# Wave 16 Second-Pass Review Sweep — 2026-05-03

**Sweep verdict:** ✅ Approved (1/1)
**Total Required-still-open:** 0
**New findings:** 0 Required, 0 Recommended, 1 Nit (DECISIONS.md draft residual — non-blocking)

---

## Per-Prompt Outcomes

| Prompt | Pass-1 Verdict | Pass-2 Verdict | Required-resolved | New findings |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| AD-525 Creative Expression v1 | ⚠️ Conditional (3R/4Rec/3N) | ✅ Approved | 3/3 ✅ | 1 Nit (DECISIONS.md draft contradiction with Section 4a tags-encoding; non-blocking) |

## Resolution Audit (AD-525)

All three Required findings closed:

- **R1 — `RecordsStore.write_entry` write-path spec gap.** Resolved via new Section 4a explicit kwarg-by-kwarg `await self._records_store.write_entry(...)` body. All kwargs match `records_store.py:89-103` signature. `tags=["creative", medium, skill_id]` chosen as the encoding for `medium`/`skill_id` (since `write_entry` assembles its own fixed-shape frontmatter at lines 113-148; arbitrary keys not supported). `message` parameter is descriptive. Caller-pattern citation updated from stale `proactive.py:2111` (notebook) to the correct `proactive.py:3033` (entry).
- **R2 — `_wire_creative_expression` invocation site missing.** Resolved via Section 6 split into 6a (define) + 6b (invoke). Section 6b inserts `if _wire_creative_expression(runtime=runtime, config=config):` at `startup/finalize.py:253`, immediately after the `_wire_self_distillation` invocation block (line 252). Sync `def` (matches `_wire_anomaly_window` line 25 shape; v1 has no awaits in wiring). Recommended #4 absorbed.
- **R3 — Big Five fields nested + `to_dict()` adapter.** Resolved by deleting the false `runtime.profile_store` dependency claim from the Dependencies section, replacing it with `crew_profile.PersonalityTraits.to_dict()` as the canonical adapter. Section 3 docstring extended with the adapter example block. Verified-against-codebase footer rewritten to show `crew_profile.py:51` (PersonalityTraits class) and `:138` (CrewProfile.personality field). Test #21 added: `test_affinity_score_accepts_personality_traits_to_dict_shape`. Soft-warning on unwired `runtime.profile_store` documented.

All Recommended (4) and Nits (3) folded.

## New Finding (Pass-2)

**Nit-N1:** DECISIONS.md draft block in the prompt's Tracking section still narrates `Frontmatter includes type: creative, medium, author, department.` This contradicts the corrected Section 4a (frontmatter assembled by `write_entry`; `medium`/`skill_id` encoded via `tags`). Build-driving sections are correct, so Builder will follow Section 4a. Recommended single-line fix at commit time; not blocking ✅.

## Pre-Check

```
./scripts/phantom-api-precheck.ps1 prompts/ad-525-creative-expression-v1.md
=== prompts/ad-525-creative-expression-v1.md ===
  1 phantom symbol(s):
    - [<Class>.<method>] SystemConfig.creative_expression
  Skipped (unresolved class):
    ~ [no_class_resolution] runtime.creative_skills_registry.list_skills(...)
```

Both items are documented FPs (Wave 5 convention #1 introduced-by-prompt wiring patterns). **0 NEW phantoms.**

## AD-685b Catches-Per-Wave

| Wave | Catches | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| 15 (own-validation) | 0 | Tooling validated against post-AD-680 ledger; clean. |
| 16 (this wave) | **1 real** | `crew_profile_store` → `profile_store` typo caught at draft time (commit 77788e2). First non-trivial real-world catch since rollout. |

**Caveat carried forward:** AD-685b validates *method existence on receiver class*, not *runtime attribute wiring*. The deeper "is `runtime.profile_store` actually wired?" check (it isn't — only a defensive `hasattr` read at acm.py:300) is AD-685c/d territory. Recommend filing as separate hygiene candidate when the surface accumulates 2+ instances.

## Convention #15 Tolerance

Wave 16 used the relaxed-tolerance allowance during pass-1 (3 Required → ⚠️ Conditional). Pass-2 ✅ Approved means tolerance reservation is fully consumed and resolved — no carry-over into Wave 17.

## Builder Dispatch Recommendation

**Single-commit dispatch.** AD-525 prompt at commit 4fd0879 is build-ready. Suggested Builder workflow:

1. Implement Section 0–6 against `prompts/ad-525-creative-expression-v1.md` (HEAD `4fd0879`).
2. Run focused test gate: `pytest tests/test_ad525_*.py -v -n 0`.
3. Run full parallel gate: `pytest tests/ -q -n 4 --dist=loadfile`.
4. **Single-line correction at DECISIONS.md write time** (per Pass-2 Nit-N1): replace the draft "Frontmatter includes type: creative, medium, author, department" sentence with "Frontmatter is assembled by `RecordsStore.write_entry`; `medium` and `skill_id` are encoded in `tags=[\"creative\", medium, skill_id]`."
5. Single commit: `AD-525: Creative Expression v1 (Skills Inventory + Records Output)`.
6. Issue #100 closes on commit.

## Hard-Stops

| # | Trigger | Status |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Required incomplete | ✅ All 3 resolved |
| 2 | New Required-class issue | ✅ None introduced |
| 3 | Pre-check finds new phantoms | ✅ 0 NEW phantoms |

No hard-stops triggered. Sweep clean.

---

**Convergence target met:** 1 ⚠️ Conditional → 1 ✅ Approved. Two-pass review (Wave 5 convention #7) honored.
