# Wave 160 — Pass-2 Review Summary

**Date:** 2026-05-14. **Pass:** 2. **Reviewer:** Architect.
**Prompts re-audited:** 3 revised (`ad-726`, `ad-722a-4`, `ad-722b-4`) + 2 unchanged re-affirmed (`ad-730-2`, `ad-723a-3`).

---

## Per-prompt pass-2 verdict

| # | Prompt | Pass-1 | Pass-2 | Headline |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | `ad-726-dm-path-refactor.md` | ❌ | ✅ Approved | ctx gains `params` + `message_text`; `sanity_result` per-step local; span recomputed to 1278..1572 (295 lines); net delta -272. |
| 2 | `ad-722a-4-divergence-auto-correction.md` | ⚠️ | ✅ Approved | Slot-clear moved to START of `step_1_sanity_gate_retry` (option a); no collision with AD-726. |
| 3 | `ad-722b-4-multi-agent-telemetry-stream.md` | ⚠️ | ✅ Approved | Hook URL is `/api/agent/avatar-telemetry/stream` (router prefix applied); pytest tests note added. |
| 4 | `ad-730-2-multi-image-dm-policy.md` | ✅ | ✅ Re-affirmed | Unchanged. |
| 5 | `ad-723a-3-sensorium-entry-metadata.md` | ✅ | ✅ Re-affirmed | Unchanged. |

---

## Required-findings tally

| Prompt | Pass-1 Required | Pass-2 Required (NEW) |
|---|---|---|
| AD-726 | 3 | **0** |
| AD-722a-4 | 3 | **0** |
| AD-722b-4 | 3 | **0** |
| AD-730-2 | 0 | 0 |
| AD-723a-3 | 0 | 0 |
| **Total** | **9** | **0** |

All 9 pass-1 Required findings resolved. Zero new Required findings introduced by the revisions. Per Convention #15 ("If ANY new Required, REJECT") → no rejection trigger.

---

## Verification highlights

### AD-726 (revised)

- `DmReplyContext` at `prompts/ad-726-dm-path-refactor.md:148-149` gains:
  ```python
  params: dict[str, object]
  message_text: str
  ```
- `sanity_result` explicitly NOT in ctx (line 154-155 comment); rebind-rules carve-out maps it to per-step local.
- Span re-verified against live HEAD: `1278..1572` = 295 lines (re-quoted at lines 18, 60, 65-69, 190, 244, 296).
- Net delta: -295 + 23 = **-272 lines**. Acceptance criterion no longer asserts a fixed line count.
- Cross-prompt seam with AD-722a-4 documented at line 220 of AD-722a-4 (prepend BEFORE verbatim body, different file).

### AD-722a-4 (revised)

- Slot-clear block at `prompts/ad-722a-4-divergence-auto-correction.md:220-232` — START of `step_1_sanity_gate_retry`, Tier-2 guarded, uses `self.ctx.runtime` + `self.ctx.agent_id`.
- Section 5 rewritten with option (a) rationale; option (b) (TTL/sequence) rejected as more complex.
- Test renamed to `test_pipeline_step_1_clears_stale_slot` (line 246).
- Section 3 verification step 3 explicitly forbids the post-emit clear.
- `compute_divergence` re-call now does two-step `dataclasses.replace` (restore custom emotion name + set `corrected=True`).
- `apply_voice_modulation` multiplication site instruction explicit (LAST write to `noise_scale`/`length_scale` before `ModulationSnapshot`).
- DEBUG → WARNING on missing runtime attr (per enabled-feature-silent-failure rule).

### AD-722b-4 (revised)

- `deriveFleetUrl()` at line 387 returns `/api/agent/avatar-telemetry/stream` (router prefix `routers/agents.py:30`).
- Section 4 leads with bold pytest URL reminder (line 395).
- Section 2 step 6 rewritten: routing precedence clarified (literals diverge, insertion order purely cosmetic).
- UI gate compliance preserved (vitest run + npm run build).

### AD-730-2 / AD-723a-3 (unchanged)

- No ``## Revision (2026-05-14)`` section in either prompt (grep-verified).
- Pass-1 ✅ verdicts re-affirmed without modification.

---

## Cross-prompt concerns (pass-2)

1. **AD-722a-4 / AD-726 seam revised.** Pass-1 cross-prompt note flagged that AD-722a-4's slot-clear lived in `step_7_mark_emitted` (the bottom of the verbatim move). Pass-2 moves it to the TOP of `step_1_sanity_gate_retry`. The seam is now a 5-line prepend BEFORE AD-726's verbatim body in `reply_pipeline.py`. AD-726 Section 3's SEARCH/REPLACE targets `routers/agents.py:1278`, not `reply_pipeline.py` — no collision. Dispatch order (AD-726 → AD-722a-4) preserved.
2. **No license drift.** All 5 prompts remain all-internal Apache 2.0.
3. **No emoji vector.** AD-722b-4 hook file is pure TS logic.
4. **No `asyncio.create_subprocess_*`.** Confirmed in all 5 prompts.
5. **`multi_replace_string_in_file` discipline preserved.** All large-span edits use single `replace_string_in_file` calls.
6. **AD numbering.** No new top-level AD numbers consumed by pass-2 revisions.

---

## Final wave verdict

**APPROVE.** All 5 prompts cleared for build dispatch. No new Required findings. All pass-1 Required findings resolved with verifiable in-prompt evidence.

## Recommendation

**ADVANCE to GATE 1.** Dispatch order from pass-1 stands (1 → 5 → 2 → 4 → 3 with AD-726 first, or operator-chosen parallelization for additive prompts 4 and 5). Builder may proceed under continuous-build mode with the standard per-prompt quality gate (`pytest tests/ -q -n 4 --dist=loadfile` after each commit).
