# Wave 23 Review Sweep

**Status:** Single-prompt sweep (Combo E only).
**Date:** 2026-05-04
**Tolerance:** Convention #15 relaxed to 1 ⚠️ allowed.

## Roster

| Prompt | Verdict | Req | Rec | Nit | Hard-Stops | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| [Combo E — AD-508 + AD-478 cognitive helpers v1](combo-E-cognitive-helpers-review.md) | ✅ Approved | 0 | 1 | 4 | 0/3 triggered | Read-only observational helpers; pre-deferral honest; privacy invariant clean. |

## Sweep Totals

- **Approved:** 1
- **Conditional:** 0
- **Not Ready:** 0
- **Required findings:** 0
- **Hard-stops triggered:** 0/3

Tolerance budget (1 ⚠️) unused. Sweep ships clean.

## Pre-Check Outcome

Documented FPs (2): `runtime.duty_scope_provider`, `runtime.workspace_ontology` — both introduced by Combo E. Verified 0 grep hits in `src/probos/` confirming both are net-new attributes. No new phantoms surfaced.

## Lessons (carry to Wave 24)

- **Combo-shape ADs continue to ship clean** when pre-deferral discipline is loud (explicit "1 of 4" + enumerated deferred children + dedicated "What This Does NOT Change" section). Combo D (Wave 20) and Combo E (Wave 23) both passed first review on this pattern. Continue using when two ADs are bounded read-only v1 capabilities.
- **`emit_event` wiring spec divergence is now a 3-way pattern** in finalize.py:
  - AD-525 / `_wire_creative_expression`: external assignment to private `_emit_event_fn` field after construction.
  - AD-530 / `_wire_classification_gate`: ctor kwarg `emit_event=emit_fn`.
  - Combo E (proposed): public `emit_event` field set externally (late-bind).
  All three are valid. Future cognitive-helper prompts should pick one shape per file; recommend default = AD-530 ctor-injection unless there's reason to defer wiring.
- **`list_work_items(status, assigned_to, limit)` is the canonical Duty Scope query** for AD-508b consumers. Future scoped-cognition ADs should reuse this kwargs triple.
