# Wave 12 Second-Pass Sweep (2026-05-03)

**Sweep verdict:** 1 ✅ Approved (target met).

## Pass-2 Results

| Prompt | Pass-1 Verdict | Pass-2 Verdict | Required Open | New Findings |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| AD-477 (Naval Organization v1: Captain's Log + Plan of the Day) | ⚠️ Conditional | ✅ Approved | 0 | 0 |

**Total Required-still-open: 0** (target: 0).
**Total new findings: 0** (target: 0).

## Resolution Summary (AD-477)

- **R1 (dreaming Option a defer):** Resolved. CaptainsLog v1 now ships 3 source aggregations (episodic + Ward Room + work items); dream-consolidation deferred to AD-477g with explicit forcing function (runtime exposes `runtime.dreaming_engine` publicly, OR `DreamScheduler` adds `recent_consolidation_summaries(...)`). Mirrors the `duty_schedule_tracker` negative-framing pattern from Wave 9B.
- **R2 (episodic by-date pattern):** Resolved. Section 2 docstring specifies `recent(k=N*4)` over-fetch + Python-side `[date_start, date_end]` UTC-midnight filter + `importance >= threshold` filter. Live API confirmed at `cognitive/episodic.py:1832`.
- **R3 (status="open" canonical enum value):** Resolved. All shipping-content `"pending"` → `"open"`; Test #8 renamed `test_plan_of_day_aggregates_open_work_items`; `WorkItemStatus.OPEN` enum verified at `workforce.py:44`.
- **Recommended #1-3:** All folded (`Field(default_factory=...)` for nested-BaseModel defaults; verified-against-codebase grep audit; Test #12 tightened to require `raises(CancelledError)`).
- **Nit #1:** Folded (start-task attributes brought under Wave 5 convention #1 callout).
- **Nits #2-3:** Deferred / moot (staged-rollout `getattr` retained; test-count contingency moot under R1 path (a)).

## Pre-check Output

```
./scripts/phantom-api-precheck.ps1 prompts/ad-477-naval-organization-v1.md

=== prompts/ad-477-naval-organization-v1.md ===
  1 phantom symbol(s):
    - [runtime.X] runtime.duty_schedule_tracker

=== Summary ===
Prompts scanned: 1
Total phantom candidates: 1
```

The single phantom is the documented NOTE self-reference for the AD-477f scheduled-duties forcing function (audit-trail, not assertion). Zero new phantoms relative to pass-1.

## AD-685 Tooling Validation

AD-685's kwarg pre-check caught its first non-trivial Wave 12 phantom — `runtime.duty_schedule_tracker` — at dispatch-time, before the pass-1 review began (commit `b37fbb4`). The Wave 11 tooling investment is validated: a structural defect was eliminated by automation rather than by reviewer-grep.

The pass-1 Required findings (R1 dreaming attribute existence; R2 absent-by-design by-date query; R3 enum-value drift) sat outside AD-685's current detection envelope. These are banked as forcing functions for future tooling-hygiene extensions:
- **AD-685c (candidate):** runtime-attribute existence checking (would have caught R1).
- **AD-685d (candidate):** absent-method-by-design surfacing (would have flagged R2).
- **AD-685e (candidate):** enum-value validation against live `Enum` definitions (would have caught R3).

## Recommended Builder Dispatch

**Single commit, ready immediately.** The revised AD-477 prompt at commit `7b5e53f` is build-ready:
- 14 tests, all named in Test Plan.
- 2 EventTypes (`CAPTAINS_LOG_GENERATED`, `PLAN_OF_DAY_GENERATED`).
- New package `src/probos/naval/` with two services and their Pydantic configs.
- Read-only consumers; no writes to existing surfaces.
- 3 hard-stops, all real possible build-time discoveries (none structural-defect punts).

Standard Builder dispatch — no special handling required. Continue per `prompts/BUILDER-EXECUTION-PLAN.md`.

## Convention Update Candidates

None this sweep. The Wave 11 + 12 convention stack (#21 proactive structural-defect sweep, #16 mandatory pre-check audit trail, AD-685 kwarg pre-check) held cleanly through this revision cycle.

## Appendix — Wave 12 Cycle Summary

| Phase | Commit | Outcome |
|---|---|---|
| Dispatch | `3ddfa85` | AD-477 v1 drafted |
| Tooling catch | `b37fbb4` | AD-685 pre-check eliminated `runtime.duty_schedule_tracker` phantom |
| Pass-1 review | `dfb51c2` | ⚠️ Conditional, 3 Required + 3 Recommended + 3 Nits |
| Revision | `7b5e53f` | All Required addressed, 3/3 Recommended folded, 1/3 Nits folded |
| Pass-2 review | (this commit) | ✅ Approved, 0 Required open, 0 new findings |
