the situation a bit awkward.\n\nFinal answer:  \nEvan wanted to share the news of his marriage with his work friends.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.67,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.2
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Evan share with Sam after their hiking trip?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "a photo of a man standing on a rock looking out over a valley",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of hiking trips involving Evan and Sam.\n\n- Result 2 (2023-05-18): Sam recalls a past hike with Evan as a great memory.\n- Result 11 (2023-05-18): Evan mentions hiking trails last week (around May 11, 2023) with amazing views.\n- Result 1 (2023-10-17): Evan talks about progress and being at the gym recently, in a conversation about hiking plans.\n- Result 14, 73, 46 (2023-10-17): Evan and Sam discuss planning a hike soon and being excited about it.\n- Result 3 and 5 (2023-12-31): Sam mentions a recent hiking trip with friends last Friday; Evan talks about a mountain drive with a minor accident.\n- Result 49 (2023-12-31): Evan shares new healthy snacks after hiking.\n- Result 53 (2023-12-31",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.94,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.48
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Evan offer to share with Sam after talking about healthy snacks?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "the recipes for cookies",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify where Evan talks about healthy snacks and what he offers to share.\n\n- In [Result 1] (2023-12-31), Evan mentions sharing some new healthy snacks he's been trying.\n- In [Result 27] (2023-12-31), Evan says: \"Yeah, I've been trying to eat healthier too. Check out this cool recipe I discovered for these energy balls.\"\n- In [Result 42] (2023-12-31), Evan says: \"Exactly! They\u2019re packed with nutrients and really easy to make. You also need to try these cookies, they are awesome! I\u2019ll send you the recipes.\"\n\nStep 2: Summarize what Evan offered.\n\nEvan offered to share recipes for healthy snacks, specifically energy balls and cookies.\n\nFinal answer:  \nEvan offered to share recipes for healthy snacks, including energy balls and cookies.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.1,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.87
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Evan and his partner share with their extended family on January 5, 2024?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "their marriage",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant date and event.\n- Result 6 (2024-01-06) from Evan to Sam says: \"My partner and I told our extended fam about our marriage yesterday (approximately January 05, 2024) \u2013 it was so special!\"\n\nStep 2: Confirm what was shared.\n- The message clearly states they shared news about their marriage with their extended family.\n\nFinal answer:  \nEvan and his partner shared the news of their marriage with their extended family on January 5, 2024.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.68,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.98
    },
    {
      "question": "What was Evan limiting himself to on his new diet?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "just two ginger snaps a day",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for mentions of Evan's new diet and any specific limits he set.  \nStep 2: In Result 62 (2024-01-06), Evan says he started a new diet limiting himself to just two ginger snaps a day.  \nStep 3: This is the only explicit mention of a specific limit Evan set on his diet.\n\nFinal answer: Evan was limiting himself to just two ginger snaps a day on his new diet.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.57,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.67
    },
    {
      "question": "What sports activity did Evan and his partner try in a recent weekend?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Snowshoeing",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Evan and his partner doing a sports activity recently.\n\nStep 2: Result 14 [2024-01-10T00:21:00] Evan to Sam says: \"my partner and I tried snowshoeing this weekend. It was part of a new adventure for us and surprisingly fun.\"\n\nStep 3: Confirm no other recent weekend sports activity with partner is mentioned.\n\nStep 4: This is the only clear recent weekend sports activity involving Evan and his partner.\n\nFinal answer: Evan and his partner recently tried snowshoeing on a weekend.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.22,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.86
    },
    {
      "question": "What advice did Evan suggest Sam seek from a doctor?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "diet plan and low-impact exercises",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify where Evan talks about advice from a doctor.  \n- Result 1 (2024-01-10): Evan asks Sam what advice he plans to get from the doctor.  \n- Result 15 (2024-01-10): Evan encourages Sam to ask the doctor for advice, suggesting the doctor could give more diet and exercise tips.  \n- Result 41 (2024-01-10): Evan advises Sam to focus on a balanced diet and low-impact exercises and to let him know how it goes.\n\nStep 2: Summarize the advice Evan suggests Sam seek from the doctor.  \nEvan suggests Sam ask the doctor for advice on diet and exercise, specifically tips for a healthier diet and low-impact exercises.\n\nFinal answer:  \nEvan suggested that Sam seek advice from the doctor on diet and exercise, including tips for a balanced diet and low-impact exercises.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.51,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.42
    },
    {
      "question": "What suggestions did Evan give for low-impact exercises?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "swimming, yoga, walking",
      "generated_answer": "Step-by-step analysis of Evan's suggestions for low-impact exercises from the context:\n\n- Result 2 (2024-01-10): Evan mentions swimming, yoga, and walking as good low-impact exercises.\n- Result 5 (2024-01-10): Evan adds going on beach sunsets as a favorite low-impact exercise that is calming.\n- Result 72 (2023-08-27): Evan mentions swimming to stay active while recovering from a knee injury.\n- Result 10 (2024-01-10): Evan encourages focusing on low-impact exercises alongside a balanced diet.\n- Result 56 (2024-01-10): Evan endorses yoga for stress relief and flexibility.\n- Result 83 (2023-10-14): Evan suggests kayaking as a fun and active outdoor low-impact exercise.\n- Result 44 (2023-10-17): Evan recommends hiking as a way to bond with nature and get exercise.\n- Result 65 (2023-",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.79,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.13
    },
    {
      "question": "What movie did Sam watch that motivated him to keep up with his routine?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "The Godfather",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of movies in the context.  \n- Result 2: Evan mentions \"The Godfather\" as a legendary movie.  \n- Result 5: Sam says he watched \"The Godfather\" last night and it motivated him to keep up with his routine.\n\nStep 2: Confirm the connection between the movie and motivation.  \n- Result 5 explicitly states Sam watched \"The Godfather\" and it motivated him.\n\nFinal answer:  \nSam watched \"The Godfather,\" which motivated him to keep up with his routine.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.57,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.35
    },
    {
      "question": "What activity helped Evan with stress and flexibility?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Yoga",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of activities Evan does for stress relief and flexibility.\n- Result 4 (2023-12-05): Sam says yoga is great for flexibility and stress.\n- Result 5 (2024-01-10): Evan lists swimming, yoga, and walking as good low-impact exercises.\n- Result 18 (2024-01-10): Evan says yoga helped him with stress and staying flexible.\n- Result 24 (2023-12-05): Evan is thinking about trying yoga for stress relief and flexibility.\n- Result 95 (2024-01-10): Evan advises Sam to focus on balanced diet and low-impact exercises (including yoga).\n\nStep 2: Confirm Evan's own experience.\n- Result 18 explicitly states: \"Yoga's definitely a great start, Sam. It's helped me with stress and staying flexible.\"\n\nFinal answer:  \nYoga helped Evan with stress relief and flexibility.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.84,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.7
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Evan share a photo of that was taken on a camping trip?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "a kayak",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of a camping trip and a photo shared by Evan.  \n- Result 3 [2024-01-11]: Evan to Sam says, \"Last summer, I took this pic on a camping trip - it was such an amazing sunset.\"  \n- Result 31 [2024-01-11]: Evan to Sam says, \"I had a great time kayaking and watching the sunset last summer - it was truly unforgettable.\"\n\nStep 2: Confirm the photo Evan shared from the camping trip was of a sunset.  \n- Result 3 explicitly states the photo was of \"such an amazing sunset\" taken on a camping trip last summer.\n\nStep 3: Cross-check if any other camping trip photo is mentioned.  \n- No other camping trip photo is mentioned in the context.\n\nFinal answer:  \nEvan shared a photo of an amazing sunset taken on a camping trip last summer.",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.11,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.62
    },
    {
      "question": "Why did Evan apologize to his partner?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "for a drunken night",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the incident involving Evan and his partner that required an apology.  \n- Result 22 (2024-01-10): Evan says he went out with friends, drank too much, and did something regrettable involving someone's roses.  \n- Result 13 (2024-01-10): Evan admits to having a pee accident near some roses while drunk.  \n- Result 43 (2024-01-11): Evan says he had to apologize to his partner for that drunken night, calling it embarrassing.  \n\nStep 2: Confirm the reason for the apology.  \n- The apology was due to Evan's embarrassing behavior while drunk, specifically the pee accident near the roses.  \n\nFinal answer:  \nEvan apologized to his partner because he had an embarrassing drunken accident involving peeing near some roses.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.29,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.86
    },
    {
      "question": "How does Evan describe being out on the water while kayaking and watching the sunset?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "peaceful",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about kayaking and watching the sunset.\n\n- Result 1 (2024-01-11): Evan to Sam says, \"I had a great time kayaking and watching the sunset last summer - it was truly unforgettable. Being out on the water is so peaceful.\"\n- Result 13 (2024-01-11): Evan mentions a camping trip with an amazing sunset, emphasizing the beauty and calming effect of nature.\n- Result 41 (2023-11-09): Evan describes a favorite spot by the beach watching waves and sunset colors as peaceful and helping find peace.\n- Result 57 (2023-11-09): Evan calls the place peaceful to relax and unwind.\n- Result 27 and 30 (2023-11-21): Evan describes nature as serene and calming.\n\nStep 2: Focus on the direct description of kayaking and being on the water.\n\n- Result 1 is the most direct and specific: \"Being out on the",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-49",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.0,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.58
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Calvin first travel to Tokyo?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "between 26 March and 20 April 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Calvin traveling to Tokyo.\n\n- Result 11 (2023-03-23): Calvin says he has never been to Japan before.\n- Result 48 (2023-03-23): Calvin says he is heading to Japan next month (April 2023).\n- Result 51 (2023-05-16): Calvin is super excited for an upcoming performance in Tokyo this month (May 2023).\n- Result 66 (2023-05-31): Calvin mentions touring with Frank Ocean last week (approx. May 24, 2023) and says Tokyo was unreal.\n- Result 26 (2023-08-14): Calvin talks about having an amazing experience touring with a well-known artist and ending with a show in Japan.\n- Result 15 (2023-09-22): Calvin reflects on his trip to Japan as an incredible experience.\n- Result 33 (2023-11-02): Calvin threw a",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.22,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.87
    },
    {
      "question": "What items did Calvin buy in March 2023?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "mansion in Japan, luxury car Ferrari 488 GTB",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify any mentions of purchases by Calvin in March 2023.\n\n- Result 55 [2023-03-23]: Calvin mentions a \"big life change\" and shows a new mansion.\n- Result 49 [2023-03-26]: Calvin says he got a new car, a luxury car, which was a dream come true.\n- Result 56 [2023-05-01]: Dave asks Calvin about a necklace, but no date in March.\n- Result 68 [2023-03-26]: Dave comments on Calvin's car, asking if it's his first one.\n- Result 79 [2023-06-21]: Calvin mentions a mechanic working on his car, but this is June.\n- Result 99 [2023-03-23]: Calvin says his agent found him an awesome place.\n\nStep 2: Confirm the timing and items.\n\n- Mansion: Mentioned on 2023-03-23 by Calvin.\n-",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.02,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.23
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Dave see Aerosmith perform live?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "on the weekend before March 26, 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Dave seeing Aerosmith live.  \n- Result 2 (2023-03-26T16:49:30) Dave to Calvin: \"If I had to pick a favorite, it would definitely be Aerosmith. Their performance was incredible.\"  \n- Result 8 (2023-03-26T16:50:30) Dave to Calvin: \"I finally saw them live and it was such an amazing experience! He was jamming out to one of their hits. Check out this epic picture of them!\"  \n- Result 1 and 4 also relate to this event on 2023-03-26.\n\nStep 2: Check the date of these messages.  \n- All these messages are from March 26, 2023, around 16:49-16:51.\n\nStep 3: Dave mentions \"last weekend\" in Result 35 (2023-03-26T16:48:30) about",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.05,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.07
    },
    {
      "question": "Which bands has Dave enjoyed listening to?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Aerosmith, The Fireworks",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of bands Dave likes or has enjoyed.\n\n- Result 4 (2023-03-26): Dave says his favorite band is Aerosmith and mentions their incredible performance.\n- Result 41 (2023-03-26): Dave attended a music festival in Boston with many cool bands.\n- Result 76 (2023-06-21): Dave joined a rock band recently.\n- Result 98 (2023-11-02): Dave mentions the logo for his rock band and that he has been a fan for ages.\n\nStep 2: Check if other specific bands are mentioned.\n\n- No other specific band names besides Aerosmith are mentioned as favorites or enjoyed by Dave.\n\nStep 3: Summarize.\n\nDave has enjoyed listening to Aerosmith and has been involved with a rock band himself. He also enjoys classic rock in general.\n\nFinal answer: Dave has enjoyed listening to Aerosmith and classic rock bands, and he recently joined a rock band himself.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.37,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.25
    },
    {
      "question": "Which country do Calvin and Dave want to meet in?",
      "category": 3,
      "gold_answer": "United States",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of meeting plans between Calvin and Dave.\n\n- Result 4 (2023-08-22): Calvin says his tour ends soon and he is heading to Boston, suggesting maybe they can meet then.\n- Result 36 (2023-09-02): Calvin says he'll let Dave know when he's in Boston and \"See you soon!\"\n- Result 8 (2023-10-04): Calvin met artists in Boston and is excited about collaborations.\n- Result 44 (2023-10-25): Calvin visited Boston with a high school friend.\n- Result 51 (2023-11-17): Calvin accepted an invitation to perform at an upcoming show in Boston.\n- Result 88 (2023-11-17): Calvin says he'll catch Dave when he's in Boston.\n- Result 91 (2023-11-13): Calvin invited his old high school buddy to see him perform in Boston.\n- Result 53 and 96 (202",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.03,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.94
    },
    {
      "question": "What are Dave's dreams?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "open a car maintenance shop, work on classic cars, build a custom car from scratch",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for any direct mentions of Dave's dreams or goals in the conversation excerpts.\n\nStep 2: In [Result 53] (2023-08-03), Dave asks Calvin about his biggest goal, but no direct answer about Dave's own dreams is given there.\n\nStep 3: In [Result 42] (2023-10-08), Dave says: \"I'm going to keep chasing my dreams and working hard.\" This shows Dave has dreams but does not specify what they are.\n\nStep 4: In [Result 58] (2023-06-21), Calvin says to Dave: \"Playing guitar in a rock band is awesome, Dave! It will bring you a lot of emotions.\" This suggests Dave is involved or interested in playing guitar in a rock band.\n\nStep 5: In [Result 27] (2023-05-01), Calvin congratulates Dave on achieving his dream, implying Dave had a dream related to ambition and",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.36,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.81
    },
    {
      "question": "Which types of cars does Dave like the most?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "classic vintage cars",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Dave's car preferences in the context.\n\n- Result 1: Calvin praises Dave for going for classic cars.\n- Result 3: Dave mentions classic cars are charming and he is into auto engineering because of them.\n- Result 33: Dave says his dream is to open a shop and work on classic cars.\n- Result 35: Dave says he is obsessed with classic cars and restored one last year.\n- Result 40: Dave says he works on all kinds of cars, including full restorations of classic cars.\n- Result 57: Dave talks about working on a classic muscle car with a modern vibe.\n- Result 89: Dave mentions spending time in his dad's garage tinkering with engines and now working on restoring cars.\n- Result 54: Dave restored a car last year and sold it to a collector (likely a classic car).\n- Result 64 and 88: Dave talks about restoring old cars, including a Ford Mustang found in",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.8,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.68
    },
    {
      "question": "Does Dave's shop employ a lot of people?",
      "category": 3,
      "gold_answer": "Yes",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Review all excerpts mentioning Dave's car maintenance shop and any details about its size or staff.\n\n- Result 7 (2023-05-01): Dave announces opening his own car maintenance shop.\n- Result 13 (2023-05-16): Dave says he opened his car shop around May 9, 2023, invited some friends to celebrate, and is excited to share his passion and help with folks' rides.\n- Result 51 (2023-05-03): Dave mentions teaming up with a local garage.\n- Result 96 (2023-10-08): Dave talks about his passion for working on cars, but no mention of staff size.\n- No other excerpts mention the number of employees or staff at Dave's shop.\n\nStep 2: Analyze the information.\n\n- Dave opened his own shop and teamed up with a local garage, which might imply some collaboration or partnership.\n- He invited friends to celebrate but does not mention hiring many employees",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.64,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.88
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Dave start his car maintenance shop?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "May 1, 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about the opening of Dave's car maintenance shop.\n\n- Result 3 (2023-05-01): Dave tells Calvin he finally opened his own car maintenance shop.\n- Result 20 (2023-05-16): Dave says he opened his car shop last week, approximately May 09, 2023.\n- Result 28 (2023-05-01): Dave mentions opening the shop was his dream and it's getting started.\n- Result 39 (2023-05-01): Dave says he opened a shop as a step toward his dream.\n\nStep 2: The most specific date is in Result 20, where Dave states he opened the shop last week, approximately May 09, 2023.\n\nStep 3: Other messages around May 1 show excitement about the shop being opened or just opened, but the clearest specific date is May 9, 2023.\n\nFinal answer: Dave started his car maintenance shop",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.24,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.84
    },
    {
      "question": "When did a mishap occur with Calvin's musical gear and favorite mic?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "On a week before 16 May, 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of a mishap involving Calvin's musical gear and mic.\n\n- Result 12 [2023-05-16]: Calvin to Dave mentions an incident last week (approx. May 09, 2023) where his place got flooded but he saved his music gear and favorite microphone.\n- Result 9 [2023-05-16]: Dave to Calvin refers to the flooding incident and expresses sympathy.\n\nStep 2: Confirm the date of the mishap.\n\n- Calvin's message on May 16, 2023, says the incident happened \"last week,\" which is approximately May 09, 2023.\n\nFinal answer:  \nCalvin's mishap with his musical gear and favorite mic occurred around May 9, 2023, when his place got flooded.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.28,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.82
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Calvin's place get flooded in Tokyo?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "On a week before 16 May, 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify any mention of Calvin's place flooding.\n- Result 38 [2023-05-16]: Calvin to Dave mentions an incident last week (approximately May 09, 2023) where his place got flooded.\n\nStep 2: Confirm the location is Tokyo.\n- The flooding incident is described as \"my place,\" and Calvin has a mansion in Japan (Results 6, 28, 30, 64), and his activities and residence are centered around Tokyo.\n\nStep 3: Date of the flooding.\n- The message is dated May 16, 2023, and Calvin says the flooding happened \"last week,\" which is approximately May 09, 2023.\n\nFinal answer:  \nCalvin's place in Tokyo got flooded around May 9, 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.45,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.21
    },
    {
      "question": "What mishaps has Calvin run into?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "flooding of his mansion, car accident",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of mishaps or problems Calvin has faced.\n\n- Result 28 (2023-06-21): Dave mentions Calvin had a car accident and asks about insurance issues.\n- Result 26 (2023-07-07): Dave asks how Calvin's car is doing after the crash, implying Calvin had a crash.\n- Result 54 (2023-09-22): Dave expresses sympathy for Calvin's car trouble after putting in work.\n- Result 77 (2023-07-07): Calvin says the car is fixed and going strong after the crash.\n- Result 35 (2023-06-21): Calvin says it took a week to sort everything out after the accident, worried about cost but it wasn't too bad.\n- Result 2 (2023-06-21): Calvin refers to the mechanic working hard to get his car running again.\n- Result 65 (2023-09-02): Dave mentions car stuff and modifications,",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.73,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.23
    },
    {
      "question": "When was Calvin's concert in Tokyo?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "last week of May 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Calvin's concert in Tokyo.\n\n- Result 4 (2023-04-20): Calvin mentions just going to an \"awesome music thingy in Tokyo.\"\n- Result 1 (2023-04-20): Calvin says the festival in Tokyo was awesome but didn't see any bands.\n- Result 6 (2023-05-16): Calvin is excited for an upcoming performance in Tokyo \"this month\" (May 2023).\n- Result 7 (2023-08-14): Calvin says the tour ended with a show in Japan and then explored his new place.\n- Result 12 (2023-08-14): Calvin says the show in Tokyo was awesome and the crowd sang along.\n- Result 11 (2023-10-19): Calvin says a photo was taken in Tokyo during a concert.\n- Result 36 (2023-05-31): Calvin says touring with Frank Ocean last week (approx. May ",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.79,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.57
    },
    {
      "question": "Would Calvin enjoy performing at the Hollywood Bowl?",
      "category": 3,
      "gold_answer": "Yes; because he enjoys the rush of performing onstage to large crowds",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for Calvin's expressed feelings about performing live and at big venues.\n- Result 15 (2023-08-31): Calvin says performing on a big stage was a dream come true and the energy was incredible.\n- Result 17 (2023-05-31): Calvin loves the rush and connection with the crowd, calling it an absolute high.\n- Result 43 (2023-08-31): Calvin was pumped from the energy of the audience on tour.\n- Result 7, 10, 13, 18, 21, 27, 57: Calvin describes performing with Frank Ocean and at festivals as amazing, with great crowd energy and connection.\n\nStep 2: Look for any mention of specific venues or cities and Calvin's attitude toward them.\n- Result 6, 19, 33, 63, 66, 70: Calvin is excited about performing in Boston and the music scene there.\n- Result 36,",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.51,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.23
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Calvin meet with the creative team for his new album?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "8 June, 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant excerpt about Calvin meeting the creative team for his album.  \n- Result 1 [2023-06-09]: Calvin says he met with the creative team for his album \"yesterday,\" which would be approximately June 8, 2023.\n\nStep 2: Confirm no other conflicting or additional dates are mentioned for this meeting.  \n- No other excerpts specify a different date for meeting the creative team for this album.\n\nFinal answer:  \nCalvin met with the creative team for his new album on June 8, 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.89,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.87
    },
    {
      "question": "Why does Dave regularly visit parks?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "because it relaxes and calms him",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Dave visiting parks in the context.\n\n- Result 6 (2023-03-23): Dave mentions spending lots of time at a beautiful park for calmness.\n- Result 8 (2023-07-07): Dave says he has been hanging out with friends at parks and arranged regular walks together.\n- Result 48 (2023-06-09): Dave describes Boston parks as serene and magical, and says he loves taking walks on weekends to recharge for the week.\n- Result 51 (2023-06-09): Dave says exploring parks on weekends is peaceful and relaxing.\n- Result 66 (2023-05-03): Dave says taking walks around is a great way to destress and peaceful.\n- Result 23 & 44 (2023-11-17): Dave found a serene spot in a park, peaceful and perfect to relax.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the reasons Dave visits parks.\n\n- He finds parks",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.65,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.27
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Dave take a trip to mountainous regions?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "July 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Dave going to mountainous regions or trips related to mountains.\n\n- Result 3 (2023-06-09): Dave says he booked a trip to a mountainous region for next month (which would be July 2023).\n- Result 41 (2023-07-21): Dave mentions a recent road trip with friends seeing stunning countryside, which could be related but not explicitly mountainous.\n- Result 54 (2023-07-07): Dave says \"today we are going to that spot\" with a lovely photo, possibly related to a mountain trip.\n- Result 7 (2023-06-09): Dave says he hasn't gone hiking recently (around June 2, 2023).\n- Result 1 (2023-06-09): Calvin says he hasn't been to the mountains but wants to go.\n- Result 86 (2023-06-09): Calvin wishes Dave a great time on his mountain trip next month.\n\nStep",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.98,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.06
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Calvin have a car incident?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "on the Friday before 21 June, 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of a car incident involving Calvin.\n\n- Result 10 (2023-06-21): Dave to Calvin mentions a car accident Calvin had and asks about insurance issues.\n- Result 22 (2023-06-21): Calvin to Dave replies that the insurance process was a hassle but is now sorted.\n- Result 4, 6, 7 (2023-06-21): Calvin talks about the mechanic fixing his car and feeling confident to drive again.\n- Result 33 (2023-07-07): Calvin says the car is fixed and going strong after the accident.\n\nStep 2: Determine the approximate timing of the incident.\n\n- The conversation about the accident and insurance is on June 21, 2023.\n- Calvin says it took a week to sort everything out (Result 6).\n- By July 7, 2023, Calvin reports the car is fixed and going strong.\n\nStep 3: Infer the incident happened",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.95,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.9
    },
    {
      "question": "How many times has Calvin had to deal with insurance paperwork?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "two times",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Calvin dealing with insurance paperwork.\n\n- Result 1 (2023-06-21): Dave asks Calvin about issues with insurance after Calvin's car accident.\n- Result 2 (2023-06-21): Calvin says the insurance process was a hassle with lots of paperwork but is now sorted.\n- Result 3 (2023-06-21): Calvin says it took only a week to sort everything out.\n- Result 20 (2023-05-16): Calvin mentions waiting on insurance to kick in to start repairs after an incident.\n- Result 23 (2023-06-21): Calvin mentions a car accident last Friday and dealing with insurance and repairs.\n- Result 61 (2023-05-16): Calvin mentions an incident (flood) and staying positive, but no direct mention of insurance paperwork here.\n\nStep 2: Count distinct times Calvin mentions dealing with insurance paperwork.\n\n- The car accident insurance process is mentioned once",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 4.31,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.71
    },
    {
      "question": "Which places or events has Calvin visited in Tokyo?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "music festival, car museum, Shibuya crossing, Shinjuku",
      "generated_answer": "Step-by-step reasoning:\n\n1. Calvin mentioned performing at a music event/festival in Tokyo multiple times:\n   - [Result 15] \"The festival in Tokyo was awesome!\"\n   - [Result 19] \"I just went to an awesome music thingy in Tokyo.\"\n   - [Result 38] \"That show in Tokyo was awesome! Everyone was so into it.\"\n   - [Result 44] \"The city was buzzing with energy and the festival crowd was so lively.\"\n   - [Result 62] \"Touring with Frank Ocean last week was wild. Tokyo was unreal \u2014 the crowd was insane.\"\n\n2. Calvin has a mansion in Japan where he recorded music and hosted a party:\n   - [Result 27] \"I had the opportunity to explore my new place - it's like a dream come true!\"\n   - [Result 41] \"We recorded a song in the studio at my mansion.\"\n   - [Result 42] \"I threw a small party",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.97,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.1
    },
    {
      "question": "Who inspired Dave's passion for car engineering?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "His Dad",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for mentions of how Dave got into car engineering or who influenced him.\n\nStep 2: In Result 5 (2023-10-23), Dave says he was fascinated with machines since he was ten and found an old car in a neighbor's garage to fix, which sparked his love for car engineering.\n\nStep 3: In Result 10 (2023-10-08), Dave mentions spending hours in his dad's garage as a child, tinkering with engines, describing it as his sanctuary.\n\nStep 4: In Result 17 (2023-10-25), Dave says his dad took him to his first car show when he was 10, which hooked him on cars and learning more.\n\nStep 5: In Result 27 (2023-08-03), Dave recalls working on cars with his dad as a kid, restoring an old car together.\n\nConclusion: Dave's passion for car engineering was inspired and nurtured by his dad,",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.44,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.93
    },
    {
      "question": "Does Calvin wish to become more popular?",
      "category": 3,
      "gold_answer": "Yes; he want's to grow his fanbase",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for any statements by Calvin about his goals related to popularity or fanbase growth.\n\n- In Result 1 (2023-08-03), Calvin says: \"My plan for now is to expand my brand worldwide and grow my fanbase. I want my music to reach more people and make an impact.\"\n\nStep 2: This clearly indicates Calvin's desire to become more popular by expanding his brand and fanbase globally.\n\nStep 3: No contradictory statements were found that would negate this desire.\n\nFinal answer: Yes, Calvin wishes to become more popular by expanding his brand worldwide and growing his fanbase.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.47,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.26
    },
    {
      "question": "Does Calvin want to expand his brand?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "yes",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for any direct statements from Calvin about expanding his brand.\n\n- In Result 4 (2023-08-03), Calvin says: \"My plan for now is to expand my brand worldwide and grow my fanbase. I want my music to reach more people and make an impact.\"\n\n- In Result 5 (2023-09-13), Calvin mentions: \"Next up, a tour - so excited! After that, I'm off to explore and grow my brand.\"\n\n- In Result 81 (2023-10-25), Calvin says: \"I'm so glad we're on this journey together and curious to see what happens next!\" which implies ongoing growth.\n\nStep 2: These statements clearly show Calvin's intention and plan to expand his brand.\n\nFinal answer:  \nYes, Calvin wants to expand his brand worldwide and grow his fanbase.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.39,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.76
    },
    {
      "question": "What is Dave's main passion?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "auto engineering",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for mentions of Dave's interests or passions in the conversation excerpts.\n\nStep 2: In Result 75 (2023-05-31), Dave says: \"I'm passionate about fixing up things. It's more than just a hobby - it gives me a sense of achievement and purpose. I get a real buzz transforming something that's not working into something that runs smoothly - it's like giving it a second chance.\"\n\nStep 3: This is the clearest direct statement about Dave's main passion.\n\nStep 4: Other excerpts show Dave encouraging Calvin in music, but no other passion is described as strongly or personally as fixing things.\n\nFinal answer:  \nDave's main passion is fixing and repairing things, which gives him a sense of achievement and purpose.",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.28,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.58
    },
    {
      "question": "Can Dave work with engines?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "yes",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for any direct mentions of Dave working with engines or having mechanical skills related to engines.\n\n- Result 4 (2023-10-08): Dave talks about spending time in his dad's garage tinkering with engines as a child, indicating early experience and interest.\n- Result 11 (2023-10-23): Dave says he has been fascinated with how machines work since age 10 and started fixing an old car, which hooked him on car engineering.\n- Result 16 (2023-08-11): Dave mentions being picked for a car mod workshop to improve his skills.\n- Result 57 (2023-08-11): Dave says he has been working on engine swaps and suspension modifications.\n- Result 83 (2023-09-22): Dave describes working on the engine of a vintage Mustang, showing hands-on engine work.\n- Result 71 (2023-05-01): Dave says working on cars is his passion and he",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.18,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.95
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Dave host a card-playing night with his friends?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "on the Friday before 22 August, 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant excerpt about Dave's card night.  \n- Result 2 [2023-08-22T11:06:00] Dave to Calvin: \"Last Friday I had a card-night with my friends, it was so much fun.\"\n\nStep 2: Determine the date of the message to find out when \"last Friday\" was.  \n- The message is dated 2023-08-22 (Tuesday).  \n- The Friday before Tuesday, August 22, 2023, is August 18, 2023.\n\nFinal answer:  \nDave hosted a card-playing night with his friends on Friday, August 18, 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.78,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.41
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Calvin record a podcast with his friends?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "21 August, 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify any mention of Calvin recording a podcast with friends.\n- Result 21 [2023-08-22T11:11:30] Calvin to Dave: \"I almost forgot, yesterday (approximately August 21, 2023) my friends and I recorded a podcast where we discuss the rapidly evolving rap industry!\"\n\nStep 2: Confirm the date of the message and the referenced \"yesterday.\"\n- The message is dated August 22, 2023.\n- \"Yesterday\" would be August 21, 2023.\n\nFinal answer:  \nCalvin recorded a podcast with his friends on August 21, 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.14,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.31
    },
    {
      "question": "Which city was Calvin visiting in August 2023?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "Miami",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Calvin traveling or visiting a city around August 2023.\n\n- Result 3 (2023-08-22): Calvin says to Dave, \"It was an incredible experience... The city was buzzing with energy and the festival crowd was so lively.\"\n- Result 86 (2023-08-14): Calvin mentions touring with a well-known artist, ending with a show in Japan and exploring his new place.\n- Result 77 (2023-09-22): Calvin reflects on his trip to Japan, saying it was incredible and he is longing to go back.\n- Result 48 (2023-10-19): Calvin says a photo was taken in Tokyo during a concert.\n- Result 50 (2023-05-16): Calvin took a picture in Tokyo.\n- Result 44 (2023-03-23): Calvin says he will be in Japan for a few months then off to Boston.\n- Result 14 (2023",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.53,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.0
    },
    {
      "question": "What does Calvin do to relax?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "take long drives in his car, embrace nature, fixing cars",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Calvin's relaxation methods in the excerpts.\n\n- Result 2 (2023-05-03): Calvin says long drives in his car help him relax, enjoying the feeling of wind and open road.\n- Result 22 (2023-11-02): Calvin mentions he only works in the studio but has another room with a TV that is cozy and relaxing, which he uses to unwind and get inspired.\n- Result 69 (2023-05-31): Calvin says fixing cars calms him down and gives a sense of achievement, like meditating.\n- Result 6 (2023-10-23): Calvin says music is a way to express himself and work through emotions, like therapy.\n- Result 7 (2023-11-17): Calvin says nature helps him appreciate life and is like a breath of fresh air.\n- Result 25 (2023-10-15): Calvin mentions taking breaks to recharge with favorite activities when facing",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.57,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.72
    },
    {
      "question": "What are Dave's hobbies other than fixing cars?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "take a walk, go hiking, listen to favorite albums, live concerts, photography",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Dave's hobbies besides fixing cars.\n\n- Result 12 (2023-10-23): Dave mentions music helps him focus and relax while working on cars.\n- Result 34 (2023-11-02): Dave says music helps him focus and stay on track during car work.\n- Result 45 (2023-11-02): Dave listens to music (vinyl) while doing car work.\n- Result 16 (2023-07-21): Dave went on a road trip with friends, enjoying driving and countryside views.\n- Result 77 (2023-07-07): Dave mentions hanging out with friends at parks and arranging regular walks.\n- Result 56 (2023-10-29): Calvin asks about Dave's photography, implying Dave is into photography.\n- Result 28 (2023-10-25): Dave recalls going to his first car show at age 10, showing interest in car shows.\n- Result",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.98,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.99
    },
    {
      "question": "What kind of music does Dave listen to?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "classic rock, Japanese music",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Dave's music preferences in the excerpts.\n\n- Result 8 (2023-11-02): Dave says, \"Lately, I've been getting into classic rock. The music from that era is timeless.\"\n- Result 56 (2023-11-02): Dave says, \"Classic rock has had a huge impact on music. Always fun to dig in and find new tunes.\"\n- Result 10 (2023-11-02): Dave mentions listening to vinyl while doing car work, implying a preference for older or classic music formats.\n- Result 71 (2023-03-26): Calvin says, \"Lovin' Aerosmith,\" which is a classic rock band, possibly reflecting Dave's influence or shared taste.\n- Result 13 and 16 (2023-09-22): They mention jamming to \"California Love\" by Tupac and Dr. Dre, indicating Dave also appreciates classic hip-hop.\n- Result 75 (",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.23,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.82
    },
    {
      "question": "Where was Dave in the last two weeks of August 2023?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "San Francisco",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant time frame: last two weeks of August 2023 means approximately August 18 to August 31, 2023.\n\nStep 2: Look for messages from or about Dave during that period.\n\n- Result 14 (2023-08-22): Calvin mentions recording a podcast with friends on August 21, 2023.\n- Result 22 (2023-08-31): Calvin says \"We're doing the shoot in Miami and picked an awesome beach.\"\n- Result 31 (2023-08-31): Dave asks Calvin if the shoot will be on location.\n- Result 33 (2023-08-31): Dave asks how performing on the big stage was.\n- Result 46 (2023-08-31): Dave congratulates Calvin on an incredible experience.\n- Result 56 (2023-08-31): Dave asks Calvin about the end of his tour.\n- Result 80 (2023-06-",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.74,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.68
    },
    {
      "question": "Where did Dave return from with new knowledge of different techniques of car restoration?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "San Francisco",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Dave gaining new knowledge or experiences related to car restoration.\n\n- Result 2 (2023-08-14): Dave to Calvin says he got to go to a car workshop in San Francisco and learned about different techniques of car restoration.\n- Result 16 (2023-09-02): Dave mentions coming back from San Francisco with great insights and knowledge on car modification.\n\nStep 2: Confirm the location associated with the new knowledge.\n\n- Both excerpts clearly state San Francisco as the place where Dave gained new knowledge and insights.\n\nFinal answer:  \nDave returned from San Francisco with new knowledge of different techniques of car restoration.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.23,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.91
    },
    {
      "question": "What was Dave doing in San Francisco?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "attending a car modification workshop",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify any mentions of San Francisco in the context.  \n- Result 23 [2023-08-14T00:35:00] Dave to Calvin: \"Hey Cal, how's it going? Something cool happened since last we talked - I got to go to a car workshop in San Francisco! So cool to dive into the world of car restoration and see all the different techniques. People were really passionate and dedicated - truly inspiring!\"\n\nStep 2: Understand what Dave was doing there.  \n- Dave visited a car workshop in San Francisco.  \n- He was exploring car restoration and learning about different techniques.  \n- He found the experience inspiring due to the passion and dedication of the people there.\n\nFinal answer:  \nDave was visiting a car workshop in San Francisco, exploring car restoration and learning about different techniques.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.42,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.78
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Dave return from San Francisco?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "September 1, 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify any mention of Dave going to or returning from San Francisco.  \n- Result 63 [2023-08-14T00:35:00] Dave to Calvin: Dave mentions going to a car workshop in San Francisco and describes the experience. This message is dated August 14, 2023.\n\nStep 2: Look for any message indicating when Dave returned from San Francisco.  \n- There is no explicit message stating Dave's return date from San Francisco.  \n- The message about San Francisco is on August 14, 2023, and it is written in past tense (\"I got to go to a car workshop...\"), implying the visit happened before or around that date.\n\nStep 3: Check if any other messages from Dave after August 14, 2023, mention his location or return.  \n- No direct mention of Dave's return from San Francisco is found in the context.\n\nFinal conclusion: The only temporal clue is that Dave was in",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.82,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.83
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Calvin book flight tickets to Boston?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "last week of August 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Calvin booking flight tickets to Boston.\n\n- Result 1 (2023-09-02): Calvin says, \"I booked a flight ticket to Boston last week (approximately August 26, 2023)!\"\n\nStep 2: Confirm no earlier or conflicting mentions.\n\n- Result 6 (2023-03-23): Calvin mentions plans to be in Japan for a few months then off to Boston, but no booking date.\n- Result 44 (2023-03-23): Calvin says he is heading there next month, but no booking date.\n- Result 11 (2023-08-22): Calvin says his tour ends soon and he's heading to Boston, maybe meet up then, no booking date.\n- Result 1 is the only explicit mention of booking a flight ticket with a date reference.\n\nFinal answer: Calvin booked his flight ticket to Boston around August 26, 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.12,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.91
    },
    {
      "question": "When was Calvin's album released?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "September 11, 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Calvin's album release in the context.\n\n- Result 3 (2023-09-13): Calvin says, \"My album finally dropped on the 11th and it was a wild feeling.\"\n- Result 1 (2023-11-02): Dave congratulates Calvin on the album release and party.\n- Result 18 (2023-11-02): Calvin mentions a party last week (around October 26, 2023) for the new album.\n- Result 57 (2023-10-29): Calvin says the album is almost finished, implying it was not yet released by late October.\n- Result 7 (2023-08-31): Calvin talks about shooting a video for the new album, so the album was not out yet at that time.\n\nStep 2: Confirm the exact release date.\n\n- Calvin states on 2023-09-13 that the album dropped on the 11th (of September",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.24,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.17
    },
    {
      "question": "Does Calvin love music tours?",
      "category": 3,
      "gold_answer": "yes",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for Calvin's statements about tours and live performances.\n\n- Result 1 (2023-08-14): Calvin had an amazing experience touring with a well-known artist, ending with a show in Japan, describing it as a dream come true.\n- Result 6 (2023-04-20): Calvin is dreaming of touring the world, performing for different people, and connecting with them.\n- Result 22 (2023-10-23): Calvin says the tour with Frank Ocean has been incredible, performing and connecting with the crowd is energizing.\n- Result 31 (2023-10-19): Calvin says the tour has been great, the energy from the crowd is awesome, and jamming with Frank Ocean is a dream come true.\n- Result 85 (2023-08-31): Calvin says performing on a big stage was a dream come true, the energy was incredible, and it felt surreal.\n- Result 40 (2023-",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.57,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.34
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Dave have a great jam session with his band?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "September 14, 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Dave having a jam session with his band.  \n- Result 8 (2023-09-15): Dave to Calvin says, \"last night was a blast! My band and I were jamming and the music just kept flowing.\"  \n- Result 14 (2023-09-15): Dave to Calvin says, \"I wish we had recorded the jam, but we were way too into it and totally forgot.\" This is a direct follow-up to Result 8, confirming the jam session happened the night before September 15, 2023.\n\nStep 2: Confirm no other jam sessions are mentioned with specific timing.  \n- Result 17 (2023-09-22): Dave to Calvin talks about jamming but this is a future plan (\"Can't wait!\"), not a past event.  \n- No other jam sessions with specific dates are mentioned.\n\nStep 3: Determine the date of the jam session.  \n- Since Result ",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 4.39,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.76
    },
    {
      "question": "Would Dave prefer working on a Dodge Charger or a Subaru Forester?",
      "category": 3,
      "gold_answer": "Dodge Charger",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify any mentions of specific car models Dave works on or prefers.\n\n- Result 61 (2023-08-11): Dave mentions working on a classic muscle car, doing engine swaps and suspension mods, giving it a modern twist.\n- Result 67 (2023-08-11): Dave says he wanted a modern vibe but also classic muscle car style.\n- Result 76 (2023-10-25): Dave talks about being hooked on cars since age 10, and now being an automotive engineer.\n- Result 56 (2023-10-23): Dave restored a car last year and sold it to a collector; now working on a new challenging project.\n- Result 48 (2023-10-04): Dave restored a car and finds it satisfying.\n- Result 20 (2023-08-11): Dave got picked for a car mod workshop and is working on cars.\n- Result 61 specifically mentions a \"classic muscle car\"",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.89,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.87
    },
    {
      "question": "What was the artists Calvin used to listen to when he was a kid?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Tupac and Dr. Dre",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify any mention of childhood or early music memories in the context.  \n- Result 2 (2023-09-22): Dave asks Calvin about songs from his childhood that bring back memories.  \n- Result 6 (2023-09-22): Calvin replies they used to rock a song by Tupac and Dr. Dre called \"California Love.\"  \n- Result 17 (2023-09-22): Calvin mentions a song from a road trip with his dad that makes him smile, but does not specify the artist.  \n\nStep 2: Confirm if any other artists from Calvin's childhood are mentioned.  \n- No other specific childhood artists are named in the excerpts.  \n\nStep 3: Synthesize the information.  \n- The only specific artists Calvin mentions from his childhood are Tupac and Dr. Dre, with the song \"California Love.\"  \n\nFinal answer:  \nCalvin used to listen to Tupac and Dr. Dre when he was a kid",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.61,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.79
    },
    {
      "question": "Which of their family member do Calvin and Dave have nostalgic memories about?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Dad",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for mentions of family members in the conversation excerpts.\n\nStep 2: In Result 11 (2023-08-03), Calvin asks Dave about memories working on cars with his dad, indicating Dave has nostalgic memories about his dad.\n\nStep 3: In Result 15 (2023-09-22), Calvin mentions a song that brings back memories from a road trip with his dad, showing Calvin has nostalgic memories about his dad.\n\nStep 4: In Result 80 (2023-09-22), Calvin talks about a trip to Japan and reflects on his journey, but no family member is mentioned there.\n\nStep 5: No other family members are mentioned with nostalgic memories.\n\nFinal answer: Both Calvin and Dave have nostalgic memories about their dads.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.08,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.31
    },
    {
      "question": "Based on the conversation, did Calvin and Dave have a meeting in Boston between August and November 2023? Answer in yes or no.",
      "category": 3,
      "gold_answer": "No",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Boston meetings or catch-ups between Calvin and Dave from August to November 2023.\n\n- Result 4 (2023-08-22): Calvin mentions his tour ends soon and he's heading to Boston, suggesting a possible meet-up.\n- Result 8 (2023-09-02): Calvin says he'll let Dave know when he's in Boston.\n- Result 52 (2023-09-02): Calvin booked a flight to Boston last week (around August 26, 2023).\n- Result 2 (2023-10-04): Calvin met artists in Boston on October 3, 2023.\n- Result 3 (2023-10-25): Calvin visited Boston with a high school friend on October 24, 2023.\n- Result 19 (2023-11-17): Calvin accepted an invitation to perform at an upcoming show in Boston.\n- Result 39 (2023-11-13): Calvin",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.23,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.95
    },
    {
      "question": "Which city was Calvin at on October 3, 2023?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "Boston",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for any messages around October 3, 2023, mentioning Calvin's location.\n\nStep 2: Result 22 [2023-10-04] Calvin to Dave says: \"We've been greatly privileged to have been granted this opportunity. It's so satisfying to bring it back to life!\" This suggests Calvin was involved in some project around that time.\n\nStep 3: Result 28 [2023-10-25] Calvin to Dave mentions: \"I had a great time yesterday (approximately October 24, 2023), and visited some sights in Boston with a high school friend.\"\n\nStep 4: Result 21 [2023-05-31] Dave to Calvin says: \"Great, Calvin! Have a great time in Boston. Can't wait to hear all about it when you get back!\" This indicates Calvin planned a trip to Boston earlier in the year.\n\nStep 5: Result 38 [2023-03-23] Calvin to Dave",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.18,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.11
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Calvin met with local artists in Boston?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "October 3, 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Calvin meeting local artists in Boston.\n- Result 1 (2023-10-04): Calvin says \"Yesterday (approximately October 03, 2023) I met with some incredible artists in Boston...\"\n- Result 77 (2023-10-04): Calvin mentions talking to those artists and a mutual friend arranged the meeting.\n\nStep 2: Confirm no other earlier or later mentions contradict or add to this.\n- Result 6 (2023-10-25): Calvin visited Boston with a high school friend on October 24, 2023, but no mention of meeting artists then.\n- Result 41 (2023-08-22): Calvin met Frank Ocean in Tokyo, not Boston.\n- Result 11 (2023-11-17): Calvin accepted an invitation to perform in Boston, no mention of meeting artists then.\n\nStep 3: Conclusion\nThe only explicit mention of meeting local artists in Boston is on October 3",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.31,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.86
    },
    {
      "question": "What shared activities do Dave and Calvin have?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Working on cars",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify activities mentioned in the conversations involving both Dave and Calvin.\n\n- Music collaboration and performances: Multiple messages (e.g., Results 6, 7, 17, 19, 32, 39, 81) mention Calvin and Dave discussing music collaborations, performances, and working with other artists.\n- Supporting and encouraging each other in music and creative projects (Results 1, 4, 14, 23, 28, 31, 46, 72).\n- Sharing photos and experiences from music events and festivals (Results 6, 19, 21, 41, 48).\n- Discussing and appreciating the creative process and hard work in music and other projects (Results 1, 4, 14, 23, 28, 31, 46, 72).\n- Dave is involved in working on cars and garage projects (Results 20, 45, 75, 88), and Calvin shows",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.6,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.08
    },
    {
      "question": "What is Dave's favorite activity?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Restoring cars",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for mentions of Dave's interests or hobbies in the conversation excerpts.\n\nStep 2: In [Result 46] (2023-08-03), Calvin asks Dave about good memories working on cars with his dad, indicating Dave has a hobby related to cars.\n\nStep 3: In [Result 70] (2023-08-14), Calvin says \"Car workshops sound totally cool and inspiring. Glad you found something that really gets you going,\" confirming Dave is involved in car workshops.\n\nStep 4: In [Result 94] (2023-07-21), Dave talks about a road trip with friends, enjoying driving on winding roads and recharging, showing his passion for cars and driving.\n\nStep 5: In [Result 79] (2023-11-02), Dave mentions listening to vinyl music while doing his car stuff, linking his car hobby with music.\n\nStep 6: In [Result 61] (2023-",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.32,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.32
    },
    {
      "question": "How many car shows has Dave attended?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "two",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify all mentions of Dave attending car shows.\n\n- Result 29 [2023-10-08]: Dave says he went to a car show last Friday, saw awesome cars, and enjoyed it.\n- Result 47 [2023-04-20]: Dave mentions going to a car show last weekend, admiring classic cars.\n- Result 79 [2023-03-23]: Dave attended an event recently (approx. March 16, 2023) described as a car lover's paradise with many classic cars on show.\n\nStep 2: Check if these mentions refer to different events.\n\n- The March 16, 2023 event (Result 79) is distinct from the April 20, 2023 car show (Result 47).\n- The October 6 or 7, 2023 car show (Result 29) is also distinct and later in the year.\n\nStep 3: No other mentions of Dave attending car shows are",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.65,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.87
    },
    {
      "question": "What was Dave doing in the first weekend of October 2023?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "attending a car show",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for any messages from or about Dave around early October 2023.\n\nStep 2: The closest relevant message is [Result 71] dated 2023-09-15, where Dave mentions: \"last weekend, I had the opportunity to attend a rock concert here in Boston.\"\n\nStep 3: The first weekend of October 2023 would be October 1-2, 2023. There is no direct message from Dave or about Dave specifically mentioning activities on that exact weekend.\n\nStep 4: The closest time frame is the September 15 message about a recent rock concert, but that is mid-September, not October.\n\nStep 5: No other messages mention Dave's activities specifically in early October 2023.\n\nConclusion: There is no explicit information about what Dave was doing in the first weekend of October 2023.\n\nFinal answer: Not enough information.",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 5.0,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.18
    },
    {
      "question": "When Dave was a child, what did he and his father do in the garage?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "tinkering with car engines, restoration and refurbishing cars",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about Dave's childhood and garage activities.\n\n- Result 22 [2023-10-08T15:15:00] Dave to Calvin: \"When I was little I'd spend hours in my dad's garage, tinkering with engines - it was like my own sanctuary.\"\n\n- Result 1 [2023-08-03T13:13:00] Calvin to Dave: \"Remember any good memories from working on cars with your dad?\"\n\n- Result 98 [2023-09-02T09:19:30] Calvin to Dave: \"I totally understand the satisfaction you get from fixing cars.\"\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.\n\nDave spent hours in his dad's garage tinkering with engines, which implies working on car engines or mechanical parts as a child.\n\nFinal answer:  \nAs a child, Dave and his father spent time in the garage tinkering with car engines, working on mechanical parts together.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.83,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.87
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Calvin buy his second Ferrari?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "first week of October 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Calvin buying a Ferrari.\n\n- Result 3 (2023-10-15): Calvin says, \"Last week (approximately October 08, 2023), I got a new Ferrari!\"\n- Result 12 (2023-08-03): Calvin talks about a trip to a Ferrari dealership but does not mention buying a Ferrari.\n- No other explicit mentions of Calvin buying a Ferrari.\n\nStep 2: Determine if this is the first or second Ferrari.\n\n- There is no mention of Calvin buying a Ferrari before October 2023.\n- Result 7 (2023-03-26) mentions Calvin getting a new luxury car but does not specify it as a Ferrari.\n- No other earlier mentions of Calvin owning a Ferrari.\n\nStep 3: Since the question is about the second Ferrari, check if there is any indication Calvin had a first Ferrari before October 2023.\n\n- No evidence in the context that Calvin owned a Ferrari before October 202",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.53,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.8
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Calvin and Frank Ocean start collaborating?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "August 2022",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of when Calvin and Frank Ocean started collaborating.\n\n- Result 1 (2023-08-22): Calvin says he met Frank Ocean at a music festival in Tokyo and they clicked, arranged a meeting, and recorded a song at his mansion.\n- Result 3 (2023-10-19): Calvin says \"It all started August last year (approximately October 19, 2022) when we met at a festival and he said he wanted to collaborate.\"\n- Result 15 (2023-08-22): Calvin mentions scoring a deal to continue collaboration with Frank Ocean.\n- Result 27 (2023-05-31): Calvin mentions touring with Frank Ocean last week (approx. May 24, 2023).\n- Result 22 (2023-10-19): Calvin says he started touring with Frank Ocean recently.\n- Result 6 (2023-10-19): Calvin says the tour has been great, jamming with",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.14,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.94
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Calvin plan on travelling to Tokyo the second time?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "November 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Calvin's travel plans to Tokyo.\n\n- Result 35 (2023-03-23): Calvin says, \"I'm heading there next month.\"\n- Result 6 (2023-10-19): Calvin says, \"I'm actually going to Tokyo next month after the tour ends.\"\n\nStep 2: Determine the date of the messages mentioning the second trip.\n\n- Result 6 is dated 2023-10-19 and mentions going to Tokyo next month after the tour ends.\n- This implies Calvin planned to travel to Tokyo in November 2023.\n\nStep 3: Confirm this is the second trip.\n\n- Earlier, Calvin had been in Tokyo around May 2023 (Result 72).\n- The October 19 message refers to a future trip \"next month,\" so this is a second planned trip.\n\nFinal answer:  \nCalvin planned to travel to Tokyo the second time in November 2023, as stated on October 19, 202",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.12,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.92
    },
    {
      "question": "Who supports Calvin in tough times?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "friends and team",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of support for Calvin in tough times.\n\n- Result 4 (2023-11-13): Calvin says having supportive people is key for his growth as an artist and motivation, especially in the tough music industry.\n- Result 5 (2023-10-23): Calvin mentions his friends and team keep him on track.\n- Result 12 (2023-11-13): Calvin says \"He's been such a great friend to me. Always there to support and encourage me. His positivity has made a big difference in my journey.\"\n- Result 77 (2023-11-13): Dave asks Calvin if having supportive people is important for artist development, implying Calvin values support.\n- Result 71 (2023-08-03): Calvin says seeing \"it\" every day keeps him motivated and reminds him to keep pushing (likely referring to support or something symbolic).\n- Result 64, 85, 84, 10, 20,",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.3,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.03
    },
    {
      "question": "What does help Calvin stay connected to the creative process?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "Calvin stays connected to the creative process by always staying up-to-date on world events and watching documentaries about artists.",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Calvin's methods or tools for staying connected to creativity.\n\n- Result 26 (2023-11-02): Calvin asks Dave if a notebook helps him stay connected to the creative process.\n- Result 65 (2023-11-02): Calvin says he usually watches music videos, concerts, and documentaries about artists and their creative process, which inspires him.\n- Result 99 (2023-11-02): Calvin mentions he only works in the studio and has a separate cozy, relaxing room with a TV to unwind and get inspired.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize these details.\n\nCalvin stays connected to the creative process by watching music videos, concerts, and documentaries about artists, which serve as inspiration. He also works in a dedicated studio space and uses a separate relaxing room to unwind and stimulate creativity.\n\nFinal answer:  \nCalvin stays connected to the creative process by watching music videos, concerts, and documentaries about artists, and by working in his",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.74,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.55
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Calvin visit some of the sights in Boston with a former high school friend?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "October 24, 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant excerpt about Calvin visiting sights in Boston with a high school friend.  \n- Result 1 [2023-10-25]: Calvin to Dave says, \"I had a great time yesterday (approximately October 24, 2023), and visited some sights in Boston with a high school friend.\"\n\nStep 2: Confirm the date of the visit.  \n- Calvin explicitly states \"yesterday\" relative to the message date 2023-10-25, so the visit was on October 24, 2023.\n\nFinal answer:  \nCalvin visited some sights in Boston with a former high school friend on October 24, 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.08,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.45
    },
    {
      "question": "Which cities did Dave travel to in 2023?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "San Francsico, Detroit",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of cities Dave traveled to in 2023 from the conversation excerpts.\n\n- Boston:  \n  - [Result 18] Calvin mentions booking a flight to Boston last week (approx. August 26, 2023).  \n  - [Result 27] Calvin says he visited some sights in Boston with a high school friend on October 24, 2023.  \n  - [Result 46] Dave took a picture in Boston last month (approx. September 29, 2023).  \n  - [Result 24] Calvin mentions contacting Dave when he arrives in Boston.  \n  - [Result 29] Dave congratulates Calvin on the upcoming tour and asks about cities or venues, implying travel plans involving cities including Boston.\n\n- Tokyo:  \n  - Multiple mentions of Tokyo, mostly about Calvin's tour and experiences ([Results 3, 4, 9, 12, 23, 26, 34, 48",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.6,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.88
    },
    {
      "question": "Which hobby did Dave pick up in October 2023?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "photography",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for any mentions of new hobbies or activities Dave started around October 2023.\n\nStep 2: In Result 89 (2023-11-17), Dave says to Calvin: \"I've taken up photography and it's been great - been taking pics of the scenery around here which is really cool.\"\n\nStep 3: This message is from November 17, 2023, so the hobby was picked up before that date, likely recently.\n\nStep 4: No other hobbies are mentioned as newly started by Dave in October 2023.\n\nFinal answer: Dave picked up photography as a hobby in October 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.94,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.65
    },
    {
      "question": "Which events in Dave's life inspired him to take up auto engineering?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "attending a car show with Dad, working on an old car in a neighbor's garage when he was young, spent a summer restoring an old car with Dad",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of what inspired Dave to start working on cars or auto engineering.\n\n- Result 5 (2023-10-23): Dave says he was fascinated with how machines work since he was ten, found an old car in a neighbor's garage, and asked to fix it. That experience sparked his love for car engineering.\n- Result 68 (2023-10-25): Dave mentions his dad took him to his first car show when he was 10, which wowed him and hooked him on learning more about cars.\n- Result 81 (2023-08-03): Dave recalls fond memories of working on cars with his dad as a kid, including restoring an old car one summer, which was hard work but satisfying.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize these points.\n\nDave's inspiration to take up auto engineering came from childhood experiences: his fascination with machines starting at age 10, fixing an old car he found in a neighbor's garage, and attending",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.47,
      "judge_latency_s": 3.18
    },
    {
      "question": "How many Ferraris does Calvin own?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "two",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Calvin mentions getting a new Ferrari around October 8, 2023 (Result 2).\n\nStep 2: Earlier, on March 26, 2023, Calvin talks about just getting a new car, which is implied to be a luxury car but not explicitly a Ferrari (Results 11, 49).\n\nStep 3: On August 3, 2023, Calvin refers to \"my Ferrari\" when talking about taking it for service (Result 80), indicating he already owned a Ferrari by then.\n\nStep 4: There is no mention of Calvin owning more than one Ferrari at any time.\n\nStep 5: The timeline suggests Calvin got his first Ferrari before August 3, 2023, and then mentions a \"new Ferrari\" in early October 2023, which likely refers to the same car.\n\nFinal answer: Calvin owns one Ferrari.",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.65,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.75
    },
    {
      "question": "What gifts has Calvin received from his artist friends?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "gold chain, custom-made guitar with an octopus on it",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of gifts Calvin received from artist friends.\n\n- Result 13 (2023-05-01): Calvin says to Dave, \"I got it from another artist as a gift - it's a great reminder of why I keep hustling as a musician!\" This is in response to Dave's comment about a necklace (Result 25).\n\n- Result 52 (2023-08-31): Calvin says, \"I had this custom made by my Japanese artist friend. It's got an octopus on it, which represents my love for art and the sea. It's one of my favorites!\" This refers to a custom item, likely the same necklace or a similar piece.\n\nStep 2: Summarize the gifts.\n\nCalvin received a necklace (with an octopus design) from an artist friend as a gift.\n\nFinal answer:  \nCalvin has received a custom-made necklace featuring an octopus design as a gift from his Japanese artist friend.",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.48,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.26
    },
    {
      "question": "How long did Dave's work on the Ford Mustang take?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "nearly two months",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of the Ford Mustang restoration by Dave.\n\n- Result 2 (2023-10-04): Dave says he has been working on a Ford Mustang found in a junkyard.\n- Result 1 (2023-09-22): Dave mentions working on the engine of a vintage Mustang and having issues.\n- Result 29 (2023-08-11): Dave talks about working on a classic muscle car with engine swaps and body mods, likely the Mustang.\n- Result 91 (2023-11-02): Dave says he found the car last week (approx. Oct 26, 2023) in bad shape and spent ages restoring it.\n- Result 9 (2023-11-02): Dave posted about making the car look like a beast around Oct 26, 2023.\n- Result 100 (2023-08-14): Dave hopes the car will be fixed by the end of next month (September 202",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.3,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.92
    },
    {
      "question": "How long was the car modification workshop in San Francisco?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "two weeks",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of the car modification workshop in San Francisco.  \n- Result 1 (2023-08-14): Dave mentions going to a car workshop in San Francisco.  \n- Result 3 (2023-09-02): Dave says he came back from San Francisco \"yesterday\" (approx. Sept 1, 2023) with insights on car modification.  \n- Result 20 (2023-08-11): Calvin congratulates Dave on being picked for the car mod workshop.  \n- Result 44 and 45 (2023-08-11): Dave talks about working on cars and learning new modifications at the workshop.  \n- Result 99 (2023-08-11): Dave shares a picture from the workshop and mentions the thrill of seeing potential come to life.\n\nStep 2: Look for any explicit mention of the workshop duration.  \n- None of the excerpts explicitly state the length of the workshop.  \n- The earliest",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.61,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.29
    },
    {
      "question": "What style of guitars does Calvin own?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "custom-made yellow guitar with an octopus on it, shiny purple guitar",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Calvin's guitars in the context.\n\n- Result 1, 2, 6, 10, 22, 38, 47, 77, 80 mention Calvin's guitar(s).\n- Result 1: Dave compliments Calvin's guitar design as unique and special.\n- Result 2: Dave notes the guitar has a gorgeous purple hue and asks why it is so shiny.\n- Result 6 and 10: The guitar means a lot to Calvin, representing his journey and passion.\n- Result 22: Dave says the customized purple glow gives it a unique look.\n- Result 38: Calvin says he got it customized with a shiny finish for uniqueness and style.\n- Result 77: Calvin says the guitar was custom made by a Japanese artist friend, with an octopus design representing his love for art and the sea.\n- Result 80: Calvin says the guitar is unique and totally his style.\n- Result 47: Calvin says",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 4.0,
      "judge_latency_s": 3.36
    },
    {
      "question": "What activities has Dave participated in with his friends?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "weekly visits to local parks, countryside roadtrip, celebration of the opening of his car maintenance shop, card-playing nights",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Dave doing activities with friends.\n\n- Result 33 [2023-07-21]: Dave went on a road trip with friends, enjoying countryside views and chatting.\n- Result 72 [2023-08-22]: Dave had a card night with friends, laughing and having a great time.\n- Result 100 [2023-07-07]: Calvin mentions regular walks with friends as a good activity, possibly referring to Dave's habits.\n\nStep 2: Summarize the activities.\n\nDave has participated in a road trip, card night, and possibly regular walks with friends.\n\nFinal answer:  \nDave has participated in a road trip, card night, and regular walks with his friends.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.05,
      "judge_latency_s": 3.4
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Dave take a photo of a Boston clock tower?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "September 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of a Boston clock tower photo by Dave.  \n- Result 3: Dave confirms the last photo Calvin referred to is the clock tower, snapped at sunset.  \n- Result 6: Dave says the photo is Boston, taken last month (approximately September 29, 2023).  \n- Result 12: Calvin asks about a recent photo, Dave replies with the Boston clock tower photo.  \n- Result 1 and 3 together confirm the clock tower photo is recent and from Boston.\n\nStep 2: Confirm the date of the photo.  \n- Result 6 states Dave took the Boston photo last month, approximately September 29, 2023.  \n- The conversation date is October 29, 2023, so \"last month\" aligns with late September 2023.\n\nFinal answer:  \nDave took the photo of the Boston clock tower around September 29, 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.73,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.95
    },
    {
      "question": "Do all of Dave's car restoration projects go smoothly?",
      "category": 1,
      "gold_answer": "No",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Review mentions of Dave's car restoration projects and any issues or challenges.\n\n- Result 27 (2023-10-23): Dave mentions restoring a car last year (Oct 2022) and selling it; now working on a new challenging project.\n- Result 83 (2023-10-23): Dave says restoration takes patience and attention to detail, implying it can be tough.\n- Result 38 (2023-09-02): Dave talks about gaining insights from a workshop and the satisfaction of giving an old car new life.\n- Result 28 (2023-10-04): Dave says restoring a car was a lot of work but satisfying.\n- Result 10 and 13 (2023-08-03): Dave recalls hard work restoring a car with his dad.\n- Result 79 (2023-05-31): Dave fixed a neighbor's car engine, implying success.\n- Result 55 (2023-10-04):",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.41,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.5
    },
    {
      "question": "Where was Calvin located in the last week of October 2023?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "Tokyo",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify any references to Calvin's location around late October 2023.\n\n- Result 94 [2023-11-02]: Calvin mentions throwing a small party at his Japanese house for his new album last week (approximately October 26, 2023).\n- Result 73 [2023-10-19]: Calvin talks about meeting a collaborator at a festival in August last year and performing on stage, but no specific location for late October 2023.\n- Result 54 [2023-10-25]: Calvin mentions visiting some sights in Boston on October 24, 2023.\n- Result 91 [2023-10-19]: Calvin says a picture was taken in Tokyo during a concert.\n- Result 24 [2023-08-22]: Calvin describes an incredible experience in a city with a lively festival crowd, but no date in late October.\n- Result 59 [2023-03-23]: Calvin says he will be in",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 4.02,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.95
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Dave find the car he repaired and started sharing in his blog?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "last week of October 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify when Dave started the car restoration project he shared on his blog.\n\n- Result 72 (2023-10-23): Dave says he restored a car last year (approximately October 23, 2022) and sold it to a collector. Now he is working on a new project.\n- Result 26 (2023-10-23): Dave talks about his love for car engineering starting when he was ten, but this is background, not the specific project.\n- Result 29 and 31 (2023-11-02): Dave mentions starting a blog on car mods approximately October 26, 2023, sharing his passion and projects.\n- Result 21 (2023-11-02): Dave says the car mod he posted about was a lot of work but worth it.\n- Result 69 and 45 (2023-08 and 2023-10): Dave shares photos and progress of a car restoration project ongoing in 202",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.54,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.8
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Dave buy a vintage camera?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "November 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Dave buying or having a vintage camera.  \n- Result 4 (2023-11-17T10:56:00) Dave to Calvin: \"Glad to hear you had such an inspiring conversation! Take a look at my new vintage camera that I bought this month...\"  \n- Result 9 (2023-11-17T10:57:00) Dave to Calvin: \"Yes, Calvin, this camera is very good...\"  \n\nStep 2: The date of these messages is November 17, 2023, and Dave says he bought the vintage camera \"this month,\" meaning November 2023.\n\nFinal answer:  \nDave bought the vintage camera in November 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.78,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.19
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Calvin attend a gala in Boston?",
      "category": 2,
      "gold_answer": "November 16, 2023",
      "generated_answer": "Calvin attended a fancy gala in Boston on November 16, 2023, as he mentioned in a message to Dave on November 17, 2023, that he went to the gala \"yesterday.\"",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.45,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.0
    },
    {
      "question": "How long did Calvin plan to stay in Japan?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "A few months",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about Calvin's planned stay in Japan.\n\n- Result 8 [2023-03-23]: Calvin says, \"I'm gonna be in Japan for a few months then off to Boston!\"\n- Result 42 [2023-03-23]: Calvin says, \"I'm heading there next month. I'll be staying in such a nice place while I'm there.\"\n\nStep 2: No other excerpts specify a different duration or contradict this.\n\nStep 3: The phrase \"a few months\" clearly indicates Calvin planned to stay in Japan for several months.\n\nFinal answer: Calvin planned to stay in Japan for a few months.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.87,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.61
    },
    {
      "question": "Which band was Dave's favorite at the music festival in April 2023?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Aerosmith",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant time frame and event. The question asks about Dave's favorite band at a music festival in April 2023.\n\nStep 2: Look for mentions of a music festival in April 2023 and Dave's favorite band.\n\n- Result 12 [2023-03-26]: Dave mentions attending a music festival in Boston last weekend (which would be around late March 2023), not April.\n- Result 1 and 65 [2023-04-20]: Calvin talks about a festival in Tokyo.\n- Result 33 [2023-03-26]: Dave says there were many great bands and his favorite was Aerosmith at a festival.\n- Result 20 [2023-03-26]: Dave saw \"them\" live and was jamming to one of their hits (likely referring to Aerosmith).\n- Result 76 and 77 [2023-03-26]: Calvin responds to Dave about Aerosmith being his favorite.\n\n",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.54,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.31
    },
    {
      "question": "Where did Calvin attend a music festival in April 2023?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Tokyo",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify any mentions of music festivals attended by Calvin around April 2023.\n\nStep 2: Result 1 (2023-04-20) shows Calvin talking about a festival in Tokyo, but no specific date is given for when he attended.\n\nStep 3: Result 27 (2023-04-20) Dave asks Calvin about the music event in Tokyo, implying it was recent.\n\nStep 4: Result 30 (2023-04-20) Calvin says he just went to an awesome music thingy in Tokyo.\n\nStep 5: Result 25 (2023-04-20) Calvin mentions an upcoming trip to Boston after finishing the Frank Ocean tour, so he had not been to Boston yet in April.\n\nStep 6: Result 5 (2023-03-26) Dave mentions he went to a music festival in Boston last weekend, but this is Dave, not Calvin.\n\nStep 7: No other mentions of Calvin attending a",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.86,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.73
    },
    {
      "question": "What advice did Calvin receive from the producer at the music festival?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "to stay true to himself and sound unique",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant excerpts about the music festival and advice from the producer.\n\n- Result 1 (2023-04-20): Calvin mentions learning a lot and getting great advice from professionals in the music industry at a music festival.\n- Result 5 (2023-04-20): Calvin specifically says the producer advised him to \"stay true to myself and sound unique,\" which motivated him to think about the direction of his music.\n- Result 3 and 41 (Dave's questions) confirm Calvin was inspired and got advice.\n\nStep 2: Summarize the advice.\n\nThe producer's advice was to stay true to himself and maintain a unique sound.\n\nFinal answer:  \nCalvin was advised by the producer at the music festival to stay true to himself and sound unique, which motivated him to consider the direction of his music.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.87,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.92
    },
    {
      "question": "What is Dave's new business venture as of 1 May, 2023?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Car maintenance shop",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for mentions of Dave's new business around May 1, 2023.\n\n- Result 14 [2023-05-01]: Calvin congratulates Dave on opening his own car maintenance shop.\n- Result 16 [2023-05-16]: Dave says he opened his car shop last week (approx. May 9, 2023).\n- Result 41 [2023-05-01]: Dave confirms he opened his own car maintenance shop.\n- Result 74 [2023-05-01]: Dave shares a photo of his shop and invites Calvin to visit.\n- Result 91 [2023-05-03]: Dave mentions teaming up with a local garage.\n- Result 95 [2023-05-03]: Calvin congratulates Dave on teaming up with a local garage.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.\n\nDave's new business venture as of early May 2023 is opening his own car maintenance shop, and shortly",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.05,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.4
    },
    {
      "question": "What type of cars does Dave work on at his shop?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "all kinds of cars, from regular maintenance to full restorations of classic cars",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts where Dave talks about the types of cars he works on.\n\n- Result 8 (2023-05-01): Dave says he works on all kinds of cars at the shop, from regular maintenance to full restorations of classic cars.\n- Result 15 (2023-05-01): Dave mentions his dream of working on classic cars because he loves their design and engineering.\n- Result 58 (2023-05-01): Dave is obsessed with classic cars and restored one last year.\n- Result 70 (2023-08-11): Dave is working on a classic muscle car, doing engine swaps and suspension modifications.\n- Result 49 (2023-10-23): Dave restored a car last year and sold it to a collector, now working on a new challenging project.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.\n\nDave works on a variety of cars at his shop, including regular maintenance vehicles and classic cars, especially classic muscle",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.82,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.26
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Calvin receive as a gift from another artist?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "a gold necklace with a diamond pendant",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Calvin receiving a gift from another artist.  \n- Result 5 (2023-05-01): Calvin to Dave says, \"I got it from another artist as a gift - it's a great reminder of why I keep hustling as a musician!\"  \n- Result 30 (2023-05-01): Dave to Calvin asks, \"Wow, that's a great necklace! Where did you get it?\"  \n- Result 35 (2023-08-31): Calvin to Dave says, \"I had this custom made by my Japanese artist friend. It's got an octopus on it, which represents my love for art and the sea. It's one of my favorites!\"  \n- Result 74 (2023-05-01): Calvin to Dave mentions a \"beautiful necklace with a diamond pendant, that's so stunning!\"\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.  \nCalvin received a necklace as a gift from another artist, specifically a custom-made",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.76,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.1
    },
    {
      "question": "What was the necklace Calvin received meant to remind him of?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "why he keeps hustling as a musician",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of the necklace Calvin received.\n- Result 3: Calvin shows Dave a beautiful necklace with a diamond pendant.\n- Result 27: Calvin says he got the necklace from another artist as a gift and it\u2019s a great reminder of why he keeps hustling as a musician.\n- Result 54: Calvin mentions a custom necklace made by a Japanese artist friend with an octopus on it, representing his love for art and the sea.\n\nStep 2: Determine which necklace is the one Calvin received as a gift and what it symbolizes.\n- Result 27 explicitly states the necklace was a gift from another artist and reminds Calvin why he keeps hustling as a musician.\n- Result 54 describes a custom necklace with an octopus symbolizing his love for art and the sea, but it does not say it was a gift or what it reminds him of.\n\nStep 3: Synthesize the information.\n- The necklace Calvin received as a gift from another artist is meant to",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.74,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.31
    },
    {
      "question": "What does Dave do when he feels his creativity is frozen?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "immerse himself in something he loves",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Dave discussing what he does when creativity is low or frozen.\n\n- Result 7 (2023-05-03): Dave says if he has trouble coming up with ideas, he immerses himself in something he loves, like concerts or favorite albums, to jumpstart inspiration. He also suggests taking a break and having fun.\n\n- Result 63 (2023-05-03): Calvin thanks Dave for the advice about taking a break to get mojo back and explore other things.\n\n- Result 51 (2023-05-03): Calvin mentions being stuck with music and creativity frozen, and Dave advises taking time to chill and asks about hobbies to relax.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.\n\nDave's approach to frozen creativity is to take a break from music, immerse himself in enjoyable activities like concerts or favorite albums, and have fun to regain inspiration.\n\nFinal answer:  \nWhen Dave feels his creativity is frozen, he takes a break by immersing himself",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.19,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.89
    },
    {
      "question": "How does Calvin plan to jumpstart his inspiration?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "explore other things and have some fun",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for mentions of how Calvin gets inspired or jumpstarts his creativity.\n\nStep 2: In [Result 78] (2023-11-02), Calvin says he watches music videos, concerts, and documentaries about artists and their creative process to learn and get inspired.\n\nStep 3: In [Result 39] (2023-05-03), Dave suggests taking a break from music and exploring other things for inspiration, but this is Dave's advice, not Calvin's stated plan.\n\nStep 4: In [Result 22] (2023-10-23), Calvin mentions staying connected and up-to-date on world events to incorporate unique perspectives and stay motivated and inspired.\n\nStep 5: In [Result 44] (2023-10-23), Calvin says he has been inspired by struggles people go through, which makes him dig deeper into his music.\n\nStep 6: Synthesizing these, Calvin jumpstarts his inspiration by watching music-related",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.51,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.89
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Calvin manage to save during the flood incident?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "music gear and favorite microphone",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant excerpt about the flood incident.  \n- Result 4 [2023-05-16T11:51:00] Calvin to Dave mentions a flood incident around May 09, 2023.\n\nStep 2: Check what Calvin says he saved during the flood.  \n- Calvin says he managed to save his music gear and favorite microphone.\n\nFinal answer:  \nCalvin managed to save his music gear and favorite microphone during the flood incident.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.39,
      "judge_latency_s": 3.13
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Dave open in May 2023?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "a car shop",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for mentions of Dave opening something in May 2023.\nStep 2: Result 13 states: \"I'm so excited, I opened my car shop last week (approximately May 09, 2023)!\"\nStep 3: Result 57 confirms Calvin congratulating Dave on opening his car shop.\nStep 4: No other openings by Dave in May 2023 are mentioned.\n\nFinal answer: Dave opened a car shop in May 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.56,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.01
    },
    {
      "question": "What gives Dave a sense of achievement and purpose?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Fixing up things",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of what Dave finds fulfilling or motivating.  \n- Result 23 (2023-05-31): Dave says he is passionate about fixing up things, which is more than a hobby and gives him a sense of achievement and purpose.  \n- Result 66 (2023-05-31): Dave mentions that transforming something and giving it new life makes him feel powerful and happy, like he really achieved something.  \n- Result 74 (2023-08-03): Dave notes Calvin's car looks great and that having something like that is motivating, implying Dave values tangible results of hard work.  \n- Result 50 (2023-05-01): Dave says a mix (likely music or work) keeps him motivated and makes it worthwhile.  \n- Result 98 (2023-11-02): Dave finds it fulfilling to share knowledge and help others unleash creativity.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the main source of Dave's sense of achievement and",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.78,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.07
    },
    {
      "question": "What fuels Calvin's soul?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Performing live",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of what Calvin says fuels his soul.  \n- Result 3 (2023-05-31): Calvin says, \"Performing live always fuels my soul! I love the rush and connection with the crowd, the feeling's indescribable\u2014it's an absolute high!\"  \n- Result 14 (2023-08-22): Calvin says, \"The city was buzzing with energy and the festival crowd was so lively - it was like fuel for my soul.\"  \n- Result 61 (2023-10-25): Calvin says, \"Being up there with someone I admire - it was a dream come true. The energy, the crowd - it made me realize how much music means to me, it's like my passion and my purpose.\"  \n- Result 97 (2023-08-31): Calvin says, \"Performing on such a big stage was a dream come true! The energy was incredible and I felt on top of the world.\"\n\n",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.88,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.48
    },
    {
      "question": "What is Dave doing to relax on weekends?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "exploring parks",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for mentions of Dave's weekend activities or hobbies related to relaxation.\n\nStep 2: In [Result 54] (2023-05-03), Dave mentions teaming up with a local garage, indicating an interest in car work.\n\nStep 3: In [Result 83] (2023-07-21), Dave talks about a road trip with friends on winding roads, which recharged him and reminded him why he loves cars.\n\nStep 4: In [Result 8] (2023-11-02), Dave says when doing his car stuff, he listens to vinyl to relax and stay on track.\n\nStep 5: In [Result 74] (2023-08-22), Dave mentions having a card night with friends last Friday, which was fun and relaxing.\n\nStep 6: In [Result 95] (2023-03-26), Dave went to a music festival in Boston last weekend, which he found awesome and",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.17,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.03
    },
    {
      "question": "What sports activity is Calvin planning to try after the tour with Frank Ocean?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Skiing",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify any mentions of activities Calvin plans to try after the tour with Frank Ocean.\n\nStep 2: In Result 3 (2023-06-21), Calvin mentions: \"Look at that snowy peak\" and says he hasn't been there before but it's on his to-do list after the tour.\n\nStep 3: In Result 48 (2023-06-09), Calvin says he hasn't been to the mountains but wants to go on a hike to a place similar to the snowy peak photo.\n\nStep 4: No other sports activities are mentioned as plans after the tour.\n\nFinal answer: Calvin is planning to go hiking after the tour with Frank Ocean.",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.49,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.96
    },
    {
      "question": "What was Calvin excited to do after getting his car fixed on 7 July, 2023?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "get back on the road",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant date and message about Calvin's car being fixed.  \n- On 2023-07-07, Calvin replied to Dave: \"Ah, it really is beautiful... Look at the front part of the mansion.\" (Result 95) \u2014 unrelated to car.  \n- On 2023-07-07, Dave asked Calvin about the car after the crash (Result 2).  \n- On 2023-07-07, Calvin responded: \"Hey Dave! Thanks for checking in. It's all good now, the car's fixed and going strong. Nothing better than cruising around - it's the best! Look at how my car looks right now. How've you been? Anything new?\" (Result 38)  \n\nStep 2: Analyze Calvin's excitement after the car was fixed.  \n- Calvin said \"Nothing better than cruising around - it's the best!\" indicating he was excited to drive and cruise around in his fixed car.  \n\nFinal answer",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.93,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.72
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Calvin and his friends arrange for in the park?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "regular walks together",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Calvin and friends in the park.\n- Result 21 (2023-07-07): Dave mentions arranging with friends for regular walks together in the park.\n- Result 60 (2023-07-07): Calvin responds positively about regular walks with friends in the park and asks if Dave has a favorite spot.\n- Result 51 (2023-07-07): Dave says \"today we are going to that spot\" in the park.\n\nStep 2: Confirm what was arranged.\n- Dave explicitly says he arranged with friends for regular walks together in the park (Result 21).\n- Calvin acknowledges and supports the idea of regular walks with friends (Result 60).\n\nStep 3: No other activities or arrangements in the park are mentioned.\n\nFinal answer:  \nCalvin and his friends arranged to have regular walks together in the park.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.36,
      "judge_latency_s": 3.43
    },
    {
      "question": "What kind of music has Calvin been creating lately?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "experimenting with different genres",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: From [Result 2] and [Result 39], Calvin has been experimenting with different genres and adding electronic elements to his songs, pushing himself out of his comfort zone.\n\nStep 2: From [Result 3], Calvin aims to expand his brand worldwide, work with artists globally, and create special music, indicating a diverse and evolving style.\n\nStep 3: From [Result 29], Calvin mentions exploring different styles and times in music to open new perspectives and broaden his musical knowledge.\n\nStep 4: From [Result 65], Calvin is having fun trying out new sounds and pushing boundaries, always seeking new ideas.\n\nStep 5: From [Result 53], Calvin has been working on collaborations with Japanese artists, which may influence his style.\n\nStep 6: From [Result 26], Calvin recalls rocking a classic hip-hop song \"California Love\" by Tupac and Dr. Dre, showing some roots or influences.\n\nStep 7: From [Result ",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.04,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.86
    },
    {
      "question": "How does Calvin describe his process of adding electronic elements to his songs?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "gives them a fresh vibe",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about Calvin adding electronic elements to his songs.  \n- Result 3 (2023-07-21): Calvin says he has been experimenting with different genres, pushing himself out of his comfort zone, and adding electronic elements to his songs to give them a fresh vibe.  \n- Result 37 (2023-07-21): Dave asks if moving between styles presents challenges, implying Calvin is experimenting with styles including electronic elements.  \n- Result 97 (2023-07-21): Calvin acknowledges switching styles can be tough but finds it exciting and motivating.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize Calvin's description.  \nCalvin describes adding electronic elements as part of experimenting with genres and pushing boundaries, which gives his songs a fresh vibe. He finds the process exciting, a form of self-discovery and growth, though it can be intimidating at times.\n\nFinal answer:  \nCalvin describes adding electronic elements to his songs as an exciting process of experimenting with different genres",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.81,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.87
    },
    {
      "question": "What car brand does Calvin own that he is proud of?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Ferrari",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Calvin's car brand in the conversation excerpts.\n\n- Result 7 (2023-08-03): Calvin mentions a trip to a Ferrari dealership and says his car is the best and he is proud of it.\n- Result 26 (2023-03-26): Calvin says he just got a new car, a luxury car, and is very happy.\n- Result 49 (2023-03-26): Calvin says he got a new car (approx. March 25, 2023) and is excited about it.\n- Result 59 (2023-10-15): Calvin says he got a new Ferrari last week (approx. October 8, 2023), calling it a masterpiece on wheels.\n- Result 67 (2023-10-15): Calvin confirms the Ferrari is a showstopper and will share a pic soon.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.\n\nCalvin owns a Ferrari, which he",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.58,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.92
    },
    {
      "question": "What is Calvin's biggest current goal?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "expand his brand worldwide and grow his fanbase",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Calvin's goals in the context.\n\n- Result 2 (2023-08-03): Dave asks Calvin about his biggest goal.\n- Result 29 (2023-08-03): Calvin responds with his plan to expand his brand worldwide, grow his fanbase, reach more people with his music, work with artists globally, and create special music.\n- Result 70 (2023-07-21): Calvin talks about making music to follow his dreams and collaborating with others.\n- Result 60 (2023-10-25): Calvin describes performing with someone he admires as a dream come true, reinforcing his passion for music.\n- Result 92 (2023-10-23): Calvin mentions the tour with Frank Ocean and the challenges of fame.\n- Result 24 (2023-10-23): Calvin talks about staying connected to world events to make his music stand out and connect with fans.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.39,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.57
    },
    {
      "question": "What is Dave's advice to Calvin regarding his dreams?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "to never forget his dreams",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify messages where Dave gives advice to Calvin about dreams.\n\n- Result 4 (2023-08-03): \"Glad to help, Calvin! Eager to see what you do. Keep at it and never forget your dreams!\"\n- Result 10 (2023-08-03): \"No problem, Calvin! Just remember to stay focused and keep going. You've got this!\"\n- Result 97 (2023-10-08): \"Thanks, Calvin! Your support really means a lot. I'll stay focused and keep going. Appreciate the encouragement!\"\n- Result 14 (2023-08-03): \"Sounds like you're really motivated, Calvin. What's the biggest goal you're working towards, music-wise or something else?\"\n- Result 67 (2023-05-01): \"Thanks, Calvin! It was a labor of love. Challenging, but so worth it.\" (less direct advice)\n- Result 91 (2023-07-21",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.11,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.85
    },
    {
      "question": "What workshop did Dave get picked for on 11 August, 2023?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Car mod workshop",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the date and event related to Dave and a workshop on or around 11 August 2023.\n\nStep 2: Result 31 [2023-08-11T17:22:30] Calvin to Dave says: \"Congrats on being picked for the car mod workshop.\"\n\nStep 3: Result 93 [2023-08-14T00:35:00] Dave to Calvin mentions attending a car workshop in San Francisco.\n\nStep 4: Result 72 [2023-08-11T17:24:30] Calvin to Dave asks about transformations and current projects related to the workshop.\n\nStep 5: Result 85 [2023-08-11T17:24:00] Dave to Calvin shares a picture from the workshop, indicating it was a car workshop.\n\nConclusion: On 11 August 2023, Dave was picked for a car modification (car mod) workshop.\n\nFinal answer: Dave was picked for a car",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.54,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.91
    },
    {
      "question": "What kind of modifications has Dave been working on in the car mod workshop?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "engine swaps, suspension modifications, and body modifications",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of the car mod workshop and Dave's work there.\n- Result 2 (2023-08-11): Dave says he got picked for a car mod workshop.\n- Result 8 (2023-08-11): Dave details working on engine swaps, suspension modifications, and now learning about body modifications on a classic muscle car.\n- Result 32 (2023-08-11): Dave mentions wanting a modern vibe with classic muscle car style.\n- Result 95 (2023-08-11): Dave shares a picture from the workshop showing the thrilling parts of the work.\n\nStep 2: Summarize the types of modifications mentioned.\n- Engine swaps\n- Suspension modifications\n- Body modifications\n- Customizing a classic muscle car with a modern twist\n\nFinal answer:  \nDave has been working on engine swaps, suspension modifications, and body modifications to give a classic muscle car a modern twist during the car mod workshop.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.47,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.26
    },
    {
      "question": "What type of car did Dave work on during the workshop?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "classic muscle car",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Dave working on cars during a workshop.  \n- Result 7 (2023-08-11): Dave says he got picked for a car mod workshop and is working on cars.  \n- Result 56 (2023-08-11): Dave mentions working on a classic muscle car doing engine swaps, suspension mods, and body modifications.  \n- Result 20 (2023-08-14): Dave talks about attending a car workshop in San Francisco focused on car restoration.  \n- Result 47 (2023-08-14): Dave shares a pic of the car he's restoring, describing it going from beat-up to a beauty.  \n\nStep 2: Check if the type of car is specified.  \n- Result 56 explicitly says \"classic muscle car\" for the car Dave is modifying in the workshop.  \n- Result 76 mentions a vintage Mustang engine Dave worked on, but this is described as a separate project with engine troubles, not",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.63,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.99
    },
    {
      "question": "What does Dave say is important for making his custom cars unique?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "attention to small details",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for mentions of what Dave says about making custom cars unique.  \nStep 2: In Result 4 [2023-08-11T17:27:30], Calvin says: \"Yeah, customizing a masterpiece with those small details is what makes it unique and personalized.\"  \nStep 3: Dave responds in Result 40 [2023-08-11T17:28:00]: \"Yeah! It's about showing my style, it's like customizing a work of art on wheels.\"  \nStep 4: Also, in Result 76 [2023-08-11T17:27:00], Dave says: \"Thanks, Calvin! It's all about those small details that make it unique and personalized.\"  \nStep 5: These indicate Dave emphasizes the importance of small details and personal style in making his custom cars unique.\n\nFinal answer:  \nDave says that paying attention to small details and showing his personal style are important for making his custom cars unique",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.69,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.18
    },
    {
      "question": "How did the audience in Tokyo react when Calvin sang one of his songs?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Everyone was so into it and sang along",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about Calvin's performance in Tokyo and audience reaction.\n\n- Result 4 (2023-08-14): Calvin to Dave: \"That show in Tokyo was awesome! Everyone was so into it when I played one of my songs and sang along. It was a magical moment.\"\n- Result 3 (2023-08-14): Calvin to Dave: \"The feeling of performing and connecting with the audience was unreal.\"\n- Result 51 (2023-08-22): Calvin to Dave: \"The festival had buzzing energy and a super upbeat crowd. We all felt connected, it was amazing!\"\n- Result 36 (2023-08-22): Calvin to Dave: \"The city was buzzing with energy and the festival crowd was so lively - it was like fuel for my soul.\"\n- Result 28 (2023-08-31): Calvin to Dave: \"Performing on such a big stage was a dream come true! The energy",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 12.81,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.81
    },
    {
      "question": "How did Calvin meet Frank Ocean?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "At a music festival in Tokyo",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for mentions of how Calvin and Frank Ocean met.  \nStep 2: Result 13 (2023-10-19) states: \"It all started August last year (approximately October 19, 2022) when we met at a festival and he said he wanted to collaborate. We clicked right away and the chemistry on stage was incredible.\"  \nStep 3: Result 1 (2023-08-22) also mentions Calvin meeting Frank Ocean at a music festival in Tokyo and clicking immediately.  \nStep 4: Both excerpts confirm the meeting happened at a music festival in August 2022, leading to collaboration.\n\nFinal answer:  \nCalvin met Frank Ocean at a music festival in August 2022, where they immediately connected and decided to collaborate.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.89,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.51
    },
    {
      "question": "Where did Calvin and Frank Ocean record a song together?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "In the studio at Calvin's mansion",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Calvin and Frank Ocean recording a song together.\n- Result 1 (2023-08-22): Calvin says they arranged a meeting and recorded a song in the studio at his mansion.\n- Result 28 (2023-08-22): Calvin mentions a deal to continue collaboration with Frank Ocean.\n- Result 17 (2023-10-19): Calvin says they met at a festival last year and collaborated.\n- Result 5 and 11 (2023-10-19): Calvin talks about touring and jamming with Frank Ocean but no mention of recording location.\n\nStep 2: The only explicit mention of recording location is in Result 1, where Calvin says they recorded a song in the studio at his mansion.\n\nFinal answer:  \nCalvin and Frank Ocean recorded a song together in the studio at Calvin's mansion.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.45,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.89
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Calvin and his friends record in August 2023?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "a podcast discussing the rap industry",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify any mentions of August 2023 in the context related to Calvin and his friends recording something.\n\nStep 2: Result 32 [2023-08-22T11:11:30] Calvin to Dave states: \"Of course, Dave can't wait to catch up! I almost forgot, yesterday (approximately August 21, 2023) my friends and I recorded a podcast where we discuss the rapidly evolving rap industry!\"\n\nStep 3: This is the only direct mention of Calvin and his friends recording something in August 2023.\n\nFinal answer: Calvin and his friends recorded a podcast about the rapidly evolving rap industry in August 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.11,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.91
    },
    {
      "question": "Where did Calvin start shooting a video for his new album?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Miami",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the message where Calvin mentions starting to shoot a video for his new album.  \n- Result 1 [2023-08-31]: Calvin says, \"Last weekend I started shooting a video for my new album - can't wait for you to check it out! Look how great it was!\"  \n- Result 69 [2023-08-31]: Calvin says, \"Oh man, they are amazing! I love the Miami vibe, it's perfect for the vid. Can't wait to show you!\"\n\nStep 2: Combine these details: The video shoot started last weekend before August 31, 2023, and Calvin mentions loving the Miami vibe for the video.\n\nStep 3: No other location is mentioned for the video shoot, so the location is Miami.\n\nFinal answer:  \nCalvin started shooting the video for his new album in Miami.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.17,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.87
    },
    {
      "question": "What design is featured on Calvin's guitar?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "octopus",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Calvin's guitar design in the context.\n\n- Result 24 [2023-08-31T15:01:30] Calvin to Dave: \"I had this custom made by my Japanese artist friend. It's got an octopus on it, which represents my love for art and the sea. It's one of my favorites!\"\n\n- Result 3 and 4 from Dave praise the guitar's unique design and its meaning to Calvin, but do not specify the design.\n\nStep 2: Confirm no other design details contradict or add to this.\n\n- Result 12: Calvin mentions a shiny finish for uniqueness and style, but no design detail.\n\n- No other specific design elements mentioned.\n\nFinal answer: Calvin's guitar features a custom octopus design made by his Japanese artist friend, symbolizing his love for art and the sea.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.73,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.95
    },
    {
      "question": "Why did Calvin get his guitar customized with a shiny finish?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "unique look",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about Calvin's guitar customization.\n\n- Result 2: Calvin says he got the guitar customized with a shiny finish because it gives it a unique look and it goes with his style.\n- Result 51: Calvin says he digs how the guitar is so unique and that it's totally his style.\n- Result 73: Calvin mentions the guitar was custom made by his Japanese artist friend, with an octopus design representing his love for art and the sea.\n- Result 12 and 5: The guitar means a lot to Calvin, representing his passion for music and friendships.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the reasons.\n\nCalvin customized the guitar with a shiny finish to give it a unique look that matches his personal style and artistic expression.\n\nFinal answer:  \nCalvin got his guitar customized with a shiny finish because it gives the instrument a unique look that fits his personal style.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.38,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.69
    },
    {
      "question": "What color glow did Calvin customize his guitar with?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "purple",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Calvin's guitar customization in the context.  \n- Result 4: Calvin says he got it customized with a shiny finish for a unique look and style.  \n- Result 3: Dave mentions the customized purple glow gives the guitar a unique look.  \n- Result 1: Dave comments on the guitar's gorgeous purple hue.  \n\nStep 2: Confirm the color of the glow.  \n- Both Dave and Calvin's messages indicate the guitar has a purple glow or hue.  \n\nFinal answer: Calvin customized his guitar with a purple glow.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.13,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.3
    },
    {
      "question": "Where did Dave come back from with insights on car modification on 1st September 2023?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "San Francisco",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant date and event.  \n- The question asks about where Dave came back from on September 1, 2023, with insights on car modification.\n\nStep 2: Look for mentions of Dave traveling or returning with car modification knowledge around that date.  \n- Result 1 [2023-09-02]: Dave to Calvin says, \"yesterday (approximately September 01, 2023) I came back from San Francsico with some great insights and knowledge on car modification.\"\n\nStep 3: Confirm the location mentioned.  \n- The location is \"San Francsico\" (likely a typo for San Francisco).\n\nFinal answer:  \nDave came back from San Francisco on September 1, 2023, with insights on car modification.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.16,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.72
    },
    {
      "question": "What emotion does Dave mention feeling when he sees the relief of someone whose car he fixed?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Proud",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts where Dave talks about fixing cars and the emotions involved.\n\n- Result 5 [2023-09-02T09:21:00] Dave to Calvin: \"Yeah, it's great! It feels really good to make a difference and see their relief when their car is fixed. Makes me proud!\"\n\n- Result 53 [2023-09-02T09:20:00] Dave to Calvin: \"Yeah, it's great fixing stuff up and seeing it turn out better. It's really rewarding and gives me a sense of purpose. Plus, it feels like I'm making a difference when I fix someone's car.\"\n\n- Result 18 [2023-09-02T09:20:30] Calvin to Dave: \"Wow, you must feel great making a real difference in someone's life, like being their superhero!\"\n\nStep 2: From Result 5, Dave explicitly states the emotion he feels when seeing the relief of someone whose car he fixed:",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.95,
      "judge_latency_s": 3.17
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Calvin book a flight ticket for on 1st September 2023?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Boston",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant date and message about Calvin booking a flight ticket.  \n- Result 7 [2023-09-02T09:21:30] Calvin to Dave: \"I booked a flight ticket to Boston last week (approximately August 26, 2023)! I'm so excited about my upcoming trip to Boston.\"\n\nStep 2: Confirm the timing of the booking relative to September 1, 2023.  \n- The message on September 2 says the ticket was booked \"last week,\" approximately August 26, 2023, which is just before September 1.\n\nStep 3: Confirm the purpose or destination of the flight ticket.  \n- The destination is Boston, and Calvin expresses excitement about the upcoming trip there.\n\nFinal answer:  \nCalvin booked a flight ticket for a trip to Boston around August 26, 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.91,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.89
    },
    {
      "question": "What is Calvin excited about after the tour?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "exploring and growing his brand",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Calvin's plans or feelings after the tour.  \n- Result 10 (2023-08-22): Calvin says his tour ends soon and he is heading to Boston, suggesting excitement about meeting up there.  \n- Result 55 (2023-06-21): Calvin mentions he hasn't been to Boston yet but plans to go after the Frank Ocean tour ends.  \n- Result 21 (2023-04-20): Calvin looks forward to his upcoming trip to Boston after finishing the Frank Ocean tour and is excited about the music scene there.  \n- Result 25 (2023-11-17): Calvin accepted an invitation to perform at an upcoming show in Boston, calling it an unforgettable musical experience.  \n- Result 29 (2023-05-31): Calvin is buzzing to perform in Boston and see what it's like.  \n- Result 63 (2023-11-13): Calvin invited an old high school buddy to see him",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.98,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.27
    },
    {
      "question": "What plans do Calvin and Dave have for when Calvin visits Boston?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Check out Dave's garage and maybe get some ideas for future projects",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Calvin mentions multiple times looking forward to exploring Boston, trying local food, and visiting popular attractions (Results 3, 4, 39, 61).\n\nStep 2: Dave offers to show Calvin around town and the music scene, including venues like Paradise Rock, House of Blues, and Fenway Park, and promises to be front row at Calvin\u2019s performances (Results 36, 95).\n\nStep 3: Calvin talks about collaborating with musicians and artists in Boston (Results 38, 80).\n\nStep 4: They plan to meet up and catch up while Calvin is in Boston (Results 2, 6, 7, 15, 41).\n\nStep 5: Calvin also mentions visiting sights in Boston with a high school friend (Result 5, 33).\n\nStep 6: They discuss working together on creative projects and supporting each other\u2019s work (Results 14, 16, 54, 86, 98).\n\nFinal",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.97,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.29
    },
    {
      "question": "Which Disney movie did Dave mention as one of his favorites?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Ratatouille",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify where Disney movies are mentioned in the context.  \n- In [Result 5], Dave says: \"It reminds me of one of my favorite Disney movies. I love the lesson it teaches about following your dreams no matter what others say.\"  \n- In [Result 42], Calvin replies: \"Thanks! Ratatouille is one of my favorites! It's all about going after what you love, no matter what anyone says.\"\n\nStep 2: Connect the two messages. Dave refers to a favorite Disney movie with a lesson about following your dreams, and Calvin responds by naming \"Ratatouille\" as one of his favorites with that same theme.\n\nStep 3: Since Dave's favorite Disney movie is not explicitly named by him, but Calvin's reply strongly implies the movie Dave mentioned is \"Ratatouille.\"\n\nFinal answer:  \nDave mentioned \"Ratatouille\" as one of his favorite Disney movies.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.01,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.98
    },
    {
      "question": "How does Dave feel about the reactions of people when they see the finished restoration project?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "satisfying and worth the hard work",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about Dave's feelings on people's reactions to his restoration work.\n\n- Result 21 [2023-09-15]: Dave says, \"It's so satisfying to see this brought back to life, especially with people's reactions when they see the finished product - makes all the hard work worth it.\"\n- Result 50 [2023-09-02]: Dave says, \"It feels really good to make a difference and see their relief when their car is fixed. Makes me proud!\"\n- Result 39 [2023-05-31]: Dave says, \"Giving it a new life makes me feel powerful and happy - like I really achieved something.\"\n- Result 2 [2023-08-14]: Dave shares excitement about the project going from a beat-up mess to a real beauty.\n- Result 95 [2023-10-04]: Dave says, \"It's so satisfying to bring an old car back to life.\"\n\nStep 2: Synthesize",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.33,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.95
    },
    {
      "question": "What activity did Calvin enjoy during his summer drives?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "feeling the wind blowing through his hair",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Calvin's summer drives in the context.  \n- Result 1 (2023-09-22): Calvin describes an amazing drive on a summer day with the wind blowing through his hair and a rush of freedom.  \n- Result 47 (2023-05-03): Calvin says long drives in his car help him relax, with the feeling of wind and open road being freeing and helping clear his head.  \n- Result 16 (2023-09-22): Dave responds to Calvin's summer drive, highlighting the feeling of freedom and reflection.\n\nStep 2: Determine what Calvin enjoyed during these drives.  \n- Calvin enjoyed the feeling of freedom and the wind blowing through his hair.  \n- He also enjoyed the rush of freedom and the opportunity to reflect and appreciate his life journey.  \n- Additionally, he found long drives relaxing and a way to clear his head.\n\nFinal answer:  \nCalvin enjoyed the feeling of freedom, the wind blowing through",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.66,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.93
    },
    {
      "question": "Which song from the childhood of Calvin brings back memories of a road trip with his dad?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "\"California Love\"",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant excerpts about Calvin's childhood memories and songs.\n- Result 2: Calvin mentions a song that always makes him smile, played during a road trip with his dad.\n- Result 13: Calvin specifies the song as \"California Love\" by Tupac and Dr. Dre.\n- Result 44: Dave confirms \"California Love\" is a classic and suggests jamming together.\n\nStep 2: Confirm the song is linked to a childhood memory and a road trip with his dad.\n- Result 2 explicitly connects the song to a road trip with his dad.\n- Result 13 names the song.\n\nFinal answer: The song from Calvin's childhood that brings back memories of a road trip with his dad is \"California Love\" by Tupac and Dr. Dre.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.36,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.86
    },
    {
      "question": "What project did Calvin work on to chill out?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "A shiny orange car",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Calvin working on a project to chill out.  \n- In [Result 7] (2023-10-04), Calvin says: \"Also, check out this project - I love working on it to chill out.\"  \n- In [Result 34] (2023-05-31), Calvin mentions: \"Working on cars helps me chill and clear my head.\"  \n- In [Result 65] (2023-05-03), Calvin says: \"Long drives in [this car] really help me relax.\"  \n\nStep 2: Determine what the project is.  \n- The project Calvin refers to in [Result 7] is not explicitly named but is linked to a hobby or creative work.  \n- In [Result 34], Calvin explicitly says working on cars helps him chill.  \n- In [Result 65], Calvin mentions long drives in a car help him relax.  \n\nStep 3: Synthesize the information.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.66,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.86
    },
    {
      "question": "What car did Dave work on in the junkyard?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Ford Mustang",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Dave working on a car found in a junkyard.  \n- Result 86 [2023-10-04]: Dave mentions working on a Ford Mustang found in a junkyard, describing it as in bad shape but with potential.\n\nStep 2: Confirm no other junkyard car mentions contradict or add details.  \n- Result 63 mentions a vintage Mustang engine Dave worked on, but no mention of junkyard.  \n- Result 47 mentions a restored car sold to a collector, but no junkyard mention.  \n- Result 73 mentions restoring a classic car last year, no junkyard mention.\n\nStep 3: Synthesize the information.  \nThe only car explicitly mentioned as found in a junkyard is the Ford Mustang Dave is restoring.\n\nFinal answer:  \nDave worked on a Ford Mustang that he found in a junkyard.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.82,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.25
    },
    {
      "question": "What does Dave find satisfying about restoring old cars?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Transforming something old and beat-up into something beautiful",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts where Dave talks about restoring old cars and what he finds satisfying.\n\n- Result 2 (2023-05-01): Dave says restoring a classic car last year was thrilling and like bringing it back to life.\n- Result 5 (2023-10-04): Dave says it's satisfying to bring an old car back to life.\n- Result 21 (2023-10-08): Dave calls restoring cars therapy, a way to escape stress, and enjoys transforming broken things into something awesome.\n- Result 56 (2023-05-31): Dave says fixing things gives him a sense of achievement and purpose, transforming something not working into something running smoothly, like giving it a second chance.\n- Result 59 (2023-05-31): Dave feels powerful and happy giving something a new life.\n- Result 66 (2023-10-04): Dave loves transforming something old and beat-up into something beautiful, small successes make him",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.92,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.03
    },
    {
      "question": "What do Calvin and Dave use to reach their goals?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Hard work and determination",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of what Calvin and Dave use to reach their goals.\n\n- Result 1 (Calvin to Dave, 2023-10-04): \"hard work and dedication are definitely key to reaching our goals and potential.\"\n- Result 5 (Calvin to Dave, 2023-10-04): \"hard work and determination matter, and it's what sets us apart.\"\n- Result 61 (Dave to Calvin, 2023-10-04): \"Hard work really does pay off!\"\n- Result 63 (Dave to Calvin, 2023-10-04): \"Hard work and determination will get us there.\"\n- Result 38 (Dave to Calvin, 2023-10-04): \"Together, we can do amazing things if we work together and stay motivated.\"\n- Result 11 (Calvin to Dave, 2023-05-01): \"when we remember why we're doing it, it keeps us going. Let's",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.52,
      "judge_latency_s": 3.5
    },
    {
      "question": "What does working on cars represent for Dave?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Therapy and a way to get away from everyday stress",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Dave expresses that working on cars is his passion and a source of great satisfaction (Results 11, 21, 46, 99).\n\nStep 2: He describes it as therapeutic and a way to escape or get away from everyday stress (Results 22, 44, 65).\n\nStep 3: It gives him a sense of accomplishment and purpose, especially transforming broken or old cars into something great (Results 8, 11, 49, 99).\n\nStep 4: It connects him to his childhood memories with his dad, making it personally meaningful (Results 22, 57).\n\nStep 5: It serves as a creative outlet and a way to express himself (Results 12, 43).\n\nStep 6: He also mentions that working on cars helps him connect back with himself and provides calmness (Result 12).\n\nFinal answer: For Dave, working on cars represents a passionate, therapeutic, and creative outlet that gives him a",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.58,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.03
    },
    {
      "question": "What does Dave aim to do with his passion for cars?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Take something broken and make it into something awesome",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify statements where Dave talks about his passion and goals related to cars.\n\n- [Result 10] Dave says working on cars is his passion and rewarding.\n- [Result 12] Dave mentions spending time in his dad's garage as a kid and now doing this as a job.\n- [Result 41] Dave says his dad took him to his first car show at age 10, which hooked him on cars, and now he is an automotive engineer.\n- [Result 53] Dave says his dream was to open a shop and work on classic cars.\n- [Result 62] Dave says he opened his car shop in early May 2023 and is excited to share his passion.\n- [Result 66] Dave says he wants to keep learning about auto engineering and maybe build a custom car from scratch someday.\n- [Result 71] Dave says being picked for a car mod workshop is a dream come true and he wants to build a custom car.\n",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.68,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.18
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Calvin recently get that is a \"masterpiece on wheels\"?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Ferrari",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for mentions of Calvin acquiring something described as a \"masterpiece on wheels.\"\n\nStep 2: In Result 18 (2023-10-15), Calvin says: \"Last week (approximately October 08, 2023), I got a new Ferrari! It's a masterpiece on wheels.\"\n\nStep 3: This is a direct statement from Calvin about what he recently got.\n\nFinal answer: Calvin recently got a new Ferrari, which he describes as a \"masterpiece on wheels.\"",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 4.58,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.98
    },
    {
      "question": "Who headlined the music festival that Dave attended in October?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "The Fireworks",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant messages about the festival Dave attended in October.  \n- Result 1 (2023-10-15): Dave to Calvin: \"The Fireworks headlined the festival.\"  \n- Result 13 (2023-10-15): Calvin to Dave asks who was the headliner after seeing a photo.  \n- Result 90 (2023-10-15): Dave to Calvin confirms the headliner was very good.  \n- Result 25 (2023-10-15): Calvin to Dave mentions The Fireworks and says they heard great things about them.\n\nStep 2: Confirm the festival date and headliner.  \n- The messages from October 15, 2023, indicate Dave attended a festival recently and that The Fireworks were the headliners.\n\nFinal answer:  \nThe Fireworks headlined the music festival that Dave attended in October.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 9.0,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.41
    },
    {
      "question": "How does Calvin stay motivated when faced with setbacks?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Reminds himself of his passion for goals, gets help from others, and takes a break to recharge",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts where Calvin talks about motivation and setbacks.\n\n- Result 1 (2023-10-15): Calvin says when setbacks come, he reminds himself why he's passionate about his goals, relies on helpful people around him, and takes breaks to recharge with favorite activities.\n- Result 28 (2023-10-15): Calvin encourages Dave not to give up and to keep pushing and believe in himself, implying Calvin himself uses belief and persistence.\n- Result 12 (2023-10-23): Calvin mentions having a strong support system with friends and team to keep on track.\n- Result 13 (2023-11-13): Calvin emphasizes the importance of supportive people for motivation and staying true to himself.\n- Result 9 (2023-10-23): Calvin takes it one day at a time, acknowledges feeling overwhelmed but pushes on because he enjoys what he does.\n- Result 61 (2023-11-17): Calvin finds nature's",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.02,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.29
    },
    {
      "question": "What activity does Dave find fulfilling, similar to Calvin's passion for music festivals?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "fixing things",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify Calvin's passion: Calvin is passionate about music festivals, performing live, and the energy and connection they bring (Results 9, 10, 20, 23, 40).\n\nStep 2: Look for what Dave finds fulfilling that is similar in nature to Calvin's passion for music festivals.\n\nStep 3: In Result 68 and Result 78, Dave compares music to repairing things, saying \"Music and repairing things are so fulfilling and satisfying\" and \"I love the feeling of taking something broken and making it whole again.\"\n\nStep 4: In Result 25, Dave mentions listening to vinyl music while doing his \"car stuff\" to relax and stay on track.\n\nStep 5: In Result 88, Dave talks about paying attention to details making a big difference, whether in music or vehicles.\n\nStep 6: These indicate that Dave finds repairing and working on vehicles fulfilling, similar to Calvin's passion for music festivals.\n\nFinal answer:  \nDave",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 5.06,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.04
    },
    {
      "question": "Where did Calvin and Dave meet Frank Ocean to start collaborating?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "at a festival",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of meeting Frank Ocean and starting collaboration.  \n- Result 1 (2023-08-22): Calvin says he met Frank Ocean at a music festival in Tokyo, they clicked, arranged a meeting, and recorded a song at his mansion.  \n- Result 3 (2023-10-19): Calvin says it all started August last year (approx. October 19, 2022) when they met at a festival and wanted to collaborate.  \n- Result 42 (2023-08-22): Calvin describes the festival as a dream come true with buzzing energy and a super upbeat crowd.  \n- Result 16 (2023-08-14): Calvin mentions touring with a well-known artist and ending with a show in Japan, then exploring his new place.  \n- Result 17 (2023-05-31): Calvin mentions touring with Frank Ocean last week in Tokyo with an insane crowd.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the timeline",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.8,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.74
    },
    {
      "question": "Which part of Tokyo is described as Tokyo's Times Square by Calvin?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Shibuya Crossing",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify where Calvin mentions a part of Tokyo as \"Tokyo's Times Square.\"  \nStep 2: In Result 2, Calvin says: \"Shibuya Crossing is like Tokyo's Times Square.\"  \nStep 3: This is a direct comparison made by Calvin, clearly identifying Shibuya Crossing as the area described.\n\nFinal answer:  \nCalvin describes Shibuya Crossing as Tokyo's Times Square.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.88,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.36
    },
    {
      "question": "What specific location in Tokyo does Calvin mention being excited to explore?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Shinjuku",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of specific Tokyo locations Calvin is excited about.  \n- Result 23 (2023-10-19): Calvin says, \"Shibuya Crossing is like Tokyo's Times Square, and I was excited to explore Shinjuku.\"  \n- Result 46 (2023-10-19): Dave mentions Shibuya and Shinjuku as cool spots, confirming Calvin's interest.\n\nStep 2: Confirm no other specific Tokyo locations are mentioned by Calvin with excitement.  \n- No other specific Tokyo locations named with excitement in the excerpts.\n\nFinal answer:  \nCalvin specifically mentions being excited to explore Shibuya Crossing and Shinjuku in Tokyo.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 4.16,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.41
    },
    {
      "question": "What dish does Dave recommend Calvin to try in Tokyo?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "ramen",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of food or dishes recommended by Dave in Tokyo.\n\n- In [Result 6], Dave says: \"Have you tried ramen yet? Here's a photo of a ramen bowl that I tried in Boston, it was delicious, but I think in Tokyo it will be even better!\"\n\nStep 2: Check if any other dishes are mentioned by Dave as recommendations.\n\n- No other specific dishes recommended by Dave are found in the context.\n\nFinal answer: Dave recommends Calvin to try ramen while in Tokyo.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.65,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.0
    },
    {
      "question": "What does Calvin find energizing during the tour?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Performing and connecting with the crowd",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Calvin's feelings about the tour and what energizes him.\n\n- Result 3 (2023-10-23): Calvin says, \"The tour's been incredible! Performing and connecting with the crowd has been so energizing.\"\n- Result 6 (2023-08-14): Calvin mentions, \"The feeling of performing and connecting with the audience was unreal.\"\n- Result 14 (2023-05-31): Calvin says, \"Performing live always fuels my soul! I love the rush and connection with the crowd, the feeling's indescribable\u2014it's an absolute high!\"\n- Result 23 (2023-08-31): Calvin says, \"The tour was amazing! I was so pumped from all the energy from the audience.\"\n- Result 32 (2023-08-31): Calvin says, \"Performing on such a big stage was a dream come true! The energy was incredible and I felt on top of the",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.6,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.85
    },
    {
      "question": "How does Calvin balance his job and personal life?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Takes it one day at a time",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about Calvin's balance of job and personal life.\n\n- Result 11 [2023-10-23T14:17:00] Dave to Calvin asks: \"How are you juggling your job plus your personal life?\"\n- Result 7 [2023-10-23T14:18:30] Calvin to Dave responds: \"I take it one day at a time, but it can get overwhelming with so many demands. Still, I enjoy what I do so I push on.\"\n- Result 27 [2023-10-23T14:19:00] Dave to Calvin: \"Glad you're finding joy in what you do! Any strategies that help you manage everything?\"\n- Result 40 [2023-10-23T14:19:30] Calvin to Dave: \"Yeah, having a strong support system is really helpful. My friends and team keep me on track.\"\n- Result 34 [2023-10-",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.83,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.96
    },
    {
      "question": "What inspired Calvin's recent music?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Struggles that people go through",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for mentions of Calvin's recent inspirations in the context.\n\n- Result 11 (2023-10-23): Calvin says he has been inspired by some of the struggles that people go through, which made him dig deeper into his music to capture those feelings.\n- Result 15 (2023-10-23): Calvin mentions staying connected and up-to-date on world events to incorporate unique perspectives into his music.\n- Result 12 (2023-09-13): Calvin talks about making a difference and sharing his own story as a motivation.\n- Result 54 (2023-08-14): Calvin describes an amazing experience touring with a well-known artist and connecting with the audience as inspiring.\n- Result 53 (2023-11-02): Calvin watches music videos, concerts, and documentaries about artists and their creative process for inspiration.\n- Result 33 and 39 (2023-11-13): Calvin is inspired by supporting young musicians and their",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 5.34,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.2
    },
    {
      "question": "How does Calvin describe his music in relation to capturing feelings?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Express himself and work through his emotions",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify excerpts where Calvin talks about music and feelings.\n\n- Result 6 (2023-10-23): Calvin says music is a way to express himself and work through emotions, like therapy.\n- Result 21 (2023-10-23): Calvin mentions being inspired by struggles people go through, digging deeper into his music to capture those feelings.\n- Result 8 (2023-10-25): Calvin describes performing as a dream come true and realizing how much music means to him, linking it to passion and purpose.\n- Result 45 (2023-10-23): Calvin says concerts are what he lives for, highlighting the connection between artist and crowd.\n- Result 25 (2023-11-02): Calvin says music has a way of touching souls.\n- Result 49 (2023-11-02): Calvin talks about exploring different styles to open new perspectives.\n- Result 77 (2023-11-02): Calvin watches music",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.66,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.62
    },
    {
      "question": "Why did Dave start working on cars?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Fascinated with how machines work",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for direct statements from Dave about why he started working on cars.  \n- Result 6 (2023-10-23): Dave says he was fascinated with how machines work since he was ten, found an old car in a neighbor's garage, asked to fix it, and loved the sense of accomplishment from transforming it.  \n- Result 19 (2023-10-08): Dave mentions spending hours in his dad's garage as a kid, tinkering with engines, which was like his sanctuary, and that he is lucky to do this as a job now.  \n- Result 25 (2023-10-25): Dave says his dad took him to his first car show when he was 10, he was hooked and wanted to learn more, leading to his career as an automotive engineer.  \n- Result 41 (2023-08-03): Dave recalls fond memories of working on cars with his dad as a kid, restoring an old car",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.64,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.21
    },
    {
      "question": "What is the toughest part of car restoration according to Dave?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Paying extra attention to detail",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify where Dave talks about challenges or tough parts of car restoration.\n\n- Result 12 (2023-10-23): Dave mentions working on a new project that is \"quite a challenge.\"\n- Result 78 (2023-10-08): Dave says \"Restoring things like this can be tough but the feeling of accomplishment it gives is great.\"\n- Result 62 (2023-09-22): Dave had a tough time with his car project because after working on the engine, he heard a weird noise, which was disappointing.\n- Result 31 (2023-08-03): Dave recalls restoring an old car with his dad was hard work.\n- Result 29 (2023-08-11): Dave mentions learning new skills like body modifications is a challenge but fun.\n\nStep 2: Look for any direct mention of what the toughest part is.\n\n- Result 1 (2023-10-23): Calvin asks Dave \"What would you",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.02,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.89
    },
    {
      "question": "What does Calvin believe makes an artist create something extraordinary?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Paying attention to small details",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for Calvin's statements about what makes art or an artist's work extraordinary.\n\nStep 2: In Result 1 (2023-10-23), Calvin says paying attention to small details makes a difference and without them, the work is just average. He wants to create something extraordinary.\n\nStep 3: In Result 18 (2023-08-11), Calvin says customizing a masterpiece with small details makes it unique and personalized.\n\nStep 4: In Result 30 (2023-10-23), Calvin again emphasizes that details can really make a difference and make something great.\n\nStep 5: Dave also agrees in Result 35 (2023-08-11) that small details make something unique and personalized.\n\nStep 6: Synthesizing these, Calvin believes that the small details and customization are what make an artist's creation extraordinary.\n\nFinal answer: Calvin believes that paying attention to small details and customizing a masterpiece with those details is what makes an",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.19,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.18
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Dave sell the car he restored last year?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Last year",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Dave mentions restoring a car last year around May 1, 2022 (Result 1).\n\nStep 2: On October 23, 2023, Calvin asks if Dave still has the classic car or is working on another project (Result 5).\n\nStep 3: Dave replies on the same day (October 23, 2023) that he restored a car last year (approximately October 23, 2022), but he sold it to a collector and is now working on something new (Result 6).\n\nStep 4: This indicates Dave sold the car sometime after finishing the restoration around October 23, 2022.\n\nFinal answer: Dave sold the car he restored last year sometime after October 23, 2022.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.11,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.94
    },
    {
      "question": "When did Calvin first get interested in cars?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "at an early age",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for any direct statements about when Calvin first got interested in cars.  \nStep 2: The conversation mostly shows Dave talking about his early interest in cars, starting at age 10 (Results 31, 40, 49).  \nStep 3: Calvin's messages do not mention a specific time or age when he first got interested in cars. He mostly talks about his current cars, repairs, and admiration for Dave's work.  \nStep 4: No explicit mention or story from Calvin about when his interest in cars began is found in the context.\n\nFinal answer:  \nNot enough information to determine when Calvin first got interested in cars.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.87,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.8
    },
    {
      "question": "How did Calvin feel about performing with someone he admires?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Unreal, like a dream come true",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about Calvin performing with someone he admires.\n\n- Result 2 (2023-10-25): Dave says Calvin looked comfortable on stage performing with someone he admires.\n- Result 11 (2023-10-25): Calvin says, \"It was unreal, Dave. Being up there with someone I admire - it was a dream come true. The energy, the crowd - it made me realize how much music means to me, it's like my passion and my purpose.\"\n- Result 35 (2023-10-19): Calvin says the collaboration started in August last year, they clicked right away, and the chemistry on stage was incredible.\n- Result 1 (2023-10-19): Dave asks how performing with \"him\" happened, implying Calvin performed with a notable artist.\n- Result 4 (2023-08-14): Calvin describes touring with a well-known artist as an amazing experience and a dream come true.\n\nStep",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.52,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.58
    },
    {
      "question": "What realization did the nightclub experience bring to Calvin?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "how much music means to him, it's like his passion and purpose",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of a nightclub or similar experience in the context.  \nStep 2: The closest relevant excerpt is [Result 34] dated 2023-11-02, where Calvin says: \"It was incredible, Dave! The room was buzzing with energy and love. It was a powerful reminder of why I'm doing this.\"  \nStep 3: This suggests that the nightclub or performance experience made Calvin realize or remember the core reason behind his music career\u2014his passion and purpose.  \nStep 4: No other excerpts explicitly mention a nightclub or similar setting with a clearer realization.\n\nFinal answer:  \nThe nightclub experience reminded Calvin of why he is pursuing music, reinforcing his passion and purpose for doing it.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.72,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.79
    },
    {
      "question": "What do Dave and Calvin agree on regarding their pursuits?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "It's fulfilling and motivating",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify statements where Dave and Calvin express agreement or shared views about their pursuits.\n\n- Result 5 (Calvin): \"Progress is what keeps us motivated and pushing for more. Let's never give up and keep striving for success. We know that hard work and determination matter, and it's what sets us apart.\"\n- Result 12 (Calvin): \"Yeah, hard work and dedication are definitely key to reaching our goals and potential.\"\n- Result 19 (Calvin): \"You find purpose in transforming things... We're both making something great out of nothing.\"\n- Result 21 (Calvin): \"That feeling is amazing. Everyone is part of it, it's like one big harmony.\"\n- Result 66 (Dave): \"That's great, Calvin. We both have discovered something that brings us fulfillment.\"\n- Result 67 (Dave): \"Me too, Calvin! Let's see where it takes us. We can keep inspiring each other!\"\n- Result 80 (Dave): \"Together",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.59,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.22
    },
    {
      "question": "Which city is featured in the photograph Dave showed Calvin?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Boston",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of photos Dave showed Calvin and the city they are associated with.\n\n- Result 37 (2023-10-29): Calvin to Dave mentions a photo Dave showed him, asking if it is the clock tower and says he was there a few years back, calling it a beautiful city.\n- Result 72 (2023-10-29): Dave to Calvin says \"That's Boston, Cal! Check this out, I took this picture last month (approx. Sept 29, 2023), and got a great shot - it was stunning!\"\n- Result 35 (2023-04-20): Calvin to Dave says \"Wow, Boston looks great! Thanks for the tips. And, awesome pic!\"\n- Result 99 (2023-04-20): Dave to Calvin offers to show favorite spots in the city, presumably Boston.\n\nStep 2: Confirm the city in the photo Dave showed Calvin is Boston.\n\n- Dave explicitly says in Result ",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.82,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.43
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Calvin do recently at his Japanese house?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Threw a small party for his new album",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Calvin's Japanese house or mansion in the context.\n\n- Result 6 (2023-11-02): Calvin says he threw a small party at his Japanese house for his new album around October 26, 2023.\n- Result 46 (2023-07-21): Calvin mentions working on transforming a Japanese mansion into a recording studio.\n- Result 57 (2023-08-22): Calvin recorded a song in the studio at his mansion with Frank Ocean.\n- Result 22 (2023-08-14): Calvin mentions exploring his new place in Japan after a show.\n- Result 68 (2023-11-02): Calvin describes the party room buzzing with energy and love.\n- Result 9, 13, 51: Calvin talks about the mansion and its views.\n\nStep 2: Focus on the most recent activity at the Japanese house.\n\n- The most recent specific event is the small party for his new album",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.01,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.82
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Dave recently start a blog about?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Car mods",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for mentions of Dave starting a blog in the context.\n\nStep 2: In Result 26 (2023-11-02), Dave tells Calvin he recently (around October 26, 2023) started a blog on car mods.\n\nStep 3: Calvin responds positively about the blog and car mods in Results 2, 3, and 6, confirming the blog topic.\n\nFinal answer: Dave recently started a blog about car modifications (car mods).",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.86,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.32
    },
    {
      "question": "What is Dave's way to share his passion with others?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Through a blog on car mods",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Dave sharing his passion.  \n- Result 10: Calvin says to Dave, \"It's really fun to share your passion through blogging.\"  \n- Result 66: Dave says to Calvin, \"I appreciate the support. It's fulfilling to share my knowledge and help others unleash their creativity.\"  \n- Result 95: Calvin says to Dave, \"Wow, Dave! Your blog is awesome. Helping others get creative is awesome.\"  \n- Result 91: Dave mentions writing lyrics and notes as something that boosts his motivation, but this is more personal than sharing.  \n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.  \nDave shares his passion primarily through blogging, where he shares knowledge and helps others be creative.\n\nFinal answer:  \nDave shares his passion with others through blogging, where he shares his knowledge and helps inspire creativity.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.42,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.89
    },
    {
      "question": "What type of videos does Calvin usually watch on his television?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Music videos, concerts, documentaries about artists and their creative process",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about Calvin's TV watching habits.\n\n- Result 3 [2023-11-02T18:01:00] Calvin to Dave: \"I usually watch music videos, concerts, and documentaries about artists and their creative process. It's cool to learn more about the industry and see what others do. Plus, it's a source of inspiration for me.\"\n\n- Result 5 [2023-11-02T18:00:00] Calvin to Dave: Mentions having a relaxation room with a TV, used to unwind and get inspired.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.\n\nCalvin watches music-related content on his TV, specifically music videos, concerts, and documentaries about artists and their creative process, which inspire him.\n\nFinal answer:  \nCalvin usually watches music videos, concerts, and documentaries about artists and their creative process on his television.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.05,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.79
    },
    {
      "question": "What type of music has Dave been getting into lately?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Classic rock",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about Dave's current music interests.  \n- Result 3 (2023-11-02T18:05:30): Dave says, \"Lately, I've been getting into classic rock. The music from that era is timeless.\"  \n- Result 1 and 38 also mention classic rock in Calvin and Dave's conversation, confirming the focus on classic rock.  \n- Result 31: Dave listens to vinyl when doing car stuff, which aligns with classic rock preferences.  \n- Result 90: Dave mentions attending a rock concert recently in Boston.  \n- Result 100: Dave joined a rock band recently and has been practicing guitar.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.  \nDave has recently been into classic rock music, practicing guitar in a rock band, attending rock concerts, and enjoying vinyl records.\n\nFinal answer:  \nDave has been getting into classic rock music lately.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.61,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.22
    },
    {
      "question": "What tools does Calvin use to boost his motivation for music?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Writing lyrics and notes",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of tools or methods Calvin uses to boost motivation for music.\n\n- Result 2: Calvin mentions collaborating with others and learning from them, plus surrounding himself with positive energy and passion.\n- Result 6: Calvin plans to expand his brand worldwide, work with artists globally, and challenge himself creatively.\n- Result 29: Calvin watches music videos, concerts, and documentaries about artists and their creative process as a source of inspiration.\n- Result 41: When setbacks come, Calvin relies on helpful people around him and takes breaks to recharge with favorite activities.\n- Result 11 & 62: Calvin values having supportive people around him for motivation and growth.\n- Result 9: Writing lyrics and notes boosts motivation.\n- Result 39 & 7: Supporting young musicians and working with new talent inspires and motivates him.\n- Result 59: Seeing his instrument every day keeps him motivated.\n- Result 86 & 57: Staying true to himself and being unique in music",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.64,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.11
    },
    {
      "question": "What type of content does Dave post on his blog that inspired others to start their own DIY projects?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "How he made his car look like a beast",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Dave's blog content and its impact on others.  \n- Result 7 (2023-11-02): Dave started a blog on car mods to share his passion.  \n- Result 13 (2023-11-02): Dave posted about how he made a car look like a beast, which inspired others to start their own DIY projects.  \n- Result 62 (2023-11-02): Dave mentions the car mod was a lot of work but worth it, implying detailed content about car modifications.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.  \nDave's blog features detailed posts about car modifications, specifically showing how he transformed a car to look impressive (\"like a beast\"). This content inspired others to begin their own DIY projects.\n\nFinal answer:  \nDave posts detailed content about car modifications on his blog, including how he transformed a car to look like a beast, which inspired others to start their own DIY projects.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.33,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.73
    },
    {
      "question": "What kind of impact does Dave's blog on car mods have on people?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "It inspires others to start their DIY projects",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Dave started his blog on car mods around October 26, 2023 (Result 1, 10).\n\nStep 2: Dave mentions that people are checking out his blog and asking for advice, indicating engagement and interest (Result 10).\n\nStep 3: Dave says his blog inspired others to start their own DIY projects (Result 10).\n\nStep 4: Calvin responds positively, saying the blog is awesome and helps others get creative (Result 30, 38).\n\nStep 5: Overall, the blog motivates and inspires people to be creative and try their own car modification projects.\n\nFinal answer:  \nDave's blog on car mods inspires and motivates people to start their own DIY projects and helps them get creative with car modifications.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.18,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.48
    },
    {
      "question": "Who did Calvin invite to see him perform in Boston on 13 November, 2023?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "his old high school buddy",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the date of the invitation message.  \nResult 18 is dated 2023-11-13 and says: \"Hey Dave, I invited my old high school buddy to see me perform in Boston!\"\n\nStep 2: Confirm the person invited.  \nCalvin explicitly states he invited his \"old high school buddy.\"\n\nFinal answer:  \nCalvin invited his old high school buddy to see him perform in Boston on November 13, 2023.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.08,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.23
    },
    {
      "question": "What hobby did Calvin take up recently?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Photography",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for mentions of Calvin's hobbies or new activities he has taken up recently.\n\nStep 2: In [Result 54] (2023-08-03), Calvin mentions taking his Ferrari for a service and asks Dave about hobbies that give a feeling of being restored, indicating Calvin's interest in cars but not necessarily a new hobby.\n\nStep 3: In [Result 72] (2023-07-21), Calvin says he started making music to follow his dreams and is stoked about his progress, suggesting music is a significant activity for him.\n\nStep 4: In [Result 93] (2023-08-03), Calvin talks about plans to expand his music brand worldwide and grow his fanbase, showing ongoing involvement in music.\n\nStep 5: In [Result 99] (2023-04-20), Calvin mentions learning from professionals in the music industry, indicating music is a focus.\n\nStep 6: No explicit mention of Calvin",
      "correct": false,
      "judge_votes": [
        false,
        false,
        false
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.82,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.95
    },
    {
      "question": "What new item did Dave buy recently?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "A vintage camera",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Look for mentions of Dave buying something new recently.\nStep 2: Check the latest dates for relevant messages.\nStep 3: In Result 100 (2023-11-17), Dave mentions buying a new vintage camera this month.\nStep 4: No other recent purchases by Dave are mentioned after that date.\n\nFinal answer: Dave recently bought a new vintage camera.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 1.94,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.75
    },
    {
      "question": "What type of photos does Dave like to capture with his new camera?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Nature - sunsets, beaches, waves",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Dave's photography interests and his new camera.\n\n- Result 3 (2023-11-17): Dave mentions buying a new vintage camera this month that takes awesome photos.\n- Result 14 (2023-11-17): Dave says he loves capturing the beauty of nature\u2014sunsets, beaches, waves\u2014and shares a recent photo from around November 10, 2023.\n- Result 16 (2023-11-17): Dave says he has been taking pics of the scenery around here.\n- Result 77 (2023-10-29): Dave shares a magnificent sunset photo he captured.\n- Result 92 (2023-11-17): Dave found a serene spot in a nearby park and took a photo.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.\n\nDave enjoys using his new vintage camera primarily to capture natural scenery, including sunsets, beaches, waves, and serene outdoor spots.\n\nFinal answer:  \nDave likes to capture photos",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.96,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.95
    },
    {
      "question": "What event did Calvin attend in Boston?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Fancy gala",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Calvin attending events in Boston.\n\n- Result 2 (2023-10-25): Calvin says he had a great time in Boston visiting sights with a high school friend.\n- Result 9 (2023-11-13): Calvin invited his old high school buddy to see him perform in Boston.\n- Result 12 (2023-11-17): Calvin accepted an invitation to perform at an upcoming show in Boston.\n- Result 44 (2023-11-17): Calvin attended a fancy gala in Boston on November 16, 2023.\n- Result 47 (2023-11-02): Calvin mentions an event where everyone came together to celebrate.\n- Result 53 (2023-11-02): Calvin describes a room buzzing with energy and love, a powerful reminder of why he is doing this.\n- Result 55 (2023-11-02): Dave congratulates Calvin on his album release and party.\n-",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.26,
      "judge_latency_s": 1.98
    },
    {
      "question": "What did Calvin discuss with the cool artist he met at the gala?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Music and art",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify the relevant excerpt about Calvin meeting a cool artist at a gala.  \n- Result 2 (2023-11-17) Calvin to Dave mentions having an interesting chat with a cool artist, talking about favorite artists, art, and the power of music connecting people.  \n- Result 73 (2023-11-17) Calvin to Dave mentions attending a fancy gala in Boston on November 16, 2023, meeting interesting people, and sharing a photo with the crew.  \n- Result 84 (2023-11-17) Dave to Calvin responds about the inspiring conversation Calvin had, linking it to the power of music bringing people together.\n\nStep 2: Synthesize the information.  \nCalvin met a cool artist at the gala (likely the fancy gala in Boston on Nov 16, 2023). They discussed their favorite artists, art, and how music connects people, which Calvin found inspiring and uplifting.\n\nFinal answer:  \nCalvin",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.69,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.06
    },
    {
      "question": "Where did Dave take a stunning photo of a waterfall?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Nearby park",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify mentions of Dave taking photos of nature or waterfalls.  \n- Result 37 (2023-11-17T11:00:00) Dave to Calvin: \"here's a picture I snapped last week (approximately November 10, 2023)! It's a peaceful scene with rocks and a waterfall.\"\n\nStep 2: Check if the location of this waterfall photo is mentioned.  \n- The message only says \"a peaceful scene with rocks and a waterfall,\" no specific location is given.\n\nStep 3: Look for any other mentions of Dave taking waterfall photos or nature photos that might specify location.  \n- Result 29 (2023-11-17T11:02:00) Dave to Calvin: \"Found an even better spot, with a bench under a tree with pink flowers - so peaceful.\" No waterfall mentioned.  \n- Result 45 (2023-11-17T10:58:00) Dave to Calvin: \"I love capturing",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 3.78,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.04
    },
    {
      "question": "What positive impact does Calvin mention nature has on tough times?",
      "category": 4,
      "gold_answer": "Nature helps us appreciate life",
      "generated_answer": "Step 1: Identify relevant excerpts about nature and tough times.\n\n- Result 1 (2023-11-17): Calvin to Dave says, \"Yeah, nature really does the trick. Its beauty helps us appreciate life when it's tough. Like a breath of fresh air!\"\n- Result 20 (2023-11-17): Dave to Calvin says, \"It's incredible how much emotion and beauty nature can convey through a photo.\"\n- Result 45 (2023-11-17): Dave to Calvin shares a photo and says, \"I totally agree, nature really can boost our spirits in tough times.\"\n\nStep 2: Synthesize Calvin's specific mention.\n\nCalvin highlights that nature's beauty helps people appreciate life during difficult times and acts like a breath of fresh air, implying it refreshes and uplifts one's spirit.\n\nFinal answer:  \nCalvin says nature's beauty helps people appreciate life during tough times and acts like a refreshing breath of fresh air that uplifts the spirit.",
      "correct": true,
      "judge_votes": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "num_retrieved": 100,
      "conversation_id": "conv-50",
      "answer_latency_s": 2.96,
      "judge_latency_s": 2.4
    }
  ]
}