{
  "status": "success",
  "unit": {
    "unit_index": 13,
    "unit_key": "13_taiwan_row10787",
    "country": "Taiwan",
    "row_id": 10787,
    "person_name": "Shyh-Fang Liu",
    "election_year": "2016",
    "pol_party": "DPP",
    "region": "National level",
    "person_bday": "Not available",
    "gender_character": "Female",
    "ethnic": "Chinese"
  },
  "started_at_utc": "2026-04-05T14:45:28Z",
  "finished_at_utc": "2026-04-05T14:52:01Z",
  "elapsed_time": 6.3039,
  "error_message": null,
  "tool_names": ["update_plan", "wikipedia", "search", "openwebpage", "save_finding"],
  "unit_dir": "/Users/cjerzak/Documents/asa-software/tracked_reports/trace_real_15units/trace_real_15units_20260405T094433/units/13_taiwan_row10787",
  "field_status": {
    "education_level": {
      "status": "found",
      "value": "Master's/Professional",
      "source_url": "https://www.moi.gov.tw/english/cp.aspx?n=7603",
      "evidence": "scratchpad_source_backed",
      "attempts": 1,
      "descriptor": "High School|Some College|Associate|Bachelor's|Master's/Professional|PhD|Unknown"
    },
    "education_institution": {
      "status": "found",
      "value": "Tamkang University (BS), Oklahoma State University (MS)",
      "source_url": "https://www.moi.gov.tw/english/cp.aspx?n=7603",
      "evidence": "scratchpad_source_backed",
      "attempts": 1,
      "descriptor": "string|Unknown"
    },
    "education_field": {
      "status": "found",
      "value": "Chemical Engineering (BS), Environmental Engineering (MS)",
      "source_url": "https://www.moi.gov.tw/english/cp.aspx?n=7603",
      "evidence": "scratchpad_source_backed",
      "attempts": 2,
      "descriptor": "string|Unknown"
    },
    "prior_occupation": {
      "status": "unknown",
      "value": "Unknown",
      "source_url": null,
      "evidence": "recovery_blocked_no_candidates",
      "attempts": 3,
      "descriptor": "string|Unknown",
      "evidence_reason": "recovery_blocked_no_candidates"
    },
    "class_background": {
      "status": "unknown",
      "value": "Unknown",
      "source_url": null,
      "evidence": "recovery_blocked_no_candidates",
      "attempts": 3,
      "descriptor": "Working class|Middle class/professional|Upper/elite|Unknown",
      "evidence_reason": "recovery_blocked_no_candidates"
    },
    "disability_status": {
      "status": "unknown",
      "value": "Unknown",
      "source_url": null,
      "evidence": "recovery_blocked_no_candidates",
      "attempts": 3,
      "descriptor": "No disability|Some disability|Unknown",
      "evidence_reason": "recovery_blocked_no_candidates"
    },
    "birth_place": {
      "status": "found",
      "value": "Taipei City, Taiwan",
      "source_url": "https://wikis.tw/劉世芳",
      "evidence": "scratchpad_source_backed",
      "attempts": 2,
      "descriptor": "string|Unknown"
    },
    "birth_year": {
      "status": "found",
      "value": 1959,
      "source_url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liu_Shyh-fang",
      "evidence": "terminal_payload_source_backed",
      "attempts": 3,
      "descriptor": "integer|null|Unknown"
    },
    "lgbtq_status": {
      "status": "unknown",
      "value": "Unknown",
      "source_url": null,
      "evidence": "recovery_blocked_no_candidates",
      "attempts": 3,
      "descriptor": "Non-LGBTQ|Openly LGBTQ|Unknown",
      "evidence_reason": "recovery_blocked_no_candidates"
    },
    "lgbtq_details": {
      "status": "unknown",
      "value": null,
      "source_url": null,
      "evidence": "recovery_blocked_no_candidates",
      "attempts": 3,
      "descriptor": "string|null",
      "evidence_reason": "recovery_blocked_no_candidates"
    },
    "confidence": {
      "status": "found",
      "value": 0.95,
      "source_url": null,
      "evidence": "terminal_payload_source_backed",
      "attempts": 3,
      "descriptor": "number"
    },
    "justification": {
      "status": "found",
      "value": "Shyh-Fang Liu was born in 1959 in Taipei City. She holds a Master's degree in Environmental Engineering from Oklahoma State University and a Bachelor's in Chemical Engineering from Tamkang University. Before her political career, she worked as an Associate Engineer at the Industrial Technology Research Institute (ITRI), which classifies her as middle class/professional. There is no public record of a disability or LGBTQ identity.",
      "source_url": null,
      "evidence": "terminal_payload_source_backed",
      "attempts": 3,
      "descriptor": "string"
    }
  },
  "diagnostics": {
    "grounding_blocks_count": 0,
    "source_consistency_fixes_count": 0,
    "field_demotions_count": 0,
    "terminal_source_policy_violations": 0,
    "terminal_source_scrubbed_fields": 0,
    "recovery_promotions_count": 0,
    "recovery_rejections_count": 5,
    "unknown_fields_count": 6,
    "unresolved_fields_count": 10,
    "grounding_blocks_count_current": 0,
    "source_consistency_fixes_count_current": 0,
    "field_demotions_count_current": 0,
    "recovery_promotions_count_current": 0,
    "recovery_rejections_count_current": 5,
    "unknown_fields_count_current": 5,
    "unresolved_fields_count_current": 5,
    "off_target_tool_results_count": 0,
    "empty_tool_results_count": 0,
    "retry_or_replan_events": 4,
    "quality_gate_failures": 5,
    "no_payload_extraction_rounds": 2,
    "webpage_no_payload_rounds": 0,
    "search_snippet_no_payload_rounds": 2,
    "webpage_llm_extraction_calls": 0,
    "webpage_langextract_calls": 4,
    "webpage_langextract_fallback_calls": 4,
    "webpage_langextract_errors": 2,
    "webpage_openwebpage_candidates_total": 4,
    "webpage_openwebpage_candidates_selected": 4,
    "webpage_openwebpage_skipped_hard_failures": 0,
    "webpage_openwebpage_skipped_empty": 0,
    "webpage_deterministic_fallback_calls": 4,
    "webpage_deterministic_fallback_payloads": 0,
    "webpage_deterministic_fallback_no_payload": 4,
    "webpage_structured_output_calls": 0,
    "webpage_structured_output_errors": 0,
    "webpage_provider_timeout": 2,
    "webpage_provider_empty_payload": 6,
    "webpage_payload_filtered_all_keys": 0,
    "search_snippet_llm_extraction_calls": 0,
    "search_snippet_langextract_calls": 0,
    "search_snippet_langextract_fallback_calls": 0,
    "search_snippet_langextract_errors": 0,
    "search_snippet_structured_output_calls": 6,
    "search_snippet_structured_output_errors": 4,
    "search_snippet_candidates_total": 37,
    "search_snippet_candidates_selected": 8,
    "search_snippet_candidates_selected_with_field_hints": 1,
    "search_snippet_skipped_duplicate_urls": 1,
    "search_snippet_skipped_low_information": 2,
    "search_snippet_openwebpage_escalation_events": 6,
    "search_snippet_openwebpage_escalation_successes": 4,
    "search_snippet_timeout_circuit_events": 0,
    "search_snippet_timeout_circuit_open_rounds": 0,
    "search_snippet_forced_openwebpage_followup_rounds": 4,
    "search_snippet_preferred_queue_size_max": 3,
    "search_snippet_escalated_to_openwebpage": 6,
    "search_snippet_deterministic_fallback_calls": 6,
    "search_snippet_deterministic_fallback_payloads": 0,
    "search_snippet_deterministic_fallback_no_payload": 6,
    "search_snippet_structured_output_elapsed_ms_total": 104349,
    "search_snippet_structured_output_elapsed_ms_max": 18773,
    "search_snippet_structured_output_timeout_elapsed_ms_total": 0,
    "search_snippet_provider_timeout": 0,
    "search_snippet_provider_empty_payload": 4,
    "search_snippet_payload_filtered_all_keys": 0,
    "search_snippet_budget_blocked_rounds": 0,
    "search_snippet_policy_blocked_rounds": 0,
    "auto_openwebpage_quota_blocked_rounds": 0,
    "auto_openwebpage_budget_blocked_rounds": 0,
    "auto_openwebpage_no_preferred_candidate_rounds": 1,
    "auto_openwebpage_no_generic_candidate_rounds": 0,
    "webpage_budget_blocked_rounds": 0,
    "webpage_policy_blocked_rounds": 0,
    "webpage_langextract_elapsed_ms_total": 62386,
    "webpage_langextract_error_elapsed_ms_total": 38105,
    "search_snippet_langextract_elapsed_ms_total": 0,
    "search_snippet_langextract_error_elapsed_ms_total": 0,
    "low_signal_rewrite_events": 0,
    "low_signal_stop_events": 0,
    "low_efficiency_replan_events": 1,
    "low_efficiency_stop_events": 1,
    "no_new_evidence_replan_events": 1,
    "no_new_evidence_stop_events": 1,
    "low_signal_rewrite_elapsed_ms_total": 0,
    "low_signal_stop_elapsed_ms_total": 0,
    "retry_threshold_crossings": 0,
    "query_dedupe_escalation_events": 0,
    "empty_round_suppression_events": 0,
    "adaptive_budget_events": 0,
    "adaptive_budget_reduced_calls_total": 0,
    "structural_repair_events": 0,
    "structural_repair_retry_events": 0,
    "finalization_invariant_failures": 0,
    "tool_call_pairing_mismatches": 0,
    "forced_finalize_pending_tool_calls_count": 0,
    "diagnostics_recovery_checkpoint_events": 0,
    "diagnostics_recovery_retry_events": 0,
    "quality_gate_recovery_events": 0,
    "anchor_hard_blocks_count": 0,
    "anchor_soft_penalties_count": 0,
    "weak_anchor_candidates_admitted_count": 0,
    "contradiction_blocks_count": 0,
    "strong_conflict_demotions_count": 84,
    "weak_anchor_promotions_survived_finalization_count": 0,
    "grounding_blocked_fields": [],
    "source_consistency_fixes": [],
    "field_demotion_fields": [],
    "terminal_source_scrubbed_field_names": [],
    "terminal_source_policy_violation_urls": [],
    "recovery_promoted_fields": [],
    "recovery_rejected_fields": ["prior_occupation", "class_background", "disability_status", "lgbtq_status", "lgbtq_details"],
    "unknown_fields": ["prior_occupation", "class_background", "disability_status", "birth_year", "lgbtq_status", "lgbtq_details"],
    "unresolved_fields": ["education_level", "education_institution", "education_field", "prior_occupation", "class_background", "disability_status", "birth_place", "birth_year", "lgbtq_status", "lgbtq_details"],
    "grounding_blocked_fields_current": [],
    "source_consistency_fixes_current": [],
    "field_demotion_fields_current": [],
    "recovery_promoted_fields_current": [],
    "recovery_rejected_fields_current": ["prior_occupation", "class_background", "disability_status", "lgbtq_status", "lgbtq_details"],
    "forced_finalize_pending_tool_calls": [],
    "unknown_fields_current": ["prior_occupation", "class_background", "disability_status", "lgbtq_status", "lgbtq_details"],
    "unresolved_fields_current": ["prior_occupation", "class_background", "disability_status", "lgbtq_status", "lgbtq_details"],
    "field_demotion_reason_counts": {},
    "recovery_reason_counts": {
      "recovery_blocked_no_candidates": 5
    },
    "unknown_reason_counts": {
      "attempted_no_verified_evidence": 6,
      "recovery_blocked_no_candidates": 5
    },
    "evidence_state_reason_counts": {},
    "finalization_invariant_failures_by_reason": {},
    "unknown_fields_by_reason": {
      "attempted_no_verified_evidence": ["prior_occupation", "class_background", "disability_status", "birth_year", "lgbtq_status", "lgbtq_details"],
      "recovery_blocked_no_candidates": ["prior_occupation", "class_background", "disability_status", "lgbtq_status", "lgbtq_details"]
    },
    "finalization_blocking_fields": [],
    "finalization_recovery_checkpoints": [],
    "anchor_mismatch_samples": [],
    "evidence_state_samples": [],
    "empty_tool_results_details": [],
    "retrieval_interventions": ["search_snippet_openwebpage_escalation", "no_new_high_quality_evidence_replan:2", "low_efficiency_replan:2", "search_snippet_extraction_no_payload", "no_new_high_quality_evidence_replan:3", "no_new_high_quality_evidence_stop:3", "no_new_high_quality_evidence_replan:4", "no_new_high_quality_evidence_stop:4", "no_new_high_quality_evidence_replan:5", "no_new_high_quality_evidence_stop:5"],
    "webpage_openwebpage_skip_reasons": [],
    "webpage_langextract_provider": "gemini",
    "webpage_langextract_last_error": "langextract_timeout:18.0s",
    "search_snippet_langextract_provider": "",
    "search_snippet_langextract_last_error": "",
    "webpage_structured_output_last_error": "",
    "search_snippet_structured_output_last_error": "provider_empty_payload",
    "anchor_strength_current": "moderate",
    "anchor_mode_current": "soft",
    "anchor_confidence_current": 0.56,
    "anchor_reasons_current": ["entity_hints", "labeled_hint", "context_tokens"],
    "tool_call_pairing": {
      "issued_tool_calls_count": 18,
      "tool_message_count": 18,
      "paired_tool_calls_count": 18,
      "unpaired_tool_calls_count": 0,
      "unpaired_tool_call_ids": [],
      "unpaired_tool_call_names": [],
      "unmatched_tool_messages_count": 0,
      "pending_on_last_message": false
    },
    "performance": {
      "performance_profile": "quality",
      "tool_round_count": 11,
      "tool_round_elapsed_ms_total": 316141,
      "tool_round_elapsed_ms_last": 134596,
      "tool_round_elapsed_ms_max": 134596,
      "search_tool_calls": 5,
      "openwebpage_tool_calls": 4,
      "other_tool_calls": 1,
      "search_tool_elapsed_ms_est_total": 158584,
      "openwebpage_tool_elapsed_ms_est_total": 156696,
      "other_tool_elapsed_ms_est_total": 848,
      "provider_error_count": 2,
      "provider_error_elapsed_ms_total": 38105,
      "low_signal_streak_peak": 1,
      "diminishing_returns_streak_peak": 3,
      "adaptive_budget_events": 0,
      "adaptive_budget_reduced_calls_total": 0,
      "fold_event_count": 0,
      "fold_summarizer_latency_m_total": 0,
      "fold_summarizer_latency_m_last": 0,
      "webpage_langextract_elapsed_ms_total": 62386,
      "webpage_langextract_error_elapsed_ms_total": 38105,
      "search_snippet_langextract_elapsed_ms_total": 0,
      "search_snippet_langextract_error_elapsed_ms_total": 0,
      "low_signal_rewrite_events": 0,
      "low_signal_stop_events": 0,
      "low_efficiency_replan_events": 1,
      "low_efficiency_stop_events": 1,
      "no_new_evidence_replan_events": 1,
      "no_new_evidence_stop_events": 1,
      "tokens_used_cumulative": 70367,
      "tokens_delta_since_last_round": 10916,
      "low_efficiency_streak": 5,
      "evidence_gain_units": 0,
      "evidence_gain_per_1k_tokens": 0,
      "low_signal_rewrite_elapsed_ms_total": 0,
      "low_signal_stop_elapsed_ms_total": 0,
      "retry_threshold_crossings": 2,
      "webpage_policy_max_open_calls": 4,
      "webpage_policy_open_only_if_score_ge": 0.25,
      "blocked_host_count_active": 1,
      "blocked_host_skip_events": 0,
      "adaptive_budget_last_reason": null,
      "fold_last_trigger_reason": null,
      "provider_error_last_type": "langextract_timeout",
      "provider_error_last_message": "langextract_timeout:18.0s"
    },
    "current_snapshot": {
      "grounding_blocks_count": 0,
      "source_consistency_fixes_count": 0,
      "field_demotions_count": 0,
      "recovery_promotions_count": 0,
      "recovery_rejections_count": 5,
      "unknown_fields_count": 5,
      "unknown_fields": ["prior_occupation", "class_background", "disability_status", "lgbtq_status", "lgbtq_details"],
      "unresolved_fields_count": 5,
      "unresolved_fields": ["prior_occupation", "class_background", "disability_status", "lgbtq_status", "lgbtq_details"]
    },
    "historical_snapshot": {
      "grounding_blocks_count": 0,
      "source_consistency_fixes_count": 0,
      "field_demotions_count": 0,
      "recovery_promotions_count": 0,
      "recovery_rejections_count": 5,
      "unknown_fields_count": 6,
      "unknown_fields": ["prior_occupation", "class_background", "disability_status", "birth_year", "lgbtq_status", "lgbtq_details"],
      "unresolved_fields_count": 10,
      "unresolved_fields": ["education_level", "education_institution", "education_field", "prior_occupation", "class_background", "disability_status", "birth_place", "birth_year", "lgbtq_status", "lgbtq_details"]
    }
  },
  "completion_gate": {
    "done": true,
    "completion_status": "complete",
    "all_required_terminalized": true,
    "all_required_concrete": false,
    "terminalized_fields": 12,
    "concrete_found_fields": 7,
    "concrete_missing_fields": ["prior_occupation", "class_background", "disability_status", "lgbtq_status", "lgbtq_details"],
    "concrete_completion_status": "in_progress",
    "resolved_fields": 12,
    "unknown_fields": 5,
    "unresolved_fields": 0,
    "total_fields": 12,
    "missing_fields": [],
    "budget_exhausted": false,
    "reason": "all_required_fields_terminalized",
    "finalize_on_all_fields_resolved": false,
    "missing_required_field_count": 0,
    "missing_required_field_details": [],
    "missing_required_terminal_field_count": 0,
    "missing_required_terminal_field_details": [],
    "missing_required_concrete_field_count": 5,
    "missing_required_concrete_field_details": [
      {
        "field": "prior_occupation",
        "status": "unknown",
        "attempts": 3,
        "unknown_reason": "recovery_blocked_no_candidates",
        "evidence": "recovery_blocked_no_candidates",
        "requires_source": false,
        "descriptor": "string|Unknown",
        "resolution_axis": "concrete"
      },
      {
        "field": "class_background",
        "status": "unknown",
        "attempts": 3,
        "unknown_reason": "recovery_blocked_no_candidates",
        "evidence": "recovery_blocked_no_candidates",
        "requires_source": false,
        "descriptor": "Working class|Middle class/professional|Upper/elite|Unknown",
        "resolution_axis": "concrete"
      },
      {
        "field": "disability_status",
        "status": "unknown",
        "attempts": 3,
        "unknown_reason": "recovery_blocked_no_candidates",
        "evidence": "recovery_blocked_no_candidates",
        "requires_source": false,
        "descriptor": "No disability|Some disability|Unknown",
        "resolution_axis": "concrete"
      },
      {
        "field": "lgbtq_status",
        "status": "unknown",
        "attempts": 3,
        "unknown_reason": "recovery_blocked_no_candidates",
        "evidence": "recovery_blocked_no_candidates",
        "requires_source": false,
        "descriptor": "Non-LGBTQ|Openly LGBTQ|Unknown",
        "resolution_axis": "concrete"
      },
      {
        "field": "lgbtq_details",
        "status": "unknown",
        "attempts": 3,
        "unknown_reason": "recovery_blocked_no_candidates",
        "evidence": "recovery_blocked_no_candidates",
        "requires_source": false,
        "descriptor": "string|null",
        "resolution_axis": "concrete"
      }
    ],
    "resolvable_fields_count": 10,
    "resolvable_found_fields_count": 5,
    "resolvable_unknown_fields_count": 5,
    "unknown_field_ratio": 0.5,
    "global_confidence_score": 0.6692,
    "confidence_components": {
      "coverage": 0.5,
      "mean_field_confidence": 0.7,
      "mean_source_quality": 0.8967,
      "consistency_penalty": 0,
      "anchor_mismatch_pressure": 0,
      "global_confidence_score": 0.6692,
      "found_fields_count": 5,
      "unknown_fields_count": 5,
      "total_fields_count": 10
    },
    "gate_component_coverage": 0.5,
    "gate_component_evidence_quality": 0.8967,
    "gate_component_field_confidence": 0.7,
    "gate_component_consistency_penalty": 0,
    "quality_gate_failed": false,
    "quality_gate_triggered": false,
    "quality_gate_blocked": false,
    "quality_gate_terminal_degraded": false,
    "quality_gate_reason": null,
    "quality_gate_reasons": [],
    "quality_gate_checks": {
      "unknown_ratio_exceeds_limit": false,
      "global_confidence_below_min": false,
      "found_fields_below_min": false,
      "invariant_not_ok": false
    },
    "finalization_invariant_failed": false,
    "finalization_invariant_reasons": [],
    "finalization_invariant_ok": true,
    "finalization_invariant_applicable": true,
    "finalization_invariant": {
      "ok": true,
      "failed": false,
      "reasons": [],
      "issues": [],
      "core_total_fields": 10,
      "core_found_fields": 5,
      "core_unknown_fields": 5,
      "core_unresolved_fields": 5,
      "diagnostics_unknown_fields_count_current": 5,
      "diagnostics_unknown_fields_current_sample": ["prior_occupation", "class_background", "disability_status", "lgbtq_status", "lgbtq_details"],
      "diagnostics_unresolved_fields_count_current": 5,
      "diagnostics_unresolved_fields_current_sample": ["prior_occupation", "class_background", "disability_status", "lgbtq_status", "lgbtq_details"],
      "diagnostics_explicit_unknown_fields_count_current": 5,
      "diagnostics_explicit_unknown_fields_current_sample": ["prior_occupation", "class_background", "disability_status", "lgbtq_status", "lgbtq_details"],
      "field_status_core_unknown_fields_sample": ["class_background", "disability_status", "lgbtq_details", "lgbtq_status", "prior_occupation"],
      "field_status_core_unresolved_fields_sample": ["class_background", "disability_status", "lgbtq_details", "lgbtq_status", "prior_occupation"],
      "diagnostics_current_snapshot_present": true,
      "tool_call_pairing": {
        "issued_tool_calls_count": 18,
        "tool_message_count": 18,
        "paired_tool_calls_count": 18,
        "unpaired_tool_calls_count": 0,
        "unpaired_tool_call_ids": [],
        "unpaired_tool_call_names": [],
        "unmatched_tool_messages_count": 0,
        "pending_on_last_message": false
      },
      "applicable": true
    },
    "auto_recovery_checkpoint_needed": false,
    "auto_recovery_reasons": [],
    "auto_recovery_priority": "invariant_reconciliation",
    "auto_recovery_action": "none",
    "quality_gate_unknown_ratio_max": 0.85,
    "quality_gate_min_resolvable_fields": 3,
    "quality_gate_min_global_confidence": 0.55,
    "quality_gate_min_found_fields": 2,
    "quality_gate_require_invariant_ok": true,
    "quality_gate_recovery_enabled": true,
    "quality_gate_recovery_failure_modes": "low_extraction_yield",
    "quality_gate_recovery_rounds_used": 0,
    "quality_gate_recovery_rounds_remaining": 1,
    "quality_gate_recovery_needed": false,
    "finalize_on_budget_exhaustion_only_if_quality_gate_passes": true,
    "artifact_markers": ["completion_gate", "field_status", "plan_enabled", "plan_present", "invoke_error_absent"]
  }
}