# Code Review Specialists Execution State

## Current State

- Status: complete
- Target scope: whole plan
- Execution window: whole plan
- Staged execution confirmation: not applicable
- Current task: none
- Next task: cleanup or promotion through normal plan cleanup flow when desired
- Last updated: 2026-05-19 00:52 CST
- Branch/commit: detached HEAD
- Source document: `docs/plans/code-review-specialists/code-review-specialists-plan.md`
- Direct source-doc execution waiver: `not applicable`

## Task Ledger

| ID | Status | Task | Evidence | Notes |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| T1 | done | Create workflow skill skeleton | `scripts/check.sh --tests -- -k code_review_specialists` | Sprint 1.1 |
| T2 | done | Add seven specialist checklists | `scripts/check.sh --tests -- -k code_review_specialists`; `scripts/check.sh --markdown` | Sprint 1.2 |
| T3 | done | Add upstream attribution and shared review contract | `scripts/check.sh --tests -- -k code_review_specialists` | Sprint 1.3 |
| T4 | done | Implement scope detection helper | `scripts/check.sh --tests -- -k code_review_specialists` | Sprint 2.1 |
| T5 | done | Implement findings merge helper | `scripts/check.sh --tests -- -k code_review_specialists` | Sprint 2.2 |
| T6 | done | Wire helper usage into workflow | `scripts/check.sh --tests -- -k code_review_specialists` | Sprint 2.3 |
| T7 | done | Add specialist review report template | `scripts/check.sh --tests -- -k code_review_specialists`; `scripts/check.sh --markdown` | Sprint 3.1 |
| T8 | done | Document optional review-evidence integration | `scripts/check.sh --tests -- -k 'issue_pr_review or review_evidence'` | Sprint 3.2 |
| T9 | done | Integrate as optional input to issue PR review | `scripts/check.sh --tests -- -k 'issue_pr_review or review_evidence'` | Sprint 3.3 |
| T10 | done | Update catalog and tooling docs | `scripts/check.sh --docs`; `scripts/check.sh --markdown` | Sprint 3.4 |
| T11 | done | Add fixture coverage for specialist outputs | `scripts/check.sh --tests -- -k code_review_specialists` | Sprint 4.1 |
| T12 | done | Run governance and repo checks | `scripts/check.sh --all` | Sprint 4.2 |
| T13 | done | Prepare handoff and cleanup notes | This file | Sprint 4.3 |

## Validation

| Command | Status | Summary | Artifact |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| `agent-docs --docs-home "$AGENT_HOME" resolve --context startup --strict --format checklist` | pass | Required startup docs present. | Terminal output |
| `agent-docs --docs-home "$AGENT_HOME" resolve --context project-dev --strict --format checklist` | pass | Required project-dev docs present. | Terminal output |
| `skills/tools/skill-management/skill-governance/scripts/validate_skill_contracts.sh --file skills/workflows/code-review/code-review-specialists/SKILL.md` | pass | New skill contract validates. | Terminal output |
| `skills/tools/skill-management/skill-governance/scripts/audit-skill-layout.sh --skill-dir skills/workflows/code-review/code-review-specialists` | pass | New skill layout audit passed. | Terminal output |
| `scripts/check.sh --tests -- -k code_review_specialists` | pass | 16 selected tests passed. | Terminal output |
| `scripts/check.sh --tests -- -k 'issue_pr_review or review_evidence'` | pass | 44 selected tests passed. | Terminal output |
| `scripts/check.sh --docs` | pass | Docs freshness audit passed. | Terminal output |
| `scripts/check.sh --markdown` | pass | Markdown lint passed. | Terminal output |
| `plan-tooling validate --file docs/plans/code-review-specialists/code-review-specialists-plan.md` | pass | Plan validation passed. | Terminal output |
| `GIT_INDEX_FILE=<temporary> scripts/check.sh --entrypoint-ownership` | pass | New untracked helper was included via temporary index without modifying the real index. | Terminal output |
| `scripts/check.sh --all` | pass | Full repo gate passed with 752 tests. | Terminal output |
| `uv run ruff check <new code-review-specialists python files>` | pass | New helper and tests pass ruff directly. | Terminal output |
| `uv run python -m py_compile <new code-review-specialists python files>` | pass | New helper and tests compile directly. | Terminal output |

## Blockers

- None currently.

## Session Log

### 2026-05-19 00:42 CST

- Read: plan and discussion source docs, `DEVELOPMENT.md`, skill
  format/anatomy docs, and neighboring review workflow / review-evidence files.
- Changed: created execution-state ledger and linked it from the plan.
- Validated: `agent-docs` startup and project-dev strict resolves passed.
- Blocked by: nothing.
- Next: implement the new skill, helper, tests, references, and docs wiring.

### 2026-05-19 00:52 CST

- Read: existing review workflow docs/tests, review-evidence docs/tests,
  catalog docs, skill anatomy docs, and validation output.
- Changed: implemented `code-review-specialists`, deterministic helper script,
  specialist references, fixtures/tests, optional review workflow integrations,
  catalog/tooling docs, changelog entry, and plan execution-state updates.
- Validated: focused tests, skill contract/layout checks, docs/markdown checks,
  plan validation, temporary-index entrypoint ownership, normal
  `scripts/check.sh --all`, and direct ruff / py_compile on new Python files.
- Blocked by: nothing. A temporary-index full-gate attempt was discarded because
  `GIT_INDEX_FILE` polluted fixture git repositories; the normal full gate
  passed afterward.
- Next: no implementation work remains; clean up or retire the plan bundle when
  the change has landed and no longer needs active execution tracking.
