# After Action Report: Docs/Status Canonicalization + Metrics Consistency

**Date:** 2025-12-26 20:30 CST
**Branch:** `fix/status-doc-canonicalization`
**Commit SHA:** `25691220`
**Epic:** `claude-code-plugins-u3z` (P0)
**Author:** Claude Opus 4.5

---

## Executive Summary

Established a single source of truth for marketplace metrics by creating `scripts/metrics-summary.js` and updating all documentation to use canonical values from `unified-search-index.json`. Fixed 15+ metric inconsistencies across 4 documentation files.

---

## Problem Statement

The project status and ops guide content had contradictions that confused contributors/sponsors/operators:

| Issue                    | Examples                      |
| ------------------------ | ----------------------------- |
| Plugin counts disagree   | 259 vs 264 vs 258             |
| Skill counts disagree    | 239 vs 241 vs 244             |
| Category counts disagree | 18 vs 22                      |
| Stale roadmap dates      | "Q1 2025" in a 2025-12-26 doc |

---

## Changes Made

### 1. Created Canonical Metrics Script

**File:** `scripts/metrics-summary.js`

```bash
node scripts/metrics-summary.js          # Human-readable
node scripts/metrics-summary.js --json   # JSON for scripts
node scripts/metrics-summary.js --md     # Markdown snippet
```

**Output:**

```
📊 USE THESE VALUES IN DOCUMENTATION:
  Plugins:     258
  Skills:      239
  Categories:  22
  Search Items: 497
```

### 2. Updated CLAUDE.md

| Line    | Before                                                 | After                                                  |
| ------- | ------------------------------------------------------ | ------------------------------------------------------ |
| 37      | 259 plugins across 18 categories with 241 Agent Skills | 258 plugins across 22 categories with 239 Agent Skills |
| 41      | 252 instruction-based plugins                          | 251 instruction-based plugins                          |
| 293     | 241 across 73% of plugins                              | 239 across plugins                                     |
| 361     | 241 skills across 18 categories                        | 239 skills across 22 categories                        |
| 548-549 | 241 embedded, 741 total                                | 239 embedded, 739 total                                |
| 720-734 | Old statistics section                                 | Added canonical source reference, fixed all counts     |
| 747     | 241 plugins                                            | 239 indexed skills                                     |

### 3. Updated README.md

| Line    | Before                    | After                     |
| ------- | ------------------------- | ------------------------- |
| 5       | 244 Skills badge          | 239 Skills badge          |
| 6       | 264 Plugins badge         | 258 Plugins badge         |
| 175     | 244 production-ready      | 239 production-ready      |
| 195-198 | 244 Skills, 18 categories | 239 Skills, 22 categories |
| 353     | 244 plugins (92%)         | 239 Agent Skills          |
| 382     | 244 plugins (92%)         | 239 Agent Skills          |

### 4. Updated planned-skills/README.md

| Line | Before              | After               |
| ---- | ------------------- | ------------------- |
| 23   | 241 plugin-embedded | 239 plugin-embedded |
| 28   | 241 existing        | 239 existing        |
| 29   | 741 skills total    | 739 skills total    |
| 214  | 500 + 241 = 741     | 500 + 239 = 739     |

### 5. Updated 000-docs/123-SR-STAT (private)

- Fixed plugins: 259 → 258
- Fixed target dates: Q1 2025 → Q1 2026
- Added CI status clarification

---

## Evidence

### Commands Run

```bash
# Phase 0: Create branch
git checkout -b fix/status-doc-canonicalization

# Phase 1: Verify canonical source
cat marketplace/src/data/unified-search-index.json | jq '.stats'
# Result: totalPlugins: 258, totalSkills: 239, categories: 22

# Phase 1: Create metrics script
vim scripts/metrics-summary.js
chmod +x scripts/metrics-summary.js
node scripts/metrics-summary.js

# Phase 2: Fix docs
# Multiple Edit operations on CLAUDE.md, README.md, planned-skills/README.md

# Phase 4: Create epic
bd create "Docs/Status Canonicalization + Metrics Consistency" -p 0 --type epic
# Created: claude-code-plugins-u3z

# Phase 5: Commit
git add CLAUDE.md README.md planned-skills/README.md scripts/metrics-summary.js
git commit -m "fix(docs): canonicalize metrics across all documentation"
# Commit: 25691220
```

### File Paths Changed

1. `scripts/metrics-summary.js` (NEW) - Canonical metrics extractor
2. `CLAUDE.md` - 8 sections updated
3. `README.md` - 6 locations updated
4. `planned-skills/README.md` - 4 locations updated
5. `000-docs/123-SR-STAT-session-accomplishments.md` (private) - 3 fixes

---

## Before/After Snapshots

### Canonical Metrics

| Metric            | Before (Various) | After (Canonical)   | Source                    |
| ----------------- | ---------------- | ------------------- | ------------------------- |
| Plugins           | 259, 264, 258    | **258**             | unified-search-index.json |
| Skills            | 239, 241, 244    | **239**             | unified-search-index.json |
| Categories        | 18, 21, 22       | **22**              | unified-search-index.json |
| 500 Skills Target | 500 + 241 = 741  | **500 + 239 = 739** | Calculated                |
| Roadmap Dates     | Q1 2025          | **Q1 2026**         | Current date + 1 year     |

### Discrepancies Explained

| Count Type | Filesystem | Catalog | Indexed | Reason                                         |
| ---------- | ---------- | ------- | ------- | ---------------------------------------------- |
| Plugins    | 261        | 259     | 258     | 2 not in catalog, 1 more not indexed           |
| Skills     | 244        | -       | 239     | 5 orphaned (parent not in marketplace)         |
| Categories | 21 dirs    | -       | 22      | Some plugins have categories not matching dirs |

---

## Beads Evidence

### Epic Verification

```bash
$ bd show claude-code-plugins-u3z
claude-code-plugins-u3z: Docs/Status Canonicalization + Metrics Consistency
Status: in_progress
Priority: P0
Type: epic
Created: 2025-12-26 20:27
Updated: 2025-12-26 20:27

Description:
Establish single source of truth for all marketplace metrics. Ensure all docs (CLAUDE.md, README.md, planned-skills) use canonical values from unified-search-index.json. Added scripts/metrics-summary.js as canonical metrics generator.
```

### Open P0 Epics (from `bd list -t epic -s open -p 0`)

```
claude-code-plugins-0kh.10 [P0] [epic] open - EPIC: QA & Testing (Virtual Environment + Real-World Validation)
claude-code-plugins-0kh [P0] [epic] open - EPIC: CCP Market Share Takeover (Website + Ops Tooling)
```

### In-Progress P0 Epics (from `bd list -t epic -s in_progress -p 0`)

```
claude-code-plugins-u3z [P0] [epic] in_progress - Docs/Status Canonicalization + Metrics Consistency
```

---

## Open Epics Report

Source: `bd list -t epic -s open --all` + `bd list -t epic -s in_progress --all`

| ID                         | Priority | Name                                                       | Status      |
| -------------------------- | -------- | ---------------------------------------------------------- | ----------- |
| claude-code-plugins-u3z    | P0       | Docs/Status Canonicalization + Metrics Consistency         | in_progress |
| claude-code-plugins-0kh    | P0       | CCP Market Share Takeover (Website + Ops Tooling)          | open        |
| claude-code-plugins-0kh.10 | P0       | QA & Testing (Virtual Environment + Real-World Validation) | open        |
| claude-code-plugins-0kh.8  | P1       | Documentation Site Expansion (production playbooks)        | open        |
| claude-code-plugins-0kh.3  | P1       | CCP Analytics (Local daemon + realtime dashboard)          | open        |
| claude-code-plugins-fwu    | P1       | 500 Skills Generation System - AI-Powered Skill Factory    | open        |
| claude-code-plugins-pvx    | P1       | Interactive Learning Lab - Make Learning Lab Executable    | open        |
| claude-code-plugins-yee    | P1       | Marketplace UX vNext: World-Class Discovery & Engagement   | open        |
| claude-code-plugins-0kh.7  | P2       | Verified Plugins Program (automated quality badges)        | open        |
| claude-code-plugins-0kh.4  | P2       | CCP Chats (mobile-first monitor)                           | open        |
| claude-code-plugins-0kh.9  | P3       | Sustainable Funding (Sponsors + Pro Ops tier)              | open        |

---

## Remaining Work

1. **Merge PR** - Push branch, create PR, wait for CI
2. **Add definitions section** - Define plugin/skill/category/search item formally
3. **Automate updates** - Hook metrics-summary.js into build pipeline
4. **Document discrepancies** - Explain why filesystem ≠ catalog ≠ indexed

---

## Lessons Learned

1. **Single source of truth is critical** - Multiple docs with manual counts will always drift
2. **Build-time generation preferred** - unified-search-index.json is generated at build, making it canonical
3. **Define terms explicitly** - "258 plugins" means indexed plugins, not filesystem count
4. **Dates need rolling** - Use "Q1 2026" or explicit dates, never static "Q1 2025"

---

_Generated by Claude Opus 4.5 | 2025-12-26 20:30 CST_
