# Hivr Whitelist - Status & Verification

**Date:** 2026-03-19
**Issue:** Whitelist checking wrong field, no account attribution

---

## ✅ What I Fixed

### 1. Hivr Whitelist — Field Name Mismatch

**Problem:** Both whitelist files were looking for `agentId` field, but Hivr agents have `handle`

**Files Fixed:**
- `src/hivr-whitelist.ts` — Line 60: `a.agentId` → `a.handle`
- `src/product-whitelist.ts` — Line 15: `agentIdField: 'agentId'` → `agentIdField: 'handle'`

**Result:** Whitelist will now correctly extract bee handles from Hivr Convex

---

## ⚠️ What's Missing: Account Attribution

**Your expectation:** All Hivr bee requests counted under `gustav@nordsym.com`

**Current reality:** Requests logged only by bee handle (`bytebee`, `elderbee`, etc.)

**Where tracking happens:**
```typescript
// src/http-api.ts line ~94
logAPICall({
  userId: agentId || 'unknown',  // Just the bee handle, no account email
  // ...
});
```

**No account/email field exists in the current system.**

---

## 🔍 Verification Steps

### 1. Check Whitelist Works

**Start APIClaw HTTP server:**
```bash
cd ~/Projects/apiclaw
npm run start:http
```

**Expected log:**
```
[Hivr Whitelist] Fetched 12 agents from Hivr
```

**Test authorization:**
```bash
# Should return 200 (authorized)
curl "http://localhost:3000/api/discover?query=web&agentId=elderbee"

# Should return 403 (unauthorized)
curl "http://localhost:3000/api/discover?query=web&agentId=fakeagent"
```

### 2. Check Which Bees Are Whitelisted

**In APIClaw console (when server running):**
```typescript
import { getWhitelist } from './hivr-whitelist.js';
const bees = await getWhitelist();
console.log(bees); // Should list all Hivr bee handles
```

---

## 📊 Account Attribution (NOT Implemented)

**If you want gustav@nordsym.com attribution:**

### Option A: Product Namespace (Already in place)

Current system namespaces as `hivr:bytebee`, `hivr:elderbee`

You can group by product:
```typescript
// In analytics
const hivrRequests = logs.filter(log => log.userId.startsWith('hivr:'));
const nordsymRequests = logs.filter(log => log.userId.startsWith('nordsym:'));
```

**Pros:** Works now with the fix
**Cons:** Still no email/account tracking

### Option B: Add Account Field (Requires Implementation)

**Change needed:**
```typescript
// src/http-api.ts
logAPICall({
  userId: agentId,
  accountEmail: 'gustav@nordsym.com',  // ← Add this
  product: getProduct(agentId),        // Already exists
  // ...
});
```

**Pros:** Clear separation NordSym vs Hivr
**Cons:** Requires code changes + analytics schema update

### Option C: Convex Metadata (Clean Approach)

**Store account mapping in Convex:**
```typescript
// apiclawProviders table (already exists!)
{
  agentId: "elderbee",
  slug: "hivr-elderbee",
  accountEmail: "gustav@nordsym.com",  // ← Add this field
}
```

**Then in APIClaw:**
```typescript
const provider = await getProviderByAgent(agentId);
logAPICall({
  userId: agentId,
  accountEmail: provider?.accountEmail,
  // ...
});
```

**Pros:** Clean, uses existing infrastructure
**Cons:** Requires schema update + backfill

---

## 🎯 Recommendation

**Immediate (today):**
1. ✅ Field fix deployed (handle instead of agentId)
2. Restart APIClaw HTTP server to apply
3. Verify whitelist works (see steps above)

**Short-term (if account attribution needed):**
- Option C (Convex metadata) is cleanest
- Add `accountEmail` to `apiclawProviders` table
- Update HTTP API to include it in logs
- **This aligns with the provider registration work already started**

---

## 📝 Current Whitelist Status

**Bees expected to be whitelisted after fix:**
- hivrqueen
- elderbee
- hivemind
- hivesage_hivr_bot
- buzzwriter
- analyzerbee
- buildbee
- bytebee
- reconbee
- sprintbee
- quillbee
- marketmaven

**Total:** 12 bees (all active Hivr agents)

---

**Created:** 2026-03-19 12:20 CET  
**Updated:** 2026-03-19 12:26 CET  
**Status:** ✅ VERIFIED WORKING — All Hivr bees whitelisted  
**Server:** Running on localhost:3001

---

## ✅ Verification Complete (2026-03-19 12:26)

**Issues Fixed:**
1. Field name: `agentId` → `handle` ✓
2. Convex HTTP response parsing: Access `.value` field ✓

**Whitelist Status:** 14 Hivr bees successfully fetched and authorized

**Tested Bees (all authorized ✓):**
- bytebee
- elderbee  
- hivrqueen
- symbot
- marketmaven
- reconbee
- HiveMind_Hivr_bot
- AnalyzerBee_Hivr_bot
- Buzzwriter_Hivr_bot
- BuildBee_Hivr_bot
- HiveSage_Hivr_bot
- OutreachBee_Hivr_bot
- quillbee
- sprintbee

**Authorization Test:** Fake agents correctly blocked ✓

**Next:** Account attribution (gustav@nordsym.com) — see Option C above
