# Verification Report

**Change**: cerebro-distribution
**Version**: N/A (planning-only)
**Type**: Planning proposal — no code, specs, design, tasks, or tests in scope

---

## Completeness

| Metric                         | Value                             |
|--------------------------------|-----------------------------------|
| Decisions documented           | 7                                 |
| Decisions with explicit status | 7/7                               |
| Risks identified               | 4                                 |
| Risks with mitigations         | 4/4                               |
| Follow-up issues created       | 5 (DALLAY-231 through DALLAY-235) |
| Execution order defined        | Yes                               |

All planning deliverables are present. Proposal is marked APPROVED.

---

## Decision Quality

| Decision                     | Status Keywords     | Clear Rationale                       | Traceable to Issue           |
|------------------------------|---------------------|---------------------------------------|------------------------------|
| D1: v1 Distribution Channels | MUST, DEFER         | Yes — lowest friction, natural model  | DALLAY-231, 232, 233         |
| D2: Binary Names             | YES, NO             | Yes — one binary, no confusion        | Implicit in all build issues |
| D3: Artifact Naming Scheme   | Explicit pattern    | Yes — mirrors corvus convention       | DALLAY-231, 233              |
| D4: Platform Matrix          | MUST, SHOULD        | Yes — cloud + dev priorities          | DALLAY-231                   |
| D5: Docker Image Specifics   | Explicit per aspect | Yes — distroless, multi-arch          | DALLAY-232                   |
| D6: Versioning Strategy      | Explicit            | Yes — semver pre-1.0 rationale        | DALLAY-234                   |
| D7: Install Paths            | Primary/Secondary   | Yes — Docker for prod, binary for dev | Implicit in docs             |

---

## Issue Traceability

| Linear ID  | Title                           | Maps to Decision(s) | Priority Consistent |
|------------|---------------------------------|---------------------|---------------------|
| DALLAY-231 | CI: native binary build matrix  | D1, D3, D4          | High (MUST) ✅       |
| DALLAY-232 | Docker: Dockerfile + multi-arch | D1, D5              | High (MUST) ✅       |
| DALLAY-233 | CI: GitHub Release assets       | D1, D3              | High (MUST) ✅       |
| DALLAY-234 | Align version + release-please  | D6                  | High (MUST) ✅       |
| DALLAY-235 | Makefile targets                | Operational         | Medium (SHOULD) ✅   |

Execution order `234 → 231 → 232 + 233 → 235` is logically sound: version alignment first, then
build matrix, then release artifacts, then convenience targets.

---

## Internal Consistency Check

| Check                                                                                     | Result                                                              |
|-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------|---------------------------------------------------------------------|
| D2 (ship only `cerebro`) vs D7 (install paths reference `cerebro serve`)                  | ✅ Consistent — `cerebro serve` is a subcommand of the single binary |
| D1 (DEFER npm) vs Risk table (no npx convenience)                                         | ✅ Consistent — risk acknowledged                                    |
| D3 (5 artifacts) vs D4 (5 platform targets)                                               | ✅ 1:1 match                                                         |
| D5 (port 4040) vs D7 (docker run -p 4040:4040)                                            | ✅ Consistent                                                        |
| D5 (tags: v{semver}, major.minor, major, latest) vs D6 (monorepo version)                 | ✅ Consistent                                                        |
| D4 MUST targets (linux-x64, linux-arm64, darwin-arm64) vs D5 Docker arches (amd64, arm64) | ✅ Consistent — Docker covers the two MUST Linux targets             |

No contradictions found.

---

## Build & Tests Execution

**N/A** — Planning-only change. No code to build or test.

---

## Spec Compliance Matrix

**N/A** — No specs defined for this planning change. The proposal IS the deliverable.

---

## Issues Found

**CRITICAL** (must fix before archive):
None

**WARNING** (should fix):
None

**SUGGESTION** (nice to have):

1. Consider adding a Decision 8 covering checksum/signature strategy for release binaries (SHA256
   files are mentioned in DALLAY-233 title but not in a formal decision).
2. Consider cross-referencing cerebro-docs change for documentation of install paths — Decision 7's
   install commands will need docs.

---

## Verdict

**PASS**

All 7 decisions have explicit status keywords (MUST/SHOULD/DEFER/YES/NO), clear rationale, and
traceable follow-up issues. Risks are identified with mitigations. No internal contradictions.
Execution order is logically sound. Ready for archive.
