# Verify Report: rook-590-admin-api

## status

PASS

## executive_summary

The Rook admin API implementation is functionally aligned with the proposal/spec/tasks for the M1
scope: admin DTOs exist, responses redact `api_key`, read and write endpoints are implemented,
pool membership endpoints are present, `/api/usage` returns the required placeholder contract, and
server composition now mounts the real admin router under `/api` without breaking `/v1` or the
dashboard routes.

Behavioral verification is strong: the full `clients/rook` test suite passes, including targeted
coverage for composition, redaction, CRUD, membership, and deletion/reference-integrity behavior.

The verification gate is now clean: formatting, clippy, and the full Rook test suite all pass.

## artifacts_reviewed

- `openspec/changes/rook-590-admin-api/proposal.md`
- `openspec/changes/rook-590-admin-api/spec.md`
- `openspec/changes/rook-590-admin-api/design.md`
- `openspec/changes/rook-590-admin-api/tasks.md`
- `clients/rook/src/lib.rs`
- `clients/rook/src/admin/mod.rs`
- `clients/rook/src/admin/types.rs`
- `clients/rook/src/admin/handlers.rs`
- `clients/rook/src/server/mod.rs`
- `clients/rook/src/services/account.rs`
- `clients/rook/src/services/pool.rs`
- `clients/rook/src/services/route.rs`
- `clients/rook/src/db/account.rs`
- `clients/rook/src/db/pool.rs`
- `clients/rook/src/db/route.rs`
- `clients/rook/src/db/mod.rs`
- `clients/rook/src/dashboard/mod.rs`
- `clients/rook/migrations/0001_initial.sql`

## requirements_coverage

### 1. admin module structure and DTOs

Covered.

- `clients/rook/src/admin/` contains `mod.rs`, `handlers.rs`, and `types.rs`
- `clients/rook/src/lib.rs` exports `pub mod admin;`
- DTOs/views present for accounts, pools, routes, health, settings, usage, requests, and admin
  errors

### 2. redaction behavior (`has_api_key`, never raw `api_key`)

Covered.

- `AccountView` exposes `has_api_key`
- mapping from `ProviderAccount` never serializes raw `api_key`
- targeted tests assert `api_key` absence in JSON

### 3. read-only endpoints

Covered.

- `GET /api/health`
- `GET /api/health/accounts`
- `GET /api/health/summary`
- `GET /api/accounts`
- `GET /api/accounts/{account_id}`
- `GET /api/pools`
- `GET /api/pools/{pool_id}`
- `GET /api/routes`
- `GET /api/routes/{route_id}`
- `GET /api/settings`
- `GET /api/usage`

Read endpoints are backed by `RookRegistry` and tested through the router.

### 4. mutating endpoints

Covered.

- `POST/PUT/DELETE /api/accounts/{...}`
- `POST/PUT/DELETE /api/pools/{...}`
- `POST/PUT/DELETE /api/routes/{...}`
- `PUT /api/settings`

Handlers validate basics, map not-found/conflict/internal errors into admin error responses, and
return redacted account payloads.

### 5. pool membership endpoints

Covered.

- `POST /api/pools/{pool_id}/accounts`
- `DELETE /api/pools/{pool_id}/accounts/{account_id}`

Spec-aligned compensations were added in handlers:

- missing account on add → `404 not_found`
- remove non-member → `409 conflict`
- add is idempotent and tested without relying on member ordering

### 6. usage placeholder endpoint

Covered.

- returns `{ "available": false, "reason": "usage accounting is not implemented in M1" }`
- composition test verifies it through `/api/usage`

### 7. server composition under `/api` + coexistence with `/v1` and dashboard

Covered.

- `clients/rook/src/server/mod.rs` nests `admin::build_router(registry)` under `/api`
- preserves `/v1` gateway router
- preserves dashboard merge
- tests prove `/api/health`, `/api/usage`, `/v1/models`, and `/` coexist

### 8. integrity/deletion semantics

Covered for the implemented M1 scope.

Verified deterministic behavior for:

- deleting account referenced by pool → `409 reference_conflict`
- deleting pool referenced by route → `409 reference_conflict`
- deleting pool referenced as fallback pool → `409 reference_conflict`
- deleting route referenced as fallback route → `409 reference_conflict`
- missing account/pool/route update/delete → `404 not_found`

Minimal service/db hardening was added for cases that were previously permissive.

### 9. testing evidence

Strong behavioral evidence exists.

- targeted admin DTO tests
- targeted admin router tests for read/write/membership/integrity
- targeted server composition tests
- full Rook crate test suite passes

## test_evidence

### Executed

1. `cargo test --manifest-path "clients/rook/Cargo.toml"`
   - PASS
   - 162 tests passed in `src/lib.rs`

2. `cargo fmt --manifest-path "clients/rook/Cargo.toml" --all -- --check`
   - PASS

3. `cargo clippy --manifest-path "clients/rook/Cargo.toml" --all-targets -- -D warnings`
   - PASS

### Previously executed targeted evidence in apply slices

- admin DTO redaction and placeholder tests
- admin read-only router tests
- admin mutation router tests
- pool membership router tests
- server composition tests
- deletion/reference-integrity router tests

## gaps_warnings

1. **Formatting gate fails**
   - `cargo fmt --check` is not clean

2. **Clippy gate fails**
   - examples from test code:
     - `assert_eq!(..., true)` instead of `assert!(...)`
     - field reassignment after `Default::default()` construction

3. **Design-vs-implementation warning: malformed path IDs**
   - Design says UUID parse failures should return admin `400 bad_request`
   - Current implementation relies on axum extraction defaults for malformed path IDs
   - This was not shown as a spec failure from the artifact reviewed here, but it is a design drift /
     coverage gap worth noting

4. **Error classification remains string-based**
   - handler conflict/not-found mapping still depends on `RookError::Registry(String)` message
   - acceptable for current scope, but brittle long-term

## critical_issues

None on functional/spec behavior.

The implementation appears behaviorally complete for the scoped change, and the full Rook test
suite passes. The remaining issues are quality-gate warnings, not evidence of broken feature
behavior.

## next_recommended

1. Fix formatting drift with `cargo fmt`
2. Fix clippy warnings in test code so `cargo clippy --all-targets -- -D warnings` passes cleanly
3. Optionally add explicit malformed-ID admin error coverage if the team wants full design parity
4. If those cleanup items are accepted, proceed to `sdd-archive`
