# Verification Report

**Change**: `rook-doctor-operational-diagnostics-679`  
**Scope verified**: local-first `rook doctor` enhancement; optional upstream probing intentionally omitted

---

### Completeness

| Metric | Value |
|--------|-------|
| Tasks total | 11 |
| Tasks complete | 9 |
| Tasks incomplete | 2 |

Incomplete tasks:
- `2.6` Add opt-in advisory upstream probe plumbing
- `3.5` Add upstream-probing tests

Assessment: these are optional-scope tasks and are consistent with the approved implementation context that upstream probing was intentionally omitted.

---

### Commands Run and Outcomes

| Command | Scope | Outcome |
|---------|-------|---------|
| `cargo fmt --all -- --check` | `clients/rook` | ✅ Passed |
| `cargo clippy --all-targets -- -D warnings` | `clients/rook` | ✅ Passed |
| `cargo test` | `clients/rook` | ✅ Passed |

Notes:
- Verification was correctly scoped to the owning workspace (`clients/rook`) per monorepo guidance.
- Formatting drift has been corrected.
- Added behavioral coverage for the required dashboard-assets failure scenario.

---

### Spec Compliance Matrix

| Requirement | Scenario | Evidence | Result |
|-------------|----------|----------|--------|
| Shared Effective Rook Configuration Assembly | doctor uses shared effective configuration assembly and reports effective bind target | `clients/rook/src/config/mod.rs`, `clients/rook/src/doctor.rs`, doctor CLI/unit tests | ✅ Satisfied for implemented scope |
| Rook Doctor Deterministic Diagnostics | happy path reports ordered config/database/assets/inbound_auth checks | `clients/rook/tests/doctor_operational_diagnostics.rs` | ✅ Satisfied |
| Rook Doctor Deterministic Diagnostics | invalid effective config fails with non-zero result | `clients/rook/src/main.rs` tests, `clients/rook/src/doctor.rs` tests | ✅ Satisfied |
| Rook Doctor Deterministic Diagnostics | startup-equivalent database readiness failures are actionable | `clients/rook/src/db/mod.rs` tests, `clients/rook/tests/doctor_operational_diagnostics.rs` | ✅ Satisfied |
| Rook Doctor Deterministic Diagnostics | missing dashboard assets fail with actionable output | `clients/rook/src/doctor.rs` tests, `clients/rook/tests/doctor_operational_diagnostics.rs`, `clients/rook/src/dashboard/mod.rs` test seam | ✅ Satisfied |
| Rook Doctor Deterministic Diagnostics | inbound auth only fails when enabled and invalid; secrets remain redacted | `clients/rook/src/doctor.rs`, `clients/rook/src/main.rs`, `clients/rook/tests/doctor_operational_diagnostics.rs` | ✅ Satisfied |
| Optional Advisory Upstream Probe Mode | upstream probing omitted by default and not required for local readiness | no probe implementation added; optional tasks intentionally left incomplete | ✅ Consistent with approved scope |

---

### Design and Task Alignment

Verified alignment with the design and task plan:
- shared startup-readiness seam is used instead of read-only DB checks
- doctor output is structured with stable check names and pass/warn/fail statuses
- secret-safe reporting is preserved
- local-first deterministic default behavior is maintained
- required dashboard-assets failure coverage is now present

Task status:
- Required local-first tasks are implemented and verified.
- Optional upstream-probing tasks remain intentionally open and do not block this change.

---

### Residual Risks / Follow-up

Non-blocking follow-up items:
- `serve` and `doctor` share configuration assembly, but future refactors should continue guarding against validation-path drift.
- If upstream advisory probes are later implemented, they should remain explicitly opt-in, bounded, and excluded from default exit semantics.

---

### Final Assessment

**Result: PASS for the implemented local-first scope.**

No blocking verification issues remain for archiving this change.
