---
arxiv_id: ''
fidelity: local_source
registered: '2026-04-24T16:29:17+08:00'
source_id: protocol-critique-20260424
title: 26-Problem Protocol Critique from Theoretical Physicist Perspective
type: analysis
---
# 26-Problem Protocol Critique from Theoretical Physicist Perspective

Identified 26 structural problems across: gate quality (4), L2 knowledge representation (6), mathematical verification (4), trust model (4), workflow (5), scaling (3). Core thesis: protocol is a compliance checklist, not a thinking partner. Python code tries to encode physics judgment which it cannot do. LLM self-validates LLM work in autonomous loops.

