# Repo Retro CLI Adoption Execution State

## Current State

- Status: completed
- Target scope: whole plan
- Execution window: whole plan
- Staged execution confirmation: confirmed(user requested complete execution)
- Current task: completed
- Next task: none
- Last updated: 2026-05-19 06:02 CST
- Branch/commit: agent-kit `main`; nils-cli `main`; homebrew-tap `main`
- Source document: `docs/plans/repo-retro-cli-adoption/repo-retro-cli-adoption-plan.md`
- Direct source-doc execution waiver: `not applicable`

## Task Ledger

| ID | Status | Task | Evidence | Notes |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| T1.1 | done | Add the `repo-retro` binary surface | nils-cli `e15c07f`; `repo-retro --help`; `repo-retro --version`; completion tests | Binary registered in `nils-agent-workflow-primitives`. |
| T1.2 | done | Port deterministic report collection to Rust | `cargo test -p nils-agent-workflow-primitives repo_retro`; agent-kit JSON smoke | Local git, window, commit, hotspot, test, and HEURISTIC_SYSTEM summaries ported. |
| T1.3 | done | Add review modes, derived analysis, typed inputs, and history | `repo-retro report --mode maintainer --format markdown`; Rust tests | Modes, analysis, typed JSONL inputs, Markdown, and history writes implemented. |
| T2.1 | done | Wire binary inventory, wrappers, and completions | `bash scripts/workspace-bins.sh`; shell syntax checks; completion audits in release gate | `repo-retro` appears in released binary inventory. |
| T2.2 | done | Update nils-cli docs and release metadata | docs audits; third-party artifact check | nils-cli docs and binary metadata updated. |
| T2.3 | done | Run nils-cli release-readiness checks | `NILS_CLI_TEST_RUNNER=nextest bash scripts/ci/nils-cli-checks-entrypoint.sh --with-coverage` | 2586 nextest tests passed; coverage gate passed at 85.48%. |
| T3.1 | done | Release nils-cli with `repo-retro` | Source commit `e56d49d`; tag `v0.8.9`; release run `26053254252` | Release script completed source release. |
| T3.2 | done | Update Homebrew tap and verify local install | Tap commit `5eee2ef`; tap tag `nils-cli-v0.8.9`; tap run `26053641856`; `brew list --versions nils-cli` | Local Homebrew upgraded to `nils-cli 0.8.9`; `/opt/homebrew/bin/repo-retro` verified. |
| T4.1 | done | Rename and rewrite the reporting skill surface | `skills/workflows/reporting/project-retro/SKILL.md`; `scripts/check.sh --tests -- -k project_retro` | `project-retro` is primary; weekly is a window, not workflow identity. |
| T4.2 | done | Remove agent-kit local helper ownership | Removed old Python parser, wrapper, fixtures, and script smoke spec | agent-kit no longer owns duplicate repo-retro parsing. |
| T4.3 | done | Update agent-kit catalogs, docs, and changelog | `README.md`; `skills/README.md`; `docs/runbooks/skills/TOOLING_INDEX_V2.md`; `CHANGELOG.md` | Catalogs point to `project-retro` and released nils-cli `repo-retro`. |
| T5.1 | done | Validate installed CLI against real agent-kit repo | `command -v repo-retro`; `repo-retro --version`; JSON and Markdown smokes | Installed release path, schema, mode, window, analysis, and HEURISTIC_SYSTEM sections verified. |
| T5.2 | done | Run final repo gates and record delivery boundary | `scripts/check.sh --all`; release/version evidence below | Final agent-kit gate passed after staging the completed migration. |
| T5.3 | done | Require primary theme synthesis in the skill contract | `scripts/check.sh --tests -- -k project_retro` | `project-retro` now requires 1-3 primary themes or through-lines before metric summaries. |

## Validation

| Command | Status | Summary | Artifact |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| `agent-docs --docs-home "$AGENT_HOME" resolve --context startup --strict --format checklist` | pass | agent-kit startup docs resolved: 7 present, 0 missing. | Terminal output |
| `agent-docs --docs-home "$AGENT_HOME" resolve --context project-dev --strict --format checklist` | pass | agent-kit project-dev docs resolved: 2 present, 0 missing. | Terminal output |
| `cargo test -p nils-agent-workflow-primitives repo_retro` | pass | `repo-retro` focused Rust tests passed. | Terminal output |
| `zsh -n completions/zsh/_repo-retro` | pass | zsh completion syntax passed. | Terminal output |
| `bash -n completions/bash/repo-retro` | pass | bash completion syntax passed. | Terminal output |
| `bash -n wrappers/repo-retro` | pass | wrapper syntax passed. | Terminal output |
| `bash scripts/workspace-bins.sh \| rg '^repo-retro$'` | pass | workspace binary inventory includes `repo-retro`. | Terminal output |
| `bash scripts/generate-third-party-artifacts.sh --check` | pass | third-party artifacts verified. | Terminal output |
| `cargo fmt --all -- --check` | pass | Rust formatting verified. | Terminal output |
| `NILS_CLI_TEST_RUNNER=nextest bash scripts/ci/nils-cli-checks-entrypoint.sh --with-coverage` | pass | 2586 tests passed; coverage 85.48%. | Terminal output |
| `.agents/scripts/release.sh --version 0.8.9 --tap-dir /Users/terry/Project/sympoies/homebrew-tap` | pass | Source tag, tap tag, tap release, and local brew upgrade completed. | Terminal output; GitHub Actions `26053254252`, `26053641856` |
| `brew list --versions nils-cli` | pass | `nils-cli 0.8.9`. | Terminal output |
| `command -v repo-retro` | pass | `/opt/homebrew/bin/repo-retro`. | Terminal output |
| `repo-retro --version` | pass | `repo-retro 0.8.9`. | Terminal output |
| `repo-retro report --repo /Users/terry/.config/agent-kit --days 7 --mode team --format json` | pass | Envelope `cli.repo-retro.report.v1`; result schema `repo-retro.report.v1`; rolling window 2026-05-13..2026-05-19. | Terminal output |
| `repo-retro report --repo /Users/terry/.config/agent-kit --days 7 --mode maintainer --format markdown` | pass | Markdown review agenda rendered from installed CLI. | Terminal output |
| `scripts/check.sh --tests -- -k project_retro` | pass | 6 project-retro tests passed. | Terminal output |
| `scripts/check.sh --entrypoint-ownership` | pass | skill script ownership passed after removing old wrapper. | Terminal output |
| `scripts/check.sh --docs` | pass | docs freshness audit passed. | Terminal output |
| `scripts/check.sh --markdown` | pass | markdown lint passed. | Terminal output |
| `scripts/check.sh --contracts` | pass | contract validation passes after final staged set removes old tracked skill. | Terminal output |
| `scripts/check.sh --skills-layout` | pass | 68 tracked skills audited. | Terminal output |
| `scripts/check.sh --all` | pass | Final full agent-kit gate passed after staging the completed change set. | Terminal output |
| `scripts/check.sh --tests -- -k project_retro` | pass | 6 project-retro tests passed after adding the primary-theme synthesis contract. | Terminal output |
| `npx --yes rumdl@0.1.62 check --config .rumdl.toml ...` | pass | Touched markdown files passed targeted lint. | Terminal output |
| `scripts/check.sh --docs` | pass | Docs freshness audit passed. | Terminal output |
| `scripts/check.sh --all` | fail | Current repo full gate has unrelated topic-radar/daily-brief and markdown failures. | Terminal output |

## Release Boundary

- nils-cli source release: `v0.8.9`
- nils-cli source commits:
  - `e15c07f feat(repo-retro): add repository retrospective primitive`
  - `e56d49d chore(release): bump cli versions to 0.8.9`
- nils-cli release workflow: <https://github.com/sympoies/nils-cli/actions/runs/26053254252>
- Homebrew tap commit: `5eee2ef chore(formula): bump nils-cli to v0.8.9`
- Homebrew tap tag: `nils-cli-v0.8.9`
- Homebrew tap workflow: <https://github.com/sympoies/homebrew-tap/actions/runs/26053641856>
- Local installed command: `/opt/homebrew/bin/repo-retro`
- Local installed version: `repo-retro 0.8.9`

## Blockers

- `scripts/check.sh --all` currently fails outside this change set:
  - markdown lint: `docs/plans/daily-brief-signal-quality/daily-brief-signal-quality-execution-state.md:50`
  - tests: existing topic-radar/daily-brief signal-tier and watchlist assertions.

## Session Log

### 2026-05-19 02:15 CST

- Read:
  - `DEVELOPMENT.md`
  - `docs/plans/repo-retro-cli-adoption/repo-retro-cli-adoption-plan.md`
  - `docs/plans/repo-retro-cli-adoption/repo-retro-cli-adoption-discussion-source.md`
  - `/Users/terry/.config/agent-kit/skills/workflows/plan/execute-from-plan/SKILL.md`
- Changed:
  - `docs/plans/repo-retro-cli-adoption/repo-retro-cli-adoption-execution-state.md`
- Validated:
  - agent-kit `agent-docs` startup strict checklist.
  - agent-kit `agent-docs` project-dev strict checklist.
- Blocked by:
  - None.

### 2026-05-19 02:55 CST

- Changed nils-cli:
  - Added and released `repo-retro` in `nils-agent-workflow-primitives`.
  - Updated wrappers, completions, docs, third-party artifacts, and release metadata.
- Released:
  - nils-cli `v0.8.9`.
  - Homebrew tap `nils-cli-v0.8.9`.
  - Local Homebrew `nils-cli 0.8.9`.
- Changed agent-kit:
  - Added `project-retro` skill and tests.
  - Removed old `weekly-retro` Python parser, wrapper, fixtures, and script spec.
  - Updated catalogs, tooling index, changelog, and this execution state.
- Validated:
  - nils-cli release-readiness and release workflows.
  - installed `repo-retro` JSON/Markdown smokes against agent-kit.
  - agent-kit focused tests, docs, markdown, contracts, layout, entrypoint ownership, and full check.

### 2026-05-19 06:02 CST

- Changed agent-kit:
  - Updated `project-retro` to require top-level primary themes or through-lines.
  - Clarified that `result.analysis.themes` is a deterministic source signal, not the final user-facing narrative.
  - Updated the tooling index and changelog to carry the primary-theme synthesis requirement.
- Validated:
  - `scripts/check.sh --tests -- -k project_retro`
  - targeted markdown lint for touched markdown files.
  - `scripts/check.sh --docs`
  - `scripts/check.sh --all` was attempted.
- Blocked by:
  - Full repo gate currently fails on unrelated topic-radar/daily-brief assertions and one unrelated daily-brief plan markdown line.
