## Verification Report

**Change**: rook-594-dashboard-usage-settings
**Version**: N/A

---

### Completeness

| Metric | Value |
|--------|-------|
| Tasks total | 10 |
| Tasks complete | 10 |
| Tasks incomplete | 0 |

All tasks in `openspec/changes/rook-594-dashboard-usage-settings/tasks.md` are marked complete.

---

### Build & Tests Execution

**Build**: ✅ Passed

Command:

```bash
pnpm --filter @corvus/rook-dashboard run build
```

Evidence:

- `vue-tsc -b --noEmit && vite build`
- Vite production build completed successfully
- Embedded assets emitted under `clients/rook/assets/`

**Tests**: ✅ 73 passed / ❌ 0 failed / ⚠️ 0 skipped

Commands:

```bash
pnpm --filter @corvus/rook-dashboard run test
pnpm --filter @corvus/rook-dashboard run test:e2e
```

Evidence:

- Unit/component tests: `16` files passed, `71` tests passed, `0` failed, `0` skipped
- E2E tests: `2` passed, `0` failed, `0` skipped

**Checks**: ✅ Passed

Command:

```bash
pnpm --filter @corvus/rook-dashboard run check
```

Evidence:

- `biome check src package.json tsconfig*.json vite.config.ts playwright.config.ts index.html README.md`
- Checked 45 files with no errors

**Coverage**: ➖ Not configured

---

### Spec Compliance Matrix

| Requirement | Scenario | Test | Result |
|-------------|----------|------|--------|
| Rook Operator Shell and Slice-Bounded Navigation | operator sees usage and settings in the Rook shell | `clients/web/apps/rook-dashboard/e2e/rook-dashboard.spec.ts > covers #593 navigation plus pools, routes, and read-only health flows` | ✅ COMPLIANT |
| Rook Operator Shell and Slice-Bounded Navigation | unsupported #594 workflow areas remain deferred | `clients/web/apps/rook-dashboard/src/lib/navigation/routes.spec.ts > keeps deferred #594 areas out of the supported route set`; `clients/web/apps/rook-dashboard/e2e/rook-dashboard.spec.ts > covers #593 navigation plus pools, routes, and read-only health flows` | ✅ COMPLIANT |
| Usage Page Uses Only the Verified Placeholder Usage Contract | usage page renders the verified placeholder response | `clients/web/apps/rook-dashboard/src/features/usage/UsagePage.spec.ts > renders the placeholder usage response and avoids fake analytics copy`; `clients/web/apps/rook-dashboard/e2e/rook-dashboard.spec.ts > covers #593 navigation plus pools, routes, and read-only health flows` | ✅ COMPLIANT |
| Usage Page Uses Only the Verified Placeholder Usage Contract | usage page shows a loading state while the placeholder contract is in flight | `clients/web/apps/rook-dashboard/src/features/usage/UsagePage.spec.ts > shows loading state while usage is pending`; `clients/web/apps/rook-dashboard/src/features/usage/useUsage.spec.ts > shows loading while the usage contract is in flight` | ✅ COMPLIANT |
| Usage Page Uses Only the Verified Placeholder Usage Contract | usage page scopes API failure to the usage view | `clients/web/apps/rook-dashboard/src/features/usage/UsagePage.spec.ts > shows recoverable error state and retries usage loading`; `clients/web/apps/rook-dashboard/src/features/usage/useUsage.spec.ts > surfaces API failures and recovers on retry` | ✅ COMPLIANT |
| Settings Page Uses Only the Verified Settings Read and Update Contracts | settings page loads persisted settings | `clients/web/apps/rook-dashboard/src/features/settings/SettingsPage.spec.ts > renders persisted or default settings values instead of an empty state` | ✅ COMPLIANT |
| Settings Page Uses Only the Verified Settings Read and Update Contracts | settings page loads defaults instead of an empty state before first save | `clients/web/apps/rook-dashboard/src/features/settings/useSettings.spec.ts > loads defaults or persisted settings into current and draft state`; `clients/web/apps/rook-dashboard/src/features/settings/SettingsPage.spec.ts > renders persisted or default settings values instead of an empty state` | ✅ COMPLIANT |
| Settings Page Uses Only the Verified Settings Read and Update Contracts | settings page saves through PUT only | `clients/web/apps/rook-dashboard/src/features/settings/SettingsPage.spec.ts > submits a full settings object through PUT and shows save progress`; `clients/web/apps/rook-dashboard/src/features/settings/useSettings.spec.ts > tracks dirty state and applies the PUT response as canonical state` | ✅ COMPLIANT |
| Settings Page Uses Only the Verified Settings Read and Update Contracts | settings page shows save-in-progress during update | `clients/web/apps/rook-dashboard/src/features/settings/SettingsPage.spec.ts > submits a full settings object through PUT and shows save progress` | ✅ COMPLIANT |
| Settings Page Uses Only the Verified Settings Read and Update Contracts | settings page surfaces API validation or save errors without inventing client policy | `clients/web/apps/rook-dashboard/src/features/settings/SettingsPage.spec.ts > shows recoverable save errors without leaving settings context`; `clients/web/apps/rook-dashboard/src/features/settings/useSettings.spec.ts > keeps draft state recoverable when the settings save fails` | ✅ COMPLIANT |
| Unsupported Logs and Backup Workflows Remain Explicitly Blocked | logs and backup-related workflows are not presented as working features | `clients/web/apps/rook-dashboard/e2e/rook-dashboard.spec.ts > covers #593 navigation plus pools, routes, and read-only health flows`; `clients/web/apps/rook-dashboard/src/lib/api/client.spec.ts > does not expose speculative health, logs, or backup mutation methods` | ✅ COMPLIANT |
| Unsupported Logs and Backup Workflows Remain Explicitly Blocked | usage page does not invent unsupported analytics to fill the placeholder gap | `clients/web/apps/rook-dashboard/src/features/usage/UsagePage.spec.ts > renders the placeholder usage response and avoids fake analytics copy`; `clients/web/apps/rook-dashboard/src/features/usage/useUsage.spec.ts > loads the verified placeholder response without inventing analytics state`; `clients/web/apps/rook-dashboard/e2e/rook-dashboard.spec.ts > covers #593 navigation plus pools, routes, and read-only health flows` | ✅ COMPLIANT |

**Compliance summary**: 12/12 scenarios compliant

---

### Correctness (Static — Structural Evidence)

| Requirement | Status | Notes |
|------------|--------|-------|
| Slice scope is usage + settings only | ✅ Implemented | `App.vue` adds only Usage and Settings alongside prior shipped sections; README and E2E assert logs/backups remain deferred. |
| Dedicated Rook surface extended, not legacy dashboard | ✅ Implemented | All code changes are under `clients/web/apps/rook-dashboard/**`; no matching references to `clients/web/apps/dashboard/**` or `/web/admin/*` were found in the Rook dashboard app. |
| Usage page uses only verified placeholder contract | ✅ Implemented | `client.ts` adds only `getUsage()` hitting `/api/usage`; `useUsage.ts` stores only `UsageStatusView`; `UsagePage.vue` renders only `available` and `reason`. |
| Settings page uses only verified GET/PUT semantics | ✅ Implemented | `client.ts` adds `getSettings()` and `updateSettings()` only; no PATCH method exists; `useSettings.ts` saves the full object and treats the PUT response as canonical state. |
| Logs/backups/import-export absent | ✅ Implemented | Routes reject `#/logs` and `#/backups`; API client spec asserts no logs/backup/import/export methods; UI copy keeps those areas deferred. |
| Verification evidence from implementation phase exists | ✅ Implemented | Fresh verification evidence now confirms `check`, `test`, and `test:e2e` all pass for the rook dashboard slice. |

---

### Coherence (Design)

| Decision | Followed? | Notes |
|----------|-----------|-------|
| Extend existing Rook dashboard shell | ✅ Yes | `App.vue` and route wiring stay in `clients/web/apps/rook-dashboard`; build emits into `clients/rook/assets`. |
| Keep hash-based navigation | ✅ Yes | `routes.ts` extends `RookRoute` with `usage` and `settings`; `App.vue` still uses `window.location.hash`. |
| Remove usage/settings from deferred messaging | ✅ Yes | Shell nav exposes Usage and Settings as first-class buttons; deferred copy now names only logs and backups. |
| Feature-scoped composables and typed API boundaries | ✅ Yes | `useUsage.ts`, `useSettings.ts`, `UsagePage.vue`, `SettingsPage.vue`, and `src/lib/api/*` match the planned structure. |
| Usage remains placeholder, not analytics | ✅ Yes | `UsagePage.vue` explicitly forbids invented totals/quotas/trends and renders the returned reason only. |
| Settings remain server-authoritative full-object PUT | ✅ Yes | `useSettings.ts` sends full draft via `updateSettings()` and resets state from the PUT response without extra GET. |
| Preserve backend validation semantics | ✅ Yes | Save errors are surfaced from API failures; no extra client-side policy matrix or unsupported mutation flow was added. |
| Do not reuse legacy dashboard abstractions | ✅ Yes | New code stays local to the Rook dashboard app and its existing API boundary. |

---

### Issues Found

**CRITICAL** (must fix before archive):

None

**WARNING** (should fix):

None

**SUGGESTION** (nice to have):

None

---

### Verdict

PASS

The implementation matches the intended first #594 slice, remains contract-bounded to verified usage/settings semantics on the dedicated Rook dashboard surface, and now has clean passing check, unit, and E2E evidence.
