# Eval Asset Quality Rubric

Use this rubric when reviewing scenarios, suites, and rubrics for promotion.

## Pass

- The target and hypothesis are explicit.
- The setup is reproducible.
- Required evidence is named.
- The pass/weak/fail criteria distinguish behavior quality.
- Runtime cost is appropriate for the intended suite.
- The asset is not a duplicate of existing coverage.

## Weak

- The asset is useful but missing one review detail, such as artifact paths,
  timeout expectations, or a clear suite placement.

## Fail

- The asset is vague, duplicative, flaky by design, too expensive for its value,
  or likely to reward weak behavior.
